The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Bearing in mind the stand and the statements so made by the respective parties as per the instruction received by them and also the law on the said subject as discussed above, the instant second appeal is being partly allowed while modifying the judgment and the order dated 02.04.2015 and decree dated 13.04.2015 passed by Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No. 1, Gorakhpur in O.S. No. 5 of 2013 (Smt. Shanti Devi and others versus Ashok Kumar and others) and the judgment and the order dated 07.08.2026 and the decree dated 13.08.2026 passed by Additional District Judge, Court No. 5, Gorakhpur in Civil Appeal No. 51 of 2015 (Smt. Shanti Devi and others versus Ashok Kumar) to the extent that in place of rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 (d) of the C.P.C., the same would be returned with a liberty to the plaintiff-appellants to present the same before the competent court of law in accordance with law. SAPL No. 725 of 2026
16. Accordingly, the second appeal is being partly allowed. October 8, 2026 Ashu (Vikas Budhwar,J.) High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
SECOND APPEAL No. - 725 of 2026
Smt Shanti Devi Widow And 5 Others
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
Ashok Kumar And 3 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s)
Counsel for Respondent(s)
:
:
Anil Pratap Singh
Adya Prasad Tewari
Court No. - 53
HON'BLE VIKAS BUDHWAR, J.
1. Heard Sri A.P. Singh, learned counsel for the plaintiff-appellants and Sri
A.P. Tewari, counsel for the defendant- respondent Ist set.
2. In view of the order which is being proposed to be passed, the notices are
not being issued to the defendant-respondent 2nd set.
3. Impugned in the present proceedings under Section 100 of the Code of
Civil Procedure (in short 'CPC'), is the judgement and the order dated
02.04.2015 and the decree dated 13.04.2015 passed by Additional Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Court No. 1, Gorakhpur in O.S. No. 05 of 2013
whereby the suit instituted by the plaintiff-appellant came to be dismissed as
not maintainable while allowing the application under Order VII Rule 11 (d)
of the CPC preferred by the defendant- respondent 1st set as well as the
order dated 07.08.2026 and the decree dated 13.08.2026 passed by
Additional District Judge, Court No. 5, Gorakhpur in Civil Appeal No. 51 of
2015 (Smt. Shanti Devi versus Ashok Kumar) whereby the appeal so
preferred was dismissed upholding the order of the trial court.
4. The brief facts of the case has worded in the appeal is that the plaintiffappellants instituted Original Suit No. 5 of 2013 before the Court of
Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Gorakhpur seeking cancellation of
the sale deed dated 29.08.2012 executed by the defendant-respondent 2nd set
in favour of defendant- respondent 1st set. An application under Order VII
Rule 11 (d) CPC came to be preferred by defendant- respondent 1st set
taking a ground that there happened to be a restraint order, restraining the
alienation/ sale of the land. The trial court by virtue of the judgment and the
SAPL No. 725 of 2026
order dated 02.04.2015 rejected the plaint while allowing the application
under Order VII Rule 11 (d) coming up with the stand that the appropriate
proceedings which can be initiated by the plaintiff-appellants is before the
revenue court as the suit was barred under Section 331 of the U.P. Zamindari
Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950.
5. Assailing the judgment and order dated 02.04.2015 passed by the trial
court, a Civil Appeal bearing No. 51 of 2015 came to be preferred by the
plaintiff-appellants which also resulted to the same fate on 07.08.2026 by the
order of the Additional District Judge, Court No. 5, Gorakhpur.
6. Assailing both the orders, the present appeal has been preferred.
7. The following substantial question of laws have been formulated by the
plaintiff appellants as under:
"(i) Whether the Courts below are justified in rejecting the plaint u/0 7
Rule 11 C.P.C. holding the suit barred by u/s 331, UPZA and LR Act ?
(ii) Whether the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below are
contrary to the judgment rendered by full bench of this Hon'ble Court in
case of Tarpat Ojha Vs. Ram Ratan Kaur ILR (1993)15 ALL 385 (F.B.)?
(iii) Whether the Courts below are justified in rejecting the plaint on the
ground of no jurisdiction to entertain the suit ?
(iv) Whether the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below suffer
from manifest error of law apparent on the face of record?"
8. The plaintiff-appellants have relied upon the (ii) substantial question of
law so as to contend that the judgment and the decree of the trial court as
well as of the lower appellate court is in teeth of the judgment of the full
bench judgment of this Court in Tarpat Ojha vs. Ram Ratan Kaur; I.L.R.
(1893) 15 All. 387 (FB) as well as the judgment in First Appeal No. 531 of
2015 (Smt. Beena Shrivastav and 6 others versus Shri Rajan Kumar and 9
others), decided on 26.11.2015. Submission is that in case the suit itself was
not maintainable then instead of rejecting the plaint, the same should have
been returned giving an opportunity to the party to approach the Court
having jurisdiction over the matter. Submission is that the observations /
finding as well as the judgment and the decree to the said extent is in
violation of the principles of law.
