Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 15353 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
SRI. C.T. RAVI
S/O THIMMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
MEMBER OF LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL
R/A DEVADATTA NILAYA,
BASAVANAHALLI MAIN ROAD,
BASAVANAHALLI EXTENSION,
CHIKKAMAGALURU - 577 101
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. PRABHULING K. NAVADGI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. SHIVAPRASAD SHANTANAGOUDAR, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by
PADMAVATHI B
K
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY SAVANOOR POLICE STATION,
SAVANOOR, REPRESENTED BY
STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
SRI. MANJUNATH MANNIYAVAR,
S/O NOT KNOWN
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS
SAVANUR POLICE STATION,
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
TQ SAVANUR, HAVERI - 581 118.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ANOOP KUMAR, ADDL. SPP FOR R1)
THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S.482(FILED U/S.528 BNSS) OF
CR.P.C
PRAYING
04.11.2024
TO
QUASH
(ANNEXURE
A)
THE
FIRST
COMPLIANT
DATED
INFORMATION
REPORT
BEARING CRIME NO.208/2024 DATED 04.11.2024 (ANNEXURE
B) REGISTERED AGAINST THE PETITIONER FOR THE OFFENCE
P/US/ 196(1)(a) OF THE BNS 2023 AND ALL FURTHER
INVESTIGATION THERETO PENDING ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL
JUDGE AND JMFC SAVANUR, HAVERI DISTRICT AS AGAINST
THE PETITIONERS.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner is before this Court seeking the following
prayers:
"I.
Quash
the
Complaint
dated
04.11.2024
(Annexure - A), First Information Report bearing
Crime
No.0208/2024
dated
04.11.2024
(Annexure-B) registered against the petitioner
for the offence punishable under Section 196(1)(a)
of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and all
further investigation thereto pending on the file of
the file of the Civil Judge and JMFC, Savanur,
Haveri District, as against the Petitioner.
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
II.
Further this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to grant
such other reliefs as deemed fit in the interest of
justice and equtiy."
2.
Heard Sri. Prabhuling K. Navadgi, learned Senior
counsel for Sri. Shivaprasad Shantanagoudar, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners and Sri. Anoop Kumar, learned
Additional State Public Prosecutor appearing for respondent
No.2.
3.
The co-accused, the former Chief Minister was
before this Court in Crl.P.No.12164/2024. The Co-ordinate
bench of this Court, qua the co-accused has quashed the
proceedings by the following order:
3.
In addition to reiterating the various contentions
urged in the petition and referring to the material on
record, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
invited my attention to the impugned complaint and FIR
in order to point out that necessary ingredients for
commission of the offences punishable under Section
196(1)(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (old
Section 153A of IPC) were conspicuously absent and not
forthcoming in the same and the impugned complaint
and FIR deserve to be quashed in the light of the
following judgments of the Apex Court and this Court:
1. Javed Ahmad Hajam v. State of Maharashtra [(2024)
4 SCC 156]
2. Shiv Prasad Semwal v. State of Uttarakhand [(2024)
7 SCC 555]
3. Bilal Ahmed Kaloo v. State of A.P., [(1997)7 SCC 431]
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
4. Suresha v. State of Karnataka [Crl.P.No.5694/2024
DD 20.09.2024]
4.
Per contra, learned Additional SPP for respondent
No.1 submits that the complaint makes out the
allegations and the entire speech clearly indicates
commission of the offences punishable under Section
196(1)(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and as
such, question of interfering with the same at this stage
would not arise in the facts and circumstances of the
instant case.
5.
Before adverting to the rival submissions, it would
be necessary to extract the complaint which is as under:
" ಾನು ಮಂಜು ಾಥ ಮ ಯವರ ವಯಸು 32 ವಷ ,
ಾನ ೇಬ
ನಂಬರ 1202 ಸವಣೂರ
ೕ
ಾ ೆ
ೕಸ
.ನಂ.
9740951558 ೊಟ! ¦ügÁå¢, " ಾಂಕ-04-11-2024
*
ಾನು ಈಗ 4 ವಷ "ಂದ ಸವಣೂರ
ೕ
ಾ ೆಯ ' (.).(.
1202 ಅಂತ ಕತ ವ, -ವ .ಸು/01ೆ2ೕ ೆ. ಸದ, ಸವಣೂರ
ೕ
ಾ ೆಯ ' ಗುಪ0 4ಾ./ ಸಂಗ5.ಸುವ ಕತ ವ, -ವ .ಸು/01ೆ2ೕ ೆ. ಈ
"ವಸ " ಾಂಕ-04-11-2024 ರಂದು ಸವಣೂರ
ೕ
6ಾ,)0ಯ '
78ಾ9ಂವ-ಸವಣೂರ
ಚು ಾವ ೆಯ
ಾಂ8ೆ5ೕಸ
ಪ?ದ
:;ಾನಸ<ಾ
ಚು ಾವ ಾ
ಪ5@ಾರ
ಉಪ
ಸ<ೆಗಳ '
ಾ ಾ
4ಾನ,
ಮುಖ,ಮಂ/5ಗಳC ಕ ಾ ಟಕ ಸ ಾ ರ ರವರು <ಾಗವ.ಸುವ ಬಂ1ೋಬಸ0
ಕತ ವ,ದ 'ದು2 ಅಲ'1ೆ ಸವಣೂರ ನಗರದ ' E.Fೆ.). ಪ?ದ ವ/Gಂದ
1ೇವHಾIನ ಮತು0 Jೈತರ ಅ(0ಯನುL ಕಬMಸು/0ರುವ ವN ಮಂಡM Pಾಗೂ
ಾಂ8ೆ5ೕಸ ಪ?ದ -;ಾ ರವನುL ಖಂQ( 4ಾನ, 4ಾR ಮುಖ,ಮಂ/5ಗಳC
75ೕ.ಬಸವJಾಜ
Sೊ4ಾTG
ಇವರ
ೇತೃತWದ '
ಪ5/ಭಟ ೆಯ
ಬಂ1ೋಬಸ0 PÀvÀðªÀ太Àð»¸ÀÄwÛzÁÝUÀ ಈ "ವಸ " ಾಂಕ-04-11-2024
ರಂದು ಮ1ಾ,ಹL 3-30 ಗಂ ೆ ಸು4ಾZ8ೆ ಸವಣೂರ ನಗರದ ಭರಮ1ೇವರ
ಸಕ
ದ ' ಬಂ1ೋಬಸ[ ಕತ ವ,ದ 1
' ಾ2ಗ 1) 4ಾನ, 4ಾR
ಮುಖ,ಮಂ/5ಗಳC 75ೕಬಸವJಾಜ Sೊ4ಾTG 2)75ೕ (.\ ರ: 4ಾR
ಮಂ/5ಗಳC 3)75ೕ.ಅರ:ಂದ Sೆಲ'ದ ]ಾಸಕರು 4)75ೕ ).JಾRೕವ 4ಾR
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
]ಾಸಕರು 5)75ೕ.ಅರುಣಕು4ಾರ ಪ^Fಾರ 4ಾR ]ಾಸಕರು ಇವರುಗಳC
ಒಂದು 6ಾಹನದ ' ಹ/0 ತಮT <ಾಷಣವನುL 4ಾQದು2 ಅದರ ' 4ಾನ,
4ಾR ಮುಖ,ಮಂ/5ಗಳC 75ೕ ಬಸವJಾಜ Sೊ4ಾTG ಮತು0 75ೕ.(.\.
