The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In view of the above discussion no case is made out for interference under Section 37 of the Act. The appeal is dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 16.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011554132018
+
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018 CM APPL. 35812/2022 CM APPL.
52757/2024
SOUTH DELHI MUNCIPAL CORPORATION
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Vikas Chopra, Standing Counsel,
MCD with Mr. Neeraj Kumar, Adv.
versus
MSV INTERNATIONAL INC
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Rajesh Yadav, Sr. Adv., with Mr.
Rohit Goel and Mr. Dhananjay
Mehlawat, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J. (ORAL)
1.
This appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 (for short ‘the Act’) is directed against the order dated 13.04.2018
rejecting the petition under Section 34 of the Act filed by the appellant.
2.
The brief facts are that the parties to the lis entered into an agreement
dated 20.11.2006, pursuant thereto the respondent was awarded the work of
‘Consultancy Services for Preparation of Master Plan, Feasibility Study,
RFP and Pilot Plan Implementation of Dairy Farm Waste Management
(DFWM) for Delhi’. The work was to be completed within nine months
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
from the date of commencement of the work. The time for completion was
extended and the work was completed within the extended period.
2.1
On 27.01.2011, the appellant issued a show case notice (for short
‘SCN’) to the respondent. On 28.01.2011, the respondent submitted the final
report in terms of the work order.
2.2
The appellant proceeded to terminate the agreement vide notice dated
29.04.2011 and blacklisted the respondent. The dispute between the parties
was referred to arbitration and the proceedings culminated in the award
dated 12.12.2017 wherein the arbitrator held that the respondent had
completed the work within the extended period and was entitled to the
balance amount due for the work done. The stand of the appellant that
consequent to termination of the agreement, the entire amount received by
the respondent was liable to be refunded was rejected. The counter claim
filed by the respondent was held to be time barred. The petition filed under
Section 34 of the Act by the appellant was dismissed. Hence, the present
appeal.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the termination of
agreement was neither considered during arbitration nor in the proceedings
under Section 34 of the Act. It is contended that the delay in submission of
the final report resulted in scrapping of the project and the respondent was
not entitled to any payment more so, when the agreement itself was
terminated.
4.
Learned counsel for the respondent emphasizes on the limited scope
of interference under Section 37 of the Act. It is argued that the factual
findings recorded by the arbitrator to the effect that the final report was
submitted on 28.01.2011 i.e. within the extended period and that there were
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
no objections or dissatisfaction raised by the appellant against the final
report are not under challenge. It is submitted that a plausible view taken by
the arbitrator calls for no interference under Section 37 of the Act.
5.
The arbitrator considered that the report dated 27.01.2011 was
submitted with the covering letter dated 28.01.2011 and this report was
produced in evidence in the arbitral proceedings. It was taken into account
that in the affidavit of admission/denial the receipt of the report was not
specifically denied by the appellant. It was pleaded “not admitted due to
letter not found in MCD record.” In absence of a specific denial of receipt of
the report and the pleadings being restricted only to the non-availability of
the covering letter in the MCD record, it was rightly concluded that the
submission of the report is not in dispute. The conclusion is fortified by the
fact that the appellant did not put any question to the witness CW-1 i.e. the
respondent vis-a-vis the submission of the report. These findings were
upheld in the petition under Section 34 of the Act.
6.
The contention of the counsel for the appellant that the project was
scrapped due to delay in submission of final report by the respondent cannot
be accepted in absence of evidence adduced by the appellant to substantiate
the case set up.
7.
Another aspect to consider is that as per the appellant the project was
scrapped on 26.08.2010 but at the same time the period for completion of
work was extended till 31.01.2011 by letter dated 05.01.2011. The
contradiction in the conduct and stand taken is writ large.
8.
The defense set up by the appellant in the arbitral proceedings that the
balance payment due for the work done was not payable and rather the
respondent was liable to refund the payment received as the project was
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
scrapped, lacks merit. The appellant failed to point out the clause in the
agreement whereunder the appellant in the eventuality of the project being
scrapped was entitled to the refund of the payment already made. No such
clause has been brought to the notice of this Court either.
9.
The learned Single Judge held that it was neither the case set up by
the appellant nor proved that an actual loss was suffered by the appellant due
to the extension of period for completion of work.
10.
The challenge in the present appeal is confined only to entitlement of
the respondent to the balance amount due for the work done. The issue
decided by the arbitrator in favour of the respondent that the work was
completed within the extended period, remains unchallenged having not
been pressed during the course of arguments. In such circumstances, the
foundation for claiming the balance amount due by the respondent that the
work was completed within the extended period remains intact.
Consequently, the balance payment awarded by the arbitrator and upheld by
the learned Single Judge does not warrant interference.
11.
The contention that the termination of the agreement was not
considered while passing the award or rejecting the petition under Section
34 of the Act, is misconceived. The factum of termination finds mention in
the award as well as the judgment of the learned Single Judge. After
considering this fact it was concluded that the work was completed within
the extended period and thus, the respondent was entitled to the balance
amount due for the work done. No basis has been made out at any stage by
the appellant that consequent to termination the payment for the work done
is liable to be refunded. The termination has no material effect on the
conclusions arrived at by the arbitrator.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
12.
The fact remains undisputed that despite issuing SCN alleging delay
in submitting the report, the report was submitted and the appellant raised no
objection or expressed any dissatisfaction vis-a-vis the report submitted. It
would be apposite to mention that clause 6.4(d) of the General Conditions of
Contract (for short ‘GCC’) stipulates that the payment is to be released on
submission of the final report and after the satisfaction of the employer on
the report. Clause 6.4(d) of the GCC provides that the work and final report
shall be deemed to have been completed and accepted after ninety days of
the receipt unless the employer raises any specific objection within the
period prescribed thereunder. The clause 6.4(d) is reproduced below:
“6.4 Mode of Billing and Payment
Billings and payments in respect of the Services shall be
made as follows:
***
(d) The final payment under this Clause shall be made only
after the final report and a final statement, identified as
such, shall have been submitted by the Consultants and
approved as satisfactory by the Employer. The Services
shall be deemed completed and finally accepted by the
Employer and the final report and final statement shall be
deemed approved by the Employer as satisfactory ninety
(90) calendar days after receipt of the final report and final
statement by the Employer unless the Employer, within
such ninety (90)- day period, gives written notice to the
Consultants specifying in detail deficiencies in the
Services, the final report to final statement. The
consultants shall thereupon promptly make any necessary
corrections, and upon completion of such corrections, the
foregoing process shall be repeated. Any amount which the
Employer has paid or caused to be paid in accordance with
this Clause in excess of the amounts actually payable in
accordance with the provisions of this Contract shall be
reimbursed by the Consultants to the Employer within
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
thirty (30) days after receipt by the Consultants of notice
thereof. Any such claim by the Employer for
reimbursement must be made within twelve (12) calendar
months after receipt by the Employer of a final report and
a final statement approved by the Employer in accordance
with the above.”
13.
In view of the above discussion no case is made out for interference
under Section 37 of the Act. The appeal is dismissed.
14.
Pending applications stand disposed of.
15.
The money deposited pursuant to the order dated 18.07.2018 be
released to the respondent.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026/msh
‘ha’
Reportable: Yes
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:43:43
FAO(OS) (COMM) 144/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review