Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
&
# !
#
"$
!
' &
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"#"$%$
$
!
!"#"$%$
!"#"$ &
"
(
-2-
&
'
!"#"$%$
"
'
!"#"$%$
(
!"#"$%$
'
$$
$$(
'
'
'
'
'
)
!
'
%# %& $%$
$
)
!
'
* +
,
-
%$
$ $%$&
-3-
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 123/3/452; 022</5= 3.2
64774>/5= ;27/260
!
#
"
$ !
%
&
"
"
'
$
4>52;
3 /0 ? @?02 46 3.2 123/3/452; 3.?3 .2 /0 3.2
3.2
?=;/@A73A;?7
C2?0A;/5=
%$
?@;20
C2?0A;/5= %
?@;2
/77?=2
A;AC/3<?7
41?7
;/
/5
=A53?0 ?58
A;B2:
4$ %
A;B2:
4 &(
=A53?0 943. 0/3A?328 ?3
?52<?7
?7A<
?;211?
7?58
3 /0 ./0 6A;3.2; @453253/45 3.?3
?88?; ?58 ./0 ?004@/?320 >2;2
/532;62;/5= >/3. 3.2 12?@26A7 1400200/45 ?58 25D4:C253 46
3.2 123/3/452; 4B2; 3.2 1;412;3/20 /5 EA203/45
.2;264;2
3.2 123/3/452; >?0 @4C127728 34 6/72 ? 0A/3 64; 3.2 ;27/26 46
12;123A?7 /5DA5@3/45 /5
12;0450 / 2
;/
41?7
?;211?
"# $%
?=?/503 02B2;?7
?88?; ?58 43.2;0
.2
-4-
0?/8
0A/3
@?C2
$" %" $% $
82@;228
9:
DA8=C253
8?328
3 /0 ./0 6A;3.2; @453253/45 3.?3 8201/32 3.2
82@;22 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3
3.2 0?/8 12;0450 >.4 ?;2
826258?530 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 >2;2 /532;62;/5= >/3. 3.2
12?@26A7 1400200/45 ?58 25D4:C253 46 3.2 1;412;3: 46 3.2
123/3/452;
5 B/2> 46 3.2 /532;62;25@2 C?82 9: 3.2
826258?530 3.2;2/5 >/3. 3.2 123/3/452;+0 1400200/45 4B2;
3.2 1;412;3: /5 EA203/45
3.2 123/3/452; ?11;4?@.28 3.2
00/03?53
?8?=/;/ A582; 3.2
?58
4CC/00/452;
276?;2 46
?;2530 ?58
25/4;
/3/F250
?/5325?5@2
@3 $%%
=/B2 1;432@3/45 34 ./C ?58 64; ;2@4B2;: 46 ./0 1;412;3: 9:
;2C4B/5= 32C14;?;: 25@;4?@.C2530 C?82 9:
?58 ./0 ?004@/?320 46
?58 .2; ?004@/?320 46
?72927?=A58/
&
00/03?53
?52<?7
/77?=2 ?58
27.2;/
;?C ?5@.?:?3
C3
;/
.?58?CC?
/77?=2 943. 6?77/5= A582;
A;AC/3<?7 ?7A<
./0 92/5= 3.2 03?32 46 ?66?/;0 ;201458253
4CC/00/452;
41?7
?774>28
3.2
4$
?117/@?3/45
-5-
;21;20253?3/45
C?82
9:
3.2
123/3/452;
8/;2@328
3.2
826258?530 /5 3.2 0A/3 34 ;2C4B2 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 ?58
4;82;28 3.2
4C2
21?;3C253 34 1;4B/82 ?11;41;/?32
1;432@3/45 34 ./C /5 B/2> 46 3.2 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22
1?0028 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3
3 /0 ?704 @45325828 9: 3.2
72?;528 @4A5027 3.?3 3.2
?5@.?:?3.
