Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
Somnath Giri & Ors.
Versus
The Union of India & Ors.
For the Petitioners
:
Ms. Reshmi Ghosh, Adv.
Ms. Parna Mukherjee, Adv.
For the Respondent Nos. 3 to 7:
Mr. Kishore Dutta Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sirsanya Bandopadhyay, Adv.
Mr. Nikhil Jhunjhunwala, Adv.
Mr. Sachin Shukla, Adv.
For the Union of India
:
Mr. Rajendra Banerjee
Mr.Rahul Sarkar
Mr. Souvik Ganguly
Heard on
:
06.08.2026
Judgment on
:
17.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
17.09.2026
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.:
1.
The writ petitioners have filed this instant writ petition seeking, inter
alia, a direction in the nature of mandamus commanding the
respondents and/or their men, agents and assigns, to forthwith
and/or immediately regularise the service of the petitioners as Dock
Pilots in Shyama Prasad Mookherjee Port, Haldia Dock Complex in
accordance with law, together with other consequential reliefs based
on the following facts as under:
a. Petitioner No. 1 was initially engaged as Dock Pilot on an ad hoc
basis under Marine Operations Division of Haldia Dock Complex,
Kolkata Port Trust for a period of 3 years on a contract by a letter
dated 23rd February 2012 issued by the respondent Nos. 5;
Petitioners No. 2 and 3 were similarly engaged by letters dated
29th May 2014.
b. All the Petitioners were certified competent to pilot vessels inside
Haldia Docks by Marine Department certificates dated 23rd July
2013 for Petitioner 1; 3rd August 2015 for Petitioners 2 and 3.
Petitioners 2 and 3 were examined and found suitable by the Board
of Examiners (August 2014); upgraded as Dock Pilot (on contract)
with increased pay.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
c. The Petitioners were paid a fixed consolidated remuneration and
are
entitled
to
other
service
benefits,
which
included
accommodation, reimbursement, leave, medical facilities and are
entitle to TA/DA as applicable to regular incumbents in the post of
Dock Pilots.
d. Petitioner No. 1's contract was renewed in 2015 and periodically
thereafter, most recently extended to 31st March 2028 vide Memo
dated 25th March 2025. Petitioner No. 2's contract was extended in
stages (2017, 2018, 2020, 2022), finally to 31st March 2028 vide
Memo dated 25th March 2025. Petitioner No. 3's contract was
similarly extended from time to time and finally to 31st March
2028 from 1st April 2025 vide Office Memo dated 25th March
2025. They eventually assumed charge as Berthing Pilots.
e. The Petitioners made applications dated 15th and 27th November
2017 seeking regularisation/permanent employment as Dock Pilot.
f. Despite being appointed as Dock Pilot, the Kolkata Port Trust by
an office Memo No. P & IR/13/4/2020/3035 dated 14 th January,
2020 re-designated the Assistant Manager (Berthing)/Dock Pilot on
contract under MO Division, The Deputy Chairman has approved
the re-designation of Contractual officers engaged in the berthing
service of Haldia Dock Complex as “Berthing Pilot”, keeping all
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
other terms and conditions of their contractual engagement same.
Accordingly, the Petitioners along with others were re-designated
as Berthing Pilots.
g. The Petitioners made further fresh applications dated 5th March
2020 to Respondent No. 4 seeking regularisation against existing
vacancies, and representations dated 8th February 2024 and 23rd
December 2024. Their latest representation was dated 10th
October 2025, following the 2025 advertisement. The petitioners
have come across advertisement No. DR/25/17 dated 24 th
September, 2025, whereby the Shyama Prasad Mookerjee Port,
Kolkata, Haldia Dock Complex published an advertisement for
direct recruitment of apprentice Dock Pilot under Marine Operation
Division, Haldia Dock Complex. Three Vacancies were published.
h. The petitioners are aggrieved that despite repeated extensions of
their contractual engagement up to 2028 and representations
seeking regularisation, their services have not been absorbed
against
existing
permanent
vacancies,
even
though
their
appointments were made under unavoidable circumstances in
compliance
with
the
KoPT
Rules,
2013,
which
mandates
replacement of ad-hoc appointments with regular appointments as
soon as possible. The petitioners challenge the inaction of the
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
authorities in regularising their services and seeking absorption as
Dock Pilots in view of their long, satisfactory and without break
service.
