Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010627922025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3504]
THURSDAY, THE 29th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 32401/2025
Between:
1. SRI GANDIA RAMANA MURTHY, S/O GANDIA APPARAO , AGED 55
YRS
D.NO.2-7
,
DUVVADA
SECTOR-II,
DUWADA
VISAKHAPATNAM.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP., BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY (HOME) SECRETARIAT, VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATHI.
2. THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, VISAKHAPATGNAM CITY.
3. THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, DUWADA POLICE STATION,
DUVVADA VISAKHAPATNAM.
4. THE SUB INSPECTOR, DUVVADA POLICE STATION, DUVVADA
VISAKHAPATNAM CITY.
5. SETTI SEETHA RAM, S/O APPALANAIDU, AGED 40 YRS, DUWADA
VISAKHAPATNAM.
6. S SERASAPALLI APPARAO, S/O SOMUNAIDU, AGED 43 YRS,
DUVVADA VISAKHAPATNAM.
7. AMARAPINNI VENKATA RAMANA, S/O CHINNODU, AGED 45 YRS,
DUWADA VISAKHAPATNAM.
8. MADAKA VARAHALU, S/O APPANNA, AGED 45 YRS, DUVVADA
VISAKHAPATNAM.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased toPleased to Issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particularly one
in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondents
particulalry the Respondent No.3 and 4 Continuously harassing the Petitioner
one way or another in connection with the Property Covered in Survey No.
130/6 Ac.2-98 cents now it is sub divided as 130/6A, 130/6B in that 130/6Ato
a total extent of Ad-49 Cents whichis in possession and enjoyment of the
Petitoiner and his family members , which originally was purchased by fore
fathers of Petitioner by
way of a Regd., Sale Deed dt.31-03-1943 vide
document no.961/43 in connection with the same the Respondents 3 and 4
Calling the Petitioner to the Police Station and threatening the petitioner to
vacate the land and to hand over to the Un-authorised persons i.e, un official
respondents i.e.,
5 to 8 who are land grabbers all are Illegal, unlawful.
Violation of Principles of Natural Justice, Violation of Police Standing orders.
Violation of Article 14,19,21,300-A- of the Constitution of India, Consequently
to direct the respondents 3 and 4 not to Call for to the Police Station or
harass or Interfere into the Civil and Property Dispute in connection with the
Land covered in Survey No. 130/6 after sub division the total extent Ac1-49
Cents in S.NO.130/6 A which is in the petitioner's possession
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. R SIVA SAI SWARUP
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR HOME
APHC010074382025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3504]
THURSDAY, THE 29th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 4148/2025
Between:
1. B RAJESWARI, WO BYPILLA KRISHNA , AGED MAJOR, D.NO.4-2/215, AANJANEYA VAAGU VAGGU CENTRE VIJAYAWADA (URBAN)
2. P.V. KRISHNA KUMARI, W/O CHANDRA SEKHAR, AGED MAJOR,
FLAT NO.B3, 3RD FLOOR, POONAMAILEE HIGH ROAD , KILPAUK,
CHENNAI PRESENTLY CAME DOWN TO VIJAYAWADA.
3. VUMMIDISETTY DURGA BHAVANI, W/O NAGESWARA RAO, AGED
MAJOR, S-3,ADGYBUC AOARTNEBTSM
RAGHURAM STREET,
VIJAYAWADA (URBAN)-520010
4. RUTHALA RAJESWARI, W/O RUTHALA SATYANARAYANA , AGED
MAJOR, D.NO. 19-13/5-22
OLD RAJA RAJESWARI PETA,
VIJAYAWADA.
5. BANKA VENKATA LAKSHMI, W/O BANKA BALA KRISHNA DAS ,
AGED MAJOR D.NO.5-6-59/3A
CHITTINAGAR, SARI RAM
BACKSIDE , VIJAYAWADA
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF AP, REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
(HOME),
SECRETARIAT,
VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATHI.
2. THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, VIJAYAWADA CITY.
3. THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, BHAVANIPURAM POLICE
STATION, VIJAYAWADA .
4. MD SHAIK LAI AHMMAD, S/O (LATE) SHAIK SILAR SAHEB , AGED
58 YRS, MUSTABADA, GANNAVARAM
MANDAL, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased toPleased to Issue a Writ or Order or Direction more particulalry one
in the Nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondent
Police particulalry the
3rd Respondent interferring into the Petitioners
possession and property rights situated at Plot No.4, 7, 8, 11, 16, Survey
No.7/lA2B3 at
Vidyapuram , Vijayawada at the instigation of Un-official
respondent no.4 it is nothing but an Interference into the Civil and Property
disputes all are Illegal, Unlawful, Violation of Principles of Natural Justice,
Violation of Article 14,19,21,300-A- of the Constitution of India, Consequently
to direct the respondent police not to Interference into the
Petitioner's
possession and property rights situated at Plot No.4, 7, 8, 11, 16, Survey
No.7/lA2B3 at Vidyapuram , Vijayawada in in any manner or what so ever
and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to direct the respondent police not to Interference into the Petitioners
possession and property rights situated at Plot No.4, 7,8,11,16, Survey
N0.7/1A2B3 at Vidyapuram , Vijayawada in any manner or what so
pending disposal of the main Writ Petition and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. R SIVA SAI SWARUP
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR HOME
ever
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION Nos:32401 and 4148 of 2025
COMMON ORDER:
As the issue involved in all the Writ Petitions is one and the same and in
view of the consent expressed by both the parties, the batch of Writ Petitions
is disposed of by way of common order.
2.
Overall sum and substance of the instant lis is that when the matter is
sub judice before competent Civil Courts, appropriate forums, interference of
police in respect of the very same subject properties inter-se parties is under
challenge in these Writ Petitions, mainly on the ground that the police have no
jurisdiction to interdict or determine the civil rights of the parties.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners draws the attention of this Court to
the relevant provisions enunciated in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Police Act, 1861.
Substantiating their assertions, learned counsels also relied on J.Lakshmi @
Lakshamamma & Another Vs. Commissioner of Police & Others1 and
G.B.C.Raj Gopal Vs. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Represented
by the Principal Secretary2.
4.
Sri P.Ajay Babu, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Home,
while denying the averments made in the affidavit filed in support of the Writ
Petitions, submitted that the respondent-police never called the petitioners to
the respective police stations and that they will not interfere with the civil
disputes inter se parties, unless any crime is registered for commission of any
2004 (2) ALD Cr.477
2014 SCC OnLine AP 322
cognizable offences. Learned Assistant Government Pleader fairly brought to
the notice of this Court the categorical instructions (dealing with land disputes)
of the Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh vide No.76/DGP’s Peshi/
2025 dated 24.10.2025 to the concerned police personnel. He also read out
the relevant paras of the same, for the sake of a comprehensive view, which
are extracted hereunder:
It has been observed that land-related disputes, both private and
government, are increasingly being reported across several districts.
These disputes are often escalating into law and order situations,
leading to communal tension, violent altercations, and property damage.
Even minor disagreements over land boundaries or ownership are, in
some instances, turning into major conflicts due to political, caste, or
community dimensions being injected into the issue.
xxx
4.
All Unit Officers and Range Officers are hereby directed to evolve
a comprehensive district-wise strategy to identify, monitor, and resolve
land dispute-related issues in coordination with the Revenue and
Judicial authorities. The following course of action shall be strictly
adhered to:
(a) Preventive Measures under Law:
1. In cases where law and order disturbances are likely, the police
must initiate preventive proceedings under BNS in coordination
with revenue authorities and, where necessary, bind over the
parties under preventive sections.
2. The local police should immediately bring the matter to the notice
of the concerned Executive Magistrate and ensure that
prohibitory orders are issued promptly to prevent breach of
peace.
3. In every such case, the local CI/SDPO must personally supervise
the situation until the dispute is brought under control or referred
to competent authorities.
