Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 3 of 2019
Ref: WP(C) No. 872 of 2017
Smt. I. Nalini Devi, aged about 61 years, W/o Nameirakpam
Biramani Singh, resident of MLA Quarter No. 4 Major Khul, P.O.
Imphal, P.S. City Police, District Imphal West, Manipur, Pin795008.
…... Appellant/s
(Respondent No. 3 in the Writ Petition)
- Versus 1.
Smt. N. Nalinibala Devi, aged about 61 years, W/o W.
Pishak Singh, resident of Singjamei Makha Khongnang
Pheidekpi, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei and District Imphal West,
Manipur Pin-795008.
........Principal Respondent
(Petitioner in Writ Petition)
2.
3.
The State of Manipur through the Principal Secretary
(Health & F.W.) Government of Manipur, Imphal, Manipur,
Pin-795001.
The Director of Health Services, Government of Manipur,
Imphal, Manipur
.......Proforma Respondent/s
(Respondent Nos. 1 to 2
in the writ Petition)
with
WA No. 37 of 2017
Ref: WP(C) No. 512 of 2015
Smt. I. Nalini Devi, aged about 60 years, W/o Nameirakpam
Biramani Singh, resident of MLA Quarter No. 4 Major Khul, P.O.
Imphal, P.S. City Police, District Imphal West, Manipur, Pin795008.
…... Appellant/s
(Respondent No. 2 in the Writ Petition)
Page 1
- Versus 1.
Smt. N. Nalinibala Devi, aged about 60 years, W/o W.
Pishak Singh, resident of Singjamei Makha Khongnang
Pheidekpi, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei and District Imphal West,
Manipur Pin-795008.
........Principal Respondent
(Petitioner in Writ Petition)
2.
The State of Manipur, through Principal Secretary (Health
& Family Welfare), Government of Manipur, Imphal,
Manipur Pin-795001
3.
Dr. N. Surbala Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
4.
Smt. Kh. Ratna Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
5.
Smt. Th. Nandarani Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
6.
Smt. A. Ibeyaima Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
7.
Smt. M. Shanti Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
.......Proforma Respondent/s
(Respondent Nos. 1, 3 to 7
in the writ Petition)
with
WA No. 38 of 2017
Ref: WP(C) No. 512 of 2015
The State of Manipur, through Principal Secretary (Health &
Family Welfare), Government of Manipur, Imphal, Manipur Pin795001
…... Appellant/s
(Respondent No. 1 in the Writ Petition)
- Versus -
Page 2
1.
Smt. N. Nalinibala Devi, aged about 60 years, W/o W.
Pishak Singh, resident of Singjamei Makha Khongnang
Pheidekpi, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei and District Imphal West,
Manipur Pin-795008.
........Principal Respondent
(Petitioner in Writ Petition)
2.
Smt. I. Nalini Devi, aged about 60 years, W/o Nameirakpam
Biramani Singh, resident of MLA Quarter No. 4 Major Khul,
P.O. Imphal, P.S. City Police, District Imphal West,
Manipur, Pin-795001.
3.
Dr. N. Surbala Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
4.
Smt. Kh. Ratna Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
5.
Smt. Th. Nandarani Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
6.
Smt. A. Ibeyaima Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
7.
Smt. M. Shanti Devi, Associate Professor, College of
Nursing, Medical Directorate, Manipur.
.......Proforma Respondent/s
(Respondent Nos. 2 to 7
in the writ Petition)
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MV. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Appellants
::
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Mrs. N. Savitri, Advocate & Mr. S.
Nepolean, G.A. assisted by Mrs. RK
Emily, Deputy GA.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Adv. assisted
by Ms. Rebati, Advocate & Mr. HS.
Paonam, Sr. Adv. assisted by Mr. S.
Gunabanta, Advocate.
Page 3
Date of Hearing
::
23.02.2023/01.03.2023/01.08.2023/02.08.2023/
14.08.2023/23.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
:: 31.10.2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[A. Guneshwar Sharma, J.]
[1]
Heard Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for the appellant
assisted by Mrs. N. Savitri, Advocate in W.A. No. 3 of 2019 and W.A. No. 37 of
2017, Mr. S. Nepolean, learned G.A. for the appellant assisted by Mrs. RK Emily,
Deputy GA in W.A. No. 38 of 2017, Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel
for contesting respondent No. 1 assisted by Ms. Rebati, Advocate in all the writ
appeals and Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel for the private
respondents assisted by Mr. S. Gunabanta, Advocate.
[2]
The present writ appeals, being WA Nos. 37 of 2017 & 38 of 2017
have been filed by the appellants (i.e., private party and State respectively)
praying for quashing and setting aside the judgment & order dated 12.05.2017
passed by a Single Bench of this Court in WP(C) No. 512 of 2015 whereby
quashing the order dated 01.08.2014 issued by the Under Secretary (Health),
Government of Manipur in respect of principal respondent/private respondent
No. 2 with the directions that the State Government shall constitute a special
DPC within 3 (three) weeks and the so constituted DPC shall examine and
consider the case of the petitioner within 3 (three) weeks. WA No. 3 of 2019 is
Page 4
filed by the appellant Smt. I. Nalini Devi against the impugned judgment/order
dated 05.12.2018 passed by a Single Bench of this Court in WP(C) No. 872 of
2017 whereby order dated 28.10.2017 passed by the State Government in
pursuance of a Special DPC constituted on the directions of the Single Judge
in Para 10 of the judgment/order dated 12.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 573 of 2015,
was set aside for non-compliance of the aforesaid directions.
[3]
Since the writ appeals relate to the same issue of appointment of
the appellant in WA Nos. 37 of 2017 and 3 of 2019, these are heard together
and being disposed of by a common order herein. In order to avoid reference
to different appellants and respondents by names in these appeals and for easy
identification, the parties are referred to their respective nomenclatures as
given in WP(C) No. 512 of 2015. Accordingly, in these writ appeals, Smt. N.