2.
Learned counsels representing the petitioners submitted that all the
petitioners have been working as Dock Pilots since 2012 and 2014
and their service has been extended from time to time and finally
extended till 2028 with satisfaction. There is no adverse report
against any one of them. All the three petitioners had completed their
training period of one year as provided, and accordingly, certificates
dated 23rd July, 2013 and 3rd August, 2015 respectively, were issued
by the then Kolkata Port Trust, Director, Marine Department’s Office,
certifying that they are competent to Pilot Vessels inside the Haldia
Docks in the capacity of Dock Pilot.
3.
It was further submitted that the petitioner No. 1 was recommended
for examination on 22nd May, 2013 and he qualified as Dock Pilot on
23rd July, 2013. Whereas Petitioner Nos. 2 and 3 were recommended
for examination by the Board of Examiners on 23 rd July, 2014, and
their examination was held on 3rd August, 2024, and both were found
suitable to be qualified as Dock Pilots. Accordingly, they were
upgraded as Dock Pilots on a contractual basis, and their pay and
allowances were increased.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
4.
Learned counsel further submitted that several representations were
made by the petitioners from 2017 after completion of initially 5 years
of service as Dock Pilots, against a permanent vacancy in future in
Dock Pilot service by extending age relaxation and priority to the
petitioners, considering their service already rendered as Dock Pilot
with no adverse report; rather, higher officials had appreciated their
performance.
5.
It was further submitted that all the petitioners possessed the
required qualification, i.e., B.Sc. Nautical Science degree at the time
of their initial engagement, which was already more than the
qualifications possessed by those recruited prior to them. They have
rendered uninterrupted services, and such duties were neither
occasional nor project-based, but permanent and integral to the daily
functioning of the respondent authorities, and they are performing
the duty of Dock Pilots appointed against regular vacancy. They also
completed the one-year training and have been working for almost 13
to 14 years. Further, Petitioner Nos. 1 and 3 were awarded
certificates of appreciation for “Outstanding Performance” in 2025
and 2023, respectively. It is not the case that petitioners entered into
the service via back door entry. All the petitioners’ appointments were
pursuant to an advertisement for recruitment of Dock Pilots on an ad
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
hoc basis published for the years 2012 and 2014 on an ad hoc
contractual basis, but they were appointed following the due process
of recruitment. Their appointment was on a sanctioned post.
6.
Learned counsel further submits that during their service tenure, the
authorities have, on two occasions, published advertisements for the
recruitment of three apprentice Dock Pilots to regular posts. The first
advertisement, i.e., DR/25/17 dated 24 th September, 2025 which was
either withdrawn or not given effect to. Subsequently, during the
pendency of the instant application, the second advertisement, being
DR/2026/06 dated 27th February, 2026, was issued.
7.
Learned counsel has further argued that the duties of both ad-hoc
and permanent dock pilots are the same. Their primary duty includes
assisting in safe berthing, unberthing, shifting of vessels within the
dock complex and ensuring navigational safety and efficient traffic
management.
8.
Reliance is placed on the Rules of 2013, which provide that an ad-hoc
appointment may be made in unavoidable circumstances, and such
temporary
appointment
should
be
replaced
with
a
regular
appointment at the earliest. The Petitioners have, however, continued
to work on an ad-hoc basis since 2012 and 2014, till date.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
9.
It was further submitted that the Petitioners have been utilised in the
capacity of regular Dock Pilots while being paid much less. While
regular Dock Pilots were initially paid Rs. 150000/- and now Rs.
200000/-, the Petitioners were initially paid Rs. 35000/- and are now
paid Rs. 83100/-.
