Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
%
$
&
& '
()
&
((
*
!
"
" "
"
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
"
#
$
%
&
!%
%%
$
%
"
!
"
"
$
-2-
"
(
%
"' (
%
%
%
" " "!
$
)
"
" * ( ((
%%
( ( ( ' ( ( '
*
'
%
*! $
&
! $
&
%
(
'
'(
!($
'+
'+
%
%
'
'*
&
( ! $
' +
*!,$
"
$
%
!
"
%
%
&
.
-
-
"
+
/01 23404056 01 70839 :693;
,>,;0?
:;,?1/,
,6/04,
( (
,>,0614 4/3 234040563; ,<<:139
,;0106> 5:4 57
;0A3
5"'
3<4056
5"(
28"
(
(
'+
; C
3<40561
+
'
'(
* ,69
'
*! $ ,69
; C
<4
!75; 1/54 E " "
014;0<4 ,69
3<4056
3110561 :9>3
! $!($ 57
<4F$
/,;,40=,
5;;" 5"* ( ((
( (( ;3>0143;39 B=
3<40561
'
45 @:,1/ 4/3 2;5<33906>1
75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/,B83 :693;
( ( ( ' '
(
/5C?
580<3
'
'+
'*
,69
3<4056 *!,$!<$
;3D364056 57
,69 '**!,$
5;;:24056
236906> 56 4/3 7083 57
,8,B:;,>0"
;8"
-3-
("
:A,;
/3 7,<4:,8 A,4;0G 57 4/3 <,13 01
580<3 6123<45; %
<5A28,064 4/,4
708806> :2 57
,;6,4,?,
'
770<3
580<3
D,<,6<031 57
54070<,4056 9,439 ( "
"( (
" "
36>,8:;: 859>39 4/3
32,;4A364 /,9 <,8839 75;
580<3
:B 6123<45; ,1 23;
,69 06 4/3 361:06> 3G,A06,4056
<3;4,06 <,6909,431 /,D3 <5AA04439 A,82;,<40<3 ,69 56 36@:0;=
04 C,1 75:69 4/,4 ,856> C04/ <,6909,431 54/3; A390,45;1 ,69
580<3 5770<0,81 /,D3 06D58D39 06 4/3 A,82;,<40<3"
14;36>4/ 57 4/3 1,09 <5A28,064 4/3 ;312569364
;3>0143;39 %
5"'
,>,0614 563
6 4/3
580<3 06040,88=
33;31/ ,69 54/3;1 06
;0A3
( (("
"
:B13@:3648= 4/3
D093 5;93; 9,439
36>,8:;:"
580<3
,8,B:;,>0
" '"( (( 4;,6173;;39 4/3 06D3140>,4056 45
<<5;906>8=
4/3 1,09
06D3140>,4056 ,69 06 ,88 ,;;31439
4/01 234040563;"
5AA0110563;
580<3 455? :2 4/3
' ,<<:139 23;1561 06<8:906>
743; <5A283406> 06D3140>,4056 4/3 1,09
580<3
8,09 </,;>3 1/334 ,>,0614 4/3 234040563; ,69 54/3;1 75; 4/3
,75;3A36405639 57736<31 B= ,;;,=06> 4/3 234040563; ,1 ,<<:139
5"( "
"
:B13@:3648= , 1:2283A364,;= </,;>3 1/334 C,1 70839
"( (
:693;
3<4056
'
(
(
( (
-4-
( ' '
+
'
'(
* ,69
3<4056
'
'+
'+
'*
,69
3<4056 *!,$!<$ *! $ ,69
! $!($ 57 " "
'"
/3
</,;>3
,69 '**!,$ ; C
8,69
,<<:139
:B
'
; C
<4"
1/334
A,43;0,81
234040563; C/5 C,1 C5;?06> ,1 4/3
580<3
3<40561
0D01056
901<8513
32:4=
,8,B:;>,0
4/,4
4/3
:23;064369364 57
014;0<4 ,883>398= <,8839
5"(' ,69 (+ ,69 4589 4/3A 4/,4 4/3;3 ,;3 <5A28,0641
,>,0614 4/3A C04/ ;3>,;9 45 A,82;,<40<3 06 4/3 3G,A06,4056 57
,69 ,883>398= 93A,6939
1"
75; 654 45 ;3>0143;
4/3 <,13 ,>,0614 4/3A"
5C3D3;
4/3A138D31 ,69 ,<<:139
5" ' 4/3 234040563; ,>;339 75; , 1:A
1"
56 , 63>540,4056 B34C336
,69 ;3<30D39 4/3 1,09 0883>,8 >;,4070<,4056