ರ: 4ಾR ಮಂ/5ಗಳC ಇವರು ತಮT <ಾಷಣದ ' ಒಂದು ಧಮ ದ ಜನರ
<ಾವ ೆ ೆರMಸುವ ಮತು0 ಉaೆ0ೕಜನ -ೕಡುವ Pಾ8ೆ <ಾಷಣ 4ಾQದು2
Sೊ4ಾTGರವರು 4ಾತ ಾಡು6ಾಗ ಸವಣೂರ ನಡುವ -ಂತ ಎ ' ಕಲ'
©ಲ'aೈ/ ಅದ ೆc ವPïá ಆ(0, ಅಂ8ಾತ ನಮT <ೋ: ಸ4ಾಜದ ಮ ೆಗಳ
-4ಾ ಣ 4ಾಡSೇಕು ಅಂaಾ ಹಣ ಮಂಜೂರು 4ಾQದು2 ಸು4ಾರು
ಮೂರು ವಷ ದ .ಂ1ೆ <ೋ: ಸ4ಾಜ ೆc ಮಂಜೂರು 4ಾQದ ಹಣ ಅದು
ಕೂಡ ವPïá ಆ(0 ಅಂತ PೇಳCaಾ0Jೆ ಅಂತ ಒಂದು Fಾ/ಯನುL ಉaೆ0ೕRಸುವ
ಉ1ೆ2ೕಶ"ಂದ ಮತು0 (.\. ರ: ರವರು ನಮ8ೆ ಸಂ:;ಾನ 1ೊಡg1ೋ
ಅಥ6ಾ ಶZೕhಾ ಾನೂನು 1ೊಡg1ೋ ಇ ' ವPïá PೆಸZನ ' Jೈತರ
ಜiೕನುಗಳನುL, 1ೇವHಾIನಗಳನುL, ೆJೆಗಳನುL ವPïá kಾaೆ8ೆ ಹಚುl/01ಾ2Jೆ
ಇ ' ಜiೕgïCºÀäzÀವರ ಶZೕhಾ ಾನೂನು ನmೆಯnಾ' ಅಂaಾ ಮತು0
ಸು4ಾರು 1600 ವಷ ಗಳ .ಂದ ಕ\!ದ HೋoೕಶWರ 1ೇವHಾIನ
ನಮTದು ಅಂ/1ಾ2Jೆ ಇವZ8ೆ hಾವpದರ ' PೊmೆಯSೇಕು ಅಂತ ಜನZ8ೆ
ೇM1ಾಗ ಜನರು ಚಪq Gಂದ PೊmೆಯSೇಕು ಅಂತ ಕೂrರುaಾ0Jೆ.
ಅಲ'1ೆ ಈಗ ಏ ಾದರೂ Sಾಲ EtlದJೆ ಚnೇFಾವ ಚಳCವM 1947 ರ '
ಎnಾ' ೊ\!1ೆ HಾಬZ8ೆ uಾvHಾ0ನ .ಂದೂಗM8ೆ ಇಂQhಾ ೊಟು! nೆ ಾc
ಚು ಾ0 4ಾQ ಆr1ೆ ಆದರೂ ಸ.ತ ನಮT Jೈತರ ಜiೕನು, 1ೇವHಾIನ
Sೇಕಂತ ಅಂತ ೈಯ ' oೖN .Qದು ೊಂಡು ಏರು ಧw-ಯ ' ಕೂQದ
ಜನರ ಮುಂ1ೆ <ಾಷಣ 4ಾQದು2 ಇದZಂದ ೋಮುಗಳ, ಅಥ6ಾ Fಾ/ಗಳ
ಮದ, ಅHೌPಾದ aೆ ಅಥ6ಾ 6ೈರತW, 6ೈಮನಸು ಮೂಡುವಂತಹ,
<ಾವ ೆಗಳC
ೆರಳCವಂaೆ ಒಂದು
ೋ:8ೆ ಉaೆ0ೕಜನ -ೕಡುವಂತಹ
<ಾಷಣ 4ಾQದು2 ಸದZ <ಾಷಣವನುL ನನL
Sೈ
ಮೂಲಕ :ೕQyೕ
t/5ೕಕರಣ 4ಾQರುaೆ0ೕ ೆ. ಸವಣೂರ ನಗರದ ' ಉಪಚು ಾವ ೆಯ -ೕ/
ಸಂ.aೆ FಾZಯ 'ದು2 ಆದರೂ ಸ.ತ oೕnಾc (ದ E.Fೆ.). ಪ?ದ
ಮುಖಂಡರು ಒಂದು Fಾ/ ಅಥ6ಾ ಒಂದೂ ೋಮನವರ <ಾವ ೆ8ೆ ಧ ೆc
ತರುವಂaೆ ಮತು0 ಒಂದು
<ಾಷಣ
4ಾQದು2
ೋiನವರನುL ಉaೆ0ೕRಸುವ Zೕ/ಯ '
ಇದನುL
ನನL
Sೈ
ದ '
:ೕQyೕ
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
4ಾQ ೊಂQರುaೆ0ೕ ೆ. ಒಂದೂ ೋiನವರ <ಾವ ೆ8ೆ ಧ ೆc ತರುವಂaೆ
ಮತು0 ಒಂದು ೋiನವರನುL ಉaೆ0ೕRಸುವ Zೕ/ಯ ' <ಾಷಣ 4ಾQದ
4ಾನ, 4ಾR ಮುಖಮಂ/5ಗಳC 75ೕ.ಬಸವJಾಜ Sೊ4ಾTG ಮತು0
75ೕ.(.\.ರ: 4ಾR ಮಂ/5ಗಳC ಇವರ oೕnೆ
ಾನೂನು ಕ5ಮ
ೈ8ೊಳzಲು ನನLದು {hಾ " ಇರುತ01ೆ."
