Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 10.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 08.10.2026
Date of uploading
:
15.10.2026
APHC010822412016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3594]
THURSDAY, THE 8th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT PETITION Nos.30640, 17678, 10587, 32133, 32418, 36940 and
36954 of 2016, 31208 and 36063 of 2017 and 7158, 45387, 45504, 47197
and 47287 of 2018 and W.P.Nos.260, 1590, 11115 of 2019 and 2051,
2110, 2514, 6480 and 6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021 and 40351, 40354 of
2022, 23960 of 2023 and 29854 of 2024 and 2564, 9604, 9702, 11011,
13099 and 13102 of 2026
WRIT PETITION NO: 30640/2016
Between:
1. M/S. SRI VEERA VENKATA SATYANARAYANA MODEM RICE MILL,
SRUNGAVRUKSHAM, PALAKODERU MANDAL, REPRESENTED
BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, SRI. KURMALA NAGARAJU @
NAGA VENKATA SATYANARAYA MURTHY S/O. KURMALA GANGA
RAJU, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS, WEST GODAVARI DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. CTO BHEEMAVARAM 2 ORS, BHEEMAVARAM, WEST GODAVARI
DISTRICT-ANDHRA PRADESH.
2. THE COMMISSIONER OF
PRADESH, HYDERABAD.
COMMERCIAL
TAXES,
ANDHRA
3. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH REPRESENTED BY ITS, SPECIAL
CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVT, A.P. SECRETARIAT, SAIFABAD,
HYDERABAD.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
2. SHAIK JEELANI BASHA(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 17678/2016
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s.syamalamba Modern Rice Mill,
AND
State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. P BALAJI VARMA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
2. SURIBABU S(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 10587/2016
Between:
...PETITIONER
M. Laila Rani
AND
Appellate Dy Commr Ct Guntur 3 Ors and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. BETHAPALLI SURYANARAYANA (CENTRAL GOVT COUNSEL)
2. SHAIK JEELANI BASHA(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
3. HARINATH N (DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA)
WRIT PETITION NO: 32133/2016
Between:
M/s. Sri Sai Surya Traders, E.g.dist.
...PETITIONER
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer E G Dist A P 3 Otrs and
Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
2. SURIBABU S(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 32418/2016
Between:
Partner, M/s.sri Radhakrishna Rice Mill, West Godavari Dist ...PETITIONER
AND
Commercial Tax Officer West Godavari Dist 2 Others
and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
2. SURIBABU S(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 36940/2016
Between:
Managing Partner, M/s. Pallavi Enterpries, Vijayawada
...PETITIONER
AND
Prl Secretary Revenue Ct Dept Hyd Another and
Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K RAJI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
2. SURIBABU S(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 36954/2016
Between:
Managing Partner, M/s. Girija Moderen Rice Mill, Vijaywada ...PETITIONER
AND
Prl Secretary Revenue Ct Dept Hyd Another and
Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K RAJI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
2. SHAIK JEELANI BASHA(SPL SC FOR CT AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 31208/2017
Between:
M/s Meharbaba Rao & Boiled Rice Mill Cont. Com.. Krishna ...PETITIONER
Dis
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer Krishna Dist 3 Others and ...RESPONDENT(S)
Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 36063/2017
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Sri Ramanjaneya Traders,
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 7158/2018
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Mohan Spintex India Limited ,
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 45387/2018
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Aiswarya Cotton Mills,
AND
The Commercial Tax Officeri and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 45504/2018
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Sri Lalitha Cotton Mills Pvt Ltd.
AND
The Commercial Tax Officeri and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 47197/2018
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Balaji Traders,
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 47287/2018
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sri Vigneswara Traders
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 260/2019
Between:
M/s Ravindranath Fruit Canning India Pvt. Ltd.,
...PETITIONER
AND
The Appellate Deputy Commissioner Ct and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
WRIT PETITION NO: 1590/2019
...RESPONDENT(S)
Between:
...PETITIONER
Saraswathi Granites
AND
The Appellate Dy Commissioner and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. THE ADVOCATE GENERAL (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 11115/2019
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sarda Metal And
AND
The Assistant Commissioner Ct and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A SARVESWAR RAO
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 2051/2020
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Quality Stones
AND
The Deputy Commissioner Ct and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 2110/2020
Between:
...RESPONDENT(S)
...PETITIONER
Quality Stones
AND
The Deputy Commissioner Ct and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 2514/2020
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Sai Ganesh Exports
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer Noi and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K ADI SIVA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 6480/2020
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Sita Lakshmi Traders,
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. G NARENDRA CHETTY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 6597/2020
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sita Lakshmi Traders
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. G NARENDRA CHETTY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)
WRIT PETITION NO: 3111/2021
Between:
M/s. Sri Venkata Sai Siva Ganga Granites
...PETITIONER
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K ADI SIVA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 40351/2022
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Jaya Mineral Exports
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K ADI SIVA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 40354/2022
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Jaya Mineral Exports
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. K ADI SIVA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 23960/2023
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s Srinivasa Granites
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K ADI SIVA VARA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 29854/2024
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Azad Traders,
AND
The Chief Commissioner Of State Taxes and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PEDDIBHOTLA VENKATA SAI RAJESH
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 2564/2026
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Ritesh Spices,
AND
Union Of India and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. DR D VENKATA RAMANA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
...RESPONDENT(S)
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 9604/2026
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sri Balaji Traders
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 9702/2026
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sri Balaji Traders
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 11011/2026
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Sri Balaji Traders
AND
Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 13099/2026
...RESPONDENT(S)
Between:
...PETITIONER
Ganesh Spices
AND
Commissioner Tax Officer and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
WRIT PETITION NO: 13102/2026
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Ganesh Spices
AND
Commercial Tax Officer and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT(S)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT PETITION Nos.30640, 17678, 10587, 32133, 32418, 36940 and
36954 of 2016, 31208 and 36063 of 2017 and 7158, 45387,45504,47197
and 47287 of 2018 and W.P.Nos.260, 1590, 11115 of 2019 and 2051,
2110, 2514, 6480 and 6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021 and 40351, 40354 of
2022, 23960 of 2023 and 29854 of 2024 and 2564, 9604, 9702, 11011,
13099 and 13102 of 2026
COMMON ORDER: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Battu Devanand)
The question involved in this batch of cases for resolution by Full
Bench is whether the time prescribed under Rule 12(7), which permits the
submission of declarations in Forms 'C' and 'F' within three months after the
end of the period to which the declaration relates, would equally apply to the
Certificate in Form 'H'. Alternatively, the question is whether Form 'H' must
necessarily be furnished before the completion of the assessment
proceedings, in the absence of any specific provision extending the time for
its submission or in the absence of any specific prescription by the State in
respect of Form ‗H‘, as to its form and submission.
