The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. For the aforesaid reasons and in view of the ratio laid down in the Sk. Abdul Odud Ali (supra), the impugned judgment and order passed in Misc. Appeal No. 46 of 2018 is hereby set aside and the judgment and order passed by the learned trial Court in Misc. (Pre-emption) Case No. 45 of 2015 is hereby affirmed.
17. Accordingly, the instant revisional application being CO 3975 of 2019 is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
CO 3975 of 2019
Srinath Mahata
Vs.
Kalicharan Raj & Ors.
For the petitioner
: Mr. Sukanta Das, Adv.
Mrs. Anulekha Bera Maiti, Adv.
For the opposite parties
: Mr. Rabindranath Mahato, Adv.
Mr. Aritra Shankar Ray, Adv.
Heard on
: 15.09.2026
Judgment on
: 15.09.2026
Uploaded on
: 15.09.2026
MD. SHABBAR RASHIDI, J.:1.
The instant revisional application has been filed assailing
the judgment and order dated September 5, 2019 passed by learned
5th Additional District Judge, Paschim Medinipore in Misc. Appeal
No. 46 of 2018.
2.
By the impugned judgment and order, the learned First
Appellate Court modified the order passed by the learned trial Court
in Pre-emption Case 45 of 2015. By the impugned order, the learned
First Appellate Court held that the appellants were entitled to preemption of the suit property, subject to payment of consideration
money and compensation as decided by the learned Trial Court as
per the provisions of law. The impugned judgment and order also
directed the learned Trial Court to decide the market value of the
suit property within three months and do the needful after payment
of such amount as decided by the learned Trial Court.
3.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner
did
not
deposit
the
requisite
amount,
i.e.,
the
consideration money mentioned in the deed, which was sought to be
pre-empted, together with 10 % thereon. In that view of the facts,
according to the learned advocate for the petitioner, the opposite
party was not entitled to pre-empt the sale involved in the deed in
question.
4.
Learned advocate for the petitioner further submits that
since the pre-emptor has not deposited the requisite amount in
terms of the provisions of Section 8 of West Bengal Land Reforms
Act, 1955, the petition for pre-emption filed by the opposite party
herein is liable to be rejected.
5.
Learned advocate for the petitioner further submits that the
learned First Appellate Court, while passing the impugned judgment
and order, was not justified in directing the learned Trial Court to
make an enquiry as to the actual market value of the properties
sought to be pre-empted.
6.
Learned advocate for the petitioner further submits that the
matter with regard to the quantum of the consideration money
required to be paid for preferring an application under Section 8 of
West Bengal Land Reforms Act was referred to a Larger Bench of
this Court in CO 785 of 2021.
7.
The Larger Bench has decided the issue by a judgment was
passed on August 28, 2026 in Sk. Abdul Odud Ali Vs. Emanulla
Khan and Others. It is submitted that in view of the ratio laid down
in such judgment and order passed by the Hon’ble Larger Bench,
the prayer in the petition for pre-emption of the properties involved
in the impugned deed does not stand and is liable to be rejected.
8.
On the other hand, learned advocate for the opposite
parties submits that the learned First Appellate Court was quite
justified in passing the impugned judgment and order. He submits
that the pre-emptee had mentioned an inflated consideration money
in the deed in question in order to avoid any application for preemption of the properties involved in such deed. Learned First
Appellate Court was justified in directing an enquiry as to the actual
market value of the properties involved in such deed for the purpose
of determination of the consideration amount liable to be paid for
such purpose. He stood by the impugned judgment and order. The
opposite party nos. 1 and 2 filed an application under Section 8 and
9 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 praying inter ala for
pre-emption of the properties involved in the impugned deed. Such
proceeding was registered as Misc. (Pre-emption) Case no. 45 of
2015. The property involved in such deed appertained to plot no.
711 of Mouja Amlakara within the district of Paschim Medinipur
measuring 10 decimal. Such properties belonged to one Khagendra
Raj and Kunja Raj. The owners sold the said property by a
registered deed dated August 11, 2015 to the petitioner in Preemption case. The petitioners purchased 19 decimals out of 76
decimals in plot no. 711 whereas the petitioner no. 2 purchased 12
decimals in the said plot. It was further contended that the suit plot
was never partitioned between the co-sharers and the vendors of the
petitioner sold out a portion of such plot to the petitioner herein
without notice upon the petitioners of Pre-emption case. The
consideration money in such deed was disclosed as 99,500/-.
However, according to the case made out by the petitioner, the
actual market value of such property was not more than Rs.
50,000/-. The remaining 7 decimals in the said plot were
subsequently transferred by the said Khagendra Raj and Kunja Raj
in favour of the opposite parties herein (petitioner in the pre-
emption case).
The opposite parties filed an application for pre-
emption of the properties purchased by the present petitioner herein
on the basis of sale deed executed in his favour.
9.
By an order passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division) in Misc. (Pre-emption) Case no. 45 of 2015, dismissed the
claim of the opposite parties herein for pre-emption of the property
purchased by the present petitioner. It was held by the learned trial
Court that
“In the light of backdrop of above discussion, evidence,
other material on record, fact and circumstance of this
case, I am of the considered view that Kunja Raj and
Khagendra Raj had transferred his entire property of
the case plot so, I find no alternative but to say that the
petitioners are not entitled to get the order of preemption of the case property.”
10.
Being aggrieved with such order, the opposite party nos. 1
and 2 preferred miscellaneous appeal being Misc. Appeal No. 46 of
2018. By the impugned judgment and order, the learned First
Appellate Court held that the present opposite party nos. 1 and 2
were entitled to pre-empt the suit property subject to payment of
consideration money, as decided by the learned trial Court as per
the provisions of law. The learned First Appellate Court also
directed, in the impugned judgment and order, to the learned Trial
Court to decide the market value of the property involved in the
deed, sought to be pre-empted within three months and to do the
needful upon receipt of the payment of the consideration money
decided by it.