Nalinibala Devi will be referred as writ petitioner/petitioner, Smt. I. Nalini Devi
as respondent No.2, State as State respondent(s) and others as private
respondents.
[4]
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner was initially
appointed as Sister Tutor vide order dated 20.10.1981 issued by the Director
of Medical Health & FW, Government of Manipur on the recommendation of a
DPC held on 28.09.1981. On 26.11.2010, the Under Secretary (Health),
Government of Manipur conveyed to the Director, Health Services, Manipur
regarding approval of the Government for nomination of the petitioner for
undergoing M.Sc. (Nursing) Course for the session 2010-2011 at the Regional
College of Nursing, Guwahati
and on 03.10.2011, the Director of Health
Page 5
Services, Manipur issued a memorandum wherein the final seniority list of
Sister Tutors, Public Health Nurses and Public Health Nurse Instructor as on
03.10.2011 was published and the name of the petitioner appeared at serial
No. 2 (Sister Tutor and the private respondent No. 2 appeared at serial No. 3.
The Under Secretary (Health), Government of Manipur issued an order dated
23.11.2011 where the petitioner along with another incumbent were promoted
to the post of Principal, FHW/GNM Training School in the Health and FW
Department, Manipur on regular basis on the recommendation of a DPC
meeting held on 16.11.2011 wherein the name of the petitioner appeared at
serial No. 1 followed by an order dated 01.12.2011 where the petitioner was
transferred and posted as Principal, School of GNM, Imphal and her name
appeared at serial No. 2.
[5]
On 07.09.2012, the Commissioner (Health & FW), Government of
Manipur issued an order wherein certain members of the teaching faculty under
the said department were utilized their services in the newly established
College of Nursing, Imphal and in the said order, one Smt. N. Kumudini Devi
who is just above the petitioner in the seniority list dated 03.10.2011 was utilized
as Principal of the College of Nursing, Imphal without considering the seniority
position of the petitioner and private respondent No. 2 (who is at serial No. 2)
has been utilized as Vice-Principal of the said College of Nursing, Imphal. On
07.09.2013, the Jt. Director (Nursing), Medical Directorate, Government of
Manipur prepared a list of teaching staffs of School of GNM & FHW Training
School, Medical Directorate wherein the name of the petitioner appeared at
Page 6
serial No. 1 with the remark that she was undergoing M.Sc. Course by enjoying
study leave till January, 2013 and the private respondent No. 2 , who is at serial
No. 2, of the said list as in-charge Principal of the School of GNM till regular
Principal returned.
[6]
On 25.09.2012, the Secretary, Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi
conveyed to the Principal, College of Nursing, Medical Directorate, Lamphelpat
that the Institution was permitted/suitable for B.Sc. (N) Programme with an
intake of 40 seats subject to the approval of State Nursing Council and
University/Board for the academic year 2012-2013. On 06.10.2013, the Deputy
Secretary (Health), Government of Manipur issued an order transferring and
posting of two incumbents including the private respondent No. 2, who was
given in-charge Principal, FHW Raining School, FW Lamphel with the remark
that the said arrangement was made till the petitioner finished her PG Course
and took over charge as Principal FHW Training School, Lamphel. The
petitioner successfully passed the M.Sc. Nursing Final Examination held in
December, 2012 in First Division from the Regional College of Nursing,
Guwahati, Assam.
[7]
On 29.12.2012, the Principal, College of Nursing, Medical
Directorate, Government of Manipur addressed a letter to the Director of Health
Services, Government of Manipur informing that regular class for B.Sc.
(Nursing) would be started from 05.11.2012 along with a chart of the teaching
faculty wherein the name of the private respondent No. 2 appeared at Sl. No.
2. Since, the petitioner having completed her M.S.c. (Nursing) course, the
Page 7
Director of Health Services, Manipur issued an order dated 18.03.2013 by
which the petitioner was relieved from her place of posting i.e. Principal, GNM
School, Lamphel to enable her to join at her new place of posting i.e., Principal,
FHW Training School, Family Welfare, Lamphel. In continuation of its earlier
order, the Deputy Secretary (Health) issued an order dated 16.07.2013 utilising
the services of the teaching faculty/Nursing Personnel mentioned therein
without the name of the petitioner as the Teaching Faculty Member in the
College of Nursing.
[8]
The Petitioner submitted a representation dated 18.07.2013 to the
Director of Health Services, Government of Manipur requesting to
upgrade/elevate her to a suitable post in the College of Nursing, Lamphel by
highlighting that she has been promoted to the post of Principal of GNM Nursing
School, Lamphel on 23.11.2011 and as per the seniority list, she appeared at
Sl. No. 2 and she has a total experience of 31 years as Sister Tutor in teaching
and one and half years as Principal. Moreover, she also possessed M.Sc.
Nursing (Pediatric Specialist). Without taking into consideration, the
qualification, experience obtained by the petitioner, the Under Secretary
(Health & FW), Government of Manipur issued an impugned order on
01.08.2014 whereby certain existing posts of the College of Nursing under the
Medical & Health Department, Manipur were upgraded/re-designated and
persons holding the posts were also absorbed against the re-designated post
and by the said order, the post of Public Health Nurse Instructor (PHNI),
RHFWCT, Imphal was re-designated as Professor-cum-Vice-Principal, College
Page 8
of Nursing and private respondent No. 2 was absorbed against this redesignated post. In the said impugned order, the petitioner was absorbed as
Associate Professor, College of Nursing.
[9]
Being suspicious of some fault play while issuing the impugned
order dated 01.08.2014, an application under RTI Act, 2005 was made by
seeking certain query/information as regards the procedure for absorption.
