Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LUCY
GURUM
AYUM
Digitally signed
by LUCY
GURUMAYUM
Date:
2024.07.19
15:03:36
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 49 of 2019
1. Smt. Potsangbam (N) Bhaigyabati Devi, aged
about 60 years, W/O Shri L. Lukhoi Singh of
Haobam Marak Keisham Leikai, P.O. Imphal
and P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West, Manipur.
2. Smt. M. Sanahanbi Devi, aged about 61 years,
retired teacher of Education (S), a resident of
Chinga Makha Chanam Pukhri Mapal P.O. &
P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur.
3. Smt. K. Ibechoubi Devi, aged about 62 years,
retired teacher of Education (S), a resident of
Khagempalli, P.O & P.S. Imphal West District,
Manipur.
4. Shri. Laimayum Dhanachandra Sharma, aged
about 63 years, S/O L. Udhob Sharma resident
of Yaiskul Hiruhanba Leikai, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, District Imphal West, Manipur.
…. Appellants
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the
Commissioner/Secretary
Education
(S)
Government of Manipur Secretariat Office,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District-Imphal West,
Manipur-795001.
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 1
2. The Accountant General, Manipur at Imphal,
(Opposite) Secretariat Office, P.O & P.S.
Imphal,
District-Imphal
West,
Manipur-
795001.
3. The Sr. Deputy Accountant General (A & E),
Manipur, Imphal (Opposite) Secretariat Office,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District – Imphal West,
Manipur-795001.
4. The
Commissioner/Secretary
(Finance),
Government of Manipur, Secretariat Office,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District-Imphal West,
Manipur-795001.
5. The Director, Education (S), Government of
Manipur at Lamphelpat, P.O & P.S. Lamphel,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
…. Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI
For the appellants
:
Mr. L. Anand, Advocate
For the respondents
:
Mr. S. Nepolean, Govt. Advocate
Mr. S. Suresh, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
07.05.2024
Date of order
:
19.07.2024
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 2
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
(Golmei Gaiphulshillu, J)
[1]
Heard Mr. L. Anand, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the appellants; Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government
Advocate appearing on behalf of the State respondent Nos. 1, 4
& 5; and Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent Nos. 2 & 3.
[2]
The instant writ appeal has been filed challenging
the impugned judgment and order dated 25.07.2019 passed in
W.P.(C) No. 690 of 2010 by the Ld. Single Judge with the
following prayer:
(i)
to admit the appeal and call for the records of
WP(C) No. 690 of 2010;
(ii)
to examine the documents/records and to set
aside the impugned Judgment and order
passed on 25.07.2019 by the Ld. Single Judge
in WP(C) No. 690 of 2010;
(iii)
to direct the respondents to refund the
deducted amount of Rs. 91936.00 (Ninety one
thousand nine hundred and thirty six only)
and Rs. 1,40,787 (one lakh forty thousand
seven hundred eighty seven only) to the
appellants/petitioners
No.
and
respectively;
(iv)
to pass any appropriate orders/ order which
the Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper for
the ends of justice.
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 3
[3]
The appellants/petitioners are the retired Primary
Teacher who were initially appointed under the Department of
Education(S), Government of Manipur vide different orders
issued by the State Government. From time to time, the service
conditions of the appellants/petitioners were upgraded and
enjoyed senior scale of pay upon considering their length of
service in the grade and were also allowed to enjoy revised pay
of scale from time to time attached to their respective post, by
the respondents and for no fault or misrepresentation on the
part
of
the
appellants/petitioners.
As
such,
the
appellants/petitioners were allowed to enjoy (Pre-revised) scale
of pay under R.O.P Rules, 1990 vide orders bearing No. 8/2/92ED dated 31st March, 1992; 8/1/92-ED, dated 28th March, 1992;
8/30/80-ED(VI) dated 22nd March, 1992 and No. 46/2/87-ED (Jr)
(III) dated 26th May, 1992 respectively.
Upon attaining their age of superannuation the
appellants/petitioners retired from their service on 18th April,
2008; 8th May, 2008; 25th October, 2008 and 24th June, 2006
respectively, accordingly, the authority concerned had also
issued respective orders to that effect. To the utter shock and
surprise, after one and half years of retirement from their
services,
the
Sr.
Accountants
Officer/Pension,
Accountant
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 4
General, Manipur issued the impugned letters addressed to the
Joint Secretary (Pension Cell, Government of Manipur) bearing
No.
Pen/I-647/S/W/2009
dated
3.06.2009,
No.
