Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 26TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
WRIT PETITION No. 36585 OF 2025 (S-KSAT)
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI SENDIL KUMAR P
S/O PERUMAL P
AGED 44 YEARS,
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU,
MADIVALA, BENGALURU
R/AT BLOCK C-1, FPB QUARTERS,
FSL COMPOUND, MADIVALA,
BENGALURU - 560 068.
2.
SRI MALLIKARJUNA SWAMY, H.R.
S/O RAMACHARI S.
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU,
FINGER PRINT UNIT,
KOTE POLICE STATION BUILDING,
1ST FLOOR, KOTE ROAD,
SHIVAMOGGA-577 202,
R/AT NO.33, “SHRI SADANA”
OKKALAKERI, 1ST CROSS,
NEAR SIDDESWARA GADDUGE, PURALE,
SHIVAMOGGA TOWN – 577 222.
NANJUNDACHARI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
3.
SRI SHIVANANDA K. RATHOD,
S/O KRISHNA,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
HEAD CONSTABLE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU, TUMAKURU
WORKING ON DEPUTATION AT FPB,
BELAGAVI
R/AT PWD QUARTERS, BLOCK-1/B
-2-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
VISHWESHWARAIAH NAGAR,
BELAGAVI- 590010.
4.
SRI MANJUNATH.S. TETAMBI,
S/O SURESH,
AGED 48 YEARS,
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU,
BALLARY UNIT, BALLARY,
R/AT POLICE GUEST HOUSE,
BRUCEPET POLICE STATION,
BALLARY-583101.
5.
SMT. JYOTHI DESAI,
W/O LAXMIKANTH DESAI,
AGED 46 YEARS,
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU, KALABURAGI,
R/AT KALLUR VILLAGE
TALUK: CHITTAPURA,
DIST: KALABURAGI-585101
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. T NARAYANASWAMY, ADV. FOR
SRI RUDRAPPA P., ADV.)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
HOME DEPARTMENT,
VIDHANA SOUDHA, 4TH FLOOR,
BENGALURU-560001.
2.
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL AND
INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE,
KARNATAKA STATE,
NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BENGALURU-560001.
3.
THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE,
CRIME AND TECHNICAL,
DG OFFICE COMPOUND
NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BENGALURU-560001.
4.
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE,
FINGER PRINT BUREAU,
-3-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
FSL COMPOUND, MADIVALA,
BENGALURU-560 068.
5.
SRI. M. MANJU,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE (FPB),
FINGER PRINT BUREAU POLICE UNIT,
DISTRICT POLICE OFFICE,
MANDYA - 571401.
6.
SRI. MALLIKARJUNAYYA PANCHAKSHARAIAH
AMBAYYANAMATHA,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE (FPB),
FINGER PRINT BUREAU POLICE UNIT.
DISTRICT POLICE OFFICE,
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT,
HOSPETE- 583201.
7.
SRI. MANTESH KALLAPPA BANAKAR.
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE (FPB),
FINGER PRINT BUREAU POLICE UNIT,
OFFICE OF COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
BENGALURU CITY, INFANTRY ROAD,
BENGALURU-560001.
8.
SRI. MALAGOUDA PHADIGOUDA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
WORKING AS HEAD CONSTABLE (FPB),
FINGER PRINT BUREAU POLICE UNIT,
DISTRICT POLICE OFFICE,
BELAGAVI DISTRICT, BELAGAVI-590001.
9.
SMT. PADMAVATHI S NANDIKOORA,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
WORKING AS POLICE SUB INSPECTOR (FPB)
FINGER PRINT BUREAU POLICE UNIT,
DISTRICT POLICE OFFICE,
KALABURGI DISTRICT,
KALABURAGI-585301.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VIKAS ROJIPURA, AGA FOR R1 TO R4
V/O/D 12.12.2025 NOTICE TO R5 TO R9 IS D/W)
THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO I) ISSUE WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO QUASH THE ORDER PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA
-4-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT BENGALURU DATED
09/06/2025 PASSED IN APPLICATION NOS. 4820-4824/2024 VIDE
ANNEXURE-A AS ERRONEOUS AND CONTRARY TO LAW, AND ALLOW
THE
APPLICATION
NOS.
