Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RAJKU Digitally signed
by RAJKUMAR
MAR
PRIYOJIT SINGH
PRIYOJI Date:
2023.07.18
T SINGH 17:20:46 -07'00'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
AB No. 10 of 2023
Soibam Shyamsunder Singh, aged about 22 years, S/o Soibam Indrakumar
Singh, a permanent resident of Wangjing Purna Heituppokpi, P.O. Wangjing
& P.S. Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur- 795148.
… Petitioner
- Versus –
1.
The Officer-in-charge, Thoubal Police Station, P.O. & P.S. Thoubal,
Thoubal District, Manipur – 795138.
2.
The Complainant/Informant, namely, Shri Soibam Ashokumar Singh,
aged about 44 years, S/o Soibam Sudam Singh, a resident of Wangjing Purna
Heituppokpi, P.O. Wangjing & P.S. Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur –
795148.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
:
For the respondent
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment & Order
:
:
:
AB No. 10 of 2023
Mr. S. Chitaranjan, Advocate,
Mr. Ch. Victor, Advocate and
Mr. A. Priyokumar, Advocate.
Mr. Y. Ashang, P.P.
27.06.2023
18.07.2023
Page 1
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
By way of the present petition under Section 438 Cr.P.C., the
petitioner who is an accused in FIR No. 84(4)2023 TBL-PS U/S 326 IPC (later
on, added Section 302 IPC) has approached this Court for granting anticipatory
bail. His earlier application, being Cril. Misc. (AB) Case No. 48 of 2023 under
Section 438 Cr.P.C was rejected by the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal, vide
order dated 16.05.2023.
[2]
The brief facts of the present case is that the petitioner is the
nephew of the informant/complainant, i.e., respondent No. 2 herein. The
father of the petitioner namely Soibam Indrakumar Singh, respondent No. 2
namely, Soibam Ashokumar Singh and Soibam Jamikanta Singh are brothers
and are the sons of Soibam Sudam Singh and (late) Soibam Landhoni Devi.
The 3(three) brothers are living separately with their own respective family
within the same locality. Both the father and mother of these 3 (three)
brothers are living with respondent No. 2. There is a dispute over an
agricultural land situated at Wangjing Heituppokpi, measuring about 0.27
hectare, between the 3(three) brothers and the agricultural land is jointly
owned by these 3(three) brothers by recording their names in the records of
rights. Respondent No. 2 sought necessary signature of the father of the
petitioner namely Soibam Indrakumar Singh for the purpose of selling a piece
of land to which the father of the petitioner denied and there was tussle
between the father of the petitioner on one side and respondent No. 2 on the
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 2
other side. On 25.04.2023, there was a negotiation at the house of the elected
Member of Wangjing Gram Panchayat and the father of the petitioner was
taken to the residence of the Ward Member. The grandparent of the petitioner
also came at the residence of the Ward Member. A verbal argument took
placed between the 3(three) brothers and as such the petitioner asked his
uncles for proper demarcation by the authority concerned first and to sell out
their respective portion only. Suddenly, respondent No. 2 and Soibam
Jaminikanta Singh started physically assaulting the father of the petitioner and
the petitioner tried to pacify them and his father escaped from the place and
they were chased by the respondents and others. As such, the petitioner also
got injury and was treated in Casualty Department of District Hospital, Thoubal
on 26.04.2023 in the morning. The mother of the petitioner also reported the
matter to the Officer-in-Charge, Thoubal Police Station on 26.04.2023 by
submitting a written report but no action was taken by the police.
[3]
After the petitioner came back from the District Hospital, Thoubal,
he came to know that his grandmother sustained injury and was taken to Shija
Hospital for treatment in the night of 25.04.2023. Respondent No. 2 made a
written report to the Officer-in-Charge, Thoubal Police Station on 26.04.2023
alleging that the petitioner assaulted his mother namely Soibam Landhoni Devi
(now deceased) by using stick and FIR No. 84(4) 2023 TBL-PS, u/s 326 IPC
was registered against the petitioner. On 27.04.2023, the petitioner learnt that
his grandmother namely Soibam Landhoni Devi expired at Shija Hospital and
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 3
police personnel came to his residence to arrest him on the allegation of
murder. Later on, Section 302 IPC was added to the F.I.R.
[4]
The petitioner approached the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal,
under Section 438 Cr.P.C, being Cril. Misc. (AB) No. 48 of 2023 and vide order
dated 02.05.2023 interim anticipatory bail was granted to the petitioner with
the conditions that: “(i) the petitioner shall co-operate with the investigation;
(ii) the petitioner shall make themselves available before the investigating
authority not later than 13.05.2023; (iii) the petitioner shall not influence
prosecution witnesses; and (iv) the petitioner shall not leave the State of
Manipur without prior permission of the Court.” However, vide order dated
16.05.2023, the bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C was rejected solely
on the ground that he did not appear before the I.O. and as such violated the
conditions imposed by the learned Sessions Judge and the bail application was
rejected and interim order was vacated. The relevant portion of the order read
as follows: “Perused the AB report of the I.O. of the case. Allegations against
the accused is of sec: 326 and 302 IPC. The I.O. of the case has submitted
that the petitioner had not appeared before him for giving his statement and
as such had violated this Court’s direction to appear before the I.O. not later
than 13.05.2023.”
