Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
t 3383 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION NO: 32182 OF 2025
Between:
1. Sri J. Srinivas Yadav, S/o Late Swamy Yadav, aged about 55 years, Occ.
Business, R/o.H.No.1-1-96/1, Street No.1, Habsiguda, Near Kallu Compound,
Hyderabad
2. Sri D.E. Nagaraj, S/o E.B. Krishna, aged about 47 years, Occ. Business, R/o
Flat No. 202, H.No. 16-11-20161413/1, Ghanasai Apartments, Opp. Ganesh
Temple, Saleemnagar, Malakpet, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, lvlunicipal
Administration and Urban Development Department, (MAUD), Secretariat,
Hyderabad
The Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad ttilunicipal Corporation, Head Office,
Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
The City Planner, Greater Hyderabad filunicipal Corporation, L.B. Nagar
Zone, Hyderabad.
M/s Radheshyam Constructions and Developers, Rep by its Managing
Partners R. Uthara Reddy and G. Mohan Rao, Having office at Plot No.
1 221
Al2, Ven kataramana Colony, Serilingampally, Hyderabad.
Jogiparthy Venkatesh, S/o. J. Yadaiah Guptha, Aged Not Known, Occ.
Agriculture Rep. by l\4/s. Radheshyam Constructions and Developers. Having
oflice at Plot No. 1221N2, Venkataramana Colony. Serilingampally,
Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order, or Direction, more particularly one in the nature of
lVlandamus, declaring the action of the Respondents in issuing Building Permit
No 1363/GHMC/LBN/2025-BP dated 10.10.2025 in favour of Respondent No. 4
as illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional, violative of Articles 14 and 300-A of the
constitution of rrdia, contrary to section 450 of the GHMC
defiance of the judgment dated 30.12.2024 in w.p.
Act, 19s5, and in wirfur
No. 10419/2023, and
consequently, sert aside the said permit and direct
Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 not
to grant or act upon any buirding permission in respect
of the property in Survey
Nos' r 06 and 1 07, Kothapet Virage, Uppar Mandar, Medchar-Marka.igiri
District,
without prior nor.ice to the petitioners and due verification
of pending ritigations
and revocation c rders.
IA NO: 10F
Petition u rder section 1 51 cpc praying that in
the circumstances stated in
the affidavit file,J in support of the petition, the High
Court may be pleased to
suspend the op'-'ration and imprementation of the
impugned Buirding permit No.
'1363/GHMC/LB'\/2025-B'
dated 'r0-10-2025 and direct Respondent Nos. 2, 3,
and 4 not to undertake. permit, arow, or carry out
any construction activity
whatsoever in 'espect of the property situated
in Survey Nos. 106 and 107
Kothapet Villagt:, Uppal Mandal, Medchal_Malkajgiri
District, pending disposal of
,
this Writ Petition.
IA NO: 2oF 20
Between:
1. M/s. Radheshyam Constructions and Develooers
?irttets-R*Lithllr"iJaov-""J-cl'H,'"n#"AT"l,"rirT,;B
i/"J,.",Hlinnil,?
122tAt2,'y'enkataramana iorony, 5;r.it;;;#p;il!,:
Hyderabad.
2. Jogiparthy Venkatesh. S/o J yadaiah Guptha, Aged Not
Known, Occ.
grttrlq, .[90 py_n,'rs, nao neinvam ail;i;.;;til;, and Devetopers.
*,'i
,'.,,,',
Havino
onrce at [)tot No. 122tN2. Venkataiamani
C.r".v.'Slriiiig-ri..,pl";;"'.
Hyderabad.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The State of Telanoana
Administlation and Ur-Gn '
Hyderabad.
,I:ft o,:x",i'B#j,x;13f, I i,fii8Bjl .J,:lfJti:
#*"rfllil'ir133:jbroJ:""'
Hvderabad M un icipal corporation, Head
r|F.:rrya!l:#Sr'
Greater Hvderabad Municipal corporation,
orrice,
L.B. Nasar
Sri J. Srinivas Yadav, S/o Late Swamy Yadav, aged about 55 y-ears, Occ.