4820-4824/2024
THEREIN;
II)
CONSEQUENTLY ISSUE WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH THE
IMPUGNED ENDORSEMENT BEARING NO.08/SIBBANDI/BE.MU.SAM/
2023-24 DATED 02/08/2024, ISSUED BY 4TH RESPONDENT VIDE
ANNEXURE-A16 AND ETC.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
ORDER ON 09.02.2026 COMING ON THIS DAY, S.G.PANDIT J.,
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
CAV ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT)
Petitioners, working as Head Constables in the Finger
Print Bureau (for short, ‘FPB’) of the second respondent
department
are
before
this
Court
questioning
the
correctness and legality of order dated 09.06.2025 in
Application
Nos.4820
to
4824/2024
passed
by
the
Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal at Bengaluru (for
short,
‘the
petitioners
Tribunal’),
to
quash
rejecting
the
endorsement
prayer
dated
of
the
02.08.2024
(Annexure-A16), rejecting the prayer of the petitioners to
count their earlier services from the date of appointment
-5-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
till they are transferred and absorbed in FPB and further
rejecting their prayer for a direction to the respondents to
count the services rendered by the petitioners in the
previous units prior to their permanent transfer to FPB unit
for the purpose of seniority and for issuance of revised
promotion order.
2.
In the present writ petition, I.A.No.1/2026 is
filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC read with Article 226 of
the Constitution of India seeking amendment of prayer to
include additional facts, grounds and additional prayer as
to hold that the Karnataka State Police including the
Ministerial Services (Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules,
(for
short, ‘2009
Rules’) published under
the
notification dated 28.05.2009 (Annexure-E) insofar as it
relates to entry in Column Nos.(5) and (6) of Sl.No.52
(Police Constable, FPB) as unconstitutional, ultravires and
void being in violation of Rule 6 of the Karnataka
Government Servants’ (Seniority) Rules, 1957 (for short,
‘1957 Rules’).
-6-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
3.
Brief facts of the case are that, the petitioners
were initially appointed as Police Constables in the year
2002 and 2001 in the District Armed Reserved Force
(DAR) and Karnataka State Reserved Police Force (KSRP).
While
they
were
working as Police Constables, it is
stated that the third respondent called options from the
Police Constables working in various units of the DAR as
well
as
KSRP
under
circular
dated
14.01.2015
(Annexure-A7) to fill up 36 vacant posts of Constables
at FPB of the third respondent. In pursuance to the
said circular, the petitioners submitted their irrevocable
options for transfer to FPB unit.
the
irrevocable
option,
(Annexure-A11),
the
by
On
consideration
of
order
dated
27.11.2015
petitioners
were
transferred
permanently as Police Constables to the FPB unit under
Rule
16A
of
the
Karnataka
Civil
Services
(General
Recruitment) Rules, 1977 (For short, ‘1977 Rules’) and in
terms of 2009 Rules. The petitioners, on their permanent
transfer joined duty at FPB unit. Subsequently, they were
placed in independent charge of the post of Head
-7-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
Constables under Rule 32 of the KCSRs. Thereafter, the
petitioners submitted individual representations. The first
petitioner submitted representation dated 20.06.2024,
requesting to count the past service of the petitioners from
the date of their appointment as Police Constables to the
date of their permanent transfer to the FPB unit for the
purpose of seniority in the FPB unit. Their request to count
the past service is rejected under impugned endorsement
dated 02.08.2024 (Annexure-A16).
4.
Questioning
the
said
endorsement,
the
petitioners were before the Tribunal in the above stated
application and under impugned order dated 09.06.2025
(Annexure-A), prayer of the petitioners is dismissed
holding that the petitioners on their own request have
been transferred to the FPB unit and relevant Cadre and
Recruitment Rules i.e., 2009 Rules would not permit
counting
of past
service. Questioning
the
impugned
endorsement and impugned order passed by the Tribunal,
the petitioners are before this Court.
-8-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
5.
When
the
matter
was
taken
up
for
final
disposal, learned counsel for the petitioners took time and
filed I.A.No.1/2026 for amendment to include challenge to
2009 Rules insofar as it relates to permanent transfer of
Police Constables to FPB unit at Sl.No.52.
6.
