Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
!
% $
! "
#
$
%
$
%
%
#&
%
RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
! "
#
'
(
)
*
(
#
) $+$
%
&
-2-
%$
*
$+$
'
(
* *
)
#
,
#
#
) -
$
&
*
#
.
#
/
*
05617089
?=2 790 @07474=5028 153
790 208@=53057
1::1;134 :012503 <=>580:
*1A> :012503 <=>580: ?=2
-3-
#479 790 <=58057 =? ;=79 790 @127408 790 B17702
48 71605 >@ ?=2 ?451: 348@=81:
%
=2 790 8160 =? ;20C47D 790 @127408 120 20?02203
7= 18 @02 79042 8717>8 ;0?=20 790
@07474=5
=BB02<41:
?4:03
;D
=>27
30?0531578
1EE240C03 ;D 790 4B@>E503 =2302 @18803 ;D 790 :012503
*>3E0 =? 790
=
=BB02<41:
31703
=>27 45
=
=30 =?
4C4:
=5
$ 348B48845E 790 1@@:4<174=5 ?4:03
;D 790 @07474=5028&30?0531578 >5302
&
>:0
2=<03>20 (?=2 89=27 F790
, =?
G) 800645E
1B053B057 7= 790 H247705 87170B0578
$
=?
B=50D
90 208@=53057&@:14574?? ?4:03 1 8>47 ?=2 20<=C02D
;0?=20
=BB02<41:
=>27
@07474=5028&30?0531578
?4:03
79042
87170B0578
07474=502
=8
87170B0578 153 @07474=502
91C0
H247705
?4:03
80@12170
H247705
= % H9= 48 30?053157
13=@703 790 H247705 87170B057 =? 30?053157
=
=%
88>08
H020 ?21B03 153 0C4305<0 913 <=BB05<03 153 17 7917
-4-
871E0 790 30?0531578 ?4:03 15 1@@:4<174=5 >5302
>:0
, =? 790
87170B0578
800645E 1B053B057 7= 790 H247705
?4:03
;D
30?053157
45<=2@=2174=5 =? ?>27902 ?1<78 17
=8
7=
121E21@9
%
800645E
=8 %
7= %%
948 1@@:4<174=5 H18 8024=>8:D =;A0<703 7= ;D 790 @:14574??
@=5 901245E 790 @127408
=BB02<41:
790 :012503 *>3E0 =? 790
=>27 20A0<703 790 1@@:4<174=5 =5 790 E2=>53
7917 =C0284E97 =2 :1@80 <155=7 1B=>57 7= 3>0 34:4E05<0 153
=5<0 790 7241: 918 <=BB05<03 15D 1B053B057 B>87 ;0
20?>803 45 <=BB02<41: 8>478 18 @2=<03>21: 74B0:4508 120
7= ;0 05?=2<03 H479 8724<75088 153 30:1D <155=7 ;0
<=53=503 >5302 790 E>480 =? 1B053B057
*>3E0 =? 790
=BB02<41:
1@@:4<174=5
1B053B057 =5
?=2
90 :012503
=>27 918 1:8= 20A0<703 790
E2=>53
7917 790
1B053B057 1@@:4<174=5 ?4:03 ;D 790 30?0531578 48 7= ?4:: >@
790 :1<>51 =? 790 <180 H94<9 <155=7 ;0 1::=H03 153 8= 1:8=
790 30?0531578 ?14:03 7= 0871;:489 3>0 34:4E05<0 153 =5 790
E2=>53 7917 790 1@@:4<174=5 ?4:03 ;D 790 30?0531578 48
;12203 ;D :4B47174=5 153 47 48 ?4:03 17 1 ;0:1703 871E0
-5-
45<>2245E 790 8717>7=2D @024=3 =? :4B47174=5 H94<9 48
4B@02B4884;:0
8=
1:8=
45<=2@=2174=5
=? 790
?=2
1B053B057
2018=5
H=>:3
<1>80
E21C0
45A>874<0 153 30?017 790 =;A0<7 =? :0E48:174C0 457057 =?
