Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16th March, 2026
Pronounced on: 8th June, 2026
+
RFA 991/2023, , CM APPL. 65697/2023 (stay), CM APPL.
65698/2023 (delay) & CM APPL. 65702/2023 (delay)
SMT. SONU
W/o Shri Naresh
R/o F-215, Gali No.19,
Pul Prahladpur, New Delhi-110044.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Narendra Malawaliya, Advocate.
Versus
HUKAM SINGH (since deceased)
S/o Sh. Saroppa
Through his LRs
(1a) SMT. SHEELA
W/o Late Hukam Singh
(1b) ROBIN
S/o Late Hukam Singh
(1c) DARSHANA
D/o Late Hukam Singh
(1d) URMILA
D/o Late Hukam Singh
All R/o RZF-200, Gali No.18,
Pul Prahladpur,
New Delhi-110044.
Through:
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
.....Respondents
Mr. Nagendra Kasana, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Section 151 CPC
has been filed by the Appellant/Defendant Smt. Sonu to challenge the exparte Judgment and decree dated 18.10.2019, whereby the Suit of the
Respondent/ Plaintiff Shri Hukam Singh, has been partly decreed and the
Appellant has been directed to hand over the Possession of the Suit property
and she has been restrained from creating third party interest, in the Suit
property.
2.
The Respondent/Plaintiff Shri Hukam Singh had filed a Suit bearing
CS No. 8091/2016 for Possession and Permanent Injunction.
3.
The facts, in brief, are that the property bearing No.F-215/19 (Old
No.RZH-40A), Mittal Colony, Pul Prahladpur, New Delhi-110044,
admeasuring 30 sq. yards (herein referred to as the “Suit Property”) was
originally owned by Shri Sunil Kumar, who vide Agreement to Sell, etc.
dated 21.02.1990 sold the Suit Property to Munna Babu, who in turn sold
the Suit Property vide Agreement to Sell, etc. dated 05.11.1993 to Smt.
Vishan Devi.
4.
The Plaintiff, Hukam Singh purchased the Suit property from Smt.
Vishan Devi, his real sister, on 07.03.2004, vide Agreement to Sell etc. for a
sale consideration of Rs.2,35,000/- and also acquired the peaceful, vacant
possession of the Suit property. He therefore, became an exclusive and sole
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
owner of the Suit Property. He also got an electricity meter installed in his
name on 07.03.2004 and has been regularly paying the electricity Bill.
5.
Smt. Vishan Devi was suffering from various age related ailments.
The Plaintiff along with his family used to frequently visit her on every
alternate day.
Smt. Vishan Devi died on 10.06.2014 and the
Defendant/Appellant Smt. Sonu, came to attend the funeral.
She claimed
herself to be the step-daughter of Smt. Vishan Devi, Plaintiff‟s sister and
requested to stay overnight. The Plaintiff being unaware of the malafide
motive of Smt. Sonu, permitted her to stay for one night only.
6.
However, on her request, he permitted her to stay till the Tehrvi of
Smt. Vishan Devi. However, after the Tehrvi ceremony despite repeated
requests of the Plaintiff, the Defendant refused to vacate the Suit Property,
and with the help of local goons, threatened the Plaintiff with dire
consequences. Thereafter, the Plaintiff approached the Police, but no action
was taken.
7.
The Plaintiff submitted that he had the knowledge that his sister
Late Smt. Vishan Devi, had severed all her relations with Smt. Sonu and had
debarred and disowned her from all the properties, vide Public Notice dated
27.11.2011 published in Newspaper „Rashtriya Sahara‟.
The Plaintiff
claimed that the permission granted to the Defendant/Appellant had already
been withdrawn and she has no right to continue in the Suit Property, in
which she is in possession as a trespasser.
8.