However, no information was furnished to the applicant in respect of the
procedure for absorption and senior position of the faculty members. Being
aggrieved by the said impugned order, the respondent No. 1/ writ petitioner filed
a writ petition being WP(C) No. 512 of 2015 before this Court by challenging
the legality of the of the impugned order dated 01.08.2014 on the inter-alia
grounds that in the impugned order dated 01.08.2014, no source of power by
which the post of Professor-cum-Vice-Principal was re-designated, was
disclosed and in the said impugned order, the post of Professor-cum-VicePrincipal, School of Nursing is bad in the eyes of law, the private respondent
No. 2 does not possess the requisite qualification of 5 years of teaching
experience as she never rendered her service as Tutor/Teacher by giving
classes to the nursing students. In the impugned order dated 01.08.2014, in
respect of the post of Professor-cum-Vice-Principal was issued in an arbitrary
manner just to favour the private respondent No. 2 and no reason was assigned
in the impugned order for issuing the name of same. While issuing the
impugned order, due process of law was not followed, meaning thereby that no
selection process/regular DPC was held by the State Government and at the
Page 9
time when the private respondent No. 2 was absorbed as Professor-cum-VicePrincipal, College of Nursing, she was a non-gazetted officer and the appointed
of the petitioner and other eligible incumbents ought to have been done by
following the relevant Recruitment Rules, 2012 frame by the INC.
[10]
The State Government (respondent No. 1) filed an affidavit-in-
opposition wherein it is stated that at the time of establishing the College of
Nursing, the State Government followed the Guidelines, 2012 of the INC
circulated with regard to the qualifications of the teaching staff and as per the
said guidelines, the qualifications for appointment to the post of Professor-cumVice-Principal are (i) M.Sc. in Nursing and (ii) five years of teaching experience.
Whereas, the said guidelines did not prescribe a specific condition that one
would have served as a Lecturer/Tutor in a recognized Nursing College as prerequisite criteria for appointment as Professor-cum-Vice-Principal in the
College of Nursing. In order to start the B.Sc. (Nursing) Programme and to get
permission from the INC, the State Government utilized the services of some
employees vide order dated 07.09.2012 including the private respondent No.
2, who had rendered service for more than 20 years in the Regional Health and
Family Welfare Training Centre, Imphal. Vide letter dated 25.09.2012, the INC
accorded permission that the service of the private respondent No. 2 was
absorbed as Professor-cum-Vice-Principal on regular basis. It is further stated
that the essential qualification or appointment as a member of the faculty in the
College of Nursing being M.Sc. (Nursing), the petitioner was not qualified for
her service being utilised as a faculty member and since, the post held by her
Page 10
in the past are not feeder posts for appointment as a member of the faculty, the
question of seniority is not relevant and application. Even though the petitioner
was granted study leave for pursuing the M.Sc. (Nursing) course, there was no
guarantee that she should be given deputation for appointment as member of
the faculty. When the order dated 07.09.2012 was issued by the State
Government, the petitioner was not considered for utilizing as the Professor
and the Associate Professor as she being a holder of B.Sc. whereas the private
respondent No. 2 having passed the M.Sc. (Nursing) in the year 1986, was
considered for utilizing as Professor-cum-Vice-Principal. It is stated that the
petitioner has no locus to review the Government (utilization) order dated
07.09.2012 where the services of the private respondents have been utilized.
Prior to her possession of M.Sc (Nursing), the petitioner was not qualified for
being utilised as a faculty member and she has not locus against the
Government order dated 07.09.2012 and its subsequent orders. In order to run
State’s own Nursing College, the faculty members were appointed by redesignating the posts held by the incumbents and other vacant posts without
creating fresh posts and by absorption against the re-designated posts
considering their years of passing M.Sc. (Nursing) and their teaching
experience. The petitioner having passed M.Sc. (Nursing) only in the year
2013, she was considered for appointment as the Associate Professor. The
post of Public Health Nursing Instructor at Regional Health & Family Welfare is
a teaching cadre post and the private respondent No. 2, being holding the said
post, had been re-designated as Professor-cum-Vice-Principal. The re-
Page 11
designated of the post and absorption of incumbents against the re-designated
posts was a state policy done with the approval of the State Cabinet in its
meeting held on 07.07.2014 and the re-designation and absorption orders were
issued in concurrence with the Finance Department and the Department of
Personnel. But the consultation from the MPSC was exempted due to the
urgent need of the faculty members in order to make the Nursing College
Functional.
[11]
The respondent Nos. 2 & 3 also filed affidavit-in-opposition where
it is stated that the respondent No. 2 passed B.Sc. (Nursing) in the year 1979
and M.Sc. (Nursing) in the year 1986 whereas respondent No. 3 passed B.Sc.
(Nursing) in the year 1988 and M.Sc. (Nursing) in the year 1995. In terms of the
National Health Policy, 2022, the Health Department, Manipur took up a step
to establish a Nursing College in the state and in response to the proposal of
the Central Government, the Director of Health Service, Manipur submitted a
detailed proposal for up-grading the School of GNM to a College of Nursing.
The INC issued a guideline prescribing minimum requirements to establish
B.Sc. (Nursing) College and the essential qualification for appointment of
Professor-cum-Vice-Principal was M.Sc. (Nursing) and the petitioner obtained
her post-graduate only in the year 2013 and in order to meet the urgent need
of qualified staff to establish the Nursing College, the private respondent No. 2
was allowed to work as in-charge Principal of the GNM Training School till
03.01.2013 and thereafter, she was utilized as the Vice-Principal, College of
Nursing. The College of Nursing started functioning in the year 2012 after
Page 12
obtaining approval from the INC. The Principal, College of Nursing issued an
order dated 14.01.2013 requesting all the qualified members of Nursing
Candidates to submit their necessary documents for consideration of
absorption to the post of teaching staff of the College of Nursing. The Director
of Health Services, Manipur issued a Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 [Annx.C23 to WP filed for first time by R-2 & 3] for furnishing documents on or before
11.03.2013 from all the Sister Tutors, Public Health Nurses and Public Health
Nursing Instructors and on 19.04.2013, the Director of Health Services,
Manipur
addressed
to
the
Principal
Secretary
(Health
&
Family
Welfare),Government of Manipur submitting proposal for creating, framing of
rules and appointment of qualified staffs as faculty members and made
proposal for absorption. The petitioner never possessed the essential
qualification nor did she have the teaching experience. After availing the
infrastructure and the teaching faculty, the INC, having satisfied, granted the
permission to start functioning of the Nursing College. Accordingly, the
Government of Manipur issued an order dated 01.08.2014 re-designating
certain posts as indicated in the order after approval being granted by the
Cabinet as well as Finance Department.
