Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 27th DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. SUNIL DUTT YADAV
CRIMINAL PETITION No.16900 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
SRI VINAY RAJASHEKHRAPPA KULKARNI
S/O LATE RAJASHEKHARAPPA KULKARNI
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
R/A. BARAKOTRI, SHIVAGIRI,
DHARWAD, KARNATAKA - 580 007
(PRESENTLY UNDER DURESS IN
JUDICIAL CUSTODY)
Digitally
signed by
PRAKASH N
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
... PETITIONER
(BY SRI C.V. NAGESH, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI SUNIL KUMAR S., ADVOCATE)
AND:
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
ANTI-CORRUPTION BRANCH
REP. BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
36, BELLARY ROAD, KGH LAYOUT
GANGANAGAR
BENGALURU - 560 032.
... RESPONDENT
(BY SRI P. PRASANNA KUMAR, ADVOCATE A/W
SRI RAHUL KRISHNA REDDY P., ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 439
OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, PRAYING TO
RELEASE HIM ON REGULAR BAIL IN SPL. CC. NO.565/2021
(CRIME NO.17(S)/2019-CBI-BLR) FOR THE OFFENCES P/U/S
-2NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
120B R/W 302, 201, 143, 147, 148 R/W 149 OF IPC, SEC.25
R/W SEC.3, 5, 8 & 29 OF ARMS ACT, WHICH IS NOW PENDING
BEFORE THE HON'BLE LXXXI ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS
JUDGE
AT
BENGALURU
(CCH-82)
(SPECIAL
COURT
EXCLUSIVELY TO DEAL WITH CRIMINAL CASES RELATED TO
ELECTED MPs/MLAs IN THE STATE OF KARNATAKA) ON SUCH
TERMS AND CONDITIONS IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE.
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED
ON
09.01.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS, THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE
THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S SUNIL DUTT YADAV
CAV ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking to be
released on Regular Bail in connection with his custody
pursuant to the proceedings pending in Spl.CC No.565/2021.
The proceedings are pending in relation to case registered with
respect to the offences under Section 120B r/w 302, 201, 143,
147, 148 r/w 149 of IPC, Section 25 r/w 3, 5, 8 and 29 of the
Arms Act before the LXXXI Additional City Civil & Sessions
Judge at Bengaluru (CCH-82).
2. It is to be noticed that the petitioner had moved an
application seeking to be enlarged on bail before the Trial Court
and the Court has rejected the application of the petitioner
seeking to be enlarged on bail.
-3NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
3. The brief facts made out are that Crime No.135/2016
was registered by the
Sub-Urban
Police
Station against
unknown persons on 15.06.2016 on the basis of information
made out by Smt.Mallavva Goudar, W/o Late Yogish Goudar as
regards the incident in which her husband was stated to have
been done to death by unknown assailants.
4.
The facts made out are that charge sheet was filed
against six accused persons for the offences under Section
120B r/w 302, 201, 143, 147, 148 r/w 149 of IPC.
5.
and
It is further made out that evidence was completed
the case was at the stage of arguments when the matter
was entrusted to CBI. The CBI renumbered the Crime as
No.RC.17(S)/2019/CBI/ACB/BLR for certain offences and took
up further investigation on 24.09.2019. The CBI had filed first
additional charge sheet against accused nos.1 to 14 for the
offences under Section 120B r/w 302, 201, 143, 147, 148 r/w
149 of IPC.
The CBI had filed the second additional charge
sheet including against the petitioner for the offences under
Section 120B, 143, 147, 148 r/w 149, 302 of IPC and under
Section 25 r/w Section 3, 5, 8 and 29 of the Arms Act.
-4NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
6.
It is made out from the facts that the accused was
arrested and later enlarged on bail by the Apex Court by order
passed in SLP (Criminal) No.4739/2021. Subsequently, though
an application was moved for cancellation of bail before the
Trial Court, the same was dismissed on the ground of
maintainability. Eventually, SLP (Criminal) 7865/2025 came to
be allowed and the bail granted earlier came to be cancelled.
It is stated that the petitioner had surrendered before the Trial
Court on 13.06.2025.
7. Learned Senior Counsel Sri.C.V.Nagesh appearing on
behalf of the petitioner would submit that all material witnesses
have been examined and it is only the evidence of official
witnesses that remains. It is further asserted that the petitioner
was granted bail before the Apex Court on 11.08.2021 and had
enjoyed the benefit of bail till said bail came to be cancelled on
06.06.2025 and accordingly had enjoyed relief of bail for a
period of about 04 years.
8. It is submitted that the petitioner had influenced the
prosecution witnesses PW's.25 and 26 and it is in such context
that bail was cancelled.