He further submitted that the Suit Property could easily fetch a
monthly rent of Rs.10,000/- per month, which he is losing and claimed an
amount of Rs.10,000/- per month for user and occupation charges. The Suit
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
was thus, filed by the Plaintiff/Respondent for directing the Defendant to
handover the peaceful and vacant possession of the Suit property, and to
restrain her from creating any third-party rights in the suit property. The
damages for unlawful use and occupation of the Suit Property, were also
claimed.
9.
The Appellant/Defendant Smt. Sonu in her Written Statement took
the preliminary objection that the Suit is barred by limitation as the alleged
sale documents are of the year 2004. Moreover, the value of the Suit
Property was more than Rs.24 lakhs and the Court had no jurisdiction. It
was further asserted that Smt. Vishan Devi, her mother had not sold the Suit
Property to the Plaintiff and no cause of action was disclosed in the Plaint.
10.
The Defendant also asserted that she had been residing in the Suit
premises since her birth, being the only legal heir of the deceased mother.
She had full right, title, interest in the Suit property, and the Suit of the
Plaintiff was liable to be dismissed.
11.
She further claimed that Plaintiff had hatched conspiracy with
BSES, to get the electricity connection transferred in his name, without the
consent of the Defendant, who is the owner of the Suit Property after the
demise of her mother Smt. Vishan Devi.
12.
On merits, it is asserted that Smt. Vishan Devi, her mother was the
exclusive owner of the Suit Property. She denied that the property was ever
sold by her to the Plaintiff, as alleged by him. It is claimed that Plaintiff had
made false and fabricated documents of the Suit Property. Moreover, the
Suit had not been filed during the lifetime of Smt. Vishan Devi, which
shows the clear manipulation by the Plaintiff, to grab the Suit Property.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
13.
It was claimed by the Defendant/Appellant that she was residing in
the Suit Property, as a family member of the Vishan Devi. She denied that
she came to attend the funeral of Smt. Vishan Devi on 10.06.2014 or had
been permitted to stay in the Suit property by the Plaintiff for a few days, to
attend the Tehrvi ceremony. It is claimed that she has an absolute right, title
and interest in the Suit property being the daughter of Smt. Vishan Devi and
is in possession of the Suit property. It was submitted that the Suit of the
Plaintiff was liable to be dismissed.
14.
The Plaintiff in his Replication reaffirmed the assertions made in
the Plaint and denied the allegations made in the Written Statement.
15.
In the pleadings, the Issues were framed as under :
(i) Whether the Suit of the Plaintiff is not maintainable for want of
pecuniary jurisdiction? OPD.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
(ii)
Whether the Suit Property is inherited by the Defendant as
being the Legal Heir of Smt. Vishan Devi w/o Sh. Ramji Lal?
OPD
(iii)
Whether the Plaintiff has purchased the Suit Property as stated
in para 2 of the Plaint? OPP.
(iv)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for the Recovery of Possession
of immovable property ie. property ad measuring 30 sq. yards
bearing no. F-215/19 (old no. RZH-40A), Mittal Colony, Pul
Prahladpur, New Delhi-110044 specifically shown in the site
plan, Annexure A of the Plaint? OPP.
(v)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for the Decree of Permanent
Injunction whereby Defendant is to be restrained from creating
any third party interest in the Suit Property i.e. property admeasuring 30 sq. yards bearing no. F-215/19 (old no. RZH40A, Mittal Colony, Pul Prahladpur, New Delhi-110044
RFA 991/2023
specifically shown in the site plan, Annexure A of the Plaint?
OPP.
(vi)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for any damages on account of
unlawful occupation, if yes; to what amount and for what
period? OPP.
(vii) Relief.
16.
The Plaintiff in support of his evidence examined himself, as PW1.
17.
PW2 Smt. Rani, sister and PW3 Sh. Sonu brother of the Plaintiff,
corroborated the testimony of the Plaintiff.
18.
PW4 Sh. Devender is a witness to the GPA documents dated
07.03.2004, in favour of the Plaintiff.
19.
No evidence was led by the Defendant and her opportunity to
lead the evidence, was closed.