4/;5:>/ ,<<:139
5" ' B= C,= 57 <,1/ ,4
9,655; ;5,9" &04/
4/313 </,;>31 4/3 234040563; C,1 ,;;31439 56
8,43; ;383,139 56 B,08 56
B375;3 4/01
0>/
"
"( ( "
"
"( (( ,69
36<3 4/3 234040563; 01
5:;4 45 @:,1/ 4/3 2;5<33906>1 ,>,0614 /0A"
"
3,;9 83,;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; ,69 83,;639
5:;4
5D3;6A364 83,93; 75; ;312569364
+"
2,;4 7;5A :;>06> 13D3;,8 <5643640561 4/3 83,;639
4,43"
3605; <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; 2;0A,;08= <56436939 4/,4 4/3
-5-
<;0A3 C,1 ;3>0143;39 ,69 06D3140>,439 B= 4/3 ;312569364
C/0</ <5A31 :693;
,8,B:;,>0
04=
580<3 ,69 654 C04/06 4/3
H:;0190<4056 06 C/0</ 4/3 234040563; C,1 06</,;>3 0"3"
:B 90D01056
,8,B:;,>0"
580<3
8,69,
1 1:</ 4/3;3 C,1 65 5<<,1056 45 4/01
234040563; 304/3; 45 2;5A013 5; ;3<30D3 ,6= ,A5:64 7;5A
,<<:139
51"(' ,69 (+ 75; 654 45 ;3>0143; 4/3 <,13 ,>,0614
4/3A"
3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/,4 4/3 06D3140>,4056 9531 654
;3D3,8 4/,4 4/3 234040563; ,69 ,<<:139
5" ' ?63C 3,</ 54/3;
,69 4/3;3 ,;3 65 <,88 934,081 B34C336 4/3A"
*"
<<5;906> 45 4/3 83,;639
3605; <5:6138 4/5:>/ 04
01 ,883>39 4/,4 4/3 234040563; ;3<30D39
580<3 C3;3 ,B83 45 ;3<5D3; 568=
2511311056 57 4/3 234040563;"
1"
4/3
1" +
7;5A 4/3
<<5;906> 45 4/3 83,;639
3605;
<5:6138 4/3 1,09 ,A5:64 B3856>1 45 4/3 234040563; C/5 /,9
5B4,0639 , >589 85,6 7;5A
:4/554 %06,6<3
5;25;,4056 56
" '"( (( B= 2839>06> >589 5;6,A3641 ,69 ;3<30D39 4/3 1,09
A563= 45 4/3
,6?
,6? ,<<5:64 57 4/3 234040563; 06 4/3
C/0</ C,1 C04/9;,C6 56
" '"( (("
,;6,4,?,
/5:>/ 4/3
234040563; 5773;39 4/01 3G28,6,4056 C04/ 95<:A3641 4/3 1,A3
/,1
<561093;39
B=
4/3
;312569364
580<3"
,148=
/3
-6-
<56436939 4/,4
5" '
3G<324 4/3 D58:64,;= 14,43A364 57 ,<<:139
,B158:438= 65 54/3; 203<3 57 3D0936<3 <0;<:A14,6<3
,223,;1 ,>,0614 4/01 234040563; 45 0A280<,43 /0A 06 4/3 ,883>39
<;0A3" 6 1:</ <0;<:A14,6<3 4/3 57736<31 ,883>39 ,>,0614 4/01
234040563; 95 654 ,44;,<4 ,>,0614 /0A"
36<3 4/3 <56406:,4056 57
2;5<33906>1 ,>,0614 4/3 234040563; 01 654/06> B:4 ,B:13 57
2;5<311 57
5:;4"
<<5;906>8= /3 2;,=1 45 ,885C 4/3 23404056"
"
83,;639
;312569364
23<0,8
<5:6138
75;
4/3
4,43 1:BA04439 4/,4 4/5:>/ 4/3 234040563; 06040,88=
0A280<,439 06 4/3 ,883>39 <;0A3 B,139 56 4/3 D58:64,;=
14,43A364 57 ,<<:139
51"(' (+ ,69
' 4/3;3,743; B,139 56
4/3 D58:64,;= 14,43A364 57 4/01 234040563;
1" +
<,1/
C,1 130I39 ,4 /01 0614,6<3 D093 2,6</,6,A, C/0</ C,1 28,<39
06 2;523;4= 8014 06
%
5" * ( (("
<5:;13 57 06D3140>,4056 4/3 ;312569364
34,08
,<<:139
3>0143;1 !