(b) Coordination with Revenue & Judicial Authorities:
1. In cases involving civil ownership or title disputes, police should
not take sides or interfere in the civil adjudication process.
2. However, close coordination with Tahsildars, RDOs, and
Revenue Divisional Officers must be maintained to ensure timely
demarcation, eviction, and enforcement of legal orders.
3. The District Collector and SP/CP shall jointly review sensitive land
disputes at least once every month to assess potential
flashpoints.
(c) Registration of Criminal Cases:
1. When criminal intent or violence is evident—such as trespass,
cheating, forgery, assault, or criminal conspiracy—appropriate
criminal cases shall be registered under relevant sections of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
2. Particular attention should be given to repeat offenders and
politically motivated land grabbers, who often exploit technicalities
in the civil process to encroach upon land or disturb peace.
3. Ensure speedy investigation and charge-sheet filing in such
cases to deter others from similar behaviour.
(d) Monitoring & Accountability:
1. District SB shall prepare and maintain a Land Dispute Risk
Register, classifying disputes as Low / Medium / High Risk based
on communal sensitivity, violence potential, and local influence
factors.
2. The SP/CP shall personally monitor the top 10 high-risk disputes
in the district and submit a monthly status report to PHQ through
the Range DIG concerned.
3. Any negligence, delay, or failure to act preventively leading to
violence will be viewed seriously, and disciplinary action will be
initiated against the responsible officers.
4. It is reiterated that Police do not play any role in deciding
ownership or possession, which falls exclusively under the
purview of civil courts and revenue authorities. However, police
intervention becomes mandatory when there is a threat to public
peace, life, or property, or when criminal acts arise from such
disputes. Officers must therefore strike the right balance between
legality and prevention, ensuring that law and order is preserved
without overstepping jurisdictional limits.
5. The above instructions shall be implemented in letter and spirit, and
Range DIGs shall review compliance during their district inspections
and monthly law & order reviews.
Emphasis supplied
5.
In view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and also
taking note of the statutory regime as well as the well-settled legal principles
of the Apex Court and various High Courts that the Police have no jurisdiction
to determine the civil disputes, and more particularly, as the civil disputes inter
se parties are pending before competent forums, this Court is inclined to
dispose of the lis, at the stage of admission itself.
6.
In light of the above facts and circumstances of the case, the core
common issue to be determined in the present batch of cases is:
Whether the police have any jurisdictional powers to interfere or
determine the civil rights of the parties, more particularly, pending the
disputes before competent Civil Courts or statutory forums or not?
7.
Heard learned counsels for the petitioners and learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Home appearing on behalf of official RespondentState and perused the entire material available on record.
8.
Police have a statutory duty to maintain law and order and preserve
public peace and safety. They are primarily responsible for preventing crime,
controlling situations that may lead to breach of the peace, protecting the lives
and properties of people, and taking lawful action against persons who
engage in violence, threats, intimidation, or other unlawful activities. The
police may also take necessary preventive measures when there is
anticipation of disturbance or danger to public order. Thus, the essential role
of Police is to prevent unlawful acts, protect people and property, maintain
peace, and ensure that individuals are able to carry on their lawful activities,
without unlawful interference.
9.
In fact, when the statutory powers are conferred on the particular wing
more particularly, judicial/quasi-judicial forums and the respective forums have
seized the matter and dealt with the matter as per the prescribed procedure,
no other executive authority, who is not vested with such adjudicatory powers
under the relevant statutory framework, cannot encroach upon or usurp the
powers of such exclusively vested jurisdictional powers of the competent
forums and deal with the rights of parties contrary to the fundamental
principles of law, if anything, going contrary to the prescribed tenets amounts
to acting without jurisdiction under the principles of law.
10.
In the scheme of Constitution of India, the duty to resolve civil disputes
is entrusted to the judiciary. No such power is empowered to the Police.
