Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
WRIT PETITION NO. 35914 OF 2024 (GM-RES)
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by
MOHANKUMAR
MOHANKUMAR B SHELAR
B SHELAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SMT. PRAMEELA V.N. D/O. V.S NINGEGOWDA
W/O. G.S. ASHOK, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
R/AT #104, VALALAHALLI VILLAGE,
HETTUR HOBLI, SAKALESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT, KARNATAKA-573123.
2.
ASHOK G.S. S/O. SHIVANNA GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
VALALAHALLI VILLAGE,
HETTUR HOBLI, SAKALESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT, KARNATAKA-573123.
3.
PREETHAM G.A. S/O. G.S. ASHOK
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,
R/AT VALALAHALLI VILLAGE,
HETTUR HOBLI, SAKALESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT, KARNATAKA-573123.
4.
PUNITHM G.A. S/O. G.S.ASHOK
AGED ABOUT: 32 YEARS,
R/AT VALALAHALLI VILLAGE,
HETTUR HOBLI, SAKALESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT, KARNATAKA-573123.
5.
T.N. VENKATACHALA
S/O. T.R. NARAYANAGOWDA
AGED ABOUT : 64 YEARS,
R/AT NO.31, 4TH CROSS,
ANUBHAVA NAGAR,
BANGALORE, KARNATAKA-560079.
… PETITIONERS
(BY SRI K.R.NAGARAJA, ADVOCATE)
-2NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
AND:
1.
V.S.VENKATESH GOWDA
S/O. SIDDALINGI SANNE GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS,
R/AT NO.100, NIRVANA,
NANDINI DOLLAR SCHEME,
NANDINI LAYOUT, BANGALORE,
KARNATAKA-560096.
2.
THE MAINTENANCE TRIBUNAL,
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER,
SAKLESHAPURA SUB DIVISION,
SAKALESHPURA, HASSAN DISTRICT,
KARANATAKA-573134.
3.
THE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL,
THE DISTRICT MAGISTRATE,
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
HASSAN DISTRICT, HASSAN,
KARNATAKA-573201.
4.
POLICE INSPECTOR,
SAKALESHPURA RURAL POLICE STATION,
SAKALESHPURA.
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI V.S.VENKATESHA GOWDA, ADVOCATE FOR C/R-1,
SRI BOPANNA BELLIAPPA, AGA FOR R-2 AND R-3)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED
ORDER / ANNEXURE-L PASSED BY THE SECOND RESPONDENT /
MAINTENANCE TRIBUNAL DATED 22.01.2024 IN FILE NO. MAG
(HI.NAA.RA)
14/2023-24
ALLOWING
PETITION
OF
FIRST
RESPONDENT AND DIRECTING PSI OF SAKLESHPUR RURAL POLICE
STATION AND DEPUTY TAHASILDHAR, HETHUR HOBLI, SAKLESHPUR
TALUK TO REMOVE OBSTRUCTION OF HADDU BASTHU AND PROVIDE
PROTECTION SUBJECT TO DECISION OF CIVIL COURT IN RESPECT
OF 0.07 GUNTAS OF LAND IN SY. NO. 24/30 OF VALALAHALLI
VILLAGE AND QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER/ ANNEXURE-O PASSED
BY THE THIRD RESPONDENT / APPELLATE TRIBUNAL DATED
05.11.2024 IN ORDER NO. MAG.HI.NA.RA/32/2023-24 BY ALLOWING
APPEAL OF PETITIONERS AND ETC.,
-3NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
The captioned writ petition is filed assailing the
concurrent orders passed by the respondent No.2–Tribunal
and the respondent No.3–Appellate Tribunal under the
provisions of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
Senior Citizens Act, 2007 (for short 'the Act, 2007').
2.