6.
A perusal of the complaint and FIR would clearly
indicate that the petitioner is alleged to have committed
the offences punishable under Section 196(1)(a) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (old Section 153A of
IPC). Under identical circumstances, in relation to the
offences punishable under Section 153-A of IPC, the
Apex Court and this Court have held in the following
judgments as under:
1.
Paragraphs 7 to 10 and 12 of the judgment of the
Apex Court in Javed Ahmad Hajam v. State of
Maharashtra [(2024)4 SCC 156] read as under:
"7. In Manzar Sayeed Khan, while
interpreting Section 153-A, in para 16, this Court
held thus: (SCC p. 9)
"16. Section 153-A IPC, as extracted
hereinabove, covers a case where a person
by words, either spoken or written, or by
signs or by visible representations or
otherwise,
promotes
or
attempts
to
promote, disharmony or feelings of enmity,
hatred or ill will between different religious,
racial, language or regional groups or castes
or communities or acts prejudicial to the
maintenance of harmony or is likely to
disturb the public tranquillity. The gist of
the offence is the intention to promote
feelings of enmity or hatred between
different
classes
of
people.
The
intention to cause disorder or incite the
people to violence is the sine qua non of
the offence under Section 153-A IPC
and the prosecution has to prove prima
facie the existence of mens rea on the
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
part of the accused. The intention has
to be judged primarily by the language
of the book and the circumstances in
which the book was written and
published. The matter complained of
within the ambit of Section 153-A must
be read as a whole. One cannot rely on
strongly worded and isolated passages
for proving the charge nor indeed can
one take a sentence here and a
sentence there and connect them by a
meticulous
process
of
inferential
reasoning."
(emphasis supplied)
8. This Court in Manzar Sayeed Khan
referred to the view taken by Vivian Bose, J., as a
Judge of the erstwhile Nagpur High Court in
Bhagwati Charan Shukla v. Provincial Govt.3 A
Division Bench of the High Court dealt with the
offence of sedition under Section 124-A IPC and
Section 4(1) of the Press (Emergency Powers) Act,
1931. The issue was whether a particular 9 article
in the press tends, directly or indirectly, to bring
hatred or contempt to the Government established
in law. This Court has approved this view in its
decision in Ramesh v. Union of India. In the said
case, this Court dealt with the issue of applicability
of Section 153-A IPC. In para 13, it was held thus:
(Ramesh case, SCC p. 676)
“13. ….. the effect of the words
must be judged from the standards of
reasonable, strong-minded, firm and
courageous men, and not those of weak
and vacillating minds, nor of those who
scent danger in every hostile point of
view. … It is the standard of ordinary
reasonable man or as they say in English
law 'the man on the top of a Clapharm
omnibus'. (Bhagwati Charan Shukla case,
SCC OnLine MP para 67)"
(emphasis supplied)
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Therefore, the yardstick laid down by Vivian Bose,
J., will have to be applied while judging the effect
of the words, spoken or written, in the context of
Section 153-A IPC.
9. We may also make a useful reference to a
decision of this Court in Patricia Mukhim v. State
of Meghalaya. Paras 8 to 10 of the said decision
read thus: (SCC pp. 41-43)
"8. 'It is of utmost importance to
keep all speech free in order for the
truth to emerge and have a civil
society.' - Thomas Jefferson. Freedom of
speech and expression guaranteed by Article
19(1)(a) of the Constitution is a very
valuable fundamental right. However, the
right is not absolute. Reasonable restrictions
can be placed on the right of free speech
and expression in the interest of sovereignty
and integrity of India, security of the State,
friendly relations with foreign States, public
order, decency or morality or in relation to
contempt of Court, defamation or incitement
to an offence. Speech crime is punishable
under Section 153-A IPC. Promotion of
enmity between different groups on grounds
of religion, race, place of birth, residence,
language, etc, and doing acts prejudicial to
maintenance of harmony is punishable with
imprisonment which may extend to three
years or with fine or with both under Section
153-A. As we are called upon to decide
whether a prima facie case is made out
against the appellant for committing
offences
under
Sections
153-A
and
505(1)(c), it is relevant to reproduce the
provisions which are as follows:
*
*
*
9. Only where the written or spoken
words have the tendency of creating public
disorder or disturbance of law and order or
affecting public tranquillity, the law needs to
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
step in to prevent such an activity. The
intention to cause disorder or incite
people to violence is the sine qua non of
the offence under Section 153-A IPC
and the prosecution has to prove 9 the
existence of mens rea in order to
succeed.
10. The gist of the offence under
Section 153-A IPC is the intention to
promote feelings of enmity or hatred
between different classes of people. The
intention has to be judged primarily by the
language of the piece of writing and the
circumstances in which it was written and
published. The matter complained of within
the ambit of Section 153-A must be read as
a whole. One cannot rely on strongly worded
and isolated passages for proving the charge
nor indeed can one take a sentence here
and a sentence there and connect them by a
meticulous
process
of
inferential reasoning.”
