Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 14TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.2854 OF 2024 (RES)
BETWEEN:
SRI.RAVIKUMAR
S/O LATE AYAPPA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
R/AT NO.162/1, 2ND CROSS
PAPAIAH REDDY LAYOUT
MANORAYANAPALYA
R.T NAGAR POST
BENGALURU-560032
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI.JAGADISH GUNDAPPA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
NAGARAJA B M
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SMT.HONNAMMA
W/O LATE CHANDRASHEKAR
S/O LATE S.SATHYANARAYANA
SINCE DECEASED
RESPONDENT NOS.2 AND 3
ARE TREATED AS LRS OF
DECEASED
RESPONDENT NO.1
2.
SRI.RENUKA
S/O LATE CHANDRASHEKAR
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
-2NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
3.
SRI.SHIVAKUMAR
S/O LATE CHANDRASHEKAR
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
ALL ARE R/AT 2ND CROSS
PAPAIAH REDDY LAYOUT
MANORAYANAPALYA
R.T NAGAR POST
BENGALURU - 560032
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.C.SHANKAR REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR C/R.2 AND R.3)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SEC.96 OF CPC., AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED
30.09.2024
PASSED
IN
O.S.NO.3528/2019 ON THE FILE OF LVI ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU., DISMISSING THE SUIT FOR
DAMAGES AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION AND ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The
captioned
appeal
is
by
the
unsuccessful
appellant- plaintiff assailing the judgment and decree
dated 30.09.2024 rendered in O.S.No.3528/2019 on the
file of the LVI Additional City Civil Judge, Bengaluru,
-3NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
wherein
plaintiff’s
ejectment
suit
instituted
in
O.S.No.3528/2019 is dismissed.
2. For the sake of brevity, the parties are referred as
they are ranked before the Trial Court.
3. Though this matter is listed in admission, the
learned counsels on record were notified on the previous
date that the matter will be heard finally as the decree
arises out of the ejectment suit. This Court also directed
the Registry to secure the Trial Court Records, which are
now placed before this court.
4. Brief facts leading to the case are as under;
The plaintiff instituted the present suit seeking
ejectment, damages and a decree of perpetual injunction
contending that he and his uncle acquired the suit
schedule properties under a registered Partition Deed
dated 20.04.2000. Under the said partition, five items
described as Schedule ‘E’ properties were allotted to the
-4NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
plaintiff’s share. Item No.3 of Schedule ‘E’ comprises land
bearing Sy.Nos.40 and 41/3, measuring East to West 65
feet and North to South 84 feet on the eastern side and 87
feet on the western side, out of a larger extent of 1 acre
10 guntas. The portion so allotted to the plaintiff is
described as Schedule ‘A’ property in the plaint, whereas
the property in dispute, measuring East to West 23 feet
and North to South 30 feet, is described as Schedule ‘B’
property.
5. It is the plaintiff’s case that Schedule ‘A’ property
was earlier enjoyed by his uncle, Krishna Reddy, and
pursuant to the family partition, exclusive possession of
the portion allotted to the plaintiff was delivered to him.
The plaintiff further alleges that at the time of such
delivery, the defendants were in occupation of a portion of
the property as tenants and were paying rent of Rs.700/
per
month,
which
Rs.1,400/- per month.
was
subsequently
enhanced
to
-5NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
6.
change
The plaintiff asserts that when he applied for
of
khatha
in
respect
of
the
property,
the
defendants filed objections claiming ownership. Upon
verification of the Encumbrance Certificate, the plaintiff
claims to have discovered that his uncle had unlawfully
sublet the property without any right or title. It is further
alleged that the defendants are asserting ownership over
the suit schedule property without any valid conveyance.
On these premises, the plaintiff instituted the present suit
seeking ejectment and damages.
7. Upon service of summons, defendant No.2 filed a
written statement, which was adopted by defendant Nos.1
and 3. The defendants contested the suit on the ground
that it is not maintainable and that the plaintiff has
approached the Court suppressing material facts.
It is
specifically contended that Krishna Reddy (defendant
No.1) had delivered possession of Schedule ‘B’ property
much prior to the execution of the partition deed dated
20.04.2000.
Defendant Nos.2 and 3 asserted absolute
-6NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
ownership over Schedule ‘B’ property on the strength of a
registered sale
deed dated 07.06.2004 executed by
defendant No.1, acting as GPA holder of Krishna Reddy.
The defendants, therefore, denied the existence of any
jural relationship of landlord and tenant and sought
dismissal of the suit.
8. On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Trial Court
framed the necessary issues and afforded opportunity to
both parties to adduce oral and documentary evidence in
support of their respective claims.