20.
Learned District Judge on appreciation of the evidence and the
testimony of the four witnesses, concluded that the Plaintiff, Hukam Singh
had purchased the Suit Property by virtue of GPA etc. dated 07.03.2004
from his sister Smt. Vishan Devi. These documents though may not create
absolute ownership, but conferred possessory rights to the Plaintiff.
21.
The Defendant/Appellant had claimed herself to be the daughter of
Smt. Vishan Devi, but had failed to produce any evidence whatsoever, to
prove that she was the daughter of Smt. Vishan Devi. Therefore, it was held
that the Defendant had not been able to prove herself to be the daughter or
possess any right to continue in the Suit premises.
22.
In so far as the damages were concerned, it was observed that no
cogent evidence had been led by the Plaintiff and the damages were denied.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
However, the Suit for Possession was decreed, and the Defendant was
directed to handover the peaceful possession of the Suit property within four
weeks permanently, and was restrained from creating any third-party interest
in the Suit property.
23.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated 18.10.2019, Smt.
Sonu, the Defendant/Appellant has filed the present Appeal.
24.
The Plaintiff had filed Affidavits of four witnesses, in support of her
case. The Plaintiff was duly cross-examined by the Counsel for the
Appellant.
However, on 21.02.2019, when the other witnesses were
examined, they could not be cross-examined by the Counsel for the
Appellant, since he was suffering from stomach pain/colitis and the
Appellant was not available as she had gone out of town for some urgent
work.
Perhaps, the opportunity of the Appellant/Defendant to cross-
examine the Plaintiff‟s witnesses was, therefore, closed.
25.
Thereafter, on 06.05.2019 no steps were taken by the Plaintiff to
summon further witnesses, and the evidence of the Plaintiff was closed on
that day. The matter was listed on 06.06.2019 for the evidence of the
Defendant/Appellant. However, the counsel for the Defendant could not
appear as he met with an accident on 06.04.2019 and FIR No.179/2019
under Section 279/337 IPC P.S. Ambedkar Nagar, was registered. The
learned Counsel got bed ridden and his mobile got damaged. The Defendant
was therefore, unable to contact the Counsel and none appeared in the
Court on behalf of the Defendant on 06.06.2019.
26.
Thereafter, she contacted the previous counsel to know about the
status of the case. Then on 17.10.2019 the counsel for the Defendant
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
inspected the case file and came to know that because of non-appearance of
Defendant and the counsel, opportunity to lead evidence by the Defendant
was closed on 21.02.2019. The Defendant engaged a new counsel who
appeared on 18.10.2019 and filed the Vakalatnama, though an ex-parte
judgment dated 18.10.2019 was announced.
27.
The Appellant then moved an Application under Order 9 Rule 13
CPC read with Section 151 CPC for setting aside the ex-parte Judgement
dated 18.10.2019. However, the Application was dismissed on 16.08.2022,
by observing that no cogent explanation had been tendered by the Appellant.
28.
Therefore, on 31.10.2022, LRs of Respondent/Plaintiff filed an
Execution Petition No.417/2022 before learned ADJ, South-East, Saket
Court. The Warrants of Possession had been issued against the Appellant.
The Bailiff reached the Suit property and it is only then, that the Appellant
came to know about the filing of Execution Petition qua the ex-parte
Judgment.
29.
She then contacted her counsel, who inspected the Court file and
they came to know about the Execution Petition.
The entire set of
documents was provided by the Appellant, to her Counsel. After scrutiny,
the counsel for the Appellant found that a pre-mediation summon/request
letter along with documents and Application, was issued by the Mediation
Centre in Pre-litigation Case No.13/2014 dated 10.11.2014 by late Hukam
Singh prior to filing of the Suit, but this fact had been concealed by the
Respondent.
30.