[5]
After this, the petitioner approached this Court under Section 438
Cr.P.C. inter alia on the ground that:
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 4
(i) the petitioner could not appeared before the Investigating
Officer as there was tension in the family on account of the
death of his own grandmother and due to religious rites and
functions of the death;
(ii) the learned Sessions Judge rejected the bail application
only on the ground that allegation of offences punishable
under Section 326 & 302 IPC have been invoked and the
failure of the petitioner before the I.O.;
(iii) the cause of death as per Medical Death Summary issued
by Shija Hospital is cardiac arrest and the manner of death is
accidental and hence charge under Section 302 IPC is not
attracted in the present case;
(iv) the petitioner has no criminal antecedents and is not
involved in any other offence; and
(v) the petitioner is a regular student studying in 5th Semester
of Bachelor of Arts in Yangambam Kumar College, Wangjing,
and if arrested, his study would be jeopardized.
[6]
It is also undertaken that the petitioner will furnish sufficient
bond(s) and would appear before the I.O. whenever required; would not
abscond or leave without the permission of the Court; would not directly or
indirectly influence any person acquainted with the present case; and will
comply all the conditions imposed by this Court.
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 5
[7]
State filed counter affidavit and stated that in the course of
examination of eye witnesses, the presence of the petitioner at the crime
scene is established. The learned Sessions Judge has rightly rejected the bail
application as the petitioner did not comply with the conditions imposed by
the Court and did not cooperate with the investigation. Regarding the Death
Summary issued by Shija Hospital, it is stated that cardiac arrest is due to
severe head injury suffered by the deceased from blunt object.
[8]
Respondent No. 2/complainant also filed counter affidavit stating
that the deceased sustained severe head injury due to assault by the petitioner
by using stick and the deceased has no history of chronic illness and the death
was due to severe head injury suffered by the deceased. The learned Sessions
Judge, Thoubal, rightly rejected the bail application as the petitioner failed to
comply the conditions imposed by the Court.
[9]
Heard learned counsel for the parties. Perused the materials on
record and case law cited at the bar.
[10]
Mr. S. Chitaranjan, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits
that on mere perusal of the Death Summary, manner of death is accidental
and cardiac arrest. He draws the attention of this Court that the cause of death
is not due to head injury and as such there is no materials to invoke provisions
of Section 302 IPC against the petitioner and if averment of the complainant
is presumed to be true, at most, Section 304 A IPC i.e. causing death by
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 6
negligence would be attracted and the same is a bailable offence. Regarding
Section 326 IPC for causing voluntary grievous hurt by dangerous weapon, it
is submitted that stick cannot be considered as a dangerous weapon and that
nature of stick is also not clearly stated by the prosecution nor the
complainant. With regard to the failure of the petitioner to appear before the
I.O as directed by the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal, it is submitted that
curfew was imposed throughout the many districts of Manipur including
Thoubal district due to the present law and order situation arisen on
03.05.2023 and that time also high tension between the families and due to
death and religious rites and functions in the family for the demise of his
grandmother, the petitioner could not appear before the Investigating Officer
for recording his statement. It is further submitted that the non-appearance
of the petitioner before the I.O. as directed by the learned Sessions Judge,
Thoubal, is not deliberate and intentional and the same is due to the situation
stated herein. Moreover, the petitioner is a student pursuing bachelor course
and if he is taken into custody, his study will be jeopardized and he has no
previous involvement in any criminal activities. It is further submitted that
rejection of the bail application on failure to appear before the I.O. in absence
of any allegation of tempering the evidence or threatening the witnesses is
not justifiable. It is prayed that bail application may be allowed. Mr. Ch. Victor,
learned counsel representing the petitioner has also highlighted that Section
438 Cr.P.C embodies the concept of personal liberty and has stated that the
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 7
Court may take judicial note of situation prevailing during the period starting
wef 4th May, 2023, where curfew was imposed in most districts of Manipur.
[11]
Learned counsel for the petitioner relies upon the following
judgment:
(i)
State
of
M.P.
vs.
Pradeep
Sharma;
indiankanoon.org/doc/176600070/ to the point that an
order under Section 438 is a device to secure the individual’s
liberty, it is neither a passport to the commission of crimes nor a
shield against any and all kinds of accusations likely or unlikely.
(ii) M.R. Narayan vs. State; CrilLJ 1472, 2003 (66) DRJ 48
(Delhi High Court) to the point that unreasonable conditions
which amounts to refusal of the bail application should not be
imposed while granting bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C.
