Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2885 OF 2024 (DEC/POS)
BETWEEN:
Digitally
signed by N
UMA
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SRI. NAGARAJU C
S/O LATE CHANGAIAH
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
2.
SMT. ROSE MARY
W/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
3.
SRI. PREMAKUMAR
S/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
4.
SRI. ASHOK KUMAR
S/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
5.
SRI. RAVIKUMAR
S/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
6.
SRI STAINLY SATHYA KUMAR
S/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
7.
SMT. RANJITHA
D/O C. NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
ALL ARE RESIDING AT
NO.76/4-2,
30TH CROSS
THILAKNAGARA MAIN ROAD
IV T BLOCK, JAYANAGARA
BENGALURU - 560 041.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. SOMASHEKARA K M, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. RATHAN SHANKAR RAO
W/O SHANKAR RAO
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
R/AT NO.733,
PRASHNTHA NILAYA
BEHIND INDUSTRIAL ESTATE
VIDYANAGAR
TUMKUR - 572 103.
KOWSALYA BAI S
SINCE DEAD BY HER LRS
2.
SMT. SHANTHA N A
D/O LATE KOWSALYA BAI S.
W/O ASHOK N.K.
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
R/AT 'ASHIRVAD NILAYA'
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT
SHIVAMOGGA - 577 201.
3.
SMT. VIDYA K. SHENDGE
D/O LATE KOWSALYA BAI S.
W/O KISHORE
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
R/AT NO.238/1
VIVEKANANDA NAGARA
GADAG DISTRICT - 282 101.
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
4.
SRI. SHASHIKUMAR S.N.
S/O LATE KOWSALYA BAI S.
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
R/AT NO.102,
2ND CROSS
YELLAPPA GARDEN
BANAGIRINAGAR
BSK 3RD STAGE
BENGALURU - 560 085.
5.
SRI RAVEENDRA S.N.
S/O LATE KOWSALYA BAI S.
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
R/AT NO.102,
2ND CROSS
KAUSHAL YELLAPPA GARDEN
2ND CROSS, NEAR WATER TANK
BANAGIRINAGAR,
BSK 3RD STAGE
BENGALURU SOUTH
BENGALURU - 560 085.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. K VIJAYKUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1, R2 TO R5)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC.,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 21.08.2024
PASSED IN OS NO.1943/2019 ON THE FILE OF LI ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE C/C. XXXVII ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU CITY (CCH 38)
AND ETC.,
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER ARGUMENTS,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
ORAL JUDGMENT
The
Regular
First
Appeal
is
filed
by
the
appellants/defendants calling in question the judgment
and decree dated 21.08.2024 passed in O.S.No.1943/2019
by the Court of XXXVII Addl. City Civil & Sessions Judge
(CCH-38), Bengaluru City (hereinafter referred to as ‘Trial
Court’ for short), whereby the suit filed for declaration and
possession is came to be decreed in part.
2.
For
the
sake
of
convenience
and
easy
reference, the parties are referred to as per their rankings
before the Trial Court.
3.
It is the case of the plaintiffs, in brief, that
plaintiff No.1 is the daughter of plaintiff No.2. Plaintiff No.2
has purchased the property through a registered sale deed
dated 17.10.1997 executed by defendant No.1 and his
brothers and, therefore, plaintiff No.2 was in possession
and enjoyment of the property and thereafter got the
khata and other revenue records mutated in her name and
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
plaintiff No.2 was paying property tax. Plaintiff No.2 was
paying taxes regularly to the BBMP. Thereafter, plaintiff
No.2 executed a registered gift deed dated 23.03.2017 in
favour of plaintiff No.1. Subsequent to the gift deed, khata
has been changed to the name of plaintiff No.1 and
plaintiff No.1 is paying taxes to the BBMP. It is stated that
defendant No.1, having no right, title or interest over the
suit property, and defendant Nos.2 to 7, who are the wife
and children of defendant No.1, having no right, title and
interest over the property, have encroached upon the suit
property and, thus, in this regard, a police complaint was
filed against the defendants. It is stated that site Nos.37
and 38 (suit schedule property) are situated adjacent to
each other and both site Nos.37 and 38 are having
dimensions of 40 feet East to West and 60 feet North to
South. There are 13 sites located in the line of the suit
property. They are numbered from 37 to 49. All these
sites are having the same measurement of 40 feet East to
West and 60 feet North to South. It is alleged against the
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
defendants that the defendants have put up a temporary
shed by encroaching upon the suit property and let out the
said temporary shed to a tenant and the defendants are
receiving rent from the tenant. Therefore, the plaintiffs
have
filed
the
suit
for
declaration,
possession
and
permanent injunction.