Business, R/o.H.No.1-1-96/1, Street No.t, Habsiguda, Near Kallu Compound,
Hyderabad
Sri D.E. Nagaraj, S/o E.B. Krishna, ageq about 47 years, Occ. Busine_ss, R/o
Flat No. 202, H.No. 16-1 1-20t1l4l3lf, Ghanasai Apartments, Opp. Ganesh
Temple' saleemnagar' Malakpet' Hyderabad'
...RES'.NDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the interim orders dated 25.10.2025 in the present Writ Petition vide W.P.
No.32 182 of 2025 and dismiss the Writ Petition with exemplary costs.
Counset for the Petitioner: SRI B. CHANDRASEN REDDY, SENIOR COUNSEL
APPEARING FOR SRI B. VAMSHIDHAR REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Counsel for the Respondents No.2 & 3: SRI SRINIVAS RAO PACHWA,
S.C. FOR GHMC
Counset for the Respondents No. 4 & 5: SRI B. MAYUR REDDY,
SENIOR COUNSEL
Counsel for the Respondents: AGP FOR REVENUE
Counset for the Respondents: SRI MOHD. ASIFUDDIN
The Court made the following: ORDER
*7
IN TIIE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION No. 32La2 of 2o.25
DATED: 18.02.2o.26
Between:
J.Srinivas Yadav and another.
...Petitioners
AND
The State of Telangana,
reptd. by its Principal Secretary,
Municipat Administration & Urban
Developrn ent Department,
Hyderabad and others.
...Respondents
-ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed to declare thc action of responclents in
issuing building permir No. t363iGFIIVlciL.BN/ 2ozs-Bp, dated
10.10.20115 in favour of respondent No.4, as illegal, arbitrary, in
violation of Articles-14 and 300-A of currstitution of tndia and
contrary to Scclion 450 of the Greater I lyderabad Municipal
Corporation Act. 1955, and also in wil[ul disobedience of the Order
dated 30.12.2024 passed by this Court in w.p.No.l04l9 of 2023 and,
for const:quential r-el ief.
t
?
2'
Heard sri B.chandrasen Reddy, Iearned
appearing for Sri B.vamshidhar Reddy,
petitioners' sri Srinivas Rao pachwa,
learned counsel_on_record for
rearned standing counsel for
respondent Nos.2 and 3 and Sri B.Mayur
Reddy, Iearned Senior
Counsel for respondent Nos.4 and 5, learned
Pleader for Revenue and Sri Mohd.
senior counser
Assistant Government
Asifuddin, learned counsel for
I
I
i
I
i
i
respondent No.5.
3.
Brief facts of the case as averred in the writ
originally, one Narasaiah yadav was the
owner of land admeasuring
Acs.2-02 gts situated in Sy.Nos.l06 and
107 of Kothapet village,
Uppal Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District,
same under registered sale deed No.23l
affidavit are that
having purchased the
I of lg7l, dated 27.12.1971;
that the said Narasaiah yadav expired on
2I.o4.rggo reaving behind
his son Mahender yadav and his daughter-in-raw
Balamani as his legal heirs; that the
chittaboina
said Mahender yadav wenr
missing and his whereabouts have remained
untraceabre; that after
completion ol mandatory period of nine years
fiom the date of his
missing, his wife-Baramani appried for issuance
certificate before the Tahsildar, who issued
of Family Member
the same on 19.r0.2005 in
3Yt of Balamani and her six child.en; that subsequentry, after
-";.
a
J
conducting survey and Panchanama, the Tahsildar issued Pattadar
Passbooks and title deeds to her and her name was recorded in the
revenue records for the years 2005 and 2006; and that the petitioners
purchased land admeasuring Ac.1-38 gts in Sy.Nos.l06 and 107,
situated at Kothapet Village, Uppal Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri
District (he'reinafter referred to as 'subject property'), under registered
Agreement of Sale-cum-General Power of Attorney (AGPA) No.3153
of 2007, dated 05.03.2007, from the said Balanrani and others and have
been in continuous, uninterrupted and peaceful possession of the
subject property.
