Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
134421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
wRt T PETITION NO: 34039 OF 2025
Between:
SRI SATYA SAI RICE CORPORATION, Rep. by its Partner Sri Challa Lakshmi
Naryana S/o Venkaiah, aged about 53 years, Rio H.No.247, KLR Avenue,
Komarabanda, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana State.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. STATE OF TELENGANA, Rep by its Principal Secretary, Cooperative Societies,
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Secretariat Building, Saifabad, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
2. THE CHIEF MANAGER, State Bank Of lndia, G.P Complex (Old Address) Now
shifted to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad Suryapeta District, Telangana State 508206.
3. THE BRANCH MANAGER, State Bank Of lndia, G.P Complex (Old Address)
Now shifted to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad Suryapeta District, Telangana State 508206.
4. SRI KESA VENKATESWARLU, S/o Pullaiah, aged about 64 years, Occ'
Business, Rio H.No. 12-14, Karalmarks Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana
State.
5. SRI KOTHA NAGESWARA RAO, S/o Sundara Bapaiah, aged about 69 years,
Occ. Business, Rl/o H.No.11-14112, Azad Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist,
Telangana State.
6. SRI MUKKAVENU GOPALA RAO, S/o Ramalingaiah, aged about 58 years, Occ'
Business, R/o H.No.1-261812, Main Road, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana
State.
7. SRI KANDIBANDA UPEADER, S/o.Rangaiah, aged about 56 years, Occ'
Business, Rl/o. H No. 12-142, Karalmarks Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist,
Telangana State.
8. SRI VUTUKURI NAGESWARA RAO, S/o.Ramatingaiah, aged about 66 years,
Occ. Business, R/o. H.No.3-107, Narayanagudem (V), Munagala (M), Suryapet
Dist, Telangana State.
9. SRI KAJA MURALI KRISHNA, S/o.Venkateswara Rao, aged about 42 years,
Occ.Business, Rl/o. H No. 12-1431112, Srinivasa Nagar, Kodad, SuryapeiDist.,
Telangana State.
10.SRl GOLLA SHANKAR RAO, S/o.Satyanarayana, aged about 53 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o. 1-2211412, Chaitanya Colony, Huzurnagar, SuryapetDist.,
Telangana State.
11.SRl MUCHERLA NAGARAJU, S/o Satyanarayana, aged about 42 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o. 4-11, Mittugudem(V), Vepalasingavaram, Huzurnagar(M),
Suryapet Dist., Telangana State.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to
issue a writ of Mandamus, declaring the acfion of the Respondents 2 and 3 in
disbursing the funds exclusively in favour of the respondents .4. 9 and 10 pending
representation dated 1-11-2025 acknowledged at 3-55 p.M. as illegal, arbitrary, unjust,
and clear violation of the banking, Regulation act, 1949 and consequently direct the
respondents 2 and 3 to continue the freezer of the cunent Account No. 521630g7479 of
the petitioner, as per the interim orders granted in l.A-No. 1 of 2o2s in w.p.No. 34039 of
2025 dl. 1 1-1 1-2025 by this Hon'ble court and pass such and pass such other order or
orders as this Hon'ble court deems just and proper the circumstances of the case.
Prayer amended as per C.O.dI.O5.O3.2O26 in lA No.212026.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under section I 51 cpc praying that in the circunrstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the
Respondent No. 2 and 3 to continue the holding of the operation of petitioner
corporation cunent Account No. 52163097479 and including the Secured Documents
of Petitioner Corporation.
l.A. NO:2OF 2025
Between:
1. SRI KESA VENKATESWARLU, S/o Pullaiah, aged about 64 years, Occ.
Business, Rio H.No. 12-14, Karalmarks Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana
State.
2. SRI KOTHA NAGESWARA RAO, S/o Sundara Bapaiah, aged about 69 years,
Occ. Business, Rl/o H.No.11-14112, Azad Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist.,
Telangana State.