[12]
The writ petitioner filed two similar rejoinder affidavits both dated
25.02.2016 to the counter affidavits of the State Respondent and private
respondent Nos. 2 & 3. It is stated that private respondent No.2 passed M. Sc.
Nursing in the year 1986, but she did not possess the requisite teaching
experience as per the prescribed Recruitment Rules for the post of Professor-
Page 13
cum-Vice Principal as she had never rendered her service either as a Lecturer
or Tutor to any recognised Nursing School in Manipur. It is emphasised that the
minimum 5 (five) years of teaching experience should be in the field of Nursing
as per the prescribed norms/rules of the Indian Nursing Council. It is stated that
all the private respondents were juniors to the writ petitioner as per the Seniority
List dated 30.06.1989 issued by the Joint Director, Health Services, Manipur. It
is highlighted that respondent No.2 had never rendered any teaching class as
a teacher in any GNM or ANM School nor in any Nursing College under the
Government of Manipur, before her absorption as Professor-cum-Vice Principal
to the newly established Nursing College. She did not possess the requisite
qualification of 5 (five) years teaching experience as per the Recruitment Rules
of Indian Nursing Council framed in the year 2012. It has been pointed out that
Indian Nursing Council recognised the following programmes as types of
nursing programmes, ie, (i) Auxiliary Nurse & Midwife- 2 years; (ii) General
Nursing & Midwifery- 3½ years; (iii) B.Sc.(Basic) – 4 years; (iv) B.Sc.(Post
Basic)- 2-3 years; (v) M.Sc.- 2 years; (vi) M.Phil- 1-2 years; (vii) Ph.D.- 3-5
years. It is pointed out that respondent No.2 never conducted classes to any of
the aforesaid nursing programmes and hence did not possess the requisite
qualification. The petitioner relied to the Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 issued
by the Director of Health Service, Manipur (annexed by the respondent No.2 as
Annx.C-23 in her counter affidavit in the writ petition) which prescribed that
teaching experience should be in FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) courses. It is stated that
respondent No.2 had no teaching experience in FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) courses
Page 14
as prescribed in the aforesaid Memorandum and hence not qualified for
appointment as Professor-cum-Vice Principal in the newly established Nursing
College.
[13]
The State respondent filed a reply affidavit dated 31.01.2017 to
the rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner. It is stated that at the time of establishing
the College of Nursing under the Medical Directorate, Manipur, the State
Government followed the guidelines of the Indian Nursing Council of June,
2012 regarding the qualifications of the Teaching Staff for B.Sc. (Nursing)
programme. The Guidelines prescribed the following:
For the post of Professor-cum-Vice Principal
- Master Degree in Nursing;
- Total 10 years of experience with minimum of 5 years of teaching
experience;
- Desirable: Independent published work of high standard/doctorate degree/
M.Phil;
For the post of Reader/Associate Professor
- Master Degree in Nursing;
- Total 7 years of experience with minimum of 3 years of teaching experience;
- Desirable: Independent published work of high standard/doctorate degree/
M.Phil;
It is stated that as per the Guidelines, a person has to possess 5 years
teaching experience as eligibility criteria for appointment to the post of
Professor-cum-Vice Principal, but the Guidelines do not prescribe the condition
specifying for serving as a Lecturer or Tutor in a recognised Nursing School as
Page 15
pre-requisite criteria for appointment as Professor-cum-Vice Principal in the
Nursing College. It is clarified that respondent No.2 passed M.Sc. (Nursing) in
the year 1986 and she rendered for more than 26 years in the Regional Health
& Family welfare Training Centre, Imphal teaching carious categories of Health
& Family Welfare Personnel and Tutors/Public Health Nursing Tutors, Auxiliary
Nurse Midwiferies/Female Health Workers, etc. and hence she was eligible at
the relevant time. It is further stated that to enable to start B.Sc. (Nursing)
programme and also to get permission/recognition from the Indian Nursing
Council, the State Government utilised the service of respondent No.2 as Vice
Principal of the new College along with the faculty members of existing Nursing
School who had M.Sc. (Nursing) degree vide Government Order No.
27/4/2010-M dated 07.09.2012 and INC granted the permission for starting the
B. Sc. (Nursing) programme vide letter No. 02/Sept/2012 dated 25.09.2012. It
is pointed out that the petitioner obtained her provisional certificate dated
14.06.2013 issued by the Principal, Regional College of Nursing, Guwahati,
Asam for passing M.Sc. (Nursing) and as such she was not eligible for
consideration on the date of submission of proposal by the State Government,
ie, as on 07.09.2012 and also on the date of granting permission on 25.09.2012
by the INC to start new B.Sc. (Nursing) course in Manipur. It is also clarified
that the posts of Senior Tutor, Sister Tutor, Public Health Nurse, Public Health
Nursing Instructors, Principal of ANM/FHW Training Schools held by the
petitioner in the past are not feeder posts for appointment to the Faculty posts
in the new College of Nursing and as such the seniority list in the non-feeder
Page 16
posts are not relevant for appointment of Faculty posts in the newly establish
College of Nursing. As per the existing rules, the qualification in the Nursing
School is B.Sc. (Nursing) while in the College, it is M.Sc. (Nursing).