10. Counsel for the Petitioners has relied upon the following decisions to
bolster her submissions that the prayer of the petitioners is based on
their legal recruitment, training, and performance for a long period on
sanctioned post: i. Official Liquidator v. Dayanand 1;
ii. Jaggo v. Union of India2;
iii. Bhola Nath v. State of Jharkhand 3;
iv. Dharam Singh v. State of U.P. 4;
v. Pawan Kumar v. Union of India;
vi. Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rambha Devi 5.
11. It was contended that the Petitioners play a pivotal role at the Haldia
Dock Complex, and without them, the entire business would have
collapsed. They work round the clock, which consequently generates
(2008) 10 SCC 1
2024 SCC OnLine 3826
2026 SCC OnLine SC 129
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1735
(2025) 3 SCC 95
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
huge revenue for the Haldia Dock, and thus their services are not
only crucial but unavoidable even for a day. Therefore, they are
entitled to regularization.
12. Mr. Dutta, Sr. Advocate representing the Respondent Nos. 3 to 7
vehemently opposed the prayer of the petitioners and further
submitted that there was an embargo against regular appointment
for 15 years, and when the authorities lifted the embargo, an
advertisement being no. DR/25/17, dated 24 th September, 2025 was
issued for the recruitment of Apprentice Dock Pilots, but none of the
candidates applied for the said posts; as such, it was cancelled, and a
fresh advertisement was issued being DR/2026/06 dated 2 nd
February, 2026.
13. It was submitted on behalf of the Respondents that the petitioners
were never engaged as departmental or regular Dock Pilots. Regular
Dock Pilots are recruited only through a structured selection process
followed by one year's training and a qualifying examination under
the Kolkata Port Trust (Recruitment, Seniority and Promotion)
Regulations, 2013. The petitioners, by contrast, were engaged purely
on contract, to perform the operational duty of pilotage of vessels
within the Haldia Dock Complex, occasioned by an embargo imposed
by the Ministry of Shipping on direct recruitment of departmental
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
officers for over 15 years, which necessitated engaging contractual
officers to keep the Dock functioning.
14. It was further submitted that the petitioners were contractually
engaged only for operational duties; administrative work, which is an
essential responsibility of a regular Dock Pilot, was never assigned to
them. This distinction in role is precisely why contractually engaged
Dock/Berthing Pilots have been given a separate nomenclature and
ranking from departmental Dock Pilots, and their duties, though
overlapping operationally to an extent, are not identical to those of
the departmental cadre.
15. Each engagement expressly provided that persons appointed on
contract acquire no right to any post. It is for a fixed tenure
terminable by one month's notice from either side (subject to an
undertaking to serve at least two years after the one-year training),
and at a fixed consolidated remuneration. The petitioners accepted
these terms of their own volition on each occasion and rendered
service accordingly; it was never obligatory on them to accept or
continue under the contractual offers.
16. It is specifically denied that the petitioners' contractual engagement
was "extended" or "renewed" from time to time. Each engagement, it
is submitted, was a fresh contract offered according to the
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
Respondents' operational requirement and separately accepted by the
petitioners, as borne out by the engagement letters themselves —
which
also
show
that
the
petitioners'
role
progressed
from
"contractual Dock Pilots" to "contractual Berthing Pilots," the current
engagement running from 25.03.2025 to 31.03.2028 and governed by
its own distinct terms and conditions.
17. Learned counsel further submitted that the Kolkata Port Trust
(Recruitment, Seniority and Promotion) Regulations, 2013, including
the ad-hoc appointment provision under Regulation 28, apply only to
departmental/regular
employees
and
have
no
application
to
contractual engagements such as the petitioners. The petitioners'
reliance on these Regulations, and their characterisation of their
engagement
misconceived;
as
being
their
against
service,
a
was
sanctioned
never
vacant
rendered
post,
against
is
any
sanctioned vacant post of Dock Pilot or any specific CPSE pay scale,
but was purely contractual, for a fixed tenure and fixed consolidated
remuneration on agreed terms.
