Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO.35739 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI VENKATA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
S/O LATE P. RAMA REDDY.
2.
SRI. SUBBA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
S/O LATE PULLA REDDY,
BOTH ARE R/O NO.5, 5TH CROSS,
MUNESHWARA LAYOUT,
DODDA BOMMASANDRA,
VIDYARANYAPURA,
BANGALORE-560 057.
BANGALORE URBAN DISTRICT.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. KRISHNAPPA M., ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
CHANDANA
BM
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
SRI MUDALAPA
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS,
S/O LATE DASAPPA,
2.
SMT. RAMAKKA
AGED ABOUT 64 YRS,
W/O MUDALAPPA
BOTH RESPONDENTS 1 & 2 ARE
RESIDING AT HARALUR VILLAGE,
JADIGENAHALLI HOBLI,
HOSAKOTE TALUK,
BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT-562 114.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
3.
SRI. RAMACHANDRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
S/O LATE CHINNAPPA
4.
SRI. SRINIVAS
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
S/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
5.
SRI. VENKATESH
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
S/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
6.
SRI. SHANKAR
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
S/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
7.
SRI. MANI
AGED ABOUT T 64 YEARS
S/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
8.
RAMALAKSHMAMMA
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
D/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
9.
GOWRAMMA
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
D/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
10.
SMT. RAMAMANI
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
D/O LATE CHINNAPPA.
ALL RESPONDENTS 3 TO 10 ARE
R/O MARASANDRA VILLAGE
KASABA HOBLI, MALUR TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT – 563 160.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. N. VAGEESH, ADVOCATE FOR C/R-1)
THIS W.P IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION
OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT QUASHING THE IMPUGNED COMMON
ORDER DTD 14.10.2025 PASSED ON (1) IA U/S 151 CPC, (2) IA U/ORDER
18 RULE 17 CPC, (3) U/S 66 (6) OF INDIAN EVIDENCE ACT 1872 READ
WITH SECTION 151 CPC IN O.S NO.32/2010 BY THE COURT OF THE PRL.
CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, HOSAKOTE AS AT ANNX-H
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY, ORDER
WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
This petition by defendant Nos.2 and 3 in O.S.No.32/2010 on
the file of the Prl. Civil Judge & JMFC, Hoskote, is directed against
the impugned common order passed on I.As. by the Trial Court
allowing the applications filed by the respondents – plaintiffs to
reopen the evidence of the plaintiff and by recalling PW1 and for
permission to mark Photostat copy of the Edurukararupatra / reconveyance deed as secondary evidence in support of their
respective claim.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned
counsel for the caveator – respondent No.1 and perused the
material on record.
3.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
respondent Nos.1 and 2 – plaintiffs instituted the aforesaid suit
against the petitioners – defendant Nos.2 and 3 and other
defendants for permanent injunction and other reliefs in relation to
the suit schedule immovable property.
The said suit is being
contested by the defendants. The plaintiffs having adduced
-4NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
evidence, the matter was posted for evidence of defendants and at
the stage of cross-examination of PW1, plaintiffs filed three
applications viz.,. (i) Application to reopen the evidence of the
plaintiff (ii) Application to recall PW1 and permit the plaintiff to mark
Photostat copy of the Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed and
(iii) Application under Section 66 of the Indian Evidence Act for
permission to permit the plaintiff to produce Photostat copy of the
Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed as secondary evidence.
4.
The said applications having been opposed by the
petitioners – defendant Nos.2 and 3, the Trial Court proceeded to
pass the impugned common order allowing all the three
applications, aggrieved by which the petitioners are before this
Court by way of the present petition. The impugned common order
passed by the Trial Court is as under:
“COMMON ORDERS ON APPLICATION FILED UNDER
SECTION 151 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL 13 to PROCEDURE, 1908
AND APPLICATION UNDER ORDER XVIII RULE 17 OF THE
CODE
a
OF
CIVIL
PROCEDURE,
APPLICATION
UNDER
SECTION
63B
AND
666)02
OF
THE
INDIAN
EVIDENCE ACT, 1872 READ WITH SECTION 151 OF THE CODE
OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
-5NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
Plaintiffs have filed the application under Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (Hereinafter referred to as C.P.C., for
brevity) seeking to re-open the evidence of the plaintiff.