Heard learned counsel Sri.T.Narayanaswamy for
Sri.P.Rudrappa,
learned
learned
Additional
counsel
Government
for
petitioners
Advocate
and
Sri.Vikas
Rojipura for respondent Nos.1 to 4. Perused the entire writ
petition papers.
7.
Learned
counsel
Sri.T.Narayanaswamy
for
petitioners would submit that the petitioners were initially
recruited and appointed as Police Constables in the year
2002 and 2001 to the DAR as well as KSRP. When the
options were called for permanent transfer of Police
Constables
working
in
various
units
of
the
Police
Department to the FPB units, the petitioners were under
the impression that when the options are called by the
department, it would be under the public interest and their
-9-
WP No. 36585 of 2025
services would be transferred to FPB unit and hence, they
submitted their option for permanent transfer to the FPB
unit. Further, learned counsel would contend that the
petitioners were not aware of the Rule under which
permanent transfer would take place and he vehemently
contends that 2009 Rules was not made available in public
domain. As such, petitioners were not aware of the Rules
which would not permit earlier service to be counted when
their services would be transferred permanently to the FPB
unit.
8.
Further, learned counsel Sri.T.Narayanaswamy
would submit that the persons who were permanently
transferred previously to FPB unit were given benefit of
counting their past service and only in the case of
petitioners, past service is not being counted, which is
discriminatory. Learned counsel would submit that when
the options are called and Police Constables working in
various units are transferred permanently to FPB unit, it
would
be
in
the
public
interest
and
under
such
- 10 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
circumstances, when the transfer is in public interest, such
transferee would be entitled for counting his past service.
9.
Learned counsel referring to Rule 6 of 1957
Rules would submit that non-counting of past service of
the petitioners is contrary to Rule 6 of 1957 Rules which
permits counting of past service, if it is in public interest.
Learned counsel would also submit that 2009 Rules was
neither in the public domain nor was it produced by the
State before the Tribunal. As such, petitioners were not in
a position to challenge the same. Further, it is submitted
that obtaining such undertaking to forego the past service
would amount to an unconscionable contract and the
petitioners were forced to sign the undertaking to forego
past service while effecting permanent transfer to FPB
unit.
10.
On
the
other
hand,
learned
Additional
Government Advocate Sri.Vikas Rojipura would invite
attention
of
this
Court
to
the
order
of
the
permanent transfer of the petitioners dated 27.11.2015
- 11 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
(Annexure-A11) and submits that one of the condition of
transfer was that their seniority would be fixed in the
transferred FPB unit below the serving Police Constables in
the
FPB
unit.
Having
accepted
the
said
condition,
subsequently the petitioners cannot turn around and
contend that they were not aware of such condition.
Further, learned Additional Government Advocate would
submit that having failed to challenge the Rules before the
Tribunal, they cannot be permitted to challenge the Rules
before this Court in this writ petition, that too, after more
than ten years of their permanent transfer to the FPB unit.
Learned Additional Government Advocate would place
reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of INDU SHEKHAR SINGH AND OTHERS VS.
STATE OF U.P., AND OTHERS1 to contend that once
having obtained entry into the FPB unit on the basis of the
above option/election, they cannot be allowed to turn
around and contend that the conditions are illegal. Thus,
he would pray for dismissing the writ petition.
(2006) 8 SCC 129
- 12 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
11.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties and on perusal of the entire writ petition
papers, the following points would arise for consideration:
i)
In the facts and circumstances of the case, whether
the petitioners would be entitled for counting their
past service on their permanent transfer to the FPB
unit?
ii)
Whether the petitioners have made out any grounds
to interfere with the impugned order passed by the
Tribunal?
12.
Answer to the above would be in the negative
for the following reasons:
The petitioners were initially recruited and appointed
as Police Constables in the DAR and KSRP in the year 2002
and one of the petitioner in the year 2001. While the
petitioners were working as Police Constables, by Circular
dated 14.01.2015 of the fourth respondent, options were
invited from the Police Constables working in various units
for transfer to the FPB unit on permanent transfer basis of
those who possess PUC or equivalent qualification after
obtaining an irrevocable option for such transfer. The
- 13 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
method of filling up of post of Police Constables in the FPB
unit is by transfer of a Civil or Armed Police Constables of
any wing of the Police who have passed PUC or possesses
equivalent qualification after obtaining an irrevocable
option for such transfer. The Cadre and Recruitment Rules
makes it clear that seniority of such Police Constables on
transfer shall be fixed below the Police Constables who are
in the cadre in the FPB unit. It also states that, if there are
no suitable persons available for transfer, then by direct
recruitment. Relevant Cadre and Recruitment Rules reads
as follows:
“(g) in the entries relating to the category of
posts of Police Constable (FPB) at serial number 52,
for the entries in columns No (5) and (6), the
following shall be substituted, namely:By transfer of Civil or Armed Police Constables
of any wing of the Police who have passed PUC or
possesses equivalent qualification after obtaining an
irrevocable option for such transfer.
