Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 31ST DAY OF AUGUST, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 591 OF 2025
C/W
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 597 OF 2025
IN COMAP No. 591/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
Digitally
signed by K
P SWETHA
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER
OFFICE AT: NO.28, 1ST FLOOR
BENGALURU DIVISIONAL OFFICE
MISSION ROAD
BENGALURU - 560 027
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI GIREESHA KODGI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SRI T.R. SAINATH
S/O T.S. RAJAGOPAL SETTY
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
2.
SMT. T. SUNITHA SAINATH
W/O T.R. SAINATH
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
BOTH ARE RESIDING AT:
NO. 13, 4TH CROSS, 5TH MAIN
CHAMRAJPET
BENGALURU - 560 018
ALSO AT NO. 82
SAI ARCADE GANDHI BAZAAR MAIN ROAD
BASAVANAGUDI
BENGALURU - 560 004
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI C. VINAY SWAMY, ADVOCATE FOR C/R-1 & R-2)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 13
(1-A) OF COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT, PRAYING TO ALLOW THIS
APPEAL, SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
10.09.2025, ONE PASSED BY THE LXXXII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU (CCH 83), IN COM. OS NO.
1503/2024 AND ETC.
IN COMAP NO. 597/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI T.R. SAINATH
S/O T.S. RAJAGOPAL SETTY
AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
2.
SMT T SUNITHA SAINATH
W/O T.R. SAINATH
AGE ABOUT 67 YEARS
BOTH ARE R/AT:
NO.13, 4TH CROSS,
5TH MAIN, CHAMRAJPET
BENGALURU - 560 004
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
ALSO AT:
NO.82, SAI ARCADE
GANDHI BAZAAR MAIN ROAD
BASAVANAGUDI
BENGALURU - 560 004
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI C. VINAY SWAMY, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED
REPRESENTED BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER
OFFICE AT NO.28, 1ST FLOOR
BENGALURU DIVISIONAL OFFICE
MISSION ROAD
BENGALURU - 560 027
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI GIREESHA KODGI, ADVOCATE)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
13(1-A) COMMERCIAL COURT ACT, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 10.09.2025 PASSED IN
COM.O.S.NO.1503/2024 BY THE HON'BLE LXXXII ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, AT BENGALURU (CCH-83)
ONLY WITH REGARD TO GRANTING OF DAMAGES OF
RS.1,25,053.3/- PER MONTH AND DIRECT THE RESPONDENT
TO PAY APPELLANT A SUM OF RS.8,50,000/- PER MONTH
FROM 08.04.2024 TILL VACATING THE SCHEDULE PROPERTY
AND ETC.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE)
1.
The present commercial appeals are cross appeals filed
under Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 [CC Act]
impugning the judgment and decree dated 10.09.2025 passed by
the LXXXII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru
Commercial
Court,
Bengaluru
[Commercial
Court]
in
Com.O.S.No.1503/2024.
2.
The plaintiffs (appellants in COMAP No.597/2025 and the
respondents in COMAP No.591/2025) [hereafter referred to as ‘the
lessors’] had filed the said suit, inter alia, seeking a decree for
possession of the suit premises and damages for unlawful
occupation at the rate of `8,50,000/- per month from the date of
filing of the suit till delivery of the possession of the suit.
3.
The lessors are the owners of the suit premises, which
measure about 14,300 square feet and is situated at Muninanjappa
Layout, Ramamurthy Nagar, Bengaluru [‘the suit premises’]. The
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
suit premises was leased to IBP Company Limited – which was
subsequently acquired by Indian Oil Corporation Limited [IOCL] –
by way of a registered lease deed dated 05.03.2004 [‘the lease
deed’ - Exhibit P1] for a period of 20 years. Under the lease deed,
the monthly rent was fixed at `71,500/- with the stipulation that the
same would increase by 15% every five years for a period of 20
years.
4.
The lease deed also contained a provision (Clause 9) for
renewal of the lease for a further period of five years on mutually
agreed terms.
5.
IOCL had sent a letter dated 06.09.2023 (Exhibit D1)
expressing its intention to seek renewal of the lease. The lessors
offered to renew the lease for a further period of five years at the
rate of `75/- per square feet from the date of expiry of lease.
6.
