Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION N O: 35068 OF 2025
Between:
Sri V.Madhava Reddy, S/o (Late) Sri V.Ramreddy, aged about 58 years,
presently working as Joint Registrar at the UCESTH JNTUH. Hyderabad
Headquarters, Kukatpally, Hyderabad. R/o. Quarters No.2 Directors Quarters,
JNTUH Campus, KPHB Kukatpally, Hyderabad - 500085
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University, Hyderabad (JNTUH), represented
by its Registrar, Kukatpally, Hyderabad.
3. Telangana State Council of Higher Education, Represented by its Secretary,
JNAFU Building, 1st Floor, Mahaveer Marg, opp. Mahaveer Hospital, Masab
Tank, Hyderabad, Telangana 500028
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an order, direction or Writ more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus or any other appropriate writ declaring the impugned transfer
proceedings vide No.C4lEstablishmentl2l2l dated 13.11.2025 issued by the
2ndRespondent, transferring the Petitioner from the Office of the Registrar, JNTUH,
Hyderabad to JNTUH University College of Engineering, Jagtial, as being illegal,
arbitrary, without jurisdiction, and in violation of the Jawaharlal Nehru Technological
Universities Act, 2008 (Act 30 of 2008), contrary to the subsisting State-wide ban on
transfers vide G.O.Ms.No.87, Finance (HRM-I), dated 31.07.2024, Memo
No.3081 512-N197/A1lHRM.lt2025-3, dated 26.06.2025, further director of
rreasuries circular [trlemo No.023-1
dated 11'11'2025' and violative of
Articles 14'
l6and2loftheConstitutionoflndia,andintheabsenceofanysanctionedpostof
college of Engineering, Jagtial' and
Joint Registrar at JNTUH University
consequentlysetasidetheimpugnedtransferproceedingsdatedl3,ll.2o2S.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
in the
praying that in the circumstances stated
cPC
section
under
Petition
the
High court may be pleased to stay
the
petition,
the
of
support
in
affidavit filed
operationoftheproceedingsvideNo.C4lEstablishmen|t2o25dated13.11.2025with
to continue the petitioner in the present
a consequent direction to the Respondents
place of posting at JNTUH Headquarters'
Hyderabad'
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
in the
praying that in the circumstances stated
Petition under Section 151 cPc
pleased to DIRECT
petition, the High court may be
affidavit filed in supporl of the
the Respondents herein, to forthwith disburse
emoluments of the Petitioner till date,
emoluments of the Petitioner' on time'
all the withheld salaries and
and to continue to pay the salary and
GUNDAVARAM
'n"tp"na"ntSRI SAI PRASEN
Counsel for the Petitioner:
SERVICES-I
FOR
GP
No'1:
Counsel for the
perr PRABHAKAR, sc FoR JNTUH
counsel for the Respondent No.2: sir
u.pnavEEN REDDY, SC FOR TSCHE
counset for the Respondent ruo.5: ini
The Court made the following: ORDER
all
SK,,J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF'TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
W.P.No.35O68 of 2o25,
Date:25.06.2o26
Between:
Sri V. Madhava ReddY.
...Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana represented by its Principal
Secretary, Higher Education Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad and others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard sri G.S.Prasen, learned counsel for the
petitioner, learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Services-I for the respondent No. 1, Sri Peri Prabhakar,
Iearned. Standing Counsel for the respondent No.2 and
perused the record.
2.
This writ petition is filed questioning the
proceedings No.c4l Establishment/ 2025 dated 13. 1 | .2025
issued by the respondent No.2 in l.ransferring the petitioner
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2,025
from the office of the Registrar, Jawaharlal Nehru
Technological university, Hyderabad (For short 'JNTUH') to
the lJniversity college of trngineering, Jagtial (For short
'ucEJ), contrary to thc subsisting statewide ban on
transfers vide G.O.Ms.No.B7, Finance (HRM-I)
dated
31 .O7 ,2024,
Memo
No.3Og l1l2A1197 lA1lHRM.rl2025-3 dated 26.06.2o2s and circular
Memo No.F2 1265612023- 1 dated 1 1. 1 t.2o2s issued by the
Dircctor of rreasuries and Accounts and also in the
absence of any sanctioned post of ..loint Registra.r at
university college of Engineering, Jagtial as illegai and
arbitrary and consequently set aside the said transfer
procecdings.
