Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Specia! Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
tr.If{T{\TII
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION
:43407 OF 2022
Sridhar Purekar, S/o P.Prakash, aged about 37 years, Occ ; Software Employee, Rl/o
Flat No. 204, Aditya Mansion, Opp. Kapra Municipality, ECIL Road, Hyderabad.
PETITIONER
Et\[,
State Bank of lndia, rep. By its Chief General Manager, Home Loan Division,
Secunderabad.
RESPONDENT
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Certiorari, to call for the records relating to the impugned
order dt. 3-10-2022 issued by the respondent and to quash the same and
consequently direct the respondent herein to pay the excess amount paid by the
petitioner herein.
:l
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant
stay of all further proceedings pursuant to the impugned order dt. 3-10-2022
issued by the respondent herein, pending disposal of the main writ petition.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cou( may be pleased to stay
the operation of the demand notice bearing Letter No. 58I/05322126467082
dated:29.10.2025 issued by the respondent and also stay all further proceedings
in respect of the demand notice bearing Letter No. 58I/05322126467082
dated:29.1 0.20:25, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for thr: Petitioner : M/s SALEHA BEGUM
Counsel for thr: Respondents : M/s PEARL LAW ASSOCIATES
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
IIRIT PETITIONS No. 434O7 OF 2O22
24.02.20/26
Between:
Sridhar Purekar
..... Petitioner
And
State Bank of India,
Rep. by its Chief General Manager,
Home [,oan Division,
Secunderabad
... Respondent
ORDER:
Petitioner states that he availed home loan from
respondent bank of Rs.7,72,OOO/-, which was disbursed. in
three phases at the rate of Rs.2,57,500/- each; at the time of
disbursement, respondent bank obtained six blank cheques
towards securit5r in respect of loan Account No.3O363578633. It
is stated, subsequenfly, petitioner noticed. various discrepancies
at the time of issuance and utilization of cheques, which
occurred due to the negligence of the staff of respondent bank in
discharge of their duties. Petitioner is stated to have submitted
ECS authorization authorizing salar5r deduction towards EMls,
however, the bank failed to deduct the salary till February,
2O!2, i.e. for about four years from 2008 to 2012. Respondent
bank ,lid not verify its records and did not issue any notice to
petitioner during the said period. Upon noticing the same,
petitioner approached respondent bank and brought to its
notice the negligence in not d.educting the salary. Thereafter,
respor:dent charged interest on the EMIs for the said period and
added the same to the principal amount and commenced
deduct:ion of salary from 20t2 onwards. It is asserted, there was
no fault on his part and no interest ought to have been charged
for the period from 2oo8 to 2012. As per the loan schedule, the
tenure of loan was 162 months payable at Rs.9,431/- per
month and the total loan liability was Rs.lS,2T,822l-, which
would have been fully discharged by November,2o2l. However,
petitiorrer paid total amount of Rs.l7,44,OS3/-, resulting in
excess payment, yet respondent bank continued. to deduct EMIs
insteaii of returning the excess amount.
1.1.
Petitioner states that he approached respondent
bank 'f,n several occasions and also submitted a written
representation in April, 2o2r requesting rectification and refund
of excerss amount, but none of the requests was considered. The
staff o:[ the respondent bank contintied to visit petitioner,s
house and collect EMIs. consequently, petitioner issued. legal
notice rlated o4-o8-2o21 through counsel, narrating the entire
facts and calling upon the bank to veri$z the loan account and
refund the excess amount paid. Even after receipt of legal
notice, the bank neither replied nor took any action. Thereafter,
petitioner is stated to have filed Writ Petition No.86OL of 2022,
which was disposed of on 2L-O2-2O22, directing respondent
bank to examine petitioner?s representation dated April, 2O2L
and legal notice dated O4-O8-2O21 and to pass orders in
accordance with law within ten weeks from the date of receipt of
a copy of the said order. Despite lapse of more than seven
months, respondent neither passed any order nor responded,
which necessitated to file Contempt Case No.1606 of 2A22,
drrring the hearing of which, on |4-LO-2O22, respondent
submitted that an order rejecting petitioner's representation had
afreadV been passed on O3-10-2022, impugned in this Writ
Petition and served on him.
1.2.