Thereafter, the lessors sent a letter dated 19.12.2023
(Exhibit P2) to the IOCL, referring to the letter dated 09.09.2023
whereby, they had offered to renew the lease for a further period of
five years at the rate of `75/- per square feet from the date of
expiry of lease. The said letter dated 19.12.2003 also reflects that
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
certain negotiations were held between the parties, which remained
inconclusive. In terms of the said letter, the lessors had made a
final offer to renew the lease at the rate of `60/- per square feet. It
was also unequivocally stated that in the event, the said final offer
was not accepted, the said letter be treated as an eviction notice
and the suit premises be handed over on expiry of the lease that is,
on 04.03.2024.
7.
IOCL did not accept the said offer. In the circumstances, the
lessors sent a notice dated 08.02.2024 (Exhibit P9) styled as
notice under Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act,1882
calling upon the IOCL to hand over vacant possession of the suit
premises on 04.03.2024 by removing all the retail outlet facilities
including canopy, sales building, underground tanks etc. The
lessors also put IOCL to notice that on failure to hand over vacant
possession, they will be constrained to initiate action for eviction
and recovery of damages at the rate of `8,50,00/- per month.
8.
IOCL responded to the said notice by the letter dated
07.03.2024 (Exhibit P7) that is, after the lease had expired. It
referred to Clause 9 of the lease deed and stated that it had
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
expressed the intent to renew the lease and was ready for further
negotiations. The letter further stated that it intended to arrange
another negotiation meeting to finalize the lease terms and the
lessors would be informed about the date of such meeting.
9.
Since, IOCL did not hand over the vacant possession of the
suit premises, the lessors initiated pre-institution mediation under
Section 12A of the CC Act. However, the mediation was
unsuccessful and a report dated 30.10.2024 (Exhibit P10) to the
said effect was furnished by the District Legal Services Authority,
Bengaluru.
10.
Thereafter, the lessors instituted the above mentioned suit.
IOCL filed the statement of defense as well as raised a counter
claim. It prayed that directions be issued to the plaintiffs to execute
necessary lease deed for renewing the lease for a further period of
five years on a reasonable monthly rental.
11.
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the learned Commercial
Court framed the following issues:
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
“1. Whether the plaintiffs prove that the lease period is
over and Defendant to quit and deliver the vacant
possession of the property to the plaintiff ?
2. Whether the Plaintiffs prove that, the Defendant is
liable to pay damages for sum of Rs.8,50,000/- per
month from 08.04.2024 to till filing of the suit and till
delivery of possession of the Suit Schedule Property ?
3. Whether the Defendant proves that, Plaintiff is liable
to execute necessary lease deed granting further lease
period as per clause 9 of Registered lease deed dated
05.03.2004 ?
4. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for relief as prayed
for ?
5. Whether the Defendant is entitled for relief as prayed
in Counter Claim ?
6. What Decree or Order ?”
12.
The parties led their evidence. On the basis of the same, the
learned Commercial Court answered Issue No.1 in affirmative; the
court found that the lessors had proved that the period of the lease
was over and they were entitled to a decree of eviction. Insofar as
the claim for damages (Issue No.2) at the rate of `8,50,000/- per
month is concerned, the learned Commercial Court did not in
favour of the lessors (plaintiffs). However, the learned Commercial
Court granted damages at the rate of `1,25,053.30/- per month till
the date of vacating the suit premises.
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
13.
IOCL had filed the present appeal (COMAP No.591/2025),
inter alia, claiming that it is entitled to renewal of the lease for a
period of five years. It also claimed that since the learned
Commercial Court had determined the damages at `1,25,053.30/per month which was 15% over the monthly rent for the last five
years of the lease, IOCL was willing to pay the said rent. Thus,
IOCL had claim that its counter claim to direct the lessors to
execute the lease deed on the said terms ought to have been
allowed. IOCL also states that it is a public utility and therefore,
public interest demanded that the lease be renewed.
14.
The lessors had also filed an appeal (COMAP No.597/2025),
assailing the impugned judgment to the extent that the learned
Commercial Court had denied damages at the rate of `8,50,000/per month for occupation of the suit premises beyond the term of
the lease, as claimed by the lessors. It is contended on their behalf
that they had produced a lease deed dated 01.02.2022 (Exhibit P8)
in respect of an immovable property in the vicinity of the suit
premises. The said lease deed evidences that the lease rent
between the contracting parties was fixed at `3,82,915/- per month
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
for an area measuring 5,738.49 square feet, which would work out
to over `66/- per square foot.
