Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
TH
RESERVED ON 7
APRIL 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 9TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 630 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI M.J. PRADEEP KUMAR
S/O LATE M. JAYASHEELA SETTY
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
PARTNER OF M/S RAGHAVENDRA ENTERPRISES
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE
AT NO.1019/2, JAYALAKSHMI VILAS ROAD
CHAMARAJAPURAM
MYSURU - 570 001
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI ANAGHA NARASIMHA C.N., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI AJIT P.B., ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by K
P SWETHA
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
AND:
1.
SRI SRINIVASA KANTHARAJE URS V.S.
PROPRIETOR OF
M/S NEW SATELLITE VIDEO VISIONS
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT NO.897/1
KANTHARAJE URS ROAD
LAKSHMIPURAM
MYSURU - 570 004
PRESENTLY AT NO.949/1
2ND MAIN ROAD
-2-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
JAYALAKSHMIPURAM
MYSURU - 570 004
MR. M MANJUNATHA (DEAD BY LRS)
S/O. SRI MYLARAISH
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
2.
SMT. N SUMA
W/O LATE MANJUNATHA
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
3.
MEGHANA
D/O LATE MANJUNATHA
AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS
4.
PALLAVI
D/O LATE MANJUNATHA
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS
R-2 TO R-4 ARE R/AT NO.1694,
"MALLIKARJUNA KRUPA"
2ND CROSS, ANIKETHANA ROAD
KUVEMPUNAGAR, MYSURU - 23
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
AT NO.1019/2, JAYALAKSHMI VILAS ROAD
CHAMARAJAPURAM, MYSURU - 570 001
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI RAGHAVENDRA K., ADVOCATE FOR R-1 &
SRI HARIKRISHNA M.S., ADVOCATE FOR R-2 TO R-4)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
13(1)(A) OF COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT 2015, PRAYING TO
CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN COM.O.S NO. 224/2023, ON THE
FILE OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT & II ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, MYSURU, AND SET ASIDE
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 04.09.2025, IN COM.
O.S NO. 224/2023, ON THE FILE OF THE COMMERCIAL COURT
& II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, MYSURU.
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED
FOR
JUDGMENT,
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS
DAY,
JUDGMENT
WAS
PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
-3-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU ,CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU ,CHIEF JUSTICE)
1.
The appellant has filed the present appeal under Section
13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, impugning the
judgment and decree dated 04.09.2025 [impugned judgment]
passed by the Commercial Court and II Additional District and
Sessions
Judge,
Mysuru
[Commercial
Court]
in
COM.O.S.No.224/2023. The suit was originally instituted as
O.S.No.93/2017 before jurisdictional Civil Court at Mysuru and was
subsequently, transferred to and re-numbered by the Commercial
Court as COM.O.S.No.224/2023.
2.
In terms of the impugned judgment and decree, the learned
Commercial Court directed the defendants in the suit to hand over
the business of CA T.V signals network in the area mentioned in
the sketch attached to the lease deed dated 25.04.2009 (Exhibit
P1) along with the material, equipments, T.V.sets etc., and
subscribers as mentioned in Schedule 'B' (Annexure-A) and
Schedule 'C' (Annexure-B) of the lease deed. The learned
Commercial Court further directed the defendants to pay rent to the
-4-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
Multi-System Operator [MSO] from 25.04.2012 till the date of
surrender; to pay arrears of rent of ₹3,90,000/-; and to pay
damages at the rate of ₹50,000/- (per month) from the date of suit
till handing over of the business.
3.
The appellant, who was arrayed as defendant No.1 in the
said suit, was a partner along with defendant No.2 (Sri
M.Manjunatha) in a firm carrying on business under the name of
M/s. Raghavendra Enterprises. Defendant No. 2 expired, and his
legal heirs (wife and daughters) were brought on record as
defendants Nos. 2(a) to 2(c). They are arrayed as respondents
Nos. 2 to 4 in the present appeal.
THE PLAINTIFF’S CASE
4.