Interference in a pending civil dispute or a potential civil dispute between two
citizens or two groups is not within the province of the police. Furthermore, if a
cognizable offence is reported to the police even as per the enunciated
scheme of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, (for brevity “BNSS
2023”), it is the duty of the police to register and investigate the crime to
unravel the truth and submit a report by way of charge sheet or final report to
the concerned jurisdictional Court only. Thereafter, it is the duty of the
competent Court to adjudicate the case after providing reasonable opportunity
to the parties as well by following statutory procedures and to reach its logical
conclusions, as per its jurisdictional sphere. It is well settled that judicial power
is a sovereign power which can be conferred only by constitutional as well as
statutory schemes, and it cannot be taken away or assumed Suo motu by any
other authority on its own, which is contrary to the well-settled legal principles.
11.
Coming to the instant issue, the Police Department, which has no
jurisdiction to determine civil rights inter se parties, seeking to take over the
powers vested in another statutory forum may lead to multifarious problems
and anomalies, not only affecting the functioning of said police wing, but also
prejudicing the rights of the parties, furthermore, to the societal interests too.
12.
It is apt to note that Courts in our Indian context generally would not
assume the role of an investigative agency, unless it is required, so why,
because it is in the orbit of an investigative agency empowered with
fundamental duties in their domain.
13.
Interesting facet in this context is that, evidently, the executive
magisterial authorities such as Mandal Level, Sub-Divisional Level, District
Level officers, though they are empowered under the provisions of the BNSS,
2023 & BNS, 2023 as well as other Legislative regimes to initiate statutory
measures, such as maintaining public peace and security and also preventing
breach of law, the said executive powers also came to a halt when the
competent Judicial Forums, such as Civil Courts, seize the subject in issue,
inter se parties.
14.
For better understanding, Section 164 BNSS, 2023 (corresponding to
Section 145 of CrPC, 1973) deals with disputes relating to land, water,
buildings or their boundaries which are likely to cause a breach of peace.
Under this provision, where a dispute exists about the actual possession of
the disputed property, the Executive Magistrate may initiate appropriate
proceedings in accordance with law and require the concerned parties to
appear before him and submit their respective claims, along with such
material as they may seek to rely upon, regarding the actual possession of the
property in question. An Executive Magistrate primarily determines who is in
actual possession of the property, rather than adjudicating the ultimate
question of ownership or title. Where necessary, particularly when the
possession cannot be ascertained, or there is an immediate likelihood of
breach of peace, the property may be attached, until the competent Court
determines the rights of the parties. The primary purpose of Section 164
BNSS, 2023 is to prevent disputes from escalating into violence and to
maintain peace and public order. Thus, even as per the provisions of BNSS,
2023 also, when competent Judicial authority seized the dispute inter-se
parties over the very same subject property, executive magisterial powers
come to be very minimal.
15.
In light of the above perception, it is relevant to note some of the
expressions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India which are as under:
In Mohd. Abid and Others v. Ravi Naresh and Others3, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that where the competent Civil Court has already
seized itself of the dispute concerning the same property, the
proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 CrPC, 1973 cannot be
permitted to continue in parallel. Determination of the inter se rights of
the parties relating to title or possession ultimately falls within the
jurisdiction of the Civil Court, whereas the proceedings before the
Executive Magistrate are intended only as a preventive measure to
avert a breach of peace.
2022 SCC OnLine SC 2416
“4. Once the Civil Court is seized of the matter, it goes without
saying that the proceedings under Section 145/146 Cr.P.C.,
cannot proceed and must come to an end. The inter-se rights of
the parties regarding title or possession are eventually to be
determined by the Civil Court.”
16.
In Mohd Shakir v. State of UP4, Apex Court held that even while
dropping proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C., an executive Magistrate
cannot make observations on the respective rights in respect of the subject
property, as it is the exclusive domain of the Civil Court.
17.