4. It ir; fumher averred that during the intennediate period when
Mahender Yadav was missing, some third parties created fahricated
documents including GPA No.364 of 1993, executed in favour of
Balakrishna and V.Ramesh and another GPA No.200 of 1995 in favour
ot'K.Sadeva Goud, basing on which, sale deeds were executed by
dividing the subject property into plots without any approved layout or
lawful ownership; that one Mandava Asha Priya clairned ownership
over the subject property, basing on the alleged layout plan approved
by Granr Panchayat in the year 1995 and she, without any manner of
right or title, illegally trespassed into the subject property and
demolished the petitioners compound wall
and also the bore-well
installed by them; that petitioners rodged
a compraint before the
Chaitanyapuri Police Station, which was registered
No.477 of 2021, dared l4.og.2o2l, charge sheet
is pending. In fact, the Gram panchayat of
as case in Crime
was filed and the same
Kothapet vilrage ceased to
exist from the year r9g5, in view of formation
of L.B.Nagar
Municipality. tt is further ave*ed that the HMDA has issued
a
caution Notice No.44 lTlrJC/ FI/r9g6y/1997, dared 30.04.1997,
confirming that layouts in Sy.Nos.l06 and 107 are unauthori
zed and
unapproved.
5. It is further averred that Mandava Asha priya fired a suit vide
o.S.No.1034 of 202t, before l-Additional Junior civil
L.B.Nagar, seeking perpetual i^junction against petitioners,
l
l
*
:l
i
Judge,
along with
an interlocutory application vide I.A.No. l2l of zo2l seeking
temporary injunction; that the trial clourt on detailed examination
the evidence on record vide order dated 30. r r .2o22,dismissed
of
the said
interlocutory application, by observing that Mandava Asha priya
failed
to establish either possession or title over the subject property and
further recorded that the petitioners are in lawfur and continuous
possession of the subject property; that subsequently,
respondent No.5
along with two others filed another suit vide O.S.No.21l2 of 2022 for
injunction against the petitioners and the same is pending; that
suppressing the pendency of the said suit and other material facts, the
vendor of :espondent No.S-Asha Priya obtained building permission
vide permit No.2289IGHMC/ LBN/2022-BP, dated 03.03.2022, for
construction ol'Stilt +5 upper floors in the disputed land in Sy.Nos.l06
and 107
6.
Aggrieved by granting of such building permission, dated
03.03.2021), petitioners submitted representations, dated 08.1 I .2021,
17 .03.202'2,, 19.03.2022,
12.07 .2022 and 23.01.2023 to the GHMC and
the GHMII authorities, on due enquiry and after affording reasonable
opportuniiy to all the concerned parties, flound that Asha Priya
obtained permission dated 03.03.2022 by suppressing the material facts
and acco::dingly, issued Show-Cause notice dated 09.03.2023, under
Section 2.50 of GHMC Act, 1955, calling upon the perrnit holder to
explain as to why the permission should not be revoked; and later, on
due conr;ideration of material placed on record, respondent No.2Commis:;ioner revoked the building permission dated 03.03.2022 vide
speaking, Order dated 10.04.2023.
7'
Aggrieved by the revocation
Akarapu Badrinath
filed a writ petit ion
claiming to have purchased
incrudes the subject
Asha priya, and this
the said writ petition,
fi'esh applicarion to
the prots in Sy.Nos.r06
granting liberty to
the GHM. as per
without considering the
Deputy commissioners,
permission was filed;
order dated 30.12.2024,
accorded permission
representation dated
8.
to submit
dury
and that the GHMC
passed by rhis courr
for constructi on vide
dated r0.10.2025,
of the subject property;
rg.t0.2025 to Zonar and
permission, however, r.ro
canceilation of
action has been taken
Aggrieved by the same, the
is filed.
Respondent Nos.4 and
5 filed counter contending
the land in Sy.No.l06 admeasuring
of
accordingly, fresh
GHM., L.B.Naga r zone,fbr
thereon by the respondents-corporation.