(emphasis in original and supplied)
10. Now, coming back to Section 153-A,
clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 153-A IPC
is attracted when by words, either spoken or
written or by signs or by visible representations or
otherwise, an attempt is made to promote
disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or ill will
between different religious, racial, language or
regional groups or castes or communities. The
promotion of disharmony, enmity, hatred or ill will
must be on the grounds of religion, race, place of
birth, residence, language, caste, community or
any other analogous grounds. Clause (b) of subsection (1) of Section 153-A IPC will apply
only when an act is committed which is prejudicial
to the maintenance of harmony between different
religious, racial, language or regional groups or
castes or communities and which disturbs or is
likely to disturb the public tranquillity.
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
12. In Manzar Sayeed Khan, this Court has
read "intention" as an essential ingredient of the
said offence. The alleged objectionable words or
expressions used by the appellant, on its plain
reading, cannot promote disharmony or feelings of
enmity, hatred or ill will between different
religious, racial, language or regional groups or
castes or communities. The WhatsApp status of
the appellant has a photograph of two barbed
wires, below which it is mentioned that "AUGUST 5
— BLACK DAY — JAMMU & KASHMIR". This is an
expression of his individual view and his reaction
to the abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution
of India. It does not reflect any intention to do
something which is prohibited under Section 153A. At best, it is a protest, which is a part of his
freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by
Article 19(1)(a)."
2.
Paragraphs 21 to 32 of the judgment of the Apex
Court
in
Shiv
Prasad
Semwal
v.
State
of Uttarakhand [(2024) 7 SCC 555] read as under:
"21. It may be noted that the entire case as
set out in the impugned FIR is based on the
allegation that the Facebook news post uploaded
by one journalist Mr Gunanand Jakhmola was
caused to be published on Parvatjan news portal
being operated by the appellant.
22. Thus, essentially, we are required to
examine whether the contents of the news report
constitute any cognizable offence so as to justify
the investigation into the allegations made in the
FIR against the appellant.
23. For the sake of ready reference, the
contents of the disputed news article are
reproduced hereinbelow:
"Gunanand Jakhmola
17-3-2020 at 30.05
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Trivender Uncle what amazing things you
are doing?
Uncle you are laying foundation stone of Art
Gallery which is going to construct by
acquiring government land.
Uncle you are associating the mafias who
are violating the decisions of Modi
Government. Don't trap yourself with
mafias, have you forgot the problems arisen
out of marriage of Gupta brother's.
Uncle you were not like this, what happened
to you? Was the troubles arisen out of
marriage of Gupta Brothers was not enough
that you are now going to laying foundation
stone of the Art Gallery which is going to
construct by acquiring government land.
Just think over it, or take report from LIU
and other agencies about this Art Gallery
which is going to construct on the acquired
government land. This is a government land
which is dismantled by mafias and your
officers.
Uncle
you
are
innocent,
anybody can use you. Advisers and officers
surrounding you they are cunning.
This cunning persons have brought you
forward against the decisions of Modi
Government.
Uncle let I inform you for your knowledge
that Modi Government means your honour
has given sanction to planning for Singtali
Project near Rishikesh. This project will
reduce the distance between Kumau and
Garhwal and also it will arrange sources of
employment in mountains.World Bank is
also giving money, but the program of
Mafias in which you are going to participate
on 20 March, that is an enemy of
mountains. It has no concern with the well
being of mountains. It is against the
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
proposed project of Modi Government and
your officers and advisers are in collusion
with that. Please inquire it and then only you
go.
Note: Kindly see the invitation card given
by mafias."
24. As per the counter-affidavit filed on behalf
of the State, after investigation, two substantive
offences were retained by the investigating officer
against the appellant, which are Sections 153-A
and 504 read with Sections 34 and 120-B IPC.
25. From a bare reading of the language of
Section 153-A IPC, it is clear that in order to
constitute such offence, the prosecution must
come out with a case that the words "spoken" or
"written" attributed to the accused, created enmity
or bad blood between different groups on the
ground of religion, race, place of birth, residence,
language, etc. or that the acts so alleged were
prejudicial to the maintenance of harmony.
26. Upon careful perusal of the offending news
article, reproduced (supra), it is crystal clear that
there is no reference to any group or groups of
people in the said article. The publication focuses
totally on the complainant imputing that he had
encroached upon public land where the foundation
stone laying ceremony was proposed at the hands
of Hon'ble Chief Minister of Uttarakhand.
27. Apparently, the post was aimed at
frustrating the proposed foundation stone laying
ceremony on the land, of which the complainant
claims to be the true owner. The post also imputes
that the person who was planning the foundation
stone ceremony was an enemy of mountains and
had no concern with the well-being of the
mountains.
28. The learned Standing Counsel for the State
tried to draw much water from these lines alleging
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
that this portion of the post tends to create a
sense of enmity and disharmony amongst people
of
hill
community
and
the
people
of plains. However, the interpretation sought to be
given to these words is far-fetched and
unconvincing. The lines referred to supra only
refer to the complainant, imputing that his
activities are prejudicial to the hills. These
words have no connection whatsoever with a
group or groups of people or communities. Hence,
the foundational facts essential to constitute the
offence under Section 153-A IPC are totally lacking
from
the
allegations
as
set
out
in
e
the FIR.
29. In Manzar Sayeed Khan v. State of
Maharashtra, this Court held that for applying
Section 153-A IPC, the presence of two or more
groups or communities is essential, whereas in the
present case, no such groups or communities were
referred to in the news article.
30. The other substantive offence which has
been applied by the investigating agency is
Section 504 IPC. The said offence can be invoked
when the insult of a person provokes him to break
public peace or to commit any other offence.
There is no such allegation in the FIR that owing to
the alleged offensive post attributable to the
appellant, the complainant was provoked to such
an extent that he could indulge in disturbing the
public peace or commit any other offence. Hence,
the FIR lacks the necessary ingredients of the said
offence as well.
31. Since we have found that the foundational
facts essential for constituting the substantive
offences under Sections 153-A and 504 IPC are
not available from the admitted allegations of
prosecution, the allegations qua the subsidiary
offences under Sections 34 and 120-B IPC would
also be non est.