The records would indicate that respondent
No.1, a practicing Advocate before this Court, instituted
proceedings under Section 4 of the Act, 2007 seeking
certain reliefs in respect of land bearing Sy.No.24/30
measuring in all 20 guntas. The respondent No.2–Tribunal,
while entertaining the application, proceeded to allow the
same and issued directions to the competent authorities to
conduct hissa proceedings, fix boundaries and demarcate
an extent of 7 guntas allegedly belonging to respondent
No.1 in the aforesaid survey number.
-4NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
3.
Feeling
aggrieved
by
the
said
order,
the
petitioners preferred an appeal before the respondent
No.3–Appellate
Tribunal.
The
Appellate
Tribunal,
by
affirming the order passed by the respondent No.2–
Tribunal, dismissed the appeal. It is these concurrent
orders which are called in question in the present writ
petition.
4.
The facts leading to the case, in brief, are as
under:
Respondent No.1 is asserting absolute ownership
over an extent of 7 guntas in Sy.No.24/30, which in all
measures 20 guntas. Respondent No.1 traces his alleged
right, title and interest over the subject property on the
strength of an oral partition said to have taken place on
29.12.1985, which, according to him, culminated in a
registered partition deed dated 31.08.2015. It is his
specific claim that an extent of 7 guntas in the aforesaid
survey
number
fell
to
his
share
under
the
said
-5NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
arrangement
and,
therefore,
he
claims
exclusive
ownership and possession over the same.
5.
Alleging
interference
by
the
petitioners
in
respect of the said portion of land, respondent No.1
invoked the provisions of the Act, 2007 by instituting
proceedings before the Tribunal.
6.
The petitioners, disputing the claim set up by
respondent No.1, have simultaneously instituted a suit for
partition and separate possession in O.S.No.399/2023
before the competent Civil Court. The petitioners contend
that the property in question is the self-acquired property
of their father late Sri V.S. Ningegowda, who had
purchased the same under a registered sale deed dated
19.09.1979. It is their specific case that, upon the demise
of their father, the petitioners, being Class-I legal heirs,
alone succeed to the estate and inherit the property.
According to the petitioners, respondent No.1, being only
the younger brother of late Sri V.S. Ningegowda, has no
-6NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
semblance of right, title or interest over the disputed
property and the claim projected by him is wholly
untenable in law.
7.
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, respondent No.1 appearing as party-in-person
and the learned Deputy Government Advocate appearing
for respondent Nos.2 and 3.
8.
This
Court
has
meticulously
examined
the
averments made in the writ petition, the statement of
objections and the documents annexed thereto, as also
the documents produced by respondent No.1 along with
the statement of objections.
9.
In the light of the rival contentions urged by the
parties, the following points arise for consideration:
(i) Whether the respondent No.2–Tribunal, while
exercising jurisdiction under Section 4 of the Act,
2007, could have directed the revenue authorities to
conduct boundary fixation and demarcation in terms
-7NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
of the registered partition deed dated 31.08.2015
and
further
proceed
to
remove
the
alleged
encroachment?
(ii) Whether the powers conferred on the Tribunal
under
Section
of
the
Act,
extend
to
adjudication of disputed questions relating to title,
possession
and
encroachment, particularly
when
such issues involve seriously disputed questions of
fact
and
are
already
the
subject
matter
of
adjudication before the competent Civil Court in O.S.
No.399/2023?
Finding on Point Nos.(i) and (ii):
10.
Before this Court proceeds to examine the rival
pleadings of the parties and the documents relied upon by
them, it would be apposite to first refer to the genealogical
relationship between the petitioners and respondent No.1.
The family tree of the petitioners and respondent No.1 is
extracted hereunder for the sake of convenience and
clarity:–
-8NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
11.
Before adverting to the scope and ambit of the
powers vested in the respondent No.2–Tribunal while
addressing the grievances of a senior citizen under the
provisions
of
the
Act,
2007,
this
Court
deems
it
appropriate to first extract the relief sought by respondent
No.1 in the application presented before the respondent
No.2–Tribunal under Section 4 of the Act.
12.