3. SRI MUKKAVENU GOPALA RAO, S/o Ramalingaiah, aged about 58 years, Occ.
Business, FUo H.No.1-261812, Main Road, Kodad, Suryapet Dist.' Telangana
State.
4. SRI KANDIBANDA UPEADER, S/o.Rangaiah, aged about 56 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o. H No. 12-142, Karalmarks Nagar, Kodad, Suryapet Dist.,
Telangana State.
5. SRI VUTUKURI NAGESWARA RAO, S/o.Ramalingaiah, aged about 66 years,
Occ. Business, Rl/o. H.No.3-107, Narayanagudem (V), Munagala (M)' Suryapet
Dist, Telangana State.
6. SRI KAJA MURALI KRISHNA, S/o.Venkateswara Rao, aged about 42 years,
Occ.Business, Rl/o. H No. 12-1431112, Srinivasa Nagar, Kodad, SuryapetDist.,
Telangana State.
7. SRI GOLLA SHANKAR RAO, S/o.Satyananyana, aged about 53 years, Occ.
Business, No. 1-2211412, Chaitanya Colony, Huzurnagar, SuryapetDist.,
Telangana State.
8. SRI MUCHERLA NAGARAJU, S/o Satyanarayana, aged aboul 42 years, Occ.
Business, Fl/o. 4-11, Miftugudem(V), Vepalasingavaram, Huzumaga(M),
Suryapet Dist-, Telangana State.
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENTS
AND
1. SRI SATYA SAI RICE CORPORATION, Rep. by its Partner Sri Challa Lakshmi
Naryana S/o Venkaiah, aged about 53 years, Rio H.No.247, KLR Avenue,
Komarabanda, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana State.
... RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER
2. STATE OF TELENGANA, Rep by its Principal Secretary, Cooperative Societies,
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Secretariat Building, Saifabad, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
THE CHIEF MANAGER, State Bank Of tndia, G.p Compler (Old Address) Now
shifted to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad Suryapeta Diskict, Telangana Siate 508206.
THE BRANCH MANAGER, State Bank Of tndia, G.p Corptex (Otd Address)
N-ow shifted to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad Suryapeta District, Telangana State -
508206.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to vacate the
lnterim Orders passed in WP.No.34039 of 202 dated 11.11.2025.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Between:
challa Narsimha Rao, s/o.Late Venkaiah, Aged about 55 years, occ: Business,
(commissioner Agent), Ryo.2-56, Bethavore, chiikur Mandar, Suryapet District.
...PET|T|ONERy|MPL. P-12
AND
1. sRl SATYA sAt RtcE coRpoRATtoN, Rep. by its partner sri chaila Lakshmi
Naryana S/o Venkaiah, aged about 53 years, Rio H.No.247, KLR Avenue,
Komarabanda, Kodad, Suryapet Dist., Telangana State.
... RESPONOENTS/PETITIONER
2. srATE oF TELENGANA, Rep by its principar Secretary, cooperative societies,
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar secretariat Buirding, saifabad, Hydeiabad, Terangana state.
3. THE cHIEF MANAGER, state Bank of rndia, G.p comprex (ord Address) Now
1!rlt-ed to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad suryapeta District. ierangana siate 508206.
THE BRANCH MANAGER, State Bank Of tndia, G.p Ccmptex (Otd Address)
N^ow
to Ananthagiri Road, Kodad suryapeta Distri,rt, Terangana state I
-shifted
508206.
SRI
pullaiah,
KESA VENKATESWARLU, S/o
aged about 64 years, Occ.
Business, Rio H.No. 12-14, Karalmarks Nagar, Kodat, Suryapet Dist., Telangana
State.
SRI KOTHA NAGESWARA
S/i Sundara Bapaiah, aged about 69 years,
Occ. Business, Fl/o H.No.iT19,
1-14112, Azad Nagar, Koclid, Suryapet 'Oist.,
Telangana State.