Seniority of such police constables on transfer
shall be fixed below the police constable who is in
the cadre in the FPB Unit.
- 14 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
If there are no suitable persons available for
transfer, by direct recruitment as follows:Ninety percent by direct recruitment of male
candidates and Ten percent by direct recruitment of
female candidates.”
The above Cadre and Recruitment Rules is clear with
regard to seniority of Police Constables on permanent
transfer to FPB Unit. A Police Constable on permanent
transfer either from DAR, KSRP or any other unit of police
to FPB unit would loose his earlier service and would be
placed below the Police Constable working already in FPB
unit.
13.
The petitioners were aware of the Rules and
with their eyes open, they submitted their option and on
transfer, they reported at FPB unit. Even in their option
form, each one of the Constables have submitted their
irrevocable option by undertaking to forego the seniority
and agreeing to be placed below the Constables who are
already in FPB unit on the date of appointment by transfer.
- 15 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
The relevant Option Form of the fourth petitioner reads as
follows:
“ANNEXURE-A
Sl.
No.
Name of the post
(FPB)
2004 Rules
By permanent absorption of Police
Constable who have completed PUC or
equivalent qualification, after obtaining
Police Constable (FPB) their willingness and ascertaining their
suitability. If there are no suitable
persons available for transfer then by
direct recruitment.
ANNEXURE-B
Sl.
No.
Name of the post
(FPB)
2009 Rules
By transfer of Civil or Armed Police
Constable of any wing of the Police
who have passed PUC or possesses
equivalent qualification after obtaining
an irrevocable option for such transfer.
Seniority of such Police Constable on
transfer shall be fixed below the Police
Police Constable (FPB) Constable who is in the cadre in the
FPB unit. If there are no suitable
persons available for transfer by direct
recruitment as follows:Ninety percent by direct recruitment of
male candidates and ten percent by
direct
recruitment
of
female
candidates.
ANNEXURE-C
OPTION
1.
I hereby express irrevocable option for being
appointed as PC, FPB by transfer.
2.
On being appointed by such transfer I am
prepared for fixing my seniority before the
- 16 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
Constable who is in the cadre of FPB unit on
the date of appointment by transfer.
vÀªÀÄä «±Áé¹,
(JªÀiï.J¸ï.mÉÃlA©)
¦.¹-250,
¨ÉgÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀÄÄzÉæ WÀlPÀ, zsÁgÀªÁqÀ.”
The petitioners have agreed to be placed below the
Constables working in FPB unit on the date of appointment
by transfer. Furthermore, the order dated 27.11.2015 by
which, the petitioners were transferred permanently under
Rule 16A of 1977 Rules to the FPB unit was with a
condition that in the seniority list of Police Constables,
petitioners’ seniority would be fixed below the Police
Constables already working in the FPB unit.
14.
The condition incorporated in the order of
permanent transfer dated 27.11.2015 reads as follows:
“ªÉÄîÌAqÀAvÉ PÀæªÀÄ ¸ÀA: 01 jAzÀ 20 gÀªÀgÉV£À
¥Éǰøï
PÁ£ïìmÉç¯ïgÀªÀgÀÄUÀ¼À
PÀæªÀĪÁV
CªÀgÀÄ
vÀªÀÄä
¸ÉêÁ
»A¢£À
£ÉêÀÄPÀUÉÆAqÀ
¢£ÁAPÀUÀ¼À
¤zsÀðj¸ÀĪÀÅzÀÄ
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
ªÀUÁðªÀuÉUÉÆAqÀ
¨ÉgÀ¼ÀÄ
eÉõÀ×vÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
DAiÀiÁ
WÀlPÀUÀ¼À°è
eÉõÀ×vÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
DzsÀj¹
EªÀgÀÄUÀ¼À
¸ÉêÁ
eÉõÀ×vÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
ªÀÄÄzÉæ
WÀlPÀUÀ¼À°è
FUÁUÀ¯ÉÃ
- 17 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
PÀvÀðªÀå ¤ªÀð»¸ÀÄwÛgÀĪÀ ¥Éǰøï PÁ£ïì mÉç¯ï gÀªÀgÀÄUÀ¼À
eÉõÀ×vÉAiÀÄ PɼÀUÉ ¥ÀjUÀt¸À®Ä ¸ÀÆa¹zÉ.”
