Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28544
:1:
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. V. BALAKRISHNAN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(CRL.) NO. 314 OF 2025
PETITIONER/PETITIONER:
SREEMATHI SURENDRAN
AGED 52 YEARS
W/O SURENDRAN, ERUMBU VALAPPIL HOUSE, P.O
AMBALAMUKU, PEECHI P.O, THRISSUR, KERALA,
PIN - 680653
BY ADVS.
SARATH BABU KOTTAKKAL
RENJITH B.MARAR
RESPONDENTS/STATE:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY (HOME),
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE DISTRICT MAGISTRATE
CIVIL STATION, AYYANTHOLE, THRISSUR,
PIN - 680003
DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF, THRISSUR,
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:2:
THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN - 680631
STATION HOUSE OFFICER
PECCHI POLICE STATION, PATTIKKAD, THRISSUR,
PIN - 680652
THE SUPERINTENDENT
CENTRAL PRISON, VIYYUR, THRISSUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 680010
BY SRI. K.A. ANAS, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR.
THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 03.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:3:
“CR”
JUDGMENT
Raja Vijayaraghavan, J.
Under challenge in this Writ Petition, preferred under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, is Ext.P1 order of detention dated 28.12.2024,
issued by the District Magistrate, Thrissur, the 2nd respondent herein.
2.
Brief facts:
The petitioner herein is the wife of the detenu. A perusal of Ext.P1
detention order would reveal that on account of the involvement of the
detenu in seven crimes registered within the territorial limits of Thrissur
District, the detenu was classified as a ‘known rowdy’ as defined under
Section 2(p)(iii) of the Kerala Anti Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007
(hereinafter stated as ‘KAA(P) Act ’ for brevity) and an order of detention
was issued on 30.03.2024. The said order was revoked on 03.06.2024 by the
Government on the strength of the opinion of the Advisory Board. After the
release of the detenu, he got involved in two crimes, i.e., Crime No. 513 of
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:4:
2024 of the Peechi Police Station and Crime No. 802 of 2024 of the very
same Police Station. The last prejudicial act was committed by the detenu on
18.09.2024. On the premise that the detenu was continuing as a “Known
Rowdy”, a Report was submitted on 06.12.2024 by the 3rd respondent,
District Police Chief, seeking initiation of proceedings under the KAA(P) Act.
At the time of submission of the report, the detenu was in judicial custody in
connection with Crime No. 802 of 2024. After arriving at the requisite
satisfaction, the detention order was issued on 28.12.2024, and the same
was executed on 31.12.2024. On 09.01.2025, the Government granted
approval, and the matter was referred to the Advisory Board for its opinion
on 17.01.2024. The report of the Advisory Board was received on
13.02.2025, wherein it is mentioned that there was sufficient cause for the
continued detention of the detenu. On receipt of the report of the Advisory
Board, the detention order was confirmed by the Government by order dated
17.02.2025.
3.
Sri. Sarath Babu Kottakkal, the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner, raised the following contentions before us:
a) The detention order was passed by the detaining authority
without arriving at the requisite satisfaction.
b) An earlier detention order was issued against the detenu and
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:5:
the same was revoked by the Government based on the
opinion of the Advisory Board. A bare perusal of the impugned
detention order reveals no reference whatsoever to the fact
that the previous detention order was revoked on the strength
of the Advisory Board’s opinion, nor does it disclose that the
procedural errors or omissions due to which the earlier order
was revoked were rectified in the procedure followed with
regard to the subsequent detention order.
c) Placing reliance on Section 13(2)(iii) of the KAA(P) Act, it was
contended that the procedural lapses or legal infirmities that
led to the revocation of the earlier detention order were
required to be cured in the process culminating in the
subsequent order. For such rectification to be meaningfully
undertaken, it was imperative that the detaining authority was
made aware of the specific reasons which weighed with the
Advisory Board in recommending revocation.
d) Though Section 10(3) of the KAA(P) Act provides that the
report of the Advisory Board, except for that part which records
its opinion, shall be confidential, the principles of fairness and
non-arbitrariness require that the non-confidential portions of
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:6:
the earlier report must be made available both to the detaining
authority and to the sponsoring authority. This is essential to
enable a meaningful application of mind as to whether the
issuance of a fresh detention order under Section 13(2) of the
KAA(P) Act is legally sustainable and factually justified.
e) The learned counsel relied on the decision of the Division
Bench of this Court in Devika v. State of Kerala1, wherein it
was held that even if the report of the Advisory Board except
the opinion part is to be kept confidential, the conclusions and
the reasons that favoured the detenu must be disclosed and
considered.