T.SRIMUKKAVENUGOPALARAO,S/oRamalingaiah,agedabout5Syears,Occ
Business, Rl/o H.No.1-261812, Main Road, Kodad, Suryapet Dist'' Telangana
State.
8. SRI KANDIBANDA UPEADER, S/o.Rangaiah' aged about 56 years, Occ'
Business,Fl/o.HNo-12-142,KaralmarksNagar,Kodad,SuryapetDist'
Telangana State.
g.SRIVUTUKURINAGESWARARAo,S/o.Ramalingaiah,agedabout66years'
Occ. Business, F|/o. H .No. 3-107, Narayanagudem (V), Munagala (M), Suryapet
Dist, Telangana State.
Rao, aged about 42 years,
1 O. SRI KAJA MURALI KRISHNA, S/o.Venkateswara
Occ.Business, Fi/o. H No. 12-14311t2, Srinivasa Nagar, Kodad, SuryapetDist''
Telangana State.
11.SRl GOLLA SHANKAR RAO, S/o.Satyanaruyana, aged about 53 years' -Occ'
Business, No. l-22ll4l2, Chaitanya Colony, Huzurnagar, SuryapetDist '
Telangana State.
I2.SRlMUCHERLANAGARAJU,S/oSatyanarayana,agedabout42years'Orcc'
Business,Rl/o.4-ll,Mittugudem(V),Vepalasingavaram,Huzurnagar(M)'
Suryapet Dist., Telangana State.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
in the
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
permit challa
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
Narsimha Rao s/o. Late Venkaiah Aged about 55 years, occ- Business
(commission
Agent)FUo2-56,Bethavole,ChilkurMandal,suryapetdistricttoimpleadasRespondent
No.'12 in writ petition No. 34039 of 2025 and also in l'As'
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI GANESH BHUJANGA RAO VADDURI
Counsel for the Respondents No.l : SRI MOHAN REDDY'
GP FOR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES
.
Counsel for the Respondents No.2&3 : SRI G'PRABHAKAR SARMA
Counsel forthe Respondents No.4TO11 : SRI S'CHANDRA MOHAN REDDY
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
WRIT PETITION No.34039 of 2025
I3th DAY OF JULY,2026
Between:
Sri Satya Sai Rice Corporation
,. . Petitioner
AND
The State ofTelangana and l0 others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Sri Ganesh Bhujanga Rao Vadduri, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Sri Mohan Reddy,, learned Govemment Pleader for Cooperative
Societies fbr respondent No. l, Sri G. Prabhakar Sarma, Ieamed counsel for
respondent Nos.2 and 3 and Sri S. Chandra Mohan Reddy. learned counsel
for respondent Nos.4 to I L Perused the entire record
2.
'f he rvrit petition
is f-rled with the following praver:
"...to issue a Writ of Mandarnus. declaring the action of the
Respondents 2 and 3 in disbursing the lunds exclusively in favour of
the rcspondents 4. 9 and l0 pending representation dated 1-11-2025
acknorvlcdged at 3-55 P.M. as illegal, arbitrary. unjust, and clear
violation of the banking Regulation act. 1949 and conse<luently direct
the respondenls 2 and 3 to continue the freezer of the current Account
No.521630872179 of the petitioner. as per the interim orcer granted in
I.A.No.l of 2025 in W.P.No.34039 of 2025 dr.
t-2025 bv this
Hon'ble Court and pass such other order or orders..."
ll-l
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
Case of the oetitioner:-
3.
