Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:2496
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S.A. No. 384 of 2019
1. Smt. Padda Mahtain, aged about 68 years, widow of Late Kalipada
Mahto
2. Ajit Mahato, aged about 53 years,
3. Kisto Mahato, aged about 54 years
4. Laltu Mahato, aged about 30 years
Nos. 2 to 4, sons of Late Kalipada Mahato
All are residents of Kalipahari, P.O. & P.S. Chirkunda, District
Dhanbad
…
…
Plaintiffs/Appellants/Appellants
-Versus1. Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC), represented by the Chief
Engineer (C), Office: At & P.O.-Maithon Dam, P.S. Chirkunda,
District Dhanbad
…
… Principal Defendants/Respondents/Respondents
2. Atul Mahato
3. Haradhan Mahato
Both sons of Late Nakul Mahato, residents of Kalipahari, P.O. & P.S.
Chirkunda, District Dhanbad
…
… Proforma Defendants/Respondents/Respondents
--CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellants
: Mr. A. K. Sahani, Advocate
For the Respondents
:
--th
19/29 January 2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants.
2.
This appeal has been filed against the judgment dated 20.08.2019
(decree sealed and signed on 29.08.2019) passed by the learned District
Judge-II, Dhanbad in Civil Appeal No. 22 of 2018, whereby the appeal
has been dismissed and the judgment dated 17.11.2017 (Decree sealed and
signed on 30.11.2017) passed by the learned Additional Civil Judge (Jr.
Division), Dhanbad in Title Suit No. 08 of 2007 has been affirmed. The
learned trial court has dismissed the suit.
2026:JHHC:2496
3.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
plaintiffs have lost in both the courts, but still a substantial question of law
arises for consideration in this case.
4.
The learned counsel has submitted that the land described in
Schedule-A of the plaint appertaining to C.S. Khata No. 71, C.S. Plot No.
1462, area 21 decimals and C.S. Plot No. 1463 area 13 decimals (Exhibit3) was recorded in C.S. record of rights in the name of Banshi Mahato,
S/o Late Dinu Mahato and Budhu Mahato, S/o Late Beni Mahato. The
learned counsel has further submitted that Lilu Mahato and Nakul Mahato
were the sister’s son of the recorded raiyat Banshi Mahato, who used to
live in the house of Banshi Mahato alongwith their mother, namely, Rasna
Mahtain and said Banshi Mahato orally gifted the Schedule-A property to
his aforesaid Bhaginas (sister’s sons) , namely, Lilu Mahato and Nakul
Mahato and as such they were in peaceful possession of the Schedule-A
land and in the remarks column of Exhibit-3, their name was mentioned
with respect to C.S. Plot No. 1462 and 1463.
5.
The learned counsel submits that while in possession, Nakul
Mahato (bhagina of Banshi Mahato) died leaving behind three sons,
namely, Atul Mahato, Kalipada Mahato and Haradhan Mahato, who were
defendant no. 2, original plaintiff and defendant no. 3 respectively before
the learned trial court. Similarly, Lilu Mahato ( other bhagina of Banshi
Mahato) also died leaving behind his only son Kashinath Mahato who
inherited the Schedule-A property and sold his half share to Kalipada
Mahato, S/o Late Nakul Mahato vide registered sale deed No. 9462
dated 11.04.1978 and said Kalipada Mahato (the original plaintiff) came
in possession over Schedule-A property with his two brothers who were
proforma defendant nos. 2 and 3.
6.
The learned counsel has submitted that that in the recent revisional
survey operation, portion of CS Plot No. 1462 and 1463 under C.S. Khata
No. 71 was recorded as R.S. Plot No. 1095 and 1096 respectively under
R.S. Khata No. 30 and a draft record of right was prepared in the name of
2026:JHHC:2496
Kalipada Mahato (the original plaintiff). The description of the aforesaid
land has been given in Schedule-B of the plaint.
7.
Against the said entry of the plaintiff’s name in the draft record of
right, the defendant no. 1 i.e. Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) filed an
application under Section 89 of the Chhota Nagpur Tenancy Act, 1908
(CNT Act) before the Settlement Officer, Dhanbad, which was registered
as Case No. 18266/1997 and the Settlement Officer, Dhanbad allowed the
said application in favor of the defendant no. 1 vide order dated
05.08.2005 and consequently, the plaintiff had filed the Title Suit No.
08/2007.
