Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 8TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 2179 OF 2011 (SP)
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI. SUBHASHCHANDRA
S/O LATE DODDA SONNAPPA
FOSTERED SON OF NARAYANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 53 YRS
R/A CHEEMACHANAHALLI VILLAGE
CHANNARAYAPATNA HOBLI, DEVANAHALLI TALUK
BANGALORE RURAL DIST.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. K.N. NITHISH, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. K.V. NARASIMHAN, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SRI. NARAYANAPPA
S/O LATE MUNICHANNAPPA
SINCE DEAD BY LRs
1(A) SMT. ASHWATHAMMA
W/O K. NARAYANASWAMY
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
R/AT HIRIGENAHALLI
CHANNARAYAPATNA HOBLI AND POST
DEVANAHALLI TALUK, BENGALURU RURAL DIST.
2.
SRI MARAPPA
S/O LATE THAMMANNA
AGED ABOUT 60 YRS
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
3.
SMT. B.K. CHANDRAMMA
AGED ABOUT 30 YRS
4.
SRI. C.M. RAJANNA
AGED ABOUT 25 YRS
ALL ARE R/A CHEEMACHANAHALLI VILLAGE
CHANNARAYAPATNA HOBLI
DEVANAHALLI TALUK
BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. A. KESHAVA BHAT, ADVOCATE FOR R1(A);
SRI. K. SHIVASHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2 TO R4)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SEC.100 R/W ORDER 42
RULES (1) AND (2) OF CPC., AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE DATED 12.7.2011 PASSED IN R.A.NO.144/2010 ON
THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE, BANGALORE
RURAL DISTRICT, BANGALORE, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND
CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 23.6.2010
PASSED IN O.S.NO.224/2006 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE & JMFC., DEVANAHALLI.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is by the unsuccessful plaintiff
questioning the concurrent judgments rendered by the
Courts
below
declining
to
grant
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
relief
of
specific
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
performance of contract based on agreement of sale dated
05.07.2000.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their rank before the trial Court.
3.
Facts leading to the case are as under:
The
plaintiff
instituted
the
suit
for
specific
performance of contract contending that defendant No.1,
who is his foster father, had executed an agreement of
sale dated 05.07.2000 agreeing to sell the suit schedule
property for a sale consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. It is the
specific
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
the
entire
sale
consideration was paid in cash to defendant No.1 on the
very date of execution of the agreement in the presence of
witnesses and that, pursuant to the said agreement,
possession of the suit schedule property was delivered to
him. The plaintiff further contended that defendant No.1
had agreed to execute a registered sale deed within one
year from the date of the agreement. According to the
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
plaintiff, notwithstanding repeated requests and demands
made by him, defendant No.1 failed to conclude the
transaction, compelling him to institute the present suit for
specific performance.
4.
Defendant No.1, on service of notice, entered
appearance and filed his written statement stoutly denying
the entire case set up by the plaintiff. Defendant No.1
specifically denied having executed any agreement of sale
in favour of the plaintiff and consequently denied receipt of
the alleged sale consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. On the
contrary, defendant No.1 contended that he had already
alienated the suit schedule properties in favour of one
Marappa under a registered sale deed dated 03.12.1999.
He further contended that certain other properties had
been alienated in favour of B.K. Chandramma under
registered sale deeds dated 18.06.2000 and 09.10.2000.
Defendant No.1 asserted that he had alienated all the
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
properties and was residing at his daughter’s house at
Heraganahalli Village.
5.
Defendant Nos.2 to 4, who claim title to the
properties through defendant No.1, also filed their written
statement denying the plaint averments in toto. They
contended that they had purchased the properties for
valuable consideration and had been put in peaceful
possession thereof much prior to the alleged agreement of
sale dated 05.07.2000 set up by the plaintiff.
6.
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the learned
Trial Court framed the necessary issues and permitted the
parties to lead oral and documentary evidence. Upon
appreciation of the evidence, particularly the evidence of
the attesting witnesses to the alleged agreement of sale
marked as Ex.P-1, and also taking note of the earlier
partition suit instituted by the plaintiff in O.S.No.70/1999,
the learned Trial Court answered Issue No.1 in the
negative. The Trial Court held that the plaintiff had failed
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
to establish due execution of the alleged agreement of sale
and, equally, had failed to prove payment of the entire
sale consideration of Rs.1,00,000/- on 05.07.2000. While
answering Issue No.2 in the affirmative, the Trial Court
held that defendant Nos.2 to 4 had acquired valid right
and title to the suit properties pursuant to the registered
sale deeds executed in their favour by defendant No.1.