2)
[i] In respect of an issue touching the refusal of the concerned
authorities, to permit the submission of ‗H‘ forms after the assessment
process, for extending the benefit in terms of Section 5(3) of CST Act,1956,
a Division Bench of this Court while considering the earlier orders in
different writ petitions, vide a batch of W.P.Nos.7158 of 2018, 10587 of
2016, 2514, 6480 and 6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021, and 40351, 40354 of
2022, 23960 of 2023, 29854 of 2024 passed the following orders dated
22.01.2025:
―…
The petitioners contend that there is no time limit for receipt of ‘H’
Forms, and that such ‘H’ Forms can be filed even after the assessment
proceedings have been completed, in view of the Judgments of the
erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana
and the State of Andhra Pradesh and this Court in W.P.No.1466 of 2017
dated 24.01.2027, W.P.No.16718 of 2019 dated 30.10.2019, W.P.No.12450
of 2019 dated 07.10.2023 and W.P.No.18205 of 2020 and batch dated
11.09.2024.
In all these Judgments, the Division Bench, in each case, had taken
the view that the Judgment of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at
Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in
the case of M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd., China Pothapally & another vs.
Commercial Tax Officer, Eluru & another1, relating to ‘C’&‘F’ forms and the
time within the such ‘C’&‘F’ Forms can be filed would apply to the
production and filing of ‘H’ Forms also.
….
The logical consequence of this interpretation would be that filing of
Form ‘H’ would not be mutatis mutandis with the filing of Form ’C’ and ‘F’.
In view of the earlier Judgments of the Division Benches of this Court
which are co-ordinate with this bench, it would only be appropriate that the
matter is placed before the Hon’ble The Chief Justice for reference to a Full
Bench to resolve this issue.‖
[ii]
Further in another batch of writ petitions vide W.P.Nos.30640 of
2016, 32418, 17678 and 32133 of 2016, 36063 and 31208 of 2017, 45387,
45504, 47197 and 47287 of 2018, 260 and 1590 of 2019, 2051, 2110 of
2020, 36940, 36954 of 2016 and 11115 of 2019 the same Division Bench of
this Court made the following order dated 29.01.2025:―The present case relates to the admissibility of the ‗H‘ Forms, after the
assessment proceedings had been completed. The said issue has been
referred to a Full Bench, by a Division Bench of this Court, by an order
dated 22.01.2025, in W.P. No.7158 of 2018 & batch.
This Writ Petition is also referred to the Full Bench.
Accordingly, Registry is directed to place the bundle before the Hon‘ble
The Chief Justice for appropriate directions.‖
[iii]
When the above orders passed in the batch of writ petitions
were placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice with a note, this Full
Bench was constituted for addressing and answering the issue referred
under the orders dated 22.01.2025 and 29.01.2025 passed by a Division
Bench of this Court in the batch of Writ Petitions mentioned above.
3)
Details of writ petitions:
The writ petitioners in each case were served with a memo for not
producing the ‗H‘ Form contemplated in terms of CST Act levying Tax. The
said memo issued against each petitioner in respect of the writ petitions
under challenge, as per details in the writ petitions are as follows:Sl.No.
01.
W.P.NO.
30640 of 2016
02.
10587 of 2016
03.
17678 of 2016
04.
32133 of 2016
05.
32418 of 2016
06.
7158 of 2018
07.
45387 of 2018
Memo details
REV.35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
Assessment
Order
vide
CTD
No.30328
TIN 28922223727/ 2014-15 (CST)
dated 17.07.2015
Assessment Order vide A.O.No.4861,
TIN No.28060179513/2011-12 (CST)
dated 25.01.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
Enclosed as
Ex.P1
Ex.P2
Ex.P1
Ex.P5
Ex.P1
Ex.P7
Ex.P3
08.
45504 of 2018
09.
47197 of 2018
10.
47287 of 2018
11.
260 of 2019
12.
1590 of 2019
13.
11115 of 2019
14.
36940 of 2016
15.
36954 of 2016
16.
31208 of 2017
17.
36063 of 2017
18.
2051 of 2020
19.
2110 of 2020
20.
2514 of 2020
21.
6480 of 2020
22.
6597 of 2020
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
311 of 2021
40351 of 2022
40354 of 2022
23960 of 2023
29854 of 2024
28.
2564 of 2026
29.
9604 of 2026
30.
9702 of 2026
31.
11011 of 2016
32.
13099 of 2026
33.
13102 of 2026
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
A.O.No.125357
TIN:37963232752,dated 08.08.2018
A.O.17813 Tin.28180186299 dated
31.03.2016
A.O.17822, TIN.28148617993 dated
31.03.2016
REV.35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV.35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
DC.ORDER.NO.2728.
Spl.R.No.18/2017-18 dt.12.11.2019
DC.ORDER.NO.-2727.
Spl.R.No.17/2017-18 dt.12.11.2019
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
AAO No.109148
TIN No:28430152276/2013-14(CST)
dt.30.03.2018.