4.
The
defendant
No.1
has
filed
the
written
statement and defendant Nos.2 to 7 have adopted the
written statement filed by defendant No.1. The defendants
have denied the ownership of plaintiff No.1 over the suit
property. It is admitted that plaintiff No.2 has acquired the
suit property through a registered sale deed dated
17.10.1997 executed by defendant No.1 and his brothers.
But, on the pretext of the said sale deed, the plaintiffs are
trying to encroach upon the property of the defendants,
which is situated adjacent to the suit property.
5.
It is the contention of the defendants that the
temporary shed is put up on site No.37 and not on site
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
No.38. It is the case of the defendants that the plaintiffs,
on the guise of claiming ownership over site No.38, are
making
an
attempt
to
encroach
upon
site
No.37.
Therefore, they filed a false and frivolous complaint before
the police and the suit filed is also false and frivolous. It is
stated that site No.37 is a corner site and site No.38 is
adjacent to site No.37. Further, it is contended that the
suit filed is barred by limitation and there is no cause of
action to file the suit. The suit property is situated in
Sy.No.11, 12/1 and 47/1 of Kothanur Village and it was
sold by defendant No.1 and his three brothers to the
plaintiffs. Therefore, taking undue advantage of the fact
that the defendants are away from the property, the
plaintiffs are trying to encroach upon their property. When
the defendants registered the same, the plaintiffs have
filed this false suit. Therefore, prayed to dismiss the suit.
6.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, the following
issues have been framed:
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
1. Whether
the
plaintiff
No.1
proves
that
she
acquired the suit schedule property under a
registered gift deed dated 23.03.2017 executed
by the 2nd plaintiff?
2. Whether the plaintiffs prove that the defendants
have illegally put up a temporary shed by
encroaching suit site No.38 belongs to them?
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the reliefs
as sought?
4. What order or decree?
7.
During the pendency of the suit, plaintiff No.2
died and plaintiff No.1 is one of the legal heirs of plaintiff
No.2 and the other legal heirs of plaintiff No.2 were
brought on record. Plaintiff No.2(c) is examined as PW.1
and got marked documents as Exs.P1 to P72. The
defendant No.1 is examined as DW.1 and no documents
were marked on his behalf.
8.
The
Trial
Court
has
decreed
the
suit
by
assigning reasons that, from the evidence on record, the
plaintiffs have proved that the husband of defendant No.2
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
has acquired the suit property through the registered sale
deed
from
defendant
No.1
and
his
brothers
dated
17.10.1997. It is observed that site No.37 is adjacent to
site No.38 and site No.37 is a corner site. Further, it
assigned reasons that plaintiff No.2 had gifted the suit
property in favour of plaintiff No.1. Thus, plaintiff No.1 had
become the owner of the property. Further, it assigned
reasons that the defendants have failed to prove that the
dimension of site No.37 is 80 x 60 feet and, in this regard,
the defendants have not produced any documentary
evidence. The Trial Court assigned reasons that there are
13 sites in the same line and all the sites are having
dimensions of 40 x 60 feet. Therefore, the Trial Court held
that the plaintiffs have acquired the suit schedule property
of the dimension of 40 x 60 feet and, thus, the defendants
have encroached upon site No.38 by putting up a
temporary shed. Thus, held that the plaintiffs are entitled
to a declaration of ownership over site No.38 of the
schedule property measuring 40 x 60 feet.
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
9.