11.
In the impugned judgment and order, the learned First
Appellate Court held as follows :“14. As per section 8 of the WBLR Act following persons are
eligible for claiming right of pre-emption
a) Bargadar
b) Co-Sharer
c) Raiyat possessing land adjoining such plot of land.
In the present case, learned Trial court has hold that
petitioners were co-sharer of the plot of land of the raiyat,
which has been transferred by seller to opposite party. In fact,
learned Trial Court finding in that regard is based upon
section 14 of the WBLR Act. Learned Advocate for the
appellants has argued that before the learned Trial Court,
appellants has successfully proved that they are the co-sharer
as well as raiyat possessing land adjoining such plot of a
land. Learned Trial court finding on the point of possessing
land by appellants on the adjoining plot, is that in that respect
there is only oral evidence. A person cannot be co-sharer and
possessing plot of land which has been sold. simultaneously
unless and until, he has separate property on the basis of
which he is claiming his right of pre-emption, but in this case
there is no two separate property owned by petitioners on the
basis of which petitioners can claim that they are co-sharer as
well as possessing the land adjoining to such plot of land. I
have
of
the
view
that
appellants
have
successfully
established through evidence that they are the co-sharer of
the plot of land of the raiyat, and failed to establish that they
are possessing the land adjoining such plot of land. Thus, the
third condition of pre-emption that is co-sharer in the plot of
land has been fulfilled by the appellants.
15. With above observation I have of the view that
appellants have fulfilled all the required conditions under
section 8 of the W.B.L.R. Act except conditions of full deposit of
consideration amount, and compensation in terms of section
8(1) of the WBLRA. From the pleadings of the both parties, it
appears to me that there is dispute between the parties
regarding actual market value of the suit property, and value
mentioned in the sale deed exhibit -C Deed no-2050 of 2015.
Since, the application of the appellants under section -8 of
WBLRA was dismissed, so the learned Trial court has not
assessed the value of the suit property. It is duty of the court
to decide the actual market value of the suit property, and
direct the parties to deposit the same in case of shortfall as
observed by the Honourable High Court in the matter of Helu
Pal Vs. Master Souvik Sarkar 2016 (3) CHN (Cal) 495.
In this case actual seller of the suit property has not
been made party but that seller is not necessary party in this
case as there is no any relief against that seller of suit
property and none of the parties have raised that issue before
this court; so I have of the view that seller is not necessary
party and his non-joinder will not be fatal for this case.”
12.
As it transpires, the learned First Appellate Court while
deciding Misc. Appeal no. 46 of 2018, held that opposite party nos.
1 and 2 to are co-sharers of the land sought to be pre-empted. On
such conclusion, the learned First Appellate Court held that
opposite party nos. 1 and 2 to be entitled for pre-empting the deed
executed in favour of the present petitioners.
13.
The question as to what amount is required to be paid by a
pre-emptor while preferring an application under Sections 8 and 9
of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act was decided by the Larger
Bench of this Court in Sk. Abdul Odud Ali (supra). It was held by
the Larger Bench to do the following :“31. In view of the above, we answer the reference in the
affirmative, holding as follows:
A pre-emption application under Section 8 of the West Bengal
Land Reforms Act, 1955 (whether on the ground of cosharership - notified or unnotified or otherwise) has to be
rejected at the outset as not maintainable if the application is
not accompanied by the statutory deposit of the consideration
amount shown in the sale deed sought to be pre-empted,
along with 10% thereon, irrespective of whether there is or is
not any allegation that the price shown in the deed was
inflated and the actual consideration money paid according to
the pre-emption is the lesser amount deposited with the preemption application.”
14.
As to the facts and circumstances of the present case, the
opposite party nos. 1 and 2 deposited Rs. 50,000/- towards
consideration money together with 10% thereof, claiming it to be the
actual market price of transformed property. It was contended that
the market value of the property sought to be pre-empted was not
more than Rs. 50,000/- for which the learned First Appellate Court
directed an enquiry to be conducted by the learned Trial Court.
15.
Now by the order passed by the Larger Bench in Sk. Abdul
Odud Ali (supra), the matter stands settled that a pre-emptor is
required to deposit the entire consideration money as described in
the deed sought to be pre-empted, together with the statutory 10%
thereof, the opposite party nos. 1 and 2 have not deposited such
amount for which the claim of the opposite party nos. 1 and 2 for
pre-empting a sale without depositing the consideration money
mentioned in the deeds sought to be pre-empted cannot be
maintained.
16.
For the aforesaid reasons and in view of the ratio laid down
in the Sk. Abdul Odud Ali (supra), the impugned judgment and
order passed in Misc. Appeal No. 46 of 2018 is hereby set aside and
the judgment and order passed by the learned trial Court in Misc.
(Pre-emption) Case No. 45 of 2015 is hereby affirmed.
17.
Accordingly, the instant revisional application being CO
3975 of 2019 is disposed of.
18.
Opposite party nos. 1 and 2 shall be at liberty to withdraw
the amount deposited by them with the learned Trial Court.
19.
The learned Trial Court shall endeavour to disburse the
amount lying to the credit of Misc. (Pre-emption) Case No. 45 of
2015 to the pre-emptors within four weeks from the date of the
application for withdrawal.
20.
Urgent Photostat Certified copy of this judgment, if applied
for, be supplied expeditiously after complying with all necessary
legal formalities.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
tbsr/20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review