According
to
the
learned
interpretation
strikes
a
necessary
counsel,
balance
this
between
confidentiality and the constitutional mandate against unlawful
detention.
f) The learned counsel also submitted that the order of detention
is liable to be set aside on the ground of inordinate and
unexplained delay. It was pointed out that the last prejudicial
activity allegedly committed by the detenu occurred on
18.09.2024, while the impugned detention order came to be
passed only on 28.12.2024, resulting in a delay of over two
[2022 (5) KLT OnLine 1220]
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:7:
months and thirteen days. According to the learned counsel,
such a prolonged delay is fatal to the order, as it snaps the "live
and proximate link" between the alleged prejudicial act and the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority, thereby
rendering the detention legally unsustainable.
4.
Sri. K.A. Anas, the learned Public Prosecutor, opposed the
contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner. According to
the learned Public Prosecutor, the observations made by this Court in
Devika (supra) are inconsistent with the authoritative pronouncements of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, particularly in A.K. Roy v. Union of India and
Another2, wherein it was held that the proceedings of the Advisory Board
except in that part of the report in which the opinion of the Advisory Board is
specified, shall be confidential and therefore, cannot be thrown open to the
public.
In order to persuade us to conclude that the Division Bench in
Devika (supra), had referred to the confidential part, the learned Public
Prosecutor has placed before us the report of the Advisory Board in Devika
(supra). He has also invited our attention to paragraph No. 10 of the
judgment wherein the confidential portion containing the reasoning of the
Advisory Board was extracted.
[(1982) 1 SCC 271]
The learned Public Prosecutor would also
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:8:
point out that the observation in paragraph No. 51 of Devika (supra) that “if
the State Government has any considered view that the Advisory Board’s
report, in its entirety, cannot be given, as it is confidential, then at least,
non-confidential part of the opinion of the Advisory Board in favour of the
detenu, more particularly, not only the conclusion therein but also the
specific reasonings which led to the conclusions, should be made available
by the State Government to both the detaining authority and the sponsoring
authority in order to enable such authorities to consider as to whether a
fresh detention order, in terms of Section 13(2) is warranted, if due to
subsequent events” is against the provisions of the Statute and the repeated
pronouncements of the Apex Court. It is further submitted that a coequal
bench of this Court in Hashitha P.K. v. State of Kerala and Ors.3, had
occasion to consider similar contentions and had held that in the light of
Section 10(3) of the KAA(P) Act which provides that the opinion of the
Advisory Board shall be confidential, the detenu is not entitled to be
furnished a copy of the opinion given by the Advisory Board.
It is further
submitted that the revocation order passed by the Government in respect of
the earlier detention order was served on the detenu and in the said order, it
has been unequivocally stated that it is based on the opinion of the Advisory
Board that such an order has been passed under Section 10(4) of the
2025:KER:483
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:9:
KAA(P) Act.
5.
Insofar as the delay of 2 months and 13 days in passing the
order is concerned, the learned Public Prosecutor submitted that the detenu
had been in judicial custody in Crime No. 802 of 2024 since 18.09.2024 and
continued to remain in custody even after the order of detention was
passed. It is contended that the detaining authority was required to assess
the likelihood of the detenu being released on bail before issuing the
detention order. In such circumstances, the learned Public Prosecutor urged
that the ‘live and proximate link between the prejudicial activities and the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority remains intact and has not
been snapped. In support of his submissions, the learned Public Prosecutor
placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Rahila Nazeer v. State of
Kerala4 as well as in Mobitha M.M v. State of Kerala5.
6.
We have carefully considered the submissions advanced and
have gone through the records.
7.
The first contention advanced by the learned counsel is with
regard to the non-supply of the previous opinion of the Advisory Board which
led to the revocation of the previous detention order. We find that the said
2016 (3) KHC 189
2025:KER:25791
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:10:
contention has been raised relying on the observations in Devika (supra).
In Devika (supra), this Court had occasion to hold that the grounds and
reasons which weighed with the Advisory Board to recommend for the
revocation of the previous order would be highly relevant and crucial to
determine whether a subsequent revocation order has to be issued. As
pointed out by the learned Public Prosecutor, this Court in Devika (supra)
has extracted certain parts of the confidential portion and the reasonings
given by the Advisory Board in paragraph No. 10 of the judgment.