It is submitted that evidence of the
-5NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
said witnesses is now complete and all of the important
witnesses have completed their evidence. It is also submitted
that none of the eyewitnesses have supported the case of the
prosecution
and
that
by
itself
would
be
a
'change
in
circumstance' warranting grant of bail.
9. It is further submitted that the offence as made out
against the petitioner is only regarding conspiracy which is not
a standalone offence and in the absence of evidence regarding
commission of the offence, the case regarding conspiracy would
stand on weak footing.
It is further submitted that the
petitioner is a three time Legislator and has no antecedents.
10. It is also submitted that the petitioner is entitled to
be enlarged on bail on the ground of parity as the other coaccused whose bail was also cancelled on the ground of
violation of bail conditions had the benefit of bail order restored
by orders passed by the High Court.
Accordingly, it is
submitted that on the principle of parity as well, the petitioner
is entitled to be enlarged on bail.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
11.
Reliance is placed on the order passed in Vipin
Kumar v. State of U.P.1 and it is submitted that the Apex
Court has clarified that once an order granting bail is set aside,
there is no prohibition to file a fresh application for bail.
Accordingly, it is submitted that though bail granted by the
Apex Court was cancelled by the Apex Court itself, by virtue of
change in circumstances, a fresh bail application ought to be
entertained.
12. Learned Counsel Sri.P.Prasanna Kumar appearing for
respondent-CBI would submit that there are certain other
witnesses who are still to be examined and has filed a memo
regarding
the
intention
of
respondent-CBI
to
examine
Sri.Motilal Ramaswamy Pawar (CW.124), Sri.P.Gopalakrishnan,
Programmer, TAFSU (CW.30), Sri.Rakesh Ranjan P.I. & I.O. of
the case who had filed the charge sheet. However, it is
vehemently submitted that the cancellation of bail by the Apex
Court has disentitled the petitioner to seek fresh bail as the
Apex Court has not reserved liberty to seek for fresh bail.
Crl.A 726/2025 arising out of SLP (Crl) No.17918/2024
-7NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
13. It is further submitted that the order passed in
Vipin Kumar's case must be understood in the context of the
particular factual matrix.
It is submitted that observations
made were in the context of bail granted by the High Court and
set aside by the Apex Court and the observation is made to the
effect that a fresh bail application could be filed. However, it is
submitted that the present case deals with a different factual
matrix where bail granted by the Apex Court has been
cancelled by the same court on the ground of violation of
conditions of bail. It is submitted that the observations made
therein cannot be extended to the present case.
14. It is specifically contended that the Apex Court in the
case of Rajesh Ranjan Yadav @ Pappu Yadav v. CBI
through its Director2 has taken note of status of elected
representatives while observing that such status may be 'wholly
irrelevant', and that mere completion of evidence of the
prosecution witnesses would not also be a relevant factor when
the allegations against the petitioner are serious.
(2007) 1 SCC 70
-8NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
15. The Trial Court was approached by the petitioner at
the first instance and petitioner had sought to be enlarged on
bail.
After detailed consideration, the trial court has rejected
the application on various grounds. The trial court has rejected
the contention of the petitioner who has claimed parity with the
co-accused who have been enlarged on bail. The trial court has
observed that parity cannot be the sole criteria. The trial court
has also accepted the contention of the respondent-CBI
regarding possibility of tampering. Finally, the Trial Court had
observed
that
where
bail
was
granted
by
a
superior
Constitutional Court and subsequently such bail granted was
cancelled, the Trial Court could not enlarge the petitioner on
bail.
16. Heard both sides.
17. At the outset, it must be noticed that the Apex Court
had enlarged the petitioner on bail by order dated 11.08.2021.
Prior to such order, the request of the petitioner for being
enlarged on bail came to be rejected by the other courts. The
operative portion of the order granting bail which would
indicate the conditions imposed are extracted below:
-9NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
"Considering the facts and circumstances
on record, we deem appropriate to pass the
following directions:
I. The appellant shall be produced before
the concerned Trial Court within three days from
today and the Trial Court shall release the
appellant on bail on such conditions as the Trial
Court may deem appropriate to impose. Such
conditions shall however include the following:
i. The appellant shall not in any way
impede the conduct and proceedings of the
investigation and the trial;
ii. The appellant shall not directly or
indirectly get in touch with any of the witnesses
nor shall he try to influence any such witnesses.
iii. The
appellant
shall
not enter
the
District Dharwad till further orders to be passed
by the Trial Court.
iv. The appellant shall mark his presence
in the office of ACP CBI Unit, Bengaluru, twice a
week.
II. Any infraction or violation of the above
conditions shall entail in cancellation of bail.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
Needless to say that grant of bail in favour
of the appellant shall not be construed as
reflection by this Court on merits of the matter,
which shall be gone into independently by the
Trial Court at every stage of the proceedings.
With the aforesaid directions, the appeal is
allowed."