Pen/I-
629/S/W/2009 dated 07.09.2009, No. Pen/I-680/S/T/IW/2009
dated 07.09.2009, and No. Pen/I-638/S/Z-I/2009/4421 dated
13.05.2009 stating that the above referred orders were issued
with retrospective effect without Finance Concurrence and as
such the orders should be treated as null and void in terms of
the impugned Finance Department O.M No. 18/05-2005-FD(PIC)
dated 10.10.2005. On the basis of the O.M. dated 10.10.2005,
the respondents deducted an amount of Rs. 91,936/- (Ninety
one thousand nine hundred and thirty six only), Rs. 2,05,226/(Two lakh five thousand two hundred twenty six only), Rs.
1,72,703/- (One lakh seventy two thousand seven hundred and
three only) and Rs. 1,40,787/- (One lakh forty thousand seven
hundred
and
eighty
seven
only)
respectively
from
the
appellants’/petitioners’ pensionary/retirement benefits, on the
pretext of overdrawal of pay and allowances after retirement
from their respective services.
Being aggrieved by the action of the respondents,
the appellants/petitioners file a writ petition being W.P.(C) No.
690 of 2010 praying for a direction to the respondents to refund
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 5
the
aforesaid
amount
which
was
deducted
from
the
pensionary/retirement benefits of the appellants/petitioners.
However, the Ld Single Judge after hearing the parties dismissed
the said writ petition vide order dated 25.07.2019. Hence, the
present writ appeal is filed for setting aside of the Judgment and
order dated 25.07.2019 passed in WP(C) No. 690 of 2010 and
also praying for allowing the relief sought therein.
[4]
The learned counsel for the petitioner contended
that the pre-revised scale of pay under R.O.P. Rules, 1990 and
subsequent revision of pay were issued from time to time by the
Education Department and the appellants/petitioners were
allowed to enjoy the same and that the applicable qualification
scales issued vide Government orders were also enjoyed by the
appellants/petitioners, while they were in service. And that the
impugned O.M dated 10.10.2005 and subsequent letters dated
03.06.2009, 07.09.2009 and 13.05.2009 were issued long after
the appellants/petitioners had already enjoyed the entitled pay
scale, qualification scale in view of the numerous orders of the
respondents and after retirement from their services.
[5]
The learned counsel for the petitioners further
contended that, in the impugned O.M dated 10.10.2005, there is
no specific instruction or direction as to when the same may be
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 6
given effect to. And the appellants/petitioners came to know of
the existence of the impugned O.M only when they received the
impugned letters dated 03.06.2009, 07.09.2009 and 13.05.2009,
creating the whole problem and thus the petitioners should not
be made to suffer for the fault/mistake committed by the
Government respondents.
He, further, contended that that action and conduct
of the respondent Government of deducting the undisputed
amount of Rs. 91,936/- (Ninety one thousand nine hundred and
thirty six only), Rs. 2,05,226/- (Two lakh five thousand two
hundred twenty six only), Rs. 1,72,703/- (One lakh seventy two
thousand seven hundred and three only) and Rs. 1,40,787/(One lakh forty thousand seven hundred and eighty seven only)
respectively
from
the
appellants/petitioners
from
their
pensionary/retirement benefits, on the pretext of overdrawal of
pay and allowances after retirement is highly illegal, arbitrary.
[6]
In support of his case, the learned counsel for the
petitioners relied upon the following cases:
1. AIR 2015 SC 696 (State of Punjab and
others –versus- Rafiq Masih),
2. (1994) 2 SCC 521 (Shyam Babu Verma and
others – versus- Union of India and others)
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 7
3. And also judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Gauhati High Court in Writ Appeal No. 57.
[7]
On perusal of the impugned order, the Hon’ble
Single Judge declined the relief sought for by the petitioners.
The
relevant
portions
of
the
order
dated
25.07.2019 read as follows:
“7.
The consent letters as above given by the
petitioners is not reflected in the writ petition and they
have not disclosed their consent letter for recovery of
the amount drawn in excess in the affidavit and petition.
This amounts to suspension of material fact.
8.
The
petitioners have voluntarily made
representations to the authority concerned giving their
consent for deduction of the over payment of the pay
and benefits from the amount payable to the petitioners
for the service period. Consequent to retirement, no
specific plea has been made by the petitioners that
there is undue influence and coercion. There is no
reference of giving such letters in the writ petition. The
petitioners are not entitled to any relief. Since the
recovery order has been made pursuant to the
unconditional consent letters of the petitioners, the
question of refunding the deducted amount does not
arise. There is no merit in the writ petition. The
petitioners by their own conduct are disentitled to the
relief sought for.”
But, it is not a case of the respondent authorities
that the petitioners had played fraud or misrepresented and got
their pay fixed at the higher scale. Overpayment of pay and
allowances cannot be treated as Government dues, but nonclearance of Quarters or house rent, service loan or loans of any
kind which the employee availed while in service and couldn’t be
cleared, can be treated as Government due. However, in the
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 8
instant case it is not so therefore, the petitioners prayed for a
direction to refund the deducted amount of money of Rs.