18. It was further contended that since the terms of engagement of
contractual Berthing/Dock Pilots and departmental Dock Pilots are
materially different, no claim of equal treatment can be founded
merely on some overlap in operational function. Whether the
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
petitioners
hold
higher
qualifications
than
their
contractual
predecessors are immaterial; what is relevant is only whether they
meet the eligibility prescribed in the impugned advertisement dated
24.09.2025 (2nd Mate FG Certificate or B.Sc. Nautical Science with
60%
marks),
a
comparison
between
this
qualification
and
departmental eligibility criteria being impermissible given the wholly
distinct terms of engagement.
19. Continuous engagement over several years, occasioned by the
Respondents' operational needs and the petitioners' own willingness
to accept successive contracts, does not confer any right to
regularisation or to have the impugned recruitment held in abeyance.
A license or qualification, it is submitted, cannot be treated as a
precondition to regularisation, and the mere fact that vacancies may
have existed since 2012/2014 does not, without more, entitle the
petitioners to be absorbed against them. Learned counsel has
submitted, that the current advertisement is for recruitment of
apprentice Dock Pilots by a regular, transparent selection process
pursuant to specific approval of the Ministry of Shipping, Port and
Waterways, and does not encroach upon any vested right of the
petitioners.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
20. Finally, it was submitted that the petitioners presently serve as
contractual Berthing Pilots on a consolidated monthly remuneration
of ₹83,100/-, plus operational allowances (₹89,093/- drawn for
September 2025), governed entirely by the terms of their current
contract expiring 31.03.2028, terms which they accepted and by
which they continue to be bound.
21. Counsel for the Respondents has relied upon the following decisions
in support of his arguments: i. Babu Parasu Kaikadi v. Babu6;
ii. Medley Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central
Excise and Customs, Daman7;
iii. Ranjit Kumar Neog v. Union of India 8;
iv.Ram Pravesh Singh v. State of Bihar 9.
22. For the foregoing reasons, it was submitted that the petitioners have
failed to establish any legal right to regularisation, to parity with
departmental
Dock
Pilots,
or
to
interdict
the
impugned
advertisement, and the writ petition is accordingly liable to be
dismissed with exemplary costs.
(2004) 1 SCC 681
(2011) 2 SCC 601
Case no. (C)/4595/2020 dated 18th March, 2025
(2006) 8 SCC 381
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
23. Learned counsel for the Union of India submitted in a similar fashion
as counsels for respondent nos. 3 to 7, and finally supported the
submission of the learned senior counsel Mr. Kishore Dutta.
24. Having heard the counsels for the parties and having gone through
the record, the issue that has come for determination before this
Court
is
whether
the
petitioners,
admittedly
engaged
on
a
contractual/ ad-hoc basis as Dock Pilots through the advertisement
and following recruitment process under the rules on the vacant
vacancy of Dock Pilot, are entitled to regularisation?
25. It is an admitted fact that the petitioners' initial engagement in 2012
and 2014 was contractual in nature, as described in the engagement
letters themselves as an ad-hoc arrangement for a period of three
years
(inclusive
of
a
one-year
training
period),
terminable
automatically on expiry, subject to renewal by a fresh contract at the
option of the Kolkata Port Trust, and further terminable by either side
on one month's notice.
26. This position is reiterated, rather than disputed, in the Affidavit-inOpposition filed on behalf of Respondent Nos. 3 to 7. It explains that
the petitioners' ad hoc engagement was necessitated by an embargo
of approximately 15 years imposed by the Ministry of Shipping,
Government of India, on the direct recruitment of departmental
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
officers and staff. This further indicates that the petitioners were
engaged as a stop-gap arrangement to perform the operational duties
of pilotage until such embargo was lifted.