c ontentions of the oe titioner:-
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
initially the petitioner was appointed as Junior Assistant in
the college of Fine Arts and Architecture at Hyderabad vide
procecdings No.c I 133186-89 dated 30.1 1. 19g9 and
thereafter promoted as Senior Assisternt, office
-\
SK, J
W.P.No.35O68 of 2025
Superintendent, Assistant Registrar, Deputy Registrar and
now as Joint Registrar-JNTUH and he has been rendering
his service over 36 years in JNTUH in various Departments
and Colieges. The petitioner being President of the JNTUH
Administrative Officers' Association actively contested the
arbitrary appointment of an outsider as the Finance Officer
at the respondent University-.JNTuH and filed several writ
petitions questioning iilegal appointments to the post of
Finance Officer in the University.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that in retaliation for filing of the writ petitions, the
respondent University issued the impugned proceedings
transferring the petitioner from the respondent University
to UCE.J, where there is admittedly no sanctioned post of
Joint Registrar. In the absence of any transfer policy in the
University Statutes, Rule 37 of Chapter XIV of the First
Statue makes the general State Government Service Rules
applicable. The subsisting ban on transfers vide
G.O.Ms.No.87 Finance (HRM-I) dated 3L.O7 .2024 read
wjth
(
I
Memo
No.30815r2-Al 197 lAl /HRM.Il2025-3
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
dated 26.06.2025 and the
Circular Memo
No.l-2 1265612023 1 dated 11.11.2025 issued by the
Director of Treasuries squarely governs the case of the
petitioner rendering any transfer after O1.O8.2024 per se
invalid except in the narrow exceptional situations which
are not attracted in the instant case
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that there is no uniform, notificd policy of rotation fclr Joint
Registrars nor any provision for posting to University
College of Engineering, Jagtial where no sanctioned post o[
Joint Registrar exists, on the contrary, &S per
G.O.Ms.No.207 Finance
(SMI'}C l)
Department
dated 09.09.201,1, eight administrative posts for UCEJ i.e,
one Assistant Registrar, one Office Superintendent, one
Senior Accountant. one Senior Assistant and four Junior
Assistants were sanctioned, but retained at the
Headquarters instead of being posted to Jagtial. He further
submits that the reliance on transf'er in the year, 2022 on
similar administrative grounds is totally misconceived as
each transfer must independently satisfy the prevailing
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
statutory framework and the Government imposed ban on
transfers and cannot be validated by past practice.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that the request made by the Principal does not disclose
any Telangana Government provision or document naming
the petitioner nor explained as to why the already
sanctioned posts i.e, Assistant Registrars, Superintendents
and senior Assistants, have not been posted back to ucEJ
in preference to creating a non-existent post of Joint
Registrar. In the absence of sanctioned post of Joint
Registrar at UCtrJ, in view of ban on transfers and also
sanctioned Administrative staff for ucEJ kept at
Headquarters, the charactetization of the transfer as a
bona fid.e, policy based rotation is unsustainable. There is
no sanctioned post of Joint Registrar at ucEJ and a nonexistent post cannot be filled by transfer under the guise of
administrative exigency and, even as per the counter, there
is no sanctioned post of Joint Register at JNTUH, which
itself reinforces the plea of the petitioner that what is being
f
r'
B
SK, J
W.I'].No.35068 of 2,025
done is a person-specific displacement dehors cadre
strength and sanctioned posts.
7.