In
paragraph No. 42 it was observed that at least the aspects relating to the
reasons and grounds made by the Advisory Board and which is binding on
the Government should have been duly taken note of by the detaining
authority before deciding as to whether subjective satisfaction can be
formed. The question is whether such a course could have been adopted in
view of the settled pronouncements of the Apex Court and the provisions of
the relevant statute.
8.
Section 10 of the KAA(P) Act reads as under:
10. Procedure of Advisory Board and further action.(1) The Advisory Board to which a reference is made
under the above section shall after considering the reference
and the materials placed before it and after calling for such
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:11:
further information as it may deem necessary from the
Government or from any person called for the purpose through
the Government, or from the person concerned and if, in any
particular case, it considers necessary so to do or if the person
concerned desires to be heard in person, after hearing him in
person, prepare its report specifying in a separate paragraph
thereof its opinion as to whether or not there is sufficient cause
for the detention of the person concerned and submit the same
within nine weeks from the date of detention of the person
concerned;
(2) When there is difference of opinion among the
members forming the Advisory Board the opinion of the majority
of such members shall be deemed to be the opinion of the
Board. The absence of a member shall not invalidate the
decision of the Board.
(3) A person against whom an order of detention has
been made under this Act shall not be entitled to appear by any
legal practitioner in any matter connected with the reference to
the Advisory Board, and the proceedings of the Advisory Board
and its report, excepting that the part of the report in which the
opinion of the Advisory Board is specified, shall be confidential:
Provided that the Board has power to permit legal
practitioners in the cases deemed fit.
(4) In every case where the Advisory Board has reported
that there is in its opinion sufficient cause for the detention of a
person, the Government may confirm the detention order and
continue the detention of the person concerned for such period
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:12:
as it thinks fit and in every case where the Advisory Board has
reported that there is in its opinion no sufficient cause for the
detention of the person concerned, the Government shall revoke
the detention order and cause the person to be released
forthwith.
9.
Section 10 of the KAA(P) Act provides for the procedure to be
followed by the Advisory Board. In every case where a detention order has
been made, the Government is required to place the matter before the
Advisory Board within three weeks from the date of detention of the person.
Under Section 10, the Advisory Board to which the reference is made shall
consider the materials and call for further information from the Government
or the person concerned, and if so required after hearing the person
concerned, prepare a report specifying in a separate paragraph thereof its
opinion as to whether or not there is sufficient cause for the detention of the
person concerned and submit the same within 9 weeks from the date of
detention. This is to comply with the mandate under Article 22(4) of the
Constitution which says that no law providing for preventive detention shall
authorise the detention of a person for a longer period than three months
unless an Advisory Board has reported before the expiration of the said
period of three months that there is, in its opinion, sufficient cause for such
detention. Section 10(3) of the KAA(P) Act says that a person against whom
an order of detention has been made under the Act shall not be entitled to
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:13:
appear by any legal practitioner in any matter connected with reference to
the Advisory Board and the proceedings of the Advisory Board, and its
report, excepting that part of the report in which the opinion of the Advisory
Board is specified, shall be confidential. Section 10(4) says that where the
Advisory Board has reported that there is, in its opinion, sufficient cause for
the detention of a person, the Government may confirm the detention order
and continue with the detention of the person concerned for such period as
it thinks fit. In every case where the Advisory Board has reported that there
is in its opinion no sufficient cause for the detention of the person
concerned, the Government shall revoke the detention order and cause the
person to be released forthwith.
10.
A reading of Section 10 (1) of the KAA(P) Act would reveal that
the report of the Advisory Board has to be in two parts. The first part is to
contain the assessment made by the Advisory Board in the form of a report
which is completely confidential. The second part contains the result of such
an assessment in the form of an opinion. It is this second part of opinion
alone which is not confidential. Section 10(4) of the KAA(P) Act obliges the
Government to revoke the detention order and cause the person to be
released forthwith in case the Advisory Board has reported that there was, in
its opinion, no sufficient cause for the detention of the person concerned.
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:14:
However, if the opinion is otherwise and the Advisory Board has found that
there was sufficient cause for the detention of the person, the appropriate
government 'may confirm' the detention order and continue the detention.
The choice is available to the appropriate government only in the latter of
these two eventualities. Therefore, in case the opinion is to the effect that
there was no sufficient cause for the detention of the person concerned, the
appropriate government has to revoke the detention order and cause the
person concerned to be released forthwith. (see also Union of India (UOI)
and Ors. Vs. Nisar Pallathukadavil Aliyar and Ors. 2019 INSC 941)
11.
