The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. I am supported by the decision ecisions rendered by a Co-ordinate Bench of th this Court in TA No. 1315/20 315/2022, Rohini Arora v Nitin Talwar; r; TA No. 1322 of 2022, Jaswind aswinder Kaur v Gurvinderjeet Singh;; and TA No. 1323 of 2022, Ushaa Ran Rani v Karmajit Singh.
13. The present petition stands disp disposed of, in the above terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TA-1717-20
-1-
IN THE
TH HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB
NJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
GARH
TA-17
1717-2025
Date oof Decision: 15.05.2026
Sonika
.… Petitioner
Versus
Jaswinder
der Singh
Si
.... Respondent
CORAM:
M: HON'BLE
H
MS. JUSTICE NIDH
NIDHI GUPTA
Present: -
Petitioner-Sonika is present
nt in pperson.
Mr. Ashutosh Sharma, Advocat
dvocate for the respondent.
NIDHII GUPTA,
GUP
J. (ORAL)
1.
By way of filing the present
sent pe
petition, the petitioner-wife is
seeking
g transfer
tran
of 02 petitions i.e.. (a) ppetition No. HMA-94-2021
(Annexure
xure P-1) titled as ‘Jaswinder
er Sin
Singh vs. Sonika’ filed by
respondent
dent-husband under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
(for short--‘the Act’); and (b) petition
ion No. HMA-1930-2024 dated
05.09.2024
2024 (Annexure P-2) titled as ‘Sonik
Sonika vs. Jaswinder Singh’ filed
by the petitioner-wife
petiti
under Section 9 of tthe Act, pending before the
learned
d Family
Fam Court, Rupnagar to the Famil
Family Court, Chandigarh.
2.
The petitioner who is present
sent in person, inter alia, submits
as under:
i)
The parties solemnized
nized marriage on 11.12.2019
according to Hindu Rites and Ceremonies.
ii)
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
No child was born out of the said wedlock.
TA-1717-20
iii)
-2-
Due to matrimonial
ial dis
discord the parties are living
separately since February
bruary, 2020.
iv)
At present the petitioner
tioner-wife is working as Clerk on
contract basis with
ith tthe State Legal Services
Authority, U.T. Chandiga
andigarh. As such she is unable to
avail leave to travel
el freq
frequently from Chandigarh to
Rupnagar to pursue
rsue both the aforementioned
petitions. It is pointed
ted ou
out that due to frequent leaves
taken by her, a show-cau
cause notice dated 10.10.2023
(Annexure P-3) hass been issued to the petitioner to
avoid being absent from dduty.
v)
Petitioner who is present in person submits that the
present job as Clerkk is th
the only source of her income
as, the respondent-husban
husband is not paying anything by
way of maintenance.
vi)
There are 03 cases filed bby the petitioner-wife which
are
pending
adjudicat
judication
at
District
Courts,
Chandigarh i.e. (i)
i) und
under the provisions of the
Protection of Women
en fro
from Domestic Violence Act,
2005; (ii) under Section
ction 144 BNSS of 2023 (Section
125 Cr.P.C.) for mainte
maintenance; and (iii) complaint
with the U.T. Police
ce for registration of case against
the respondent-husband.
band.
3.
It is accordingly prayed that the present petition may be
allowed; and
an both the petitions bearin
bearing Nos. (a) HMA-94-2021
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
TA-1717-20
-3-
(Annexure
xure P-1) titled as ‘Jaswinder
er Si
Singh vs. Sonika’ filed by
respondent
dent-husband;
and
(b)
HMA-193
1930-2024
dated
05.09.2024
(Annexure
xure P
P-2) titled as ‘Sonika vs. Jas
Jaswinder Singh’ filed by the
petitioner-wi
wife petition be transferredd from the learned Family Court,
Rupnagar to the Family Court at Chandigarh
digarh.
4.
Per Contra, learned counsel
nsel fo
for the respondent vehemently
opposes
es the submissions advanced by the pe
petitioner who is present person
and submits
ubmits that the petitioner herself
elf ha
has filed petition bearing No.
HMA-870--2024 dated 30.09.2024 (Annexur
nnexure P-2) under Section 9 of the
Act before
efore the
t learned Family Court, Rupn
Rupnangar. On a Court query, the
petitioner
ner clarifies
cla
that although, the aforesa
foresaid petition (Annexure P-2) is
pending
g befo
before the learned Family Court,
urt, Ru
Rupnagar, however, the counsel
representing
ing her in the said case has refused to pursue the same as, he is
also facing
cing threats
th
from the respondent-side.
side.
5.
No other argument has been
een m
made on behalf of the parties. I
have heard
eard llearned counsel for the parties
rties aand carefully gone through the
case file.
ile. I ffind no merit in the submission
issions advanced on behalf of the
respondent.
dent.
6.
Besides the facts as noticed
iced hhereinabove, which constitute
itute
sufficient
ent grounds
gro
for transfer, the legal
al posi
position in such like cases is well
established.
ished. In this regard, judgmentt of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt
rendered
ed in N.C.V. Aishwarya vs A.S.