15.
It was argued on behalf of the lessors that the suit premises
was a corner property in an area where the rentals were high. It
was submitted that the evidence brought on record clearly
indicated that the rental would be about `66 per square feet and
therefore, the lessors were entitled to damages as claimed by
them.
REASONS AND CONCLUSIONS
16.
As apparent from the above, the disputes involved in the
present appeals are two-fold. First, whether IOCL is entitled to
renewal of the lease notwithstanding that the parties were unable
to mutually agree to the terms of renewal. And second, whether the
lessors were entitled to the damages as claimed.
17.
Clause 9 of the lease deed (Exhibit P1) is central to the
dispute and is set out below:
“9) If the lessee shall be desirous of renewing this
present lease after a period of 20 years and of such
desire shall have given to the Lessors not less than
three months notice prior to the expiration hereof and
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
shall have duly observed and performed all the terms
and conditions hereof the Lessors shall grant to them a
renewal lease of the said premises for a further period
of 5 years at mutually agreeable terms and a fresh
document may be executed by the lessee and the
Lessors for the further extension of the lease.”
18.
A plain reading of the said clause indicates that in the event
IOCL was desirous of renewing the lease, it was required to send a
notice not less than three months prior to the expiry of the lease.
According to IOCL, it had sent a letter dated 06.09.2023 (Exhibit
D1) expressing its intention for seeking renewal of the lease. The
relevant extract of the said letter reads as under:
“We seek your kind attention and offer our complete
acceptance to extend our relationship by renewing the
lease which is about to expire by 04/03/2024. In this
regard, you are requested to give us your offer in
writing to our office for extending the said lease in order
to start the proceedings of negotiation etc. in renewing
the RO lease.”
19.
As apparent from the above, IOCL called upon the lessors to
give their offer in writing to extend the lease for commencing
negotiations for renewing the lease of the suit premises.
Admittedly, the lessors had made an offer to renew the lease for a
further period of 5 years at a rent of `8,50,000/- per month.
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
20.
Admittedly, negotiations were held between the parties
thereafter as clearly evident from the notice dated 19.12.2023
(Exhibit P2). The lessors had visited IOCL's office on 07.11.2023,
and they claimed that IOCL had indicated that it would be willing to
pay an amount of `2,00,000/- per month as rent. The said letter
also indicates that another meeting was held wherein IOCL offered
a monthly rental of `1,33,000/- for the suit premises. However, the
said rental was not acceptable to the lessors. The lessors claimed
that they had made an offer to renew the lease at a rent of `75/per square foot, which would amount to `10,50,000/- per month.
However, IOCL was not willing to accept the same. Accordingly,
the lessors offered to lease out the suit premises for a monthly
rental of `8,50,000/-, which they claimed that it works out to about
5.7% of the scheduled rates published by the Government of
Karnataka for the properties in the area where the suit premises
was located.
21.
In the letter dated 19.12.2023 (Exhibit-P2), the lessors
confirmed that their final offer would be `60/- per square foot per
month, which evidently was not acceptable to IOCL.
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
22.
As noted above, the lessors had issued a legal notice calling
upon IOCL to vacate the suit premises on the expiry of the lease.
IOCL failed and neglected to vacate the suit premises and
responded to the notice after the lease had expired, inter alia,
stating that IOCL would arrange a meeting for further negotiations.
23.
It is amply clear from the above that the parties were unable
to arrive at mutually agreed terms on which the lease could be
renewed. IOCL’s contention that it was entitled to renewal of the
lease, notwithstanding that the parties were unable to mutually
agree on the terms and conditions, is without merit.
24.
Clause 9 of the lease deed merely provides that in the event,
IOCL was interested in renewing the lease, for a further period of
five years, it would send a notice at least three months prior to the
expiry of the lease and on such notice, the lessors shall renew the
lease at mutually agreeable terms. However, as evident, the parties
were unable to arrive at any mutually agreed terms, therefore, they
did not execute any fresh agreement.
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
25.
