Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.04.21 11:55:15 +05'30'
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021
Ref:- W.P.(C) No. 741 of 2019
Shri Soraisam Manimacha Singh aged about 59 years
S/O S. Ibobi Singh of by occupation a Veterinary Field
Assistant of Assam Rifles, a resident of Chingmakha
Maisnam Leikai, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Singjamei and
District – Imphal West, Manipur.
........ Petitioner
-Versus1.
The Union of India, represented by its Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India,
North Block, New Delhi-01.
2.
The Director General of Assam Rifles, Ministry of
Hoe Affairs, Laitkhor, Shillong-793010.
3.
The Controller of Accounts, Pay & Account Office
(Assam Rifles) Shillong, Old DGAR Complex,
Laitmukhra, Pin Code-793011.
........ Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
30.03.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
17.04.2023
::
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(M.V. Muralidaran, Acting CJ)
This review petition has been filed by the petitioner
to review the order dated 23.1.2020 passed by this Court in
W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019.
2.
Heard Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, the learned DSGI for the
respondents.
3.
The petitioner sought to review the order dated
23.1.2020 passed by this Court W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019 by
contending that the ACP scheme dated 9.8.1999 provides for
financial upgradation under the scheme to the next higher grade
with the existing hierarchy in a cadre/category of the post without
creating new posts for the purpose. However, in the case of
isolated posts, in the absence of defined hierarchy grades,
financial
upgradation
shall
be
given
by
the
Ministries/Departments concerned in the immediately next higher
pay scales.
4.
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, the learned counsel for the
petitioner argued that the post of VFA (Assam Rifles) is an
isolated post having no promotional post and at the same time, it
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |3
falls under common category of post governed by Section 30(b)
of the Indian Veterinary Council Act, 1984 as also clarified in the
5th CPC (ROP) 1997. He would submit that comparisons have
been made with AFO (Vety) in SSB which is in the same Ministry
and carrying the same pay scale of Rs.4000-6000/- and, as such,
granting of Rs.4000-6000 to 5500-9000/- is in accordance with
the Office Memorandum dated 9.8.1999, which was later on
clarified by the Office Memorandum dated 10.2.2000 and
18.7.2001 respectively.
5.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
Office Memorandum dated 9.8.1999 will only apply to those
isolated post who does not find any similarity of post in the same
Ministry/Department/Cadre or whose scale of pay has not been
recommended separately or as specifically by the Pay
Commission for mobility under ACPs.
6.
The learned counsel urged that during the course of
hearing of the writ petition, the petitioner has failed to appraise
this Court about the fact that DoPT Office Memorandum dated
18.7.2001, Point of Doubt 44, which clearly states that Annexure
II of the Office Memorandum dated 9.8.1999 applies where Pay
Commission has not made any specific recommendation
regarding scales to be allowed under the ACPs and where it is
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |4
not possible to identify similar post in some organization.
Therefore, it is very clear that Annexure II of the Office
Memorandum dated 9.8.1999 will apply where no any similar
post is found in same Organization/Ministry or any specific scale
of pay is not recommended for ACPs by Pay Commission.
7.
Adding further, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that due to non-appraisal from the side of the petitioner
during the hearing of the writ petition about the applicability of the
Office
Memorandum
dated
10.2.2000
and
18.7.2001
respectively, this Court was pleased to held that the petitioner
cannot plead for himself a benefit except under the ACP scheme
dated 9.8.1999 and the notification dated 30.9.1997.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner then
submitted that the petitioner has failed to apprise this Court while
hearing the writ petition that the post of the petitioner (VFA) is an
isolated post and according to the clarification given in the Office
Memorandum dated 10.2.2000 and 18.7.2001, similarity of post
in the same Ministry/Department/Cadre is drawn and that AFO is
a similar post in the same Ministry/Department/Cadre and that
the petitioner is entitled to get a financial upgradation of the pay
of the DFO as 1st ACP.
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |5
9.
The learned counsel next submitted that the
petitioner was in the pay scale of Rs.4000-6000/- and if only the
ACP scheme dated 9.8.1999 is taken into account, the petitioner
is only liable to receive the 1st ACP grant of Rs.4500-125-7000
(S-8) in accordance with the Standard Common Pay AnnexureII of the Office Memorandum, but the petitioner must receive
promotional pay scale of Rs.5500-9000/- at 1st ACP according to
the clarification of ACP scheme vide Office Memorandum dated
10.2.2000 and 18.7.2001. Since the petitioner belongs to the
common category para veterinary staff for which a composite pay
scale of Rs.4000-6000 has been accorded.