Plaintiffs have filed the application under Order XVIII Rule 17
of CPC seeking to recall PW.1 and permit them to mark photocopy
of Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed.
Plaintiffs have filed the application under Section 63(B) of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Hereinafter referred to as 'IE Act’, for
brevity)
seeking
to
permit
him
to
produce
photocopy
of
Edurukararupatra/re-conveyance deed as secondary evidence.
2. It is averred in the affidavit annexed to the applications that
in the year 2004 the plaintiffs approached the defendant No.1 and
availed a hand loan of Rs.1,00,000/-. At the time of the
advancement of the loan amount, defendant No.1 insisted that the
plaintiffs execute a sale deed for security purposes and defendant
No.1 promised to reconvey the property by executing an reconveyance deed after the repayment of the said loan. As such, the
plaintiffs executed the sale deed instead of a mortgage deed in
favour of defendant No.1 and in turn, defendant No.1 executed
Edaru Kararu Patra on the same day. Subsequently, defendant No.1
retained all original documents with him. Thereafter, the plaintiffs
repaid the entire loan amount to defendant No.1. Despite the
repayment of the loan amount, defendant No.1 failed to execute a
re-conveyance deed. The original of Edaru Kararu Patra is not with
the custody of the plaintiffs and same is in the custody of the
defendant No. 1. Now, defendant No.1 is denying the custody of the
original Edaru Kararu Patra and as such, they intend to mark the
Edaru Kararu Patra as secondary evidence. With these, the plaintiffs
prayed to allow the applications.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
3. On the other hand the defendant No.2 and 3 resisted the
applications by filing common objection and specifically contended
that the applications are not maintainable either in law or on facts.
The applications are filed at a highly belated stage and evidence of
the plaintiffs was closed way back. The applications are filed only to
prolong the proceedings. These defendants categorically denied the
alleged Edaru Kararu Patra said to be executed by defendant No.1
and no such deed was executed. The alleged Edaru Kararu Patra is
unregistered one and cannot be looked into. Therefore, the
defendant No.2 and 3 prayed to dismissal of the applications.
4. The points that would arise for consideration are:1. Whether the applications are deserves to be
allowed?
2. What order?
5. Heard.
6. The learned counsel for the plaintiff, in support of his
arguments, has relied upon the following decision:
1. 2016 (16) SCC 483- Rakesh Mohindra-Vs-Anita
Beri and Others.
2 C.R.P. (PD) No.2771/2014 dated 24.11.2017 of
Hon'ble High Court Madras - Pitchai (Deceased) -Vs- P. Raji
and Others;
7. My answer to the above said points are as follows:
Point No.1: In the Affirmative;
Point No.2: As per final order for the following
REASONS
-7NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
8. Point No.1:- After hearing and careful perusal of the
application, objection and materials placed on record the plaintiffs
have filed the present application praying to reopen the evidence of
the
plaintiffs
and
permit
them
to
mark
photocopy
of
Edurukararupatra/re-conveyance deed as secondary evidence. It is
the specific case of the plaintiffs that in the year 2004 they have
approached the defendant No.1 and availed a hand loan of
Rs.1,00,000/-. At the time of the advancement of the loan amount,
defendant No.1 insisted them to execute a sale deed for security
purposes, and he promised to reconvey the property by executing
an re-conveyance deed after the repayment of the said loan. As
such, they have executed the sale deed instead of a mortgage deed
in favour of defendant No.1 and in turn, defendant No.1 executed
Edaru Kararu Patra on the same day. despite the repayment of the
loan amount, defendant No 1 failed to execute a re-conveyance
deed. The original of Edaru Karáru patra is in the custody of the
defendant No.1. Now, defendant No.1 is denying the custody as
well as execution of the Edaru kararu Patra. On the other hand the
defendant No2 and 3 denied the execution of the alleged Edaru
Kararu Patra and specifically contended that the alleged Edaru
Kararu Patra is unregistered one and cannot be looked into.