The prayer sought by respondent No.1 in the
said application reads as under:–
-9NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
"I herein respectfully pray that this Hon'ble
Authority be pleased to pass orders in the interest
of justice and equity.
(a) To direct the respondents not to interfere with
the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
schedule properties as more fully described in the
schedule to the petition as per document no.5 & 6
as I am the class 1 heir to the propositor of the
Joint
Hindu
Properties
of
Late
Siddalingi
Sannegowda.
(b) To direct the respondents to restrain from
abusing the Petitioner who is a senior citizen, in
filthy language unbecoming of a family member
who are all enjoying the properties of my brother
Late V.S. Ningegowda.
(c) Direct the respondents to disconnect the flow of
sewerage water to the gober gas unit and not to
use my property as cow shed and also to store the
cow dung including cattle shed to direct them to
clear the place at their cost and risk at once.
(d) To issue directions to the authorities viz., the
President
Panchayath
Valalahalli
Grama
Panchayath, Executive Officer Taluk Panchayath,
sakaleshpur and the Tahasildar Sakaleshpur Taluk
to consider the Petitions by ordering for an enquiry
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
to the schedule property and to dispose off the
petition in a expeditious manner within a period of
2 months.
(e) To direct the Sixth Respondent, Sakleshpur
Rural Station to provide protection to me and my
family members.
(f) Any other relief or reliefs to the Petitioner with
this Hon'ble Authority deems fit and property in the
interest of justice and equity."
13.
It would also be apposite for this Court to
extract the relief sought by the petitioners in the suit for
partition
and
separate
possession
instituted
in
O.S.No.399/2023 before the competent Civil Court. The
prayer sought in the said suit is extracted hereunder for
immediate reference:–
"ªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ WÀ£À £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄzÀ°è ¥Áæyð¹PÉÆ¼ÀÄîªÀÅzÉãÉAzÀgÉ,
F zÁªÁzÀ ªÉÄ®ÌAqÀ J¯Áè CA±ÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀjUÀt¹ ªÀiÁ£Àå WÀ£À
£ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀĪÀÅ PÀ鴃 ªÀiÁr;
1. ¢£ÁAPÀ 31.08.2015 gÀAzÀÄ 1, 2 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3£Éà ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼À £ÀqÀĪÉ
¸ÀPÀ¯ÉñÀ¥ÀÅgÀ
G¥À£ÉÆAzÁuÁ¢üPÁjUÀ¼À
PÀZÉÃjAiÀİè
¥ÀvÀæ
¸ÀASÉå
1108/2015-16 gÀ°è £ÉÆAzÁtÂAiÀiÁVgÀĪÀ «¨sÁUÀ ¥ÀvÀæªÀ£ÀÄß ªÀiÁ£Àå
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
£ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀĪÀÅ DzÉñÀzÀ ªÀÄÆ®PÀ gÀzÀÄÝ ¥Àr¸À¨ÉÃPÉAzÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¸ÀzÀj
«¨sÁUÀ
¥ÀvÀæªÀÅ
ªÁ¢UÀ¼À£ÀÄß
§zÀÝ¥Àr¸ÀĪÀÅ¢®è
JAzÀÄ
DzÉòzÀ¨ÉÃPÁVAiÀÄÄ
2.