27. It is significant that, notwithstanding the length and continuity of
their service, a facet strongly emphasized by the petitioners, the case
as originally pleaded in the writ petition contains no averment that
the petitioners were, at any point, appointed against a sanctioned or
existing vacancy of Dock Pilot. The assertion to that effect appears to
have been introduced for the first time in paragraph 26 of the
Affidavit-in-Reply, where it is claimed that the petitioners were
"continuously
discharging
their
duties
being
operational
and
administrative jobs similar to that of the Dock Pilots appointed as
against sanctioned post." This averment, however, is unsupported by
any contemporaneous record, service book entry, sanction order, or
otherwise, placed before this Court, and therefore cannot be accepted
as displacing the admitted contractual character of the engagement
borne out by the petitioners' own annexures.
28. The respondents have also drawn a distinction, which this Court
finds relevant, between the mode of selection, training, and functions
of regular/departmental Dock Pilots on the one hand, and the
petitioners on the other. Regular Dock Pilots are appointed strictly in
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
terms of the Kolkata Port Trust Employees' (Recruitment, Seniority
and Promotion) Regulations, 2013, through a structured process of
selection, a year of training as trainee/apprentice, a qualifying
examination, and only thereafter deployed for operational pilotage
duty,
and
administrative
are
additionally
functions
apart
required
from
to
discharge
operational
certain
duties.
The
petitioners, by contrast, were engaged to discharge purely operational
duties, a fact which, as pointed out by the respondents, finds an echo
in the petitioners' own representation dated 5th March 2020.
29. While the petitioners contend that the certificate/licence issued to
them by the Director, Marine Department, is identical to that issued
to regular Dock Pilots and therefore establishes parity of function,
this Court is of the view that possession of an operating licence, i.e., a
professional/technical competency certification necessary for anyone
piloting vessels within the dock, whether engaged on contract or
otherwise, cannot, by itself, be equated with parity of service
conditions, mode of recruitment, or entitlement to the post.
30. The law on regularisation of temporary, ad-hoc, or contractual
employees has been authoritatively laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, and it is necessary to advert to the binding
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
precedents cited in the instant case, particularly given that they point
in different directions and require reconciliation.
31. The petitioners have placed reliance upon Bhola Nath v. State of
Jharkhand
&
Ors.
(Supra),
in
support
of
their
claim
for
regularisation. The respondents, however, submit that this case is
factually distinguishable, since the petitioners therein were appointed
against vacant and sanctioned posts, and were, upon joining,
subjected to transfer, posting, and other service incidents ordinarily
applicable to regular employees, none of which features, the
respondents contend, are present in the case at hand.
32. The respondents further submit that Bhola Nath (Supra), being a
two-Judge decision, failed to notice the earlier three-Judge decision
in Dayanand (Supra), and ought therefore to be treated as rendered
per incuriam, relying in this regard upon Babu Parasu Kaikadi
(Supra) and Medley Pharmaceuticals (Supra) at paragraph 43 on
the doctrine of per incuriam, and upon Bajaj Allianz General
Insurance Co. Ltd. (Supra) at paragraphs 161 and 165, on the
scope of that doctrine.
33. There is considerable force in the respondents' submission on this
score. It is a well-settled principle of judicial discipline that a decision
of a smaller Bench must yield to, and cannot depart from, the ratio of
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
a larger Bench without appropriate reference; and a decision
rendered in ignorance of a binding precedent of a larger or coordinate
Bench is liable to be treated as per incuriam to that extent.
Dayanand (Supra), being a three-Judge Bench decision, considered,
as noticed at paragraphs 2, 3(i), 3(iii), 4, 5, 49, 50 and 116 thereof,
the constitutional dimension of regularisation and absorption of
contractual/ad-hoc employees through the lens of Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution and the rule-making power under the proviso to
Article 309, and held that a direction for absorption of employees not
appointed in accordance with the prescribed procedure would be
detrimental to public interest, both by compelling the executive to
abandon a considered policy decision and by resulting in a virtual
abrogation of statutory recruitment rules. If, as the respondents
submit, Bhola Nath (Supra) did not have the benefit of considering
Dayanand (Supra) on this very issue of regularisation/absorption of
contractual employees, the persuasive value of Bhola Nath (Supra)
before this Court stands correspondingly diminished. Consequently,
there should be an inclination to proceed on the touchstone of the
principles enunciated in Dayanand (Supra).