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, while interpreting the statutory regime
in respect of the powers of the Courts in Shailesh Kumar Singh alias
Shailesh R.Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.5, held that while
exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India or Section
482 CrPC, the Court must examine the allegations in the FIR and the material
on record to ascertain whether the ingredients of any criminal offence are
disclosed. The criminal process cannot be permitted to be used as a means
for recovery of a monetary claim arising out of a commercial dispute, and
quashing of criminal proceedings cannot be made subject to payment of a
specified amount to the complainant. Where the dispute is essentially civil or
commercial in nature, the parties are at liberty to pursue the appropriate civil
remedy.
18.
In this context, it is trite to quote the specific observations of the Apex
Court in Shailesh Kumar Singh’s case (supra), which reads are as under:
2022 SCC OnLine SC 2389
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1462
“11. The entire case is squarely covered by a recent pronouncement of
this Court in the case of “Delhi Race Club (1940) Limited v. State of
Uttar Pradesh”, (2024) 10 SCC 690. In the said decision, the entire law
as to what constitutes cheating and criminal breach of trust respectively
has been exhaustively explained. It appears that this very decision was
relied upon by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner before
the High Court. However, instead of looking into the matter on its own
merits, the High Court thought fit to direct the petitioner to go for
mediation and that too by making payment of Rs. 25,00,000/- to the 4th
respondent as a condition precedent. We fail to understand, why the
High Court should undertake such exercise. The High Court may either
allow the petition saying that no offence is disclosed or may reject the
petition saying that no case for quashing is made out. Why should the
High Court make an attempt to help the complainant to recover the
amount due and payable by the accused. It is for the Civil Court or
Commercial Court as the case may be to look into in a suit that may be
filed for recovery of money or in any other proceedings, be it under the
Arbitration Act, 1996 or under the provisions of the IB Code, 2016.
12. xxx
13. …. Money cannot be recovered, more particularly, in a civil dispute
between the parties by filing a First Information Report and seeking the
help of the Police. This amounts to abuse of process of law.”
Thus, from the above vivid opinions of the Apex Court, it is too well settled that
the police have no Jurisdiction to meddle with civil rights inter se parties.
19.
It is relevant to note that when the police interfere with the rights of the
parties without any lawful or jurisdictional authority, such interference can
have serious and far-reaching consequences, not only for larger societal
interests but also the very functioning of the police and the discharge of their
statutory duties. For instance, if a Station House Officer of a prominent and
sensitive police station, along with his subordinate personnel, engages in
resolving civil disputes based on his own whims and fancies, without any
jurisdiction conferred upon them, it would affect all the stakeholders in the civil
disputes and give rise to far more complications. Ultimately, such conduct
would also adversely affect the maintenance of law and order and the
effective discharge of their own statutory policing duties also which is not good
for the societal interest as well as the police department's interest too.
20.
In the above scenario, it is pertinent to note different expressions of the
Constitutional Courts while dealing with the rights of police in interfering with
the civil rights of the parties. In J. Lakshmi @ Lakshmamma and Anr. vs
Commissioner of Police6, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad
reiterated that the police authorities have no jurisdiction to interfere with the
disputes or to compel the parties to arrive at a settlement through police
intervention. Determination of civil rights and disputes relating to title or
possession purely falls within the domain of the Civil Court, and police cannot
assume such adjudicatory powers. The High Court, while observing that police
cannot interfere in civil disputes, observed as under:
“4. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that when the dispute is
purely of civil nature, the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution cannot be exercised. The Supreme Court also repeatedly
laid down that when the dispute between the two citizens is of civil
nature and no crime is registered, police have no jurisdiction to interfere
in the civil dispute. Further, when there is a civil litigation either before
the court of law or before the tribunal, the police have no jurisdiction to
interfere in the civil disputes. Further, when there is a civil litigation
either before a court of law or before a tribunal, the police cannot
interfere and even if a complaint is made in relation to such dispute
pending in a civil court, the citizens have to be advised to resolve the
dispute through a duly constituted court of law.