(iii) Khajim @ Khajimulla Khan Vrs. The State of
Karnataka; indiankanoon.org/doc/155371923/ to the
point that it is the duty of the Court to satisfy itself on the basis
of the material placed on record that the breach of any conditions
of bail goes to the root of the trial in question and it is also well
settled proposition of law that once the bail is granted it should
not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering any
circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 8
to allow the accused the benefit of freedom of enjoying the
concession of bail during the trial.
[12]
It is highlighted that mere failure to appear before the
Investigating Officer as directed by the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal and
in absence of any allegations of interfering in the investigation will not warrant
cancellation of the interim bail already granted.
[13]
Mr. Y. Ashang, learned PP for the State, submits that the
investigation is at initial stage and learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal, was right
in cancelling the bail application as the petitioner did not appear before the
Investigating Officer as directed and as well as it is a proof that he is not
cooperating with the investigation. No proper explanation is given in the bail
application for failure to appear before the I.O. In the course of investigation,
many eye witnesses gave their statements that the petitioner assaulted the
deceased. The Death Summary Report issued by Shija Hospital (AnnexureA/6) cannot be a conclusive evidence to establish the cause of death and as
such the petitioner cannot take advantage of the same and the cause of death
will be established during the course of trial on the basis of expert opinion. Till
date also, the petitioner is not appearing before the I.O. as directed and crime
weapon is yet to be seized. Learned PP relies on the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court reported in (2014) 13 SCC 579 to the effect that recovery
of the crime weapon is to be made and accordingly anticipatory bail was
rejected.
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 9
[14]
Mr. Th. Mahira, learned counsel assisted by Mr. Vijaykumar,
learned counsel for respondent No. 2/complainant, submits that the presence
of the petitioner at the crime scene has been established from the eye
witnesses. The charge under Section 302 IPC was added as the deceased died
due to head injury inflicted by the petitioner. The reasons for failure to appear
before the I.O. due to curfew and mob violence as submitted during the
hearing is not mentioned in the bail application. The cause of death accidental
as mentioned in Death Summary issued by the Shija Hospital (Annexure-A/6)
is not conclusive and the same has to be ascertained during the course of the
trial. It is submitted that the bail application be rejected.
[15]
Considered the submissions made by the counsel for the parties
at the bar, perused the materials on record and the case laws cited. Question
involved in the present case is whether failure to appear before the
Investigating Officer as directed by the learned Session Judge is sufficient to
reject the bail application and reject the interim anticipatory bail granted
already.
[16]
It is seen from the pleadings of the parties and documents on
record that there is a property dispute between the three brothers and on the
day of the occurrence there was a negotiation between the brothers at the
residence of the Ward Member. In a sudden altercation between brothers,
injuries were suffered specially by the deceased and the petitioner. The injury
to the deceased was allegedly inflicted by stick blow. The deceased succumbed
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 10
to her injuries and the ‘Death Summary’ issued by SHIJA Hospital is not
conclusive. The real cause of death is to be ascertained during the trial and
the materials on record do not indicate that the cause of death was due to
head injury. From the available record, it is apparent that the injury was
sustained in a sudden fight and was not pre-mediated. The petitioner was on
interim bail and his bail application was rejected on the ground that he did not
appear before the IO as directed by the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal and
Section 302 IPC was invoked. Apparently, the petitioner has no previous
criminal record and is a student pursuing graduation. Even though, the
petitioner did not mention the curfew and mob violence as reason for nonappearance before the IO in his application, this Court can take judicial note
of this well-known event.
[17]
This Court is of the view that rejection of the bail application
solely on ground of non-appearance before the IO will not be proper, when
the petitioner is a young student and the injury was caused in sudden fight
between brothers while negotiating in a property dispute. The petitioner also
sustained injury in the fight. Real cause of death will be established during the
trial.
[18]
In the circumstances, the bail application is allowed. In case of
arrest, the petitioner shall be released on furnishing a bail bond of Rs.50,000/with a surety of like amount to the satisfaction of the arresting authority
subject to the following conditions that:
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 11
(a)
The petitioner shall co-operate with the investigation and shall
appear before the IO on 1st and 15th of every month (till October, 2023)
and on such dates as directed by the IO;
(b)
The petitioner shall not tamper with any evidence in connection
with the present FIR and shall not influence any person acquainted with
the present case;
(c)
The petitioner shall not leave the State of Manipur without the
permission of learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal; and
(d)
The respondents may approach this Court for cancellation of bail,
if the petitioner fails to comply any of the conditions as mentioned
above.
[19]
With these observations and directions the bail application is
disposed of. Send a copy of this order to the learned Sessions Judge, Thoubal
and the OC, Thoubal PS for information. It is clarified that this Court does not
express any opinion on the merit of the case and anything stated herein shall
be confined to disposing the bail application.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Indrajeet
AB No. 10 of 2023
Page 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review