Mandava
TS-bpAss Act, 2020,by
No.4 herein in respect
that petitioners submitted
present Writ petition
the petitioner therein
1363/GHM./LBN/2025_Bp,
in favour of respondent
of 2023,
30.12.2024, disposed
of suit filed by hinr; that
in w'P.No.l04r9 of 2023,
one
and 102 which
three others from
court vide order dared
application for building
the impugned buirding
videw.p.No. r04lg
property, arong with
disclosing the pendency
impugned permit No.
order dated 10.04.2023,
that originally,
Acs. I -04 gts was classified
as
Panga
,Inam, Iand showing the name of one
Sailu as lnamdar; that
afterthederniseofthesaidPangaSailu,thenamesofhislegalheirsP.Laxmaiah,P'lstariandP'Pentaiah'wererecordedaslnamdars;and
thattheyappliedforgrantofoccupancyRightsCertif,rcate(oRC)and
accordingll',theRDOEast'RangaReddyvideproceedingsdated
10.12.1991, granted
ORC in their favour'
g.ItisfurtheraverredthatthenamesofP.Sreeramuluandothers'
continuedtobereflectedinthepahaniesfortheyearslgg3-94and
|gg4-g5irrespectoflandadmeasuringAc.0-36gtsinSy.No.l07and
thesaidownersalongwiththeownersoflandinSy.Nos.l0sandl09,
developerlthelandsintoplotsandobtainedGramPanchayatlayout
fromNagloleGramPanchayat,dated04.02.lgTSinrespectoftheentire
were
gts and that registered GPAs
Acs.g-00
adrneasuring
land
executei.inrespectofabovesaidlandsandptotsweresoldunder
various::egisteredsaledeedsthroughGPAholders;thatMandavaAsha
Priya ptrrchased plots bearing Nos'33'
square 'yards each, total admeasuring
34' 48 and 49' admeasuring
800 Sq'yrds in Sy'Nos'106 and
toz, situated at Kothapet Yillage, R.R.District, Undef fegistefed Sale
deed Nr.5338 of 1996, dated 23.09.1996, from panga pentaiah
others; whire so, when the petitioners
and
tried to interfere with the
possession of subject plots, Asha Priya filed
a suit vide O.S.No.l034 of
2021 on the file of v Junior Civil Judge, R.R. District,
ar L.B.Nagar
and initially, the said Court vide Order dared 30.1 I .2022
in t.A.No.l2l
of 2022 in o.S.No.lo34 of 2021, granted ad-interirn injunction.
l0'
It is further averred that respondent No.5 along with three others
purchased Plot Nos.33,34,4g and 49 in Sy.Nos.l06
and 107, which
includes the subject property, from Mandava Asha priya,
registered sale deed No.20 r of 2022, dated 05.0 I .2022;and
same day, respondent No.5 entered into Development
under
rhar, on the
Agreement-cum_
General Power of Attomey bearing No.37l of 2022, rvith respondent
No.4 for development of the subject prcperty; and that frorn the date
of
the said purchase, respondent Nos.4 and 5 are in possession and
enjoyment of the subject property; and that subsequently, in view
sale of the subject plots in favour of respondent No.5, Asha priya
of
has
withdrawn the suit as not pressed.
1. It is further averred that when the petitioners again tried to
interfere with the possession of the subject plots by respondent Nos.4
and 5, respondent No.5 along with two others filed a suit vide
o-s.No.2ll2 of 2022 on the file of principal Senior civil Judge,
*
Medchal-Malkajgiri District and obtained interim Orders dated
09.12.2022 in I.A.No.346 of 2022 and the said suit is pending.
12. tt is mrther averred that petitioners are claiming to be owners of
subject property having purchased the same from one Chittaboina
Balamani and others under registered AGPA dated 05.03.2007; that the
said Balanrani and others filed a suit vide O.5.No.470 of 2007 on the
file of Prircipal Junior Civil Judge, R.R.District, at L.B.Nagar, against
the then plot owners of the layout and after the trial, the said suit was
dismissed vide Judgment and decree dated 28.L2.2012 and no appeal
was preferred and thus, the Judgment and decree dated 28.12.2012 has
become firal
13. It isr further averred that vendors of the petitioners were never in
possession of the subject property and physically, the land
admeasuring Ac.l-38 gts is not available, as the land in Sy.Nos.l06
and 107 was already converted into layout, dividing the same into
plots, anrl presently houses are existing in the said land; and that the
petitioners, having failed in the suits, approached respondent No.2 with
unclean hands by suppressing the dismissal of O.S.No.470 of 2007;
that respondent No.3, on due verification of the documents and
physical possession of Asha Priya-vendor of respondent No.5,
l0
accorded permission for
construction vide
No.2289.GHMCILBN/2022-Bp, dared
subsequently, she sold the same to
permit
03.03.2022, in her favour and
respondent No.5 and in pursuance
thereof, respondent No.4-Developer
had been in the process of
construction by investing huge money.
