Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
"#
$%&'(
) *+,+,%(*.*-/0/
&* $+'+* %1
'-2'(' '(3 %+&*-/
) */4%(3*(+/
!
"#
*5*(3*- 66'-7'8
) *+,+,%(*-
.*-/0/
$+'+* %1
'-2'(' '(3 %+&*-/
) */4%(3*(+/
!
"#
'5**( 90:') *+,+,%(*-
.*-/0/
$+'+* %1
'-2'(' '(3 %+&*-/
) */4%(3*(+/
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
*/*-5*3 %(;
-%(%0(<*3 %(;
48%'3*3 %(; =
Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced ?
Whether full judgment is pronounced ?
";
> ? "
No
Yes
$
$
!"#$% %&%$'
( )
*
!#&++ %&%$'
,
*
!#-$. %&%$'
/0
)
1 2 3
*
4 !
!"#$% %&%$'
4 %
4 !
!#&++ %&%$'
!#-$. %&%$'
4 !
!#&++ %&%$'
*
-%.+
%&%.
4 !
!#-$. %&%$'
6 1 3
8888888
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
!"#$% 7 !#-$. %&%$'
$
-
,
)
)
*
:
%
6 2 6
CWP 34752 2025
)
<
' <
0 *
6 *
certiorari
*
!'
certiorari
:
*
%$ &+ %&%$
@' 6
@
-A )
*
#'
@6
* 3
2 =2'
)
&$
' <
@
* 3
)3
2 =2'
> 2 =2'?'
2 3
@
%- &$ %&%$
@'
*
*
=2'
' <
:
4 &";%&%$
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
%%.;%%#
* 3
mandamus
@
*
4 &";%&%$
)3
%- &$ %&%$
!'
*
' <
mandamus
),
)3 *
0 6
*
*
!'
*
)
' <
*
-A
%!'
mandamus
*
-. &. %&%$
?
.'
)3
!,#
@$%&'( $,(6&A
!
4 %2 3
)
4 &";%&%$
%- &$ %&%$
@ 1
@
&$
4 +;%&%%
@' 6
4 !
-. &. %&%$ 2 6
* 3
)
2 =2'
:
%$ &A %&-A
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
!'
)
)
%- &# %&%!
)3
2 3
-. &. %&%$
!" %'
%&-.
>5
5*
*
)
%% -& %&-!
)
* 3
*
*)
;C5
)
*6
-. &. %&%$
-. &# %&%$
6 *
*
-$&
*
0'
-&&
0'
),
%$ &+ %&%$
#'
@
&$
-A
2 =2'
* 3
)
2 6
$'
.'
*
*
*
*
-- &# %&%!
B
0 6
"'
?'
%$ &" %&-A &- &$ %&-+
"
$
-. -& %&%$
+'
*
:
%+ &+ %&%$
:
)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
*
**
)3
4 -
!,,#
@ *5*(3*- 66'-7'8A
.
4 %&
%&%$
-! &A %&%$
D
D *
&%
$'
%+
@' 6
*
* 3 @
*
6@
)
E
*)
)
E
)
* 3 2
%$ -- %&%$
:
3 *
6@
* 36
:
6@
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
6@
*
* 3
* 3
3 -%
*
-%
!$F
<
3 *
3'
),
)
-- -- %&%$
-A
:
)
&% -- %&%$
)3
)3
*
:
.' 4
@
@
3'
**
)3
&%
!,,,#
@ '5**( 90:'-A
#
4 %&
%&%$
D
-! &A %&%$
D *
@'
*)
* 3
6@
) :
-'
%+
@ @
*
D
=2'
)
* 3 )
*
)3
)
&% &+ %&%$
"'
:
-'
:
*
&% -- %&%$ )
),
!$F
*
#'
6@
*
*
* 3
:
*
&A -- %&%$
6@
) )
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
:
* 3
)
)
**
),
)3
** *
)3
=
$
!,#
@$%&'( $,(6&A
A
E
)
* 3 :
@
*3
@
*3 @ D
3)
E 6
<
-&&F
)
@
*
@
35*
)
%' 6 *
*)
--
&-
@
@6
4 &+;%&%%
2 =2'
:
)
* 3
) :
supra'
%$ &" %&-A
)
) 0 *
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
-+' B
:
)
)
2 6
)
'
<
*
)
;C5
)
)3
'
)
+
5 )
@
* 3
*3
-&
B
-$ &# %&-"
&- &# %&%%
-A'
%-'
&- &$ %&-+
)
*
2 3
%&'
*
)
)
)
)
* 3
-- &# %&%!
2 3
%!'
<
G *
;
-A
%&
%-' 2 6
)
&!
*
2 =2'
)
*
:
!$
* 3
),
--
E
)
supra'
:
)
)3
@ 6
)
:
*
)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)
2 =2'
* 3
supra' 6
<
)
*
)3
),
<
)
),
%- -- %&%$
)
@
-. -% %&%$
@
5 !;"' 6
3 )
)3
-.
< 6
*
-- -% %&%$
)3
&%
)
;1
-%
Per contra,
2 =2'
:
&$
:
-!
*
%$ &+ %&%$ 6
%. -% %&%$
5 !;$'
3)
&%
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)
@
B
:
&-
*
* 3
%% -% %&%!
@
2 =2'
* 3
*)
* 3 2 6
, *
)3
of 2025
@
LPA No.2408
>Sachin Kumar vs. State of Haryana and others’ decided
on 29.11.2025 6
)
:
3 *
)
*
@ *5*(3*- 66'-7'8A
@ '5**( 90:'-A
!,,#
!,,,#
-!
