Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
!
& $
!
"
#
$
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
&
'
(
!
&
)
%
'
-2-
(
!
"
#
$
*
%
+
&&'
+
+
*
+
!
!
&!&
, &!&
)
$
) +
*
+
+
+
+
!
&
,
# %
$
+
!, &!&
+
+
&!&
$
+
$
$
)
!
,.
) +
$
+
&
,
*
+
,.
+
&!&
$
$
$
+
/ 0
*
)
)
) +
$
-3-
2345 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 ?2=@=@9724 375 6234725
89:7;26 3??234@7A <94 =>2 42;?97527=;
&
>@; ?2=@=@97 @; <@625 BC =>2 ?2=@=@9724 D>9 D3;
52<27537= @7
9,
&!&
3AA4@2E25 BC =>2 @F?:A725
94524 ?3;;25 @7 =>2 ;3@5 94@A@736 ;:@= 97
4524 --- ;>94= /
:62
375 & 9< =>2
0% BC
55@=@9736
952 9<
@E@6 49825:42 #<94
@E@6 ):5A2 375 ) +
#>242@73<=24 42<24425 =9 3; /=4@36
897<@4F25 @7
53=25 !
?3;;25 BC =>2
55@=@9736
&!&
375 ) +
3??2663=2
,
3;
3@8>:4
$
3@8>:4
9:4=0% D>@8> D3; 3669D25
375 =>2423<=24
!
<@625 :7524
, &!&
27@94
E@52 94524
@E@6 ):5A2
#>242@73<=24 42<24425 =9 3; /<@4;=
9:4=0%
>2 ?34=@2; =9 =>2 ?498225@7A; ;>366 B2 42<24425 =9
?63@7=@<<;
52<27537=
<94
=>2
;3G2
9<
23;C
:7524;=375@7A
>2 ?63@7=@<<; <@625 ;:@= <94 ?24F3727= @7H:78=@97 @7
9,
&!&
;22G@7A 528422 <94 ?24F3727= @7H:78=@97
-4-
375 9=>24 897;2I:27=@36 426@2<;
:4@7A =>2 ?275278C 9< =>2
;:@=
83F2 =9 B2 <@625 BC =>2
37 3??6@83=@97 @7
?63@7=@<<; :7524
4524 --- -
=2F?9434C @7H:78=@97
:62
375 & 9<
<94 A437= 9<
>2 ;3@5 3??6@83=@97 83F2 =9 B2
3669D25 97 897=2;= 375 37 94524 83F2 =9 B2 ?3;;25 @7 <3E9:4
9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 42;=43@7@7A =>2 52<27537= >@; F27 3A27=;
;24E37=; 3==9472C; <49F 83:;@7A 37C @7=24<242782 D@=> =>2
?9;;2;;@97 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 9E24 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C =@66
5@;?9;36 9< =>2 ;:@=
= D3; 36;9 ;=3=25 =>3= =>2 94524 9<
=2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 D9:65 79= 89F2 @7 =>2 D3C =9 ?42E27=
37C ?24;97 94 =>2 897824725 3:=>94@=@2; D>9 >3E2 =9
F23;:42 =>2 637525 ?49?24=@2; @786:5@7A =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62
?49?24=C 375 <@J =>2 B9:7534@2; 897;@524 =>2 42?42;27=3=@97
9< =>2 52<27537= 375 =3G2 3??49?4@3=2 38=@97 @7 3889453782
D@=> 63D 3; ?24 =>2 94524 9< =>@;
9:4=
2@7A 3AA4@2E25 BC =>2 94524 9< =>2 6234725 =4@36
):5A2 =>2 52<27537= ?42<24425 37 3??236 @7
B2<942 =>2
3@8>:4
55@=@9736
27@94
897;@5243=@97
3??2343782 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<;
9 , &!&
@E@6 ):5A2 375 ) +
9<
=>2
;:BF@;;@97;
3=
3<=24
=>2 ;3@5 3??236 83F2 =9 B2
-5-
42H28=25 375 =>2 @7=24@F 94524 ?3;;25 BC =>2 =4@36
83F2 =9 B2 3<<@4F25
9:4= 97
= @; =>@; 94524 9< B9=> =>2
9:4=; =>3= @; I:2;=@9725 @7 =>@; ?2=@=@97 BC =>2 52<27537= 97
=>2 <9669D@7A A49:75;
= @; =>2 E2>2F27= 897=27=@97 9< =>2 6234725
89:7;26 3??234@7A <94 =>2 52<27537= =>3= =>2 94524; ?3;;25
BC B9=> =>2
;3F2
9:4=; 342 ?24E24;2 34B@=434C @662A36 375 =>2
42I:@42; =9 B2 ;2= 3;@52 375 42E24;25
234725
89:7;26 <:4=>24 897=275; =>3= =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4=