AAO
No.176339
TIN
No:28430152276/2011-12(CST)
dt.07.11.2019.
AO.No.63076/31.03.2017
AO.No.59673/25.03.2017
AO.No.64162/31.03.2017
AO.No.64238/31.03.2017
Assessment
No.CST/Nil/2015-16
Tin.3739834422,
(A.O.No.167534)
dt.23.09.2019
DIN:DIN3720122591299
TIN:37600233815/2015-16(CST)
Dt.20.12.2025
TIN.28660183373/2012-13/CST
dt.28.10.2015
TIN.28660183373/2011-12
dt.31.03.2015
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
REV-35024/12/2016-CT-II(1)-1
dt.30.04.2016
Ex.P3
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P3
Ex.P3
Ex.P1
Ex.P2
Ex.P2
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P5
Ex.P3
Ex.P3
Ex.P3
Ex.P2
Ex.P3
Ex.P3
Ex.P2
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P1
Ex.P5
Ex.P13
Ex.P13
4)
Heard Sri M.V.J.K. Kumar, K. Srinivasa Rao, P. Balaji Varma, K.
Raji Redy, A. Sarveswara Rao, K. Adi Siva Vara Prasad, G.Narendra Chetty,
P. Venkata Sai Rajesh, Dr.D. Venkata Ramana Reddy, learned counsel for
the writ petitioners; Sri R. Kalyan Chakravarthy, learned Government
Pleader for Commercial Tax and Sri S.A.V. Sai Kumar, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Commercial Tax appearing for the respondents.
5)
Summary of the arguments of learned counsel for the
petitioners:A. Objective of the Article 286 of the Constitution is to exempt the
Export Sales from the clutches of sales tax, when the Constitution
came into force in 1950.
B. Central Sales Tax [CST] was introduced by Constitutional
amendment by formulating principles when sale is inter-state and
when it is outside the State and when it is sale in the course of
import and export.
C. In Coffee Board, Banglore Vs. Joint Commercial Tax Officer,
Madras case [cited 1 supra ] the Hon‘ble Apex Court held that the
sale by the Coffee Board to the exporter was only for export not for
sale, in the course of export. Parliament, thereafter, considered
the same and by the Central Sales Tax (Amendment) Act, 1956,
inserted Section 5(3) in the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 providing
that the last sale immediately preceding to the export, shall also
deemed to be a sale in the course of such export.
D. For claiming the benefit under Section 5(3) of the CST Act 1956,
Form ‗H‘ was prescribed and the exporter must furnish Form H.
The Central Government, in exercise of the rule-making power
conferred under the Act, prescribed relevant forms and rules,
namely, the Central Sales Tax (Registration and Turnover) Rules,
1957. Rule 12(10) prescribes the form of declaration in Form ‗H‘,
while Rule 12(7) governs the time and manner in which such
declaration is required to be furnished with reference to ‗C‘ forms
and the same shall apply to ‗H‘ forms also in view of Rule
12(10)(b) r/w Rule 13 (3) of CST Rules.
E. Section 13 of the CST Act, confers rule-making powers upon two
distinct
authorities.
Section
13(1)
empowers
the
Central
Government to make rules, whereas Section 13(3) empowers the
State Government to make rules. Though the State Government
was empowered under Section 13(3) to make rules in respect of
Form ‗H‘, it did not exercise the said power.
F. Since the State Government failed to prescribe the procedure and
the method, which the requirement was to be complied with, the
dealer cannot be expected to comply with a requirement for which
no prescribed procedure or mechanism was available, then the
doctrine of ―Lex Non Cogit Ad Impossibilia‖ would apply.
6) Summary of arguments of the learned Government Pleader:
A. Form ‗C‘ is relating to Inter-state sale and covered in terms of Section
8 (4) of the CST Act r/w Rule 12(1).
B. Form ‗F‘ is referred to in Section 6A of the Act r/w Rule 12(5) and as
to movement of the goods from one State to another by the reason of
transfer by him to other place of his business (Branch transfer).
C. Form ‗H‘ is a condition precedent to an export sale referring to in
Section 5 (4).
D. Section 13(3) is relating to making rules not inconsistent with Central
Rules. The same is not helpful to the petitioners to claim exemption
from the central rules in the absence of specific rule.
E. Rule 12(10(b)) requires careful application. Rule 12(1) specifies that
the declaration and certificate referred to in sub-section (4) of Section
8 of the CST Act must be in Form 'C' and Form 'D' respectively. While
Rule 12(7) prescribes the time limit for furnishing Form Nos. C. Form
No. H is not covered under Rule 12(7).
F. Rule 12[10(a)] is a self-contained provision dealing with the time limit
up to which the Form can be submitted.
Benefit contemplated for the Forms ‗C‘ and ‗F‘ cannot be extended to
‗H‘ forms in the absence of Rules made in terms of Section 13(3), (4) (5) by
the State Government, taking aid of Rule 12[10(b)].
7)
Learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon the following
authorities:i)
The observations made in a case of Coffee Board, Bangalore
Vs. Joint Commercial Tax Officers Madras and Others1 a judgment
rendered by the Constitution Bench of the Hon‘ble Apex Court, relating to
the proposition concerning the interpretation of Article 286 of the
Constitution of India, which deals with restrictions on the imposition of tax
on the sale or purchase of goods, particularly in relation to sales in the
course of export. Petitions in terms of Article 32 of the Constitution of India
were filed assailing the levy of Sales Tax on certain transactions relating to
the sales which the Board claims are sales in the course of export of Coffee
out of the India and thus, such transactions were not liable to sales Tax.
ii)
The observations of the Hon'ble Apex Court in State of
Andhra Pradesh Vs. Hyderabad Asbestos Cement Production Limited 2.
