Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010565032024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3529]
TUESDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION NO: 29398/2024
Between:
1. SRIRAMA PANKAJAM, W/O LATE SRI RAMA KRISHNA RAO, DOOR
21-4-1, SKME WORKS, P B ROAD, VIZIANAGARAM
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
(REVENUE), MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI - 110001
2. THE CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES, REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHAIRMAN DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, MINISTRY OF FINANCE
NORTH BLOCK NEW DELHI -110001
3. THE PRINCIPAL
HYDERABAD
CHIEF
COMMISSIONER
OF
INCOME
TAX,
4. INCOME TAX OFFICER, ITO WARD-1, VIJAYANAGARAM
5. INCOME TAX OFFICER, ITO WARD -1(5) VISHAKHAPATNAM
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased topleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of the writ of MANDAMUS declaring the rejection order vide DIN
and Order No. ITBA/COM/F/17/2023-24/1062609373 (1) dated 14.03.2024
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
passed by the Respondent No.3 rejecting the application dated 18.03.2021
submitted by the Petitioner herein for refund of Rs. 11, 08, 486/- paid in
excess under the head of income from capital gains in the AY 2013-14 as
illegal, arbitrary, unjust and contrary to the provisions of the Income Tax Act
besides being violative of Articles 14, and 300A of the Constitution of India
and consequently set aside the same and direct the Respondents No. 3 and
4 herein to refund the tax Rs. 11, 08, 486/- towards the tax paid by the
Petitioner herein for the Assessment Year 2013-14and/or pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased direct the Respondents No. 3& 4 herein to consider the application(s)
dated 18.03.2021 and 13.11.2023 submitted by the Petitioner without
reference to DIN & Order No. ITBA/COM/F/17/2023-24/1062609373 (1) dated
14.03.2024 passed by Respondent No.3 and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to Grant leave to the Respondents to file the counter affidavit in W.P.
29398 of 2024 by condoning the delay in the interest of justice and also
direct that the said counter affidavit be taken on record and or Pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. JYOTHI RATNA ANUMOLU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. ANUP KOUSHIK KARAVADI
2. DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
The Court made the following Order: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice R. Raghunandan Rao)
The petitioner herein had inherited a 1/3rd share from the undivided
property, along with a building bearing D.No.10-4-18/B, in layout No.218/61 of
town survey No.1041 of Waltair ward within the limits of Greater
Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation. This property had devolved on her,
along with her son and daughter, on account of the demise of her husband,
who was the owner of this property.
2.
The petitioner along with her son and daughter, had given the said land
for development, by way of construction of flats to M/s. Sri Lakshmi Vallabha
Constructions, Visakhapatnam vide Development Agreement cum GPA, dated
24.02.2011. The petitioner had thereafter, claimed that, capital gains, on
account of this transaction, would arise in the financial year, 2012-2013,
corresponding to assessment year, 2013-2014. On that basis, the petitioner
offered and paid an amount of Rs.11,08,486/- as capital gains of tax arising
out of this transaction, in relation to assessment year, 2013-2014.
3.
The 4th respondent, however, initiated assessment proceedings for the
financial year, 2010-2011, corresponding to assessment year, 2011-2012,
contending that, the capital gains arise, out of the aforesaid transaction, in the
financial year, 2010-2011, and as such, capital gains should have been paid in
that year. These assessment proceedings culminated, in an Order, dated
13.12.2018, passed by the 5th respondent.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
4.
The petitioner being aggrieved by this Order, had filed an Appeal,
before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) – 1, Visakhapatnam. While
the said Appeal was pending, the petitioner taking an advantage of the
scheme ‘Vivad Se Viswas Scheme’, introduced by the 1st respondent, has
paid a sum of Rs.9,55,706/- as tax towards full and final settlement of all dues
arising against the petitioner, on 22.02.2021.
5.
The petitioner, after making such payment, had then approached the 3rd
respondent – Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, for refund of the tax paid,
for the assessment year, 2013-2014. This application was made under
Section 119(2)(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which reads as follows:
“119. Instructions to subordinate authorities:- (1) The
Board may, from time to time, issue such orders, instructions and
directions to other income-tax authorities as it may deem fit for
the proper administration of this Act, and such authorities and all
other persons employed in the execution of this Act shall observe
and follow such orders, instructions and directions of the Board:
Provided that no such orders, instructions or directions shall
be issued (a).
so as to require any income-tax authority to make a
particular assessment or to dispose of a particular case in a
particular manner; or
(b).
so as to interfere with the discretion of [the Joint
Commissioner (Appeals) or the Commissioner (Appeals)] in the
exercise of his appellate functions.
(2).
Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, (a).