E
'
:
3 *
),
!$F
*
"'
&% &+ %&%$
2 6
-! &A %&%$
-'
D
@
) :
,
*
D *
*)
)3
)
2 ?)
Tej
Prakash Pathak and others Vs. Rajasthan High Court and others,
(2025) 2 SCC 1
3 )
* *
*
B
3 *
:
3 *
6@
)
)
-"
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
* 3
<
%$ &" %&-A
&- &# %&%%
-- &# %&%!
"
--'
&- &$ %&-+
-"'
&# &% %&%!
-$
-.
3'
)3
)
6@
*
-!'
2 3
2 6
* 3
*)
*
'
:
6@
*
&%
* 3
6@
* 3
-"
E
*
**
:
3 *
-'
&% &+ %&%$
-&
)
"'
*
*
Tej Prakash Pathak>
)
)
supra' 2
) *
*
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
:
3 *
),
*
*
'
3*
)
)
3 ),
*
*
3 6
),
*
)
)
3 6
)3
%$F
'
) %$F 6
!$F 4
*
*
< 6
* 6
)3
2 ?)
Madan Lal and others Vs.
State of Jammu and Kashmir, (1995) 3 SCC 486, State of U.P. Vs.
Karunesh Kumar, 2023 AIR SC 52
Tejvir Singh Sodhi Vs. State of
Jammu and Kashmir, (2023) 17 SCC 147.
-$
E
)
)
:
*
3 *
)
!"
*
6@
)3
)
* 3 B
'
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
>
3?
*
:
)3
* *
*
*
2 6
*
@
Sachin Kumar>
-.
*
supra'
E
)
%&%!
:
&! &$ %&%!
!;%
@
%- &. %&%!
!#-$. %&%$'
D
D *
@
$"
<
%$
)3
&%
2 6
6@
&-
D
* 3
&-
)3
2'
*)
-#
:
@
%+
D
&$ &% %&%$ 6
6@
*
2'
* 36
* 3 &-
&%
D *
*
2'
&-
D
2' <
:
%+
-. -% %&%$
%&%$' 2 6
*)
5 !;$
6@
!#-$.
* 36
*
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
5 !;-
)
@ 3
4 %#&-"
* 3
;C5' 6
4 -#"+#
4 &!
* 3D
' 6
4 %&
*
@
*)
*
6@
* 3 )
%$ &" %&-A
5 !;.'
2 3
)3
)
)
$
)
.
-A
$
3 @ 3
? $$
*
*
'
3 6
) :
*
*
*
:
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
,
)3
'
-+
@
!"#$% %&%$
)
*
<
),
%- -- %&%$
*
-- -% %&%$
)3
%&
2 6
*
*
:
3 *
6 * :
)
,
)3
“Whether relaxation in the selection criteria with respect to
persons
with
disabilities
is
constitutionally
and
jurisprudentially justified and warranted?”
%(/+,+0+,%('8 '(3 $+'+0+%-2
-%+*<+,%(/ +%
*-/%(/ 7,+&
,/'B,8,+,*/
%-
)
*
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
*
<
*
,
:
G
G
)
:
)
:
2 6
)
)
)3
)3
)
)
=
*
*
)3
)
)
)
:
3 3
%%
)
)
)
* 6
)
)3
*
)
)
)
)
)
)
*
6 3
*
* *
**
D
*
)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
**
*
6 0
)
=
*
)3
2 ?)
Jeeja Ghosh and an
other Vs. Union of India and others, (2016) 7 SCC 761
)
0 *
*
*
0 *
* (
*
)
6 *6
)
“39. In international human rights law, equality is founded upon
two complementary principles: non(discrimination and reasonable
differentiation. The principle of non(discrimination seeks to ensure
that all persons can equally enjoy and exercise all their rights and
freedoms. Discrimination occurs due to arbitrary denial of
opportunities for equal participation. For example, when public
facilities and services are set on standards out of the reach of
persons with disabilities, it leads to exclusion and denial of
rights. Equality not only implies preventing discrimination
(example, the protection of individuals against unfavourable
treatment by introducing anti discrimination laws), but goes
beyond in remedying discrimination against groups suffering
systematic discrimination in society. In concrete terms, it means
embracing the notion of positive rights, affirmative action and
reasonable accommodation. The move from the patronising and
paternalistic approach to persons with disabilities represented by
the medical model to viewing them as members of the community
with equal rights has also been reflected in the evolution of
international standards relating specifically to disabilities, as well
as in moves to place the rights of persons with disabilities within
the category of universal human rights. {See ( Report of United
Nations Consultative Expert Group Meeting on International
Norms and Standards Relating to Disability 10(2(2001}.
xxx
xxx
xxx
42.
…What is to be borne in mind is that they are also
human beings and they have to grow as normal persons and are to
be extended all facilities in this behalf. The subject of the rights of
persons with disabilities should be approached from human rights
perspective, which recognised that persons with disabilities were
entitled to enjoy the full range of internationally guaranteed rights
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
and freedoms without discrimination on the ground of disability.
This creates an obligation on the part of the State to take positive
measures to ensure that in reality persons with disabilities get
enabled to exercise those rights. There should be insistence on
the full measure of general human rights guarantees in the case
of persons with disabilities, as well as developing specific
instruments that refine and given detailed contextual content of
those general guarantees. There should be a full recognition of
the fact that persons with disability were integral part of the
community, equal in dignity and entitled to enjoy the same human
rights and freedoms as others. It is a sad commentary that this
perceptions has not sunk in the mind and souls of those who are
not concerned with the enforcement of these rights. The persons
suffering from mental or physical disability experience and
encounter nonpareil form of discrimination. They are not looked
down by people. However, they are not accepted in the main
stream either even when people sympathies with them. Most
common, their lives are handicapped by social, cultural and
attitudinal barriers which hamper their full participation and
enjoyment of equal rights and opportunities. This is the worst form
of discrimination which disabled feel as their grievance is that
others do not understand them.
xxx
xxx
xxx
45. It is the common experience of several persons with
disabilities that they are unable to lead a full life due to societal
barriers and discrimination faced by them in employment, access
to public spaces, transportation etc. Persons with disability are
most neglected lot not only in the society but also in the family.