Further, the defendants have admitted in their
cross-examination that they have put up a temporary shed
construction on site No.37, but they have stated that they
have not put up any construction on site No.38. Therefore,
assigned reasons that when both sites are adjacent to
each
other, it is proved that the
defendants have
encroached upon site No.38 also by putting up temporary
construction. Further, assigned reasons that when site
Nos.37 to 49 are in the same line and having dimensions
of 40 x 60 feet and the plaintiffs have purchased site
No.38 measuring 40 x 60 feet, the same is supported by
Ex.P80 - layout plan. Therefore, decreed the suit in favour
of the plaintiffs.
10.
Further, the Trial Court observed that during
the course of cross-examination, a question was put to
DW.1 as to whether the layout plan was given to the
plaintiffs at the time of selling the site, but DW.1
arrogantly answered that it was not for him to identify the
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
sites and their measurements. Therefore, the Trial Court
has found fault with the defendants that though the
defendants suppressed the evidence before the Court,
they have answered that it was not his obligation to
produce the layout plan. Therefore, when the defendants
have answered that it is not his obligation to produce the
layout plan, the defendants have suppressed the material
before the Court and, therefore, has drawn an adverse
inference against the defendants and thus held that the
plaintiffs are the owners of the suit schedule property and
the defendants have encroached upon the suit schedule
property.
11.
Further, it was observed that the plaintiffs have
produced a Xerox copy of the layout plan, which is
secondary evidence, by laying the foundation. Therefore,
the Trial Court accepted Ex.P80-layout plan as secondary
evidence and accordingly accepted the said evidence and,
based on Ex.P80 - layout plan, held that the plaintiffs have
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
proved that they are the owners of site No.38 and that the
defendants have encroached upon site No.38. Further, it is
held that the suit filed is within the period of limitation.
Therefore, for all the reasons stated above, the Trial Court
has decreed the suit.
12.
decreeing
Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree
the
suit
in
favour
of
the
plaintiffs,
the
defendants have preferred the appeal by raising various
grounds
and
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants/defendants, in consonance with the grounds
raised, has argued that the Trial Court has not framed the
issues properly. It is argued that the suit is barred by
limitation and, as per the admission of PW.1 in the crossexamination,
the
plaintiffs
knew
the
fact
that
the
defendants have encroached upon the suit property in the
year 2005, but the suit was filed in the year 2019.
Therefore, the suit filed is barred by limitation. But, on this
aspect, the Trial Court has not framed the issues properly
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
and, if the Trial Court had framed the issue in this regard,
then the defendants would have been in a position to
prove that the suit is barred by limitation. Therefore,
prayed to set aside the judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court and remand the matter to the Trial Court
for fresh consideration.
13.
Further, submitted that the Trial Court has not
framed an issue regarding damages. Therefore, without
framing
an
issue
and
without
adjudication
on
the
damages, directly decreeing the suit for damages is not
correct. Therefore, prayed to set aside the judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court.
14.
Further, argued that the plaintiffs have failed to
protect their property. Therefore, on a wrong pretext, they
are making a futile attempt by making allegations against
the defendants that the defendants have encroached upon
the property. Therefore, when the plaintiffs themselves
have committed a fault in failing to protect their property
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
but are illegally encroaching upon the property of the
defendants, which is site No.37, the Trial Court, in this
regard, has not properly appreciated the evidence on
record. Hence, prayed to allow the appeal.
15.
Further, submitted that during the course of
arguments,
this
Court
has
appointed
a
Court
Commissioner, who is designated as ADLR, and he has
submitted a report and plan and, in this regard, evidence
is required. Therefore, the case be remanded to the Trial
Court
for
fresh
submissions,
adjudication.
learned
counsel
Hence,
for
on
the
all
these
appellants/
defendants prayed to allow the appeal and set aside the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
16.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the
respondents/plaintiffs submitted that defendant No.1 and
his brothers have sold the suit site No.38 in favour of
plaintiff No.2. Therefore, the plaintiffs have become the
owners of suit site No.38 measuring 40 x 60 feet. The
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
defendants are the owners of site No.37 measuring 40 x
60 feet, but they failed to protect their property and, when
they failed to protect their property, now they are making
an illegal claim over the suit property by encroaching upon
the suit property and this is rightly considered by the Trial
Court and the decree passed is legal and correct.