9. Shri A.P. Tiwari who appears for the defendant-respondent 1st set on the
other hand submits that the judgment and the decree of the trial court as
SAPL No. 725 of 2026
affirmed by the lower appellate court is perfectly valid in accordance with
law, since the suit itself was not maintainable before the civil court and the
remedy lies before the revenue court to the said extent, no interference is
warranted, however, he submits that the proper course open for the trial
court as well as the lower appellate court in affirming the judgment and the
decree of the trial court, was to return the plaint so as to enable the plaintiffappellants to seek remedy before the revenue court. He thus submits that the
judgement and the decree of the trial court as well as lower appellate court
be modified to that extent.
10. I have heard the submissions so made across the bar and perused the
record carefully.
11. Apparently, the plaintiff-appellants instituted suit before the Court of
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Gorakhpur seeking cancellation of the sale
deed dated 29.08.2012 executed by the defendant-respondent IInd set in
favour of defendant-respondent Ist set. Though various grounds were taken
that the said sale deed was in breach and violation of the orders of the Court
which forbid any alienation of the land / property in question. However, the
trial court rejected the plaint while allowing the application so preferred by
defendant-respondent 1st set under Order 7 Rule 11 (d) of the CPC. The said
order was subject matter of challenge at the behest of plaintiff-appellants and
the appeal was also dismissed.
12. In Tarpat Ojha (supra) as followed in Smt. Beena Srivastava (supra),
the following was observed as under:
"14. Section 9 C.P.C. provides that suit of civil nature is maintainable
before Civil Court, except its cognizance is expressly or impliedly barred.
In this case, subject matter of dispute is agricultural land. Dispute
relating to title of land has to be decided by Revenue Court and
jurisdiction of Civil Court is expressly barred under Section 331 of U.P.
Act No. 1 of 1951. Suit before Civil Court is not maintainable.
15. Where suit appears from statement in plaint to be barred by any law,
then plaint can be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) C.P.C. In other
words, if relief sought in suit is barred under any law, then plaint can be
rejected under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. However, if jurisdiction to try
suit is barred, then Presiding Officer is required to return plaint for
presentation before appropriate Court under Order VII Rule 10 C.P.C. In
this case, jurisdiction of Civil Court to try suit is barred under Section
331 of U.P. Act No. 1 of 1951, as such, plaint is liable to be returned for
SAPL No. 725 of 2026
presentation before appropriate Court under Order VII Rule 10 C.P.C. as
held by Full Bench of This Court in Tarapat Ojha vs. Ram Ratan Kaur,
I.L.R. (1893) 15 All. 385 (FB). However, Court below has illegally
rejected plaint under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C.
16. In the result, appeal succeeds and is partly allowed. Order passed by
Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Gorakhpur dated 18.9.2015, passed in Civil
Suit No. 971 of 2014 (Beena and others vs. Rajan), is modified. Civil
Judge (Sr. Division), Gorakhpur is directed to return plaint to plaintiffs
for presentation before appropriate Court, according to provisions of
Order VII Rule 10(2) C.P.C. On return of plaint, plaintiffs shall file suit
before appropriate Court within 90 days from the date of return of
plaint."
13. Though this Court was proceeding to admit the appeal in view of
substantial question of law (ii) but according to Shri A.P. Tiwari who
appears for the defendant-respondent Ist set, no useful purpose will be
served in admitting the appeal as ultimately the law in this regard is well
clear in view of the judgements as referred to above, thus, according to him,
as per the instruction received from his client, the judgement and the decree
of the trial court as well as the lower appellate court be modified to the
extent that in place of rejection of the plaint, the plaint be returned to be
presented before the court having jurisdiction over the matter.
14. To such a submission, Shri A.P. Singh, learned counsel for the plaintiffappellants has no objection as according to him, this much is the only relief
which at this juncture the plaintiff-appellants claims.
15. Bearing in mind the stand and the statements so made by the respective
parties as per the instruction received by them and also the law on the said
subject as discussed above, the instant second appeal is being partly allowed
while modifying the judgment and the order dated 02.04.2015 and decree
dated 13.04.2015 passed by Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court
No. 1, Gorakhpur in O.S. No. 5 of 2013 (Smt. Shanti Devi and others versus
Ashok Kumar and others) and the judgment and the order dated 07.08.2026
and the decree dated 13.08.2026 passed by Additional District Judge, Court
No. 5, Gorakhpur in Civil Appeal No. 51 of 2015 (Smt. Shanti Devi and
others versus Ashok Kumar) to the extent that in place of rejection of the
plaint under Order VII Rule 11 (d) of the C.P.C., the same would be returned
with a liberty to the plaintiff-appellants to present the same before the
competent court of law in accordance with law.
SAPL No. 725 of 2026
16. Accordingly, the second appeal is being partly allowed.
October 8, 2026
Ashu
(Vikas Budhwar,J.)
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review