The petitioner is apartnership firm by name M/s. Sri Satya Sai Rice
Corporation represented its partner Sri Chatla Lakshmi Narayana
(hereinafter referred to as 'deponent'), who is deponent herein. The said
firm is registered on the rolls of Registrar of Firms vide registration
No.46l2000. Said firm was instituted in the year 2000 with the deponent
and other partners. Said firm is engaged in the business of dealing in sales
of rice and paddy subject to terms and conditions. The firm is established in
the year 1999 by the partners with mutual consent and the same was
extended by time and again in the year 2022 and later on 2023 respectively'
The partnership deed contains l8 clauses dealing with the responsibilities
of the partners. The deponent herein performed a crucial role from the year
1999 onwards upto the year 2022, making huge profits for the partnels' The
deponent herein and the l't partner of the petitioner-firm have jointly
performed the duties of the petitioner-firm, whereas, respondent No'4
interrupted and disturbed the activities of the petitioner-firn. As a result,
the deponent decided to come out as an active partner and stood as a
sleeping partner. The deponent had exclusive cheque power and other key
roles with the partners of the petitioner-firm. As per clause No 7 of the
partnership deed dated 17.05.2023, the deponent and respondent No'4 rvere
RY..I
wP 14039 2025
entitled to operate the bank account or accounts. Respondent No.4, though
a sleeping paftner, unilaterally started managing activities ol petitioner-firm
fiom September, 2023 to October, 2025. During said pericd, the accounts,
financial transactions, and other income and expenditure st.]tement was not
fumished, despite several requests. As per clause No.6 ol the partnership
deed, the accounts have to be furnished for every year in nonth of October
and said information is not furnished. Respondent No.4 and respondent
Nos.5 to l1 colluded in proposing to prepare a new business prornotion tbr
the financial year 2026, the deponent was deeply aggrieved by such a
development. The depor-rent remitted amounts in the pet tioner-firm to a
tune of Rs.34,20,000/- and said amount is disclosed in the income tax
returns Respondent Nos.4 to I I without any transparent manner failed to
disclose clear information rvith respect to statement of account for the
financial year 2024-2025. When questioned, respondent N,rs.4 to I I gave a
reckless repl1,. In the circunlstances, the deponent approtLched the banker
State Bank of India ('SBI')-respondent No.2 and submitted a complaint
about the financial transactions of the petitioner-firm as on 01.11.2025. At
the request ofdeponent, the SBI gave statement to the deponent disclosing
balance of petitioner-firm Rs.25,00,7531, but the currr:nt account was
suspicious and ambiguous as operated by respondent No.4 along with other
respondent Nos.5 to I l. The deponent claims to have a Icgitimate right to
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
demand accountability from the remaining paftners. The representation
submitted by deponent is considered and current account bearing
No.52163087479 of the petitioner-firm w'as put on hold. Respondent Nos.4
to I I expelled the deponent from the petitioner-firm invoking clause No. I 6
without following due process of law. In the circumstances, the deponent
pleaded that not only the bank account, but several banking transactions are
liable to be kept on hold, as the documents belonging to the deponent and
others may be misused by the other partners. i.e., documents kept for
security purpose with the bank subject to tems and conditions. The
deponent is dependent upon the petitioner-firm business for a long time and
currently there are conflicts between the deponent and respondent Nos.4 to
I 1. On account of litigation created by them, the deponent's financial
situation is in danger, as the secured properties are lying in the bank.
Hence, the present writ petition is filed.
C ase of respondent Nos.2 and 3:-
4.
Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 filed counter alleging that the petitioner is a
partnership firm represented by its partner Challa Lakshmi
Narayana/deponent and others i.e., respondent Nos.4 to 1 l. The partnership
firm availed cash credit loan of Rs.4,00,00,000/- vide bank account bearing
No.52163087479 and GECL loan of Rs.24,50,000/- vide accotnt
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
No.40610865055 from respondent Nos.2 and 3 against the security of
movable and irnmovable properties. The deponent and othe r partners stood
as guarantors lor availing the loan. The deponent submitted representation
dated 01.11.2025 stating that there are financial transactions u'ith issues
between the partners o1' the petitioner and requested tle bank to stop
financial transaction with respect to loan account No.52l (r3087479. Upon
receiving said letter. respondent Nos.2 and 3 put the cash credit account on
hold. Further, the deponent filed the present writ petition n,ith a prayer to
put on hold the current account of the petitioner-firm. There is a dispute
between the deponent and others partners i.e., respondent IJos.4 to l1 about
modifuing and altering the procedure under partnership, as such the writ
petition is filed. The SBI is not party to the partnership. Interim orders
rvere passed in I.A.No. 1 of 2025 in the present writ petition and therefore,,
the loan accolrnt is put on hold. Thereafter, the petitiorer firm paid the
entire dues in the cash credit loan account and there are no dues in the said
loan account. However. there is amount due in GECL accr)unt. Respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 pleaded that the writ petition is not maintainable as the bank is
not a party to the partnership deed.