.S. Sa
Saravana Karthik Sha,” 2022
Live Law
aw (SC)
(S 627, is notable, wherein
ein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held ass unde
under:“9. The cardinal principle
ple for exercise of power under
er
section 24 of the Code of Civil
ivil Procedure is that the ends of
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
TA-1717-20
-4-
justice should demand thee tra
transfer of the suit, appeal or
other proceeding. In matrimon
imonial matters, wherever Courts
rts
are called upon to considerr th
the plea of transfer, the Courts
rts
have to take into consideratio
ation the economic soundness of
both the parties, the sociall str
strata of the spouses and their
eir
behavioural pattern, theirr sta
standard of life prior to the
he
marriage and subsequent ther
thereto and the circumstances of
both the parties in eking out their livelihood and under
er
whose protective umbrella they are seeking their sustenance
ce
to life. Given the prevailingg so
socioeconomic paradigm in the
he
Indian society, generally, it is the wife's convenience which
ch
must be looked at while conside
sidering transfer.
10. Further, when two orr mo
more proceedings are pending in
different Courts between the same parties which raise
ise
common question of fact and
nd la
law, and when the decisions in
the cases are interdependent,
nt, it is desirable that they should
ld
be tried together by thee sa
same Judge so as to avoid
id
multiplicity in trial of the
he ssame issues and conflict of
decisions.”
7.
Further reliance can be placed
aced uupon the judgments in Sumita
Singh vs Ku
Kumar Sanjay, 2002 SC 396 and Rajani Kishor Pardeshivs
Kishorr Babulal
Bab
Pardeshi, 2005(12)) SCC 237, wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme
me Court
C
has observed that “w
“while deciding the transfer
application,
ion, the Courts are required to give more weightage and
consideratio
ration to the convenience of thee fem
female litigants and transfer of
legal proce
roceedings from one Court too an
another should ordinarily be
allowed,, tak
taking into consideration their
eir cconvenience and the Courts
should desis
esist from putting female litigants
ts un
under undue hardships.”
8.
Even this Court in number
mber of cases has followed the
aforesaid
aid principle
pr
of law. Accordingly,
ngly, iit is well settled that while
considering
ering the transfer of a matrimonial
nial di
dispute/case, at the instance of
the wife,
ife, the Court is to consider thee fami
family condition of the wife, the
custody
y of the
th minor child, economic condi
condition of the wife, her physical
health and earning capacity of the husba
husband and most important the
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
TA-1717-20
-5-
convenience
nience of the wife i.e. she cannott trave
travel alone without assistance of
a malee member
mem
of her family, connectivity
ctivity of the place to and fro from
her place
ace of residence as well as bearing
aring of the litigation charges and
travelling
ing expenses.
ex
9.
In view of the judgmentss i.e. Sumita Singh’s case (supra),
Rajanii Kish
Kishor Pardeshi’s case (supra)
ra) an
and N.C.V. Aishwarya’s case
(supra)) passed
pass
by the Hon’ble Supreme
reme Court, this Court deems it
appropriate
riate to allow the present petition
etition, subject to the following
conditions:
ions:a)
Both the petitions beari
bearing Nos. (a) HMA-94-2021
(Annexure P-1) titled as ‘Jaswinder Singh vs.
Sonika’ filed by the re
respondent-husband; and (b)
petition under Section
ction 9 of the Act bearing No.
HMA-1930-2024 dated 05.09.2024 (Annexure P-2)
titled as ‘Sonika vs. Jas
Jaswinder Singh’ filed by the
petitioner-wife, pending
nding before the learned Family
Court, Rupnagar is transf
transferred to the Family Court at
Chandigarh.
b)
The learned District
ct Jud
Judge, Rupnagar is directed to
transfer complete recor
record pertaining to both the
aforesaid cases to District
istrict Judge, Chandigarh.
c)
The parties are directed
ected tto appear before the District
Judge, Chandigarh on 117.06.2026.
d)
The District Judge, Chan
Chandigarh will assign the said
petitions to the Court
rt of ccompetent jurisdiction.
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
TA-1717-20
10.
-6-
The concerned Court at Chandi
handigarh will make all endeavour
to refer
er the case before the Mediation
tion aand Conciliation Centre for
exploring
ing the possibility of some amicable
able se
settlement between the parties.
11.
The Court concerned, where the litigation is pending
between
en the parties, will accommodate them with one date in one
calendar
ar month.
mon
12.
I am supported by the decision
ecisions rendered by a Co-ordinate
Bench of th
this Court in TA No. 1315/20
315/2022, Rohini Arora v Nitin
Talwar;
r; TA No. 1322 of 2022, Jaswind
aswinder Kaur v Gurvinderjeet
Singh;; and TA No. 1323 of 2022, Ushaa Ran
Rani v Karmajit Singh.
13.
The present petition stands disp
disposed of, in the above terms.
14.
Pending application(s), if any, sshall also stand disposed of.
15.05.2026
rishu
( NIDHI GUPTA )
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable
RISHU KATARIA
2026.05.18 19:48
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review