Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
Date of Decision: 11.03.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
SMT. RAM DULARI AND ORS
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr Manish Maini , Ms.Anjali Singh,
Advocates.
versus
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI ND ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms Avni Singh Panel, Counsel for
GNCTD
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
1.
The petition has been filed for the following reliefs:
“a) Directing Respondent No. 1 to 4 to immediately grant and release the
Exgratia amount of Rs. 1,00,00,000/- (Rs. One Crore only) along with
interest @ 12% p.a. in favor of the Petitioners from the date of death ie....
12.07.2020 till realization.
b) Direct Respondent no.1 to 4 to pay the litigation expenses to the
Petitioners to the tune of Rs. 2,00,000/- and another sum of Rs. 5,00,000/for the mental agony, mental pain and hardship suffered for pursuing their
remedies for the last 3 years.
c) Direct Respondent No.5/ DTC to file on record the duty roaster from
March’2020 to July’2020 of the deceased Sh. Bharat Singh, Permanent
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Driver (DTC Rohini Depot-II]) having permanent Batch no. 23946 and
Token no. 65932.
d) Such other order or orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances may also be passed.”
2.
The matter was called out for hearing on 15.12.2023 and the Court
had directed for the issuance of notice to the respondents.
3.
The respondent no.5 i.e., Delhi Transport Corporation („DTC‟), who
is the employer, has filed the reply, however, no reply was filed by
respondents-Government of NCT of Delhi (hereinafter “GNCTD”).
4.
On 26.07.2024 and 18.11.2024, the Court granted further time to the
respondent nos. 1 to 4 i.e., all of them being arms of the GNCTD, to file a
reply. Despite the same, unfortunately, no steps were taken by the GNCTD.
5.
It appears that since reply was not being filed, therefore, the matter
was directed to be listed before the Court of the Joint Registrar, and the Joint
Registrar on 14.01.2025 and 10.07.2025 granted respondent nos. 1 to 4 an
opportunity to file reply.
6.
On 11.02.2026, since no reply was forthcoming despite a number of
opportunities being granted to the GNCTD, the Court had to pass the
following directions:
“2. Looking at the nature of the grievance it is appropriate to direct the
respondents to take instructions and to positively file the reply within a
period of two weeks. If the reply is not filed within a period of two weeks,
the Court will have to take coercive steps against the respondents.
3. It be noted that that directions to file the reply was issued way back in
the year 2023, and on 10.07.2025, the opportunity to file the reply was
closed.
4. Further, liberty is granted to the respondents to file the reply in view of
the facts and situation involved in the case.”
7.
Till date, there is no reply on behalf of the respondents. During the
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
course of the hearing, learned counsel for the respondents has brought on
record a copy of the decision dated 16.10.2023 taken by the Group of
Ministers (hereinafter “GoM”) to indicate that the claim of the petitioner has
been rejected by the GoM in the meeting which was conducted on
13.09.2023. The following is the decision taken on 16.10.2023:
" To,
The Managing Director,
Delhi Transport Corporation (HQ),
Govt. of NCT of Delhi,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi-110002.
Sub: Proposal for grant of ex-gratia of Rs One Crore to the family of
deceased employees of DTC, expired due to illness (COVID-19+).
Sir/Madam,
With reference to above cited subject, I am directed to inform that
the case files of following deceased employees of DTC were placed before
the Group of Ministers (GoM) in the meeting held on 13.09.2023. The
observation of the GoM is as under:
S.
No.
Name
& Place of Posting
Designation
Date
Death
of Observation of GoM
1.
Sh. Hari Om, Keshopur Depot, 16.04.2021
Delhi Transport
Conductor
Corporation
2.
Sh. Jai Lal Delhi Transport 18.04.2021
Kapoor, Ex- Corporation
Senior
(HQ)
Manager
3.
Sh. Bharat Rohini Depot-II, 12.07.2020
Singh, Driver DTC
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
The
deceased
were
performing their routine
duty as Conductor/Senior
Manager/Driver
which
though may be termed as an
essential services, however,
it is in no way on Covid duty
or even Covid related duties
involving
treatment,
facilitation or care of Covid
patients. They were not
performing specific duties
like patient care duties/duty
in a containment zone
during COVID-19 pandemic
/working
in
COVID
designated hospital/special
COVID relief work.
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Accordingly, the Competent Authority has decided that the aforesaid cases
are NOT covered under the provisions of Cabinet Decision No. 2835
dated 13.05.2020.
Yours faithfully,
-sdSDM-II (HQ)"
8.
The present matter will, therefore, have to be, finally, decided on
merits.
9.
The petitioners herein are the widow, mother and children of the
deceased late Sh. Bharat Singh who expired on 12.07.2020 due to COVID19. The petitioners have approached this Court seeking relief of ex-gratia
compensation of Rs. 1 Crore from the respondents.
10.
It appears from the facts that the GNCTD vide a Cabinet decision,
which culminated into the passing of Circular dated 19.04.2020 had taken a
decision for grant of ex-gratia compensation to the family of the employees
who died of the COVID-19 disease while on COVID-19 duty. The relevant
portion of the said circular is extracted as under:
"In partial modification of order No. 11/13/H&FW/HR-M/2020/CD1126000847/881-890, dated 07/04/2020 the Govt. of NCT of Delhi vide
Cabinet Decision No. 2824, dated 18/04/2020 the following is decided
with respect to Awarding compensation to family of employees who die of
COVID-19 disease while on COVID-19 duty.
“Any person including Doctor, Nurse, Para-Medical Staff,
Security/Sanitation Staff, or any other Government Officer/Official
including Police Officer/Official, whether temporary or permanent
employee or contractual, in Government or Private Sector, deployed for
COVID-19 duties by Government of NCT of Delhi, if expires by
contracting the disease during discharge of his/her duty, his/her family
shall be compensated with ex-gratia amount of Rupees One Crore,
posthumously."
