Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:986-DB
Serial No. 01
Supplementary I List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 42 of 2024
Date of CAV
: 29.10.2024
Date of pronouncement: 07.11.2024
Shri. Soidur Rahman Mollah
......Appellant
- Versus 1.
The State of Meghalaya, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Home (Police)
Department, Meghalaya, Shillong.
2.
The Director General of Police, Meghalaya, Shillong.
3.
The Additional Director General of Police, Meghalaya, Shillong.
4.
The Inspector General of Police, Meghalaya, Shillong.
5.
The Superintendent of Police, Resubelpara, District North Garo
Hills, Meghalaya.
6.
The Accountant General (A&E), Meghalaya, Shillong.
......Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
:
For the Respondents :
i)
Mr. S.K. Hassan, Adv.
Ms. M. Rahman, Adv.
Mrs. N.G. Shylla, Sr. GA with
Ms. I. Lyngwa, GA [For R 1-5]
Ms. E. B. Passah, Adv. vice
Mr. K. Kharmawphalng, Adv. [For R 6]
Whether approved for
Yes
2024:MLHC:986-DB
reporting in Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
No
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
Soidur Rahman Mollah, the appellant-writ petitioner was a
motor mechanic in the office of the Superintendent of Police,
Resubelpara, District North Garo Hills, Meghalaya. He was appointed
in service on 3rd March, 1988. On the basis of his year of birth recorded
as 1964 in the verification roll of the concerned department (no date or
month of birth is on record), he was superannuated after 30th June, 2022,
at the recorded age of 58 years. He claims that his date of birth is 24 th
January, 1967, also entered in the records, that he ought to retire on 31 st
January, 2025 and that he has been wrongfully discharged from service.
He preferred the instant writ petition in this Court [WP(C) No.
297 of 2023 : Shri Soidur Rahman Mollah vs. State of Meghalaya
and others].
The learned single judge hearing the writ thoroughly disbelieved
him, dismissed his claim and rejected the writ petition.
Hence, this appeal.
2024:MLHC:986-DB
It is quite common for an employee particularly a government
employee, just before retirement, to claim that his actual age is less than
that recorded in the records of the employer, to ask for rectification of
the records so as to postpone his imminent retirement. The courts have
frowned upon this kind of a litigant. It has viewed the claim to an earlier
date of birth with suspicion and thought this kind of an employee to be
an opportunist and an unscrupulous person.
On most occasions such claims are not entertained. In few select
cases where the employer was manifestly at fault in recording the age of
the employee and there was good reason why the employee could not
approach the court at an earlier point of time specified by the rules to
seek age rectification, the courts have allowed the claim for age
revision.
These legal principles would be evident from the authorities cited
by Mrs. N.G. Shylla, learned Sr. GA for the respondents, mentioned
below.
In State of Madhya Pradesh and others vs. Premlal Shrivas:
(2011) 9 SCC 664 the court frowned upon the correction of the date of
birth of a government employee on the eve of his retirement,
maintaining that correction of the date of birth could only be effected
2024:MLHC:986-DB
within the time stipulated by the rules and should not be allowed
thereafter, unless there was negligence or a manifestly incorrect entry.
See also Karnataka Rural Infrastructure Development Limited vs.
T.P. Nataraja and others: (2021) 12 SCC 27 and Secretary and
Commissioner, Home Department and others vs. R. Kirubakaran:
(1994) Supp(1) SCC 155.
The same principle was applied in Bharat Coking Coal Limited
and others vs. Shyam Kishore Singh: (2020) 3 SCC 411 with the
additional observation that having accepted an entry throughout his
tenure, an employee could not be allowed to change it at the very end of
it.
On the other hand when the date of birth as claimed by the
employee is supportable from the records but the employer thinks that
such recording is erroneous or ignores it and proposes to consider the
later recorded date of birth as correct, the court has not allowed such
exercise to be done without hearing the employee.
In Shankar Lal vs. Hindustan Copper Limited and others:
(2022) 6 SCC 211, the voluntary retirement benefits under the
Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS) of Hindustan Copper Limited
were reduced by the act of the employer unilaterally raising the date of
2024:MLHC:986-DB
birth of the employee. The employee’s stand was that his date of birth
was 21st September, 1949 and this was recorded in the service book of
the employer when he joined service in 1971. The case of the employee
was at the time of his retirement, he came to know that his date of birth
was raised to 21st September 1945. The employer took the stand that its
recording of the date of birth as 21 st September, 1949 was an act by
mistake. Aniruddha Bose, J. delivering the judgment of the Supreme
Court remarked as follows:
“23. The employer has taken a stand that the date of birth
recorded of the appellant in the service book was an act by
mistake. This is a weak explanation in our opinion. Several
subsequent steps were taken by the employer in relation to the
appellant’s employment on the basis of the entry in his service
book. The employer are the custodian of these records. They
acted all along on the basis of the service entries till the appellant
took VRS. It has been pleaded by the appellant that at the time of
his appointment, the office of the respondent company entered in
all their records his date of birth as 21-9-1949. In the light of
these facts, we are not inclined to accept the version of the
employer that service book recordal was a mistake. The
employer, a public sector unit in this case, was expected to act
with a certain element of responsibility in maintaining the service
records of their workmen and ensure that there is uniformity in
particulars concerning individual employees. There is no
explanation as to how this mistake occurred and how pay slips
continued to be issued carrying the mistaken date of birth for such
a long time. The High Court in our view ought not to have had
accepted “mistake” as the cause for different entries in different
documents.
27. We find the action of the employer lacking in authority of law
in this case on two counts. First, it fails for not adhering to the
2024:MLHC:986-DB
principles of natural justice. The decision not to follow the
service book recordal was taken without giving an opportunity of
hearing to the appellant. The opportunity of hearing of the
appellant also accrued because the employer themselves had
proceeded on the basis that the later date i.e. 21-9-1949 was the
birthdate of the appellant and this was a long established position.