91,936/- (Ninety one thousand nine hundred and thirty six only),
Rs. 2,05,226/- (Two lakh five thousand two hundred twenty six
only), Rs. 1,72,703/- (One lakh seventy two thousand seven
hundred and three only) and Rs. 1,40,787/- (One lakh forty
thousand seven hundred and eighty seven only) respectively.
[8]
Most importantly, in the instant case, it is not
disputed that the appellants/petitioners are the primary teachers
in the Education Department and got retired in the year 2006
and 2008 respectively almost two decades back.
[9]
It is well settled that the pension is not the bounty,
but a hard earned benefits/money of an employee, who has put
in long and dedicated service till their age of retirement. The
same principle would hold good for other retirement benefits
also. It is no doubt true that the appellants gave their consent in
the aforesaid consent certificates, agreeing to the deduction of
Government dues from their retirement gratuity or from other
pension benefits payable to bank, however, merely because their
consent were given by them did not absolute the authorities
from basing such deduction on legally valid and tenable grounds.
We should also keep in mind that an employee on the verge of
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 9
retirement would not in a position to bargain and would be
inclined to give consent so that his/her retirement benefits are
processed expeditiously. Therefore, the mere fact that the
petitioners gave their consent is not sufficient in itself to hold
against them and gave the authorities a clean chit for their
arbitrary and wholly unsustainable it.
[10]
Normally/obviously, if the retiring staff refused to
sign in the consent letter, the pension proposal could not be
processed. Therefore, face with that situation only, the employee
is signing, in the instant case, as rightly argued by the learned
counsel for the appellants/petitioners, the petitioners are at that
stage are bound to sign said letters against their will for speedy
sanction of their pension proposal. Thus, the case of the
respondents that base on the consent letter was made cannot be
countenance.
[11]
In (1994) 2 SCC 521 (Shyam Babu Verma & Ors.
-versus- Union of India & Ors.), wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that:
“11. Although we have held that the petitioners were
entitled only to the pay scale of Rs 330-480 in terms of
the recommendations of the Third Pay Commission
w.e.f. January 1, 1973 and only after the period of 10
years, they became entitled to the pay scale of Rs 330560 but as they have received the scale of Rs 330-560
since 1973 due to no fault of theirs and that scale is
being reduced in the year 1984 with effect from January
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 10
1, 1973, it shall only be just and proper not to recover
any excess amount which has already been paid to
them. Accordingly, we direct that no steps should be
taken to recover or to adjust any excess amount paid to
the petitioners due to the fault of the respondents, the
petitioners being in no way responsible for the same.”
[12]
In AIR 2015 SC 696 (State of Punjab and others –
versus- Rafiq Masih), the Hon’ble Supreme Court at para 18
held that:“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the issue of
recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made
by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that
as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein
above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by the
employers, would be impermissible in law:
Recovery from the employees belongings to
(i)
Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service).
(ii)
Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
Recovery from the employees, when the excess
(iii)
payment has been made for period in excess of
five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv)
Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required
to work against an inferior post.
In any other case, where the Court arrives at the
(v)
conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would for
outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer’s right to recover.”
[13]
The observation made by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court is squarely applicable to the case in hand, as some of such
observation are that where recovery is impermissible in law are:-
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 11
(i) Recovery from the employees belongings to Class-III and
Class-IV service (or Group-C and Group-D service); (ii) Recovery
from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to
retire within one year, of the order of recovery; (iii) Recovery
from the employees, when the excess payment has been made
for period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
[14]
In the present case, since the petitioners hold a
Class – III post before their retirement and since any alleged
excess payment has been made more than four decades back,
we are of the considered view that it is not permissible to make
any recovery from the retirement benefits of the petitioners on
the ground of excess payment of pay and allowances, in view of
the Principals laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to
herein above.
[15]
In the result, taking into consideration the facts
and circumstance of the present case and discussions and
reasons given herein above and keeping in view the orders and
observations made by the Hon’ble Apex Court, we are of the
view that the order of the Hon’ble Single Judge impugned herein
is bad in fact as well as in law. Accordingly, the order of the
Hon’ble Single Judge is set aside and the present appeal is
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 12
allowed with direction to the respondents to refund the deducted
amount of money of Rs. 91,936/- (Ninety one thousand nine
hundred and thirty six only), Rs. 2,05,226/- (Two lakh five
thousand two hundred twenty six only), Rs. 1,72,703/- (One lakh
seventy two thousand seven hundred and three only) and Rs.
1,40,787/- (One lakh forty thousand seven hundred and eighty
seven only) respectively to the appellants/petitioners, within
2(two) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order.
[16]
With the above, the present writ appeal is disposed
of. Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Lucy
Writ Appeal No. 49 of 2019
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review