Moreover, AFO
(Vety.) in SSB falls under the same Ministry and is also similarly
situated with the post of VFA in Assam Rifles and, as such,
granted the scale of pay of promotional post of AFO (Vety.) which
is DFO (Vety.) with the corresponding pay of Rs.5500-9000/-.
Therefore, due to the failure of the then counsel appeared for the
petitioner in not properly appraising the case of the petitioner
before this Court, the petitioner suffered adverse orders of
dismissal of the writ petition.
10.
Arguing so, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner has got good case in succeeding in
the writ petition. Thus, a prayer has been made to review the
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |6
order dated 23.1.2020 passed in W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019 and
grant the reliefs as prayed for in the writ petition. In support, the
learned counsel placed reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
Board of Control for Cricket in India v.
Netaji Cricket Club and others, (2005) 4
SCC 741.
(ii) State of Uttar Pradesh and others v. Arvind
Kumar Srivastava and others, (2015) 1
SCC 347.
(iii) M.M.Thomas v. State of Kerala and
another, 2000 Legal Eagle (SC) 29.
11.
Supporting the order under review, Mr. Kh.
Samarjit, the learned DSGI submitted that there is no error in the
order of this Court dated 23.1.2020 passed in W.P.(C) No.741 of
2019 and having found that there is no infirmity in the order of the
CAT, this Court has rightly dismissed the writ petition and there
is no valid ground to review the same. Thus, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the review petition.
12.
We have considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials
available on record.
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |7
13.
The writ petition, being W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019,
has been filed by the petitioner to quash the order dated
17.1.2019 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Guwahati Bench in O.A.No.042/00285/2015 and the letter dated
3.1.2013 of the Pay and Accounts Officer and the speaking order
dated 22.5.2015 and to direct the respondents to grant the 1st
financial upgradation in parity with the post of AFO (Vety) SSB
and other common category para veterinary in the scale of
Rs.5500-9000 (pay scale of DFO (Vety) SSB) w.e.f. 9.8.1999
along with all consequential benefit, monetary allowances and
interest on the arrear pay in accordance with the Office
Memorandum dated 10.2.2000.
The petitioner also sought
direction on the respondents to fix the pay at Rs.4300 as on
1.1.1996 with date of next increment February 1996 in the scale
of Rs.4000-100-6000/- vide III proviso of fixation of Pay Rules,
1997 and accordingly calculate the pay of the petitioner.
14.
Though it is not necessary to state the case
projected
by
the
petitioner
before
the
CAT
in
O.A.No.042/00265/2015 and its decision, for the sake of
completion, the finding of arrived at by the CAT is reproduced
hereunder:
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |8
“9. The issue here is nothing but comparing of
an apple with another apple. It is not contested
by the applicant that the post of Veterinary Field
Assistant in Assam Rifles is isolated post. If the
post of Veterinary Field Assistant is isolated
one, accordingly the order of Ministry of Finance
in regard to the implementation of the 5th CPC
and also financial upgradation under ACP has
to be complied with. It that is so, since the
applicant was placed in the scale of Sl. No.7
Rs.4000-100-6000, the next scale of financial
upgradation would naturally S-8 4500-125-7000
and obviously not as S-10 which is the scale of
5500-175-9000. Comparing of the isolated post
of Veterinary Field Assistant of Assam Rifles
that with of the pay scale of Assistant Field
Officer (Vety) in the scale of Rs.4000-100-6000,
Para Cadre of SSB may not be justifiable.
10. Moreover, there is no any indication from
the Govt. letter as well as from the contention of
the applicant that the Veterinary posts in the
SSB are also isolated posts. On the face of the
Govt. order dated 13.04.2004, it appears that
there is a proper cadre structure in that
organization. The number of sanctioned posts
of the different scales against these posts is
clearly indicated. Therefore, demanding of the
ascending
scales
in
the
cadre
of
that
organization only because the next higher scale
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
Page |9
of scale 400-100-6000 is 5500-175-9000 found
not maintainable.