Moreover, since in the own records of the employer two date
were shown, under normal circumstances it would have been
incumbent on their part to undertake an exercise on application of
mind to determine in which of these two records the mistake had
crept in. That process would also have had to involve
participation of the appellant, which would have been compatible
with the principles of natural justice.
29. The very reasoning on which an employee is not permitted to
raise age-correction plea at the fag end of his service to extend his
tenure should also apply to the employer as well. It is the
employer here who had proceeded on the basis of age of the
appellant reflected in his service book during the latter’s service
tenure and they ought not to be permitted to fall back on the Form
B which would curtail the VRS benefit of the appellant.”
Some points arise in this appeal, which do not usually arise in
most cases.
The unusual element in this case is that the appellant-writ
petitioner was appointed in service on 3rd March, 1988. In the
verification roll which was filled up by him and thereafter approved and
entered in the records of the department, his year of birth was stated to
be 1964. The date and month were not stated.
Some six days after his joining, the school which the appellant
attended till class VII, on 9th March, 1988, issued a certificate stating
2024:MLHC:986-DB
that according to the records of the school, his date of birth was 24 th
January, 1967. However, learned counsel for the respondents tells us
that at some point of time not known to the authorities, the date of birth,
24th January, 1967 was entered in the records. How it was entered and
who entered it is not known. This latter date of birth was not approved
by the department. However, learned counsel for the appellant-writ
petitioner shows us identity cards at pages 40 and 43 of the stay petition
said to be issued by the Meghalaya Police, where his date of birth is
recorded as 24th January, 1967. In the notice for superannuation pension
dated 10th May, 2022, at page 45 of the appeal against Serial 6, his date
of birth is shown as 1964 in brackets and 24 th January, 1967 outside the
brackets. In the statement of accounts of the Principal Accountant
General, for the year ending 31st March, 2022 at page 52 of the petition,
his date of birth is shown as 24 th January, 1967. Therefore, according to
the verification roll which is an admission by the appellant-writ
petitioner, his date of birth is 1964 whereas according to other records
of the department, it is 24th January, 1967.
Learned counsel for the respondents very rightly pointed out that
it was quite surprising and suspicious that the school certificate
certifying the date of birth was issued six days after the appellant/writ
2024:MLHC:986-DB
petitioner’s joining service and it was equally surprising and suspicious
that it was accepted by the department. Furthermore, even when the date
of birth was recorded as 1964, no steps were taken by the appellant-writ
petitioner till he nearly reached the age of retirement for recording 24 th
January, 1967 as the date of birth.
The appellant-writ petitioner has withdrawn all the retirement
benefits after retirement.
The question arises when in so many records, the date of birth of
the appellant/writ petitioner is shown as 24th January, 1967, on what
basis the employer police department proceed to issue the
superannuation notice declaring his year of birth as 1964.
In fact, the Superintendent of Police, North Garo Hills,
Resubelpara admitted in a communication dated 19th April, 2022 that
initially, the date of birth recorded in the records was 1964, thereafter
24th January, 1967 “is found to have entered in his Service Sheet (Vol-I)
as “(1964) 24th January, 1967”. However, he added that “no Official
order of the Competent Authority could be seen in his Service
Records/Service Book for changing his Date of Birth from 1964 to 24 th
January, 1967.”
We declare the following principles.
2024:MLHC:986-DB
A government employee may seek age rectification if it is
permitted by the rules of employment and within the time provided for
that purpose. Where a government employee, on the eve of retirement
proposes to seek age correction, the effect of which would be to
postpone the date of retirement it should normally not be allowed unless
some manifest error in the record or culpable negligence in its
preparation is evident. In these exceptional cases, the court might
venture to get the age of the employee reassessed. However, if as in this
case there are two entries against the date of birth of a government
employee in the records, the latter one claimed by the employee to be
the correct date and the earlier one by the employer, the employer
should not take any unilateral decision to decide on the correct date of
birth of an employee which is to be entered in the records. Before
making a determination of the date of birth, an employee must be given
a reasonable opportunity of hearing and upon hearing, and considering
the case of the employee reasonably, should a decision be taken in this
regard. This kind of a decision can be taken at any time during the
tenure of the employee, even if it is at the “fag end” of his tenure.
2024:MLHC:986-DB
That was not done in this case and the appellant-writ petitioner
made to retire after 30th June, 2022, considering his year of birth as
1964.
Now, this brings this case close to the facts in the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Shankar Lal vs. Hindustan Copper Limited and
others: (2022) 6 SCC 211. If the respondents as employer were to
superannuate the appellant on the footing i.e., the date of birth was 1964
and not 24th January, 1967, both of which were in the records, it
amounted to the employer taking a decision on the age of the employee
at the time of his retirement. The judgment declared “the very reasoning
on which an employee is not permitted to raise age-correction plea at
the fag end of his service to extend his tenure should apply to the
employer as well.” Therefore, what was needed was to give the
appellant a hearing and pass a reasoned order with regard to his age as
laid down by Bose, J in that judgment.
In those circumstances, we partly allow this appeal by directing
the competent authority of the respondents to take a decision as referred
to in the said communication of the Superintendent of Police dated 19 th
April, 2022 after giving a hearing to the appellant and by a reasoned
order within two months of communication of this order. On the basis
2024:MLHC:986-DB
of the decision taken, the respondents could either affirm the decision to
superannuate the appellant or take a fresh decision on his date of birth
and superannuation with consequential reliefs. The impugned judgment
and order is set aside
This appeal is accordingly, partly allowed.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2024.11.07 14:18:27 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review