?5@.?:?3. .?0 ?704 ;214;328 34
?72927?=A58/
;201458253
;?C
?.0/78?; 3.?3
2B2741C253
.?58?11? ?58 43.2;0
.?B2 543 ;2C4B28 3.2 /772=?7 03;A@3A;2
123/3/452; .?0 ?11;4?@.28 3./0
66/@2;
25@2
3.2
4A;3 @453258/5= 3.?3
8201/32 3.2 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22 1?0028 9: 3.2
/B/7
4A;3
/5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 ?=?/503 3.2 0?/8 12;0450 ?58 3.2 4;82;0
1?0028 9: 3.2
00/03?53
4CC/00/452; 54 03210 ?;2 3?<25
34 ;2C4B2 3.2 /772=?7 25@;4?@.C253 ?58 03;A@3A;2 1A3 A1
9: 3.2 0?/8 12;0450
"
3 /0 6A;3.2; @45325828 9: 3.2 72?;528 @4A5027
64; 3.2 123/3/452; 3.?3 ?=?/5 45 $
;2EA20328 ;201458253
$%$& 3.2 123/3/452;
?0 >277 ?0 ;201458253
/C172C253 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2
00/03?53
4 ( 34
4CC/00/452; ?58
-6-
3?<2 ?11;41;/?32 ?@3/45
8/;2@328 ;201458253
?028 45 >./@. ;201458253
4 ( 34 3?<2 ?11;41;/?32 ?@3/45 ?0 12;
3.2 ;A720 ;27:/5= A145 3.2 DA8=C253 1?0028 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7
0A/3
8201/32 >./@. 54 @45@;232 ?@3/45 .?0 9225 3?<25
25@2 3.2 123/3/452; .?0 ?11;4?@.28 3./0
4A;3 8A2 34 3.2
/5?@3/45 46 3.2 ;2014582530 ?58 545!@450/82;?3/45 46 ./0
;21;20253?3/45
(
2?;528
;21;20253/5= 3.2
88/3/45?7
8B4@?32
3?32 @4532580 3.?3 8201/32 1?00/5= 46
3.2 4;82; 9: ;201458253
552GA;2!
4B2;5C253
4$
?58 3.2;2?632;
/00A28 34 ;201458253
00/03?53
4CC/00/452; ?3
3.2 0A902EA253 8/;2@3/45
4 ( 34 /C172C253 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2
4;/=/5?7 0A/3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2
00/03?53
4CC/00/452; 54
?@3/45 /0 3?<25 64; 3.2 ;2?045 3.?3 3.2 123/3/452; .?0 34
?11;4?@. 3.2
/B/7
4A;3 ?58 6/72 2G2@A3/45 123/3/45 ?58 543
9: >?: 46 ? >;/3 ?58 04 ?704 3.2
?5@.?:?3
2B2741C253
66/@2; .?0 543 9225 C?82 ? 1?;3: 34 3./0 123/3/45
.2;264;2 3./0 123/3/45 /0 543 0A03?/5?972
-7-
.?B2 .2?;8 3.2 72?;528 @4A5027 64; 3.2
123/3/452; ?58 72?;528
88/3/45?7
4B2;5C253
8B4@?32 64;
3.2 ;201458253! 3?32
#
3 /0 543 /5 8/01A32 3.?3 3.2 123/3/452; /5/3/?328
0A/3 /5
"# $%
>./@. @?C2 34 92 82@;228 45
$" %" $% $ ?=?/503 3.2 826258?530
3 /0 ?704 543 /5
8/01A32 3.?3 /5 B/2> 46 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 ?58 8/04928/25@2
46 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2 @/B/7
4A;3
;201458253
4CC/00/452; 34 3?<2 ?@3/45
4$
00/03?53
3.2 123/3/452; C4B28
?=?/503 3.2 826?A73/5= 1?;3: 3.2 826258?530 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7
0A/3 ?58 ?5 4;82; ?704 @?C2 34 92 1?0028 9: ;201458253
4$
9:
=/B/5=
?11;41;/?32
8/;2@3/450
3.2
0?/8
826258?530 3.2;2/5 >.4 .?8 25@;4?@.28 ?58 ?704 34 3.2
47/@2
21?;3C253 34 /5/3/?32 ?11;41;/?32 ?@3/45
4>2B2;
54 0A@. ?@3/45 /0 3?<25 9: 3.2 ;201458253! 47/@2 4; 3.2
@45@2;528 ?A3.4;/3/20 /5@7A8/5= 3.2 72332; 46 3.2
>./@.
/0 /00A28 64; ;2C4B?7 46 3.2 25@;4?@.C253 9: 3.2 0?/8
12;0450 >.2;2 3.2 @41: /0 ?704 =/B25 34 3.2
5012@34; ?58 3.2
?.0/78?;
47/@2
A9
201/32 >./@. 54 ?@3/45 /0
-8-
3?<25 9: ;201458253
?58 (
.?0 ;/=.37: ?11;4?@.28 3./0
H
3.2
4A;3
3 3./0 14/53 46 3/C2 /3 /0 ;272B?53 34 ;262; 34
/;@A7?; 46 3.2
%
25@2 3.2 123/3/452;
4B2;5C253 46
?;5?3?<? 8?328
$%$$ >./@. ;2?80 ?0 A582;
# ( ) ( *+ !+
,
-
.
%
"
/
/
3 435( 4
/
6 7
"
.
"
%
+3
.
,
333 3 . " # ;< +
"
.
"
=
/
"
""
)
"
.
9 : "
,
-
!
"
-9-
.