8.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
defendant no. 1 i.e. Damodar Valley Corporation filed their written
statement stating that the plaintiffs had no valid cause of action and the
suit was barred under the provision of CNT Act. It was asserted in the
written statement that the land in question was acquired by the DVC in
L.A. Case No. 01/1950-51 and the compensation was paid to the recorded
raiyat-Nakul Mahato (father of the original plaintiff) vide voucher no. 129
dated 06.06.1952. It was also asserted that the plaintiffs were contesting
the suit on the basis of the sale deed dated 11.04.1978, but the plaintiffs
never challenged the order before any competent court. The title of the
plaintiffs on the basis of the sale deed dated 1.04.1978 was disputed.
9.
The learned counsel submits that the defendant 1 st party did not
adduce any documentary evidence to support their claim and further only
one witness was examined as DW-1, but he was not cross-examined and
therefore his statement was not read as evidence.
10.
The learned counsel submits that the entire case was decided in
absence of any evidence from the side of the contesting defendant i.e.
DVC. The learned counsel submits that the learned trial court had decided
issue nos. 1 and 2 in favour of the plaintiffs, but the learned 1st appellate
court has reversed the finding without any cross-objection or cross-appeal
from the side of the contesting defendant. The learned counsel submits
2026:JHHC:2496
that such an approach by the learned 1st appellate court is not permissible
under law.
11.
After hearing the learned counsel for the appellants, who has given
the factual background from the impugned judgment, this Court finds that
the suit was filed seeking a declaration of right, title interest and
possession with respect to Schedule-B property in favor of the plaintiffs
alongwith the proforma defendants and also for a decree of permanent
injunction restraining the defendant no. 1 (Damodar Valley CorporationDVC)
from interfering with the possession of the plaintiffs and the
proforma defendants over the lands described in Schedule-B of the pliant.
12.
The defendant no. 1 had filed the written statement stating that the
disputed land was acquired vide notification dated 18.04.1951 and that the
DVC had filed a case under Section 89 of the CNT Act for rectification
and correction of record of rights which was decided in favor of the
defendant no. 1 vide order dated 05.08.2005 and that the plaintiffs and the
proforma defendant nos. 2 and 3 were not in possession of the acquired
land of plot no. 1462 and 1463 of khata no. 71 and R.S. plot no. 1095 and
1096, area 24 decimals of Kalipahari Mouza.
13.
The defendant no. 2 had also filed his written statement supporting
the case of the plaintiffs.
14.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial court
framed the following issues for consideration: “1. Whether suit filed by plaintiff is maintainable in the
present form?
2. Whether plaintiff has valid cause of action in the present
suit?
3. Whether the plaintiff has right, title and possession over the
suit land as described in Schedule-B land?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any other relief or reliefs
as prayed by him?”
15.
The learned trial court decided issue nos. 1 and 2 in favor of the
plaintiffs by observing that in spite of the fact that the application under
Section 89 of the CNT Act was decided in favor of the DVC vide order
2026:JHHC:2496
dated 05.08.2005, the suit seeking declaration of title and confirmation of
possession was not barred under Section 258 of the CNT Act.
16.
So far as issue nos. 3 and 4 are concerned, the learned trial court
considered the materials on record and recorded that the plaintiff has filed
the suit to establish that he has title over the Schedule-B land and has
pleaded that Lilu Mahato and Nakul Mahato were the Bhaginas in sisterly
relation of the recorded raiyat Banshi Mahato who used to live in the
house of Banshi Mahato alongwith their mother, namely, Rasna Mahtian
and it was the case of the plaintiff that before Cadastral Survey Operation
of record of rights, the recorded raiyat Banshi Mahato had orally gifted
the Schedule-A property to his aforesaid Bhaginas, namely, Lilu Mahato
and Nakul Mahato and they were in possession of the Schedule-A
property. The learned trial court further recorded that it was pleaded that
Nakul Mahato died leaving behind three sons, namely, Atul Mahato,
Kalipada Mahato and Haradhan Mahato and similarly Nakul Mahato died
leaving behind one son, namely, Kashinath Mahato and consequently they
inherited the Schedule-A property and came in peaceful possession.
Further, it was also pleaded that Kashinath Mahato had sold the ScheduleA property to the extent of his share to the original plaintiff-Kalipada
Mahato, S/o Nakul Mahato vide registered sale deed dated 11.04.1978 and
delivered the possession in favor of the original plaintiff and thus the
original plaintiff alongwith the proforma defendants have become the
absolute owners with respect to Schedule-A land.