51"(' ,69
234040563; ,<<:139
,;3
3D3;4/38311
9:;06> 4/3
580<3 5B4,0639 4/3
,88
$ 57 4/3 A5B083 6:AB3;1 57 234040563;
' ,69 4/513
,;3 06 4/3 6,A3 57
51" ' ,69 ('" 6 1:</ <0;<:A14,6<3 4/3;3
A,43;0,81 75;4/<5A06> ,>,0614 4/01 234040563; 75;
-7-
4/3 57736<31 /3 /,1 B336 </,;>3 1/33439"
36<3 /3 2;,=1 45
901A011 4/3 23404056"
"
/,D3 >0D36 A= ,6G05:1 <561093;,4056 B54/ 56 4/3
1:BA0110561 A,93 B= 4/3 83,;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 ;3123<40D3
2,;4031 ,69 4/3 95<:A3641 ,D,08,B83 56 ;3<5;9"
"
;3>014;,4056
<5:89
B3
>,4/3;39
<,13
;0A3
5AA0110563;
7;5A
5"'
;3<5;91
( ((
4/3
,743;
580<3
,8,B:;,>0 4;,6173;;39 4/3 06D3140>,4056 45
36>,8:;: D093 5;93; 9,439
" '"( (("
<<5;906>8= 4/3 1,09
580<3 455? :2 4/3 06D3140>,4056 ,69 ,;;31439
' ,<<:139
23;1561"
4/3 123<070<
/3 234040563; B306> ,<<:139
5"(
,883>,4056 ,D3;;39 06 4/3 </,;>3 1/334 ,>,0614 /0A 01 4/,4 /3
C,1 C5;?06> ,1
32:4=
:23;064369364 57
0D01056 <,8839 :2 ,<<:139
580<3 57
8,69
:B
51"(' ,69 (+ ,69 4589 4/3A 4/,4
4/3;3 ,;3 <5A28,0641 ,>,0614 4/3A C04/ ;3>,;9 45 , 1<,A 06 4/3
3G,A06,4056 C/0</ C,1 <569:<439 75; 1383<4056 45 4/3 2514 57
580<3
:B 6123<45; ,69 ,883>398= 93A,6939
75; 4/3A"
06<3 ,<<:139
1"
51"(' ,69 (+ C3;3 654 06 , 25104056
45 2,= 4/3 1,09 ,A5:64 04 C,1 ,>;339 4/,4 4/3= C088 2,= , 1:A
1"
45 /0A"
/3 234040563; ;3<30D39 4/3 1,09
-8-
0883>,8 >;,4070<,4056 75; 654 45 ;3>0143; ,6= <5A28,064 ,>,0614
,<<:139
51"(' ,69 (+ 06 4/3
1<,A B= 0675;A06> 4/3A 45
/,69 5D3; 4/3 A563= 45 ,<<:139
5" '
:9;,>5:9, J
" "
,408 C/5 01 4/3 2;0A3 ,<<:139 06 4/3 1<,A ,69 C,1 ?65C6 45
4/01 234040563; 2;05; 45 4/3 06<09364"
/3 </,;>3 1/334 A,43;0,81
7:;4/3; ;3D3,81 4/,4 4/3 ,A5:64 57
1"
5D3; 45 4/01 234040563; B= ,<<:139
5" ' ,4
665D,
,; B3,;06> ;3>014;,4056
"
5"
C,1 /,6939
(
9,655;
5,9 06 ,6
' *+"
743; 4/3 ,;;314 57 4/01 234040563; 4/3 ;312569364
580<3 130I39
1" +
,4 /01 0614,6<3 ,69 04 01 123<070<,88=
14,439 B= 4/01 234040563; 4/,4
23;156,8 3G236131"
28,<39 B375;3 4/3
1"+ '
C,1 12364 75; /01
/3 130I39 ,A5:64 57
,>014;,43 06 %
1" +
C,1
5" * ( ((" /3 3G28,6,4056
5773;39 B= 4/3 234040563; 01 4/,4 4/3 1,09 ,A5:64 C,1 5B4,0639
B= /0A 7;5A
:4/554 %06,6<3
5;25;,4056 B= 2839>06> 4/3 >589
5;6,A3641 56
" '"( (( ,69 ;3<30D39 4/3 A563= 45 /01
,;6,4,?,
,<<5:64
,6?