More often they are an object of pity. There are hardly any
meaningful attempts to assimilate them in the mainstream of the
nation's life. The apathy towards their problems is so pervasive
that even the number of disabled persons existing in the country is
not well documented.”
'
%!
,
)
6 *
:
<
?
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)
G
*
“Article 14.
The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or
the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India
Article 16.
(1)There shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters
relating to employment or appointment to any office under the
State.
(4) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from making any
provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of
any backward class of citizens which, in the opinion of the State, is
not adequately represented in the services under the State.
Article 21.
No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except
according to procedure established by law.
Article 41.
The State shall, within the limits of its economic capacity and
development, make effective provision for securing the right to
work, to education and to public assistance in cases of
unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement, and in other
cases of undeserved want.
Article 243W.
xxx
xxx
xxx
9.
Safeguarding the interests of weaker sections of society,
including the handicapped and mentally retarded.”
%"
*
)
=
5*
>
-+$$?' 6
)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
B
D:
'
-++$
G
)
*
*
-+$$ 6
)3
5*
*
)
%&-. 5
'
)
“2. Definitions.—
In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,—
(y) “reasonable accommodation” means necessary and
appropriate modification and adjustments, without imposing
a disproportionate or undue burden in a particular case, to
ensure to persons with disabilities the enjoyment or exercise
of rights equally with others
3. Equality and non discrimination.—
(1) The appropriate Government shall ensure that the persons
with disabilities enjoy the right to equality, life with dignity
and respect for his or her integrity equally with others.
(2) The appropriate Government shall take steps to utilise the
capacity of persons with disabilities by providing appropriate
environment.
(3) No person with disability shall be discriminated on the
ground of disability, unless it is shown that the impugned act or
omission is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate
aim.
(4) No person shall be deprived of his or her personal liberty
only on the ground of disability.
(5) The appropriate Government shall take necessary steps to
ensure reasonable accommodation for persons with
disabilities.
33. Identification of posts for reservation.—
The appropriate Government shall—
(i) identify posts in the establishments which can be held by
respective category of persons with benchmark disabilities in
respect of the vacancies reserved in accordance with the
provisions of section 34;
(ii) constitute an expert committee with representation of
persons with benchmark disabilities for identification of such
posts; and
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
(iii) undertake periodic review of the identified posts at an
interval not exceeding three years.
34. Reservation.—
(1) Every appropriate Government shall appoint in every
Government establishment, not less than four per cent. of the
total number of vacancies in the cadre strength in each group of
posts meant to be filled with persons with benchmark disabilities
of which, one per cent. each shall be reserved for persons with
benchmark disabilities under clauses (a), (b) and (c) and one per
cent. for persons with benchmark disabilities under clauses (d)
and (e), namely:—
(a) blindness and low vision;
(b) deaf and hard of hearing;
(c) locomotor disability including cerebral palsy, leprosy
cured, dwarfism, acid attack victims and muscular dystro(
phy;
(d) autism, intellectual disability, specific learning disabil(
ity and mental illness;
(e) multiple disabilities from amongst persons under
clauses (a) to (d) including deaf(blindness in the posts iden(
tified for each disabilities:
Provided that the reservation in promotion shall be in ac(
cordance with such instructions as are issued by the appropriate
Government from time to time:
Provided further that the appropriate Government, in con(
sultation with the Chief Commissioner or the State Commissioner,
as the case may be, may, having regard to the type of work carried
out in any Government establishment, by notification and subject
to such conditions, if any, as may be specified in such notifications
exempt any Government establishment from the provisions of this
section.
(2) Where in any recruitment year any vacancy cannot be filled
up due to non availability of a suitable person with benchmark
disability or for any other sufficient reasons, such vacancy shall
be carried forward in the succeeding recruitment year and if in
the succeeding recruitment year also suitable person with
benchmark disability is not available, it may first be filled by in
terchange among the five categories and only when there is no
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
person with disability available for the post in that year, the em
ployer shall fill up the vacancy by appointment of a person,
other than a person with disability:
Provided that if the nature of vacancies in an establishment
is such that a given category of person cannot be employed, the
vacancies may be interchanged among the five categories with the
prior approval of the appropriate Government.
(3) The appropriate Government may, by notification, provide for
such relaxation of upper age limit for employment of persons with
benchmark disability, as it thinks fit.”
'
%$
2 ?)
In Re: Recruitment of Vis
ually Impaired in Judicial Services, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 481
:
)
6 0
*
6 <
*
:
)
)
6 =
*
:
*
)
G
:
*
)3
3 *
)
)
)
)
)
)
<
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)
)
*
"%3,1,<'+,%( %1 $*8*<+,%( -,+*-,'
%.
3 :
:
6 3 3
)
)
)
)
)
*
)3
*
*
:
)
:
)
)
2 6
*
)
)
) ,
*
*
%#
< Re: Recruitment of Visually Impaired in Judicial Services
supra'
6 (
* @
2 ?)