zÁªÁ µÉqÀÆå¯ï ¸ÀéwÛ£À°è ªÀÄÈvÀ ¤AUÉÃUËqÀ£À ªÀÄPÀ̼ÀÄ ºÁUÀÆ
PÁè¸ï-1 ªÁgÀ¸ÀÄzÁgÀgÁzÀ 1 jAzÀ 5£Éà ªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3£Éà ¥ÀæwªÁ¢
ªÀiÁvÁæ 1/6£Éà ¨sÁUÀzÀ »¸Áì ºÀPÀÄÌ ºÉÆAzÀ®Ä ºÀPÀÄ̼îÀªÀgÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉ
JAzÀÆ WÉÆÃ¶¹, ªÁ¢UÀ½UÉ zÁªÁ µÉqÀÆå¯ï ¸ÀéwÛ£À°è 1/6£Éà ¨sÁUÀzÀ
»¸Áì ºÀPÀÌ£ÀÄß ºÉÆAzÀĪÀAvÉ DzÉò¹, ¸ÀzÀj 1/6£Éà ¨sÁUÀzÀ »¸ÉìAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
ªÁ¢UÀ½UÉ ¥ÀævÉåÃPÀªÁV «¨sÁV¹PÉÆlÄÖ, ªÁ¢AiÀĪÀgÀÄUÀ¼À »¸ÉìÃUÉ ¥ÀævÉåÃPÀ
¸Áé¢üãÀ PÉÆr¹PÉÆqÀ¨ÉÃPÉAzÀÄ, ºÁUÀÆ
3. zÁªÁzÀ RZÀÄð ¸ÀªÉÄÃvÀ, WÀ£À £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄzÀ «ªÉÃZÀ£ÉUÉ vÉÆÃj
§gÀĪÀ EvÀgÉ CªÀ±ÀåPÀ ¥ÀjºÁgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß, ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ½AzÀ ªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ
ºÉÆAzÀĪÀAvÉ
DzÉò¸À¨ÉÃPÁVAiÀÄÄ,
ºÁUÀÆ
ªÁ¢UÀ¼À
zÁªÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
ªÁ¢UÀ¼À ¥ÀgÀªÁV ºÁUÀÆ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼À «gÀÄzÀݪÁV rQæ¸À¨ÉÃPÉAzÀÄ
£ÁåAiÀiÁ©üªÀÈ¢Þ zÀȶ֬ÄAzÀ ¥ÁæxÀð£É."
14.
Respondent No.1, who is arrayed as defendant
No.1 in O.S.No.399/2023, has filed a detailed written
statement contesting the claim of the present petitioners.
The said written statement is also produced along with the
present writ petition and is marked at Annexure–H.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
15.
This Court is of the considered view that the
averments made in paragraphs 4, 5, 9 and 10 of the
written statement assume significance while examining the
nature of the dispute inter se between the parties. The
pleadings contained therein would also have a direct
bearing on the question as to whether the respondent
No.2–Tribunal has exceeded the jurisdiction vested in it by
entertaining an application involving complex and seriously
disputed questions of fact relating to title, possession and
alleged encroachment, which ordinarily fall within the
exclusive domain of a competent Civil Court. Therefore,
this Court deems it appropriate to extract paragraphs 4, 5,
9 and 10 of the written statement, which read as under:–
"4. The averments made in paragraph No.2 of
the plaint that the plaintiffs and defendant No.3 are
the
children
of
Late
V.S
Ningegowda
and
Hoovamma and they are the inheritance is admitted
to be correct. The further contention of the plaintiff
that the suit schedule property old Sy.No.is 24/3
and their father has purchased the 20 guntas of
land in total measurement as per the registered
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
sale deed dated 19.09.1979 by the Late Annegowda
S/o Patel Siddegowda and same is registered
before the Sakaleshpura Sub-Registrar Office in
document
NO.527/1979-80
is
admitted
to
be
correct. But this defendant denied that the said
property
is
self
acquired
property
of
Late
V.S.Ningegowda. The further averments in the
same
para
that
the
Pahani
documents
were
standing in the name of Late V.S.Ningegowda and
khata
was
changed
in
respect
of
Sy.No.24/3
measuring 20 guntas is admitted to be correct.
After
his
death the
revenue
documents
were
changed on the basis of Pavathikhatha in favour of
plaintiff No.1 to 5 and in favour of Defendant No.3
and further averments that except plaintiff and
defendant No.3 are having right over the suit
schedule properties and others have no right in the
said suit schedule property and the suit schedule
property is not the joint family property nor
ancestral property is totally denied as false.