17.
Further, submitted that all the sites in the same
line are totally 13 in number and each site is having a
dimension of 40 x 60 feet. When the defendants admitted
that they have sold the suit property measuring 40 x 60
feet, the plaintiffs have filed the suit for declaration and
possession of the property measuring 40 x 60 feet.
Further, submitted that the BBMP has acquired the eastern
side of site No.37 and thus the dimension of site No.37 is
diminished and, therefore, the defendants are making a
false
claim by
Therefore,
encroaching
submitted
that
upon
when
the
suit
the
property.
defendants
themselves have admitted that they have sold suit site
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
No.38, the plaintiffs are entitled to ownership of site No.38
measuring 40 x 60 feet as per the sale deed dated
17.10.1997 and this is correctly considered by the Trial
Court and accordingly, the suit is decreed. Therefore,
prayed to dismiss the appeal.
18.
Further, submitted that the suit filed is within
the period of limitation. The plaintiffs came to know for the
first time that encroachment was made by the defendants
by putting up a temporary shed on site No.38. Thereafter,
they filed a police complaint and a criminal case was
registered and it went to trial and the defendants were
acquitted. Thus, reckoning the date in the year 2013, filing
the suit for declaration and possession is within the period
of limitation as per Article 65 of the Limitation Act.
Therefore, the suit filed is within the period of limitation.
19.
Further, submitted that when the defendants
are claiming that the dimension of site No.37 is 80 x 60
feet, the defendants have not produced any evidence to
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
prove that the dimension of site No.37 is 80 x 60 feet.
But, on the contrary, the plaintiffs themselves have
produced Ex.P80- layout plan, which is approved by the
Kothanur Gram Panchayat, showing that site Nos.37 to 49
are situated in the same line and each site is having a
dimension of 40 x 60 feet. Therefore, the plaintiffs proved
their pleading that site No.37 is measuring 40 x 60.
Further, submitted that at the time of registration of the
sale deed executed by the defendants in favour of plaintiff
No.2,
the
defendants
have
handed
over
the
Gram
Panchayat approved layout plan to plaintiff No.2 and a
copy of the same is produced as per Ex.P80. Therefore,
the defendants, after forming sites in the layout and
demarcating and identifying the sites, have sold out suit
site No.38 and DW.1, by giving an evasive answer, has
tried to suppress the material facts, which is correctly
appreciated by the Trial Court and accordingly, an adverse
inference
has
been
drawn
against
the
defendants.
Therefore, the Trial Court has assigned the reasons in a
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
proper manner and arrived at a just conclusion and
correctly answered all the issues and rightly held that the
plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of declaration, possession
and injunction. Therefore, there is no perversity or
illegality in the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court. Hence, prayed to dismiss the suit and dismiss the
appeal with costs.
20.
Upon hearing the submission of learned counsel
appearing on behalf of both the parties and perusing the
materials available on record, the following points would
arise for consideration:
1. Whether,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
involved in the case, the plaintiffs prove that
plaintiff No.2 acquired suit schedule site No.38 (as
described in the plaint) under a registered sale
deed dated 17.10.1997 executed by defendant
No.1 and his brothers in favour of plaintiff No.2
and, thereafter, plaintiff No.2 executed a gift deed
in favour of plaintiff No.1 and, thus, the plaintiffs
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
have become the owners of the suit schedule
property?
2. Whether,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
involved in the case, the plaintiffs prove that the
defendants have encroached the site No.38 by
putting up a temporary shed?
3. Whether,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
involved in the case, defendants prove that site
No.37 is having dimension of 80x60 feet and thus,
the defendants are the owners of site No.37
measuring 80x60 feet?
4. Whether,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
involved in the case, the defendants prove that
the suit is barred by limitation?
5. Whether,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
involved in the case, the defendants prove that in
the
absence
of
properly
framed
issues
on
damages as claimed by the plaintiffs and without
adjudication on the damages, whether the trial
Court is correct in awarding damages?