Reliance is placed on A.V. Papayya Sastry & Ors. vs. Govt. of A.P
and Ors., decided on 07.03.2007, wherein the Supreme Court held that the
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
litigant who approached the Court, is bound to produce all the documents
executed by him which are relevant for the litigation. If vital documents are
withheld in order to gain advantage on the other side, then he would be
guilty of playing fraud upon the Court as well as the opposite party. It was
thus, held that the principle of finality of litigation, cannot be pressed to the
extent of such an absurdity that it becomes an engine of fraud in the hands of
dishonest litigants.
31.
The Objections were filed in the Execution Petition, wherein the
counsel for the Appellant compared the documents i.e. GPA, Will etc., with
the documents filed in the Mediation Centre in pre-mediation process. On
comparison of the documents, the Appellant realized that forgery, perjury
and manipulation in the entire set of title documents filed with the Suit had
been done, and the Judgment dated 18.10.2019 and Decree dated 01.08.2023
had been obtained fraudulently.
32.
It was claimed that the entire chain of documents qua the Suit
property had been manipulated, as a new Municipal Property Number had
been mentioned, even though no new number had been allocated to the Suit
property.
33.
The Appellant claimed that the Respondent is trying to grab the
property of the Appellant, through a deep-rooted conspiracy and has
committed perjury and fraud upon the Court.
34.
Furthermore, the Execution Petition No.417/2022 was not
maintainable, as the Decree had been obtained by fraud. The Execution
Petition has been dismissed, on 16.05.2023.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
Thereafter, the Appellant
preferred an Application for Review of the Order, but the same was
withdrawn on 11.07.2023.
35.
The Respondent had also filed SC No.1525/2015 titled as “Hukam
Singh vs. The State” for grant of Succession Certificate in respect of
employees benefits, etc. of the Appellant‟s mother. The Appellant‟s name
was deleted from the array of parties in the said Petition and it was
concealed that the Appellant is the only daughter, entitled to compensation
and other benefits, as Smt. Vishan Devi was the Government employee.
36.
The Succession Certificate was granted, and Hukam Singh along
with his brother withdrew the entire amount from the Employer i.e
Retirement Benefits GPF etc. A total sum of Rs.10,62,315/- was withdrawn.
When the Appellant came to know, she filed an Appeal against the Order of
grant of Succession Certificate, whereby the Appeal was allowed and the
grant of Succession Certificate which was obtained by fraud, was set aside
and the matter was remanded back with directions to array the Appellant
Smt. Sonu as a party.
37.
The learned ACJ-cum-CCJ-cum-ARC, South-East directed the
Respondent to deposit back the entire amount that had been fraudulently
withdrawn, under the Certificate of Succession.
38.
Reliance is placed on S.P Chengalvaraya Naidu vs. Jagannath AIR
1994 SCC (1) 1, wherein the Supreme Court held that fraud avoids all
judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal. It is settled proposition of law that a
Judgment and Decree obtained by fraud, is a nullity and non-est in law.
39.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court in the case of Indian Bank vs.
Satyam Fibres (India) Pvt. Ltd. (1996) 5 SCC 550 held that the judiciary in
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
India, also possesses inherent power especially under Section 151 CPC to
recall its Judgment and Order, if it is obtained by fraud.
40.
The Appellant has challenged the impugned Order dated 16.08.2022
and ex-parte Judgment dated 18.10.2019, on the grounds that the alleged
property documents had been forged and manipulated, to the extent of
mentioning new number of the Suit property as F-215/19, Mittal Colony, Pul
Prahlad Pur, New Delhi on each document. The signatures of the witnesses
were obtained on those documents just before the filing of the Suit, as is
evident from the perusal of the documents.
41.
The ADJ has failed to appreciate that there was no Agreement to
Sell in respect of the Suit Property and the alleged Agreement was without,
consideration and is void.
42.
It is further averred that from the cross-examination of the
Respondent, it is established that he never purchased the Suit property and
no documents were ever executed in his favour. The Suit for Possession
was therefore, not maintainable, without seeking Declaration.
43.