9. In support of his case, the plaintiff examined
himself as P.W.1 and another witness as P.W.2 and
produced four documents, which were marked as Exs.P.1
to P.4.
10. On the other hand, the defendants examined
defendant No.2 as D.W.1 and produced as many as
seventy four documents to substantiate their claim of title
and
possession.
Upon
appreciation
of
the
oral
and
-7NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
documentary evidence, the Trial Court dismissed the suit
holding that the plaintiff failed to establish that the
defendants were tenants in respect of the suit schedule
property and further failed to prove lawful termination of
tenancy as required under law.
11.
plaintiff
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the
and
the
learned
counsel
representing
the
defendants.
12.
The following points arise for consideration in
the present appeal:
(i)
Whether
the
Trial
Court
was
justified in dismissing the suit by holding
that the plaintiff failed to establish his title
over the Schedule ‘B’ property?
(ii)
Whether
the
Trial
Court
was
justified in recording a finding that the
plaintiff failed to prove the existence of a
jural relationship of landlord and tenant and
the
valid
termination
accordance with law?
of
tenancy
in
-8NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
(iii) What order?
Findings on Point Nos.(i) and (ii) :-
13. The plaintiff has instituted the present suit
asserting absolute ownership over the suit schedule
property by tracing his title to a registered Partition Deed
dated 20.04.2000. It is the specific case of the plaintiff
that under the said partition, the properties described as
Schedule ‘E’ were allotted to his share and that the
defendants were originally inducted into the premises by
his uncle - Krishna Reddy. According to the plaintiff, upon
the partition, there was an implied attornment in his
favour and having acquired title pursuant to the partition,
he stepped into the shoes of the landlord and is, therefore,
entitled to seek eviction of the defendants from the suit
schedule property.
14. However, on a careful examination of the
records, it is evident that the present suit is one for
ejectment founded on an alleged relationship of landlord
-9NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
and tenant. In such circumstances, issuance of a quit
notice as contemplated under Section 106 of the Transfer
of
Property
requirement.
Act,
is
a
mandatory
statutory
Admittedly, no such notice terminating the
alleged tenancy has been issued prior to the institution of
the suit. In the absence of compliance with the statutory
mandate, the very foundation of the ejectment action
stands vitiated, rendering the suit procedurally untenable.
15. Be that as it may, the more fundamental issue
that arises for consideration is whether the plaintiff could
have maintained an ejectment suit at all, when the very
document
under
which
he
claims
title
namely,
the
registered Partition Deed dated 20.04.2000 unequivocally
excludes the suit schedule property from the partition.
A plain reading of the recitals in the said partition deed
clearly discloses that Schedule ‘B’ property was not the
subject matter of allotment under the partition and stood
excluded therefrom. If the suit schedule property did not
form part of the properties allotted to the plaintiff, the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
plaintiff cannot assert ownership or claim to have acquired
landlordship over the said property merely on the strength
of the partition.
16. It is trite that a party seeking eviction must first
establish his title or lawful status as landlord in respect of
the
suit
schedule
property.
When
the
foundational
document relied upon by the plaintiff itself negates
inclusion of the suit schedule property, the theory of
attornment post-partition, as propounded by the plaintiff,
becomes wholly untenable. Attornment presupposes a
lawful transfer of reversionary interest, which, in the
present case, is conspicuously absent.
17. In this backdrop, this Court finds it appropriate
to advert to and examine the recitals contained in the
registered Partition Deed dated 20.04.2000, as the said
document strikes at the very root of the plaintiff’s claim.
The relevant portion of the partition deed, which assumes
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
decisive
significance
for
adjudication
of
the
present
controversy, is extracted hereinbelow:
". . . . . . . CzÉà jÃw LzÀ£Éà ¨sÁUÀ¸ÀÛgÁzÀ ²æÃ gÀ«PÀĪÀiÁgï
gÀªÀgÀ ¨sÁUÀPÉÌ vÉUÉzÀÄPÉÆAqÀ ¸ÀªÉð £ÀA§gÀÄ 40 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 41:3gÀ D¹ÛAiÀİè
CªÀgÀÄ ¸ÀĪÀiÁgÀÄ 30 * 23 Cr D¹ÛAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¢£ÁAPÀ: 10-7-1989
gÀAzÀÄ PÉ. ºÉÆ£ÀߪÀÄä PÉÆÃA ZÀAzÀæ±ÉÃRgï ªÀÄvÀÄÛ r.£ÁgÁAiÀÄt¥Àà
gÀªÀgÀÄUÀ½UÉ PÀæAiÀÄ ªÀiÁrgÀÄvÁÛgÉ. . . . . ."