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
6. Whether, the judgment and decree passed by the
Trial Court requires interference by this Court, if
so, at what extent?
21.
In the present case, upon considering the
pleadings and evidence adduced by both the parties, it is
an undisputed fact that the plaintiff No.2 had purchased
the suit schedule property, which is site No.38 from
defendant No.1 and his brothers through registered sale
deed dated 17.10.1997. Subsequently, plaintiff No.2 had
gifted the suit schedule property in favour of plaintiff No.1
through registered gift deed dated 23.03.2017. It is also
an undisputed fact that the defendants are the owners of
site No.37.
22. It is the pleadings of the plaintiffs that site Nos.37
and 38 (suit schedule property) are situated adjacent to
each other and that both sites measure East to West 40
feet and North to South 60 feet and defendants site No.37
is a corner site. It is also pleaded by the plaintiffs in the
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
plaint that sites were formed in Sy.nos.11, 12/1 and 47/1
of Kothanur Village and that 13 sites were formed in the
same line, numbered as site Nos.37 to 49
having
dimensions of 40 x 60 feet.
23.
The defendants in their written statement
admitted that plaintiff No.2 had acquired the suit property
(Site
No.38)
through
registered
sale
deed
dated
17.10.1997 executed by defendant No.1 and his brothers.
Therefore, the defendants are not disputing the fact that
plaintiffs are owners of site No.38 which is suit schedule
property. But, it is the case of defendants that the
plaintiffs on the guise of claiming ownership over site
No.38, plaintiffs are trying to encroach the site No.37.
But, it is the case of the plaintiffs that the defendants have
encroached upon site No.38.
and
counter
allegations
Considering the allegations
made
by
the
plaintiffs
and
defendants, the plaintiffs have filed suit for declaration,
possession and permanent injunction.
Therefore, when
this being the dispute arose, the plaintiffs have exercised
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
their right in filing the suit for seeking declaratory relief of
title and possession and also removal of encroachment.
But the defendants have not filed any counter claim in the
written statement.
As discussed above, the defendants
have admitted that the plaintiffs are owners of the suit
schedule property, which is site No.38.
24.
Initially, before formation of the layout, the
defendants were owners of the land bearing Sy.nos.11,
12/1 and 47/2. It is the case of plaintiffs that defendants
have formed layout and got the layout plan approved by
the Kothanur Gram Panchayat and the defendants have
sold site No.38, which is suit schedule property to plaintiff
No.2 through registered sale deed dated 17.10.1997.
Ex.P2 is the sale deed dated 17.10.1997.
Therefore,
plaintiff No.2 acquired the suit schedule property through
registered sale deed dated 17.101997 and became owner
of the property.
defendants.
This fact is not disputed by the
Thereafter, plaintiff No.2 had gifted the suit
schedule property in favour of plaintiff No.1. Therefore, in
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
this regard, the findings given by the Trial Court that
plaintiffs are owners of site No.38 which is morefully
described in plaint schedule property is correct, legal and
is as per evidence.
25.
Consequently, the plaintiffs got their names
mutated in the revenue records and accordingly produced
documentary
evidence
encumbrance certificates.
such
as
tax
paid
receipts,
Therefore, the Trial Court is
correct in holding that the plaintiffs are having title and
ownership over the suit schedule property, which is site
No.38.
26.
When the defendants are claiming that the
plaintiffs are encroaching upon site No.37 but they have
not put forward any claim either by filing the suit or by
raising counterclaim in the written statement in the suit
filed by the plaintiffs.
During the course of cross-
examination of D.W.1, it was suggested to D.W.1 that
what is the measurement of site No.37, the answer given
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
by D.W.1 is that the dimensions of site No.37 is 80 x 60
feet. For the first time in his evidence, D.W.1 has stated
that the dimensions of site No.37 is 80 x 60 feet but the
defendants have not stated in the written statement and
also in the examination-in-chief that the dimensions of site
No.37 as 80 x 60 feet.