It is settled law that as per the Section 17 of Registration Act read
with Section 49 of Registration Act, that where the consideration amount is
more than Rs.100/- qua the transfer of immovable property, it must be
registered. The transferred documents are all false and fabricated and are
unregistered and do not create any right, title, interest in favour of the
Plaintiff. Furthermore, these documents were executed in the month of
March, 2004, but it was suppressed that at the time of execution of the
alleged documents, new property number had not been allotted. This fact
has been clarified from the Ration Card in the name of Smt. Vishan Devi
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
Ex.PW1/3 which had been filed by the Respondent. The Ration Card was
issued on 03.11.2004 and the address was mentioned as H-40A, Block
Mittal Chowk, Pul Prahlad Pur, Tuglakabad, New Delhi i.e. the old
Municipal Number.
44.
Furthermore, in Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of
Haryana & Anr. SLP (C) 13917 of 2009 and Judgment Ramesh Chand vs.
Suresh Chand 2025 INSC 1059 relied by the learned ADJ in the Judgment
dated 18.10.2016, is not applicable to the facts in the present case.
45.
In Smriti Debbarma vs. Prabha Ranjan Debbarma 2023 Civil
Appeal No.178/2019 the Supreme Court held that the Plaintiff must
establish his legal title to the property, to be entitled to a Decree of
Possession. The Defendant cannot be dispossessed, unless the Plaintiff has
established a better right and title over the Suit property. A person who is in
possession, is assumed to have a character of owner and has a legal right
against the entire world except the rightful owner.
46.
It is further submitted that the non-appearance of the Counsel for the
Defendant during the cross-examination of some witnesses of the Plaintiff
and inability to lead the evidence of the Appellant was for the circumstances
explained herein above.
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned
Judgment dated 18.10.2019 be set aside.
47.
The Respondent in reply to the Appeal, has submitted that the
learned ADJ has given cogent reasons for decreeing the Suit, in favour of
the Plaintiff. It is further explained that the Application under Order 9 Rule
13 (4) CPC filed by the Appellant, was dismissed vide Order dated
16.08.2022, which has not been challenged further by the Appellant.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
48.
Furthermore, first Execution Petition No.417/2022 was dismissed
for want of Decree Sheet, as the counsel for the Plaintiff had inadvertently
forgotten to deposit the deficit Court Fee of Rs.231/- and Decree sheet was
not prepared. Deficit Court Fee was deposited, thereafter second Execution
Petition No.612/2023 was filed, which is pending adjudication.
49.
It is submitted that the Suit Property was self-acquired property of
the Plaintiff‟s sister, from whom the Plaintiff had purchased the Suit
Property. The Succession Certificate in his favour in respect of the movable
properties of Late Smt. Vishan Devi, has already been granted.
It is,
therefore, submitted that there is no merit in the present Appeal, which is
liable to be dismissed.
50.
The Appellant in the Rejoinder has reaffirmed the grounds as stated
in the Appeal.
Submissions heard and record perused.
51.
The Plaintiff/Respondent had filed a Suit for Possession on the basis
of the Agreement to Sell etc. executed in his favour. He had explained the
chain of ownership and had deposed that the Suit Property was purchased by
Munna Babu from Sunil Kumar through Agreement to Sell, GPA etc. dated
21.02.1990 Ex.PW1/14 and Ex.PW1/15 respectively.
Thereafter, Shri
Munna Babu sold the property to Smt. Vishan Devi the real sister of the
Plaintiff vide Agreement to Sell, GPA, Receipt etc. dated 05.11.2019 Ex.
PW1/10 to Ex.PW1/13.
52.
Smt. Vishan Devi, the real sister sold the Suit Property to the
Plaintiff vide GPA, Agreement to Sell, etc. dated 07.03.2004 which are
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
Ex.PW1/4 to Ex. 1/9.
PW1 Sh. Hukum Singh, the Plaintiff, who proved
these documents, was duly cross-examined by the Defendant, but no
contradiction could be brought forth in the cross-examination.