0 6
:
&! 3
)
)
#&F
3 *
)
*
,
:
*
:
0 *
* (
)
)
)
6 *6
“46. Thus, the principle of indirect discrimination hereinbefore
applied to counter gender(based discrimination, can also be
applied to the facts of the present case, where disabled/visually
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
impaired legal practitioners are sought to be equated with their
able(bodied counterparts in the matter of application of certain
conditions for participation for selection to the post of judicial
officers. Applying such a test of indirect discrimination, the ease
of practice as well as the securing of marks cannot be said to be
an equal condition to both classes of citizens, viz., disabled and
ablebodied lawyers, given that the atmosphere in which they
operate cannot be said to be the same. This is also a perfect
example of how unequals are sought to be treated equally, and
that itself would be a negation of the principle of substantive
equality. Therefore, it can easily be inferred that the rule relating
to practice or in the alternative, to secure 70% in the first attempt
in the examinations, is a case of indirect discrimination as the
provisions are facially neutral but discriminatory in operation. In
view of the same, Rule 7 of the Madhya Pradesh Judicial Service
Rules, 1994, to the extent it prescribes the additional requirement
of either a three(year practice period or securing an aggregate
score of 70% in the first attempt, is liable to be struck down
insofar as it applies to PwD candidates. Accordingly, the
impugned Rule will be applicable to PwD candidates insofar as it
prescribes the educational and other qualifications as eligibility
criteria including the minimum aggregate score of 70% (with
relaxation as may be determined like in the case of SC/ST
candidates) but without the requirement of either that it should be
in the first attempt or that they should have three years' practice.
This issue stands answered in the said terms.”
'
%A
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
*
)
)
)
*
<
)
9 *
*
)
)
>
)
)
,
*
?
)
B
)
)
<
:
%+
:
)
)3
) 0
‘Equality,? 5 2
6 3
G *
)
)
)
“The truth is that it is absurd and degrading for men to make
much of their intellectual and moral superiority to each other and
still more of their superiority in the arts which bring wealth and
power, because, judged by their place in any universal scheme,
they are infinitely great or infinitely small............ The equality
which all these thinkers emphasise as desirable is not equality of
capacity or attainment but of circumstances, and institutions, and
manner of life. The inequality which they deplore is not the
inequality of personal gifts, but of the social and economic
environment ............. Their view, in short, is that, because men are
men, social institutions, property rights, and the organisation of
industry, and the system of public health and education should be
planned, as far as is possible to emphasise and strengthen, not the
class differences which divide but the common humanity which
unite, them.”
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
!&
D:
*
)
:
)
)
G *
)
)
*
)
*3
*
-" -$ -. 7 "6
<
)
*
)
)
:
)
* 6
*
:
)3 6 3
*
*
,
*
:
)3
)
)
?
0 *
*
)
G
*
:
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
**
>
)
=
!-
@
2 ?)
Sawhney Vs. Union of India, 1993 AIR SC 477,
0 *
* (
Indra
*
&+ ( *
6 * )
*
“831. We must also make it clear that it would not be impermissi
ble for the State to extend concessions and relaxations to mem
bers of reserved categories in the matter of promotion without
compromising the efficiency of the administration. The relax(
ation concerned in Thomas [(1976) 2 SCC 310, 380 :1976 scc
(l&s) 227: (1976) 1 SCR 906)] and the concessions namely carry(
ing forward of vacancies and provisions for in(service coaching/
training in Karamchari Sangh [(1981) 1 SCC 246, 289 : 1981
SCC(L&S) 50: (1981) 2 SCR 185, 234] are instances of such con(
cessions and relaxations. However, it would not be permissible to
prescribe lower qualifying marks or a lesser level of evaluation
for the members of reserved categories since that would compro(
mise the efficiency of administration. We reiterate that while it
may be permissible to prescribe a reasonably lesser qualifying
marks or evaluation for the OBCs, SCs and STs( consistent with
the efficiency of administration and the nature of duties attaching
to the office concerned ( in the matter of direct recruitment, such a
course would not be permissible in the matter of promotions for
reasons recorded hereinabove.
xxx
xxx
xxx
836. We do not think it necessary to express ourselves at any
length on the correctness or otherwise of the opposing points of
view referred to above. (It is, however, necessary to point out that
the mandate ( if it can be called that ( of Article 335 is to take the
claims of members of SC/ST into consideration, consistent with
the maintenance of efficiency of administration. It would be a mis(
reading of Article to say that the mandate is maintenance of effi(
ciency of administration.) May be, efficiency, competence and
merit are not synonymous concepts; May be, it is wrong to treat
merit as synonymous with efficiency in administration and that
merit is but a component of the efficiency of an administrator.
Even so, the relevance and significance of merit at the stage of
initial recruitment cannot be ignored. It cannot also be ignored
that the very idea of reservation implies selection of a less meri
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
torious person. At the same time, we recognise that this much
cost has to be paid, if the, constitutional promise of social justice
is to be redeemed. We also firmly believe that given an opportu
nity, members of these classes are bound to overcome their ini
tial disadvantages and would compete with and may, in some
cases, excel members of open competitor candidates. It is unde(
niable that nature has endowed merit upon members of backward
classes as much as it has endowed upon members of other classes
and that what is required is an opportunity to prove it. It may not,
therefore, be said that reservations are antimeritian. Merit there
is even among the reserved candidates and the small difference,
that may be allowed at the stage of initial recruitment is bound
to disappear in course of time. These members too will compete
with and improve their efficiency along with others.”
'
!%
:
*
2 3
3 *
)3 Indra Sawhney?