Therefore, it is not open for the petitioners to contend that
they were not aware of the said position of placing them
below the Police Constables already working in FPB Unit on
their permanent transfer to FPB Unit. The Cadre and
Recruitment Rules and condition incorporated in the order
of permanent transfer dated 27.11.2015 also make it clear
with regard to their seniority i.e., to place the petitioners
below the Constables already working in FPB unit.
15.
In the above circumstances, the petitioners’
contention that they were not aware of the Cadre and
Recruitment Rules or to forego their service rendered as
Police Constables prior to their permanent transfer cannot
be believed or accepted.
16.
The
decision
in
INDU
SHEKHAR
SINGH
(supra) makes it clear that when one exercises his option
or election for transfer, it is for him to accept or not to
accept. Having accepted with a condition that they would
- 18 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
forego seniority and being agreeable to be placed below
the Police Constables already working in FPB unit, it is not
open for the petitioners to turn around and question the
same after more than ten years. Relevant paragraphs 25
and 26 of the said decision reads as follows:
“25. The State was making an offer to the
respondents not in terms of any specific power
under the Rules, but in exercise of its residuary
power (assuming that the same was available). The
State, therefore, was within its right to impose
conditions. The respondents exercised their right of
election. They could have accepted the said offer or
rejected the same. While making the said offer, the
State categorically stated that for the purpose of
fixation of seniority, they would not be obtaining
the benefits of services rendered in the U.P. Jal
Nigam and would be placed below in the cadre till
the date of absorption. The submission of Mr Verma
that the period for which they were with the
Authority by way of deputation, should have been
considered towards seniority cannot be accepted
simply for the reason that till they were absorbed,
they continued to be in the employment of the Jal
Nigam. Furthermore, the said condition imposed is
backed by another condition that the deputed
employee who is seeking for absorption shall be
placed below the officers appointed in the cadre till
- 19 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
the
date
of
absorption.
Respondents
to
accepted the said offer without any demur on 3-91987, 28-11-1991 and 6-4-1987 respectively.
26.
They, therefore, exercised their right of
option. Once they obtained entry on the basis of
election, they cannot be allowed to turn round and
contend that the conditions are illegal. (See R.N.
Gosain v. Yashpal
Dhir [(1992)
SCC
683]
, Ramankutty Guptan v. Avara [(1994) 2 SCC 642]
and Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar [(2003) 2 SCC
721 : 2003 SCC (L&S) 200] .) Furthermore, there is
no fundamental right in regard to the counting of
the services rendered in an autonomous body. The
past services can be taken into consideration only
when the Rules permit the same or where a special
situation exists, which would entitle the employee
to obtain such benefit of past service.”
17.
The petitioners have filed I.A.No.1/2026 for
amendment to challenge relevant portion of the Rule.
Admittedly, the said Rule is not challenged before the
Tribunal, which is the Court of first instance. Having not
challenged the Rule before the Tribunal and having
suffered an order before the Tribunal, that too, after more
than ten years from the date of permanent transfer to FPB
- 20 -
WP No. 36585 of 2025
Unit, it is not open for the petitioners to challenge the Rule
under which they were permanently transferred to FPB
unit. Therefore, I.A.No.1/2026 stands rejected.
18.
For the reasons recorded above, we do not find
any infirmities in the order passed by the Tribunal and on
the other hand, when the petitioners have consented or
opted to forego earlier seniority, Rule 6 of 1957 Rules
would have no application. There is no merit in the writ
petition and accordingly stands dismissed.
Sd/(S.G.PANDIT)
JUDGE
Sd/(K. V. ARAVIND)
JUDGE
NC
CT:bms
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review