Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 25.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 18.03.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 18.03.2026
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
SONIKA ARYA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Anil Singhal, Adv.
Versus
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI THROUGH ITS CHIEF
SECRETARY & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Ms. Avnish Ahlawat, SC along
with Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh,
Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Petition, the Petitioner seeks issuance of a
writ in the nature of certiorari by assailing the order dated 09.09.2025
[hereinafter referred to as the ‘Impugned Order’] passed by the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi
[hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal] in Original Application (‘O.A.’)
No. 4229/2017 captioned Mrs Sonika Arya v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
& Ors., whereby the OA preferred by the Petitioner came to be
dismissed.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
2.
By way of the said OA, the Petitioner had sought a direction to
the Respondents to consider her for appointment to the post of PGT
(Sanskrit) - (Female) under Post Code 178/14 against an unfilled
vacancy in the Other Backward Classes (‘OBC’) category. The
Petitioner was placed at Serial No. 2 in the unselected OBC waitlist
pursuant to Advertisement No. 01/14 issued by the Delhi Subordinate
Services Selection Board (‘DSSSB’).
3.
The learned Tribunal, while noticing that one of the four
advertised OBC vacancies remained unfilled and that the candidature
of one selected OBC candidate was ultimately cancelled, declined
relief to the Petitioner on the ground that the waiting panel had
expired on 09.10.2017 and that the cancellation of the said candidature
on 05.09.2018 could not revive or extend an exhausted panel.
4.
In order to appreciate the issue involved in this Petition,
relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
5.
DSSSB issued Advertisement No.01/14 in the year 2014,
inviting applications for, inter alia, the post of PGT (Sanskrit)
(Female) under Post Code 178/14. Sixteen vacancies (UR-07, OBC04, SC-02, ST-03 including 01 OH and 01 VH) were notified for the
said post, out of which four vacancies were earmarked for the OBC
category. The Petitioner participated in the selection process and
applied for the same in the OBC category.
6.
Upon declaration of the result on 10.10.2016, three candidates
were declared successful in the OBC Category and appointed, whereas
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
the candidature of one selected OBC candidate bearing Roll No.
35002828 was kept pending for verification of her OBC certificate.
7.
The Petitioner was placed at Serial No. 2 in the unselected OBC
waitlist and was called for document verification. The fourth
advertised OBC vacancy remained unfilled on account of the pending
verification of the aforesaid candidate for a considerable time.
8.
The Petitioner sought clarification regarding the status of the
fourth vacancy from the DSSSB, and was informed that the
candidature of the said candidate was still under consideration.
9.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the Petitioner instituted O.A. No.
4229/2017 before the learned Tribunal in November 2017, seeking
consideration for appointment against the said vacancy. During the
pendency of the proceedings, the candidature of the fourth selected
candidate bearing Roll No. 35002828, vide Result Notice No. 714
dated 05.09.2018, was cancelled.
10.
The Respondents, however, took the position before the learned
Tribunal that the waiting panel was valid only for a period of one year
from the date of declaration of the result, i.e., till 09.10.2017, and
since the cancellation of the fourth candidature occurred thereafter, the
Petitioner could not be considered for appointment.
11.
The learned Tribunal dismissed the Original Application of the
Petitioner, holding that the OA had been filed in November 2017, i.e.
after the expiry of the waiting panel in October 2017. The cancellation
of Roll No. 35002828 in September 2018 took place well after the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
expiry of the wait-list on 09.10.2017, and cannot revive or extend an
exhausted panel and the Petitioner, being only a wait-list candidate,
had no enforceable right to appointment.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
12.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal failed to appreciate that four vacancies were admittedly
advertised under the OBC category, whereas only three candidates
were appointed and one vacancy remained unfilled on account of the
Respondents’ prolonged verification of the candidature of Roll No.
35002828.
13.
It is contended that the Petitioner, being placed at Serial No. 2
in the unselected OBC merit list and having been called for document
verification, had a legitimate right to be considered against the said
vacancy once the candidature of the above candidate was cancelled on
05.09.2018.
14.