Therefore, D.W.1 has stated for
the first time during the course of cross-examination that
the dimensions of site No.37 as 80 x 60 feet, which is
nothing but an attempt being made by defendants to claim
site of the plaintiffs also.
Therefore, the evidence of the
defendants is proved to be false one. In this regard, the
Trial Court, has correctly appreciated the evidence on
record and held that the defendants have failed to prove
that the dimensions of site No.37 is 80 x 60 feet.
27.
Ex.P80 is the photocopy of the layout plan.
According to the plaintiffs, the said layout plan was given
to plaintiff No.2 by defendant No.1 and his brothers at the
time of registration of sale deed dated 17.10.1997 when
they sold site No.38, which is suit schedule property in
- 25 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
favour of plaintiff No.2.
during the evidence.
The same has been produced
The defendants have disputed the
Ex.P80 layout plan, on the ground that they have not
furnished the layout plan to plaintiff No.2 at the time of
registration of sale deed dated 17.10.1997.
When the
plaintiffs cross-examined D.W.1 regarding this, the D.W.1
has given an evasive answer and found that D.W.1 has
suffered
inconvenience
examination
conducted
during
the
by
plaintiffs
the
course
of
and
crossthis
is
correctly observed by the Trial Court. Therefore, the Trial
Court in this regard has correctly appreciated the evidence
on record in this regard, which needs no interference.
28.
Admittedly, the defendants are the owners of
the lands bearing Sy.nos.11, 12/1 and 47/1 of Kothanuru
Village and have formed layout and it is also admitted that
the defendants have sold the site No.38, which is suit
schedule property in favour of plaintiff No.2 by executing
registered sale deed.
Therefore, the defendants must
have provided the layout plan to plaintiff No.2 unless the
- 26 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
sale deed could not have been registered.
Unless
identification was made in the layout plan, there is no
question of execution of registered sale deed of selling the
site No.38 in favour of plaintiff No.2.
Therefore, the
defendants have formed layout as per Ex.P80 and upon
considering this layout plan though it is the photocopy of
the plan which is secondary evidence as per Sections 63
and 65 of the Indian Evidence Act.
29.
The plaintiffs have laid down the foundation for
secondary evidence by stating that the original layout plan
was with the defendants, since plaintiff No.2 was the
purchaser of the single site and therefore, there could not
have been any occasion for handing over the entire layout
plan to plaintiff No.2.
In this regard, the plaintiffs have
well laid down the foundation upon leading secondary
evidence, which is Ex.P80. Therefore, the Trial Court is
correct in believing the Ex.P80 layout plan.
Therefore, the
plaintiffs have proved the fact that the defendants have
formed layout in the aforesaid survey numbers and as per
- 27 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
the said layout plan, the site Nos.37 to 49, totally 13 site
numbers were formed in the same line.
Site No.37,
belonging to the defendants is a corner site having
dimensions 40 x 60 feet and also it is proved that the
dimensions of site No.38 which is suit schedule property is
also 40 x 60 feet. When this is the factual position, upon
considering the pleadings and evidence of record, as
discussed above, the plaintiffs have proved that they are
the owners of site No.38 and the defendants are owners of
site No.37.
30.
Then, the question that arises is, who has
encroached upon the property?
31.
This Court, during the course of arguments in
the appeal, has appointed the Court Commissioner to find
out the encroachment over site Nos.37 and 38. The Court
Commissioner has given two reports along with sketch. In
the first report, the Court Commissioner has earmarked
the dimensions of site Nos.37 and 38 conjointly but
- 28 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
without mentioning site Nos.37 and 38. Therefore, upon
the memo of instructions submitted by both the learned
counsel, this Court directed the Court Commissioner to
carry out measurement for the second time. Accordingly,
the Court Commissioner submitted the report for the
second time clearly identifying the site Nos.37 and 38.
Upon considering these two sketches along with the report
of the Court Commissioner, it is found that the same tally
with the layout plan as per Ex.P80.
32.
