Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WPA 26541 of 2026
25.09.
Soumya Nandi
Vs.
The Zonal Manager.
Indian Bank and others.
---------------
Ct. No. 18
Ab
Mr. Subhas Chandra Atha,
Ms. Payel Pramanik.
… for the petitioner.
Mr. Shiv Mangal Singh,
Ms. Anjali Mishra.
… for the Bank.
1. The petitioner is aggrieved that he has been transferred
on August 5, 2026, quite in violation of the prescribed
norms and Rules of the transfer policy of the Indian
Bank. The transfer was effected on August 5, 2026 at
11.34 a.m. and the release order was made on the very
same day at about 5.00 p.m.
2. Mr.
Atha,
learned
Advocate
appearing
for
the
petitioner, submits that the transfer order is in gross
violation of the transfer policy and, hence, cannot be
sustained with in view of the following:
(a) The cut-off date for reckoning fulfillment of the
conditions laid down in the policy has been
specified as June 30 of every year unless
otherwise specified.
(b) The Bank shall endeavour to complete the
transfer exercised by June 30 every year.
(c) Mid-term transfers shall be considered only in
case of promotions and administrative exigencies.
(d) Minimum service period of an Officer at a
particular place of posting will be three years of
active service.
(e) The petitioner has completed merely a period of
one year and a month at the time of his transfer.
3. Mr. Singh, learned Advocate appearing for the Bank,
has made the following submissions:
(a) The tenure for rotational transfer has been
specified as a timeline between a minimum of one
year to a maximum of three years. Thus, a
person, who has served in a particular post for a
year is liable to be transferred. The petitioner has
served this period and is, thus, liable to be
transferred.
(b) The Bank discharging public functions is entitled
to transfer its employees on the ground of
administrative exigency, thereby requiring no
further explanation or limitation to such transfer.
(c) The petitioner having served for more than a year
in his current place of posting is liable to be
transferred. The transfer is, therefore, justified
and justifiable.
(d) He has placed reliance on three decisions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in 1995
Suppl. (4) SCC 169 (Abani Kanta Ray vs. State of
Orissa and others), (2001) 8 SCC 574 (National
Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. vs. (1) Shri
Bhagwan (2) Shiv Prakash) and (2004) 11 SCC
402 (State of U.P. and others vs. Gobardhan Lal).
4. I have heard the learned Advocates for the parties,
considered the documents and the decisions relied
upon by them.
5. That transfer is not a matter of right and is an
incidence of service is fairly well established and
accepted. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
several decisions over a period of time has laid down
the law with certainty and conclusively. These issues
are not in dispute.
6. The Courts are generally circumspect to interfere into
orders of transfer. Transfers concern the internal
management of an institution, into which a Court
would normally not interfere. However, one of the
establish grounds to interfere is when a transfer is
caused contrary to the policy, Rules and Regulations
applicable to that particular institution.
7. This discussion and deliberation is prescribed in
Transfer Policy for Officers up to Scale-III, Version
2.1,
Human
Resource
Management
Department
(hereinafter referred to as “said policy”).
8. For a better understanding, the relevant clauses are
set out under:
“Guidelines on Transfer of Officers
1.0 ……
1.3 The normal tenure of an Officer at a place of
posting will be 03 years of active service.
1.6 The cutoff date for reckoning the fulfillment
of the conditions laid down in this policy shall be
30th June of every year unless and otherwise
specified.
1.7 The Bank shall endeavor to complete the
transfer exercise by 30th June every year. Midterm transfers shall be considered only I n case
of promotions and administrative exigencies. The
transfer exercise will be through online portal.
The online portal may also include the Bank’s
transfer policy, guidelines and related circulars,
seniority list and other details in order to bring
efficiency and transparency in transfer process.
3.0 Transfers at the instance of the Bank
1. Rotational Transfers
2. Transfer/Placement on Promotion.
3. Transfer on account of Administrative
exigencies/Business requirement.