Respondent No.1 was the plaintiff in the said suit. He
claimed that he was carrying on the business of providing cable TV
network services under the sole proprietorship concern, M/s.New
Satellite Video Visions. He claimed that he had entered into a lease
deed dated 25.04.2009 [the lease deed] with M/s.Raghavendra
Enterprises, through its partners, defendant Nos. 1 and 2, to run
the business of cable TV and network operations, which were
being carried on at the premises bearing No. 897/1, Kantharaje Urs
Road, Lakshmipuram, Mysuru [the premises]. The plaintiff claimed
-5-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
that, under the lease agreement, he handed over all machinery and
equipment used in the business, as well as the list of subscribers
annexed to the lease deed. Under the lease deed, the defendants
were liable to pay a monthly rent of ₹35,000/- and had also
deposited a refundable security deposit of ₹15,00,000/-. The term
of the lease deed was three years, with effect from 01.05.2009 to
31.04.2012. According to the plaintiff, the defendants paid the
lease rent as agreed till 30.04.2012. However, they failed to pay
the same thereafter. He claimed that the defendants had agreed
that future lease rent be deducted from the security deposit of
₹15,00,000/-. The plaintiff also averred that the defendants paid
rent to the landlord of the premises.
5.
The plaintiff claimed that since the defendants had failed to
pay the lease rent, he served a legal notice dated 14.11.2016 on
the defendants, determining the lease from 05.01.2017, and calling
upon the defendants to surrender the lease along with the material
and the subscribers as mentioned in Schedule 'B' (Annexure-A)
and Schedule 'C' (Annexure-B) of the lease deed. The plaintiff
claimed that as on 31.12.2016, the defendants were in arrears of
rent to the extent of ₹18,90,000/- and after adjusting the security
deposit amount of ₹15,00,000/-, ₹3,90,000/- was due and payable
-6-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
as on the said date. The plaintiff also claimed damages at the rate
of ₹50,000/- per month from 05.01.2017, the date on which the
plaintiff claimed to have determined the lease.
THE DEFENCE
6.
The defendants contested the suit and raised several pleas,
including that the suit was not maintainable and was barred by
limitation. The defendants did not dispute that they had entered into
the lease deed (lease deed dated 25.04.2009). However, they
claimed that there was no contractual relationship between the
parties after the lease deed expired. They denied any oral
agreement extending the lease deed and claimed that they were
discharged from any further performance of obligations upon
termination of the lease deed. They also claimed that they were not
running the cable TV business under the name of 'M/s.New
Satellite Video Visions'.
THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
7.
The learned Commercial Court framed the following issues
for consideration:
1. Whether the Plaintiff proves that they have leased
the business M/s New Satellite Video Vision as
cable TV networking programme in favour of
Defendant and such lease has been terminated
from 05.01.2017 in accordance with law?
-7-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
2. Whether the Plaintiff proves that he has leased the
materials and equipments as described in
Annexure -A and B in favour of Defendants ?
3. Whether the Plaintiff proves that the Defendants
are in arrears of rent of Rs.3,90,000/-?
4. Whether the Plaintiff proves that the Defendant is
liable to hand over the business in CA TV Signal
Network
business
along
with
materials,
equipment, TV sets etc., and subscribers as
described in Annexure-A & B in the Lease Deed
and housed in A schedule property ?
5. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for the suit claim as
sought ?
6. What order or decree?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES
1. Whether the Defendants prove that the Firm
should have been made as party to the suit and
the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties?
2. Whether the Defendants further prove that, suit is
barred by limitation?"
8.
Issues Nos. 1 to 5 were decided in the affirmative, that is, in
favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. Additional issues
were also framed and decided in the negative. The learned
Commercial Court found that there was no material to establish
that the business in question had been handed over to the plaintiff
after completion of the lease period. Further, there was material to
establish that the defendants were carrying on business. In view of
the said findings, the learned Commercial Court held that the
-8-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
defendants are liable to pay arrears of rent and to hand over the
materials, equipment, and the list of subscribers as agreed.
9.
The learned Commercial Court decided the question whether
the suit was liable to be dismissed on non-joinder of parties, in the
negative. The Court held that since partners of M/s.Raghavendra
Enterprises were arrayed as parties; the suit could not be
dismissed on the ground that the firm was not a party to the suit.
Insofar as the issue of limitation is concerned (additional issue
number No.2), the learned Commercial Court held that the cause of
action would arise from the date when the defendants refused to
hand over the business to the plaintiff and therefore, the suit was
not barred by limitation.
REASONS AND CONCLUSIONS
10.
There is no dispute that the parties entered into an
agreement dated 25.04.2009 (the lease deed, Exhibit P1), and the
plaintiff's claims are based on its terms. The recitals of the lease
deed state that the plaintiff was carrying on business under the
name and style of M/s. New Satellite Video Visions. The second
party to the lease deed (M/s. Raghavendra Enterprises) was also
engaged in the same business in and around Mysuru City.
-9-
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
11.