D@=>9:= 3??6@83=@97 9< @752?27527= H:5@8@9:; F@75 >3; ;@F?6C
27594;25 =>2 <@75@7A 375 423;97@7A 9< =>2 =4@36
9:4= @;
D@=>9:= 699G@7A @7=9 =>2 F24@=; 9< =>2 F3==24 =>2 598:F27=;
?495:825 375 =>2 ;3F2 @; 79= ;:??94=25 BC =>2 423;97; 375
=>2 34A:F27= ?:= <94=> BC =>2 52<27537=
= @; <:4=>24
897=27525 =>3= A437= 9< @7H:78=@97 @; 3 5@;842=@9734C 375
2I:@=3B62 94524
>@; D9:65 >3E2 =9 B2 ?3;;25 B3;25 97
;2E2436 F3=24@36; ?63825 B2<942 =>2
9:4=
782 =>242 @; 3
;24@9:; 869:5 97 =>2 =@=62 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; @786:5@7A =>2 63D<:6
?9;;2;;@97 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; @7 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C
B9=> =>2 =4@36
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4= 89:65
-6-
79= >3E2 A437=25 375 3<<@4F25 =>2 94524 9< =2F?9434C
@7H:78=@97
9 36;9
>2 897=275; =>3= 3
83;2
42I:@42; =9 B2 =3G27 79=2 9< 375 3= =>2 ;3F2 =@F2 =>2 63D<:6
?9;;2;;@97 <69D 9< =@=62 63D<:6 =@=62 375 =>2
>3; 79= B227 897;@52425 BC B9=> =>2
9:4=;
=@=62
=>2
@F?:A725 94524; 342 79= ;:;=3@73B62 375 =>2 ;3F2 42I:@42;
=9 B2 ;2= 3;@52
'
= @; 36;9 897=27525 BC =>2 6234725 89:7;26 =>3=
B9=> =>2
=3G27
9:4=; D>@62 ?3;;@7A =>2 @F?:A725 94524 >3E2
@7=9
897;@5243=@97
42A345@7A
797 ?495:8=@97
9<
598:F27=; BC =>2 52<27537= =9 ?49E2 >@; =@=62 3; D266 3;
?9;;2;;@97
9E24
=>2
;:@=
;8>25:62
?49?24=C
D>@8>
@;
2449729:; 3; 52<27537= >3; ?63825 366 F3=24@36; 5@;869;@7A
>@; 4@A>= 9E24 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C B234@7A
9;
<94F25
# :4E2C
:4E2C
& % 9E24 D>@8> =>2 ?69=; 342
>2 52<27537= >3; 36;9 ?63825 F:=3=@97 42A@;=24
5@;869;@7A 94@A@736 9D724;>@? 9E24 =>2 6375 @7 I:2;=@97
= @;
36;9 897=27525 =>3= =>2 52<27537= >3; ?495:825 3B:7537=
F3=24@36; B2<942 =>2
9:4= 375 >3; 36;9 B49:A>= =9 =>2 79=@82
-7-
9< =>2
9:4= 42A345@7A :763D<:6 @662A36 897;=4:8=@97; 9E24 =>2
;:@= ?69=; BC E@963=@7A =>2 B:@65@7A BC2 63D;
= @; 36;9 897=27525 BC 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2
52<27537= =>3= =>2 =4@36
9:4= >3; F2426C 89F2 =9 =>2
89786:;@97 97 =>2 5:F?@7A 9< 824=3@7 897;=4:8=@97 F3=24@36;
BC =>2 ?63@7=@<<; =>3= =>2C >3E2 @7E2;=25 >:A2 3F9:7= 375
=>3= 797 A437= 9< @7H:78=@97 D9:65 83:;2 @442?3@43B62 @7H:4C
375 >345;>@? =9 =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 43=>24 =>37 =9 =>2 52<27537=
D>@8> @; 3 ;24@9:; 24494 388945@7A =9 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2
52<27537=
=4@36
= @; 36;9 897=27525 BC 6234725 89:7;26 =>3= =>2
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4= >3; @A79425 =>2
7282;;34C 42I:@42F27=; 375 @7A425@27=; D>@62 A437= 9<
=2F?9434C @7H:78=@97
7 =>2 ?42;27= 83;2 =>2 ?63@7=@<<; >3E2
<3@625 =9 2;=3B6@;> =>2@4 63D<:6 =@=62 375 63D<:6 ?9;;2;;@97 9E24
=>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C
7 =>2;2 A49:75; >2 ;22G; =9
3669D =>2 ?2=@=@97 375 897;2I:27=6C
@F?:A725 H:5AF27=; 9< =>2 =4@36
3??2663=2
9:4=
=9 ;2= 3;@52 =>2
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;=
-8-
.