5. The further averments made in paragraph
No.3 in the plaint that the parents of the plaintiff
and defendant No.3 by name Late V.S.Ningegowda
and Hoovamma have died is admitted and further
averments that plaintiffs and defendant No.3 have
right in schedule property and they have equal right
and owner and except plaintiffs and defendant No.3
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
others have no right over the suit schedule property
is totally denied as false and same has to be proved
by the plaintiffs.
9. The defendant No.1 submits that, during
the
life
time of Late
SidlingiSannegowda had
purchased the suit schedule property in the name
of Late V.S.Ningegowda by contributing the joint
family funds as
he was the elder son in the joint
family and taking care of all the joint family
properties until December 29th 1985 jointly and the
said
SidlingiSannegowda
several
other
had
properties.
also
purchased
Therefore,
Late
Ningegowda had no exclusive right over the suit
schedule property and same is not the self acquired
property as he does not have any independent
source of income as such. The 1st defendant was
the State Government Officer and he had also
contributed the money for purchase of the suit
schedule property as well as for development of the
joint family properties which are situated in the
native village until 2013 till his retirement. It is
submitted
that
during
the
life
time
of
Late
SidlingiSannegowda had taken steps to partition all
joint family properties for which Jubani Hissa Draft
was made and same was read over to all family
members and after their consent Jubani Hissa was
made on 29.12.1985 and all family members have
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
agreed upon and signed the same at that point of
time.
10. The defendant No.1 submit that as such
the self acquired properties of Hindu Joint Family
member if thrown in "common Hotchpot" to be
treated as joint family property. As per the Jubani
Hissa all family members are in possession and
enjoyment of their respective shares which were
allotted to them and also all revenue documents
are standing in their name in respect of their
properties. The defendant No.1 is produced the
copy of the mutation registers as DOCUMENT NO:
1&2 respectively. The defendant No. 1 herewith
produced the copy of the proceedings of Jubani
Hissa, Copy of the Jubani Hissa dated 29.12.1985
and photo copy of Jubani Hissa as DOCUMENT NO.3
TO 5. As per the Jubani Hissa entered in to between
family members, the schedule property mentioned
in the plaint was also shown as a " House property"
and same will be goes in favour of V.Tejas S/o
Venkatesh Gowda V.S. who is the 2nd son of Late
Sidlingi Sanne gowda and also it has been decided
and agreed in the Jubani Hissa the 1st son V.S.
Ningegowda and 2nd son V.S.Venkateshgowda have
to live together until their life time in the said house
property.
The
said
SidlingiSannegowda
passed
away on 26.06.1987. Accordingly the said house
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
property should goes to V.S.Venkateshgowda and
his son Tejas. V. Since Late Ningegowda V.S. died
on
04.12.1998
and
also
his
wife
Late
Smt.
Hoovamma also died on 03.07.1999. The defendant
produced the copy of death certificates of both as
DOCUMENT NO:6&7 respectively. It is submitted
that until their death the defendant No.1 was
looking after the welfare of the joint family and
further his mother Puttamma also passed away on
24.11.2002. The defendant produced the death
certificate of Puttamma as DOCUMENT NO.8. At
that point of time the plaintiff No. 5 was not
married. However the plaintiff No.2 and 4 have
married during 1999 and 2001. It is pertaining to
note the defendant No.1 had taken care of them
and also performed their marriage by spending his
own earned money as a head of the joint family, to
keep the family growing further as per the wishes
of the elders and as per the Jubani Hissa. He had
also performed all family functions and rituals of
death persons in the family as per the family wishes
until year 2015. In the meanwhile it is pertaining to
note that Late V.S.Ninge Gowda has handed over
the connected Original sale deed of the house
property ( Suit schedule property) including family
tree as well as income certificate of the year 199798 of his family along with one more property
situated at Markahalli village in Sy.No.56 which
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
were all allotted to the defendant No.1, to fecilitate
the defendant No.1 to take up appropriate action.