[14]
Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 also filed additional counter affidavit dated
27.02.2017 to the rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner reiterating the stands taken
in their counter affidavit. The Guidelines do not prescribe that the 5 years
teaching experience should be in the field of Nursing only as wrongly contended
by the petitioner. On the other hand, the petitioner was not eligible as she did
not possess M.Sc. (Nursing) degree at the time of consideration by the State
Government and also at the time of granting of permission by the Indian Nursing
Council and as such she had no locus to challenge the appointment of
respondent No.2 as Professor-cum-Vice Principal of the Nursing College.
[15]
In the impugned judgment and order dated 12.05.2017, learned
Single Judge framed three issues for consideration as- “(a) Whether the writ
petition is maintainable or not?; (b) Whether the private respondent No.2 does
possess the requisite qualification of 5 years of teaching experience for
appointment by way of absorption?; (c) Whether, in facts and circumstances of
the present case, the impugned order dated 01.-8.2014 issued by the State
Government is bad in law?”. Regarding the first issue, it was observed that as
per the final inter-se seniority list published on 03.10.2011, the petitioner was
admittedly senior to the private respondent No.2. On 23.11.2011, the petitioner
was promoted to the post of Principal, FHW/GNM Training School in the Health
Page 17
& Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Manipur, while the private respondent
No.2 was never promoted to such post except for holding the charge thereof
when the petitioner was undergoing M.Sc. (Nursing) course. Holding that the
eligibility of a person for appointment by promotion or absorption is relevant at
the time of consideration, the petitioner is eligible. Her appointment as
Associate Professor on absorption in a lower grade will amount to demotion
without any due process. It was held that the petitioner was eligible as per
Guidelines of 2012 issued by INC and the writ petition was maintainable and
the petitioner had locus for question the absorption of the private respondent
No.2 as Vice-Principal. On the second issue, it was observed that the minimum
qualifications for appointment as the Vice-Principal, College of Nursing are- (i)
Master degree in Nursing, and (ii) Total 10 years experience with minimum of
5 years of teaching experience. While interpreting the expression ‘teaching
experience’ as prescribed in Guidelines of 2012, it was held that it should be in
any Nursing programmes recognised by INC and the Regional Health & Family
Welfare Training Centre, Govt. of Manipur was not recognised by the INC.
Further, it was observed that the private respondent No.2 could not produce
any
certificate
that
she
had
teaching
experience
of
years
in
FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) as mentioned in the Memorandum dated 04.03.2013
issued by the Director of Health Services, Govt. of Manipur. Accordingly, it was
held that the private respondent No. 2 was not qualified for being absorbed as
the Vice-Principal, College of Nursing. Consequently, impugned order dated
01.08.2014 issued by the Under Secretary (Health), Govt. of Manipur was
Page 18
quashed and set aside quo the appointment of the private respondent No.2 as
Professor-cum-Vice Principal, College of Nursing, Manipur and directed the
State Government to constitute a special DPC within three weeks to examina
and consider the case of the petitioner and recommend her name for absorption
as Vice-Principal, College of Nursing or any other equivalent post in the cadre
of the Principal, College of Nursing, if found eligible prior to the issuance of the
impugned order dated 01.08.2014.
[16]
As directed by the learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment
and order dated 12.05.2017 in WP(C) No.512 of 2015, a Special DPC was
constituted vide order dated 23.10.2017 and a meeting was convened on
28.10.2017. The Special DPC did not recommend the petitioner for absorption
to the post of Professor-cum-Vice Principal of Nursing College or to any other
equivalent post in the cadre of the Principal, College of Nursing on the grounds
that- (a) The petitioner did not possess the requisite qualification of
M.Sc.(Nursing) prescribed for the post of Professor-cum-Vice Principal at the
time of establishment of the Nursing College in September, 2012 and she was
holding the post of Principal, School of GNM with the qualification of
B.Sc.(Nursing). Even though the order of absorption was on 01.08.2014, the
consideration for the posts was based on the eligibility at the time of
establishment of the College of Nursing in September, 2012.; (b) As per
Guidelines of 2013, the petitioner was also ineligible.; (c) Guidelines of 2013
stated that the experience should be acquired after the receiving of the
M.Sc.(Nursing) degree.; (d) The Committee sought the clarification from Indian
Page 19
Nursing Council regarding the qualification and experience of the petitioner and
the same was awaited.; (e) No post equivalent to the Professor-cum-Vice
Principal, in the cadre of the Principal, College of Nursing was available. A
formal order dated 28.10.2017 was issued by the Under Secretary (Health &
FW), Govt. of Manipur in terms of the proceedings of the Special DPC not
recommending the name of the petitioner for absorption.
[17]
The petitioner challenged the order dated 28.10.2017 intimating
non-recommendation of her name by way of writ petition being WP(C) No. 872
of 2017. Vide impugned order dated 05.12.2018, learned Single Judge held
that the Special DPC did not consider the observations made in para 10 of the
judgment and order dated 12.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 512 of 2015. Since the
Guidelines was purportedly extended upto April 2014, the eligibility of the
petitioner ought to be examined prior to issuance of order of absorption dated
01.08.2014. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 28.10.2017 issued on the
basis of the proceedings of the Special DPC was set aside. However, there was
no further direction for considering the name of the petitioner for absorption.
[18]
Private Respondent No.2 and State challenged the impugned
order dated 12.05.2017 passed by learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 512 of
2015 by filing separate writ appeals being WA No. 37 of 2017 and WA No. 38
of 2017 respectively. Respondent No.2 also challenged the impugned order
dated 05.12.2018 passed by learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 872 of 2017
by filing another writ appeal being WA No. 3 of 2019. As these appeals are
Page 20
relating to the same issue, they are being heard together and disposed of by a
common judgment.