6234725 89:7;26 3??234@7A <94 =>2
?63@7=@<<; ;:;=3@7; =>2 @F?:A725 94524; BC 897=275@7A =>3=
=>242 @; 79 @662A36@=C 94 ?24E24;@=C @7 =>2 94524 ?3;;25 BC =>2
=4@36
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4= 375 ;22G;
5@;F@;;36 9< =>2 ?2=@=@97
!
3E@7A
>2345
=>2
6234725
89:7;26
<94
=>2
?2=@=@9724 375 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 42;?97527=; =>2 ?9@7=
=>3= 34@;2; <94 897;@5243=@97 @; D>2=>24 =>2 @F?:A725 94524
?3;;25 BC =>2 =4@36
9:4= 375 =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4= 8366;
<94 37C @7=24<242782
*>27 37 3??6@83=@97 @; <@625 :7524
:62
375 & 9<
4524 --- -
<94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 =>2
<942F9;= 42I:@42F27=; 342 =>422 7282;;34C @7A425@27=;
73F26C
?4@F3 <38@2 83;2
B363782 9< 897E27@2782 375
>345;>@? =>3= D9:65 B2 83:;25 =9 =>2 3AA4@2E25 ?34=C
=>2 B3;@; 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; >3E@7A <@625 =>2 ;:@= 375 ?63825 97
428945 3 42A@;=2425 ;362 5225 375 >3E@7A ;>9D7 824=3@7
F3=24@36; G2?= @7 =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C >3E@7A ?49E25
=>2 63D<:6 ?9;;2;;@97 97 =>2 B3;@; 9< =>2 =@=62 D>@8> >2
-9-
863@F; =>2 =4@36
9:4= 83F2 =9 3 89786:;@97 =>3= =>2 ?63@7=@<<;
>3E2 F352 9:= 9<
83;2 <94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C
@7H:78=@97 375 A437=25 =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 42;=43@7@7A =>2
52<27537= <49F @7=24<24@7A D@=> =>2 ?2382<:6 ?9;;2;;@97 375
27H9CF27= 9< =>2 ;:@= ;8>25:62 ?49?24=C
>2 =4@36
9:4= D3;
36;9 9< =>2 9?@7@97 =>3= =>2 B363782 9< 897E27@2782 =@6=; @7
<3E9:4 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 375 >345;>@? D9:65 B2 83:;25 F942
=9 =>2 ?63@7=@<<; =>37 =9 =>2 52<27537=
&
= @; 3 <:753F27=36 4:62 9< 63D =>3= D>@62
897;@524@7A 37 3??6@83=@97 :7524
9<
4524 --- -
D>3= @; =9 B2 ;227 BC =>2 =4@36
:62
375 &
9:4= @; =9 F3G2 9:= 3
83;2 BC =>2 ?34=C <94 897;@5243=@97 9< 3
83;2
= @;
:759:B=256C 86234 =>3= D@=>9:= 37 @9=3 9< 59:B= =>3= =>2
83;2 @; 79= =9 B2 897<:;25 D@=>
>2
=@=62
=@=62 89:65 B2 2;=3B6@;>25 BC 2@=>24 9< =>2
?34=C 3<=24 =4@36 94 5:4@7A =>2 89:4;2 9< =4@36
83;2 @; F352 9:= 3= =>2 @7@=@36 ;=3A2 F3C B2 2E27 BC 3
?24;97 D>9 592; 79= >3E2 3
5236@7A D@=> 37 3??6@83=@97 :7524
9<
=@=62
4524 --- -
= =>2 =@F2 9<
:62
375 &
D>3= @; =9 B2 897;@52425 =>2 ;:B;=37=@36 I:2;=@97 =9
- 10 -
B2 43@;25 375 528@525 @; 976C
=@=62
>2 =4@36
83;2 375 79=
9:4= 7225; =9 B2 ;3=@;<@25 97 =>2 B3;@;
9< F3=24@36; ?63825 B2<942 @= D>2=>24 >2 >3; F352 9:= 3