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
32. The complainant has also alleged in the FIR
that the accused intended to blackmail him by
publishing the news article in question. However,
there is no allegation in the FIR that the accused
tried to extract any wrongful gain or valuable
security from the complainant on the basis of the
mischievous/ malicious post."
3.
Paragraphs 10 and 12 of the judgment of the Apex
Court in Bilal Ahmed Kaloo v. State of A.P. [(1997)
7 SCC 431] read as under:
"10. Section 153-A was amended by the
Criminal and Election Laws (Amendment) Act,
1969 (Act No. 35 of 1969). It consists of three
clauses of which clauses (a) and (b) alone are
material now. By the same Amending Act subsection (2) was added to Section 505 of the Indian
Penal Code. Clauses (a) and (b) of Section 153-A
and Section 505(2) are extracted below:
"153-A.
Promoting
enmity
between
different groups on grounds of religion, race,
place of birth, residence, language, etc., and
doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of
harmony.— (1)Whoever—
(a) by words, either spoken or written, or by
signs or by visible representations or
otherwise,
promotes
or
attempts
to
promote, on grounds of religion, race, place
of birth, residence, language, caste or
community or any other ground whatsoever,
disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or
ill will between different religious, racial,
language or regional groups or castes or
communities, or
(b) commits any act which is prejudicial to
the maintenance of harmony between
different religious, racial, language or
regional groups or castes or communities,
and which disturbs or is likely to disturb the
public tranquillity, or
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
(c)
*
*
*
shall be punished with imprisonment which
may extend to three years, or with fine, or
with both.
*
*
*
505. (2) Statements creating or
promoting enmity, hatred or ill will between
classes.—Whoever makes, publishes or
circulates
any
statement
or
report
containing rumour or alarming news with
intent to create or promote, or which is
likely to create or promote, on grounds of
religion, race, place of birth, residence,
language, caste or community or any other
ground whatsoever, feelings of enmity,
hatred or ill will between different religious,
racial, language or regional groups or castes
or communities, shall be punished with
imprisonment which may extend to three
years, or with fine, or with both."
The common ingredient in both the offences is
promoting feeling of enmity, hatred or ill will
between different religious or racial or linguistic or
regional groups or castes or communities. Section
153-A covers a case where a person by "words,
either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible
representations" promotes or attempts to promote
such feeling. Under Section 505(2), promotion of
such feelings should have been done by making
and publishing or circulating any statement or
report containing rumour or alarming news.
12. The main distinction between the two
offences is that while publication of the words or
representation is not necessary under the former,
such publication is sine qua non under Section
505. The words "whoever makes, publishes or
circulates" used in the setting of Section 505(2)
cannot be interpreted disjunctively but only as
supplementary to each other. If it is construed
disjunctively, anyone who makes a statement
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
falling within the meaning of Section 505 would,
without publication or circulation, be liable to
conviction. But the same is the effect with Section
153-A also and then that section would have been
bad for redundancy. The intention of the
legislature in providing two different sections on
the same subject would have been to cover two
different fields of similar colour. The fact that both
sections were included as a package in the same
amending enactment lends further support to the
said construction."
4.
Paragraphs 8 to 10 of the judgment of this Court in
Suresha v. State of Karnataka [Crl.P.No.5694/2024
DD 20.09.2024] read as under:
"8. The offences alleged are the ones
punishable under Sections 153A, 504, 506 and
others relating to unlawful assembly. Whether this
would become the ingredients of Section 153A of
the IPC is to be noticed. Section 153A of the IPC
reads as follows:
“153-A. Promoting enmity between
different groups on grounds of religion,
race,
place
of
birth,
residence,
language,
etc.,
and
doing
acts
prejudicial
to
maintenance
of
harmony.—(1) Whoever—
(a)
by words, either spoken or written, or
by signs or by visible representations or
otherwise,
promotes
or
attempts
to
promote, on grounds of religion, race, place
of birth, residence, language, caste or
community or any other ground whatsoever,
disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or
ill-will between different religious, racial,
language or regional groups or castes or
communities, or
(b)
commits any act which is prejudicial
to the maintenance of harmony between
different religious, racial, language or
regional groups or castes or communities,
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
and which disturbs or is likely to disturb the
public tranquillity, or
(c)
organises any exercise, movement,
drill or other similar activity intending that
the participants in such activity shall use or
be trained to use criminal force or violence
or knowing it to be likely that the
participants in such activity will use or be
trained to use criminal force or violence, or
participates in such activity intending to use
or be trained to use criminal force or
violence or knowing it to be likely that the
participants in such activity will use or be
trained to use criminal force or violence,
against any religious, racial, language or
regional group or caste or community and
such activity, for any reason whatsoever
causes or is likely to cause fear or alarm or
a feeling of insecurity amongst members of
such religious, racial, language or regional
group or caste or community,
shall be punished with imprisonment which
may extend to three years, or with fine, or
with both.
Offence committed in place of
worship, etc.—(2) Whoever commits an
offence specified in sub-section (1) in any
place of worship or in any assembly
engaged in the performance of religious
worship or religious ceremonies, shall be
punished with imprisonment which may
extend to five years and shall also be liable
to fine.”
Section 153A makes it an offence if enmity is
promoted between different groups of religion. The
present case is a classic illustration of misuse of
Section 153A of the IPC. It is a case of
counterblast to a complaint registered by these
petitioners. The defence is that the petitioners
were shouting Bharath Matha Ki Jai and praising
the Prime Minister of the nation. The allegation by
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
the complainant does not even refer to any of
those things.
To protect the skin of the
complainant and others, the skin of the petitioners
is sought to be ripped off. It does not meet even a
single ingredient of Section 153A of the IPC. A
pure case of counterblast is sought to be projected
as a crime under Section 153A of the IPC. The
ingredients that are necessary to bring home the
complaint under Section 153A need not detain this
Court for long or delve deep into the matter.
9. The Apex Court in the case of JAVED
AHMAD HAJAM v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
[(2024) 4 SCC 156], has held as follows:
“…. ….
….