0I@03474=>8 13A>34<174=5 =? 8>47 >5302 790
=>278
<7
=20=C02
=BB02<41:
=BB02<41:
=>27 918 1:8=
<=B0 7= 790 <=5<:>84=5 7917 790 1B053B057 H=>:3 <915E0
790 517>20 153 <9121<702 =? 790 8>47
<<=2345E:D 20A0<703
790 1@@:4<174=5
012503 <=>580: ?=2 790 30?0531578 C090B057:D
<=5705303 7917 790 4B@>E503 =2302 @18803 ;D 790 :012503
*>3E0 =? 790
=BB02<41:
=>27 48 12;47212D
4::0E1: 153
@02C0280 153 20J>4208 7= ;0 807 18430 ?=2 790 2018=5 7917
=BB02<41:
=>27 918 022=50=>8:D <=B0 7= 790
<=5<:>84=5 7917 790 1@@:4<174=5 48 ?4:03 17 1 ;0:1703 871E0
1?702 <=BB05<0B057 =? 790 @:14574??G8 0C4305<0 153 =5 790
E2=>53 7917 790 81B0 H=>:3 <1>80 30:1D 45 790 8>47
7 48
?>27902 <=5705303 ;D 790 <=>580: 7917 790 @2=@=803
1B053B057 3=08 5=7 <915E0 =2 1:702 790 517>20 =? 790
-6-
8>47 5047902 47 48 ;12203 ;D 790 :1H =? :4B47174=5 18 790
30?0531578 120 5=7 800645E 7= 4572=3><0 790 50H <180 =2
4572=3><45E 15D ?1<78 7917 120 ;12203 ;D 790 :1H =?
:4B47174=5 5=2 120 790D 800645E 20<=C02D =? 1B=>57 18
790D 120 =5:D 800645E 13A>87B057 =? 790 1B=>57 1:2013D
:D45E H479 790 @:14574??
,
7 48 1:8= <=5705303 ;D 790 :012503 <=>580: 7917
79=>E9 30?053157
87170B057 30?053157
=
913 ?4:03 1 80@12170 H247705
=
918 ?4:03 15=7902 807 =? H247705
87170B057 H94<9 48 13=@703 ;D 30?053157
= % 7917 4780:?
H4:: 5=7 7160 1H1D 790 24E97 =? 790 30?0531578 7= ?4:0 15
1B053B057 1@@:4<174=5 7= 790 =24E451: H247705 87170B057
9020?=20
90 <=570538 7917 790
=BB02<41:
=>27 918
4E5=203 1:: 79080 18@0<78 153 B48<=5872>03 790 =;A0<7
453057 =? 790 :0E48:17>20 45E20340578 153 20J>420B0578 =?
790 1B053B057 18 <=570B@:1703 >5302
=? 790
>:0
,
8= 1:8= 790 ?1<7 7917 790 30?0531578 120 5=7
4572=3><45E 15D 50H <180 =2 15D 50H ?1<78 7917 120 ;12203
;D 790 :1H =? :4B47174=5
047902 79020 48 <915E0 45 790
-7-
<9121<702 =? 790 8>47 5=2 79020 1 <=>5702<:14B ?=2 20<=C02D
=? 790 1B=>57
7 48 1:8= <=5705303 7917 79020 48 5= :1<>51
?4::03 >@ ;D H1D =? 790 1B053B057 5=2 15D 13B4884=5
;045E H479321H5 ;D 790 30?0531578 H94:0 45<=2@=21745E 790
1B053B057
05<0 90 80068 7= 1::=H 790 @07474=5 153
<=580J>057:D 807 18430 790 4B@>E503 =2302 @18803 ;D 790
:012503 *>3E0 =? 790
=BB02<41:
+
=>27
:012503 <=>580: 1@@01245E ?=2 790
208@=53057&@:14574?? C090B057:D =;A0<78 7= 790 <=570574=58
@>7 ?=279 ;D 790 :012503 <=>580: ?=2 790 30?0531578
@24B124:D <=5705345E 7917
4287:D 790 1B053B057 1@@:4<174=5 48 5=H ?4:03 ;D 1::
790 30?0531578 H902018 790 H247705 87170B0578 H020 ?4:03
;D 30?053157
=8
13=@703
H247705
80@12170:D 153 30?053157
87170B057
9020?=20 H905 30?053157
=?