9. The learned counsel for the plaintiffs submitted that the
defence of the defendants is blanket denial. The document in
question is in existence and proof of the document in question is
subject to trial. The plaintiffs have complied the statutory
requirement as envisaged under Order XVI of CPC and Section 66
of the Evidence Act. The defendants nowhere claimed that the
document in question is forged or created one. A proper stamp duty
has been paid under the agreement. The police complaint given by
the plaintiffs is sufficient foundation to adduce secondary evidence.
As such, he prayed to allow the application. To fortify his arguments,
-8NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
has relied upon one decision. Counter to that, the learned counsel
for the defendants argued that there is no pleading in respect of the
custody of the original proposed document and the plaint does not
depict a foundation with respect to the alleged document. The
plaintiff has not given any notice in respect of the alleged document
during the lifetime of defendant No.1. The document sought to be
marked is insufficiently stamped and unregistered. Therefore, it
cannot be looked into any purpose. The plaintiff has not placed any
materials to substantiate that he has made efforts, as claimed. As
such, he prayed reject the same.
10. When the matter was posted for cross-examination of
DW.1, at this stage the plaintiff has filed the present applications. It
is the specific contention of the plaintiff that the original of the
proposed documents is with the custody of the defendants and they
have evasively denied the same. Therefore, marking of the
proposed document is very much necessary to prove the case of the
plaintiff. I have carefully and cautiously gone through the document
now sought to be marked. During the proceedings, the plaintiff has
filed the application under Order XVI Rule 6 of CPC seeking
summon the original re-conveyance deed from the custody of the
Lrs of defendant No.1. The said application is allowed and Lrs of
defendant No.1 remained absent. It is just and necessary to refer
provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 particularly, Section 17 and
49 of the Registration Act, 1908, which is being reproduced below:17. Documents of which registration is compulsory.(1) The following documents shall be registered, if the
property to which they relate is situate in a district in which,
and it they have been executed on or after the date on which,
Act No. XVI of 1864, or the Indian Registration Act, 1866, or
-9NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
the Indian Registration Act, 1871, or the Indian Registration
Act, 1877, or this Act came or comes into force, namely:(a) instruments of gift of immovable property;
(b) other non-testamentary instruments which purport or
operate to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish,
whether in present or in future, any right, title or interest,
whether vested or contingent, of the value of one hundred
rupees and upwards, to or in immovable property;
(c) non-testamentary instruments which acknowledge the
receipt or payment of any consideration on account of the
creation , declaration, assignment, limitation or extinction of
any such right, title or interest; and
(d) leases of immovable property from year to year, or for
any term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent:
(e) non-testamentary instruments transferring or assigning
any decree or order of a Court or any award when such
decree or order or award purports or operates to create,
declare, assign, limit or extinguish, whether in present or in
future, any right, title or interest, whether vested or
contingent of the value of one hundred rupees and upwards,
to or in immovable property:
Provided that the State Government may, by order published
in the Official Gazette, exempt from the operation of this subsection any lease executed in any district, or part of a district,
the terms granted by which do not exceed five years and the
annual rents reserved by which do not exceed fifty rupees
(1A) The documents containing contracts to transfer for
consideration, any immovable property for the purpose of
section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882)
shall be registered if they have been executed on or after the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
commencement of the Registration and Other Related laws
(Amendment) Act, 2001 (48 of 2001) and if such documents
are not registered on or after such commencement, then,
they shall have no effect for the purposes of the said section
53A
(2) Nothing in clauses (b) and (c) of sub-section (1) applies
to(1) any composition deed, or
(ii) any instrument relating to shares in a joint stock
Company, notwithstanding that the assets of such Company
consist in whole or in part of immovable property; or (iii) any
debenture issued by any such Company and not creating.