18. On a careful reading of the extracted recitals of
the registered Partition Deed dated 20.04.2000, it is
manifestly clear that a portion measuring East to West 23
feet and North to South 30 feet stands expressly excluded
from the purview of partition effected among the plaintiff
and other family members. The exclusion is not vague or
incidental, but is categorically recorded with a specific
recital that the said portion had already been alienated in
favour of defendant No.1, namely, Smt.Honnamma, under
a registered Sale Deed dated 10.07.1989. The recitals
further disclose that though the transaction traces its
origin to a General Power of Attorney executed by Krishna
Reddy, defendant No.1, acting under such authority,
subsequently executed a registered Sale Deed dated
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
07.06.2004 in favour of defendant Nos.2 and 3 jointly,
which is marked as Ex.D.4.
19. The extent described in the registered Sale Deed
dated 07.06.2004 squarely corresponds with the extent
expressly excluded under the Partition Deed. This factual
matrix is further fortified by the rebuttal evidence adduced
by the defendants, which corroborates both the identity
and extent of the excluded property.
20. In the light of the recitals contained in the
registered Partition Deed dated 20.04.2000 (Ex.P.1) and
the registered Sale Deed dated 07.06.2004 (Ex.D.4)
obtained by defendant Nos.2 and 3, it becomes abundantly
clear that the disputed property, described as Schedule
‘B’ property, was never allotted to the plaintiff’s share
under the partition, contrary to what is asserted in the
plaint. Once the foundational claim of allotment under the
partition
fails,
the
plaintiff’s
further
assertion
that
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
defendant Nos.1 to 3 are his tenants and that he is
entitled to seek ejectment falls to the ground.
21. The defendants have not only asserted title but
have substantiated the same by producing the registered
Sale Deed. Significantly, even the plaintiff’s own title
document,
namely
the
Partition
Deed,
acknowledges
exclusion of the suit schedule property and does not allot
it to any of the coparceners, including the plaintiff. If the
suit schedule property was never allotted to the plaintiff,
the question of existence of a jural relationship of landlord
and tenant between the plaintiff and the defendants does
not arise.
22. Equally significant is the admitted position that
the plaintiff has not challenged the registered Sale Deed
dated 07.06.2004 executed in favour of defendant Nos.2
and 3 in a manner known to law. In the absence of a
prayer seeking declaration of title or setting aside of the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
sale deed, the plaintiff cannot collaterally impeach the
defendants’ title in an ejectment suit.
23. This
Court
finds that
the
Trial
Court
has
meticulously examined the rebuttal evidence adduced by
the defendants, particularly the registered Sale Deed
marked at Ex.D.4, tax paid receipts marked at Exs.D.5 to
D.7, khatha extract for the year 2005 marked at Ex.D.8,
khatha certificates marked at Exs.D.9 and D.10, and
encumbrance certificates marked at Exs.D.11 to D.14. The
cumulative effect of these documents clearly establishes
that the family of the plaintiff had lost possession of the
suit schedule property much prior to the execution of the
Partition Deed dated 20.04.2000 and that defendant Nos.2
and 3 have been in exclusive possession pursuant to the
registered Sale Deed dated 07.06.2004.
24. In view of the overwhelming rebuttal evidence,
the plaintiff has failed to establish that the Schedule
‘B’ property formed part of his share under the partition.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
The recitals contained in the registered Partition Deed are
binding on the plaintiff, and having accepted the benefits
of the partition, the plaintiff is estopped from asserting
title to a property which stands expressly excluded
therefrom.
This
Court,
upon
an
independent
re-
appreciation of the entire oral and documentary evidence,
concurs with the findings recorded by the Trial Court that
the plaintiff has failed to prove title over the suit schedule
property.
25. This Court is also of the considered view that the
ejectment
suit,
as
instituted,
is
fundamentally
misconceived. Even if the plaint averments are taken at
their face value, the suit is barred by Section 2(e)(i) of the
Karnataka Rent Act, 1999, inasmuch as the alleged agreed
rent is less than Rs.3,500/- per month. Consequently, the
plaintiff could not have maintained an ejectment suit
before the Civil Court and the remedy, if any, lay
elsewhere. On this ground as well, the suit is not
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:2371
RFA No. 2854 of 2024
HC-KAR
maintainable.
Accordingly, point Nos.(i) and (ii) are
answered in the Affirmative.
26.
Findings on Point No.(iii):- In view of the
findings recorded on point Nos.(i) and (ii), this Court
proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
(i) The appeal is devoid of merits and
is accordingly dismissed.
(ii) Pending applications, if any, are
also dismissed.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
NBM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review