RY. J
wP 340_19 2025
Case o f respondent Nos.4toll:-
5.
Respondent Nos.4 to 11 filed counter stating that the
not approached the Court with clean hands but suppressed
deponent has
real facts' It is
Nos'4 to 1l
pleaded that the deponent is seeking action against respondent
in modifing the procedure under the partnership deed by
getting improper
majority. While he was expelled from the petitioner-firm'
it is pleaded that
true facts are suppressed and interim order dated 11'11'2025
is obtained in
I.A.No.1 of 2025 before this Court. The deponent playing
an active role
and accruing benefit to the remaining partners is
denied Further' the events
leading to collusion and expulsion of the deponent are
allegations about not furnishing financial statements
denied' All the
or profit loss account
are all denied.
6.
According to respondent Nos'4 to 1i, the deponent and respondent
No.4 were acting as cashiers for past 25 years' Accolding
to respondent
No.4, the deponent committed irregularities without giving
accounts to
other members, without revealing the profit loss details and
deponent wrote difference amount of Rs'76,00,,000/- The
later the
deponent has
admittedinwritingthatheisresponsiblefordifferenceofRs'76'00'000/-in
cash balance in the closing accounts of the year 2023 '
placed before village elders and it was unanimously
The matter was
resolved that the
R\-. J
\\'P 34039 2025
deponent admitted in writing that he is responsible firr difference of
Rs.76,00,000/- in cash balance in the closing accounts of the year 2023.h
is the deponent,
"vho
informed that expenses of cash and gain were not
rvritten fbr the last 2 to 3 years. In the meetings hetd, Rs.5,00,000/- was
accepted and rcmaining Rs.71,00,000/- was settled as arrears. The deponent
did not agree to be removed f'r'om cash management and ltsked association
elders to do justice. Othel partners in the organization wanted justice, and
the panchayat resolved the matter at the request of partners. The elders,
after hearing the all-concerned, decided that out ofRs.76,()0,000/- deducted
Rs.16,00.000 will not be spent and remaining Rs.60,00,C,00/- will har.e to
be paid by the deponent to the flrm. The partners have invested the
arTrounts and they got profit. The deponent, as per clause No.16, after
internention of elders rvas removed. The other partners are running the
firm
.
While so, the deponent made baseless allegation to damage the
reputation of the trmr. The members of petitioner-firm ale onlv disbursing
the br.rsiness even cooperated with the deponent. Respondent Nos.4 to 11
are unable to pay amounts to the farmers because o1'holding of firm
accounts The total of 1i,344 quintals ofpaddy payments are due for an
amount of Rs.2,66.50,160i-. Further, due to freezing ofthe bank account of
RY..I
wP 34039 2025
the petitioner-firm is unable to purchase paddy, cannot pay farmers'
cannot
conductbusinessetc.Itispleadedthatthewritpetitionisnotmaintainable
as the reliefs relate to partnership disputes, accounts, intemal financial
reconciliation, conduct of rights etc' Lastly, it is submitted that
deponent approached the Court with unclean hands as such, not
the
entitled to
any relief, and it is prayed that the petition be dismissed'
Re lv by the pe titioner:-
8.