10. Now, coming back to Section 153A, clause (a) of sub-section (1) of
Section 153-AIPC is attracted when by
words, either spoken or written or by
signs or by visible representations or
otherwise, an attempt is made to
promote disharmony or feelings of
enmity, hatred or ill will between
different religious, racial, language or
regional
groups
or
castes
or
communities.
The
promotion
of
disharmony, enmity, hatred or ill will
must be on the grounds of religion,
race,
place
of
birth,
residence,
language, caste, community or any
other analogous grounds. Clause (b) of
sub-section (1) of Section 153-AIPC
will apply only when an act is
committed which is prejudicial to the
maintenance of harmony
between
different religious, racial, language or
regional
groups
or
castes
or
communities and which disturbs or is
likely to disturb the public tranquillity.
11. Now, coming to the words used by the
appellant on his WhatsApp status, we may
note here that the first statement is that
August 5 is a Black Day for Jammu and
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Kashmir. 5-8-2019 is the day on which
Article 370 of the Constitution of India was
abrogated,
and
two
separate
Union
Territories of Jammu and Kashmir were
formed. Further, the appellant has posted
that “Article 370 was abrogated, we are not
happy”. On a plain reading, the appellant
intended to criticise the action of the
abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution
of India. He has expressed unhappiness
over the said act of abrogation. The
aforesaid words do not refer to any religion,
race, place of birth, residence, language,
caste or community. It is a simple protest
by the appellant against the decision to
abrogate Article 370 of the Constitution of
India and the further steps taken based on
that decision. The Constitution of India,
under Article 19(1)(a), guarantees freedom
of speech and expression. Under the said
guarantee, every citizen has the right to
offer criticism of the action of abrogation of
Article 370 or, for that matter, every
decision of the State. He has the right to say
he is unhappy with any decision of the
State.
12. In Manzar
Sayeed
Khan [Manzar
Sayeed Khan v. State
of Maharashtra,
(2007) 5 SCC 1 : (2007) 2 SCC (Cri) 417] ,
this Court has read “intention” as an
essential ingredient of the said offence. The
alleged objectionable words or expressions
used by the appellant, on its plain reading,
cannot promote disharmony or feelings of
enmity, hatred or ill will between different
religious, racial, language or regional groups
or castes or communities. The WhatsApp
status of the appellant has a photograph of
two barbed wires, below which it is
mentioned that “AUGUST 5 — BLACK DAY —
JAMMU & KASHMIR”. This is an expression of
his individual view and his reaction to the
abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
of India. It does not reflect any intention to
do something which is prohibited under
Section 153-A. At best, it is a protest, which
is a part of his freedom of speech and
expression guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a).
13. Every citizen of India has a right to
be critical of the action of abrogation of
Article 370 and the change of status of
Jammu and Kashmir. Describing the day
the abrogation happened as a “Black
Day” is an expression of protest and
anguish. If every criticism or protest of
the actions of the State is to be held as
an offence under Section 153-A,
democracy, which is an essential
feature of the Constitution of India, will
not survive.
14. The right to dissent in a legitimate
and lawful manner is an integral part of
the rights guaranteed under Article
19(1)(a). Every individual must respect
the right of others to dissent. An
opportunity
to
peacefully
protest
against
the
decisions
of
the
Government is an essential part of
democracy. The right to dissent in a
lawful manner must be treated as a
part of the right to lead a dignified and
meaningful life guaranteed by Article
21. But the protest or dissent must be
within four corners of the modes
permissible in a democratic set up. It is
subject
to
reasonable
restrictions
imposed in accordance with clause (2)
of Article 19. In the present case, the
appellant has not at all crossed the line.
15. The High Court has held [Javed Ahmed
Hajam v. State of Maharashtra, 2023 SCC
OnLine Bom 819] that the possibility of
stirring up the emotions of a group of people
cannot be ruled out. The appellant's college
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
teachers, students, and parents were
allegedly members of the WhatsApp group.
As held by Vivian Bose, J., the effect of the
words used by the appellant on his
WhatsApp status will have to be judged from
the standards of reasonable women and
men. We cannot apply the standards of
people with weak and vacillating minds. Our
country has been a democratic republic for
more than 75 years. The people of our
country know the importance of democratic
values. Therefore, it is not possible to
conclude that the words will promote
disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or
ill will between different religious groups.
The test to be applied is not the effect of the
words on some individuals with weak minds
or who see a danger in every hostile point of
view. The test is of the general impact of the
utterances on reasonable people who are
significant in numbers. Merely because a few
individuals may develop hatred or ill will, it
will not be sufficient to attract clause (a) of
sub-section (1) of Section 153-AIPC.
16. As regards the picture containing
“Chand” and below that the words “14th
August-Happy Independence Day Pakistan”,
we are of the view that it will not attract
clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 153AIPC. Every citizen has the right to extend
good wishes to the citizens of the other
countries on their respective Independence
Days. If a citizen of India extends good
wishes to the citizens of Pakistan on 14th
August, which is their Independence Day,
there is nothing wrong with it. It is a gesture
of goodwill. In such a case, it cannot be said
that such acts will tend to create
disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or
ill will between different religious groups.
Motives cannot be attributed to the
appellant only because he belongs to a
particular religion.
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
17. Now, the time has come to enlighten
and educate our police machinery on the
concept of freedom of speech and
expression guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a) of
the Constitution and the extent of
reasonable restraint on their free speech
and expression. They must be sensitised
about the democratic values enshrined in
our Constitution.
18. For the same reasons, clause (b) of
sub-section (1) of Section 153-AIPC will not
be attracted as what is depicted on the
WhatsApp status of the appellant cannot be
said to be prejudicial to the maintenance of
harmony among various groups as stated
therein.
Thus,
continuation
of
the
prosecution of the appellant for the offence
punishable under Section 153-AIPC will be a
gross abuse of the process of law.”
(Emphasis
supplied)
The Apex Court, in a subsequent judgment, in the
case of SHIV PRASAD SEMWAL v. STATE OF
UTTARAKHAND [2024 SCC OnLine SC 322],
has held as follows:
“…. ….
….