30?053157
=%
=
= % 918 5=7 ?4:03 790 H247705
87170B057 153 918 B020:D 13=@703 790 87170B057 =?
30?053157
=
<155=7
?4:0
1@@:4<174=5
?=2
1B053B057 =? 790 H247705 87170B057 18 =24E451::D 90 918
-8-
5=7 ?4:03 790 H247705 87170B057 =2 84E503 790 H247705
87170B057
0<=53:D
30?053157
=
1:7=E07902
?4:03
34??02057 H247705 87170B0578 79=>E9 790 <=>580: H18 790
81B0 153 H905 7917 ;045E 790 <180
79200 30?0531578
?4:45E 1 <=BB=5 1@@:4<174=5 ?=2 1B053B057 1:8= H=>:3 5=7
;0 8>871451;:0 =5 7948 E2=>53 1:8= 90 80068 20A0<74=5 153
8>871458 790 4B@>E503 =2302
9423:D ;D C427>0 =? 790 1B053B057 790 30?0531578
120 5=H 72D45E 7= 4572=3><0 790 453057 B130 ;D 790B 153
1:8= H479 20E123 7= 790 E==38 5=7 ;045E 45 E==3 <=53474=5
153 =? @==2 J>1:47D H94<9 790D 913 5=7 214803 012:402 ;>7
913 13B47703 7= 91C45E C024?403 790 E==38 18 ;045E =? E==3
J>1:47D 18 @02 @121E21@9
= $ =? 790 H247705 87170B057
90 1B053B057 48 5=H ?4:03 45 1 ;0:1703 871E0 1?702 790
0C4305<0 =? 790 @:14574?? 153 H905 790 B17702 48 @=8703 ?=2
0C4305<0
=?
30?0531578
9020?=20
1?70279=>E97 =? 790 30?0531578 7= ?4:0 790 1B053B057
1@@:4<174=5 45 790 ;0:1703 871E0 7= =C02<=B0 <027145 :1<>51
-9-
153 790 13B4884=58 B130 ;D 790 30?0531578 45 79042
@:01345E8 18 H0:: 18 45 790 0C4305<0
187:D
=? 790
8 @02 790 @2=C484=58 =?
=
>:0
,
5= 1B053B057 89=>:3 ;0 1::=H03 1?702 790
7241: 918 <=BB05<03
>5:088 790 30?0531578 89=H 3>0
34:4E05<0 153 <1>74=5 ?=2 5=7 91C45E 71605 8><9 870@8 7=
<122D =>7 790 1B053B057 17 790 012:4087 @=457 =? 74B0
1C45E 5=7 89=H5 1:: 79080 18@0<78 153 B1645E 15
1@@:4<174=5 ?=2 4572=3><74=5 =? 50H ?1<78 H=>:3 @20A>34<0
790 24E978 153 790 87153 =? 790 @:14574?? H94<9 <155=7 ;0
1::=H03
9020?=20 90 80068 20A0<74=5 =? 790 @07474=5 153
7= 1??42B 790 =2302 =? 790 :012503
=BB02<41:
=>27
91C0 90123 790 :012503 <=>580: ?=2 790
@07474=5028&30?0531578
208@=53057&@:14574??