The deponent, referring to the atlegations made in the counter'
submitsthathewasneverexpelledfromthefirmwithmajoritydecisionas
on the date of filing of the writ petition and as on the date of
submission of
letter to respondent No.3-SBI. It is stated tl.lat respondent Nos
2 and 3-Bank
did not respond to the complaint given by the deponent for stopping
transactions of the OCC account. As respondent No.4 was having
the
his own
net banking facility and he transferred amount of Rs' l'45'72'000/-
to the
otheraccountsofhiskithandkin.RespondentNo.4.incollusionwithother
respondents, is making online transfer of amounts and therefore'
the relief
is sought for continuation of holding of operation of the petitioner-fitm
current account. It is pleaded that the petitioner-firm is registered
Indian Contract Act and the partners are entitled to avail
remedy under Arbitration Act as per clause No'14 of
under
appropriate
partnership deed and
RY..I
wP 34039 2025
the sarne shall be binding. However, said remedies were never availed by
the respondents and never expelled the deponent in any manner
Respondent Nos.4 to 1
I unanimously ruled the administration including
operational banks and misappropriation accounts for which there was no
other go but to submit lepresentation dated 01 . 1 I .2025 requesting the bank
to hold operations of accounts of petitioner-firm to prevent from further
transfer until the w rit petition is adjudicated.
9.
It is pleaded that the petitioner approached this Court under Article
226 of Constitution as respondent Nos.4 to 11 have transferred amounts
more than Rs.l ,45.72,000/- to near and dear of responderrt Nos.4 to 1 l. For'
which the partners and respondent Nos.2 and 3-SBI rvould be responsible
and would be liable. It is alleged that the transfer of am,tunts was done by
respondent Nos.4 to ll
in collusion with respondent No.3-SBI
Respondents and others have filed counter along with arrdited accounts for
the last 3 years and respectively i.e..2022-23,2023-21 and 2024-25, rvhile
filing audited financial statements, they have not filed .he capital account
sheets with a conspiracy to conceal the capital accounts held with the firm
After the statement of capital account of partnership firrrr as on 31.03.2025
w,as sought from the charteled accountant and he fbund suppression of
capital to a tune of Rs.57,17,700/-. In such backdrop, the partners have
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
mutually indulged in manipulation to expel the deponent from the
partnership firm. In that circumstances, it is submitted that the writ petition
is maintainable and respondent No.3 has to contitrue to hold the current
account ol the petitioner- {lrm.
Contentions of the petitioner:-
10. The learned counsel for petitioner argued that the partners of the
petitioner-firm have committed irregularities and therefore, there was no
alternative but to approach this Court to direct respondent No'3 to put the
current account of the partnership firm on hold. It is alleged that there is
collusion between respondent No.3 and respondent Nos'4 to I 1 in
disbursing amounts to the near and dear of lespondent Nos'4 to I I '
Respondent No.3 by permitting online transler of about Rs 1,45,72,000/has acted in violation of the banking regulations and therefore, according to
the deponent, the writ petition is maintainable and there is a need to
continue to hotd such account in order to prevent fufther financial
irregularities by respondent Nos.4 to 11. In that context, the petitioner
submitted copy of statement showing transfer of funds with effect from
0l . I I .2025 on representation submitted to the banker. Further, statement of
the petitioner showing transfer of amounts from petitioner account to Rice
Mill corporation, where respondent Nos.4 to I I failed to disclose it in
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
income tax retums dated 0l .08.2024 is submitted. Along with the writ
petition. copy of registration of the partnership and copy of complaint
given to the Branch Manager SBl, Kodad Branch is submitted
Contentions of respondent Nos.2 and 3:1
l.
The learned counsel for respondent Nos.2 and -i submitted that,
pursuant to the lepresentations submitted by the petitiorer as well as the
interim orders of this Court in interlocutory application, there was a hold on
the cash credit loan account of the petitioner-firm. Therea fter, the petitioner
firm has repaid the entire dues in cash credit loan account and there are no
dues in the said loan account. It is pleaded that since there are no dues, the
cash credit loan account u-ould be closed in case this Court permits to do
SO
In order to suppoft their contention, the leamed counsel for respondent
Nos.2 and 3 relied upon true extract of statement of crash credit loan
account No.52163087479 and, true extract of statement of GECL loan
account No.40610865055 of petitioner firm.