In Akshoy Konai v. State of West Bengal6 a contention
was taken on behalf of the detenu that the decision of the Advisory Board
was never communicated to him. The further submission was that the
opinion of the Advisory Board should have been communicated to the
detenu so as to enable him to question the legality of said opinion. These
submissions were rejected by a Bench of three Judges of the Apex Court by
observing as under:
4. The first objection against the Petitioner's detention
raised by Shri B. Dutta, the learned Counsel appearing as amicus
curiae in support of the writ petition, is that though the Petitioner
had been heard in person by the Advisory Board the decision of
[(1973) 1 SCC 297]
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:15:
the Board was never communicated to him. This omission,
according to the counsel, invalidates the Petitioner's detention as
he was not able to take any step to have this opinion scrutinised
by any judicial tribunal. This submission is, in our opinion,
difficult to accept. Under Section 11 of the Act the Advisory
Board is required only to submit its report to the appropriate
Government. There is no obligation imposed by the Act on the
Board to communicate its decision to the detenu. The mere fact
that Under Section 11 the Board hears the person affected by the
detention order in case he desires to be so heard, would not for
that reason alone impose on the Board a legal obligation to
communicate its decision to the detenu. Our attention has not
been drawn to any provision of law or to any principle which
would imply any such obligation. In any event omission on the
part of the Advisory Board to do so cannot invalidate the
Petitioner's detention.
5. The submission that the Advisory Board should have
communicated its opinion to the Petitioner so as to enable him to
question its legality is also misconceived. In the first instance the
Advisory Board constituted Under Section 9 of the Act, as its
name connotes, is only required to function in an advisory
capacity. Its opinion which is merely an advice is binding on the
appropriate Government only if according to it there is no
sufficient cause for the detention in question: in that eventuality
the detenu cannot possibly have any grievance. When the Board
reports that there is sufficient cause for the detention in question
the appropriate Government is not bound under the law to
confirm the order of detention. It may or may not do so. The
advisory opinion of the Board is merely intended to assist the
2025:KER:28544
:16:
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
appropriate
Government
in
determining
the
question
of
confirming the detention order and continuing the detention. It is
binding on the appropriate Government only when it favours the
detenu and not when it goes against him. Such advisory opinion
can scarcely be an appropriate subject-matter of review or
scrutiny by the judicial courts or tribunals. Secondly the
proceedings of the Board and its report are expressly declared by
Section 11(4) of the Act to be confidential except that part of the
report in which its opinion is specified. This provision clearly
indicates that the advisory opinion is never intended to be open
to challenge on the merits before any tribunal. So far as the final
opinion of the Board is concerned the communication of the
confirmation of the detention order by the State Government
clearly informed the Petitioner that the opinion of the Board was
against him.
12.
In A.K. Roy (supra), the unfairness and unreasonableness of
the procedure before the Advisory Board was one of the contentions taken
by the learned counsel.
It was argued before the Apex Court that the
Advisory Board must give reasons in support of its opinion which must be
furnished to the detenu and that the proceedings of the Advisory Board must
be open to the public. It was observed that the duty and function of the
Advisory Board are to determine whether there was sufficient cause for
detention of the person concerned on the date on which the order of
detention was passed and whether or not there is sufficient cause for
detention of that person on the date of the report. It was observed in para
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:17:
98 as under:
98. ... ...In proceedings before the Advisory Board, the
question for consideration of the Board is not whether the detenu
is guilty of any charge but whether there is sufficient cause for the
detention of the person concerned. The detention, it must be
remembered, is based not on facts proved either by applying the
test of preponderance of probabilities or of reasonable doubt. The
detention is based on the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority that it is necessary to detain a particular person in order
to prevent him from acting in a manner prejudicial to certain
stated objects. The proceeding of the Advisory Board has
therefore to be structured differently from the proceeding of
judicial or quasi-judicial tribunals, before which there is a lis to
adjudicate upon.
13.
In Nisar Pallathukadavil Aliyar and Ors (supra), while
elucidating on the nature and validity of the opinion, it was observed as
under:
According to the aforesaid decisions the nature of opinion
given by the Advisory Board is neither judicial nor quasi judicial;
that it would be erroneous and unsafe to treat the opinion
expressed by the Advisory Board as amounting to a judgment of a
criminal court; that the Advisory Board does not try the question
about the propriety or validity of the citizen's detention as a court
of law would, but, its function is limited. As stated in Akshoy
2025:KER:28544
:18:
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
Konai, the opinion is merely intended to assist the government
and it is binding on the appropriate government only if it favours
the detenu and not when it goes against him. It was laid down in
said decision that the opinion of the Advisory Board cannot be
subject
matter
of
review
or
scrutiny
by
the
judicial
courts/tribunals. The element of confidentiality was also taken
note of and it was observed that the Advisory Board opinion is
never intended to be open to challenge on the merits before any
tribunal.