The defendant No.1 is producing the copies of said
documents
as
DOCUMENT
No.
to
respectively."
16.
On a conjoint reading of the prayer sought in
the application filed before the respondent No.2–Tribunal
under Section 4 of the Act, 2007, the reliefs sought by the
petitioners in O.S.No.399/2023 and the defence set up by
respondent No.1 in the written statement filed in the said
suit, this Court is of the considered view that the core
dispute between the parties revolves around the question
of title in respect of the property bearing Sy.No.24/30
measuring 20 guntas, out of which respondent No.1 is
asserting exclusive ownership over an extent of 7 guntas
on the strength of an alleged registered partition deed
dated 31.08.2015. The petitioners, however, are seriously
disputing the very authenticity and genuineness of the
said document and contend that the same is a fabricated
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
document created to defeat their lawful rights. Such rival
claims, in the considered opinion of this Court, necessarily
require a full-fledged adjudication before a competent Civil
Court on the basis of oral and documentary evidence.
17.
Though respondent No.1 is admittedly a senior
citizen, it is also not in dispute that he is a practicing
Advocate before this Court. This Court is therefore of the
view that respondent No.1 could not have invoked the
summary jurisdiction under Section 4 of the Act, 2007 for
adjudication of disputed civil rights relating to title,
partition,
possession
and
alleged
encroachment.
The
nature of relief sought in the application filed under
Section 4, extracted supra, itself clearly demonstrates that
the dispute projected before the Tribunal was not one
pertaining to maintenance or welfare simpliciter, but
substantially involved adjudication of civil rights over
immovable property.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
18.
These observations gain further significance in
the light of the stand taken by respondent No.1 in the
pending suit for partition and separate possession in
O.S.No.399/2023, wherein the present petitioner no.1,
who is the daughter of late Sri V.S. Ningegowda, and
petitioner Nos. 2 to 4 are her husband and children
respectively, have specifically asserted that the property in
question is the self-acquired property of petitioner No.1’s
father, acquired under a registered sale deed dated
19.09.1979 and that respondent No.1, being merely the
younger brother of their father, has no semblance of right,
title or interest over the said property. The petitioners
have further alleged that respondent No.1 has taken
undue advantage of the circumstances and has created a
fabricated partition deed to unlawfully lay claim over a
portion of the property.
19.
A closer scrutiny of the pleadings in the written
statement, particularly paragraphs 9 and 10 extracted
supra, would however indicate that respondent No.1 has
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
projected a completely different case. It is his specific
contention that the property, though purchased in the
name of late Sri V.S. Ningegowda, was in fact acquired
during
the
lifetime
of
the
propositus
Siddalingi
Sannegowda, who is the father of respondent No.1 and
grandfather
of
the
petitioner
No.1.
According
to
respondent No.1, the property was purchased in the name
of Sri V.S. Ningegowda only because he was the eldest son
of the family. Respondent No.1 has further contended that
even assuming that the property stood in the exclusive
name
of late
Sri V.S.
Ningegowda, the
same
was
subsequently thrown into the common hotchpotch and
treated as joint family property. Proceeding on this
premise, respondent No.1 asserts that there was an oral
partition in the year 1985, which was subsequently
reduced into writing under the registered partition deed
dated 31.08.2015, whereunder an extent of 7 guntas
allegedly fell to his share.
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
20.
The
petitioners,
on
the
contrary,
have
categorically disputed the very existence and validity of
the alleged oral partition as well as the registered partition
deed
dated
31.08.2015.
Thus,
from
the
pleadings
exchanged between the parties, it clearly emerges that
while the petitioners are asserting exclusive inheritance
rights by contending that the property is the self-acquired
property of their father, respondent No.1 is setting up a
rival plea that the property constitutes joint family
property
acquired
out
of
joint
family
nucleus
and
subsequently partitioned amongst the members of the
family.