18.
before the
An application was moved for cancellation of bail
Trial Court which came to be rejected and SLP
(Criminal) 7865/2025 came to be filed which was eventually
allowed and the bail granted to the petitioner herein came to be
cancelled. The Apex Court in its order dated 06.06.2025 had
observed that there was sufficient material on record that
attempts have been made by the petitioner to either contact
witnesses or alternatively, influence such witnesses.
19.
The observation made at Para 19 would be of
relevance and is extracted below:
"19. Therefore, keeping in mind the totality
of circumstances, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the bail granted to the Respondent
ought to be cancelled. Consequently, the bail
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
granted to Accused No. 15 i.e., the Respondent is
hereby cancelled. The Respondent shall surrender
before the concerned trial court / jail authority
within a period of 1 (one) week from today.
However, we deem it appropriate to direct the
Learned
Trial
Court
to
make
endeavours
to
conclude the trial expeditiously, without being
influenced by any of our observation(s)."
20.
The question that requires to be answered is,
whether petitioner could have approached the trial court
seeking for enlargement on bail considering that the bail
granted to the petitioner by the Apex Court was cancelled by
the Apex Court itself without reserving liberty ?
21. Admittedly, the bail was granted by the Apex Court
by order dated 11.08.2021 and conditions were imposed as
extracted above.
The condition No.I (ii) provided that the
appellant shall not directly or indirectly get in touch with any of
the witnesses nor shall he try to influence any such witnesses.
Further it is provided at condition No.II that any infraction or
violation of the above conditions would entail in cancellation of
bail.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
22. It is necessary to note that cancellation of bail by the
Apex Court as per the order of the Apex Court in SLP (Criminal)
7865/2025 vide order dated 06.06.2025 and the ground on
which the order came to be passed was "… it would be suffice
to state that there is sufficient material on record to suggest
that the attempt(s) have been made by the respondent to
either
contact
witnesses
or
alternatively,
influence
such
witnesses."
23. Further, while cancelling bail and directing the
petitioner herein to surrender, it was observed as follows:
"However, we deem it appropriate to direct
the learned Trial Court to make endeavours to
conclude the trial expeditiously, without being
influenced by any of our observation(s)."
24. The following becomes clear:i)
Cancellation of bail was on the basis that attempt was
made to contact or influence the witnesses.
ii)
The order cancelling bail did not reserve liberty to
approach again.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
iii)
The direction to complete trial expeditiously would in fact
indicate that there was the intention of the Apex Court to
mitigate the long incarceration by directing speedy
conclusion of the trial.
While 'change in circumstances' could be a ground for
re-approaching
the
court
seeking
fresh
bail
where
an
application is rejected on merits, however the same logic
cannot be extended in cases where the bail granted is cancelled
due to violation of conditions.
25.
The grant of bail has an element of exercise of
judicial discretion, though premised on liberty based rights.
While no doubt the foundation of bail jurisprudence is on the
bedrock of 'Bail is the rule and Jail is the exception', however a
balance is struck with the societal concerns of the 'crime
against society' by denying bail till certain stages of trial to
secure an uninfluenced trial.
The courts evaluate the risk of
tampering of evidence by way of potentiality to influence the
witnesses and may either deny bail till they are examined, or
release them on bail after imposing suitable conditions. While
allowing the accused to be enlarged on bail, it is but expected
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
that the condition imposed is to be adhered to. The orders that
enlarge the accused on bail also provides for cancellation of bail
in the event of violation of the conditions. Such condition is a
normal condition imposed which in effect seeks to pre-empt the
misuse of an order which had enlarged the petitioner on bail
and secured his liberty subject to adherence to certain
conditions.
26.
The case of cancellation of bail is to be looked at
differently unlike an order of setting aside the order of bail
granted
by
a
court
subordinate
in
its
hierarchy.
The
considerations in setting aside an order of bail by a superior
court are different and in contradistinction to the conditions
taken note of while cancelling an order of bail granted by the
same court or any other court on the premise of violation of
conditions imposed. In the present case, this court is dealing
with the latter case.
27.
The ground of 'change in circumstances' may be a
ground for reconsideration of an order rejecting bail, but would
be of no avail where the bail is cancelled for violation of
conditions imposed.
When the bail granted is cancelled for
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
violation of bail conditions, the accused essentially disentitles
himself of exercise of judicial discretion subsequently. The
subsequent events of nearing completion of examination of
witnesses are of no relevance.
28.
In the present case, when the Apex Court has
cancelled the bail on the ground of violation of conditions
without reserving liberty, it would be against judicial propriety
for any other court to reconsider and grant bail. The petitioner
ought to have approached the Apex Court and sought for
reconsideration, especially where the Apex Court had not
reserved any liberty.