"
"
"
"
>
"
"
"
=
"
"
/
.
&
.
"
"
"
?
""
"
"
.
"
"
-
"
"
!
/
"
"
.
"
"
;
"
"
"" "
""
@.
"
"
""
".
"
+
"
< &
A
"/
""
"
- 10 -
"
"
"" ""
B &
.
.
"
""
/
"
.
"
""
.
.
$
. ".
+
""
""
C
&
""
""
"
"
"
/
D
"
.
"
=
)
"
+
"
.
+
"
+
-
"
""
.
.
"
""
,
C$;E
.
""
.
(
&
"
"
""
"
E&
4 " 0
"
- 11 -
/
/
: "
.
.
,
&
"
# FA 4
>
<
""
/
"
: "
-
""
4 ,&1+ !C+
<
C
/
.
+ /
F
- 0 9
: " ,
+A
D
""
"
"
%
F
'
,
A/827/52
-
4 $
"
.
0 9
G
/
46 3.2 0?/8
: "
/;@A7?; C?<20 /3
@72?; 3.?3 45@2 ?5 4;82; /0 1?0028 9: 3.2
4A;3 ?58
;2?@.20 6/5?7/3: 3.2 ?A3.4;/3/20 @45@2;528 ?;2 94A58 34
/C172C253 3.2 4;82; /5 72332; ?58 01/;/3 >./@. .?0 543 9225
8452 /5 3.2 1;20253 @?02
3 /0 ?704 543 3.2 @?02 46 3.2
;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 4; 3.2 1;/B?32 1?;3/20 3.?3 3.2:
.?B2 @.?7725=28 3.2 0?/8 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22 1?0028 9:
3.2 3;/?7
4A;3
5 3.2 1;20253 @?02
/3 /0 0225 3.?3 /5
@453/5A?3/45 46 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.2 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22 46
3.2 3;/?7
4A;3
3.2 123/3/452; ?11;4?@.28 3.2
4CC/00/452; /5B4</5= 3.2 1;4B/0/450 46 3.2
?58
276?;2 46
?;2530 ?58
25/4;
/3/F250
00/03?53
?/5325?5@2
@3 $%%
- 12 -
1;432@3 ./C0276 ?58 ./0 1;412;3: 6;4C 3.2 25@;4?@.C253
9: 3.2 826258?530 /5 3.2 0A/3
?8 3.2 ;201458253
?A3.4;/3/20 @4C17/28 >/3. 3.2 8/;2@3/450 /00A28 9: 3.2
4A;3
?58
3.?3
3.2
00/03?53
4CC/00/452;
EA203/45 46 25@;4?@.C253 >4A78 543 .?B2 ?;/025
3.2;2
>?0
25@;4?@.C253
25@;4?@.C253
.?8
3.2:
/B/7
3.2
B25 /6
;2C4B28
3.2
3.2 EA203/45 46 123/3/452; /5B4</5= >;/3
DA;/08/@3/45 >4A78 543 ?;/02
.?0 9225 /00A28 9: 3.2
.2
/;@A7?; 8?328
4B2;5C253 46
%
$%$$
?;5?3?<? 1;2@/027:
64; 3.2 ;2?045 3.?3 3/C27: ?@3/45 9: 3.2 ;201458253
?A3.4;/3/20
>/77
1;2B253
6A;3.2;
7/3/=?3/45
.?;80./1
/5@45B25/25@2 ?58 8;/B/5= 3.2 0A@@2006A7 1?;3: 34 6/72 ?