:012503
<=>580:
?=2
90 @=457 7917 124808 ?=2 <=584302174=5
(4)
#907902
1B053B057
8=>E97
7=
;0
45<=2@=21703 ;D 790 30?0531578 20J>4208 7= ;0
1::=H03K
- 10 -
(44)
#917 =2302K
#94:0
301:45E
H479
1@@:4<174=5
?=2
1B053B057 =? @:01345E8 =? 790 @:14574?? 153 7917 =? 790
30?053157
790D ;=79 87153 =5 34??02057 ?==745E
1B053B057 =? 790 H247705 87170B0578 ;D 790 30?0531578
120 7= ;0 <=58430203 :054057:D 153 20J>4208 7= ;0 1::=H03
45 790 ?=::=H45E <42<>B8715<08
(4)
? 790 1B053B057 48 20J>4203 ?=2 0??0<74C0 153
@2=@02 13A>34<174=5 =? 790 <=572=C028D ;07H005
790 @127408
(44)
= 1C=43 B>:74@:4<47D =? 790 @2=<00345E8
?=2
30<4345E 790 201: 348@>70 45 J>0874=5
(444)
#9020 47 3=08 5=7 <1>80 15D 45A>874<0 7= 790
=7902 8430
(4C)
#9020
1B053B057
8=>E97
3=08
5=7
H479321H 15D <:012 13B4884=5 B130 ;D 790
@127408 4 0
30?0531578 H94<9 <=5?028 15D 24E97
=5 790 =7902 8430 4 0
790 @:14574??
- 11 -
(C)
#9020 790 1B053B057 3=08 5=7 21480 15D 74B0
;12203 <:14B 208>:745E =2 34C08745E =? 790 =7902
8430 =? 1 C1:>1;:0 1<<2>03 24E97
7 48 1:8= 8005 7917 790 1B053B0578 =? 790
H247705 87170B0578 120 E05021::D 5=7 1::=H03 45 790
?=::=H45E <42<>B8715<08
(4)
#9020 790 1B053B057 48 74B0 ;12203
(44)
7 4572=3><08 1 50H <180 <915E08 790 <9121<702
=? 790 8>47
(444)
#9020 790 @21D02 B130 48 B1:1?430
(4C)
#9020;D 1B053B057
790 =7902 8430 :=808 1
C1:43 0C4305<0
5 790 @208057 <180 5= 3=>;7 30?053157
=
918 ?4:03 1 80@12170 H247705 87170B057 ;D 94B80:? 153
30?053157
=
918 ?4:03 1 80@12170 H247705 87170B057 153
30?053157
= % 918 13=@703 790 H247705 87170B057 =?
30?053157
=
7917 H4:: 5=7 7160 1H1D 790 87170B0578
1:2013D ?4:03 ;D 790B ;0?=20 790
=>27
0?053157
=%
- 12 -
91C45E 13=@703 790 87170B057 =? 30?053157
E==3
30?053157
87170B057 90280:?
=
=%
91C45E
?4:03
=
48 18
H247705
9=>E9 47 48 <=5705703 7917 30?053157
918 ?4:03 1 80@12170 H247705 87170B057 7917 ;D 4780:?
H4:: 5=7 ;12 790 C02D 81B0 :1HD02 1@@01245E ?=2 1:: 79200
30?0531578 ?2=B ?4:45E 15 1@@:4<174=5 ?=2 1B053B057 7= 790
H247705 87170B0578
90 @2=@=803 1B053B057 3=08 5=7
4572=3><0 15D 50H <180
90 30?0531578 120 5=H 72D45E 7=
133 ?>27902 ?1<78 7= 790 1:2013D 0I48745E ?1<78 =? 790 <180
H479 20E123 7= <027145 31708 74B0:4508 4530578 153 <027145
1B=>57 =? 30@=847 :D45E H479 790 @:14574??
3= 5=7 1E200
H479 790 <=570574=5 =? 790 :012503 <=>580: ?=2 790
208@=53057&@:14574??
30?0531578
5=H
4572=3><45E 1 74B0 ;12203 <:14B 18 5= 8><9 1B053B057 48
8=>E97
90 30?0531578 120 5=7 800645E 15D 207>25 =?
1B=>57 790 30?0531578 120 =5:D 800645E 13A>87B057 =?