11. Considering the above facts and relevant
orders on the subject, we found that the
applicant has not justified ground to sustain his
O.A.
The O.A. is therefore, liable to be
dismissed.
12. The applicant also had prayed to direct the
respondents to refund the amount already
deducted from the pay of the applicant w.e.f.
09.08.1999 with admissible allowances and
benefits as per existing rules promulgated by
the Govt. of India. In this connection, it may be
highlighted that as per decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court rendered in the case of State of
Punjab & Others vs Rafiq Masih (White
Washer) etc., (2015) 4 SCC 334 no recovery is
to be effect from Group ‘C’ employees.
Therefore, it will not be justified to make
recovery from the applicant for the over
payment already made during the period he
was placed in the higher scale of Rs.5500-1759000 particularly when this mistake was
committed by the respondents. We hereby
accordingly,
while
O.A.No.042/00285/2015,
dismissing
the
direct
the
respondents that no recovery shall be effected
from the applicant for the over payment made
and whatever recovery of amount already
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 10
effected shall be refunded to the applicant
forthwith.
13. O.A. stands dismissed partly. No order as
to costs.”
15.
When the petitioner assailed the aforesaid order of
the CAT in the writ petition, this Court, after analysing the
arguments made by the learned counsel appearing for the
parties, held as under:
“[12] The petitioner in this case cannot plead for
himself a benefit except under the ACP Scheme
dated 9th August, 1999 and the 30th September,
1997 Notification as he falls under the said
scheme.
The
Tribunal
was
justified
in
dismissing the application for all the above
reasons. We find no merit in the plea of the
petitioner.
[13] Accordingly, finding no merit the writ
petition is dismissed.”
16.
It is pertinent to note that it is not the case of the
petitioner that while passing the order under review this Court
has committed error in dismissing the writ petition partly. On the
other hand, the entire averments of the review petition blame the
learned counsel who appeared for the petitioner in the writ
petition by contending that the petitioner has failed to appraise
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 11
this Court. Thus, it is clear that the failure of the learned counsel
for the petitioner in appraising the correct facts before this Court
would not amount to error in the order as stated by the petitioner.
17.
At this juncture, by placing on record, the decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of (i) Netaji Cricket
Club; (ii) Arvind Kumar Srivastava and (iii) M.M.Thomas, supra,
the learned counsel contended that an application for review
would also be maintainable if there exists sufficient reason
therefor.
18.
In Netaji Cricket Club, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held:
“90. Thus, a mistake on the part of the court
which would include a mistake in the nature of
the undertaking may also call for a review of the
order. An application for review would also be
maintainable if there exists sufficient reason
therefor.
What would constitute sufficient
reason would depend on the facts and
circumstances of the case.
The words
‘sufficient reason’ in Order 47, Rule 1 of the
Code
is
wide
enough
to
include
a
misconception of fact or law by a court or even
an Advocate. An application for review may be
necessitated by way of invoking the doctrine
“actus curiae neminem gravabit”.
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 12
19.
In Arvind Kumar Srivastava, supra, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“22.1. The normal rule is that when a particular
set of employees is given relief by the court, all
other identically situated persons need to be
treated alike by extending that benefit. Not
doing so would amount to discrimination and
would be violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. This principle needs to
be
applied
in
service
matters
more
emphatically as service jurisprudence evolved
by this Court from time to time postulates that
all similarly situated persons should be treated
similarly. Therefore, the normal rule would be
that merely because other similarly situated
persons did not approach the Court earlier,
they are not to be treated differently.”
20.
In M.M.Thomas, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held:
“17. If suo power of correcting its own record is
denied to the High Court, when it noticed the
apparent errors its consequence is that the
superior status of the High Court will dwindle
down. Therefore, it is only proper to think that
the plenary powers of the High Court would
include the power of review relating to errors
apparent on the face of record.”
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 13
21.
On a thorough reading of the order of the CAT,
order under review passed in the writ petition and the averments
set out by the petitioner in the review petition, it is clear that on
behalf of the petitioner three different counsel appeared and
different grounds were raised for the claim of the petitioner.
Therefore, there is no mistake apparent on the face of record and
exercising review jurisdiction of this Court to review the order
does not arise, as this Court while passing the order in the writ
petition on merits partly dismissed the writ petition. If there is
apparent errors, then this Court by exercising review power,
correct such error. In the case on hand, there is no sufficient
reason for reviewing the order. Therefore, the decisions relied
upon by learned counsel for the petitioner are not applicable to
the case of the petitioner in the facts and circumstances stated
above.