Contentions of res
ndent Nos.4 to I l:-
12. The leamed counsel for respondent Nos.4 to ll submits that there
are no loans due in the crash credit loan account which i; subject matter of
tlp w'it petition as such prayed that the hold be removed. Further, it is
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
pleaded that the deponent herein has suppressed material facts and to prove
the same submitted copy of settlement between the deponent and unofficial
respondents, the minutes of rreeting and resolutions dated 14.04.2025,
14.07.2024 and 18.08.2024. Funher. copy of payments due list of farmers,
copy of income tax return acknowledgment dated 28.09.2023,24.09.2024
and 17.10.2025 and copy of order in the present writ petition dated
11.11.2025 are filed.
13. The documents submitted by respondent l"\os.4 to 1l show that there
was a meeting held before the village elders wherein it is decided that there
was a difference of Rs.76,00,0001 in the accounts ofthe petitioner firm out
of which Rs. 16,00,000/- was written off towards expenses and the deponent
was directed to pay remaining amount of Rs.60,00,000/- to the partnership
firm. The request ofdeponent to reduce the said amount was not accepted.
This resolution was signed by all the panners including the deponent.
Further, the agenda of meetings dated 14.04.2024 and 11.07.2024 are also
submitted. There was discussion about the amounts due by the deponent as
per the resolution dated I1.07.2024 and he was directed to pay the due
amounts by 01.08.2024. The incorne tax accounts are also submitted by
respondent Nos.4 to 1 I .
1,2
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
14. The learned counsel for respondent Nos.4 to l l relied upon judgment
in the case of State of Bihar v. Jain Plastics and Chemicals Limitedr,
wherein it is held that breach of contract would not be a ground for exercise
of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Cons,titution.
15. F'urther. ret-erence is made to the case of Best [)nterprises v. S.
Elanchizian2. wherein it is held that by the High Court c,f Madras that the
bank accotmt of a firm is to be operated by two partners. Out of the four
partners and three of then.r are holding 7lo/o of the sharc have decided to
continue the business and only one partner does not want to continue with
the flrm. Therefore. the bank cannot fieeze the account at the instance of
one partner. On the basis of aflorementioned, it is argued that the request of
one partner rvho is expelled from the partnership cannct be a ground for
keeping the petitioner'-firm's account on hold.
16. Reliance is placed upon the case in M/s.CPR-CIPPL-GVRIIPL
(JV) v. The Chairman and Managing Director, Singareni Collieries
Company Limiteds, wherein it is held that interpretarion of terms and
conditions of a contract may not be permitted under Article 226 of
Constitution of India.
^-
' lzooz; t scc zto
' AtR 2006 rutaD 274
'.W.P.No.22127 of 2024, dated 19.06.2025-TSHC
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
Findinss of the Court:-
17. The deponent presented the case simply to the effect that a
partnership firm was established in the year 1999 -2000 and the deponent
along with respondent No.4 have run the accounts of said t-rrm for a period
of 25 years. Thereafter, on account of collusion between the partners, the
deponent remained aloof as a sleeping partner. Taking advantage of the
situation, respondent Nos.4 to 1l have committed irregularities and there
was a difference of Rs.56,00,,000/- in the cash account of the firm. When
the deponent, demanded information relating to the cash accounts and
profit and loss statements, respondent Nos.4 to 1l have given reckless
answers. Therefore, the deponent was cornpelleci to approach respondent
No.3-bank by submitting representation dated 01.11.2025 demanding the
respondent No.3 to keep the current account of the petitioner-flrm on hold'
Thereafter, the deponent approached this Courr by way of writ petition and
was granted with interirn relief in the interlocutory applications, resulting in
the current account of the partnership firm being kept on hold' Ilowever,
when the counter filed by respondent Nos.2 and 3 is seen, it is seen that the
loan account has been cleared i.e., the entire loan has been repaid. In effect,
thg prayer of the writ petition i.e. to continue to keep freeze on current
account No.52160387479 is no longer required
t4
RY. J
wP 34039 2025
18. Besides the repayrnent of loan of the account which is subject matter
of the writ petition, the other facts brought on record by 'espondent Nos.4
Lo I I show that thele was financial mismanagement otl the part of the
deponent leading to a meeting being held before the village elders and said
rr.reeting resolving that the deponent is responsible firr the difference
amount of Rs.76,00,000i- in the cash account of the f rm out of which
Rs. 16.00,000/- u'as rvritten off towards expenses
of ,he firm and the
deponent was found due to pay Rs.60,00,000/- to the firm. This fact is
suppressed by the deponent. Further, resolutions were passed in subsequent
meetings b1, the partners, demanding the deponent tc pay the amount
decided by the village elders in a stipulated time frame. Said facts are also
supprcssed b_v the rvrit petitioner.