14' It is further averred that petitioners filed w.p.No.l4567
questioning the building permission
was dismissed by this court vide
of 2022
dated 03.03.2022 and rhe same
order dated 24.03.2022, directing the
petitioners to avair appropriate remedy
petitioners preferred w.A.N o.2g9 of
before the civir court; that
2022 and the same was also
dismissed vide order dated 19.04.2022,
and,having faired in ail their
attempts, the petitioners approached respondent
No.2 for cancelration
of building permission by suppressing the facts and
same, respondent No.2 issued that show-cause
notice dated 0g.03.2023
to vendor of respondent No.5 and that reply was
bringing to the notice of respondent No.2
passed by this court in w.p.N o.14567
basing on the
given therero,
the orders dated 24.03.2022
of 2022, wherein it is observed
that the respondents-GHMC has no jurisdiction
to go into the aspects
as to whether the registered document in favour
of Asha priya is
genuine or whether the petitioners or Asha priya-vendor
of respondent
l1
No.5, are the owners of the subject property; and that, without
considering the said order, respondent No.2 revoked the earlier
building pe:mission, by proceedings dated 10.04.2023.
15. It is iurther averred that aggrieved by the revocation Order dated
10.04.2023, respondent No.5 filed a writ petition vtde w.p.No. l04lg
of 2023 antl this Court vide Order dated 30.12.2024, dismissed the writ
petition, hc'wever, granted liberty to respondent No.5 herein to submit
fresh applir;ation under TS-bPASS by disclosing the pendency of suit
in o.S.No.'.zl12 of 2022 and further, observed that it is for the GHMG
to consider the same in accordance with law; that in pursuance of the
said order. respondent Nos.4 and 5 submitted fresh application to
GHMC by disclosing pendency of suir in o.S.No.2 l12 of 2022 and,
GHMC, by duly examining all the documents and also physical
possession of respondent Nos.4 and 5 over the subject propefty,
accorded permission fbr constructionvide permit dated lo.lo.2025,
for
constructicrfl of Stilt + 5 upper floors and respondent Nos.4 and 5 have
also compieted construction of Stilt + 2 upper floors as on 25.10.2025,
however, in view of interim order of status quo passed by
on 25 .10 -2025, respondent Nos.4 and 5 stopped further
this court
construction. It
is specifi,:ally averred that petitioners have not challenged the
{
i,*
registered sale deed/titre deed of respondent
No.5 and having failed to
obtain order from the competent civil court,
the petitioners cannot
seek cancellation of the building permission
and thus, prayed to
dismiss the writ petition.
16. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioners submitted that
petitioners have purchased the subject property
under registered AGPA
dated 05.03.2007 from original owner-chittaboina
others, who were in possession and enjoyment
I
I
I
I
I
i
,
Balamani and
of the same; that vendor
of respondent No.S-Asha priya was never in possession
property; that the application fired by vendor of
of the subject
respondent No.5 for
ad-interim injunction vide t.A.No.l2l of 2O2l in
o.S.No.l034 of
2021, was dismissed by the triar court with categorical
observation
that vendor of respondent No.5 failed to establish title
as well as
possession over the subject property. He further
submitted that vendor
i
i
of respondent No.5 obtained permission for construction.vide permit
t{
I
l:
a
t
dated 03-03.2022, by suppressing and misrepresenting the
facts
including pendency of civil Suits, therefore, GHMC has
rightry
revoked the said permission on the complaint submitted
by the
petitioners. He further submitted that GHMC granted
impugned
permission on 10.r0.2025, without considering the earlier
revocation
r3
proceedings as well as the observations made by this Court in
W.P.No.l04l9 of 2023, therefore, the impugned perrnission dated
10.10.202i is liable to be set aside.