It was a case imposing Income Tax and receiving ‗C‘ Forms in terms of Rule
12(7) and also receiving of ‗C‘ Forms in the appellate proceedings as well.
iii)
Observations of a Division Bench of erstwhile High Court of
Andhra Pradesh vide W.P. No.10978 and 12657 of 2005. It was a case of
enabling acceptance of Form ‗C‘ after assessment, while referring to proviso
sub Rule 7 to Rule 12 of Central Sales Tax.
AIR 1971 SC 817, 1969 3 SCC 349
(1994) 5 SCC 100
iv)
Apart from the above learned counsel for the petitioners also
relied on the other judgments of the Division Bench of this Court, which are
mentioned in the reference.
8) Learned Government Pleader representing the State relied on :[i]
the observations of Hon'ble Apex Court made in a case
between Sales Tax Officer, Ponkunnam and
K. I. Abraham3, vide para
9. It was a case of submissions of Form ‗C‘ and examining the sufficiency
of reason. In the said case, the direction of Hon'ble Apex Court was to
make fresh assessment order after consideration of declaration forms,
considering that in the absence of any time limit, the duty of the assessee is
to furnish the declarations in ‗C‘ Form within in a reasonable time..
[ii]
the observations of the Hon‘ble Apex Court in Ashok Service
Centre and others Vs State of Orissa4, where it was a case of missing
turnover tax and the understanding of meaning of expression of mutatis
mutandis is explained in para 17, which reads as follows:
“17. Section 3(2) of the Act which makes the provisions of the principal
Act mutatis mutandis applicable to the levy of additional tax is a part of
the charging provision of the Act and it does not say that only those
provisions of the principal Act which relate to assessment and collection
of tax will be applicable to the proceedings under the Act. Before
considering what provisions of the principal Act should be read as part
of the Act, we have to understand the meaning of the expression
‗mutatis mutandis‘. Earl Jowitt's The Dictionary of English Law (1959)
defines ‗mutatis mutandis‘ as ‗with the necessary changes in points of
detail‘. Black's Law Dictionary (Revised 4th Edn., 1968) defines ‗mutatis
mutandis‘ as ―with the necessary changes in points of detail, meaning
that matters or things are generally the same, but to be altered when
1967 SCC OnLine SC 157
1983 2 SCC 82 : 1983 SCC (Tax) 90
necessary, as to names, offices, and the like. Housman v. Waterhouse
[191 App Div 850 : 182 NYS 249, 251] . In Bouvier's Law Dictionary (3rd
Revision, Vol. II), the expression ‗mutatis mutandis’ is defined as ―[T]he
necessary changes. This is a phrase of frequent practical occurrence,
meaning that matters or things are generally the same, but to be altered
when necessary, as to names, offices, and the like‖. Extension of an
earlier Act ‗mutatis mutandis‘ to a later Act brings in the idea of
adaptation, but so far only as it is necessary for the purpose, making a
change without altering the essential nature of the thing changed,
subject of course to express provisions made in the later Act. Section
3(2) of the Act shows that the State legislature intended not to depart
substantially from the principal Act except with regard to matters in
respect of which express provision had been made in the Act. ….‖
For understanding the expression ‗mutatis mutandis’ this judgment is
relied on by the learned Government Pleader.
[iii]
Observations
of
the
Hon'ble
Apex
Court
made
in
Commissioner of Customs (Import), Mumbai Vs. Dilip Kumar and
Company and Others5 vide paras 24 and 31, dealing with the principle
that the Court has to apply strict interpretation in respect of Penal and
statutory laws. The observation of paras 24, 25 and 31 read as follows:
―24. In construing penal statutes and taxation statutes, the Court has to
apply strict rule of interpretation. The penal statute which tends to
deprive a person of right to life and liberty has to be given strict
interpretation or else many innocents might become victims of
discretionary
decision-making.
Insofar
as
taxation
statutes
are
concerned, Article 265 of the Constitution [ ―265. Taxes not to be
imposed save by authority of law.—No tax shall be levied or
collected except by authority of law.‖] prohibits the State from extracting
tax from the citizens without authority of law. It is axiomatic that taxation
statute has to be interpreted strictly because the State cannot at their
whims and fancies burden the citizens without authority of law. In other
words, when the competent Legislature mandates taxing certain
(2018) 9 SCC 1: (2018) SCC Online SC 747
persons/certain objects in certain circumstances, it cannot be
expanded/interpreted to include those, which were not intended by the
legislature.
25.
At the outset, we must clarify the position of ―plain meaning rule
or clear and unambiguous rule‖ with respect to tax law. ―The plain
meaning rule‖ suggests that when the language in the statute is plain
and unambiguous, the court has to read and understand the plain
language as such, and there is no scope for any interpretation. This
salutary maxim flows from the phrase ―cum inverbis nulla ambiguitas
est, non debet admitti voluntatis quaestio‖. Following such maxim, the
courts sometimes have made strict interpretation subordinate to the
plain meaning rule [Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Ltd. v. CCT,
1992 Supp (1) SCC 21] , though strict interpretation is used in the
precise sense. To say that strict interpretation involves plain reading of
the statute and to say that one has to utilize strict interpretation in the
event of ambiguity is self-contradictory.
…..
31. It was further observed:
―In all tax matters one has to interpret the taxation statute strictly.
Simply because one class of legal entities is given a benefit which is
specifically stated in the Act, does not mean that the benefit can be
extended to legal entities not referred to in the Act as there is no equity
in matters of taxation….‖
9)
Analysis and Reasoning:-
The core issue that requires consideration and determination for
answering the reference regarding extending the benefit in terms of Section
5(3) of CST Act, is whether the submission of From ‗H‘ can be permitted
beyond the time of assessment by the first assessing authority, on par with
the Form ‗C‘ or Form ‗F‘, by taking aid of Rule 12(7) which covers such
submissions upon satisfaction of sufficient cause, in respect of form ‗C‘, and
Form ‗F‘ , and whether Rule 12[(10) (b)] allows such parity among Form ‗H‘
From ‗C‘ or Form ‗F‘ in relation to time for submission.