)3
)
supra'
*
“Instructions dated 25.04.2018 (Annexure P 11 in CWP 37099
2025)
“Subject: Reservation for Persons with Benchmark Disabilities:
xxx
xxx
xxx
M) EXCHANGE AND CARRY FORWARD OF RESERVATION
IN CASE OF DIRECT RECRUITMENT:
(i) Reservation for each of the four categories of persons with
benchmark disabilities shall be made separately. But if the nature
of vacancies in an establishment is such that a person of a
specific category of disability cannot be employed, the
vacancies may be interchanged among the four categories with
the approval of the Social Justice & Empowerment Department
and reservation may be determined and vacancies filled
accordingly.
(ii) If any vacancy reserved for any category of disability cannot
be filled due to non( availability of a suitable person with that
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
disability or, for any other sufficient reason, such vacancy shall be
carried forward to the subsequent recruitment year.
(iii) In the subsequent recruitment year the carried forward
vacancy shall be treated as reserved for the category of disability
for which it was kept reserved in the initial year of recruitment.
However, if a suitable person with that disability is not available,
it may be filled by interchange among the four categories of
disabilities. In case no suitable person with benchmark
disabilities is available for filling up the post in the subsequent
year also, the employer may fill up the vacancy by appointment
of a person other than a person with disability.”
(Instructions 15.07.2014 (Annexure 12 in CWP 37099 2025)
“Subject:
Grant
of
reservation
in
Jobs
under
Government/Government Undertakings & Local Bodies as well
as in admission in Government/Government aided
educational/technical/ Professional institutions.
xxx
xxx
xxx
L) INTER SE EXCHANGE AND CARRY FORWARD OF
RESERVATION IN CASE OF DIRECT RECRUITMENT:
a) Reservation for each of the three categories of persons with
disabilities shall be made separately. But if the nature of vacan
cies in an establishment is such that a person of a specific cate
gory of disability cannot be employed, the vacancies may be in
terchanged among the three categories with the approval of the
Department of Social Justice & Empowerment and reservation
may be determined and vacancies filled accordingly.
b) If any vacancy reserved for any category of disability cannot be
filled due to non(availability of a suitable person with that disabil(
ity or, for any other sufficient reason, such vacancy shall not be
filled and shall be carried forward as a 'backlog reserved va
cancy' to the subsequent recruitment year.
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
c) In the subsequent recruitment year the 'backlog reserved va(
cancy' shall be treated as reserved for the category of disability
for which it was kept reserved in the initial year of recruitment.
However, if a suitable person with that disability is not available,
it may be filled by interchange among the three categories of
disabilities. In case no suitable person with disability is available
for filling up the post in the subsequent year also, the employer
may fill up the vacancy by appointment of a person other than a
person with disability. If the vacancy is filled by a person with dis(
ability of the category for which it was reserved or by a person of
other category of disability by inter se exchange in the subsequent
recruitment year, it will be treated to have been filled by reserva(
tion. But if the vacancy is filled by a person other than a person
with disability in the subsequent recruitment year, reservation
shall be carried forward for a further period upto two recruitment
years whereafter the reservation shall lapse. In these two subse(
quent years, if situation so arises, the procedure for filling up the
reserved vacancy shall be the same as followed in the first subse(
quent recruitment year.
In order to ensure that cases of lapse of reservation are kept
to the minimum, any recruitment of the disabled candidates shall
first be counted against the additional quota brought forward
from previous years, if any, in their chronological order. If candi(
dates are not available for all the vacancies, the older carried for(
ward reservation would be filled first and the relatively later car(
ried forward reservation would be further carried forward.
xxx
xxx
xxx
O) RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
If sufficient number of persons with disabilities are not
available on the basis of the general standard to fill all the va
cancies reserved for them, candidates belonging to this category
may be selected on relaxed standard to fill up the remaining va
cancies reserved for them provided they are not found unfit for
such post or posts. Thus, to the extent the number of vacancies re(
served for persons with disabilities cannot be filled on the basis of
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
general standards, candidates belonging to this category may be
taken by relaxing the standards to make up the deficiency in the
reserved quota subject to the fitness of these candidates for ap(
pointment to the post/posts in question.”
Instructions dated 01.05.2019 (Annexure P 13 in CWP 37099
2025)
“Subject: Reservation for the Persons with Benchmark Disabili
ties in case of direct recruitment to Govt. jobs.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Q) RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
i) If sufficient numbers of candidates with benchmark disabili
ties candidates are not available on the basis of the general stan
dard to fill all the vacancies reserved for them, candidates be
longing to this category may be selected on relaxed standard to
fill up the remaining vacancies reserved for them provided they
are not found unfit for such post or posts. However, this provi
sion shall not be used to allow any relaxation in the eligibility
criteria laid down for the issuance of certificate of disability.
ii) Same relaxed standard should be applied for all the candidates
with Benchmark Disabilities whether they belong to Unreserved/
SC/BC. No further relaxation of standards will be considered or
admissible in favour of any candidate from any category whatso(
ever.”
Instructions dated 01.07.2022 (Annexure P 14 in CWP 37099
2025)
“Subject: Grant of Reservation in Promotion to the Persons with
Benchmark Disabilities under the Rights of Persons with Dis
abilities Act, 2016.
xxx
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
xxx
xxx
9. RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
9.1 If sufficient number of PwBD candidates with benchmark dis(
abilities are not available on the basis of prescribed standard to
fill all the vacancies (in case of promotion through Limited De(
partmental Competitive Examination/ Departmental Examination,
etc.) reserved for them, candidates belonging to this category may
be selected on relaxed standard to fill up the remaining vacancies
reserved for them, provided they are not found unfit for such post
or posts. However, this provision shall not be used to allow any
relaxation in the eligibility criteria laid down for the issuance of
certificate of benchmark disability.