19. ………………………The report of the Advisory Board,
excepting its opinion, is strictly confidential and the nature of the
power so exercised by the Advisory Board in giving its report and
the opinion, has already been pronounced upon by this Court in
the cases referred to above viz. Dharam Singh Rathi
AIR 1958
SC 152 Akshoy Konai (1973) 1 SCC 297, A.K. Roy (1982) 1 SCC
271 and Calcutta Dock Labour Board (1965) 3 SCR 453
.
14.
In view of the discussion above, we hold that the observations
in paragraphs 42 and 48 of Devika (supra) have been made without taking
note of the law laid down in the binding precedents of the Apex Court and is
therefore per incuriam. As held by the Apex Court, the first part of the report
prepared by the Advisory Board under Section 10(1) of the Act shall only
contain the assessment made by the Advisory Board in the form of a report.
This part of the report is completely confidential. The second part shall
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:19:
contain the result of such assessment in the form of an opinion and shall only
contain whether or not there is sufficient cause for the detention of the
person concerned. The Advisory Board’s opinion is merely advisory in nature
and is meant for the Government. The opinion of the Advisory Board cannot
be subject matter of review or scrutiny by the judicial courts/tribunals. The
element of confidentiality is also to be maintained. The Advisory Board’s
opinion is not intended to be open to challenge on the merits before any
Tribunal. The opinion of the Board is merely an advice which is binding on the
Government only if, according to it, there is no sufficient cause for the
detention in question: in that eventuality, the detenu cannot possibly have
any grievance. The detenu is not entitled to a copy of the report of the
advisory board let alone the reasons which persuaded the Board to
recommend for the revocation. While passing the subsequent detention order,
the details of the previous detention orders are to be mentioned. If the same
has been revoked by the Government, the said fact is also to be stated.
Procedural errors and omissions which led to the revocation are to be
rectified if a subsequent order is required to be issued. A copy of the
revocation order passed by the Government of the previous detention order is
also required to be supplied. In that view of the matter, we reject the
contention of the learned counsel that the conclusions and the reasons of the
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:20:
Advisory Board in respect of the earlier detention order ought to be made
available to the sponsoring authority as well as the detaining authority.
15.
Insofar as the delay of 2 months and 13 days in passing the
order of detention is concerned, we find that the detenu was arrested in
connection with Crime No. 802 of 24 on 18.9.2024. When the detention order
was passed, the detenu was in judicial custody. From the order of detention,
we find that the detaining authority was aware of the fact that the detenu
was in custody and has also received information that he was likely to be
released on bail. His criminal antecedents and his predilection to get himself
involved in grave crimes, if released on bail, were also taken note of.
16.
Where detention orders are passed in relation to persons who
are already in jail, the detaining authorities are required to apply their mind
and show their awareness in this regard on the grounds of detention, and the
chances of release of such persons on bail. In Kamarunnissa v. Union Of
India And Another7, the Apex Court had observed that even in the case of
a person in custody, a detention order can be validly passed: (1) if the
authority passing the order is aware of the fact that he is actually in custody;
(2) if he has a reason to believe on the basis of reliable material placed
before him (a) that there is a real possibility of his release on bail, and (b)
1991 AIR SC 1640
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:21:
that on being released, he would in all probability indulge in prejudicial
activities; and (3) if it is felt essential to detain him to prevent him from so
doing. If an order is passed after recording satisfaction in that regard, the
order would be valid. In the case at hand, the order of detention shows an
awareness of custody and/or a possibility of release on bail. As the statutory
requirements are to be satisfied in its letter and spirit, some delay is
inevitable. As the detention order was passed on getting inputs as to his
impending release on bail, it cannot be said that there has been any delay in
passing the order.
In view of the discussion above, we hold that the petitioner has not
made out any case for interference.
This Writ Petition is dismissed.
Sd/RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V
JUDGE
Sd/P.V.BALAKRISHNAN
JUDGE
APM
2025:KER:28544
W.P (Crl.) No. 314 of 2025
:22:
APPENDIX OF WP(CRL.) 314/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
THE DETENTION ORDER ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT DATED 28.12.2024
Exhibit P2
THE TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER DATED
17.02.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review