10)
Previous Orders of some Division Benches of this Court:-
[i]
The orders in W.P. No.1466 of 2017 are remitting the matter for
fresh consideration relating to the ‗H‘ Forms, while observing that the ‗C‘
Forms, in terms of Rule 12(7) of the CST (R&T) Rules, were considered
even after the assessment and a similar facility was not extended to the ‗H‘
Forms. These orders were simply directing the concerned to consider and
pass fresh orders.
[ii]
The orders in W.P No.16718 of 2019 are to consider the ‗C‘
form and ‗H‘ form declarations in accordance with law after referring to the
observations in W.P. No.1466 of 2017.
[iii]
The observations in W.P.No.12450 of 2019 are directly
touching the prescribed period in which Form ‗C‘, Form ‗F‘ and Form ‗H‘
shall be furnished to the prescribed authority.
It is observed in this
orders that, in respect of Form ‗C‘ and Form ‗F‘, there is clear reference to
Rule 12(7) and in terms of the said Rule, and that Form ‗C‘ and ‗F‘ can be
furnished by assessee within 3 months after end of the period to which the
declaration or certificate relates to. But in respect of ‗H‘ Forms, there is
reference to Rule 12 [10(a)] that the declaration referred to sub-section (4)
of Section 5 shall be in Form No.H and shall be furnished to the prescribed
authority up to the time of assessment by first assessing authority. Further,
it is also observed in this orders that Form ‗H‘ shall be furnished to the
prescribed authority up to the time of assessment by the assessing
authority, and that unlike section 12 (7), no specific proviso is created to
12[10(a)] confronting power to the prescribed authority, to allow assessee to
file Form ‗H‘ declaration after stipulated period. However, following the
orders of the co-ordinate Division Bench passed in earlier Writ Petitions
No.1466 of 2017 and W.P. No. 16718 of 2019, the Division Bench of this
Court in WP No. 12450 of 2019 has also directed the concerned to consider
the documents of Form No.C and H and to pass orders.
[iv]
Thereafter in the W.P.Nos.18205 of 2020 and Batch benefit
was extended after referring to Rule 12(1) and Rule 12(10) and also the
language of Rule 12(10) (b). In para 10 of the orders it is observed that the
rules do not provide for absolute right in the dealers to file Forms at any
stage and the rules only permits such filing where the assessing authority is
satisfied that sufficient cause that has been shown for non-filing of the
Forms within the stipulated under the Act and the Rules, giving a way for
filing forms showing sufficient reasons for the delay.
11)
Now it is relevant to note that,
1. W.P.No.1466 of 2017 direction provides simple direction to
consider ‗H‘ Forms afresh at admission stage.
2. W.P.16718 of 2019 direction is to consider ‗H‘ forms on par with ‗C‘
forms following the observations made in W.P. No. 1466 of 2017.
3. The observations in 12450 of 2019, although mentions no specific
proviso to Rule 12[10(a)] is there unlike Rule 12(7), allowed the
assessee to file ‗H‘ forms after stipulated time following the
previous judgments of the co-ordinate Benches, extending benefit
for ‗H‘ forms on par with the ‗C‘ form.
4. The observations in W.P. No. 18205 of 2020 and batch, show that
although rules do not provide absolute right to the file forms at any
stage, the assessing authority if satisfied that there is sufficient
cause for non-filing within the time, can consider the ‗H‘ forms.
5. The Division Bench of this Court, while making the reference
mentioned above in a batch of writ petitions, vide W.P.No.7158 of
2018 and batch, after referring to the earlier orders of the Division
Benches, examined the scope of Rule 12(7) in relation to Form ‗C‘
and Form ‗F‘, in juxtaposition to declaration ‗H‘ From contemplated
under Rule 12(10) and found that there is no provision in Rule
12(10) akin to Rule 12(7) and the time frame set under rule 12(10)
is absolute and there is no scope for grant of any further time and
Rule 12(10) (b) on its closer look would drive to infer that if any
rules are made by respective State Governments relating to Form
‗H‘, then the rules as applied to declaration in form ‗C‘, would apply
to Form ‗H‘. Since the rules made by the State do not provide for
filing for ‗H‘ Form, the Rule 12(10) (b) will not come into play.
However, in view of the earlier judgments of the Division Benches,
the reference is made to full bench for resolving the issue.
Subsequently, in another batch of writ petitions in W.P.Nos.30640
of 2016 and batch, orders dated 29.01.2025 are passed.
12)
For proper adjudication of the issue involved herein, the
relevant provisions of CST Act, 1956 and the CST (Registration & Turnover)
Rules, 1957 are extracted as hereinunder:
Section 5 of the CST Act is relating to the export sales and exemption
provided there for including the last sale preceding the export sale.
Deeming that the last sale preceding to export sale is also an export sale.
Section 5 of the CST Act reads as follows:5. When is a sale or purchase of goods said to take place in
the course of import or export:(1) A sale or purchase of goods shall be deemed to take
place in the course of the export of the goods out of the territory
of India only if the sale or purchase either occasions such export
or is effected by a transfer of documents of title to the goods after
the goods have crossed the customs frontiers of India.
(2)A sale or purchase of goods shall be deemed to take place in
the course of the import of the goods into the territory of India
only if the sale or purchase either occasions such import or is
effected by a transfer of documents of title to the goods before
the goods have crossed the customs frontiers of India.
(3) [Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), the
last sale or purchase of any goods preceding the sale or
purchase occasioning the export of those goods out of the
territory of India shall also be deemed to be in the course of such
export, if such last sale or purchase took place after, and was for
the purpose of complying with, the agreement or order for or in
relation to such export.] [Inserted by Act 103 of 1976, Section 3
(w.r.e.f. 1.4.1976). ]
(4) [The provisions of sub-section (3) shall not apply to any sale
or purchase of goods unless the dealer selling the goods
furnishes to the prescribed authority in the prescribed manner a
declaration duly filled and signed by the exporter to whom the
goods are sold in a prescribed form obtained from the prescribed
authority.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), if any
designated Indian carrier purchases Aviation Turbine Fuel for the
purposes of its international flight, such purchase shall be
deemed to take place in the course of the export of goods out of
the territory of India.