declaring, assigning, limiting or extinguishing any right, title
or interest, to or in immovable property except in so far as it
entitles the holder to the security afforded by a registered
instrument whereby the Company has mortgaged, Conveyed
or otherwise transferred the whole or part of its immovable
property or any interest therein to trustees upon trust for the
benefit of the holders of such debentures; or
(iv) any endorsement upon or transfer of any debenture issued by any such Company, or
(v) any document other than the documents specified in subsection (1A) not itself creating, declaring, assigning, limiting
or extinguishing any right, title or interest of the value of one
hundred rupees and upwards to or in immovable property.
but merely creating a right to obtain another document which
will, when executed, create, declare, assign, limit or
extinguish any such right, title or interest, or
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
(vi) any decree or order of a Court 2 [except a decree or
order expressed to be made on a compromise and
comprising immovable property other than that which is the
subject-matter of the suit or proceeding; or
(vii) any grant of immovable property by 3 (Government); or
(viii) any instrument of partition made by a Revenue-Officer,
or
(ix) any order granting a loan or instrument of collateral security granted under the Land Improvement Act. 1871, or the
Land Improvement Loans Act, 1883, or
(x) any order granting a loan under the Agriculturists, Loans
Act, 1884, or instrument for securing the repayment of a loan
made under that Act, or 4 (xa) any order made under the
Charitable Endowments Act, 1890 (6 of 1890), vesting any
property in a Treasurer of Charitable Endowments or divesting any such Treasurer of any property, or
(xi) any endorsement on a mortgage-deed acknowledging
the payment of the whole or any part of the mortgage-money,
and any other receipt for payment of money due under a
mortgage when the receipt does not purport to extinguish the
mortgage, or
(xii) any certificate of sale granted to the purchaser of any
property sold by public auction by a Civil or Revenue-Officer.
[Explanation. A document purporting or operating to effect a
contract for the sale of immovable property shall not be
deemed to require or ever to have required registration by
reason only of the fact that such document contains a recital
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
of the payment of any earnest money or of the whole or any
part of the purchase money.)
(3)Authorities to adopt a son, executed after the 1st day of
January, 1872, and not conferred by a will, shall also be
registered.
49. Effect of non-registration of documents required to
be registered. No document required by section 17 1 [or by
any provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of
1882)], to be registered shall(a) affect any immovable property comprised therein, or
(b) confer any power to adopt, or
(c) be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such
property or conferring such power, unless it has been
registered:
[Provided
that
an
unregistered
document
affecting
immovable property and required by this Act or the Transfer
of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882), to be registered may be
received as evidence of a contract in a suit for specific
performance under Chapter II of the Specific Relief Act, 1877
(3 of 1877) or as evidence of any collateral transaction not
required to be effected by registered instrument.
11. The above provisions manifests compulsory registration
of kinds of documents and effect of non-registration of registrable
documents. It is worth to refer decision of the Hon'ble High Court of
Rajasthan in the case of Bhikkilal & Others -Vs- Smt. Shanti Devi &
Others reported in 2008 SCC OnLine Raj 23, wherein the Hon'ble
High Court held at para No.9 that Whether a non-testamentary
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
document in respect of immovable properties is compulsorily
registrable or not depends on the facts, and circumstances and the
terms of the document. No hard and fast rule can be laid down. The
crucial test in each case is as to the nature of the document itself, if
it does create a right, title or interest in itself, whether in present or in
future, it is compulsory registrable u/s.17(1)(b). However, if by itself it
does not create any right but visualises creation or extinction of a
right by some other document, then it falls squarely within the ambit
of S. 17(2)(v) and, hence, not registrable. In the instant case, the
agreement in dispute was a simple agreement to reconvey property
under certain conditions mentioned therein and, thus, was not
compulsorily registrable. Under the circumstances, even provisions
of section 92(4) of the Evidence Act are not applicable in the present
case. In view of above ratio, the document now sought to be
produced is also simple agreement to recovery property. Therefore,
nothing bars to mark the proposed document in evidence. It is worth
to refer decision of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of J. Yashoda Vs- K. Shobha Rani reported in (2007) 5 SCC 730 wherein the
Hon'ble Apex Court held at para No.7 that Secondary evidence, as a
general rule is admissible only in the absence of primary evidence. If
the original itself is found to be inadmissible through failure of the
party, who files it to prove it to be valid, the same party is not entitled
to introduce secondary evidence of its contents. It is further held at
para No.8 that Essentially, secondary evidence is an evidence which
may be given in the absence of that better evidence which law
requires to be given first, when a proper explanation of its absence
is given. The definition in Section 63 is exhaustive as the Section
declares that secondary evidence "means and includes" and then
follow the five kinds of secondary evidence. It is further held at para
No.9 that the rule which is the most universal, namely that the best
evidence the nature of the case will admit shall be produced,
decides this objection that rule only means that, so long as the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
higher or superior evidence is within your possession or may be
reached by you, you shall give no inferior proof in relation to it.