l.earned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that a past acquiescence while working at UCEH/UCESI{T
on a non-sanctioned Joint Registrar post cannot estop the
petitiorrer from questioning a patently illegal outstation
posting now, especially when Jagtial is outside Hyderabad
Head Quarters jurisdiction with a lower HRA slab, no CCA
and different budget head and ten separate administrative
posts have already been sanctioned specifically for UCtrJ as
per G.O.Ms.No.2O7 Finance (SMPC-I) Department
dated 09.O9.2O 1 1 , but are being retained at Headquarters
instead of being posted to Jagtial. The invocation of Statute
V(1)(v)(18) and Statute XIV clause 16 cannot override the
basic rcquirement that transfers must be to sanctioned
posts. The Statute V(1)(v)(18) of JNTUH allows the
Univcrsity to transfer members of the teaching,
administrative and other staff from one College or
Institution to another. Statute xIV clause 16 similarly
stated with regard to postings and transfers shall be
SK, J
W.P.No.35O68 of 2025
ordered by the competent authority. These are enabling
provisions, which state that who can transfer and in what
general manner, but they do not state that transfers can
ignore sanctioned posts or Government orders'
8.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner further submits
that the reliance made by the respondents that the
transfers may be made even during ban wherever
administrative exigency warrants is equally untenable since
no cogent material is produced to show any exceptional
exigency vis-a-vis the petitioner, and the very fact that
sartctioned staff of UCE.I are kept back at Head Quarters
undermines the plea of bona fide necessity. He further
submits that there are no specifically defined or sanctioned
administrative post earmarked for individual units or
constituent colleges is factually incorrect in the face of a
specific reliance on behalf of the petitioner as per
G.O.Ms.No.207 Finance
(SMPC-I) Department
dated og.og.2oll , ten administrative posts were
sanctioned for UCEJ, and the counter is conspicuously
silent as to why those sanctioned incumbents were
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2,025
withdrawn lrom Jagtial and r:tained at Headquarter. The
reflerence made by the respondents in the counter that the
other Joint Registrars allegedly working in smaller units
within Hyderabad only show that postings within Head
Quarter jurisdiction on available work have been made, it
does not justify a punitive outstation posting to a non-
sanctioned post at Jagtial in breach of statutory and
Government ordcr rcstraints. FIe further submits that in
the absence of a sanctioned post of Joint Registrar at
UCttJ, the subsisting statutory and executive ban on
transfers and the petitioner being an office bearer of a
recognized service association, the impugned proceedings
are illegal and arbitrary and requested to allow the writ
petitiorr by setting arsidc the impugned proceedings.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the
following Judgment;
SK,.J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
1.
Sunil Shrirang Bawaskar Vs. Dr. Punjabrao
Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapeeth Akolal.
Contentions of the resoondent-U niversitv:-
10.
Learned Standing Counsel for the respondent No.2
basing on the counter submits that the respondent
University follows a uniform policy of rotation and ensures
that no incumbent continues in one unit for an unduly
long time and in the present case, after completion of two
years at JNTUH and after considering the exigency of
administrative work at UCEJ, the petitioner being senior
administrator with prior experience in autonomous colleges
was posted to another autonomous constituent unit i.e.,
UCtr.I on administrative grounds and also on the request
made by the Principal, UCE.I to depute Administrative
Officers to support general administration, financial
matters, statutory approvals and for better liaison with
University Headquarters. Regarding the appointment of
'201o SCC online tSom 356
/
I
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 ol2025
Finance officer, aS per the panel furnished by
the
Government,theUniversityhasappointedDr.M.Surender
as Finance officer in the year, 2022 after following
due
procedureandthereisnoviolationofGovernment
guidelines or University statutes and the said appointment
was made strictly in accclrd.ance with G.o.Ms.No.22
trducation Department datecl 04.O4.2O13 and the
l'ligher
relevant
provisions of the University Act and Statutes'
11.
Learned stand.ing counsel for the respclndent
No'2
furthcrsubmitsthrrtthcpctitionerhasquestionedthc
existence of a clear vacancy for the post of Joint
Registra-r
at uclrJ is concerned., even at the JNTUH, there is no
sanctioned'postofJclirrtRegistrarandthoughthe
petitioner is furlly awarc that no sanctioned post exists
Flyderabacl college, yet he never raised any
at
objection while
workingthere.Itisonlyaftercompletionoftwoyearso[
scrvice:attheI.{yderabaclCollege,therespondentNo.2
University transferred him to another autonomous
...
i.". , UCEJ .
college
The transfer has been made purely on
administrative grounds by considering the need for
SK, J
W.P.No.35O68 of 2025
experienced administrative personnel at
the newly
autonomous college at Jagtial and as there is a provision as
per Statute V(I)(v)(18), the University has the authority to
transfer members of the teaching, administrative and other
staff and posts from one College or Institution to another
and from the teaching departments to administratrve
departments and vice-versa.
12.
Learned Standing Counsel for the respondent No.2
further submits that there are no specifically defined or
sanctioned administrative posts earmarked for individual
Units or Constituent Colleges in the University. Based on
the requirement and on administrative grounds, the
University is empowered to transfer Administrative Officers
in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The petitioner
is well aware that his senior colleagues had earlier worked
in .INTUH University College'of Engineering, Science &
Technologr and retired on superannuation. Presently
another Joint Registrar, who is senior to the petitioner, is
a.lso
serving in the .TNTUH University College of
Management, Hyderabad, which is a comparatively small
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 o1'2025
unit, In accordance with the statutory provisions, the
petitioner was transferred to UCtrJ considering his
experience in autonomous college matters and there is no
personal motive or mala fide intention behind his transfer.