As discussed above, the dimensions of site
No.38 is 40 x 60 feet and also as per layout plan Ex.P80
the dimensions of site No.38 is also 40 x 60 feet. But in
the sketch of Court Commissioner report, the dimensions
of site No.37 is shown as 34 feet from West to East
towards northern side and 19 feet from West to East
towards southern side. The length of the site shown from
North to South is 61 feet towards eastern side and 60 feet
length from North to South towards western side.
From
the Court Commissioner’s report, it is revealed that the
- 29 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
portion towards the eastern side of the property from
North to South is shown as road. Therefore, subsequently
the BBMP authorities might have acquired the portion of
the site No.37 for formation of the road.
The Court
Commissioner has shown dimensions of site No.38, as 40
feet from West to East towards southern side and 7 feet
and 33 feet from West to East on the northern side. There
is a triangle area shown in site No.38. From the eastern
side, the length of the site from North to South is shown as
60 feet and towards western side the length of the site
from North to South is shown as 59’.
Therefore, upon
considering the report of the Court Commissioner which
tallies with the layout plan marked as Ex.P80, the plaintiffs
have made out a case that they are the owners of the site
No.38, which is suit schedule property and the defendants
have encroached the site No.38 which is correctly assessed
and appreciated by the Trial Court and therefore. the
appreciation of evidence made by the Trial Court is found
- 30 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
to
be
justifiable
and
correct
one,
which
needs
no
plaintiffs
have
produced
interference.
33.
Further,
the
photographs showing that sheds were put up on site No.38
which is also corroborated by the report of the Court
Commissioner.
Thus, the plaintiffs have proved that the
defendants have encroached upon site No.38.
34.
Therefore, the plaintiffs have proved by placing
evidence on record that they are the owners of the suit
schedule property which is site No.38 and that the
defendants have encroached upon site No.38 and put up a
shed. Therefore, the Trial Court is correct in declaring the
plaintiffs are owners of site No.38, which is suit schedule
property and also that the defendants have encroached
upon site No.38 by putting up a shed.
Accordingly, the
Trial Court has correctly decreed the suit for declaration,
possession and also for mandatory injunction for removal
of the construction made in site No.38.
- 31 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
35.
Upon considering the evidence on record as
discussed above, this Court does not find any perversity in
the approach and the appreciation of evidence made by
the Trial Court. Therefore, decreeing the suit in favour of
plaintiffs declaring the plaintiffs as owners of site No.38
and decreeing the suit for possession and also for
mandatory injunction for removal of the shed constructed
on site No.38 and also granting permanent injunction
against the defendants are found to be correct, legal and
justifiable one. Accordingly, I answer point Nos.1 and 2 in
the affirmative and point No.3 in the negative.
POINT NO.4
36.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellants/
defendants submitted that the suit is barred by limitation.
With reference to the evidence of P.W.1, the learned
counsel submitted that during the course of crossexamination, P.W.1 admitted that he came to know about
the encroachment by the defendants in the year 2005.
- 32 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
But, upon considering the cross-examination of P.W.1,
PW.1 has denied the suggestion put by the defendants
that the plaintiffs came to know in the year 2005 that the
defendants were in possession of the suit schedule
property. The suggestion put by the defendants was
denied by P.W.1. Therefore, such denial of the suggestion
does not mean that the plaintiffs had the knowledge of the
encroachment of the property by the defendants in the
year 2005.
37.
Further, in the same cross-examination, P.W.1
has stated that in the year 2005, the defendants did not
allow the plaintiffs to enter inside the suit property. This is
the only statement made by PW.1 to the effect that the
defendants did not allow the plaintiffs to enter site No.38,
which
does
not
mean
that
the
plaintiff
knew
encroachment of defendants in the year 2005.
the
Not
allowing the plaintiffs to enter the site and coming to know
- 33 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
the encroachment by the defendants are two different
aspects.
38.
Upon considering the cause of action pleaded in
the plaint in paragraph No.7 of the plaint, it is stated that
on 14.07.2013, the son of plaintiff No.2 while traveling
near the suit schedule property found that the defendants
were trying to put a temporary shed in site Nos.37 and 38.