83;2 <94 A437= 9< 37 @7=24@F 94524 375 =>3= =>2
B363782 9< 897E27@2782 =@6=; @7 >@; <3E9:4 ;9 36;9 D>2=>24
>345;>@? D9:65 B2 83:;25 F942 =9 D>@8> 9< =>2 ?34=@2;
>242<942 @= D9:65 B2 E24C 84:8@36 <94 B9=> =>2 ?34=@2; 375
<94 =>2
9:4= =9 =3G2 3 ?49?24 897;8@9:; 375 83:=@9:;
5@;842=@9734C 528@;@97 D>@62 A437=@7A 37 94524 9< =2F?9434C
@7H:78=@97 375 79= =9 897<:;2 375 F@J =>2 I:2;=@97 9<
83;2 D@=> =>3= 9<
=@=62
782 =>2
89F2; =9 =>2 9?@7@97 =>3= =>242 @; 3
9:= =>27 =>2
9:4=
83;2 F352
9:4= 89:65 ?498225 <:4=>24 =9 A437= 37 94524
9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 =9 =>2 ?34=C @7 D>9;2 <3E9:4 =>2
B363782 9< 897E27@2782 =@6=; 375 =9 D>9F >345;>@? @; 83:;25
,
>2
971B62
?2J
9:4= @7 =>2 83;2 9<
>3; 5236= D@=> =>@; F3==24 375 =>2
?4@78@?62; <94 A437= 9< =2F?9434C @7H:78=@97 3= ?343A43?>
9; ,, 375 ,
D>@8> 4235; 3; :7524
- 11 -
!
!"#
+,
$%&#
$ $
' %( '#)!%
*
' %
! "## !$%&
'(
(
# )
)
)
*
(
,
)
'
+)
')
& '(
'(
&
-
-
)
+)
.
+ (
(
(
'
+)
)
'
'
/ (
)'
'
0)
&
&
"
'(
)
# )
)
'(
-
'
+)
(
)
+) (-
)
(
(
.
)
*
+)
0)
'
(
- 12 -
+) (
'
+) (&
&
)
(
'
(
'
+) (& ')
(
+) (
)
'
(
&
'
'(
0)
(
(
'
)
'
-
)
+)
)
.
)
)
# )
+)
+)
)'
(
'
)
+) (
)
&
+)
)
(
'
)
+)
'
' '
+) (
) &
)
'
)
'
)
+)
)
)
) &
# )
)'+
0) &
# )
.
)
+)
"
1 2
+)
3)
)
"
"## 5 4 6
= @; 36;9 4262E37= =9 F27=@97 >242 =>3= D>@62
5236@7A D@=> =>2 ?2=@=@97 :7524
4=@862; &&
375 &&' 9< =>2
- 13 -
97;=@=:=@97 9< 75@3 =>@;
9< =>2 F3==24 3; =>@;
H:4@;5@8=@97
>@;
9:4= 7225 79= A9 @7=9 =>2 F24@=;
9:4= @; 79= ;@==@7A @7 =>2 3??2663=2
9:4= D9:65 >3E2 =9 ;22 D>2=>24 =>2
@F?:A725 94524 ?3;;25 BC =>2 =4@36
9:4= @; 3 ?24E24;2
@662A36 94 D>2=>24 @= D9:65 8366 <94 @7=24<242782 375 79=
E27=:42 @7=9 =>2 59F3@7 9< =>2 3??2663=2
9:4=1; H:4@;5@8=@97
7524 =>2 8@48:F;=3782; >3E@7A A972 =>49:A> =>2 @F?:A725
94524 9< =>2 =4@36
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4=
375 =>2 ;:BF@;;@97 9< 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 ?2=@=@9724 375
=>2 42;?97527=;
59 79= <@75 37C A995 A49:75 94 89A27=
423;97 =9 @7=24<242 D@=> =>2 D266 423;9725 94524 9< =>2 =4@36
9:4= 3; D266 3; =>2 <@4;= 3??2663=2
9:4=
= @; 3A3@7 722562;; =9 F27=@97 =>3= @= D9:65 B2
9?27 <94 =>2 52<27537= =9 ?6382 366 ;:8> F3=24@36 B2<942 =>2
9:4= 375 5@;?49E2 =>2 83;2 9< =>2 ?63@7=@<<; 3; @= @; 364235C
>265 BC =>2 6234725 =4@36 ):5A2 =>3= =>2 @F?:A725 94524
?3;;25 @; 976C <94 528@5@7A =>2 3??6@83=@97 375 79= =>2 F3@7
;:@=
88945@7A6C
?3;; =>2 <9669D@7A
- 14 -
>@; ?2=@=@97 @; 5@;F@;;25
()
&
!
%
''
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review