790 1B=>57 1:2013D :D45E H479 790 @:14574?? =5 790 B=50D
721581<74=5 =? <027145 8>@@:D =? E==38 51B0:D
==2
1:
- 13 -
%
#94:0
301:45E
H479
1@@:4<174=5
?=2
1B053B057 18 871703 ;D B0 012:402 B=20 8= 45 790 <1808
=? 1 H247705 87170B057 790
=>278 120 20J>4203 7= 7160 1
@21EB174< C40H 153 1 :054057 1@@2=1<9 153 ;0 :4;021: 45
1::=H45E 790 1B053B057 45 =2302 7= 30<430 790 201:
<=572=C028D 45 348@>70 153 ?=2 15 0??0<74C0 13A>34<174=5 =?
790 B17702 ;D 790 241:
=>27
7 48 1:8= 20:0C157 7= B0574=5 9020 7917 790
1B053B057 48 8=>E97 7= 4572=3><0 133474=51: =2 1 50H
?1<78 H479=>7 79020 ;045E 15D 74B0 ;12203 <:14B =2 <1>80
=? 1<74=5 H94<9 3=08 5=7 <1>80 15D 13C0280 4B@1<7 =5 790
@:14574??G8 <180
><9 1B053B0578 120 20J>4203 7= ;0
1::=H03 8= 1:8= 47 48 20:0C157 7917 4? <027145 133474=51: ?1<78
120 45<:>303 H94<9 H020 5=7 @:01303 012:402 ;D 790
30?0531578 790 81B0 <15 ;0 1::=H03
3= 5=7 ?453 30:1D
H=>:3 <=B0 7= @:1D 45 790 @208057 <180 18 790 <180 48 5=H
807 3=H5 ?=2 0C4305<0 =? 790 30?0531578
9020?=20 790
@2=C48= 1?702 <=BB05<0B057 =? 7241: ?=2 790 30?0531578 7=
89=H 3>0 34:4E05<0 H=>:3 5=7 7160 1H1D 790 45<=2@=2174=5
- 14 -
=? 790 1B053B057 ;D 790 30?0531578 18 47 3=08 5=7 1??0<7
790 <180 =? 790 @:14574??
$
012503 <=>580: ?=2 790 30?0531578 918 @:1<03
20:415<0 >@=5 7H= A>3EB0578 45 8>@@=27 =? 948 <180
50 45
790 <180 =?
$%& 153 15=7902 =50 45 790 <180 =? ' (
#
! "
##
)
*
( )
+
'
",!
## "&
5 ?1<7 =5
E=45E 792=>E9 79080 7H= A>3EB0578 79080 7H= A>3EB0578
8>@@=27 790 <180 =? 790 30?0531578 B=20 7915 7917 =? 790
@:14574??
0 1:8= 20:408 >@=5 790 =2302 =? 790
05<9 =? 7948
+
$
=>27 45 #
=
948 A>3EB057 =? 790
$$$&
= =2345170
$ 30<4303 =5
= =2345170
05<9 =?
=>27 48 5=7 1@@:4<1;:0 7= 790 ?1<78 =? 790 @208057
<180
8 871703 ;D B0 012:402 790 :1<>51 8= <:14B03
7= ;0 ?4::03 >@ ;D 790 30?0531578 3=08 5=7 12480 45 790 <180
- 15 -
=5 9153
18 5=7945E 48 5=H 4572=3><03 ;D H1D =? 15
1B053B057 ;D 790 30?0531578
13B4884=5 7917 48 H479321H5
8= 1:8= 79020 48 5=
7 @121E21@9
=8 $ 153
=?
790 =24E451: H247705 87170B057 790 30?0531578 913 45 ?1<7
71605 >@ 1 @:01 7917 790 E==38 8>@@:403 H020 5=7 =? E==3
J>1:47D 153 H020 =? @==2 J>1:47D 153 5=H ;D C427>0 =? 790
1B053B057 790D 120 ?>27902 871745E <027145 ?1<78 153 1:8=
800645E ?=2 13A>87B057 =? 790 1B=>57 1:2013D :D45E H479
790 @:14574??