9.2 The same relaxed standard should be applied for all the
PwBD candidates with benchmark disabilities, irrespective of
whether they belong to the Unreserved/Scheduled Caste/Back(
ward Classes category. No further relaxation of standards will be
considered or admissible in favour of any candidate from any cat(
egory whatsoever.
xxx
xxx
xxx
14. ZONE OF CONSIDERATION, INTERSE EXCHANGE AND
CARRY FORWARD OF RESERVATION IN CASE OF PROMO(
TION
14.1 While filling up the reserved vacancies by promotion by se(
lection, those PWBD candidates who are within the normal zone
of consideration shall be considered for promotion. However, if
adequate number of PWBD candidates of the respective category
are not available within the normal zone, the zone of considera(
tion may be extended to five times the number of vacancies and
the PwBD candidate falling within the extended zone may be con(
sidered for promotion. In the event of non(availability of candi(
dates even in the extended zone, the vacancy shall not be filled
and be carried forward to the subsequent year. In the subsequent
year, if a PwBD of the required category is not available, the
reservation can be exchanged with the other categories, so that
post can be filled by a person with other category of disability, if
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
possible. If a PwBD candidate of other category is within the zone
of consideration and within the number of vacancies available, he
cannot be denied promotion on the grounds of disability. If it is
not possible to fill up the post by reservation even in the 2nd year,
the post may be filled by a person other than a PwBD, and the
reservation shall be carried forward for two subsequent recruit(
ment years, whereafter it shall lapse.
14.2 While filling up vacancies by promotion by non(selection, the
eligible candidates with benchmark disabilities within the normal
zone of consideration shall be considered for promotion against
the reserved vacancies. In case no eligible candidate of the re(
spective category of disability is available in the normal zone of
consideration, additional PwBD candidates of respective category
to the extent required shall be considered by going down the se(
niority list, provided they are eligible, and that the post is identi(
fied for them. In the event of non(availability of PwBD candidates
for promotion even in the extended zone, the vacancy shall not be
filled and shall be carried forward. In the subsequent year if
PwBD of respective category is not available, the same can be ex(
changed with other categories of disabilities identified for it. If it
is not possible to fill up the vacancy by reservation even by ex(
change, the reservation shall be carried forward for two subse(
quent recruitment years, whereafter it shall lapse
14.3 In order to ensure that cases of lapse of reservation are kept
to the minimum, any recruitment of the PwBD candidates shall
first be counted against the vacant posts brought forward from
previous years, if any, in the chronological order. If candidates are
not available for all the vacancies, the older carried(forward
posts shall be filled first, and the current vacancies shall be car(
ried forward, if not filled up, provided that in every recruitment,
the number of vacancies reserved for PWBD, including the car(
ried forward vacancies, shall be announced beforehand for the in(
formation of all aspirants.”
Instructions dated 11.07.2023 (Annexure P 16 in CWP 37099
2025)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
“Subject: Grant of Reservation in Promotion to the Persons with
Benchmark Disabilities under the Rights of Persons with Dis
abilities Act, 2016.
xxx
xxx
xxx
6. IDENTIFICATION OF POSTS:(
6.1 The State Government, Department of Social Justice& Em(
powerment, Haryana has already adopted the list of identified
posts circulated by the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment
(Department of Disability Affairs), Government of India, New
Delhi vide their Notification No. 38(16/2020(DDIII dated 4th Jan(
uary, 2021. The adoption of such 'list' by the State Government
was conveyed vide notification bearing No.459(SW(4)/2021, dated
25th October, 2021 of the Social Justice & Empowerment Depart(
ment, Haryana.
The 'list' of posts is not an exhaustive list. The Departments, Pub(
lic Sector Undertakings and the Autonomous Bodies can fur(
ther supplement the list. If a post is already held by a person with
disability, it shall be deemed to have been identified. The nomen(
clature used in the 'list' includes any other nomenclature used for
comparable posts with functions identical to the posts identified in
the said notification.
9. RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:(
9.1 If sufficient number of PwBD candidates with benchmark
disabilities are not available on the basis of prescribed standard
to fill all the vacancies (in case of promotion through Limited De(
partmental Competitive Examination/ Departmental Examination,
etc.) reserved for them, candidates belonging to this category may
be selected on relaxed standard to fill up the remaining vacancies
reserved for them, provided they are not found unfit for such post
or posts. However, this provision shall not be used to allow any
relaxation in the eligibility criteria laid down for the issuance of
certificate of benchmark disability.
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
9.2 The same relaxed standard should be applied for all the
PwBD candidates with benchmark disabilities, irrespective of
whether they belong to the Unreserved/Scheduled Caste/Back(
ward Classes category. No further relaxation of standards will be
considered or admissible in favour of any candidate from any cat(
egory whatsoever.”
'
!!
)
)
)
)
)
*
B
*
)
)
*
)
)
* )
2 6
!#-$. %&%!
)
!#&++ %&%$
Devender Aggarwal’s
Naveen
Kumar’s
%$ &" %&-A
%&%$'
3 6
* 3
)
*
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)
*
)
--
!#&++
3 @ 3
*
!"#$% %&%$
Sohan Singh?
*
*
*
:
* 3
3 *
!"
(supra)
0 *
*
*
),
% 3'
!
)3
*
2 3
)
*
)
)
)
*
)
*
)
0 *
)3
)
*
( * )
*
2 ?)