22.
It is settled law that under Order 47, Rule 1 of the
Code, a judgment is open to review, inter alia, if there is a mistake
apparent on the face of the record, the discovery of new and
important matter or evidence, which after exercise of due
diligence, was not within the knowledge of the petitioner or on
account of some mistake or error apparent on face of record or
for any sufficient reason.
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 14
23.
The party seeking review has also to show that such
matter or evidence was not within its knowledge and even after
the exercise of due diligence, the same could not be produced
before the Court/Tribunal earlier.
24.
In the instant case, the order sought to be reviewed
has been passed based on the facts put forth by the learned
counsel for the petitioner as well as the learned Additional
Solicitor General and, therefore, there is no apparent error on the
face of record or discovery of new facts for making the present
review application maintainable.
25.
A mistake or an error apparent on the face of the
record means a mistake or an error which is prima facie visible
and does not require any detail examination. In the present case
the petitioner has not been able to point out any error apparent
on the face of the record.
26.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in a catena of
decisions, while dealing with the scope of review has held that
re-appreciation of evidence and re-hearing of case without there
being any error apparent on the face of the record is not
permissible in the light of the provisions as contained under
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 15
Section 114 and Order 47, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908.
27.
In S.Bagirathi Ammal v. Palani Roman Catholic
Mission, reported in (2009) 10 SCC 464, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held thus:
“12. An error contemplated under the Rule
must be such which is apparent on the face of
the record and not an error which has to be
fished out and searched. In other words, it
must be an error of inadvertence. It should be
something more than a mere error and it must
be one which must be manifest on the face of
the record. When does an error cease to be
mere error and becomes an error apparent on
the face of the record depends upon the
materials placed before the court. If the error
is so apparent that without further investigation
or enquiry, only one conclusion can be drawn
in
favour
of
the
applicant,
in
such
circumstances, the review will lie. Under the
guise of review, the parties are not entitled to
rehearing of the same issue but the issue can
be decided just by a perusal of the records and
if it is manifest can be set right by reviewing
the order. With this background, let us analyse
the impugned judgment of the High Court and
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 16
find out whether it satisfies any of the tests
formulated above.
.......
26. As held earlier, if the judgment/order is
vitiated by an apparent error or it is a palpable
wrong and if the error is self-evident, review is
permissible and in this case the High Court
has rightly applied the said principles as
provided under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. In view
of the same, we are unable to accept the
arguments
of
learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing for the appellant, on the other hand,
we are in entire agreement with the view
expressed by the High Court.”
28.
Rehearing of a case can be done on account of
some mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record or
for any other sufficient reason. In the present case, as stated
supra, there is no error apparent on the face of the record and
the petitioner, in fact, under the guise of review is challenging the
order passed by this Court, which is not permissible under law.
29.
In the instant case, if the review petitioner is
aggrieved by the order passed in the writ petition, he ought to
have filed an appeal and not the review petition. The fact remains
that as against order dated 23.1.2020 passed in the writ petition,
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 17
the petitioner had also preferred SLP No.8309 of 2020 before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and later on the petitioner has withdrawn
the said SLP with liberty to file a review petition. Accordingly, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, by the order dated 20.8.2020, dismissed
the SL.P.No.8309 of 2020.
Where the order in question is
appealable, the aggrieved party has adequate and efficacious
remedy of preferring an appeal and not under the guise of review
petition.
30.
It is a settled law that every error whether factual or
legal cannot be made subject-matter of review under Order 47
Rule 1 of the Code though it can be made subject-matter of
appeal arising out of such order. In other words, in order to attract
the provisions of Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code, the error/mistake
must be apparent on the face of the record of the case. Here,
we find that there is no error apparent on the face of record while
passing the order under review.
31.
In light of the above, this Court does not find any
reason to review the order dated 23.1.2020 passed in W.P.(C)
No.741 of 2019. That apart, there is no error apparent on the
face of the record. No case for interference is made out in the
matter.
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
P a g e | 18
32.
In the result, the review petition is dismissed. There
will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
Rev. Pet. No. 13 of 2021 (Ref:- W.P.(C) No.741 of 2019)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review