According to petitioner, under the impugned order,
respondent demanded payment of Rs.7,53,O53/- with interest
at L6.35oh, whereas petitioner had already paid Rs.L7,44,033/'
against the total loan liability of Rs.15,27,822f -, resulting in
excess pa5rment of Rs.2,l6,2lLl- aTong with interest at 16.350/o
per annum. Respondent rejected his representation without
proper verification of records. The impugned. order refers to
cancellation of flat allotted to petitioner by Rajeev Swagruha
Corporation Limited and refirnd of Rs.15,7L,586f -, but they
a
continued to collect EMIs. It is stated, cancellation of allotment
was done by oflicials of Rajeev swagruha corporation Limited.,
theref,cre, no violation of loan terms can be attributed. to him.
when respondent had already collected the entire loan amount
along with interest and also collected excess amount, the
impugned order is arbitrary, vitiated and does'not stand judicial
scrutilty.
1.3.
Petitioner alleges that impugned order was issued
with ;!rrl intention to evade refund of excess amount of
Rs.2,16,2L1l- and that under the guise of the said order,
respondent is now threatening recovery of Rs.7,s3,0s3/- with
interest at L6.35yo, which is unreasonable and unwarranted.
Hence, the Writ Petition.
2-
In the counter filed by the respond.ent bank, it is
stated, the competent authorit5r passed the detailed impugned
order substantiating the reasons and grounds for rejecting
petitioner;s claims as being contrar5r to the unequivocal
covenants and undertakings executed by petitioner under the
Memor,andum of rerm Loan Agreement for Home Loan granted
to public dated 13-05-2008. They place on record. the true
factual position that petitioner had ad.mittedty availed home
loan fla<:ility of Rs.8,15,ooo/- for purchase of a double bed room
flat under Rajeev swagruha Housing Scheme at chandanagar,
-,,.,--.,J
.
Papireddynagar, Ranga Reddy District, admeasuring 685.50
square feet, bearing Lot No.793, allotted by the A.P. Housing
Board uide letter No.E/EE/WD I 685.50 Sft. Flat/Chandanagar.
In acknowledgment thereof, petitioner executed a Memorandum
of Term Loan Agreement for Home Loan granted to public dated
13-O5-2008.
2.t.
It is stated, the competent authorif, in paragraph 3
of the order impugned, observed that ECS mandate furnished
by petitioner was not properly adhered. to by the Bank d.uring an
intermittent period. On that limited issue, petitioner was held
entitled to interest remission amounting to Rs.65,683/-. The
said amount was refunded and adjgsted in the loan account
towards the dues payable by petitioner. The calculation sheet
reflecting the said adjustment was annexed as Annexure-A to
the order communicated to petitioner. E:<cept to this limited
extent, respondent denies the truth, validity and genuineness of
the remaining allegations made by petitioner.
2.2.
With respect to petitioner's contention that loan
tenure was t62 months, EMI was Rs.9,431/-, EMI liability
would have ended by November, 2021, and petitioner paid a
total sum of Rs.17,44,033/- resulting in alleged excess
payment, respondent states that the said contentions are
contrary to the express covenants contained in Clause 2(b) of
the Memorandum of Term Loan Agreement dated 13-05-2008.
Under the said clause, interest is chargeable on floating rate
basis irr accordance with the guidelines issued by the Resenre
Bank of India. Respondent reproduces. th-e clause which
provides that interest shall be applied at 2.5Vo below SBAR,
rising or falling, at monthly rests calculated on daily balances,
and Bank is entitled at any time to change the rate of interest at
its sole discretion, even without change in SBAR. The borrower
is deenred to have notices of such changes through display at
the branch, publication in newspapers, or reflection in passbook
or statements of account. It is stated, pursuant to the said
clause and the RBI guidelines, including the Master Direction Reserve Bank of India (Interest Rate of Advances) Directions,
2Ot6, interest was applied from time to time. tt is categorically
denied that any excess amount was collected and stated that
petitiorrer remains legally-bound to pay the outstanding amount
reflected in the books of account.
2.3.
It is stated, the action of charging interest is strictly
in accordance with RBI guidelines and. the extant instructions of
the Ba:rk cannot be faulted. It is asserted that Writ Petition is
speculeLtive in nature and is liable to be rejected on this ground
as well, Respondent refers to order dated 21-02-2022 inWrit
Petition No.86OL of 2022 and submits that in compliance with
the said directions issued therein, the competent authority
passed the impugned order and communicated the same to
petitioner along with Annexure-A-1 showing refund and
adjustment of Rs.65,683/-, Annexure-A,2 detailing the
calculation of interest after the loan account was treated as
unsecured, and other material statements.
2.4.