19. This Court cannot decide financial mismanagement either on the part
of the deponent or respondent Nos.4 to I 1. The bank statements produced
before this Court cannot be perused for giving a finding either in favour of
the deponent or respondent Nos.4 to I l. Such an exeLcise can be taken up
by a fact-finding Court and not a Writ Court. This Court cannot take
er.idence on record and give a finding about who is responsible for
mismanagentent and whether there is failure on the rart of respondent
Nos.4 to ll in managing the aft'airs olthe petitioner-firrr. The writ petition
RY, J
wP 34039 2025
is a result ofclever drafting, placing the blame on respondent Nos. 2 and 3-
SBI for the purpose of achieving the goal of freezing the account of the
petitioner-firm pursuant to a purely private dispute between the partners of
a partnership firm.
20. The application ofclauses ofa partnership firm cannot be intelpreted
by this Court in the writ jurisdiction. About mismanagement or collusion
between the bank and respondent No.4 is no longer an issue, as respondent
Nos.2and3havefiledCountersubmittingthatth.epetitionerfirmrepaid
entire dues in the cash credit loan account and there are no dues in said
loan
account i.e., the current account which is subject matter ofthe writ petition.
.
In view of the foregoing, in view ofpayment of the loan there can be
no apprehension for the petitioner/deponent about mismanagement of said
loan account. Further, a dispute between private individuals pursuant to a
contract cannot be a subject matter befbre this courl under Article 226
of
Constitution.
22. Lastly, there is suppression of facts on the part of the deponent with
respect to the village elders holding him responsible for the difference
in
cashaccountanddirectinghimtopayRs'60,00,000/-tothepartnership
finn. It is settled principle that any person who approaches the Court with
unclean hands is not entitled to any reliet-. In any case, the alleged
cause of
RY. J
wP 14039 2025
action is no longer available to the deponent in view of repayment of loan
accolrnt, which is subject matter of the writ petition.
23. [n view of the fbregoing, it is held that the w.rit petition is
misconcei",ed and not maintainable. Hence, the same is liable to be
dismissed.
24. In the result. the u.rit petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as
to costs. N,liscellaneous applications, if any, pending shall stand closed.
SD/.B.REKHA RANI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
'---'---1-
CTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI GANESH BHUJANGA RAO VADDURI, Advocate tOpUCl
2. TWO CCS tO GP FOR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES, High COUrt for thc StAtE Of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
3. One CC to SRI G.PRABHAKAR SARMA, Advocate tOpUCl
4. One CC to SRI S.CHANDRA MOHAN REDDY, Advocate IOPUCI
5. Two CD Copies.
M.
BSK
1,7
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1310712026
5TAr 5 Or
{
)
o
2t
a)
ORDER
WP.No.34039 of 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
\
(
o
t$tt
Jut
r DE
G,
t
Y-i,
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review