The Trial Court also recorded a categorical finding that the
plaintiff was not in possession of the suit schedule
properties. Consequently, the suit came to be dismissed.
7.
in
Aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed
O.S.No.224/2006,
the
plaintiff
preferred
R.A.No.144/2010. The learned First Appellate Court, upon
an
independent
re-appreciation
of
the
oral
and
documentary evidence, recorded a categorical finding that
the alleged agreement of sale had not been satisfactorily
established by the plaintiff. The Appellate Court also took
note of the fact that the plaintiff had earlier instituted a
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
suit for partition against defendant No.1 claiming a share
in the properties on the premise that he was the foster son
of defendant No.1. Having regard to the failure of the said
claim, the Appellate Court found significance in the
subsequent plea that, during the pendency of the partition
suit, the dispute was amicably resolved in the presence of
panchayatdars and that defendant No.1 thereafter agreed
to sell the property to the plaintiff upon receipt of the
entire sale consideration. The Appellate Court found that
this version was not corroborated by any independent
evidence. It also noticed that the alleged payment of the
entire sale consideration was not established and that
there was no satisfactory evidence to demonstrate that
Siddappa had paid the sum of Rs.1,00,000/- to defendant
No.1. On these findings, the Appellate Court concurred
with the reasons assigned by the Trial Court and dismissed
the appeal. These concurrent findings are assailed in the
present second appeal.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
8.
The present second appeal was instituted in the
year 2011 and has remained pending for nearly sixteen
years.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff has
advanced
elaborate
submissions
contending
that
defendant Nos.2 to 4 obtained the sale deeds at a point of
time when a status quo order was operating in the earlier
partition suit. It is further contended that the nature and
tenor
of
the
cross-examination
defendants,
according
to
substantial
support
the
to
the
conducted
learned
plaintiff’s
by
the
counsel,
lend
case
regarding
payment of the entire sale consideration under the
agreement dated 05.07.2000. It is therefore urged that
the concurrent findings recorded by the Courts below
warrant interference in the present second appeal.
10.
Per
contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
defendant Nos.2 to 4 would contend that the conduct of
the plaintiff, when examined in the backdrop of the earlier
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
partition proceedings and the subsequent suit for specific
performance, creates a
serious
doubt
regarding
the
genuineness of the alleged transaction. Learned counsel
would submit that both the Courts have examined the
evidence of the attesting witnesses in detail and, upon
such appreciation, have concurrently concluded that the
plaintiff failed to establish the execution of the alleged
agreement as well as payment of the sale consideration. It
is therefore contended that no substantial question of law
arises for consideration.
11.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties
and having perused the records, this Court has given its
anxious consideration to the concurrent findings recorded
by the Courts below.
12.
The records disclose that the plaintiff had
initially instituted O.S.No.70/1999 seeking partition and
separate
possession
against
defendant
No.1
on
the
premise that he was the foster son of defendant No.1 and
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
was consequently entitled to a share in the properties. The
said suit was pending consideration when the plaintiff
instituted the subsequent suit for specific performance in
O.S.No.224/2006.
Significantly,
the
suit
for
specific
performance was instituted on 03.10.2001. However, the
plaint in the subsequent suit does not disclose the
pendency of the earlier partition proceedings. It was only
in the year 2009, by way of amendment, that paragraph
4A came to be incorporated in the plaint and the factual
background relating to the earlier partition suit was
brought on record.
13.
In
the
backdrop
of
these
undisputed
and
significant circumstances, the question that falls for
consideration is whether the concurrent finding recorded
by the Courts below on Issue No.1, namely, that the
plaintiff failed to prove the alleged agreement of sale, is so
perverse or contrary to the evidence on record as to give
rise
to
a
substantial
question
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
of
law
warranting
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
interference under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.
14.
The material on record discloses that defendant
No.1 had alienated the suit schedule properties covered
under the alleged agreement of sale even prior to the
institution
of
03.10.2001.
the
suit
for
The
plaintiff
specific
seeks
to
performance
on
overcome
this
circumstance by relying upon the recitals in the alleged
agreement, according to which, during the pendency of
the
earlier
partition
proceedings,
a
panchayat
was
convened and, pursuant to deliberations held in the
presence of the panchayatdars, defendant No.1 agreed to
sell the property to the plaintiff. The plaintiff further
asserts that the entire sale consideration was paid on the
date of execution of the agreement.
15.