Explanation:- For the purposes of this sub-section, "designated
Indian carrier" means any carrier which the Central Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify in this behalf.]
[Inserted by Act 18 of 2005, Section 90 (w.e.f. 13.5.2005). ]‖
Analysis with reference to the statutory forms:-
Parameters
Form 'C'
Form 'F'
Form 'H'
Parent provision
Section 8(4)
Section 6A(1)
Section 5(4) r/w 5(3)
Nature of benefit
Concessional rate on a
taxable inter-State sale
Discharge of burden of
proof that movement
was not a sale
Exemption — sale deemed in
the course of export
Statutory time
language
―within the prescribed
time or within such
further time as that
authority may, for
sufficient cause,
permit‖ (post-1972)
―within the prescribed
time or within such
further time as that
authority may, for
sufficient cause, permit‖
Governing subrule
Rule 12(1) r/w 12(7)
Rule 12(5) r/w 12(7)
―in the prescribed manner‖
only — no extension clause
Rule12 (10) [(a) The declaration
referred to in sub-section (4) of
section 5 shall be in Form H and
shall be furnished to the prescribed
authority
upto
the
time
of
assessment by the first assessing
authority.]
(b) [ The provisions of the rules
framed by the respective State
Governments under sub-sections
(3), (4) and (5) of section 13 relating
to authority from whom and the
conditions subject to which any form
of certificate in Form H may be
obtained, the manner in which such
form shall be kept in custody and
records relating thereto maintained
and the manner in which any such
forms may be used and any such
certificate may be furnished insofar
as they apply to declaration in Form
C prescribed under these rules shall
mutatis mutandis apply to certificate
in Form H.]
Prescribed time
3 months from end of
the period (Rule 12(7))
3 months from end of
the period (Rule 12(7))
Power to enlarge
time
Yes — proviso to Rule
12(7), on sufficient
cause
Yes — proviso to Rule
12(7), on sufficient
cause
None — no proviso; terminus
is the first assessment
Issuing authority
of form
Purchasing registered
dealer (obtained from
his prescribed
authority)
Transferee branch /
agent / principal
Exporter to whom the goods
are sold
13)
Section 13 (3) and (4) of the CST Act which enables the
respective state Governments to make rules and the matters there of are as
follows:―13. Power to make rules –
(3)
The State Government may make rules, not inconsistent with the
provisions of this Act and the rules made under sub-section (1), to carry
out the purposes of this Act.
(4)
In particular and without prejudice to the powers conferred
by sub-section (3), the State Government may make rules for all or
any of the following purposes, namely:(a)
the publication of lists of registered dealers, of the
amendments made in such lists from time to time, and the
particulars to be contained in such lists;
(aa) the manner in
which security may be furnished under sub-section (2-A) or subsection (3-A) or sub-section (3-C) of section 7 and the manner in
which and the time within which any deficiency may be made up
under sub-section (3-E) of that section;
(b)
the form and manner in which accounts relating to
sales in the course of inter-State trade or commerce shall be kept
by registered dealers;
(c)
the furnishing of any information relating to the
stocks of goods of purchases, sales and deliveries of books by,
any dealer or any other information relating to his business as may
be necessary for the purposes of this Act;
(d)
the inspection of any books, accounts or
documents required to be kept under this Act, the entry into any
premises at all reasonable times for the purposes of searching for
any such books, accounts or documents kept or suspected to be
kept in such premises and the seizure of such books, accounts or
documents;
(e)
the authority from whom, the conditions subject to
which and fees subject to payment of which any form of certificate
prescribed under clause (a) of the first proviso to sub-section (2) of
section 6 or of declaration prescribed under sub-section (1) of
section 6-A or sub-section (4) of section 8 may be obtained, the
manner in which such forms shall be kept in custody and records
relating thereto maintained and the manner in which any such form
may be used and any such certificate or declaration may be
furnished; [Substituted by Act 61 of 1972, Section 10, for Clause
(e) (w.e.f. 1.4.1973). ]
(ee) the form and manner in which, and the authority to
whom, an appeal may be preferred under sub-section (3-H) of
section 7, the procedure to be followed in hearing such appeals
and the fees payable in respect of such appeals;
(f)
in the case of an undivided Hindu family,
association, club, society, firm or company or in the case of a
person who carries on business as a guardian or trustee or
otherwise on behalf of another person, the furnishing of a
declaration stating the name of the person who shall be deemed to
be the manager in relation to the business of the dealer in the
State and the form in which such declaration may be given;
(g)
the time within which, the manner in which and the
authorities to whom any change in the ownership of any business
or in the name, place or nature of any business carried on by any
dealer shall be furnished.
14)
Rule 12 of the CST (R&T) Rules dealing with the
declarations are as follows:―12(1)The declaration and the certificate referred to in sub-section (4)
of section 8 shall be in Forms C and D respectively:[Provided that Form C
in force before the commencement of the Central Sales Tax (Registration
and Turnover) (Amendment) Rules, 1974, or before the commencement
of the Central Sales Tax (Registration and Turnover) (Amendment) Rules,
1976, may also be used upto the 31st December, [1980] with suitable
modifications. Provided further that a single declaration may cover all
transactions of sale, which take place in a quarter of a financial year
between the same two dealers:
Provided also that where, in the case of any transaction of
sale, the delivery of goods is spread over to different quarters in a
financial year or of different financial years, it shall be necessary to furnish
a separate declaration or certificate in respect of goods delivered in each
quarter of a financial year.] [Substituted by G.S.R. 588(E), dated
16.9.2005 (w.e.f. 1.10.2005). ]
(2) Where a blank or duly completed form of declaration is
lost, whether such loss occurs while it is in the custody of the purchasing
dealer or in transit to the selling dealer, the purchasing dealer shall furnish
in respect of every such form so lost an indemnity bond [in Form G to the
notified authority from whom the said form was obtained, for such sum as
the said authority may having regard to the circumstances of the case, fix.