In the scheme of the Constitution of India, the duty to resolve civil
disputes is entrusted to judiciary. Police have no such power. Any
interference by police in a pending civil dispute or a potential civil
dispute between two citizens or two groups of citizens is not within the
province of the police. Furthermore, if a cognizable offence is reported
to the police, it is the duty of the police to register the crime
2004 SCC OnLine AP 29
under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.,)
and take up investigation immediately. In a given case, even if a civil
dispute, to say a land dispute, is pending before a civil court and if the
quarrel between the two warring parties has a potential of resulting in a
law and order problem posing threat to the society at large, the police
can always take up the case only after registering the crime
under Section 154 Cr.P.C. Without registering the crime and without
any reason the police cannot interfere.”
21.
In G.B.C. Raj Gopal vs. The Government of A.P., Rep. by the
Principal Secretary (2014)7, High Court of Andhra Pradesh, at Hyderabad,
while stating that the police have no jurisdiction to adjudicate civil or property
disputes inter se, parties opined that:
“51. The function of resolving civil disputes is entrusted to the judiciary.
Police officers lack jurisdiction to interfere in civil/property disputes
between two citizens. Even in criminal case, their role is limited to the
registration of complaints and causing investigation. The power to
adjudge whether or not an accused is guilty of having committed a
criminal offence, and to convict and sentence him therefor, is vested
exclusively in the judicial branch of the State. Judicial power cannot be
exercised by agencies outside the judicial orbit and, where there is no
legislative foundation for exercise of judicial power by a forum, it has no
legal capacity to entertain requests for adjudication. Judicial power is a
facet of sovereign power and can be conferred only by a Statute or by a
Statutory instrument. It cannot be assumed suo motu. No authority may
exercise adjudicatory powers absent a conferment of such powers by
Statutory instruments. The coercive power of the State may not be
employed to adjudicate disputes. (M/s. Janathaem Industries Ltd., rep.,
by its Public Relations Officer M.S. Ganesan, Vijayawada v. The District
Collector, Krishna district at Vijayawada).”
22.
Thus, once the statutory powers that are conferred on the Executive
Authorities itself come into the plunge with the intervention of Civil Courts, the
very fundamental, foundational fact that the police authorities have not been
conferred adjudicatory powers under the statutory scheme either in terms of
provisions of BNS, 2023
2014 SCC OnLine AP 322
or BNSS, 2023 nor under police laws, police
interference with the civil disputes of parties is per-se illegal, arbitrary and
absolutely without jurisdiction; moreover, it is diametrically opposed to the
constitutional vistas.
23.
It is also well settled that where the legal position on an issue stands
authoritatively settled by the Supreme Court, it is not necessary to multiply
authorities by referring to a catena of judgments reiterating the same
proposition. In furtherance of the above settled proposition, this Court is not
venturing into referring similar dictums.
24.
Yet another facet is that, even as per the data records, though Andhra
Pradesh police population is approximately 166.18 per one lakh population,
however, as per the United Nations recommendations, a Police-Population
ratio of 222 per lakh is required for apt policing. Hence, overall perception also
suggests that police, extending their limited forces, infrastructural facilities and
professional powers towards non-Jurisdictional arenas, may leads to futile
exercise except for the “unjust enrichment” of some of police personnel's
interests, which is per se illegal and unconstitutional and also against the letter
and spirit of our “Indian Constitutional” tenets, as well as antithesis to “Salus
populi suprema lex esto” (Let the welfare of the people be the supreme
law).
25.
Recently, in Rohit Chaturvedi v. State of Uttarakhand8, the Supreme
Court of India reiterated that executive action having a bearing upon the
2026 SCC Online SC 865
personal liberty of an individual must satisfy the constitutional requirement of
fairness and non-arbitrariness under Article 21 of the Constitution and held
that the exercise of executive discretion affecting liberty cannot be allowed to
remain
uncanalised
and
must
be
based
on
relevant
and
rational
considerations. Apex Court also emphasized that deprivation of liberty must
have a lawful, rational and constitutionally sustainable basis and cannot rest
upon a cryptic or unexplained executive decision.