[19]
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government Advocate submits that as
per the Guidelines of 2012 issued by the Indian Nursing Council, the
Qualification of Teaching Staff for B.Sc.(Nursing) programme with 60 students
intake (Relaxed till 2012) for ‘Principal-cum-Vice Principal are - Master Degree
in Nursing; Total 10 years of experience out of which with minimum of 5 years
of teaching experience; Desirable: Independent published work of high
standard/doctorate degree/ M.Phil’. The qualification as per Guidelines of 2013
is M.Sc.(N) with 12 years experience after M.Sc.(N) out of which 10 years
should be teaching experience with minimum of 5 years in collegiate
programme and Ph.D. is desirable. Learned GA has highlighted the important
fact that the qualification as stipulated in the Guidelines of 2012 should be
acquired as on the date of utilisation of the Teaching Faculty of School of GNM,
Imphal; FHW Training School, Imphal and FHW Training School (FW) for
establishing a new Nursing College by the State Government vide order dated
07.09.2012; or on 25.09.2012 when the Indian Nursing Council gave
permission for starting B.Sc.(Nursing) programme for the academic year 201213; or in the month of November, 2012 when the B.Sc.(Nursing) course actually
commenced. It is vehemently submitted that on these relevant dates, the
petitioner did not possess the requisite qualification of M.Sc.(N) degree and as
such she was not eligible for consideration for appointment by absorption as
Professor-cum-Vice Principal in the newly established Nursing College. The
Page 21
petitioner, being ineligible, had no locus to challenge the appointment of private
respondent No.2. Learned GA clarifies that the learned Single Judge committed
patent error in holding that the petitioner was eligible as on the date of issue of
absorption order dated 01.08.2014. It is stated that the cutoff date should be at
most on 25.09.2012, the date on which INC granted permission to start B.Sc.(N)
and the incumbents should possess all the requisite qualifications on such date.
It is also pointed that Guidelines of 2012 did not prescribe that 5 years teaching
experience should be in any Nursing Course such as FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N)
courses as indicated in Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 issued by the Director,
Health Services, Manipur. In short, it is submitted that the petitioner did not
possess the requisite qualifications as stipulated in the Guidelines of 2012 as
on the date of approval of the new B.Sc.(N) course by INC and actual starting
of the classes in November, 2012. Accordingly, the petitioner was not eligible
and the private respondent No.2 was eligible as she had 33 years of experience
out of which teaching for 26 years after Master degree in various Nursing
Schools. Learned GA refers to the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Dr. Umakant Saran v. State of Bihar: (1973) 1 SCC 485 to the effect
that writ of mandamus does not lie when the petitioner did not have the requisite
teaching qualification and he is not an aggrieved person.
[20]
Learned GA has pointed out that since the petitioner was not
eligible at the relevant time for consideration for putting up proposal for utilizing
Teaching Faculty of the existing School of GNM, FHW Training School and
FHW Training School (FW) as Teaching Faculty for the proposed Nursing
Page 22
College, her name was not included in the list issued vide order dated
07.09.2012 issued by Commissioner (Health & FW), Government of Manipur.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner appeared in the M.Sc.(N) final
examination held in December, 2012 and her provisional certificate dated
14.06.2013 issued by Regional College of Nursing, Guwahati for passing
M.Sc.(N) was submitted later on. Since there was still vacancy when the final
absorption order dated 01.08.2014 (impugned order in the writ petition), the
name of the petitioner was considered for the available seat of Associate
Professor. It is also clarified that the teaching faculty in the existing Nursing
Schools are not feeder cadre for the corresponding posts in the newly
established Nursing College. Instead of fresh creation of new posts for the
College, the posts in the Schools have been upgraded and eligible candidates
are absorbed. As the petitioner was not eligible at time of sending proposal, her
name was not considered for the post of Vice Principal. It is stated that the pay
scale of the Principal of Nursing School is Rs.9300-34800 + GP Rs.4400 while
that of Associate Professor of College is Rs.9300-34800 + GP Rs.5400. It is
stressed by learned GA that pay scale of Associate Professor of College is
more than that of the Principal of the School and hence, learned Single Judge
was wrong in holding that the petitioner was demoted. It is prayed that the
impugned order dated 12.05.2017 passed in WP(C) No. 512 of 2015 be set
aside by dismissing the prayers in the writ petition. If WA No. 38 of 2017 is
allowed, WA No. 3 of 2019 will be infructuous.
Page 23
[20]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel submits that the private
respondent No.2 passed M.Sc.(N) in the year 1986 from University of Delhi. As
per the Certificate of Teaching Experience by the Principal, Regional Health &
FW Trg. Centre, Imphal, the private respondent No.2 has teaching experience
of 33 years and out of which 26 years after Master degree in various Nursing
Schools. It is pointed out that the petitioner appeared in M.Sc.(N) final
examination held in December, 2012 and submitted her provisional certificate
dated 14.06.2013 issued by Regional College of Nursing, Guwahati for passing
M.Sc.(N) examination. This shows that the petitioner was not eligible for
considering against the post of Professor-cum-Vice Principal of the proposed
new Nursing College as on 07.09.2012, the date on which existing faculty
members of the Schools were utilized in the new College and she was not
rightly considered.
[21]
Learned senior counsel for the private respondent No.2 has drawn
the attention of this Court to a very important fact that the petitioner did not
specifically plead how the respondent No.2 was not eligible and how the
petitioner was eligible. No document is annexed in this regard. It is only in the
rejoinder affidavit that the petitioner alleged that the respondent No.2 did not
have 5 years teaching experience in FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) courses as
mentioned in the Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 issued by the Director of
Health Services, Manipur. It is pointed out that this document was produced by
the respondent No.2 in her counter affidavit for the first time to indicate calling
of certain documents by the government. It is vehemently submitted that
Page 24
Director of Health Services, Manipur has no authority to define the qualification
for appointment of Teaching Faculty of the Nursing College. The same is to be
issued by the Indian Nursing Council in terms of the mandate of Section 16(g)
of the Indian Nursing Council Act, 1947 and no other authority has no power to
enlarge and/or restrict the essential qualifications of the Teaching Faculty. Mr.