22. It may be noted that the entire case as
set out in the impugned FIR is based on the
allegation that the Facebook news post uploaded
by one journalist Mr. Gunanand Jakhmola was
caused to be published on Parvatjan news portal
being operated by the appellant.
23. Thus, essentially, we are required to
examine whether the contents of the news report
constitute any cognizable offence so as to justify
the investigation into the allegations made in the
FIR against the appellant.
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
24. For the sake of ready reference, the
contents of the disputed news article are
reproduced hereinbelow:—
“Gunanand Jakhmola
17th March 2020 at 30.05
Trivender Uncle what amazing things you
are doing?
Uncle you are laying foundation stone of Art
Gallery which is going to construct by
acquiring government land.
Uncle you are associating the mafias who
are violating the decisions of Modi
Government.
Don't trap yourself with mafias, have you
forgot the problems arisen out of marriage
of Gupta brother's.
Uncle you were not like this, what happened
to you? Was the troubles arisen out of
marriage of Gupta Brothers was not enough
that you are now going to laying foundation
stone of the Art Gallery which is going to
construct by acquiring government land.
Just think over it, or take report from LIU
and other agencies about this Art Gallery
which is going to construct on the acquired
government land. This is a government land
which is dismantled by mafias and your
officers. Uncle you are innocent, anybody
can use you. Advisers and officers
surrounding you they are cunning.
This cunning persons have brought you
forward against the decisions of Modi
Government.
Uncle let I inform you for your knowledge
that Modi Government means your honour
has given sanction to planning for Singtali
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Project near Rishikesh. This project will
reduce the distance between Kumau and
Garhwal and also it will arrange sources of
employment in mountains. World bank is
also giving money, but the program of
Mafias in which you are going to participate
on 20 March, that is an enemy of
mountains. It has no concern with the well
being of mountains. It is against the
proposed project of Modi Government and
your officers and advisers are in collusion
with that. Please inquire it and then only
you go.
Note: Kindly see the invitation card given by
mafias.”
25. As per the counter affidavit filed on
behalf of the State, after investigation, two
substantive offences were retained by the
Investigating Officer against the appellant, which
are Sections 153A and 504 read with Sections 34
and 120B IPC.
26. From a bare reading of the
language of Section 153A IPC, it is clear that
in order to constitute such offence, the
prosecution must come out with a case that
the words ‘spoken’ or ‘written’ attributed to
the accused, created enmity or bad blood
between different groups on the ground of
religion, race, place of birth, residence,
language, etc., or that the acts so alleged
were prejudicial to the maintenance of
harmony.
27. Upon careful perusal of the offending
news article, reproduced (supra), it is crystal clear
that there is no reference to any group or groups
of people in the said article. The publication
focuses totally on the complainant imputing that
he had encroached upon public land where the
foundation stone laying ceremony was proposed at
the hands of Hon'ble Chief Minister of
- 25 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Uttarakhand. Apparently, the post was aimed at
frustrating the proposed foundation stone laying
ceremony on the land, of which the complainant
claims to be the true owner. The post also imputes
that the person who was planning the foundation
stone ceremony was an enemy of mountains and
had no concern with the well-being of the
mountains.
28. Learned standing counsel for the
State tried to draw much water from these
lines alleging that this portion of the post
tends to create a sense of enmity and
disharmony
amongst
people
of
hill
community and the people of plains.
However, the interpretation sought to be
given to these words is far-fetched and
unconvincing.
The
lines
referred
to supra only refer to the complainant,
imputing that his activities are prejudicial to
the hills. These words have no connection
whatsoever with a group or groups of people
or communities. Hence, the foundational
facts essential to constitute the offence
under Section 153A IPC are totally lacking
from the allegations as set out in the FIR.”
29. In
the
case
of Manzar
Sayeed
Khan v. State of Maharashtra, this Court held that
for applying Section 153A IPC, the presence of two
or more groups or communities is essential,
whereas in the present case, no such groups or
communities were referred to in the news article.
30. The
other
substantive
offence
which has been applied by the investigating
agency is Section 504 IPC. The said offence
can be invoked when the insult of a person
provokes him to break public peace or to
commit any other offence. There is no such
allegation in the FIR that owing to the
alleged offensive post attributable to the
appellant, the complainant was provoked to
such an extent that he could indulge in
- 26 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
disturbing the public peace or commit any
other offence. Hence, the FIR lacks the
necessary ingredients of the said offence as
well. Since we have found that the
foundational facts essential for constituting
the
substantive
offences
under
Sections 153A and 504 IPC are not available
from the admitted allegations of prosecution,
the allegations qua the subsidiary offences
under Sections 34 and 120B IPC would also
be non est.
31. The complainant has also alleged in the
FIR that the accused intended to blackmail him by
publishing the news article in question. However,
there is no allegation in the FIR that the accused
tried to extract any wrongful gain or valuable
security from the complainant on the basis of the
mischievous/malicious post.
32. In
the
case
of State
of
Haryana v. Bhajan Lal , this Court examined the
principles governing the scope of exercise of
powers by the High Court in a petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India and under
Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of criminal
proceedings and held as follows:—
“102. In
the
backdrop
of
the
interpretation of the various relevant
provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV
and of the principles of law enunciated by
this Court in a series of decisions relating to
the exercise of the extraordinary power
under Article 226 or the inherent powers
under Section 482 of the Code which we
have extracted and reproduced above, we
give the following categories of cases by
way of illustration wherein such power could
be exercised either to prevent abuse of the
process of any court or otherwise to secure
the ends of justice, though it may not be
possible to lay down any precise, clearly
defined and sufficiently channelised and
- 27 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to
give an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of
cases wherein such power should be
exercised.
(1)
Where the allegations made in the first
information report or the complaint, even if
they are taken at their face value and
accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case
against the accused.
(2)
Where
the
allegations
in
the
first
information report and other materials, if
any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose
a
cognizable
offence,
justifying
an
investigation by police officers under
Section 156(1) of the Code except under an
order of a Magistrate within the purview of
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(3)
Where the uncontroverted allegations made
in the FIR or complaint and the evidence
collected in support of the same do not
disclose the commission of any offence and
make out a case against the accused.