Learned counsel submits that the delay in finalising the
verification of the said candidate was entirely attributable to the
Respondents, and the Petitioner cannot be made to suffer on account
of administrative inaction. It is argued that the vacancy had in fact
arisen during the pendency of the Original Application before the
Tribunal and, therefore, the Respondents were under an obligation to
operate the waitlist and consider the next eligible candidate.
15.
It is further submitted by the counsel for the Petitioner that the
learned Tribunal erred in holding that the waiting panel had expired
on 09.10.2017, inasmuch as the result of all the advertised vacancies
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
had not been finalised by that date. According to the Petitioner, the
panel could not be treated as exhausted until the candidature of the
pending candidate for the fourth vacancy was decided.
16.
Reliance is placed on the decision of this Court in Kuldeep
Singh v. DSSSB1, to contend that where the recruitment process is not
fully completed, and vacancies remain unfilled for reasons attributable
to the employer, the Respondents are obliged to operate a reserve
panel so that notified vacancies do not go to waste.
17.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner also submits that the
Respondents cannot be permitted to take advantage of their own delay
in concluding the verification process and thereafter plead expiry of
the panel to deny appointment to an otherwise eligible candidate.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
18.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the Respondents
submits that the Petitioner was placed at Serial No. 2 in the unselected
OBC waitlist and did not figure in the selected merit list of candidates.
It is submitted that inclusion in a waitlist does not confer any vested or
indefeasible right to appointment.
19.
It is also submitted that the result of the examination was
declared on 10.10.2016, and the waiting panel, as per the applicable
policy of the DSSSB, remained valid for a period of one year, i.e., till
09.10.2017. Since the Petitioner did not fall within the zone of
selection during that period, no right accrued in her favour.
2012 (118) DLT 101
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
20.
Learned counsel contends that the candidature of Roll No.
35002828 was cancelled only on 05.09.2018, i.e., well after the expiry
of the waiting panel. Therefore, the Respondents were legally
precluded from operating the waitlist panel thereafter, and the unfilled
vacancy was rightly returned to the user department.
21.
It is further submitted that the Petitioner, being at Serial No. 2
in the unselected OBC list, could not have been considered in any case
unless the first waitlisted OBC candidate had been exhausted during
the validity period of the panel.
22.
It was also contended that a candidate in a select or wait list
does not acquire an enforceable right to appointment and that no
direction can be issued once the waiting panel has lapsed.
23.
The Ld. Counsel for the Respondents submits that the learned
Tribunal has correctly appreciated the factual and legal position, and
no interference is called for in the exercise of jurisdiction under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
24.
The Petitioner admittedly did not figure in the selected list of
candidates. She was placed at Serial No. 2 in the OBC waitlist. It is
well settled that inclusion in a waitlist does not confer any vested right
to appointment but only a limited right to be considered, subject to the
availability of a vacancy during the validity period of the waitlist
panel unless the governing rules provide otherwise.
25.
Even assuming that one OBC vacancy ultimately remained
unfilled, the Petitioner would enter the zone of consideration only
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
upon exhaustion of the first waitlisted candidate. There is no material
on record to demonstrate that the first waitlist candidate was either
unavailable, unwilling, or otherwise disqualified during the validity
period of the panel. In the absence of such circumstances, no
enforceable right to consideration accrued in favour of the Petitioner.
26.
The result of the examination was declared on 10.10.2016. As
per the policy governing the Respondents, the waiting panel remained
valid for a period of one year, i.e., till 09.10.2017.
27.
The Original Application came to be instituted in November
2017, after the date when the waitlist panel had already expired.
Significantly, on the date of institution of the Original Application, no
vacancy had arisen, and the waitlist panel had ceased to be operative.
28.
The candidature of the fourth selected candidate in the OBC
Category, whose result had been kept pending, came to be cancelled
only on 05.09.2018, i.e., nearly one year after the expiry of the panel.
The vacancy, therefore, crystallised at a point in time when the
waitlist panel had already lapsed, and a lapsed panel cannot be
operated by a subsequent vacancy. Equally, a cause of action cannot
be created retrospectively during the pendency of proceedings when
none existed on the date of institution.
29.
The Supreme Court in Rajasthan Public Service Commission,
Ajmer v. Yati Jain & Ors2 and the connected appeals, has held that a
candidate included in a waiting list does not acquire any indefeasible
right to appointment and that such inclusion only enables
2026 INSC 64
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
consideration if a selected candidate does not join and such
contingency arises during the validity of the waitlist.