,69
C04/9;,C6
4/3
1,A3
" '"( (( ,223,;1 45 B3 654 , 2;5B,B83 93736<3
,A5:64 C,1 130I39 ,4 4/3 0614,6<3 57 234040563; 56
,1 4/3
"
"( ((
0"3" ,743; 8,213 57 (( 9,=1" %:;4/3; 4/3 234040563; /,1 654 >0D36
-9-
,6= 1:</ 931<;024056 ;3<3024 57 4/3 <,1/ C04/9;,C6 7;5A 4/3
,6? 56 4/,4 9,="
("
;312569364
3 4/,4 ,1 04 A,= 4/3 <,88 934,081 5B4,0639 B= 4/3
580<3 ;3D3,81 4/,4 56
2/563 <,881 B34C336 ,<<:139
"( (
4/3;3 ,;3 75:;
5" ' ,69 4/01 234040563;"
D58:64,;= 14,43A364 57 ,<<:139
,743; <5A2834056 57
"
/3
5"(' ;3D3,81 4/,4 563 C33?
3G,A06,4056 4/3 234040563; <,8839 /0A
4/;5:>/ /01 A5B083 2/563 ,69 93A,6939 A563= 654 45
0A280<,43 /0A ,69 ,<<:139
5"(+ 06 4/3 1<,A"
D58:64,;= 14,43A364 57 ,<<:139
934,081 57 ,<<:139
/3 1,09
5"(' <5;;5B5;,431 4/3 <,88
5" ' ,69 4/3 234040563;" %:;4/3; 9:;06> 4/3
<5:;13 57 130I:;3 57 4/3 ,A5:64 ,4 4/3 0614,6<3 57 234040563; ,
934,08 130I3; 2,6</,6,A, C,1 9;,C6 B= 4/3
,69
580<3 563
A31/
01/C,6,4/ ,;3 4/3 C04631131 75; 4/3 1,09 2,6</,6,A," 6
1:</ <0;<:A14,6<31
56 5D3;,88 23;:1,8 57 4/3 </,;>3 1/334
A,43;0,81 06 A= <561093;39 D03C 4/3;3 ,;3 1:770<0364
A,43;0,81 75;4/<5A06> ,>,0614 4/01 234040563; 75; 4/3
57736<31 /3 /,1 B336 </,;>3 1/33439" 4 01 23;406364 45 A364056
,4 4/01 H:6<4:;3 4/3 234040563; B306> 4/3
32:4=
:23;064369364
- 10 -
580<3
;312569364
"
65 D36>3,6<3 C/,4153D3; ,>,0614 /0A B= 4/3
580<3 45 7,8138= 0A280<,43 /0A 06 4/3 ,883>39 <;0A3"
1:</
<0;<:A14,6<3
@:,1/06>
4/3
<;0A06,8
2;5<33906>1 01 <,8839 75; 568= 06 , <,13 C/3;3 4/3 <5A28,064
9531 654 901<8513 ,6= 57736<3
5; 01 7;0D585:1
D3G,405:1 5;
522;3110D3" 7 4/3 ,883>,40561 134 5:4 06 4/3 <5A28,064 95 654
<561404:43 57736<3 57 C/0</ <5>60I,6<3 /,1 B336 4,?36 B= 4/3
A,>014;,43 04 01 5236 75; 4/01
5:;4 45 @:,1/ 4/3 1,A3" 4 01 654
63<311,;= 4/,4 , A340<:85:1 ,6,8=101 57 <,13 1/5:89 B3 9563
B375;3 4;0,8 45 7069 5:4 C/34/3; 4/3 <,13 C5:89 369 06 <56D0<4056
5; ,<@:044,8" 7 04 ,223,;1 56 , ;3,906> 57 4/3 <5A28,064 ,69
<561093;,4056 57 4/3 ,883>,4056 4/3;306
06 4/3 80>/4 57 4/3
14,43A364 A,93 56 5,4/ 4/,4 4/3 06>;3903641 57 4/3 57736<3 ,;3
901<85139 4/3;3 C5:89 B3 65 H:14070<,4056 75; 4/01
5:;4 45
0643;73;3 ,1 /389 06 4/3 <,13 57
;325;439 06
'"
901<85131 ,
"
6 4/3 0614,64 <,13
4/3 </,;>3 1/334 A,43;0,81
<,13 ,>,0614 4/3 234040563; 75; 4/3
57736<3 /3 /,1 B336 </,;>3 1/33439" 6 1:</ <0;<:A14,6<31
- 11 -
4/3 1,A3 /,1 45 B3 431439 06 , 934,0839 4;0,8"
36<3 C04/5:4
3G2;31106> ,6= 5206056 56 4/3 A3;041 57 4/3 <,13 1:770<3 45
/589 4/,4 4/3 2;5<33906>1 <,6654 B3 @:,1/39 ,4 4/01 14,>3"
<<5;906>8=
!" #"
4/3
23404056
8,<?1
A3;041
,69
4/3
$!"
,)
&
%
(
%
5"-
5"- (
1,A3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review