Section 65 deals with the proof of the contents of the documents
tendered in evidence. In order to enable a party to produce
secondary evidence it is necessary for the party to prove existence
and execution of the original document. Under Section 64,
documents are to be provided by primary evidence. Section 65,
however permits secondary evidence to be given of the existence,
condition or contents of documents under the circumstances
mentioned. The conditions laid down in the said Section must be
fulfilled before secondary evidence can be admitted. Secondary
evidence of the contents of a document cannot be admitted without
non-production of the original being first accounted for in such a
manner as to bring it within one or other of the cases provided for in
the Section. In the case on hand, the plaintiff has complied with
Section 65 of the Evidence Act. Therefore, there is no embargo to
mark the photocopy of the Edaru Kararu Patra for a just decision of
the suit. It is settled law that mere marking of a document does not
tantamount to proof of a document. The reasons assigned in the
applications are justified and made out a prima-facie to allow the
applications. If the applications are allowed, no way prejudice to the
defendants. If any prejudice will be caused to the defendants same
may be compensated by imposing cost on the plaintiff. In view of
above, I answer point No. 1 in the 'Affirmative'
12. Point No.2: In view of discussion and the findings arrived
at point No.1, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
Application filed under Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 and application under Order XVIII Rule 17 of CPC
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
and application under Section 66(b) of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 are allowed on cost of Rs.500/-.
Consequently, evidence of plaintiff is re-opened and
permitted to adduce further chief examination by:28/10”
5.
A perusal of the material on record including impugned
order will indicate that the same does not contain any illegality or
infirmity nor can the same is said to have caused any prejudice or
occasioned failure of justice particularly when all rival contentions
between the parties regarding admissibility, proof, relevance,
probative
value,
etc.
of
the
alleged
Photostat
copy
of
Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed, which would necessarily
have to be decided by the Trial Court in accordance with law after
considering the rival contentions of both parties and permit the
petitioners – defendant Nos.2 and 3 to cross-examine the plaintiff –
PW1 in relation to the said Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed
also.
6.
Under these circumstances, in the light of the judgment
of the Apex Court in the case of Radhey Shyam Vs. Chhabi Nath
- (2015) 5 SCC 423, I am of the view that the impugned order
cannot be said to have suffer from any illegality or infirmity nor can
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
the same is said to have caused any prejudice or resulted in
miscarriage of justice warranting interference by this Court in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, as held by the Apex Court in the cases of Radhey Shyam
Vs. Chhabi Nath - (2015) 5 SCC 423, K.P. Natarajan Vs.
Muthalammal – AIR 2021 SC 3443 and Mohamed Ali Vs. V.
Jaya & others – (2022) 10 SCC 477.
7.
In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
(i)
The petition is hereby disposed of without
interfering with the impugned order.
(ii)
Respondents – plaintiffs are permitted to recall
PW1 and produce and mark the alleged Photostat copy of
the
Edurukararupatra
/
re-conveyance
deed
dated
19.05.2004 as an exhibit in support of their claim subject to
the condition that all rival contentions between the plaintiffs
and defendants as regards admissibility, proof, relevance,
probative value, etc. of the alleged Photostat copy of
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:972
WP No. 35739 of 2025
HC-KAR
Edurukararupatra / re-conveyance deed are kept open to be
decided by the Trial Court in accordance with law.
(iii)
Trial Court is directed to dispose of the suit as
expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of six
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
SV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 58
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review