17. Per contra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent
Nos.4 and 5 submitted that the entire extent of land in Sy.Nos.106 and
107 along with adjacent lands was developed into plots and the layout
was approved by Nagole Gram Panchayat in the year 1978 and plots
have been sold to various individuals under registered sale deeds and
structures have also been raised thereon. He further submitted that it is
a settled principle of law that while processing the application for
permissic,n for construction, GHMC has to only verify the prima focie
title and cossession; that the respondent Nos.4 and 5 and their vendors
have been in possession and enjoyment of the subject and GHMC after
due verification of the title documents as well as physical possession of
respondent Nos.4 and 5 over the subject property, granted permission
for consr.ruction. He further submitted that GHMC did not violate the
orders of this Court dated 30.12.2024 in W.P.No.l04t9 of 2023 as
alleged 'ry the petitioners and in fact, this Coun while dismissing the
writ petition filed by respondent No.5 has granted liberty to submit
fresh application through TS-bPASS by duly disclosing the pendency
t4
of o.S.No.2l12 of 2022 and accordingly, fresh application for building
permission was hled by disclosing the pendency of the suit-
oS.No.2l12 of, 2022 and that the authorities of GHMC, alrer due
consideration of all the material placed before it, has rightly granted
permission for construction. He fuither submitted that disputed
question of title and facts cannot be gone into by the GHMC while
processing the application for building permission. By contending thus,
learned senior counsel for respondent Nos.4 and 5 submitted that no
grounds are made <lut by the petitioners to cancel the irnpugned
building permit and the writ petition, being devoid of any merit, is
liable to be set aside.
18. Learned Standing Counsel for respondent Nos.2 and 3 submitted
that respondents-Corporation has considered the entire material placed
before it, along with the TS-bPASS application filed by respondent
No.5, particularly the Af,fidavit-curn-Undertaking given by respondent
No.5, wherein the pendency of suit-OS.No.2l12 of 2022 is stated, and
having found prima facie title in favour of respondent No.5 and his
possession over the subject property, granted the impugned building
permission and as such, the Writ Petition is liable to be dismissed.
l5
19. This Court gave its earnest consideration to the submissions
advanced try learned counsel for both the parties and perused the entire
material a'trailable on record
20. Penrsal of the material available on record discloses that the
petitionersr are claiming title to the subject property based on the
registered sale deed executed in their favour by Balamani and others,
and that respondent No.5, on the other hand, is claiming title to the
subject property based on the registered sale deed in his favour by one
Mandava Asha Priya. Earlier, the suit-OS.No.470 of 2007 filed by
Balamani and others against plot owners in respect of layout in
Sy.Nos.l06 and 107, seeking the relief of perpetual injunction was
dismissed by the Court of Principal Junior Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy
District, vide judgment dated 28.12.2012. wherein it is categorically
observed that Balamani and others-plaintifl-s therein had no possession
over the schedule [and. Further, it is also apt to note that the suitOS.No.21l2 of 2022 filed by respondent No.5 herein along with two
others against the petitioners herein seeking the relief of perpetual
injunction is pending before the trial Court and that the trial Court
though Lnitially granted ad-interim order on 09.12.2022 in IA.No.346
of 2022, subsequently, dismissed the said application on merits
t6
21. From the above, it is evident that the title and rights of the
parties in respect of the subject property is not crystallized and the said
issue is pending adjudication before the trial Court.
22. Furtherrnore, it is not out of place to note that this Court in Writ
Petition No.14567 of 2022, filed by the petitioners herein against one
Mandava Asha Priya-vendor of respondent No.5, vide order dated
24.03.2022, categorically observed that respondents-Corporation has
no jurisdiction to go into the aspects as to whether the registered
document in favour of Mandava Asha praiya-vendor of respondent
No.5, is a genuine one, or whether the petitioners herein or the said
Mandava Asha Priya is the owner of the subject property and that if the
petitioners case is that sale deed in favour of Mandava Asha priya is
not binding on them, basing on which building permission was
granted, they can seek appropriate remedy before a civil court. on
appeal-wA.No.289 of 2022 filed against the said order, a Division
Bench of this Courr vide orders dated r9.o4.zoz2 upheld the
observations made in Writ Petition No.14567 of 2022 and dismissed
the Writ Appeal.