Respondent states that on examination of records,
it was found that though loan was availed as a secured home
loan in M"y, 2008, no securit5r existed in favour of Bank as on
the date of impugned order. The loan documents and sanction
teims cast a clear obligation on petitioner to create securit5r
interest over the flat proposed to be acquired under the Rajiv
Swagruha Housing Scheme at Chandandgs, Ranga Reddy
District. Upon taking up the issue with Rajiv Swagruha
Copporation Limited, they were informed that petitioner himself
sought cancellation of allotment of flat and obtained refund of
Rs.15,71,586/- from the Corporation which was paid uide
Andhra Bank cheque No.OOOO04 dated 02'Ol-2O18 in favour of
petitioner. Petitioner collected and encashed the said cheque
directly without informing the Bank and without crediting the
proceeds to the loan account, despite the fact that consideration
originally paid to the Corporation was sourced from the Bank
loan.
2.5.
Respondent asserts that in terms of the loan
covenants, the Bank had charged not only over the asset
proposed to be acquired but also over any refunded proceeds
arising therefrom. Therefore, the refunded amount of
Rs.15,i21,586/- was legitimately payable to the Bank. Petitioner,
with ntala fide intention, collected and utilized the refunded
amount without disclosure to the Bank, amounting to wilful
breach of loan covenants and acts tantamounting to criminal
misapp,repriation and cheating of the Bank.U In view of the
above ,:onduct, respondent was constrained to treat the loan
account as an unsecllred advance with effect from Janua4r,
2Ol8 and to charge interest at the O.D. rate in accordance with
RBI guidelines and the extant instructions of the Bank. Until
such time, loan was charged at a concessional rate on the
assumption of availability of security and because it was a
priority sector loan. After the account became unsecured, the
application of O.D. interest was justified. Detailed statements in
this regard were forwarded to petitioner along with the
impugrred order.
2.6.
Respondent states that since the loan account
remainr:d unpaid, it was classified as a Non-Performing Asset on
22-O9-i|O22. Upoo recalculation of interest on the basis of the
unsecured loan, it was communicated that an amount of
Rs.3,L2,3o6/- was due and payable under the unsecured roan
from 2ola onwards. They refers to clause 2tkl of the
Memorandum of rerm Loan Agreement, under which petitioner
undertook not to sell, assign, mortgage, or qtherwise encumber
the asset acquired through Bank funds without prior
permission so long as the borrower remained indebted to Bank.
Petitioner violated the said covenant, exposing himself to
criminal action and action under the RBI Master Directions on
Fraud, 2OL6. He was therefore, informed that Rs.7,53,00O/was due and payable along with interest at L6.3s%per annum
(clean o.D. interest) with monthly rests and other incidental
charges.
3.
Petitioner filed reply almost reiterating the writ
averments. It is stated, respondent Bank itself admitted that
ECS mandate furnished by petitioner was not properly adhered
to, which establishes that ECS was inoperative due to the fault
of the Bank, hence, adjustment of interest of about Rs.65,6gO/-
is stated to be arbitrary and attributable solely to the negligence
of respondent Bank. It is further stated that, petitioner paid
Rs.17,44,O33/- in total, resulting in excess pa5rment of
Rs-2, L6,2rL / -. Th.e contention of respondent Bank that interest
is chargeable on a floating rate basis is denied and stated to be
contrar5r to the agreed loan terms.
li
,;
:
i
3.1.
Petitioner states that cancellation of flat was
effecteC by Rajeev Swagruha Housing Scheme authorities and
not due to any default on his part. He further denies the claim
of cha:rging O.D. interest and contends that declaration of loan
accourrt as T.[PA' on 22-09-2022 is illegal, as no notice was
issued under the SARFAESI Act prior to such declaration.
4.
Heard Ms. Saleha Begum, learned counsel for
petitio:eer.
5.
M/s Pearl Law Associates, learned Standing
Counsel for respondent bank argues that Writ Petition is not
mainteLinable under Article 226 of the Constitution as the issues
raised pertain to contractual obligations and involve disputed
questions of fact arising out of a loan agreement. It is contended
that ',r'rit jurisdiction cannot be invoked for adjudication of
private contractual disputes or for interpretation and
enforct:ment of contractual terms. He places reliance on the
judgmr:nt of the Honble Supreme Court in Rc;'asthorn State
Indusl|rial Deaelopment and Inuestnlent CotTtoratiort- o.
Diamo,nd. &
@m Deaelopment Cot'Ttoration Limited.t,
wherein it was categorically held that contractual disputes
cannot ordinarily be agitated und.er writ jurisdiction and that
enforcr:ment of contractual terms must be relegated to civil
' lzors; i scc 470
:.'"-.-=J
tl
remedies or arbitration, if provided. They also relies on the
judgments in Bareillg Development Authoritg a- Aiai Pal
Singh2, State of U.P. a. Bridge & Roof Co. (India) Ltd..s and
Kerala State Etectricitg Board o. Kurien E, Kollathi4+.