When administrative necessity arises, the University may
transfer any incumbent to any constituent college as per
thc provisions of thc Act and Statutes and even during
general transfer bans, the Government and Universities
may transfer employees wherever administrative exigency
warrants and transfer of the petitioner is fully justified and
made strictly on administrative grounds and requested to
dismiss the writ petition.
13.
l.earncd Counsel for tkrc respondent No.2 reliecl on
the following .Judgments;
1. Tsering Norbu Vs. State of Arunachal Pradesh2
2.
N.K. Singh vs. Union of Indiag
2 2025 SCC Online Gau 5042
3 (1994) 6 SCC 98
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
Consideratio n and Findines:-
14.
After hearing both sides and perusing the material
on record, this Court is of the considered view that the
petitioner is working as Joint Registrar in the respondent
No.2-University and also the President of JNTUH
Administrative Officers' Association and the salne was
recognized by the respondent University. The contention of
the petitioner is that the petitioner being President of the
JNTUH Administrative Officers' Association filed various
writ petitions before this Court in questioning the
appointment of Finance Officer in the University and in
view of the salne, the respondent-University with a mala
fide intention transferred the petitioner to UCEJ in nonexistent post.
15.
The contention of the petitioner is that the staff
appointed as per the sanctioned posts of UCEJ are working
in university Headquarters at Hyderabad. As the ucEJ
obtained status of autonomous recently and with a mala
fide intention to suffer the petitioner, the respondents had
SK, J
W.l'].No.35068 of 2025
transferred him from I{yderabad to .Iagtial in a non-
existent post. As per G.O.Ms.No.207 Finance (SMPC-I)
Department dated 09 .O9.2O 1 1 , the Gclvernment sanctioned
administrative posts in .INTUH University College of
Engineering, Jagtial and no post of Joint Registrar therein.
At the time of' hearing, this Court directcd the
respondent-University to produce the document regarding
the sanctioned post of Joint Registrar in composite
affiliated colleges, but the learned Standing Counsel after
few adjournments submits ttrat there is no specific
sanctioned post of Joint Registrar in any Ccllleges and the
petitioner is presently working in JNTUH, Hyderabad where
there is no Joint Registrar post and since two years, he is
continuing as Joint Registrar in the autonomous college
and therc is no need for a sanctioned post to transfcr the
petitioner from Hyderabad to Jagtial. The respondents
further contended that the Vice Chancellor is empowered tct
transfer any employee frorn clne cadre to other cadre from
teaching to non-tcaching post and in view of the same,
t7
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
there is no violation of the service conditions for
transferring the petitioner from Hyderabad to Jagtial.
17.
The contention of the petitioner is that the
petitioner cannot estop from questioning his transfer from
Hyderabad to .Iagtial as presently he is working in
Hyderabad other than the Head office. If the petitioner is
continued in autonomous college at Hyderabad, he can
receive the same pay such as ccA and HRA and once the
petitioner transferred from the present place to Jagtial, he
may lose the HRA and ccA as received in Hyderabad.
iB.
The petitioner is working as President of the
JNTUH Administrative officers' Association and also filed
writ petitions before this court. The respondent University
has the right to transfer any one, however, there must be
an existing post, and, an employee cannot be transferred to
a non-existent post. The Joint Registrar post is only at the
University Head Quarters and the ()overnment also
sanctioned the posts up to the Assistant Registrar in UCEJ
as per G.O.Ms.No.2O7 Finance Department dated
f
t'
1B
SK, J
W, l). No. 35068 of' 2,O2i>
09.09 .2Ol1, but the question of transferring the petitioner
in the cadre of .Joint Register in UCtrJ in the non-existent
post cannot be acceptablc.
19.
The respondent-University in its counter has not
denicd with regard to the staff' posted in the sanctioned
posts in UCEJ are working in Hyderabad. The action clf the
respondent-University in transferring the petitioner to the
non-existent post of Joint Registrar under administrative
exigency is not convincible. In view of the same, there is a
force in the contention of the petitioner that with a mala
fide intention, the respon<lr:nt University transferred the
petitioner in the impugned order.
20.
The .Iudgment relied on by the learned counsel for
the petitioner in Sunil Shrirang Bawaskar's case ( 1 supra),
the Honble High Court of Bombay held in para 4 as under;
"4. Having regard to the circumstances of the case, we hold
that tl-re petrtioncr car.rnot be transfcrred to a non-existent post in
Akolzr arrd continued to be paid from Nagpur, We however, make it
clear that this does not mean that P.K.v. cannot direct any of its
employee holcling the post of Assistant Professor at Nagpur to work at
Akola on circuit. lt rs very clear that p.K.V. is entitled to get the
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 of 2025
sanctioned posts at Akola or even transfer the existing posts of
Assistant Professor (veterinary Science) from Nagpur to Akola,
whcreupon a suitable pet:son can bc posted to that post. Thc
impugned order is thus quashed and set aside."