34. Dayanand (Supra), at paragraph 113, has in turn relied upon Ram
Pravesh
Singh
(Supra),
for
the
proposition
that
legitimate
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
expectation is not, in itself, a legal right. However, mere expectation
of a benefit, relief, or remedy that may ordinarily flow from a promise
or an established practice, does not, without more, translate into an
enforceable right to regularisation, more particularly in the case of
contractual engagements. This principle applies with equal force to
the facts at hand, where the petitioners' engagement letters
themselves recorded, in specific terms, the ad-hoc and time-bound
character of the appointment, coupled with an express reservation to
the Kolkata Port Trust of the right to enter into a fresh contract, as
opposed to an automatic extension or renewal on expiry of each term.
35. There is also merit in the distinction drawn by the respondents
between the present case and the decisions of Jaggo v. Union of
India (Supra) and Ranjit Kumar Neog v. Union of India (Supra),
relied upon by the petitioners, since the initial engagement of the
employees in those cases was on a part-time, ad-hoc basis and not
contractual in nature, which is a material distinction from the case in
hand, where the petitioners' own engagement letters describe their
appointment as "Contractual Agreement." Similarly, Dharam Singh
v. State of U.P. (Supra), is distinguishable on facts, the controversy
therein having centred upon non-sanctioning of Group C and Group
D ministerial/support posts by the State Government, a context
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
materially different both in the nature of the duties performed and in
the issue that fell for consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, as opposed to the question of absorption in posts of a more
specialised/technical character, as considered in Dayanand (Supra).
36. Applying the above principles, it is found that the petitioners' claim
for regularisation cannot rest merely on the length or continuity of
their contractual engagement. It is by now well established that mere
prolonged or continuous service, howsoever long, does not by itself
ripen into a right to permanence or substantive status; regularisation
cannot be treated as an independent mode of appointment or
recruitment de hors the prescribed Recruitment Rules, and its office
is confined to the condonation of procedural irregularities in an
appointment otherwise validly made, not to the creation of a right
where none otherwise exists under the Rules governing recruitment.
37. The petitioners' engagement, on the record as it stands, was not
made pursuant to, or against, any sanctioned vacancy of Dock Pilots.
It was occasioned by a distinct and time-bound administrative
necessity, and was consistently treated, extended, and re-designated
(culminating in re-designation as "Berthing Pilot", and continuation
in that capacity thereafter) as a contractual arrangement, and not as
an appointment against the regular cadre strength of Dock Pilots.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
38. In these circumstances, the parity sought to be drawn by the
petitioners with regular Dock Pilots on the strength of the identity of
the pilotage licence issued by the Marine Department, and the nature
of operational duties performed does not suffice to establish an
entitlement to regularisation, particularly where the very Recruitment
Regulations of 2013 relied upon by both sides contemplate a
structured process of direct recruitment, examination, and training
for entry into the regular cadre, a process distinct from, and not
fulfilled by, the petitioners' mode of ad-hoc contractual engagement.
39. In light of the above discussion, this writ petition being WPA 24866
of 2025 is, thus, dismissed without any order as to costs. Connected
applications, if any, stand disposed of.
40. However, relying on the aforesaid facts, i.e., the tenure of the
petitioners’
consistent
service,
training,
their
qualification,
performance, appreciation received by them from the authorities and
age, this Court is of the view that, even though they may not be
entitled to regularization straight away, they may be considered for
the selection process. Therefore, on humanitarian grounds, the
Respondent authorities are directed to consider the Petitioners for the
selection process for regular posts for Dock Pilots, as and when a
vacancy for the same arises in accordance with law.
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
41. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
42. All parties shall act on a server copy of this judgment uploaded from
the official website of High Court at Calcutta.
43. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, is to
be given to the parties on priority basis on compliance of all legal
formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
(P.A)
WPA No. 24866 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review