@4532C13 123/3/45
4>2B2; /5 B/2> 46 3.2 6?@3 3.?3 3.2
;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 .?B2 543 ?@328 /5 ? 3/C27: C?552;
72?8/5= 34 3.2 A552@200?;: .?;?00C253 ?58 3.2 ?772=28
8?C?=2 3.?3 /0 @?A028 34 3.2 123/3/452;
3.2 0?C2 >/77
.?B2 34 92 ?8.2;28 34 /5 03;/@3 4928/25@2 9: 3.2
;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20
9: 3.2 72?;528
5 3.2 1;20253 @?02 /3 /0 0A9C/3328
88/3/45?7
4B2;5C253
8B4@?32 3.?3 .2
- 13 -
.?0 54 /503;A@3/450 ?0 34 >.23.2; 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.2
4A;3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2
@4C17/28
00/03?53
4CC/00/452; .?B2 9225
8201/32 3.2 72332; /00A28 9: 3.2
4CC/00/452; ?58 3.2 ?5@.?:?3
2B2741C253
00/03?53
66/@2;
3 /0 ?704 ;272B?53 34 C253/45 .2;2 3.?3
/;@A7?; 8?328
%
/B/7
$%$$ /00A28 9: 3.2
3.2
4B2;5C253 46
?;5?3?<? 82?70 >/3. 3.2 @4502EA25@20 46 543 ?8.2;/5= 34
3.2 0?/8
/;@A7?; 9: @4502EA253/?7 1;4@228/5=0 ?=?/503 3.2
@45@2;528 466/@2;0 /5@7A8/5= 3.2 ;2014582530 .2;2/5 64; 543
492:/5= 3.2 4;82;0 ?58 1;4B/8/5= 52@200?;: ;27/26 34 3.2
123/3/452; /5 B/2> 46 3.2 DA8=C253 ?58 82@;22 1?0028 9:
3.2
/B/7
4A;3
0 @4532C17?328 A582;
A/827/52
4(
8/0@/17/5?;: 1;4@228/5=0 ?;2 34 92 /5/3/?328 ?=?/503 3.2
2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4 52=72@3 34 @4C17: >/3. 3.2 4;82;0 46
3.2
4A;3
.?B/5=
5 3.2 1;20253 @?02 45 .?58 8201/32 3.2 4;82;0
1?0028
9:
;201458253
4$
00/03?53
4CC/00/452; 34 1;4B/82 1;432@3/45 ?58 34 ;2C4B2 3.2
25@;4?@.C253 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 4;82; 46 3.2
2B2741C253
66/@2; 34 3.2 DA;/08/@3/45?7
47/@2
?5@.?:?3
84 543
- 14 -
6/58 ?5: @4C17/?5@2 4; ;2C4B?7 46 3.2 25@;4?@.C253
582; 3.2 @/;@AC03?5@20
%
$%$$ 3./0
2@;23?;:
/5 B/2> 46 3.2
/;@A7?; 8?328
4A;3 822C0 /3 6/3 34 8/;2@3 3.2
3.2
@45@2;528
21?;3C253
;/5@/1?7
/5/3/?32
8/0@/17/5?;: 1;4@228/5=0 ?=?/503 3.2 2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4
.?B2 52=72@328 34 @4C17: >/3. 3.2 4;82;0 46 3.2
?58 ?704 64774>
A/827/52
/6 64A58 =A/73: 34 64774>
46 3.2 0?/8
A/827/52
4A;30
/;@A7?; 04 ?704
4 # 46 3.2 0?/8
/;@A7?;
3 /0 ?704 4125 34 3.2 123/3/452; 34 /5/3/?32 @4532C13
1;4@228/5=0 ?=?/503 3.2 826258?530 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 >.4
?;2 ?772=28 34 .?B2 25@;4?@.28 ./0 1;412;3: ?0 12; 3.2
DA8=C253 /5 3.2 4;/=/5?7 0A/3 /5
"# $%
.2 3>4
1;4@200 46 @4532C13 ?=?/503 3.2 @4532C54;0 ?58 B/47?3/45
46 3.2 4;82;0 9: 3.2 ;201458253 ?A3.4;/3/20 @4A78 ;A5
1?;?77277:
.2 0?C2 >4A78 .?B2 34 92 82@/828 ?632;
@458A@3/5= ? 1;412; 25EA/;: 943. /5 3.2 @4532C13 123/3/45
?0 >277 ?0 /5 3.2 25EA/;: 1;4@228/5=0 9: 1;4B/8/5=
;2?045?972 4114;3A5/3: 34 ?77 @45@2;528 1?;3/20
$
582; 3.2 @/;@AC03?5@20
1?00 3.2 64774>/5=
- 15 -
/
.2 123/3/45 /0 8/014028 46
//
.2
123/3/452;
/0
?3
7/92;3:
6/72
?
@4532C13 123/3/45 ?=?/503 3.2 826258?530
>.4 .?B2 25@;4?@.28 ?58 B/47?328 3.2
4;82;0 46 3.2 3;/?7
///
2@4587:
3.2
4A;3
;/5@/1?7
2@;23?;: 46 3.2
@45@2;528
21?;3C253
?11;41;/?32
8/0@/17/5?;:
0.?77
/5/3/?32
1;4@228/5=0
?=?/503 3.2 2;;/5= 466/@2;0 >.4 .?B2 6?/728
?58 52=72@328 34 @4C17: >/3. 3.2 4;82;0 46
3.2
/B/7
4;82;0
4A;3 ?58 3.?3 46 3.2 0A902EA253
1?0028
4CC/00/452;
/B
9:
3.2
00/03?53
?8=/;/
;214;3 34 3./0 2662@3 0.?77 92 6/728 9264;2
3./0
4A;3 >/3./5 3>4 C453.0 6;4C 3.2 8?32
46 ;2@2/13 46 @2;3/6/28 @41: 46 3./0 4;82;
'
&
#
!)*
!
#
"
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review