(4)
Where, the allegations in the FIR do not
constitute
a
cognizable
offence
but
constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no
investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as
contemplated under Section 155(2) of the
Code.
(5)
Where the allegations made in the FIR or
complaint are so absurd and inherently
improbable on the basis of which no prudent
person can ever reach a just conclusion that
there is sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused.
(6)
Where there is an express legal bar
engrafted in any of the provisions of the
- 28 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Code or the concerned Act (under which a
criminal proceeding is instituted) to the
institution
and
continuance
of
the
proceedings and/or where there is a specific
provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the
grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7)
Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly
attended with mala fide and/or where the
proceeding is maliciously instituted with an
ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on
the accused and with a view to spite him
due to private and personal grudge.”
33. Tested on the touchstone of the above
principles, we are of the firm view that allowing
continuance of the proceedings pursuant to the
impugned FIR bearing No. 31 of 2020 registered
at P.S. Muni Ki Reti, District Tehri Garhwal against
the appellant is nothing but gross abuse of process
of law because the allegations as set out in the FIR
do not disclose necessary ingredients of any
cognizable offence. Hence, the impugned FIR and
all proceedings sought to be taken against the
appellant are hereby quashed and set aside.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The Apex Court did not permit further
investigation even in a crime before it. The FIR
itself was quashed, as the High Court of
Uttarakhand had rejected the petition which
challenged the FIR.
10. In the light of the judgments of the Apex
Court and unequivocal facts narrated hereinabove,
what would unmistakably emerge is high
improbability of the happening of the incident
even, against the 2nd respondent/complainant. The
complaint cannot but be held to be a counter-blast
to what the petitioners have registered, not
against the complainant but against several
accused named therein. It would be apposite to
refer to a judgment of the High Court of Andhra
- 29 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
Pradesh, which lays down certain necessary
ingredients to drive home an offence under
Section 153A of the IPC even prima facie. The
High Court of Andhra Pradesh in KOLLU
ANKABABU v. TIRUPATHI RAMESH [2022 SCC
OnLine AP 2812], has held as follows:
“….
….
….
17. The ingredients necessary for
making out an offence under Section 153A(a) is that the accused person by words
either spoken or written etc., promotes or
attempts to promote, disharmony or feelings
of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different
religious, racial, language or regional groups
or castes or communities on grounds of
religion, race, place of birth, residence,
language, caste or community or any other
ground whatsoever.
18. The ingredients necessary for
making out an offence under Section
153-A(b) is the commission of any act
which is prejudicial to the maintenance
of harmony between different religious
racial, language or regional groups or
castes or communities, and which
disturbs or is likely to disturb the public
tranquillity.
19. The ingredients necessary for an
offence under Section 153-A(c) is to
organise any exercise, movement, drill
etc., so that participates in such
activities can be trained to use violence
or criminal force against any religious,
racial, language or regional group or
caste or community and such activity
for any reason whatsoever causes or is
likely to cause fear or alarm or a feeling
of insecurity amongst members of such
religious, racial, language or regional
group or caste or communities.
- 30 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
20. The language in all the three
sub-clauses of Section 153-A require
the following conditions to be met
before any offence can be said to have
been committed within this provision:—
a)
The actions should cause enmity
between groups; Ill will against
one group would not attract the
above provisions.
b)
These
actions
should
be
committed with the intention of
causing such enmity.
c)
This
provision
would
be
applicable only where enmity is
caused on grounds of religion,
race, place of birth, residence,
language, caste or community or
any other ground whatsoever.
d)
The term “or any other ground
whatsoever” would have to be
read
in
tandem
with
the
preceding words and as such the
scope of this term would be that
the grounds would only have to
be grounds akin to the preceding
grounds set out in the provision.
e)
The groups between whom such
enmity or disharmony or hatred
or ill-will is caused would be
groups defined on the basis of
their religion, race, language,
place
of
birth,
caste
or
community.
f)
Differences or ill-will caused
between two groups which are
not defined on the basis of the
above requirements would not
- 31 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
attract
the
provisions
Section 153-A IPC.”
(Emphasis
of
supplied)
In the light of the afore-narrated facts and the
judgments extracted supra, permitting even
investigation into the case at hand would be prima
facie permitting investigation into the sloganeering
of Bharath Matha Ki Jai inter alia, which can by no
stretch of imagination be promoting disharmony or
enmity amongst religions. Sloganeering Bharath
Matha Ki Jai would only lead to harmony and
never a discord. "
6.
If the impugned complaint and FIR are examined
bearing in mind the principles enunciated in the aforesaid
judgments, it is clear that except stating that the
properties are Wakf properties and that the petitioner is
alleged to have stated that wherever a stone is thrown, a
Wakf property is found, there are no other allegations in
the impugned complaint so as to attract the offences
punishable under Section 196(1)(a) of the Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 by the petitioner. Under these
circumstances, in the light of vague, bald, omnibus,
cryptic and laconic allegations made in the impugned
complaint which does not disclose commission of the
offences punishable under Section 196(1)(a) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 coupled with the
principles enunciated by the Apex Court and this Court in
the aforementioned judgments, I am of the opinion that
continuation of the proceedings insofar as it relates to
the petitioner would amount to abuse of the process of
law warranting interference in the present petition.
7.
In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
(i)
The petition is hereby allowed;
(ii) The impugned FIR dated 04.11.2024 in Crime
No.208/2024 pending on the file of the Civil Judge
and JMFC, Savanur, Haveri District, insofar as the
petitioner is concerned, is hereby quashed; .
- 32 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44965
CRL.P No. 15353 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010730032025
(iii) It is needless to state that this order is
restricted to the impugned complaint and will
apply to the petitioner/accused No.1 only and shall
not apply to the remaining accused."
In the light of the petitioner being, the co-accused also
together while the alleged statement was made, is entitled to
the same benefit that the petitioner in the said criminal
petition.
4.
For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
i.
The criminal petition is allowed.
ii.
The investigation in crime No.208/2024 pending on
the file of Civil Judge and JMFC, Savanur, Haveri
District, qua the petitioner stands quashed.
Sd/(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
JY
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review