Such indemnity bond shall be furnished by the selling dealer to the
notified authority of his State if a duly completed form of declaration
received by him is lost, whether such loss occurs while it is in his custody
or while it is in transit to the notified authority of his State:][Provided that
where more than one form of declaration is lost, the purchasing dealer or
the selling dealer, as the case may be, may furnish one such indemnity
bond to cover all the forms of declarations so lost
(3) Where a declaration form furnished by the dealer
purchasing the goods or the certificate furnished by the Government has
been lost, the dealer selling the goods, may demand from the dealer who
purchased the goods or, as the case may be, from the Government, which
purchased the goods, a duplicate of such form or certificate, and the same
shall be furnished with the following declaration recorded in red ink and
signed by the dealer or authorised officer or the Government, as the case
may be, on all the three portions of such form or certificate:"I hereby declare that this is the duplicate of the declaration
form/certificate
No.........................signed
on.....................and
issued
to.............................who is registered dealer of................(State) and
whose registration certificate number is ................"]
(4) The certificate referred to in sub-section (2) of section 6
shall be in Form EI or Form EII, as the case may be.]
(5)[ The declaration referred to in sub-section (1) of section 6A shall be in Form F:]
Provided that a single declaration may cover transfer of goods, by a
dealer, to any other place of his business or to his agent or principal, as
the case may be, effected during a period of one calendar month:
Provided further that if the space provided in Form F is not
sufficient for making the entries, the particulars specified in Form F may
be given in separate annexures attached to that form so long as it is
indicated in the form that the annexures form part thereof and every such
annexure is also signed by the person signing the declaration in Form
F:Provided further that Form F in force/before the commencement of the
Central Sales Tax (Registration and Turnover) (Second Amendment)
Rules, 1973 may continue to be used up to 31st day of December, [1980]
with suitable modifications.]
(6)
Form C referred to in sub-rule (1), or as the case may
be Form F referred to in sub-rule (5), shall be the one obtained by the
purchasing dealer or, as the case may be, the transferee in the State in
which the goods covered by such form are delivered.
Explanation .-Where, by reason of the purchasing dealer not
being registered under section 7 in the State in which the goods covered
by Form C referred to in sub-rule (1) are delivered, he is not able to obtain
the said form in that State, Form C may be the one obtained by him in the
State in which he is registered under the said section.
(7) The declaration in Form C or Form F or the certificate
in Form E-I or Form E-II shall be furnished to the prescribed
authority within three months after the end of the period to which the
declaration or the certificate relates: Provided that if the prescribed
authority is satisfied that the person concerned was prevented by
sufficient cause from furnishing such declaration or certificate
within the aforesaid time, that authority may allow such declaration
or certificate to be furnished within such further time as that
authority may permit.
(8)[(a) The person referred to in clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of
rule 3 shall alone be competent to sign the declaration in Form C or Form
F or the certificate in Form EI or Form EII] [Inserted by G.S.R. 56(E),
dated 9.2.1973 (w.e.f. 1.4.1973).]:[Provided that where such person is a
proprietor of any business or a partner of a firm or a karta or manager of a
Hindu undivided family, any other person authorised by him in writing may
also sign such declaration or certificate: Provided further that in the case
of a company such declaration or certificate can also be signed by any
other officer of the company authorised under the Memorandum or
Articles of Association of the company or under any other special or
general resolution of the company or under a resolution passed by the
Board of Directors of the company, to authenticate any document on
behalf of such company.
(b) Such person shall signify on such declaration or certificate
his status and shall make a verification in the manner provided in such
declaration or certificate.
(9) (a) The provisions of sub-rule (2)] and sub-rule (3) shall,
with necessary modifications, apply to the declaration in Form F or the
certificate in Form EI or Form EII.
(b) The provisions of the second and third provisos to sub-rule
(1) shall, with necessary modifications, apply to certificates in Form EI or
Form EII.
(10) (a) The declaration referred to in sub-section (4) of
section 5 shall be in Form H and shall be furnished to the prescribed
authority upto the time of assessment by the first assessing
authority.
(b) The provisions of the rules framed by the
respective State Governments under sub-sections (3), (4) and (5) of
section 13 relating to authority from whom and the conditions
subject to which any form of certificate in Form H may be obtained,
the manner in which such form shall be kept in custody and records
relating thereto maintained and the manner in which any such forms
may be used and any such certificate may be furnished insofar as
they apply to declaration in Form C prescribed under these rules
shall mutatis mutandis apply to certificate in Form H.
(11) The declaration referred to in sub-section (8) of section 8
of the Act, shall be in Form I.
(11-A) The certificate referred to in sub-section (4) of section
6 shall be in Form J and shall be furnished to the prescribed authority upto
the time of assessment by the first assessing authority.‖
15)
It is clear case of both sides that the Form and the procedure in
respect of export sale referred in Section 5 of CST Act and Form ‗H‘ neither
Form nor procedure is prescribed under the State Rules. A close and clear
reading of Rule 12 of CST (R&T) Rules 1957 leads one to understand that
Rule 12(10) alone is clearly and conspicuously dealing with Form H. Rule
12[10(b)] provides saving as to the applicability of the provisions of rules
framed by the respective State Governments under sub-Sections (3),(4) and
(5) of Section 13 relating to 1. the authority from whom
2. condition subject to which any form of certificate in Form H may be
obtained.
3. manner in which such form shall be kept in the custody.
4. records relating there to maintain.