Vikash
Kumar Vs. Union Public Service Commission, (2021) 5 SCC 370,
0 *
*
)
(
H
6 *
“35. The principle of reasonable accommodation captures the
positive obligation of the State and private parties to provide
additional support to persons with disabilities to facilitate their
full and effective participation in society. The concept of
reasonable accommodation is developed in section (H) below. For
the present, suffice it to say that, for a person with disability, the
constitutionally guaranteed fundamental rights to equality, the
six freedoms and the right to life under Article 21 will ring
hollow if they are not given this additional support that helps
make these rights real and meaningful for them. Reasonable
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
=
accommodation is the instrumentality ( are an obligation as a
society ( to enable the disabled to enjoy the constitutional
guarantee of equality and non(discrimination. In this context, it
would be apposite to remember Justice R M Lodha's (as he then
was) observation in Justice Sunanda Bhandare Foundation v.
Union of India, (2018) 2 SCC 397, where he stated:
"9...In the matters of providing relief to those who are
differently abled, the approach and attitude of the executive
must be liberal and relief oriented and not obstructive or
lethargic…”
xxx
xxx
xxx
45. The principle of reasonable accommodation acknowledges
that if disability as a social construct has to be remedied,
conditions have to be affirmatively created for facilitating the
development of the disabled. Reasonable accommodation is
founded in the norm of inclusion. Exclusion results in the
negation of individual dignity and worth or they can choose the
route of reasonable accommodation, where each individuals'
dignity and worth is respected. Under this route, the "powerful
and the majority adapt their own rules and practices, within the
limits of reason and short of undue hardship, to permit realization
of these ends.”
'
!$
B
( * @
2 ?)
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal Vs. Union of India, 2021(3) SCR 823
:
:
0 *
* (
6 3
(
)
H
6 *6
“28. Article 14 of the Indian Constitution states that "the State
shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal
protection of the laws within the territory of India". The right to
equality under the Indian Constitution has two facets ( formal
equality and substantive equality. While formal equality means
that every person, irrespective of their attributes must be treated
equally and must not be discriminated against; substantive
equality is aimed at producing equality of outcomes through
different modes of affirmative action. The principle of
reasonable accommodation is one of the means for achieving
substantive equality, pursuant to which disabled individuals
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
must be reasonably accommodated based on their individual
capacities. Disability, as a social construct, precedes the medical
condition of an individual. The sense of disability is introduced
because of the absence of access to facilities.”
'
!$ %
6 (
* )
2 ?)
Kabir
Paharia Vs. National Medical Commission, 2025 AIR SC 2861
0 *
* (
“5. The constitutional promise of equality is not merely formal
but substantive, requiring the State to take affirmative measures
to ensure that PwD and PwBD can meaningfully participate in
all spheres of life, including professional education. We
emphasize that reasonable accommodation is not a matter of
charity but a fundamental right flowing from Articles 14, 16,
and 21 of our Constitution. When administrative authorities
create arbitrary barriers that exclude qualified PwBD candidates,
they not only violate statutory provisions but also perpetuate the
historical injustice and stigmatisation. The fundamental rights and
the dignity of PwD and PwBD candidates must be protected by
ensuring that assessment of their capabilities is individualised,
evidence(based, and free from stereotypical assumptions that have
no scientific foundation.”
'
!$ !
( * )
?)
Om
Rathod Vs. Director General of Health Services, 2024 SCC OnLine SC
0 *
*
(
, 3 H
“28. Justice KV Viswanathan speaking for this Court in Omkar
Gond (supra) has applied a purposive interpretation to the
guidelines (Appendix "H(1") in the context of a medical aspirant
with dialectic incapacity. This Court held that the principle of
reasonable accommodation in Section 2(y) of the RPWD Act
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
read with Article 41 of the Constitution necessarily means that
(i) a person cannot be disqualified merely on the basis of a
benchmark quantification. Such a criteria would be
unconstitutional for being overbroad; (ii) the Disability
Assessment Board must not act as monotonous automations
looking at the quantified disability and disqualifying candidates.
The Board must examine if the candidate can pursue the course
with their disability; and (iii) in doing so, the Board is not merely
obliged to provide assistive devices and other substances which
will help the candidate. The true role of the Board is to assess the
competence of a candidate.
29. The principle of reasonable accommodation is not only
statutorily prescribed but also rooted in the fundamental rights
guaranteed to persons with disabilities under Part III of the
Constitution. Reasonable accommodation is a fundamental right.
It is a gateway right for persons with disabilities to enjoy all the
other rights enshrined in the Constitution and the law. Without
the gateway right of reasonable accommodation, a person with
disability is forced to navigate in a world which excludes them by
design. It strikes a fatal blow to their ability to make life choices
and pursue opportunities. From mundane tasks of daily life to
actions undertaken to realise personal and professional
aspirations ( all are throttled when reasonable accommodations
are denied. Reasonable accommodation is a facet of substantive
equality and its failure constitutes discrimination. In Vikash
Kumar v. UPSC, (2021) 5 SCC 370 this Court adjudicated on
whether a person with a writer's cramp is entitled to a scribe for
writing the examination. Allowing the use of a scribe, this Court
held that the benchmark standard can only be applied where
expressly stipulated. Section 2(s) of the RPWD Act defines a
person with disability as a person with long term physical, mental,
intellectual or sensory impairment which, in interaction with
barriers, hinders their full and effective participation in society
equally with others. Therefore, a person ( to be considered as a
person with disability ( does not have to qualify any benchmark.
The principle that the rights and entitlements cannot be
constricted by adopting a benchmark as a condition precedent was
also upheld by this Court in Avni Prakash v. NTA (2023) 2 SCC
286.
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
“47. When reasonable accommodation is denied to a person with
disability, it amounts to discrimination and violates the
fundamental rights of the aggrieved person and the preambular
virtue of fraternity along with justice, liberty and equality.
Persons with disability are not objects of pity or charity but an
integral part of our society and nation. The advancement of rights
for persons with disabilities is a national project along with
eradication of all forms of discrimination. A component of this
project is the inclusion of persons with disabilities in all pursuits
of life.”