Therefore, he immediately resisted the action of the
defendants and at that time the defendants threatened the
son of plaintiff No.2. In this regard, he has lodged a
complaint before the police.
39.
When this being the cause of action pleaded
that the plaintiffs came to know about the encroachment
made by the defendants for the first time on 14.07.2013,
contrary to the same, the defendants have not elicited
anything in the course of cross-examination to show that
the plaintiffs had knowledge of the encroachment even
prior to year 2013 much less in the year 2005.
As
- 34 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
discussed above, the suggestion made by the defendants
to P.W.1 during cross-examination that the plaintiffs came
to know about the encroachment in the year 2005, was
denied by P.W.1. Further, it is the evidence of P.W.1 that
in the year 2005, the defendants did not allow the
plaintiffs to enter site No.38, this does not mean that the
plaintiffs had knowledge regarding encroachment by the
defendants in the year 2005. It is the case of the plaintiffs
that, in the year 2013 the son of plaintiff No.2 noticed that
construction was being carried out on the suit schedule
property. Therefore, the said date is the reckoning date of
cause of action for filing the suit for possession.
Hence,
the suit filed for possession along with the reliefs of
declaration and mandatory injunction is within the period
of limitation as per Article 65 of the the Limitation Act.
Therefore, there is no merit found in the arguments of
learned counsel for the appellants.
Hence, it is proved
that the suit is filed within the period of limitation.
Accordingly, I answer point No.4 in the negative.
- 35 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
40.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellants/
defendants submitted that the Trial Court has decreed by
awarding damages without framing any issue in this
regard. The plaintiffs have pleaded in the plaint that they
are claiming damages from the defendants and which is
denied by defendants in their written statement.
When
there is an assertion by the plaintiffs and denial by the
defendants in this regard, then the Trial Court ought to
have framed an issue the Trial Court regarding the award
of damages.
But upon perusal of the records and the
judgment and decree, it is found that no specific issue was
framed regarding the award of damages.
When in the
absence of such an issue, the defendants did not venture
into the adjudicatory process to dispute the claim for
damages.
Therefore, awarding damages without framing
an issue in this regard is not correct.
Therefore, while
awarding damages, it is incumbent upon the Trial Court to
frame
proper
and
appropriate
issue
based
on
the
pleadings. Suppose, if the Trial Court omits to frame an
- 36 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
issue, both the parties in the suit are having liberty for
recasting issues upon request made to the Trial Court.
But, in this regard, the plaintiffs have not made any
attempt requesting the Trial Court to frame an issue
concerning damages.
Therefore, there is failure on the
part of the plaintiffs to approach the Trial Court seeking for
framing of an appropriate issue in this regard. Hence, to
this extent, the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court in awarding damages is liable to be interfered with.
Therefore, the award of damages by the Trial Court
without framing an issue is not correct.
Therefore,
judgment and decree is interfered with only to the extent
of the award of damages.
Accordingly, I answer point
No.5 in the negative.
41.
Therefore, the judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court is liable to be confirmed insofar as the
grant
of
concerned.
relief
of
declaratory
and
possession
are
The judgment and decree is liable to be
- 37 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
interfered with insofar as the award of damages is
concerned.
Accordingly, the award of damages is set
aside and the remaining portions of the judgment and
decree are confirmed.
decree is modified.
To this extent, the judgment and
Accordingly, I answer point No.6 in
partly affirmative.
42.
Hence, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
i)
The Regular First Appeal is allowed in part
with
costs
payable
by
defendants
to
plaintiffs.
ii)
The judgment and decree dated 21.08.2024
passed in O.S.No.1943/2019 by the XXXVII
Addl. City Civil & Sessions Judge (CCH-38),
Bengaluru City are confirmed insofar as the
grant of decree of declaratory relief and
possession
concerned.
and
permanent
injunction
is
- 38 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:50907
RFA No. 2885 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753752024
iii)
The judgment and decree is set aside only to
the extent of the award of damages is
concerned. The other findings, observations
and the decree are kept intact.
iv)
Draw decree accordingly.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
KA – paras 1 to 20
UN – paras 21 to end
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review