5.
1.
Learned Standing Counsel submits that
discretionary and equitable nature of writ jurisdiction requires
existence of a clear legal right and a corresponding statutory or
public duw, which is absent in the present case. It is asserted
that a writ of mandamus cannot be'issued to create rights or
enforce purely contractual obligations. The Bank submits that
the writ petition does not disclose any violation of statutory
duff, public law element, or arbitrariness walTanting exercise of
writ jurisdiction, and therefore the petition is liable to be
dismissed on the ground of maintainability alone.
5.2.
According to learned Standing Counsel, Writ
Petition suffers from non-joinder of necessary party. The
impugned order has been passed by the Assistant General
Manager, State Bank of India, RBo Banjara Hills, but the said
Authority has not been impleaded. It is submitted, petitioner
has not approached the Court with clean hands, has
suppressed material facts, and has selectively placed documents
21rsse;2 scc 116
lrsso; 6scc22
n
6 scc 293
1zooo1
t2
^i
-:.:i
on re(:ord to mislead the court. Reliance is placed on the
judgm,:nt of the Honble Supreme Court in K.D. Shartna u.
steel authoritg of rndia Limiteds, wherein it was held that
petitioner, who suppresses material facts or inakes mislead.ing
statements, is not entitled to equitable relief under Articles 32
or 226 of the Constitution.
5.3.
l,earned Standing counsel submits that housing
loan interest was charged at applicable rates from the date of
sanction in May, 2oo8 till 01.01.201g. overdraft interest rate
was charged only from 02.o1.2018, the date on which petitioner
breachr:d the terms and conditions of loan agreement. petitioner
has noi- pleaded anywhere in the writ affidavit that oD interest
*.". acplied only from o2.0L 2018, and by suppressing
Annexure-l and Annexure-2, has attempted to mislead this
court into believing that oD interest was levied from the date of
sanction.
5.4.
Relevant clauses of the Memorandum of rerm Loan
Agreem,:nt executed by petitioner were relied upon. clause 2(b)
stipulates repayment of loan in EMIs of Rs.9,43L/- each along
with interest. The agreement expressly provides that loan is on
floating interest rate basis at 2.2szo below SBAR, subject to
variation, and empowers the Bank to revise interest rates and
5lzooel l2
scc 481
l3
charge enhanced rates in case of default or irregularity. The
agreement further authorises the Bank to charge penal interest
and enhanced interest at its discretion in case of breach.
Clause 2(k) prohibits sale, assignment, mortgage or
encumbrance of the flat without prior permission of Bank,
Clause 2(1) mandates creation of security by way of mortgage,
and Clause 2(r) obligates the borrower to abide by the sanction
letter, RBI rules, and governmental directions as amended from
time to time. Clause 2(wl clearly states that borrower has
understood all terms and conditions and agreed to abide by
them, failing which the Bank has the right to recall the loan.
5.5.
According to learned Standing Counsel, petitioner
entered into the Agreement with fulI knowledge and consent and
is therefore bound by the contractual terms and he has not
challenged the validity of the Agreement or its clauses. Reliance
is placed on Indian Bo;nk o. Blue Jaggers Estates Lt&6,
wherein the Honble Supreme Court held that a borrower who
has signed an Agreement with open eyes cannot subsequently
challenge the agreed terms, including interest rates.
Further reliance is placed on Raiesh Mongo o. Housing
Deaelopmcnt Finance CorTroration Ltd.7 wherein it was held
that a borrower, having executed the Agreement and availed the
6 (zoro)8 scc 129
s scc 299
lzoz+y
I
t4
loan, rlo.rrrrot subsequently dispute interest rates or seek refi.rnd
after ;lcquiescence. Reliance is also placed on Eongkong &
shanghai Banking corTtoration Ltd.. u. Au)az|, wherein it
was treld that courts cannot rewrite contractual terms or
scrutinize interest rates agreed between parties unless
arbitrzLriness or mala fides are established.
5-6.
on the issue of burden of proof, it is argued that as
per pt:titioner, cancellation of allotment was done by Rajiv
swagn-rha corporation Limited and that no fault can be
attribu.ted to him. However, petitioner failed to fiLe the letter of
cancelJation, which is a document in his possession. Nonproduc:tion of such a material document warrants drawing of
advers,:
inference
against
him.
Relian<:e is placed on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
court :.n s.P. chengalvaraga. Naidu a. Jagannathe, wherein
it was held that suppression of vital documents amounts to
playing fraud on the court and that a litigant who approaches
the c,rurt with falsehood has no right to be heard.