'
!.
B
*
-$ &A %&-A
*
*
)
<
-# &$ %&%%
)3
*
3 =
)
@
)3
@
2*
Munna Lal Yadav Vs. Department of Empowerment of Persons With
Disabilities and others, W.P.(C) 7197/2021
0 *
*
(
6 *6
“45. Section 20 of the RPwD Act further mandates that the
Government has to ensure that no Government establishment shall
discriminate against any PwDs in any matter relating to
employment, and shall provide reasonable accommodation and
appropriate barrier free and conducive environment to employees
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
with disability. It shall ensure that no promotion shall be denied to
a person merely on the ground of disability and no Government
establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank an employee
who acquires a disability during his or her service.
xxx
xxx
xxx
48. The “Reasonable Accommodation” is defined in Section 2(y)
of the RPwD Act, as under:
“(y) “reasonable accommodation” means necessary and
appropriate modification and adjustments, without imposing
a disproportionate or undue burden in a particular case, to
ensure to persons with disabilities the enjoyment or exercise
of rights equally with others.”
49. A reading of the above provisions together, therefore,
establishes that every Government Establishment is to ensure
that there inter alia should not be any restriction on an employee
on the basis of the disability, and necessary and appropriate
relaxations and adjustments, without imposing disproportionate
or undue burden on the employers, should be made, in
particular to ensure that the PwD enjoys or exercises rights at
par with others.
xxx
xxx
xxx
56. From the above, it would be evident that the RPwD Act
requires a relaxed standard to be adopted as far as the PwDs or
PwBDs are concerned. The Supreme Court has further held that
in case enough suitable candidates are not available after
selection, further relaxation can be done in assessing the
suitability of the candidate.
This is also the mandate of the Office Memorandums dated
15.01.2018 and 17.05.2022 issued by the DoPT, which prescribe
as under:
“11. RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
11.1 If sufficient number of candidates with benchmark
disabilities candidates are not available on the basis of the
general standard to fill all the vacancies reserved for them.
candidates belonging to this category may be selected on
relaxed standard to fill up the remaining vacancies reserved
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
for them provided they are not found unfit for such post or
posts. However, this provision shall not be used to allow any
relaxation in the eligibility criteria laid down for the issuance
of certificate of disability.
11.2 Same relaxed standard should be applied for all the
candidates with Benchmark Disabilities whether they belong
to Unreserved/SC/ST/OBC. No further relaxation standards
will be considered or admissible in favour of any candidate
from a category whatsoever.”
Office Memorandum Dated 17.05.2022:
“8. RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
8.1. If sufficient number of PwBD candidates with benchmark
disabilities are not available on the basis of the prescribed
standard to fill the vacancies (in case of promotion through
Limited
Departmental
Competitive
Examination/Departmental Examination, etc.) reserved for
them, candidates belonging to this category may be selected
on relaxed standard to fill up the remaining vacancies
reserved for them, provided they are not found unfit for such
post or posts. However, this provision shall not be used to
allow any relaxation in eligibility criteria laid down for the
issuance of certificate of benchmark disability.
8.2 The same relaxed standard should be applied for all the
PwBD candidates with benchmark disabilities, irrespective of
whether they belong to the Unreserved/ SC/ ST/ OBC
category. No further relaxation of standards will be
considered or admissible in favour of any candidate for any
category whatsoever.”
!#
, *
Sachin Kumar?
),
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
)3
supra'
)
*
@
:
3 *
)
)
!$F
3)
:
< 6
)
)
*
3 )
*
*
3 *
)3
)
:
*
3 6
) *
*
)
)3
*
3 2 6
@
)3
*
<
)
>reasonable accommodation’
% 3' ! $'
<
:
*
*
<
)3 *
*
*
)
)3
)
)
2 6
ex facie
B
C
*
*
)
)
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
!A
*
*
3 9
)
)
*
)3
*
)
)
)
*
<
sub judice )
? $
!+
<
)
:
6 *
“Implementing relaxation in selection standards for persons
with disabilities in order to provide them reasonable
accommodations, in terms of Sections 2(y) & 3(5) of the
RPWD Act, does not violate Articles 14 & 16 of the
Constitution of India. If the selection process carried out on
strict equal terms in a mechanical manner, the cause of
substantive equality would fail. Thus, providing differential
treatment to the persons with disabilities treatment to
remove disadvantage does not violate Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution. The State bears the responsibility to
remove barriers that obstruct genuine opportunities for
persons with disabilities and such relaxation ensures that
equality becomes real, meaningful and transformative
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
rather than merely formal and illusory. As such, the
relaxation in selection criteria for persons with disabilities is
not a concession but a constitutional obligation to achieve
substantive equality in furtherance of Article 14, 16, 21 of
the Constitution and the statutory framework of the RPWD
Act.”
"&
*3
6 *
'
2 3
)
)
*
-# &$ %&%%
-$ &A %&-A
)3
* 1
<
2 ?)
,
In re: Recruitment of Visually
Imparied in Judicial Services?
Kumar?
supra'
)
supra'
Om Rathod?
G
&" 6 0
Vikash
supra'
&% 6 0
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
*
B
2 3
'
B
)
&% 6 0
*
C
*
'
<
*
)
3)
3)
@6
&% 6 0
'
, )
2 3
C
*
*
*
*
G
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
,
=
'
C
, ) 2 3
*
)3 6 3
)
&!
'
)
2 3
*
, )
C
*
"-
*
"%
'
)
)
@
%# &% %&%.
vishnu
VISHNU
2026.02.28 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document
Punjab and Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh
0 *;
H ;4
)
H ;4
$
A
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review