In State of U.P. vs. Lalji Tandon1 , the Supreme Court had
explained that there was a difference between 'an extension' of
lease in accordance with the covenant in that regard contained in
the principal lease and 'renewal of lease'. Whereas, in the case of
extension, it is not necessary to execute a fresh lease deed as it is
a necessary consequence of the clauses contained in the lease
deed. However, if the option of renewal is to be exercised, it is
necessary to execute a fresh lease deed between the parties failing
which, a lease for the renewal term would not come into existence.
26.
It is material to note that in the present case a fresh lease
deed, which is necessary did not come into existence, for want of
mutual agreement.
27.
We also consider it apposite to refer to the decision of the
Supreme Court in Naveen Chand vs. Nagarjuna Travels &
Hotels (P) Ltd.2 In that case, the import of the following clause of a
lease deed fell for consideration of the court:
"In pursuance of the said arrangement and in
consideration of the rent hereby reserved, the Lessor
hereby grants and demises by way of lease the
(2004 1 SCC 1
(2002) 6 SCC 331
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
portions of the premises described in the schedule
attached hereto and delineated in the plan attached
hereto for a period of 25 years in the first instance
with the right of renewal as hereinafter set out. The
initial period of the Lease shall commence from
1-8-1970.
The lessee shall pay the rent at the rate of Rs.650
per month for the first 5 years and Rs.850 per month
for the subsequent period of 5 years; Rs.1050 per
month for the third period of 5 years and Rs.1300 per
month for the remaining period of 10 years.
The aforesaid rent and the aforesaid rates shall be
paid by the lessee on or before the 10th of every
succeeding month at the office or at the premises of
the lessor or on such other place as the lessor may
appoint on his behalf from time to time."
28.
After noting the above clause, the Supreme Court observed
as under:
"From the above noted covenant in the lease deed, it
is clear that the lease was granted for a period of 25
years in the first instance with the right of renewal as
hereinafter set out. Though the right of renewal is
mentioned in the clause, there is no mention about
the terms and conditions of renewal either in the
clause quoted above or elsewhere in the document.
On a fair reading of the document it appears that the
right of renewal stated therein is shrouded in
uncertainty and vagueness. The renewal clause in a
lease deed is an important term of the agreement.
Ordinarily the Court should be reluctant to ignore
such a term of the lease, unless on a fair reading and
reasonable construction no meaning can be attached
to it. Since the renewal clause is not clear and
specific regarding the terms of renewal the Court is to
ascertain the intention of the parties from the
materials on record. As noted earlier, the lease deed
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
read as a whole, does not indicate the manner in
which the right of renewal is to be exercised by the
parties and the terms and conditions of such
renewal."
***
29.
***
***
We also consider it apposite to refer to the decision of the
Supreme Court In Shanti Prasad Devi vs. Shankar Mahto3. In
that agreement between the parties in the said case included a
renewal clause which required the lessee to exercise the option
prior to the expiry of the original period (as in the present case).
The lease also contained a clause regarding fixation of the terms
and conditions of the renewed period by mutual consent and in
absence thereof through mediation through local mukia or panchas
of the village. The lessee had sent a legal notice seeking renewal
of the lease.
However, the lessor did not respond to the said
notice. The lessor thereafter filed a suit for eviction of the lessee
from the demised premises and the lessee filed a cross suit
seeking specific performance of the agreement.
The Supreme
Court held that the lessee's cross suit for specific performance was
rightly rejected. In regard to the clauses of the renewal regarding
(2005) 5 SCC 543
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
fixation of terms and conditions for the renewed period, the Court
observed as under:
20. ... ... ... The clauses of renewal requiring fixation
of the terms and conditions for renewed period of
lease mutually or in the alternative through
village Mukhia and Panchas are
uncertain
and
incapable of specific performance. After legal notice
of renewal, the lessor did not send any positive reply
and instead filed a suit for ejectment, therefore, there
was no mutual consent for renewal. The forum
agreed to for deciding dispute was through
local Mukhia and Panchas of the village. The renewal
clauses of the agreement were vague and incapable
of specific performance. The Mukhia and Panchas
were not named in the agreement and the method of
choosing either of the two forums was not specified."
30.
In Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. vs. Indian Institute of
Engineering Technology4, the Madras High Court interpreted a
renewal clause which is set out below:
“….PROVIDED ALWAYS AND IT IS AGREED AND
DECLARED that the expiration of the said term of 20
years this lease will be automatically and without any
further act of any of the parties hereto be renewed for a
further term of 10 years from the expiration of the said
term hereby granted unless the lease shall prior to the
expiration of the last mentioned term give to the
intention not to take any renewed lease. The renewed
lease will be on the monthly rent to be mutually agreed
upon and under and subject to the same covenants,
conditions and agreements as are herein contained
including the present covenant for renewal.”
2012 SCC OnLine Mad 1485
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
31.
The parties were unable to agree as to the monthly rent
payable for the renewed term. In this regard, the Division Bench of
the Madras High Court observed as under:
"58. In the present case it is manifested from
various communications exchanged between the
plaintiffs and defendants that the plaintiffs have
expressed their inability to renew the lease in favour of
the defendant. It is also manifested that the plaintiffs
have also demanded enhanced rent if really the
defendant was interested on renewing the lease.
Though the defendant had been writing so many letters
to the plaintiff saying that he was interested in the
renewal of the lease and also to finalise the rental
terms, the defendants had not evinced any interest in
pursuing the matter further. Therefore, the plaintiffs had
ultimately issued a notice under Ex. A7 determining the
tenancy with the end of 31.05.1992 and the defendant
was also put under notice to quit the suit property with
the end of 31.05.1993 and deliver vacant possession
on 01.06.1993. It has also been stated that the
possession of the defendant in respect of the demised
premises on and from 01.06.1992 is that of a
trespassers and therefore, the defendant was directed
to pay the damages at the rate of Rs. 60,000/- per
mensum from June 1992 for use and occupation. Even
after this notice the defendant had not responded.
59. As revealed from the lease agreement
particularly from Clause I(j), the renewed lease will be
on the monthly rent to be mutually agreed upon and
under and subject to the same covenants, conditions. It
is palpable that the plaintiffs have not agreed for the
renewal of the lease for a further period of 10 years
after the ending of original lease period of 20 years.
The plaintiffs have also not given consent for the
defendant to continue in the possession and therefore,
it is obvious to note here that the possession of the
defendants in respect of the suit property after
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
01.06.1992 is wrongful and he is liable to pay damages
for the use and occupation.
60. This court has closely scrutinised the oral and
documentary evidences available on record. As
observed earlier the mere renewal clause which find a
place in Clause I(j) of the lease agreement, (Ex. A2)
does not create a fresh lease. Keeping in view of this
fact this court does not find any infirmity in the
judgment of the trial court and therefore, this court is of
considered view that the appeal is liable to be
dismissed as devoid of merits. Hence the defendant is
liable to be evicted as his tenency has been terminated
by efflux of time as contemplated under Section 111(a)
of The Transfer of Property Act."
32.
We may also refer to the decision of the Andhra Pradesh
High Court in Indian Oil Corporation Limited v. Karem Zaheer
Yar Jung5. The lease in question in that case also included a
renewal clause, inter alia, providing that the renewed lease would
be on the same monthly rent/at the rate mutually agreed. IOCL
filed a suit for specific performance for renewal of the lease, which
was rejected by the Division Bench. We consider it apposite to
refer to the following extract from the said decision:
"12. The lease in question was to be in effect from 18-1966 for a period of ten years. After referring to the
conditions concerning the payment of monthly rent, the
rights and obligations of the IOC and the landlady, Ex.
A-8 incorporates the following clause, which is subject
1997 SCC OnLine AP 271
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
matter of controversy and referred to as the ‘renewal
clause’:
“…It is agreed and declared that at the expiration of
the said term of ten years this lease will be automatically
and without any further act of any of the parties hereto
be renewed for a further term of ten years from the
expiration of the said term hereby granted unless the
lessee shall prior to the expiration of the last mentioned
term give to the lessors one calender month's previous
notice in writing of their intention not to take any
renewed lease. The renewed lease will be on the same
monthly rent/at the rate to be mutually agreed upon and
subject to the same covenants, conditions and
agreements as are herein contained including the
present covenant for renewal.”