The said finding of the High court of Bombay squarely
apply to the facts of this case.
.
The Judgments relied on by the learned counsel for
the respondent University in Tsering Norbu's case (2
supra) and N.K. Singh's case (3 supra) are not apply to
the facts of the case as in the instant case with a mala fide
intention, the respondent University transferred the
petitioner to the non-existent post in spite of several
employees, who have posted in the sanctioned posts in
UCtrJ, are working in Headquarters at Hyderabad and
transferred the petitioner on the ground of administrative
exigency and therefore, the transfer of the petitioner cannot
be acceptable.
22.
In similar circumstances, the Honble High court
of Andhra Pradesh passed orders in M. Venkateswara Rao
/
SK, J
W.P.No.35068 ol2O2S
vs. state of Andhra pradesh4 and the relevant para 6 is
as follows;
"6. c)n the other hand, the impugned order was passed by the
2nd respondent directing ttre pctitioner to discharge his duties at
Vijilapuram PHC on administrative convenience until further orders
and it is not for iimitecl period or a specilic period. Therefore, it is
e'ident from the order impugned in the writ petition that the
respondents are circumventing the rules as there is no possibility
of
transferring the petitioner to vijilapuram where there is no post
of
MPI-IS(M) and issuecl direction for indefinite periocl to clischarge
his
duties at Vijalapuram, where no post of MpFIS(M) is sanctioned.
Therefore, the order itself indicates a different intention of
the
authorities somehow to keep the petitioner away to the local area i,c.,
Kalakada, chittoor District for the reasons best known to the
respondents. 'l'hus, passing such an order circumventing the rules
is a
serious illegality and thereby the sarne is liable to be set aside.
The above findings of the High court of Andhra pradesh
apply to the facts of the instant case.
23.
ln thc above circumstances, it clearly shows that
the respondent University with a mala fide intention
transferred the petitioner from Hyderabad to Jagtial in a
non-existent post. In view of the settled law, this Court can
interfere with the impugned .rder of transfer and the same
is liable to be set aside and the petitioner has to continue
,4
Unreported Judqment in W,p.No.12Bt of 2O2l clated
20.01,2021
SK,.]
2L
W. I'].No. 350 68
as .Joint Registrar
Fleadquarters
the Writ
With the above findings'
aflowed bY
13'11'2025
shment/ 2025 dated
the resPonden t
1S
issued by
the respondent
No.2-University ancl
No'2-
the petitioner
continue
to
directed
Registrar'
Hyderabad as Joint
25.
Petition rs
Proceedings
setting aside the imPugned
No.C4 / Establi
UniversitY
of
present place
in Hyderabad in the
working or in the University
ol 20'2'5
Miscellaneous
petition shall stand
in
No order as to costs'
writ
in this
petitions' if any pending
closed'
//rRuE
SD,'P'C' S,LiJ.*A DEVI
coPY/
iSiisinNr REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
K'SARATH
Hon'ble 9ti i5lite
one Fair Copv to tlne
Perusat)
(For His uoJ"niP" Kind
to
Justice
un'o:,::':'" Ministry of Law'
1. 11 LR CoPies'
, l3:,y,:1"$B"J,",lro'
-i"i"ngana
3. The secre,ury,
Advocates Association
and companv
Library' High court
Buildings'
HYderabad'
4.ThePrincipalsecretary,HigherEducationDepartment,secretariat,Hyderabad,
o|]]#
rechnorosicar universitv'
Hvderabad
J?*?]?llil^]'l:n"
, :::
t;;^::t",Liui"lt"*"J\i:[
:rx:S"":,l'i;1t.#H1'3##3ffi
1st
Building,
F
,[lf#p;i*',Ui-$ru"='llf,Y$.#n:Yif;
c9
3'3,'3'::i+"ansana,a'i
;,lli"#il:H'l,EgxwstsBvlBE?E*\'.'J.Pi""",b
CoPies
11 .Two CD
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2510612026
1 Hu Sr4 14:
(
ORDER
WP.No.35068 of 2025
.r
d o6
t
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
q o4pl
[}
Jur2026
alt
.ti'
*
-l):s,,.arcri
.1
.:r.!
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review