We consider it apposite to set out some of the terms of the
lease deed that are relevant for adjudicating the disputes. The
same are reproduced below:
"1. The term of the lease is for a period of three (3)
years with effect from 01/05/2009 to 30/04/2012 (First
of May Two Thousand and Nine to Thirtieth of April
Two Thousand and Twelve).
2.
The FIRST PARTY has agreed to LEASE out
the business and the network under the name and
style M/s NEW SATEILITE VIDEO VISIONS with its
subscribers listed in Annexure "B' and also agreed to
give all the carriage from his control room to its
customers TV set, which are listed in Annexure 'A'
through a joint survey.
3.
In consideration to the LEASE of the said
business the SECOND PARTY has agreed to pay a
sum of Rs. 15,00,000/- (Rupees Fifteen lakhs only) as
security deposit and monthly rent of Rs. 35,000/(Rupees Thirty five thousand only) to the FIRST
PARTY. Monthly rent of Rs. 35,000/- shall have to be
paid to the FIRST PARTY by the SECOND PARTY
within fifth of every month.
4.
The SECOND PARTY is entitled to receive back
the security deposit of Rs. 15,00,000/- (Rupees
Fifteen lakhs only) at the time of surrendering the
LEASE on expiry of the stipulated period of three
years and same shall carry no interest.
5.
The SECOND PARTY has agreed to surrender
or give the position all the carriage which will be in his
position at the time of surrendering the LEASE to the
FIRST PARTY in good conditions.
6.
The SECOND PARTY has agreed to surrender
all the subscribers of the number listed in annexure 'B'
in case if the number of subscribers is decreased
except DTH reason, then the SECOND PARTY has
agreed to pay a sum of Rs. 6000/- per subscriber.
- 10 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
7.
The SECOND PARTY has also agreed that he
will surrender the expanded subscribers with carriage
to the FIRST PARTY if any, at the time of
surrendering the LEASE, for which the SECOND
PARTY is not entitled for any benefit in terms of
money as he has enjoyed the subscription benefits
from the date of connection till the date of surrender.
8.
The SECOND PARTY alone responsible for the
payment of signal charges, salary to the employees,
electricity bill, telephone bill, maintenance expenses,
any type of Tax payable to state and center and any
damages claimed by any claimants during the period
of LEASE, any accident occurs during the period of
LEASE to any of the employees, customers and
public.
9.
The SECOND PARTY has agreed to pay the
escalation in signal charges payable to MSO.
10. The FIRST PARTY is entitled to enter, verily the
business, accounts maintained by the SECOND
PARTY during the period of LEASE.
11. The FIRST PARTY is entitled to receive dues
from its customers listed in annexure 'B' if any for
which the SECOND PARTY has also agreed to cooperate in collecting the said dues and vice versa."
12.
It is also relevant to refer to the schedule to the lease deed,
which is reproduced below:
SCHEDULE
1. Name of the Firm:
M/s. NEW SATELLITE
VIDEO VISIONS
2. Address of the Firm:
#897/1, Kantha Raje Urs
Road, Lakshmipuram,
Mysore - 570 004.
- 11 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
3. East & West,
North & South:
13.
SKETCH GIVEN
Annexure-A of the lease deed sets out the list of equipment
which was handed over to the defendants. The said annexure
contains two tabular statements. The first table contains the list of
equipments and the details of the control room. The second table
lists equipment, such as amplifiers and nodes, that were placed at
various locations. The said annexure also mentions fibre cable and
other necessary accessories for the carriage of signals. AnnexureB sets out the list of subscribers (574 serial entries in total) and
their addresses.
14.
As is apparent from the above, the term of the lease deed
expired on 30.04.2012, and there is no document on record to
establish that the parties agreed to extend the lease on the same
terms and conditions. According to the plaintiff, there was an oral
agreement to the said effect. However, the same is not reflected in
any contemporaneous document. Admittedly, the defendants had
paid rent till 30.04.2012, but had not paid any amount thereafter.
The plaintiff claimed that the parties had agreed that the said rental
would be adjusted from the security deposit. However, there is no
evidence of this oral agreement. It is also material to note that the
- 12 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
lease deed expressly recorded that the defendants would not
postpone the surrender of the leased premises on expiry of the
lease period.
15.
In the given circumstances, it is difficult to accept that the
lease deed was extended beyond the agreed three-year period.
Although the agreement between the parties is termed as lease, it
is essentially an agreement under which the defendants took over
the plaintiff's business and agreed to pay the plaintiff a monthly
remuneration of ₹35,000/-. The defendants had also taken over the
equipment and network used to provide services to subscribers. At
the material time, the said business was being controlled from the
premises at No. 897/1, Kantharaje Urs Road, Lakshmipuram,
Mysuru, which the parties referred to as “the control room”.