***
***
***
14. One more important aspect that needs to be
noticed in the interpretation of the renewal clause is that
the words “to be renewed for a further term of ten years
from the expiration of the said term…” necessarily
contemplate a fresh lease agreement to be brought into
existence for the period subsequent to 31-7-1976. The
words “without any further act of any of the parties”
preceding the above words do not have the effect of
creating a valid lease agreement for the second term of
ten years without there being actually no document in
existence. The right of the party to have an agreement
executed is different from approximating that right to the
document itself coming into existence. The fresh
document as contemplated by the agreement, it is
uncontroversial, did not and could not materialise for the
reason that there was no mutuality with regard to the
rent to be paid for the said premises after 31-7-1976.
15. Yet another aspect that has a vital bearing on the
question is the fact that there was no agreement
between the IOC and the landlady either with regard to
the renewal period or the quantum of rent. On both the
aspects, no part of the evidence supports the case of
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
the IOC. Paragraph 5 of the written statement filed by
the IOC in O.S. No. 966 of 1982 (suit filed by the
landlady) admits to the fact that “there was no meeting
ground for settlement in regard to the execution of the
lease deed and the quantum of rent.” In the plaint filed
by the IOC in O.S. No. 1145 of 1981, the relief claimed
was for a direction to the landlady to execute a lease
deed for ten years from 1-8-1976 inclusive of the
“clause as to renewal”. It is, therefore, clear that there
was no agreement in law based upon which the IOC
could seek specific performance.
(emphasis added)
33.
In view of the above, we concur with the view of the learned
Commercial Court that IOCL's occupation of the suit premises,
after the expiry of the lease was unlawful and the lessors were
entitled to a decree of eviction.
34.
It is also relevant to note that the negotiations conducted by
IOCL were not confined to renewal for a period of five years only. It
is relevant to refer to the following extract from the evidence
affidavit furnished by DW-1.
“9. I state that the Defendant's Negotiation Committee
conducted several meetings with the landowners and
the negotiations were not successful on multiple
occasions. Landowners were not willing to increase the
lease period for more than 5 years as initially offered.
The Negotiation committee requested for a lease
period of minimum 15 years for further negotiate and
conclude rental terms.
10. I state that the Rental amount of Rs.1,33,000/- was
not a negotiated or concluded rental offer from this
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
defendant. The amount offered by this Defendants
negotiation committee as part of the Negotiation tends
to increase and Negotiations for renewal were
underway during this period.”
35.
It is clear from the above that the negotiation committee had
sought renewal for a period of 15 years and it also made an initial
offer of `1,33,000/- per month as also averred by the lessors in the
plaint and also mentioned therein in the notice dated 19.12.2023
(Exhibit P2). However, according to the lessors, the rental of the
premises was much higher, and they insisted on standing by the
last offer of `8,50,000/- per month, which worked out to be `59.44
per square foot.
36.
Insofar as the quantification of damages for occupation of the
premises after the termination of the lease is concerned, the
learned Commercial Court had rightly held that there is no
evidence to establish that market rate for the suit premises was as
claimed. The lessors had relied on the lease deed dated
01.02.2022 in respect of a property in the vicinity of the suit
premises. However, a plain reading of the lease deed (Exhibit P8)
indicates that it is a fully built up commercial property. Thus, the
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
lease rentals that are payable for the said property would not be
sufficient to establish the lease rentals for a vacant plot.
37.
In the aforesaid circumstances, it is evident that the rental
was determined on the basis of the agreed rentals as trued up for
the period after the expiry of the lease term.
38.
The learned Commercial Court had merely followed the
quantum of rentals stipulated under the lease deed (Exhibit P1).
The said lease deed stipulated a monthly rental of `71,500/- per
month to be increased by 15% every five years. Thus, the monthly
rental drawn for the last five years of the term of the lease was
`1,08,742.56/-. Applying 15% escalation as provided under the
lease deed for the period beyond the term of the lease would work
out to `1,25,053.30/- per month which was directed to be paid by
the learned Commercial Court. Since the damages as assessed
essentially draw support from the rate of escalation as agreed
under the lease deed between the parties, no further evidence, in
our view, would be required to grant damages at that rate.
39.
In view of the above, we find no grounds to interfere with the
impugned judgment and decree.
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48190-DB
COMAP No. 591 of 2025
C/W COMAP No. 597 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010717382025
40.
The present appeals are accordingly dismissed.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(K.S. HEMALEKHA)
JUDGE
KPS
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review