26.
In this context, it is apt to note some of the ground realities and
problems that existed in our contemporary society, from the backdrop of the
colonial phase too. In fact, Sri Upendra Baxi, a renowned law scholar,
observed that “the colonial police survived decolonization; it simply changed
masters”, highlighting the continuity of the colonial policing system even after
India attained independence. The police structure, methods and legal
framework largely continued to reflect the colonial model, mainly based on the
Police Act, 1861, which was primarily designed to maintain order, control the
population and protect the interests of the ruling authority, rather than to
function as a citizen-oriented service. Thus, although the British rulers were
replaced by an elected Indian government, the basic institutional character of
the police remained substantially unchanged. Hence, all the stakeholders
contribute their respective support to change the overall existing police
structures from the colonial phase to people-centric policing in the larger
interest of modern Indian and turns into Democratic policing, which means a
system of policing in which the police exercise their powers within the limits of
law, remain accountable to constitutional and democratic institutions, and
respond to the legitimate needs and rights of the people.
27.
In considered opinion of this Court, after perceiving the overall facts and
circumstances of the core issue in the present batch of cases, police are
entrusted with the responsibility of protecting life, liberty, rights and public
order, but they are not an authority above the people. Police powers are
conferred by law and must be exercised fairly, reasonably and proportionately.
Thus, the police must act as guardians of the constitutional principles, rather
than as rulers exercising unchecked authority over citizens. It is significant to
note the dictum of the Supreme Court held in Prakash Singh vs. Union of
India,9 which plays a pivotal role in our Indian police reforms. Apex Court,
through its thoughtful consideration, formulated seven (07) directives in the
Prakash Singh’s case so as to strengthen the existing policing into more
professional, accountable and independent from unnecessary interference
from other quarters. Eminent legal personality Sri Solij Sorabjee, who was the
chairman of the Committee, contributed to formulate the Model Police Act,
2006 (MPA), which was a model draft legislation prepared by the Government
of India and circulated to the respective State Governments for enact or
amend the existing Police legislations. It seems only some State Governments
have passed their local Police laws inspired by the MPA, 2006. It is also apt to
note that subsequently, the Department-Related Parliamentary Standing
Committee on Home Affairs also forwarded its Report mentioning subsequent
2006 (8) SCC 1
developments on police training, modernization, and reforms by taking note of
previous Police Reforms Committees etc.
28.
In essence, when the police interfere with the rights of parties, without
any lawful or jurisdictional authority, such interference can have serious and
far-reaching consequences, not only on larger societal interests but also the
very functioning of the police too. Hence, clear boundaries of functions of law
enforcement agencies and judicial functions should be maintained.
29.
All in all, from the overall facts and circumstances coupled with statutory
regime as well as well-settled legal principles by the Supreme Court and other
constitutional Courts, it is unequivocally settled that the police have no
jurisdiction to adjudicate upon or determine the civil rights of parties inter se.
The determination of civil rights is within the domain of Civil Courts and other
legislative-conferred forums only. Accordingly, the core issue is answered.
30.
Accordingly, these Writ Petitions are disposed of as under:
i.
Respondent-Police are directed not to interfere or adjudicate or
determine or settle the civil rights of the parties, without legal cause.
ii.
Respondent-Police personnel to follow the guidelines issued by
the Director General of Police, Andhra Pradesh, vide Communication
No.76/DGP’s Peshi/2025 dated 24.10.2025 in its stricto sensu.
iii.
Likewise, it shall be open to the respective parties to work out
their legal remedies before the appropriate Civil Courts or competent
forums, in terms of the law.
iv.
It is hereby clarified that, if the police made out any cognizable
offences against the petitioners, they are at liberty to proceed in
accordance with the law;
There shall be no order as to costs.
Interlocutory applications, if any, pending shall stand closed.
____________________________________
JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
Date: 29.10.2026
vnb
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION Nos: 32401 and 4148 of 2025
Date: 29.10.2026
vnb
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review