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the deceased was a
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
frontline worker and had been deployed for transportation of migrant
workers as he was a permanent driver of respondent no. 5 i.e., the DTC. It is
stated that he lost his life after contracting COVID-19. The reply of
respondent no. 5-DTC, indicates that the deceased was a driver with the
DTC and as per its record performed his last duty on 03.07.2020. It is
further stated in the reply of the DTC that the deceased was admitted to
Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital, Shahdara on 11.07.2020, and he expired on
12.07.2020. A „Certificate of Death Due to Covid‟ dated 05.11.2020 was
further issued by the GNCTD, Directorate General of Health Services
(Nursing Home Cell). The same is extracted as under:
“CERTIFICATION OF DEATH DUE TO COVID
It is certified that the Case Sheet along with Death Summary and COVID
Test report of late Bharat Singh S/o Girdhari Lal 52 yrs/ Male was
received by Death Audit Committee from Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital
through email.
The Death Audit Committee, constituted vide Order No. 52/DGHS/PHIV/COVID- I9/prsecyhfw/5204-58 dated 20.04.2020, examined the case
records in respect of Late Bharat Singh S/o Girdhari Lai 52 Yrs/Male, as
recorded in the death summary issued by Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital
through email.
It was found that he died due to COVID-19 on 12.07.2020. The primary
cause of death is COVID-19 (ICD-10 coding U07.1) and was reported by
the Death Audit Committee in its report dated 13.07.2020 as per
“Guidance for appropriate recording of COVID-19 related deaths in
India” issued by ICMR/NCDIR on 10.05.2020.”
12.
It would be apposite to note the state of affairs which prevailed when
the Cabinet Decision was taken and the subsequent circular came to be
issued. The country was confronted with an unprecedented pandemic which
disrupted every aspect of civic life and placed extraordinary pressure upon
the State machinery. It was persons like late Sh. Bharat Singh, who ensured
that there was no complete collapse of essential public services and basic
civic functioning. Much like soldiers who stand at the borders to protect the
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
nation in times of external threat, these frontline workers continued to
discharge their duties amidst grave personal risk, exposure and uncertainty,
so that the life of the community could continue with some semblance of
order. It was in recognition of this extraordinary sacrifice, and the
indispensable nature of such service, that the policy for grant of ex gratia
compensation came to be framed.
13.
The observation of the GoM, seems to restrict the operation of the
Cabinet decision only to those individuals who were performing specific
duties like patient care duties/duty in a containment zone during COVID-19
pandemic/working in COVID designated hospital/special COVID relief
work. Such a curtailment is de hors the scheme of the circular and does not,
in any manner, bear out from the same. There is no difference between
COVID-19 duty and routine duty and any artificial distinction sought to be
created, would be arbitrary and unsustainable in the eyes of law.
14.
While the conclusion being reached by the Court is based exclusively
on the text, object and purpose of the Cabinet Decision, a brief reference
may also be made to the manner in which the Govt. announced the said
Cabinet Decision, as reported by reputed news agencies:
“We started the scheme to cover any doctor, nurse, lab technician or
hospital sanitation worker contracting the infection and dying during the
course of duty,” Kejriwal said. “There are other people too who are looking
after corona patients - policemen, civil defence volunteers, teachers and fire
service personnel. If anyone contracts coronavirus and dies while attending
to corona patients, their families will also be given Rs 1 crore.”1
“Those serving the coronavirus patients are "no less than soldiers
protecting the country”…”During a war, a soldier protects his country,
risks his life.... our whole nation is indebted to them. Today, the job that you
guys (health workers) are doing is no less than that of a soldier. You are
Alok KN Mishra, „Delhi Govt. Expands Reach of Rs. 1 Cr. Compensation‟, The Economic Times, 19th
April, 2020, accessible at <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/delhi-govtexpands-reach-of-rs-1-cr-compensation/articleshow/75229622.cms?from=mdr>.
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
risking your life to save people of this country,”
“Delhi government had earlier announced that if any soldier dies while
protecting the country, his family will be given Rs 1 crore. Today, as a mark
of respect, I want to announce that if unfortunately, any health worker - a
sanitation worker, doctor or nurse - is martyred while serving COVID-19
patients, their families will be given Rs 1 crore. Whether they are from
private or government sector... it doesn't matter”2
15.
When the petitioner was admittedly deployed for performing his duty
for transportation of migrant workers, in no case, it can be said that the
petitioner was not deployed for COVID-19 duty. Reference may also be
made to the decision with respect to another DTC driver, namely, late Sh.
Lal Singh, who was almost similarly placed as the petitioner, and was
granted ex-gratia compensation.
16.
It is, thus, palpably apparent that the petitioner is eligible for the ex-
gratia amount of Rs. 1 Crore under the Cabinet decision, which culminated
into the Circular dated 19.04.2020.
17.
The Court, therefore, directs the respondents to grant petitioners the
ex-gratia compensation of Rs. 1 crore within a period of six (6) weeks from
today.
18.
With the aforesaid direction, the petition, along with pending
application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
19.
List on 04.05.2026 for compliance and consideration as to on what
rate the interest has to be provided.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
MARCH 11, 2026/aks/ksr
Swati Bhasin, „Rs. 1 Crore for Families of COVID-19 Warriors If They Die‟, 14th April, 2020, accessible
at
<https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/arvind-kejriwal-announces-rs-1-crore-for-families-of-healthpersonnel-if-they-lose-their-lives-while-2204204>.
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 16201/2023
18:35:16
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review