23. Thus, it is manifesr that when the genuinity of the registered sale
deed in favour of Mandava Asha Priya and subsequently, the registered
t7
sale deed r:xecuted by her in favour of respondent No.5 is disputed by
the petitioners, the same has to be decided by a competent civil Court.
Tlris Court while exercising the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India cannot adjudicate the disputed questions of
title and possession over the subject property.
24. That apart, the petitioners without seeking appropriate remedy
against Asha Priya-vendor of respondent No.5 before a civil Court, as
was observed by this Court in order dated 24.03.2022, in Writ Petition
No.l456lt of 2022, has filed present writ petition betbre this Court.
25. Respondent No.5 has stepped into the shoes of Mandava Asha
Priya in
'riew
of execution of registered sale deed dated 05.01 .2022 in
his favour and obtained building pennission in respect of the subject
property. However, at the instance of the petitioners, the said
permission was revoked by the GHMC, vide order dated 10.04.2023.
Subsequently, Writ Petition No.l04l9 of 2023 filed by respondent
No.5 challenging the revocation order was dismissed by this Court,
granting liberty to respondent No.5 to submit fresh application with
GHMC under TS-bPASS by disclosing the pendency of the suitOS.No.2llZ of 2022 filed by him and others against the petitioners
l8
seeking perpetual injunction and it is for the GHMC to consider the
same in accordance with law.
26. It is the case of respondent No.5 that in purported compliance of
the said order, he has again apptied for building permission by duly
enclosing an Affidavit-cum-Undertaking, stating about the pendency of
the suit-oS.No.2l12 of 2022 filed by him against the petitioners and
further, has undertaken that he wili adhere to the Court orders passed
in respect of the subject property.
27. It appears that the respondents-Corporation has considered the
same and issued the impugned building permit in favour of respondent
No.5. The commissioner, while considering the application for
building permission, is empowered only to veriff the prima facie title
and possession of the applicant over the property. He cannot delve into
and adjudicate the disputed quesrions of title or ownership of the
property. The law in this regard is well-settled by the erstwhite High
Court in Hyderabad Potteries Private Limited v. Collector,
Hyderobarlr, wherein, it is held as hereunder:-
"The commisstonens not entitled to decide any disputed
questions of tttle or the ownership. All that the commtssioner
required to do ts to find out prima facie title and lawful
'J2opl) 3 ALD 600
l9
possession of the applicant and obviously such consideration ts
confin'zd to only for the purpose of granting permission and
nothtng n'tore. "
28. In this regard, it is also relevant to note the judgment of the
erstwhile Jigh Court of Andhra Pradesh rendered in K. Povsn Raj v.
The Municipal Corporation of Hytlerabal wherein it is hetd as
follows:"The' commissioner therefore cannot be compelled to decicle
the title dispute if it is complex in nature and he is entitled to
proceed on the basis of prima facie title of the applicant for
grant of permission."
29. [n :he light of the above settled legal position, this Courl holds
that the oomrnissioner, on due verification of the prima facie title as
well as possession of respondent No.5 over the subject propefty, has
accorded building permission. Thus, the Commissioner has well acted
within the jurisdiction conferred on him and therefore, the impugned
building permit issued in favour of respondent No.5 cannot be faulted
with. Ttre petitioners failed to rnake out any case to cancel the
impugned building permission and as such, the writ Petition is [iable
to be dismissed.
'1zoos; t ALD7g2
I
30. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stands closed.
.P. PONNA KRISHNA
STANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. One CC to SRI B. VAfuISHIDHAR REDDY,
loPUcI
2' Two CCs to lMunicipal Administra.tion and Urban Development, High Court for
the State of Telanglna at Hyderabad.
iOUn
3. one cc to sRr SR|NVASA RAo PACHWA, sc FoR GHMC
topucl
4. one cc to sRr B. MAYUR REDDY, senior counser
topucl
5. Two ccs to Gp FoR REVENUE,
--' High court for the state of relangana
Hyderabad.[OUT]
6. One CC to SRt MOHD.AS|FUDD|N, Advocate [OPUC]
7. Two CD Copies
PIVI
BS
a
at
HIGH COURT
DATED:1810212026
t
o
(,,
1 $ES
16 ilAf, 2026
* D
tsp
J
RDER
WP.No.32182 ot 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
,r)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review