N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel has highlighted the fact that the Guidelines
of 2012 issued by the INC does not contain the teaching experience in
FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) courses as mentioned in the Memorandum dated
04.03.2013 issued by the Director of Health Services, Manipur. He argues that
this memorandum cannot lay down the essential qualification of teaching
faculty of Nursing College against the mandate of Section 16(g) of the Act of
1947. It is also submitted that if the respondent No.2 was not eligible at all, then
INC would not have approved the Nursing College vide letter dated 25.09.2012
when her name was recommended by the State Govt. for utilizing as Professorcum-Vice Principal vide order dated 07.09.2012. Reliance is placed on the
decisions reported as AIR 1979 SC 1676 and (1998) 8 SCC 469 to harp that
statutory rules cannot be overridden by execution order.
[22]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel has also raised the
question of maintainability of the writ petition filed the petitioner on the grounds
of non-challenging of - (a) Order dated 07.09.2012 issued by the Commissioner
(Health & FW), Govt. of Manipur for utilisation of the existing Faculty Member
of the Schools for the new College, (b) Letter dated 25.09.2012 issued by the
Indian Nursing Council permitting to start B.Sc.(N) programme in the new
Page 25
Nursing College in Manipur for the academic year 2012-13, (c) Letter dated
29.12.2012 sent by the Principal, College of Nursing to the Director of Health
Services Manipur regarding the absorption of faculty and starting of class wef
05.11.2012, and (d) Order dated 30.01.2015 issued by the Deputy Secretary
(Health & FW), Govt. of Manipur for absorption, upgradation and redesignation
of posts.
[23]
In short, the submissions of Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel are that- (i) the petitioner was not eligible in the year 2012 when the
names of Teaching Faculty of the Schools were utilised for the College and
sent to the Indian Nursing Council, (ii) she was also not eligible when INC gave
permission to start the B.Sc.(N) courses for the academic session 2012-13, (iii)
the petitioner was considered only in the year 2014 in the vacancy of Associate
Professor and she was eligible by this time, and (iv) the writ petition is not
maintainable due to non-challenge of the orders of utilisation dated 07.09.2012
and approval letter dated 25.09.2012 issued by INC and Order dated
30.01.2015. It is prayed that the impugned order dated 12.05.2017 in WP(C)
No. 512 of 2015 be set aside and consequently impugned order dated
05.12.2018 in WP(C) No. 872 of 2017 also be set aside.
[24]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
supported the impugned orders. He submits that the petitioner was appointed
as Sister Tutor in the School of Nursing, Lamphelpat, Imphal vide order dated
20.10.1981. As per Inter-se Final Seniority List of Sister Tutors, Public Health
Nurses and Public Health Nurse Instructors issued by the Director of Health
Page 26
Services, Manipur as on 03.10.2011, the petitioner was senior to the private
respondent who was appointed on 26.03.1982. Vide order dated 23.11.2011
issued by the Under Secretary (Health), Govt. of Manipur, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Principal FHW/GNM Training School and vide order
dated 01.12.2011 she was posted as Principal of School of GNM, Imphal. It is
pointed out that the respondent No.2 was never appointed as Principal of any
Nursing School and she was made as i/c Principal of School of GNM, Imphal
when the petitioner was on study leave for undergoing M.Sc.(N) till January,
2013. It is further stated that the petitioner appeared in the final examination of
M.Sc.(N) conducted in the month of December, 2012 and her provisional
certificate of passing M.Sc.(N) course dated 14.06.2013 was issued by
Regional College of Nursing, Guwahati, Assam.
[25]
It is the specific case of the petitioner that the private respondent
No.2 did not the minimum teaching experience of 5 years as stipulated by the
Indian Nursing Council in its Guidelines of 2012, as she never taught in any
nursing courses recognised by INC. Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior
counsel draws the attention of this Court to the fact that there are pleadings on
behalf of the State respondents for cut-off date for absorption and upgradation
of teaching faculty of various Nursing Schools as faculty of the new Nursing
College. It is stated that the plea of cut-off date as 07.09.2012 (date of
utilisation) or 25.09.2012 (date of permission to start B.Sc.(N) course by INC)
cannot be accepted and is an afterthought. It is submitted that as on 01.08.2014
(date of absorption of various faculty of Nursing Schools as faculty of the
Page 27
Nursing College including the petitioner), the petitioner was eligible as per
Guidelines of 2012. Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel supports the
finding of the learned Single Judge to the fact that the petitioner was eligible on
01.08.2012, when faculty members for the Nursing College were finally
absorbed. If the petitioner was not eligible on 01.08.2014, her name would not
have been considered for the post of Associate Professor. It is pointed out that
eligibility criteria for the Associate Professor is also Master degree in Nursing
and the petitioner ought to be considered for absorption as Professor-cum-Vice
Principal.
[26]
Regarding the admissibility of the teaching experience in
FHW/GNM/B.Sc.(N) stipulated by Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 issued by
the Director of Health Services, Manipur, Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior
counsel submits that there is nothing wrong in prescribing these criteria in
addition to the ones that prescribed by INC as the same is for selecting better
candidate. He further states that the Memorandum dated 04.03.2013 is
produced by the private respondent No.2 herself for the first time in her counter
affidavit as Annexure-C/23 and she cannot dispute the same as invalid.