The
alleged
payment
of
the
entire
sale
consideration assumes considerable significance, since it
bears directly upon the genuineness of the transaction
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
itself. The plaintiff and defendant No.1 were admittedly
litigating against
proceedings.
each other in the earlier partition
Their
relationship,
therefore,
cannot
be
viewed in isolation from the pending dispute. If, during the
pendency of such proceedings, the parties had in fact
arrived at an amicable settlement through the intervention
of panchayatdars and defendant No.1 had thereafter
agreed to sell the property to the plaintiff upon receipt of
the entire sale consideration, the persons who allegedly
facilitated such settlement would have been natural and
material witnesses.
16.
Yet, none of the panchayatdars has been
examined by the plaintiff. More importantly, the plaintiff
examined both the attesting witnesses to the alleged
agreement. The evidence of these witnesses, however,
does not advance the plaintiff’s case. On the contrary,
both witnesses have made material admissions in crossexamination
which
indicate
that
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
the
entire
sale
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
consideration was not paid on the date on which the
alleged agreement was prepared and executed. These
admissions go to the root of the plaintiff’s case. The
specific assertion in the plaint that the entire sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- was paid to defendant No.1 on 05.07.2000
stands materially contradicted by the evidence of the very
witnesses relied upon by the plaintiff to establish the
transaction.
17.
The conduct of the plaintiff assumes further
significance
when
considered
in
its
chronological
perspective. The plaintiff initially instituted a suit for
partition claiming a right in the properties on the footing
that he was the foster son of defendant No.1. Thereafter,
during the pendency of the dispute, he set up the alleged
agreement of sale dated 05.07.2000 and instituted a
separate
suit
for
specific
performance.
In
such
circumstances, the burden resting upon the plaintiff to
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
establish the genuineness of the subsequent transaction
necessarily assumes significance.
18.
The
plaintiff’s
case
is
that
the
alleged
transaction was the result of a settlement arrived at
through
the
intervention
of
panchayatdars.
Those
panchayatdars were therefore material witnesses to the
genesis of the alleged agreement. Their non-examination
remains unexplained. Equally significant is the failure to
examine Siddappa, through whom the plaintiff claims to
have established payment of the entire sale consideration
to
defendant
No.1.
The
absence
of
these
material
witnesses, coupled with the admissions elicited from PW.2
and
PW.3
regarding
payment
of
the
consideration,
materially weakens the plaintiff’s case.
19.
There
is
yet
another
circumstance
which
assumes significance. The plaintiff claims that possession
of the suit schedule property was delivered to him
pursuant
to
the
alleged
agreement.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
However,
the
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
registered sale deeds under which defendant Nos.2 to 4
claim title contain recitals inconsistent with the plaintiff’s
assertion of possession. The Courts below have, therefore,
rightly found that the plaintiff failed to establish that
possession was delivered to him pursuant to the alleged
agreement of sale.
20.
When
cumulatively,
the
this
entire
Court
finds
evidence
no
is
examined
perversity
in
the
conclusion reached by the Trial Court and affirmed by the
First Appellate Court. Both Courts have concurrently found
that the plaintiff failed to prove the alleged agreement of
sale. Such conclusion is founded upon the appreciation of
oral and documentary evidence and, in particular, upon
the material admissions elicited from the plaintiff’s own
witnesses.
The
Courts
below
have
also
taken
into
consideration the earlier partition suit instituted by the
plaintiff, its subsequent dismissal for non-prosecution, and
the fact that the subsequent suit for specific performance
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
did not initially disclose the pendency of the earlier
proceedings.
21.
The subsequent incorporation of paragraph 4A
by way of amendment in the year 2009 does not, by itself,
efface the significance of the original omission. More
importantly, the question before the Court is not merely
whether the alleged agreement contains the signatures of
the parties, but whether the plaintiff has satisfactorily
established the transaction pleaded by him, including the
alleged settlement, payment of the entire consideration
and
delivery
of
possession.
On
appreciation
of
the
evidence, both Courts have found that these essential
circumstances have not been established.
22.
It is also well settled that the relief of specific
performance is discretionary and equitable in character.
Even where execution of an agreement is established, the
Court is required to examine the attendant circumstances
and the conduct of the parties before granting such relief.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48786
RSA No. 2179 of 2011
CNR: KAHC010826032011
In the present case, the Courts below, upon appreciation
of the entire material on record, have found the plaintiff’s
version
to
perversity,
be
unsubstantiated.
illegality
or
This
misapplication
Court
of
finds
the
no
settled
principles warranting interference with such concurrent
findings.
23.
In
view
of
the
foregoing
discussion,
the
concurrent findings recorded by the Courts below do not
suffer from perversity or any error of law giving rise to a
substantial question of law. No substantial question of law
arises for consideration in the present second appeal.
24.
Accordingly,
the
second
appeal
stands
dismissed. Parties shall bear their respective costs.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
CA
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 2
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review