However, it is admitted that the said control room was in rented
premises. The plaintiff had claimed that the defendants had shifted
the business from the said premises to the first floor of House No.
949/1, Second Main Road, Lakshmipura, Mysuru, and were
continuing the said business from the said premises using the
equipment.
16.
The plaintiff has examined himself as PW1. During his cross-
examination, he was asked what was meant by the word 'Rent' as
- 13 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
mentioned in the lease deed. In his response, he stated that "Since
we have given our infrastructure to them, we were taking rent".
However, he conceded that the lease deed did not mention what
the infrastructure consisted of. He also acknowledged that the
control room had been moved from the rented premises to his
house.
17.
The relevant extract of the PW1's cross-examination is set
out below:
"7. It is correct to suggest that we shifted our
control room from the said rented house to our
own house; the witness answers "Yes." It is
correct to suggest that the said house is our own
house; the witness answers "Yes." To the
suggestion that signals are being sent to cable TV
subscribers from the control room located in our
own house, the witness states, "They are being
sent now." We shifted the cable TV control room
to our house in the year 2013. The said control
room is located on the first floor of our house. It is
correct to suggest that I have been residing in the
said house since before 2013; the witness
answers "Yes." The witness states that the lock
and key of the said control room are with me and
also with them (the defendants). They pay the
electricity bill for the said control room. No
agreement has been entered into between me
and the defendant specifically regarding the
control room. The witness further states, "The
defendant came here for the reason that the rent
would be 'waived off."
- 14 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
18.
It is clear from the above that the business that had been
handed over to the defendants came under the plaintiff's control, as
the control room was admittedly moved to his house. Although the
plaintiff had claimed that the defendants also paid the electricity
bills for the control room, there was no evidence or material to that
effect.
19.
Defendant No.1 was also examined as DW1. He was cross-
examined and stated that he had surrendered the lease but had not
taken any written document from the plaintiff. However, he also
stated that the plaintiff had made statements to the effect that the
plaintiff had shifted the business office to his house and that
thereafter the defendants had not conducted any business at the
location to which it was shifted.
20.
In view of the above, there is no dispute that the control room
had been shifted from the rented premises and is now housed in
the plaintiff’s residence. It is also not disputed that he is in control
of the said office (Control Room). Although the plaintiff also claims
that the defendants had a key to the office (control room), there is
no further evidence indicating that the defendants were carrying on
the business from the plaintiff’s residence.
There is also no
- 15 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
evidence on record that at the time of filing the suit, the defendants
were still engaged in the business of providing cable TV services.
21.
There is no evidence of any agreement between the parties
other than a statement made by PW1, which is denied by DW1,
that the lease deed had been extended. We are unable to accept
that there was any agreement between the parties for extension of
the lease deed. It is also well settled under Section 92 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 that oral statements cannot be accepted as
modifying the terms of a written agreement.
22.
In this view, the plaintiff's action of claiming rent would not be
sustainable. It is not disputed that the plaintiff's cause of action for
recovering the assets, as well as demanding the transfer of the
business would commence from the date of expiry of the term of
the lease agreement. Thus, any action for recovery of the same
would now be barred by limitation. Thus, the plaintiff's claim for the
same is barred by limitation.
23.
We also note that although the learned Commercial Court
has awarded damages at the rate of ₹50,000/- per month, there is
no evidence whatsoever on record which would substantiate the
quantum of the damages allegedly suffered by the plaintiff. This
- 16 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
Court also cannot ignore that the market value of the equipment
handed over to the defendants in 2009, would by now have
significantly depreciated in value.
24.
The period of limitation under Article 52 of the Limitation Act,
1963 for recovery of rent is three years from when the arrears
become due. Further, as under Article 55 of the Limitation Act,
1963, the period of limitation for instituting any action for
compensation for breach of any contract is three years from the
date when the contract is broken.
25.
As noted above, the term of the lease deed expired on
30.04.2012.
The defendants did not make any payment of the
lease rents (monthly consideration as agreed under the lease
deed) thereafter. Thus, the period of limitation commenced from
the said date.
26.
Under Article 113 of the Limitation Act, the period for
limitation is three years from the date on which the right to sue
accrues.
27.
Accordingly, the action instituted by the plaintiff (respondent
No.1) is barred by limitation.
- 17 -
COMAP No. 630 of 2025
28.
In view of the above, the impugned judgment and decree are
set aside. The appeal is accordingly allowed.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(C.M. POONACHA)
JUDGE
KPS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review