30.
The Supreme Court further clarified that the waiting list cannot
be treated as a perennial source of recruitment. A waiting list has a
limited validity period, and once its period of validity expires and the
panel stands exhausted, no appointment can be made therefrom. A
vacancy arising after the expiry of the waiting list must be filled only
through a fresh recruitment process, and the limited right of a waitlisted candidate does not survive the lapse of the panel. The
prescription of a time-limit is intended to prevent the operation of
stale panels and to safeguard the rights of future aspirants. The limited
right of a wait-listed candidate is confined to consideration during the
subsistence of the list and does not survive its lapse.
31.
In the present case, the waiting panel expired on 09.10.2017,
whereas the cancellation of the candidature of the fourth selected
candidate occurred on 05.09.2018. The panel having lapsed, no right
of consideration survived in favour of the Petitioner.
32.
The contention of the Petitioner that the result could not be
treated as final so long as the candidature of one selected candidate
remained under verification is misconceived.
33.
The declaration of the result on 10.10.2016 was complete in
respect of the selected list of candidates and the waitlist. The
pendency of verification of one candidate did not defer the operation
of the waitlist panel, nor did it extend its validity period in the absence
of any rule to that effect. To accept such a contention would render the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
life
of
waitlist
panels
indeterminate
and
contingent
upon
administrative timelines of verification.
34.
The reliance placed by the Petitioner upon the decision of this
Court in Kuldeep Singh (supra) is misplaced. That decision arose in a
materially different setting, where the recruitment was governed by a
general merit list, the advertisement did not prescribe minimum
qualifying marks, and, more importantly, did not indicate any outer
time-limit for exhaustion of the vacancies notified in that examination.
It was in that backdrop that the Court observed that the zone of
consideration could legitimately move downward until all notified
vacancies from that examination were filled, particularly where the
user department itself continued to requisition names from the same
examination.
35.
In the present case, the governing advertisement, 01/2014, in
the note under mode of selection itself expressly stipulated that the
reserve panel/waiting list would remain valid only for one year from
the date of declaration of result, and that only vacancies arising within
the contingencies specified therein within the one-year period could
be filled therefrom. The result was declared on 10.10.2016, and the
panel ceased to remain operative on 09.10.2017. The vacancy sought
to be relied upon by the Petitioner arose only upon cancellation of
candidature on 05.09.2018, i.e. after the waitlist had lapsed.
36.
The Petitioner has also failed to demonstrate any arbitrariness,
discrimination, or mala fides on the part of the Respondents. No
candidate lower in rank in the waitlist to the Petitioner has been
shown to have been appointed in derogation of the Petitioner's claim,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
nor has any violation of the statutory recruitment rules been
demonstrated.
37.
The principle that inclusion in a select or waitlist does not
confer a right to appointment, particularly after the expiry of the
panel, is well settled. The learned Tribunal, in substance, applied the
correct legal position in holding that the cancellation of candidature in
September 2018 could not revive a panel that had lapsed in October
2017.
CONCLUSION:
38.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the opinion
that the Petitioner does not possess any subsisting or enforceable right
to seek appointment against the post in question. The waiting panel
had admittedly expired on 09.10.2017, prior to both the institution of
the Original Application and the eventual cancellation of the
candidature of the selected candidate on 05.09.2018. Any vacancy,
having arisen after the lapse of the waitlist panel, could not be filled
from an exhausted list.
39.
The Petitioner, being placed at Serial No. 2 in the unselected
OBC waitlist and there being no material to show that the candidature
of the first waitlisted candidate had been exhausted during the validity
of the waitlist panel, never entered the zone of consideration. No
arbitrariness, discrimination, or violation of the recruitment rules has
been demonstrated by the Petitioner.
40.
The conclusion arrived at by the learned Tribunal reflects a
view that is plausible. No jurisdictional error, manifest perversity, or
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
patent illegality has been shown so as to justify interference by this
Court. The Impugned Order, therefore, warrants no interference.
41.
The present Petition is, accordingly, dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
MARCH 18, 2026
jai/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:07:35
W.P.(C) 15587/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review