By misuse of liberty granted, the
petitioner had disentitled himself from claiming to be released
on bail by relying on merits of claim of bail on any grounds.
The accused is required to move the Apex Court itself for
reconsideration.
29.
observations
The reliance placed by the petitioner on the
in
Vipin
Kumar
v.
State
of
U.P.
in
Crl.A 726/2025 (arising out of SLP (Crl) No.17918/2024),
requires consideration. The observations made at para 3 to 6
are of relevance and extracted below:-
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
"3. The earlier bail application of the appellant
was allowed by the High Court vide order dated
03.10.2023. However, the said order was set aside
by this Court. Thereafter, the appellant applied
afresh for bail before the High Court and the said
application was rejected solely on the ground that
Supreme Court of India while cancelling the bail
granted by the High Court, had not given any
liberty
to
the
appellant
to
file
a
fresh
bail
application.
4. There is no prohibition in filing a fresh bail
application
after
the
earlier
was
rejected
or
cancelled, if granted. This Court in cancelling the
bail application has not taken away the right of the
appellant
to
apply
for
bail
afresh,
if
the
circumstances permit.
5. Filing of a fresh bail application, once an
earlier bail application has been rejected or if
granted and thereafter cancelled is a matter of right
and solely on the ground that the Apex Court had
not permitted filing of the fresh bail application, the
High Court was not justified in dismissing the bail
application.
6.
In
view
circumstances,
of
the
the
order
aforesaid
facts
impugned
and
dated
31.05.2024 passed by the High Court rejecting the
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
bail application of the appellant is hereby set aside
and the matter is remanded to the High Court for
decision afresh on merits."
30. In light of such observations, it is contended that the
petitioner has rightly approached the Trial Court in light of
changed circumstances and the application ought to have been
considered.
31. It is to be noticed that in Vipin Kumar (supra), the
accused in the above mentioned case was initially enlarged on
bail by the High Court. The said order came to be challenged
before the Apex Court and bail granted by the High court in
terms of the order passed in the case of Deepanshu v. State
of U.P. and Another3 was set aside.
32. The challenge to the bail granted, was supported by
the State contending that bail was undeservedly granted. The
said bail order was set aside observing that the bail order was
granted by a cryptic order and that the accused was the
threatening the victim's family.
Crl.A 121/2024 arising out of SLP (Criminal) No. 15608/2023
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
33. In the second round, the fresh bail application was
filed which was rejected as not being maintainable and the
Apex Court had clarified as per the observations made which
are extracted as above at Para 29.
34. It must be noticed that the observations made in
Vipin Kumar (supra) was that the bail granted by the High
Court was set aside by the Apex Court.
Essentially it was a
decision of reversal of an order granting bail being passed by a
superior court. Such order would still permit approaching the
trial
court
'if
circumstances
circumstances
for
grant
of
permit'
bail
are
viz.,
where
fresh
made
out.
Such
observations are to be construed in the context of bail being
granted by an order on merits and cancelled by a superior
Court.
35. However, such observations cannot be extended to a
case as in the present where bail granted has been cancelled by
the Apex Court on the ground of violation of bail conditions.
36. The distinction between reversal of an order of bail
by the superior Court and cancellation of bail for violation of
bail conditions is stark and must be maintained.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
37. Once an order is made in the former case, approach
on fresh grounds would be permissible, but in the latter case
the accused is to seek for fresh indulgence for reconsideration.
38. The words 'granted and thereafter cancelled' thus in
Vipin Kumar (supra) must be read in the context of the
order.
Accordingly, this Court holds that the petitioner is to
re-approach the Apex Court and make out an appropriate case
instead of the current exercise of having approached the trial
Court and this Court once again.
39.
In light of the above, it would be impermissible to
enter into other contentions raised by the petitioner including
that the subsequent events of completion of examination of
important witnesses by itself ensuring absence of opportunity
to tamper with the witnesses being a ground to enlarge the
petitioner on bail cannot be considered.
Further, other
contentions raised by the petitioner including that of release of
co-accused on parity by this court cannot be taken benefit of by
the petitioner as the petitioner's bail was granted and cancelled
by the Apex Court.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:4344
CRL.P No. 16900 of 2025
HC-KAR
40. The question of entering into the contention by the
respondent that the petitioner has tampered with witnesses
and is ineligible for claim to be released on bail also need not
be entered into in light of the view expressed above that it
would be appropriate for the petitioner to approach the Apex
Court itself.
41. Accordingly the petition is rejected subject to the
above observations. All contentions by the petitioner regarding
the grounds made out for him to be enlarged on bail are
kept open.
42. It is made clear that the court has not recorded any
finding regarding the merits of the claim and has merely
disposed of the petition holding that petitioner is required to
have approached the Apex Court itself.
Sd/(S SUNIL DUTT YADAV)
JUDGE
NP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review