5302 790 <42<>B8715<08
=BB02<41:
=>27 918 B48<=5872>03 790 @245<4@:0 =? 1B053B057 153
918 <=BB47703 15 022=2 45 <=B45E 7= 1 <=5<:>84=5 7917 790
30?0531578 120 4572=3><45E 1 74B0 ;12203 <:14B
17 1
;0:1703 871E0 153 913 5=7 89=H5 3>0 34:4E05<0 153 790
1B053B057 H=>:3 <915E0 790 517>20 =? 790 8>47 30@24C45E
790 @:14574?? =? C1:>1;:0 24E97
1B =? 790 =@454=5 7917
79020 48 5= 13B4884=5 H94<9 48 ;045E H479321H5 =2 71605
;1<6 ;D 790 30?0531578 45 790 1B053B057 7917 48 8=>E97
8= 1:8= 79020 48 5= :1<>51 7917 48 ;045E ?4::03 >@
=5G;:0
@0I
=>27 45 790 <180 =? ' (
)
*
- 16 -
#
( )
8>@21 17
121E21@9
=8 , (4) 7=
, (I4) 301:7 H479 790 B15502 45 H94<9 790 1B053B0578
120 7= ;0 1::=H03
90 81B0 H=>:3 ;0 1@@:4<1;:0 7= 790
@208057 ?1<78 =? 790 <180 7= ;0 1390203 7= H94<9 2013 18
>5302
-.
! "
#
#
!
$
%
%
! "
#
&
(
!
"
)*
'#
- 17 -
%
#
#
%
#
#
+
+
#
!
$
#
#
#
#
#
#
!
- 18 -
#
#
!
,
#
!
,
#
.
!
$
%
!
. /
! ,
#
!
.
,
#
#
#
! ,
#
- 19 -
#
#
#
!
.
,
#
! "
!$
#
%
+
#
#
! 0
#
%
#
!
!
5$678/08
,
9:8 ;
3 !
(%
!#
'
7 48 1:8= <=5705303 ;D 790 :012503 <=>580: ?=2
790 30?0531578 7917 790 30?0531578 120 5=7 800645E
?21B45E =? ?2089 488>08 18 790 1B053B057 7917 48 8=>E97
?=2 48 1:2013D <=C0203 45 790 488>08 ?21B03 ;D 790
9020?=20
=BB02<41:
=>27
=>27 5003 5=7 E= 457= 790
- 20 -
?21B45E =? ?>27902 488>08 153 <15 @2=<003 ?>27902 45 790
B17702 0I@03474=>8:D 45 C40H =? 790 ?1<7 7917 790 8>47 48
<=BB02<41: 45 517>20 153 ?4:03 45 790 D012
H479=>7
<1>845E ?>27902 30:1D
+
5 C40H =? 1;=C0 348<>884=58
7917 790 :012503 *>3E0 =? 790
<=BB47703
022=2
1B =? 790 C40H
=BB02<41:
@02C02847D 45
=>27 918
20A0<745E
1@@:4<174=5 800645E 1B053B057 H94<9 20J>4208 7= ;0 807
18430
<<=2345E:D
@2=<003 7= @188 790 ?=::=H45E
(4)
90 #247 07474=5 48 1::=H03
(44)
90 4B@>E503 =2302 31703
=5
=
245<4@1:
=BB02<41:
=
0884=58 *>3E0
1:1;>21E4 48
9020;D 807 18430
=580J>057:D
>5302
>:0
$ @18803
2=<03>20 48 1::=H03
, =? 790
&
;D
=
?4:03
=30 =?
4C4:
- 21 -
(444)
90 30?0531578 120 @02B47703 7= 45<=2@=2170 790
1B053B057
?4:0
1B05303
H247705
87170B0578 153 802C0 1 <=@D =5 790 =7902 8430
'(
%
&
!
=
:
=
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review