5.0 Rotational Transfers
5.1
Location
Branch/spe
cialized
Vertical/Any
Department
in
Adminitrativ
e Office
In
the
current
Zone/Admin
istrative
Office
In
the
Current
State
Minimum
tenure
(as
on
cut-off
date)
1 year
Maximum
Tenure (as
on
cut-off
date)
3 Years
3 Years
6 Years
3 years
9 Years
9. On conjoint reading of this afore-stated policy, it
leads
to
certain
inevitable
conclusions.
These
conclusions may be summarized as under:
(a) An Officer in the grade of the petitioner is
liable to be transferred as an incidence of
service.
(b) Such transfer should be effected by June 30
of every year as the cut-off date for reckoning
the fulfillment of conditions laid down in the
policy.
(c) The Bank shall endeavour to complete the
transfers by June 30 of every year.
(d) Mid-term transfer is permissible, only in cases
of promotion and administrative exigency.
(e) If it is a rotational transfer, the minimum cutoff date is one year and the maximum three
years.
Thus,
a
person
being
transferred
should have served a minimum of one year at
a post, to become liable to be transferred. This
does not apply to a transfer on administrative
exigency.
10. The petitioner has joined his current place of posting
on June 17, 2025. Thus, on June 30, 2026, he had
already served a period of one year, thereby making
him liable to be transferred to another post. This
liability, only if he was transferred on rotational basis.
This impediment is not applicable if the petitioner is
transferred on administrative exigency. The employer,
the respondent Bank herein, is entitled to transfer an
incumbent if the same is effected on the ground of
administrative exigency, at any time, notwithstanding
the tenure of his service.
11. The petitioner was transferred on August 5, 2026. The
policy makes a departure or distinction insofar as the
timelines for effecting the transfer is concerned. Thus,
if a transfer is made on a rotational basis or on the
ground of administrative exigency, it has to abide by
the policy specifications, that the transfer should be
effected by June 30 every year. However, such an
interpretation could impinge the entire prospect and
possibility of an administrative exigency. The exigency
could well arise at any time and cannot be limited to
the fixed date of June 30 of each year. Thus, if an
administrative exigency arose, for example, at any
time after June 30, a transfer could be effected to
address
this
administrative
exigency.
Thus,
the
timeline for transfer to be effected on June 30 every
year to be necessarily applicable to rotational transfer
only.
12. The difficulty in this case arises upon perusal of the
order of transfer dated August 5, 2026. This is
coupled with Mr. Singh’s argument that the petitioner
having completed a tenure of one year in his current
place of posting is, therefore, liable to be transferred.
The overt insinuation of Mr. Singh is that the
petitioner has been transferred on rotational basis
and yet he submits that the transfer could be effected
at any time after June 30 as this is a transfer on the
ground of administrative exigency.
13. Without even getting into submissions made by the
Bank on these two counts, seeking to club the two
grounds
together,
the
transfer
order
itself
is
ominously silent as to the ground. The transfer order
does not disclose any ground at all.
14. From a bare perusal of the said order it is impossible
to ascertain whether the transfer has been effected on
administrative ground or rotational ground or on any
other ground. The petitioner has admittedly not been
promoted.
15. The reason for this is; had this been a transfer on
administrative exigency, the same had to be disclosed
by the Bank. There is no such disclosure. If on the
other hand, it was indicated as rotational transfer, it
is clearly beyond the domain of the transfer policy,
being effected on August 5, 2026 when it should have
been done by June 30, 2026.
16. The judgments placed by Mr. Singh relate to this
issue when a transfer has been made in accordance
with the policy/Rules of an institution. In fact, in the
decision of Abani Kanta Ray (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has mentioned that the Courts can
interfere when the transfer is arbitrary or vitiated by
mala fides or infraction of any professed norm or
principle governing the transfer.
17. The instant case clearly falls within this parameter, as
the ground of transfer has not been disclosed, for the
reasons afore-stated.
18. In view of the afore-stated findings, the order of
transfer and the release order both dated August 5,
2026 are set aside.
19. I make it clear that this will, however, not stop the
Bank from initiating further process of transfer, if so
advised.
20. With the afore-stated observations, the writ petition is
disposed of.
21. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
22. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties on priority basis.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review