Though. the Branch Manager of Huma5run Nagar Branch
approar:hed Rajiv swagruha corporation Limited seeking
cancell:rtion letter, the same was not furnished as the Bank is
not pri'4y to the said docurnent. It is further contended that
81zozs1s
e
scc s2
ltss+1l scc 1
-. -,1
irrespective of whether the cancellation was initiated by
Corporation or petitioner, the same has no bearing on the core
issue, namely, entitlement of the Bank to charge OD interest as
per contractual terms.
6.
Upon careful consideration of the pleadings,
documents, and submissions, it is to be seen, the foundational
facts relating to ECS lapse are not in dispute. Respondent Bank
itself, in the impugned order, admitted that ECS mandate
furnished by petitioner was not properly adhered to by them
during an intermittent period and granted interest remission of
Rs.65,683/-. Once respondent Bank admits its own failure in
implementing ECS mandate, the entire period from 2O08 to
February, 2Ol2 cannot be treated as default attributable to
petitioner. Charging interest and capitalising the sarne for a
period during which the Bank admittedly failed to act amounts
to arbitrariness and violation of principles of fairness.
7.
The contention of respondent Bank that loan was
on floating rate basis and governed by RBI guidelines does not
answer the core issue, namely, whether excess recovery was
made despite full discharge of liability. Petitioner consistently
asserted, with figures, that total payable amount was
Rs.15,27,822/ -
and he paid Rs.17,44,O33f -, in excess.
Respondent Bank has not disputed the total amount paid, but
i
I
I
I
I
I
[;
l'
t6
sought to justify continued demand. by applyrng oD interest
retrospectively after cancellation of allotment, without
establisrhing any wilful defaurt on the part of petitioner
8-
The plea of the Bank that petitioner breached
covenarts by not depositing the refunded amount of
Rs.15,7L,5861- cannot be accepted in the facts of this case.
Responlent did not dispute that loan was serviced through
sarary cleduction and that EMIs continued. to be collected even
after cancellation. Respondent also did not issue any
contemporaneous notice demanding immediate deposit of the
refunde,l amount nor recalculated liability at that stage. The
impugned order was passed only after initiation of contempt
proceedings, which indicates lack of timely action and.
applicat.on of mind.
9'
Reliance placed by respondent Bank on
maintairrability of writ petition is also misplaced. Though
contractrral disputes ordinarily lie outside writ jurisdiction,
where a'bitrariness, admitted negligence, excess recovery,
and
non-compliance with earlier judiciar directions are established.,
this court is not precluded from exercising jurisdiction under
Article 2i>-6. The impugned order dated 03-ro-2022 was passed
pursuant to the directions issued in writ petition
No. g60l of
2022, therefore, is amenable to judicial review.
.l
t7
10.
It is also to be observed that loan accorrnt was
declared as NPA on 22-09-2022 wlthout even issuing notice
under the SARFAESI Act, though recovery of EMIs was made
continuously and the amount was paid in excess, which further
vitiates the action of the respondent Bank. Respondent failed to
demonstrate compliance with statutory safeguards prior to
classiffing the account as NPA. This Court is therefore, of the
view that impugned order was passed on consideration of some
facts and ignoring lapses on the part of Bank. Respondent seeks
to justify excess recovery by belated application of OD interest,
however, they fail to take into consideration the fact that
petitioner had already paid more than the agreed loan liabilify.
tl.
action of respondent Bank is therefore, arbitrar5r,
unreasonable and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
I 1.
The Writ Petition is therefore, allowed. The
impugned order dated O3-|O-2O22 is set aside. Respondent
Bank is directed to recalculate the loan account by excluding
interest charged for the period from 2oo8 to Februaryr, 2oL2
attributable to ECS lapse, give full credit to the total amount of
Rs.17,44,O331- paid by petitioner, and refund the excess
amount of Rs.2,l6,2Lll- with applicable interest, within a
reasonable time. No costs.
l8
.,. . ,l!
t-.'-...
L2.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any sha.ll stand closed.
SD/. A.JAYASREE
REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To
OFFICER
1. The Chie,f General Manager, State Bank of lndia,
Division,
Secunderabad.
2. One CC to M/s. SALEHA BEGUM, Advocate loPUcl
3. One CC':o M/s. PEARL LAW ASSOCIATES, Advocate loPUcI
4. Two CD rlopies
SA
BS
u
i
I
{
\
HIGH COURT
DATED i2,410212026
T HES
()
13 u,.j ,'i,
..!.
*
ORDER
WP.No.43407 of 2A22
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
b
\7
0p
*
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review