53.
The only aspect on which the Appellant challenged the genuineness
of the document, was that the new Municipal Number i.e. F-215/19 was
mentioned in the Agreement to Sell, when in fact this new number had not
been allocated to the Suit Property. The Plaintiff may have mentioned the
new property number, but the identity of the property is not in question.
Pertinently, no cogent evidence has been laid by the Appellant to prove that
these documents were fraudulent. Merely because the new property number
has been mentioned would be of little consequence in view of the identity of
the property not being in dispute.
54.
The entire chain of documents in respect of the purchase of the Suit
property from Sunil Kumar till the Plaintiff, have been duly proved. The
chain of documents coupled with those in favour of the Plaintiff, therefore,
established that the Plaintiff acquired proprietary rights in the property in
question vide documents dated 07.03.2004, and that he acquired the legal
possession in the Suit Property.
55.
Smt. Vishan Devi being the sister of the Plaintiff, may have
continued to reside in the Suit property, but the Plaintiff acquired
proprietary/possessory rights in the Suit Property. It is established that the
possession of Smt. Vishan Devi was merely permissive, once the property
was purchased by the Plaintiff, on 07.03.2004.
56.
The Plaintiff deposed that Smt. Vishan Devi was residing in the Suit
Property till her demise, on 10.06.2014. According to his testimony, the
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
Appellant Smt. Sonu, came to attend the last rights of Smt. Vishan Devi and
was permitted by him to occupy the Suit premises, but thereafter she refused
to vacate.
57.
The Appellant had claimed that she had been residing with Smt.
Vishan Devi. The Plaintiff had admitted that the marriage of the Appellant
took place on the Suit premises. The Appellant may have been living with
Smt. Vishan Devi during her lifetime and may have gotten married from the
suit premises, but thereafter, it is only Smt. Vishan Devi who was residing in
the Suit Property. The Appellant has not been able to show that she has any
legal right to continue in the premises, once it got sold to the Plaintiff.
58.
The controversy of the Appellant being the real or the step daughter,
is of little consequence, in the light of the proprietary documents executed in
favour of the Plaintiff/ Respondent and were duly proved. Likewise, much
emphasis has been laid by the Appellant that a Succession Petition in respect
of the movable goods of the deceased Smt. Vishan Devi, who was a
Government employee, was filed.
59.
Though, the appellant, Smt. Sonu was a party initially, but her name
was deleted and the Succession Certificate was issued in the name of the
Respondent and he along with his brother, withdrew the benefits of Smt.
Vishan Devi in the sum of Rs.10,62,315/-.
60.
The Appellant thereafter, filed an Application and the Succession
Certificate so granted in favour of the Respondent, was set aside and the
case was re-opened. Not only this, the Respondent was directed to deposit
the released amount, back in the Court.
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
61.
Now this aspect again is of little consequence in the present Suit,
which was solely based on the proprietary right of the Plaintiff, to claim the
Possession of the Suit property.
Whatever may be the status of the
Appellant, she is deriving it from Smt. Vishan Devi. Once, it is proved that
Smt. Vishan Devi had sold the Suit Property to the Plaintiff, the Appellant
cannot claim any superior rights than Smt. Vishan Devi.
62.
The learned ADJ has thus, rightly held that on the basis of the GPA,
etc. the Plaintiff was able to establish his better title over the Appellant, in
respect of Suit property. He may not be an absolute owner in the classical
sense of having a Sale Deed in his favour, but he had better proprietary title
than the Appellant, who has not been able to establish any right, title,
interest in the Suit property.
The learned ADJ, therefore, has rightly
decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff for Possession and Injunction from
restraining the Appellant from creating any third party rights in the Suit
property.
63.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby,
dismissed.
64.
The pending Application(s), if any, are also disposed of,
accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 8, 2026
va
KUMAR BHATT
11:30:13
RFA 991/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review