21.
essentially
Therefore, the dispute between the parties is
one
involving
adjudication
of
complicated
questions relating to title, nature of property, validity of
the alleged partition, rival inheritance claims and alleged
encroachment, all of which would necessarily require
appreciation of evidence in a properly constituted civil
trial. In the backdrop of these seriously disputed and
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
complex questions of fact and law emerging from the
pleadings and documents placed by both parties, this
Court is of the considered view that the respondent No.2–
Tribunal has clearly exceeded the limited jurisdiction
vested in it under the Act, 2007 by embarking upon
adjudication of issues which squarely fall within the
domain of the competent Civil Court.
22.
This Court is therefore
of the view that,
notwithstanding the fact that respondent No.1 is a senior
citizen, he could not have invoked the provisions of the
Act, 2007 in the peculiar facts of the present case,
particularly when he has already entered appearance and
filed a detailed written statement in the pending partition
suit in O.S.No.399/2023, wherein the very same questions
relating
to
title
and
entitlement
are
directly
and
substantially in issue.
23.
The object and purpose of Section 4 of the Act,
2007 is to provide a speedy and efficacious remedy to
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
senior citizens who are neglected or denied maintenance
and basic amenities by children or relatives who are
otherwise
legally
obligated
to
maintain
them.
The
jurisdiction conferred on the Tribunal under the Act, 2007
is essentially summary in nature and is intended to secure
the welfare and protection of senior citizens in matters
relating to maintenance, residence and protection from
abandonment. The provisions of the Act, 2007 cannot be
expanded so as to confer jurisdiction upon the Tribunal to
adjudicate intricate questions relating to title, partition,
validity of documents, fixation of boundaries or allegations
of encroachment, all of which squarely fall within the
exclusive domain of a competent Civil Court.
24.
In the present case, respondent No.1, under
the guise of invoking Section 4 of the Act, 2007, has in
substance sought adjudication of civil rights by seeking
fixation of boundaries, demarcation of land and removal of
alleged encroachment on the strength of a registered
partition deed dated 31.08.2015. The very said partition
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
deed is seriously disputed by the petitioners, who have not
only questioned its genuineness and validity but have also
instituted a comprehensive suit for partition and separate
possession in O.S.No.399/2023, wherein the rival claims of
the parties in respect of the very same property are
directly and substantially in issue. Once the validity of the
partition deed, nature of the property and entitlement of
the parties are all subjects of adjudication before the
competent Civil Court, the Tribunal exercising summary
jurisdiction under the Act, 2007, could not have ventured
into
deciding
directing
such
fixation
contentious
of
issues
boundaries
and
indirectly
by
removal
of
encroachment. The orders passed by the Tribunal virtually
amount to recognition and enforcement of the alleged title
claimed by respondent No.1 under the disputed partition
deed, which is wholly impermissible in proceedings under
the Act, 2007. Therefore, this Court is of the considered
view that respondent No.1 could not have maintained the
application under Section 4 of the Act, 2007 seeking the
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
aforesaid reliefs and the respondent No.2–Tribunal has
clearly acted beyond the scope of jurisdiction vested in it
under the statute.
Accordingly, Point Nos. (i) and (ii) are answered in
the Negative.
25.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court proceeds
to pass the following:
ORDER
(i) The writ petition is allowed;
(ii) The impugned order dated 22.01.2024
passed by the respondent No.2–Tribunal as per
Annexure-L, and the order dated 05.11.2024
passed by the respondent No.3 –Appellate
Tribunal as per Annexure-O, affirming the same
are hereby set aside;
(iii)
Liberty
is
however
reserved
to
respondent No.1 to work out his rights and
remedies
in
the
pending
suit
in
O.S.
No.399/2023 and all rival contentions of the
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC:30110
WP No. 35914 of 2024
HC-KAR
parties are left open to be adjudicated by the
competent Civil Court in accordance with law.
(iv) Pending interlocutory applications, if
any, stands disposed of.
SD/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
CA/CT:GSM
LIST NO.: 19 SL NO.: 5
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review