17.
The learned trial court thereafter referred to the provision of Section
122 of the Transfer of Property Act and recorded that the plaintiff claimed
that he received Schedule-A land by oral gift, but oral gift of immovable
properties is invalid in law until and unless it is in writing and registered.
The learned trial court ultimately decided issue no. 3 and 4 against the
plaintiff. The finding is as follows: “………………………………………………………………………..
..……………………………………………………………………….
2026:JHHC:2496
In the present suit the Plaintiff himself claims that schedule A
land was transferred to him orally. There is no gift deed. The
plaintiff had possession over aforesaid land but he had no
title. There is no deed executed in his favour. The plaintiff
failed to prove his right, title and interest over Schedule A and
B land. He has examined four witnesses P.W.-1,2,3 &4. The
P.W. 1 & 2 have supported his possession over schedule A &
Schedule B land but there is no oral evidence in support his
title to the aforesaid land. In fact Title cannot be proved by
oral evidence. For proving Title it has to show the roots from
where it emerged and how it was acquired by him. The
plaintiff claims that he received Schedule A land by oral gifts.
But oral gift of immovable properties is invalid in law until
and unless it is in writing registered. All of them has
supported his claim for possession. But his claim of title, right
and interest is not established. He has stated in his arguments
that defendants failed to prove their right and title over the
schedule B land. In present case it was Plaintiff who came
before court with prayer of declaration of right title and
interest. It was his duty to prove his claim. The benefit of
lacunae on the part of defendant cannot be given to him.
The plaintiff who is examined as P.W. 1 has denied that his
father has not received any compensation form D.V.C. but he
has admitted that there was dispute between D.V.C. and his
father and order of settlement officer u/s 89 C.N.T. Act against
them. The Ext-4 which is certified copy of order passed by
settlement officer is passed in favour of defendant, DVC.
Although D.V.C. has not filed relevant documents to support
their claim but it doesn't justify claim of plaintiff.
The issue no.4 is whether plaintiff is entitled to any other relief
or reliefs? This issue is also not decided in his favour. In my
opinion Plaintiff is not entitled to any other relief or reliefs.”
18.
The learned 1st appellate court considered the materials on record
and framed the following point for consideration : “(i) Whether the plaintiffs/appellants have right, title and
possession over Schedule-B land.
2026:JHHC:2496
(ii) Whether issue no. I & II decided by court below in
favour of plaintiffs/appellants is not sustainable in the eye
of law.
(iii) Impugned Judgment and decree of the Ld. Court below
dismissing the suit is sustainable in the facts and evidences
available on the record.”
19.
The learned 1st appellate court considered all the points and held
that the suit was not maintainable and the plaintiff had no valid cause of
action. However, at the same time, the learned court has entered into the
merits of the case also and has recorded a clear finding that the plaintiff
has not been able to prove his right, title and possession with respect to
the suit property. The learned 1st appellate court recorded that mere entry
in the remark column of record of rights neither create any title in favor of
any person nor the same extinguishes the right of any party and entries in
remark column in khatiyan is not a proof of title.
20.
The learned 1st appellate court referred to Exhibit-4, which was the
order passed by the Settlement Officer, wherein it was recorded that the
compensation with respect to the suit property was given in L.A. Case No.
01/1950-51, but the order passed under Section 89 was not challenged and
Exhibit-1 of the year 1978 was executed after the acquisition. The learned
court also recorded that the plaintiffs had asserted that the vendor had
derived title by virtue of oral gift of Schedule-A property and then sold by
virtue of registered sale deed dated 11.04.1978, but neither any date of gift
was mentioned nor any such document was produced and such transaction
was against the provision of Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act.
21.
This Court finds that both the learned courts have entered into the
claim of title of the plaintiffs whose claim was based on oral gift and the
same was held to be in violation of Section 123 of the Transfer of
Property Act and thus, the plaintiff along with proforma defendant no. 2
and 3 failed to prove their right and title over the property.
22.
This court finds that both the courts have passed well-reasoned
judgement considering every aspect of the matter. No perversity in the
2026:JHHC:2496
matter of appreciation of evidence by the learned courts has been pointed
out by the learned counsel for the appellants. This Court finds that no
question of law, much less any substantial question of law is involved in
this 2nd appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
23.
Pending I.A., if any, is closed.
24.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the court concerned
through ‘e-mail/FAX’.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Dated: 29.01.2026
Mukul/Uploaded On: 09.03.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review