……….
(b).
the Board may, if it considers it desirable or
expedient so to do for avoiding genuine hardship in any case or
class of cases, by general or special order, authorize [any
income-tax authority, not being [a Joint Commissioner (Appeals)
or a Commissioner (Appeals)]] to admit an application or claim for
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
any exemption, deduction, refund or any other relief under this
Act after the expiry of the period specified by or under this Act for
making such application or claim and deal with the same on
merits in accordance with law;”
6.
This application came to be rejected by the 3rd respondent with the
following endorsement:
“3.
The submissions made by the assessee have been
carefully examined. The issue with regard to issue of refund is
not a subject matter of section 119(2)(b) of the IT Act, 1961,
which is a legal issue and does not come under the purview of
section 119(2)(b). Hence, the application made u/s 119(2)(b) is
rejected.”
7.
Aggrieved by this order of rejection, the petitioner has approached this
Court, by way of the present Writ Petition.
8.
Ms. Jyothi Ratna Anumolu, learned counsel for the petitioner, would
contend that, this is a case of genuine hardship in as much as the petitioner is
being forced to pay tax on capital gains, twice, on the same transaction and
the same would be violative of Article 265 of the Constitution of India, which
requires any tax would have to be on the basis of a Law, which is reasonable
and fair. The learned counsel would also contend that, the rejection of the
application of the petitioner is without giving any reasons in as much as the
reason given has no relevance to the claim raised by the petitioner.
9.
Sri Anup Koushik Karavadi, the learned Standing Counsel for Income
Tax, appearing for the respondents, relies upon a Circular of the Central
Board of Direct Taxes, issued on 09.06.2015. The learned Standing Counsel
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
would draw the attention of this Court to paragraph – 3 of the said Circular
bearing No.9/2015. In this paragraph, the Authorities were directed not to
entertain any claim, under Section 119(2)(b) of the Income Tax Act, if it is
beyond the period of six (06) years from the assessment year for which the
claim is made. He would submit that, in the present case, the assessment
order, in which the payments have been made, was for the assessment year
2013-2014, and the limitation, would end on, 31.03.2020, whereas the claim
under Section 119(2)(b) had been made by the petitioner, on 18.03.2021,
which is beyond the period of six (06) years.
10.
The learned Standing Counsel would further elaborate that, the period
of six (06) years was stipulated, under this clause because the Department
requires to maintain the records of the assessee for a period of six (06) years
and it would be difficult for the Department to ascertain the actual facts
beyond the period of six (06) years.
11.
The aforesaid contention of the learned Standing Counsel would have
to be rejected, on two (02) grounds. Firstly, there is no dispute as to the fact
that the petitioner had paid the tax, on the same transaction, for the
assessment year, 2013-2014 as well as for the assessment year, 2011-2012.
In such circumstances, the availability or absence of records would make no
difference.
12.
It is settled law that the Circulars issued by the Central Board of Direct
Taxes would be binding on the Authorities. However, such guidelines or
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
circulars would not be binding on this Court, especially when this Court is
exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Apart from
this, the fact remains that there is no time period stipulated under Section
119(2)(b). A look at Section 119(2)(b) would also show that claims, which
cannot be made, on account of expiry of time for making such claims are still
be considered under Section 119(2)(b). In such circumstances, fixing an outer
time limit in relation to such claims can be counterproductive. This would also
be contrary to the spirit of Section 119(2)(b).
13.
The undisputed fact is that the petitioner has suffered double taxation
on the very same transaction. In such circumstances, there is a genuine
hardship, which requires to be dealt with by the Department. However, the 3rd
respondent refused to deal with this issue and sought to reject the claim of the
petitioner, on grounds, which are entirely extraneous to the issue.
14.
In these circumstances, we are of the opinion that there is a genuine
hardship suffered by the petitioner, which requires to be rectified by this Court.
15.
Accordingly, this Writ Petition is allowed, setting aside the order of the
3rd respondent, dated 14.03.2024, with a further direction to the respondents
to refund the tax of Rs.11,08,486/- collected from the petitioner, for the
assessment year, 2013-2014. Further, since the petitioner had to pay tax, for
the assessment year, 2011-2012 only, in 2021, there shall be no requirement
to pay interest till that date. However, interest shall be paid by the Department,
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
on the amount of Rs.11,08,486/- from the date on which the petitioner had
filed the application under Section 119(2)(b) till date of payment.
There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J
________________
T.C.D. SEKHAR, J
Date:20.01.2026
KPV
RRR,J & TCDS,J
W.P.No.29398 of 2024
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION No.29398 of 2024
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice R. Raghunandan Rao)
20.01.2026
KPV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review