5. the manner in which such form may be used , and
6. any such certificate may be furnished in so far as they apply the
declaration in form C prescribed shall be mutatis mutandis applied
to the Certificate in Form H.
16)
When Rule 12[10(b)] refers to so many aspects, and it does not
refer to the time, it can be understood that Rule 12[(10(a)] is clearly and
conspicuously addressing the time for submission.
There is no ambiguity
or conflict between Rule 12 [10(a) and (b)] as to the time. On the contrary
Rule 12(10(a)] is dealing with the time, Rule 12[10(b)] is dealing with the
other aspects and referring to the applicability of the conditions relating to
submission of ‗C‘ form and their applicability to H form. Therefore it is clear
that with regard to time, Rule 12[10(a)] alone is applicable and Rule 12(7) is
not applicable. Even if it is to be accepted that CST ( R&T) Rules, 1957 are
made for Andhra Pradesh invoking Section 13 (3) (4) (5) of CST Act, 1956
no rule is found indicating the time prescribed covering or applicability to
Form H. Therefore, the claim that time contemplated under Rule 12(7)
would extend to Rule 12(10) and to Form H also found not acceptable.
Further, it is also clear that Rule 12[10(a)] is fixing the time and the mandate
under Section 13(3) is that the State Government may make rules, but not
inconsistent with the provisions of the Act and the Rules made under subsection (1) of Section 13. Therefore, when CST Rules, 1957 are made
under Section 13(1) CST Act 1956, contra-interpretation particularly in the
absence of any specific State Rule found not possible.
17)
FINDINGS:
In view of the discussion made above, the reference is answered
holding that time prescribed under Rule 12(7) of CST (R&T) Rules, 1957 as
to submission of declaration forms in Form ‗C‘ and Form ‗F‘ within three
months after the end of the period to which the declaration relates to, does
not extend to Form H and the benefit under the Rule 12[10 (b)] does not
apply to invoke the parity between the Form C and Form H particularly with
regard to time limit, when Rule 12[10 (a)] is very clear that the declaration
referred under Section 5(4) shall be in Form H and shall be furnished to the
prescribed authority up to the time of assessment by the first assessing
authority.
18)
All the Writ Petitions shall stand disposed of in the above terms.
19)
There shall be no orders as to costs.
__________________________
JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
_________________________________
JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
__________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Dated: 08.10.2026
PGR
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT PETITION Nos.30640, 17678, 10587, 32133, 32418, 36940 and 36954 of
2016, 31208 and 36063 of 2017 and 7158, 45387, 45504, 47197 and 47287 of
2018 and W.P.Nos.260, 1590, 11115 of 2019 and 2051, 2110, 2514, 6480 and
6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021 and 40351, 40354 of 2022, 23960 of 2023 and
29854 of 2024 and 2564, 9604, 9702, 11011, 13099 and 13102 of 2026
% 08.10.2026
# Between:
1. M/S. SRI VEERA VENKATA SATYANARAYANA MODEM RICE MILL,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, SRI KURMALA
NAGARAJU @ NAGA VENKATA SATYANARAYA MURTHY AND OTHERS.
...PETITIONER
AND
$1. THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, BHEEMAVARAM, WEST GODAVARI
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH AND OTHERS.
... RESPONDENTS.
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
1.
Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers may
be allowed to see the Order?
Yes/No
2.
Whether the copies of Order may be marked
to Law Reporters/Journals?
Yes/No
Whether Your Lordships wish to see the fair
copy of the Order?
Yes/No
3.
__________________________
JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
_________________________________
JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
_________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT PETITION Nos.30640, 17678, 10587, 32133, 32418, 36940 and 36954 of
2016, 31208 and 36063 of 2017 and 7158, 45387, 45504, 47197 and 47287 of
2018 and W.P.Nos.260, 1590, 11115 of 2019 and 2051, 2110, 2514, 6480 and
6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021 and 40351, 40354 of 2022, 23960 of 2023 and
29854 of 2024 and 2564, 9604, 9702, 11011, 13099 and 13102 of 2026
% 08.10.2026
# Between:
1. M/S. SRI VEERA VENKATA SATYANARAYANA MODEM RICE MILL,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, SRI KURMALA
NAGARAJU @ NAGA VENKATA SATYANARAYA MURTHY AND OTHERS.
...PETITIONER
AND
$1. THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER, BHEEMAVARAM, WEST GODAVARI
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH AND OTHERS.
...RESPONDENT(S):
! Counsel for the Petitioners
:
Sri M.V.J.K. Kumar, K. Srinivasa Rao,
Sri P. Balaji Varma, K. Raji Redy,
Sri A. Sarveswara Rao,
Sri K. Adi Siva Vara Prasad,
Sri G.Narendra Chetty,
Sri P. Venkata Sai Rajesh,
Sri Dr. D. Venkata Ramana Reddy.
! Counsel for the Respondents:
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
AIR 1971 SC 817, 1969 3 SCC 349
(1994) 5 SCC 100
1967 SCC OnLine SC 157
1983 2 SCC 82 : 1983 SCC (Tax) 90
(2018) 9 SCC 1: (2018) SCC Online SC 747
Sri R. Kalyan Chakravarthy, learned
Government Pleader for Commercial Tax,
Sri S.A.V. Sai Kumar, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Commercial Tax
(224)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT PETITION Nos.30640, 17678, 10587, 32133, 32418,
36940 and 36954 of 2016, 31208 and 36063 of 2017 and
7158, 45387, 45504, 47197 and 47287 of 2018 and
W.P.Nos.260, 1590, 11115 of 2019 and 2051, 2110, 2514,
6480 and 6597 of 2020, 3111 of 2021 and 40351, 40354 of
2022, 23960 of 2023 and 29854 of 2024 and 2564, 9604,
9702, 11011, 13099 and 13102 of 2026
Date:08.10.2026
PGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review