Learned senior counsel clarifies that by order dated 07.09.2012, the services
of the faculty members of the existing Nursing Schools were utilised for the new
College as an interim measure and final absorption was done as per the
impugned Order dated 01.08.2014. The second order of absorption dated
30.01.2015 is in continuous of the earlier order dated 01.08.2014 (impugned in
Page 28
the writ petition) which is clarificatory in nature and not in supersession. Hence,
it is sufficient to challenge the main order dated 01.08.2014 alone.
[27]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel distinguishes the
decision reported as (1973) 1 SCC 485 cited by learned GA as the posts are
not equivalent. He refers to the case of Shankar K. Mondal v. State of Bihar:
(2003) 9 SCC 519 regarding the cut-off date for appointment as prescribed by
relevant rules; if not by advertisement; if not by last date of receiving the
application. In the case in hand, learned senior counsel has pointed out that
there is no cut-off date and hence 01.04.2014 should be the cut-off date.
Reliance is placed on the recent judgment of State of HP v. Rajkumar: (2023)
3 SCC 773 @ Para 82.2 to highlight that a candidate has a right for
consideration as per the existing rules on the date of consideration. Reference
is made to the judgment in the case of RS Garg v. State of UP: (2006) 6 SCC
430 which laid down the ratio that experience in the feeder cadre is essential
for promotion to the higher post and mere experience in the service is not
sufficient. It is pointed out that the private respondent No.2 did not have
minimum 5 years teaching experience in any Nursing course recognised by the
INC and hence, she is not eligible. It is submitted that the impugned order dated
12.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 512 of 2015 does not suffer from any illegality and
hence, the writ appeals being WA Nos. 37 of 2017 and 38 of 2107 may be
rejected. As the impugned order dated 05.12.2018 in WP(C) No. 872 of 2017
is for implementation of the earlier order dated 12.05.2017, writ appeal being
WA No. 3 of 2019 may also be dismissed.
Page 29
[28]
Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
other private respondents adopts the submissions of learned GA and learned
senior counsel for private respondent No.2. He has pointed out that in para 11
of the impugned order dated 12.05.2015, the quashing and setting aside of
order dated 01.08.2014 for absorption was confined to the absorption of the
private respondent No.2 alone and the same does not affect the absorption of
his clients.
[29]
We have considered the rival submissions made bar, the
materials on record and case laws cited. It is an admitted fact that the petitioner
was senior to the private respondent No.2 in the inter-se seniority list of faculty
members in Nursing Schools. It is also an admitted fact that the petitioner did
not possess M.Sc.(N) degree when the utilisation order dated 07.09.2012 was
issued and also when the permission for the new Nursing College was granted
by INC on 25.09.2013 and the faculty of School are not feeder for the College.
[30]
For getting permission from the Indian Nursing Council, the State
Government has to submit a list of eligible faculty members for the proposed
Nursing College. It is also admitted fact that the Guidelines of 2012 is the
relevant rules prescribing minimum qualifications for various teaching posts in
a Nursing College. The Guidelines prescribe M.Sc.(N) with 10 years’
experience including 5 years teaching experience. By the order dated
07.09.2012 issued by the Commissioner (Health & FW), Manipur, 14 nos. of
teaching faculty of the existing Nursing College were utilised as faculty for the
proposed Nursing College and the proposal was submitted to the Indian
Page 30
Nursing Council which gave permission vide its letter dated 25.09.2012 to start
B.Sc.(N) course from the academic year 2012-2013. From this, it is clear that
the cut-off date or the relevant date for consideration would be either
07.09.2012 or 25.09.2012 and not 01.08.2014 as wrongly held by learned
Single Judge. Accordingly, we are of the considered view that the petitioner
was not eligible for consideration for the post of Professor-cum-Vice Principal
of the Nursing College. As rightly pointed out by learned GA, the name of the
petitioner was considered for absorption in the vacant post of Associate
Professor in the order dated 01.08.2014. The same will not make the cut-off
date for absorption of other posts including that of Vice-Principal as 01.08.2014.
In the case of Umakant Saran v. State of Bihar: (1973) 1 SCC 485, Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that a person who is not eligible for consideration for
appointment at the relevant point of time has no right to question the
appointments made under the rule, since he is not an aggrieved person. Hence,
the writ petition is not maintainable on this point alone.
[31]
Admittedly, the petitioner did not challenge the order dated
07.09.2012 of utilising the faculty for the new Nursing College, the letter dated
25.09.2012 issued by the INC permitting the State Government to start B.Sc.(N)
course and letter dated 29.12.2012 issued by the Principal of Nursing College
for absorption of 14 faculty members of Nursing Schools. It is also held that
quashing of the absorption of the private respondent No.2 is not proper without
challenging the above orders/letter.
Page 31
[32]
With respect to the finding of the learned Single Judge of
ineligibility of the private respondent No.2 for not having required 5 years
teaching experience, we are of the view that the Memorandum dated
03.04.2013 issued by the Director of Health Services cannot override or restrict
the eligibility criteria laid down by the Indian Nursing Council in Guidelines of
2012. It is seen that the Guidelines of 2012 prescribe teaching experience of 5
years only and do not contain teaching experience of 5 years in FHW/GNM/
B.Sc.(N) as prescribed in the Memorandum dated 04.03.2013. We are of the
opinion that Director of Health Services, Manipur does not have any power to
restrict the essential qualification for Professor-cum-Vice Principal stipulated by
INC, as the power to make such rule is to the INC alone in view of mandate of
Section 16(g) of the Indian Nursing Council Act, 1947 [Kindly see AIR 2023
SC 126]. Accordingly, it is held that the respondent No.2 was eligible for
appointment as Professor-cum-Vice Principal as per the Guidelines of 2012.
[33]
When the petitioner was considered for the post of Associate
Professor vide order dated 01.08.2014, she could not be absorbed against Vice
Principal as she was not eligible at the relevant date and that post had already
been adjusted by the private respondent No.2. It is the settled proposition of
law as held in the case of R Prabha Devi v. Government of India: (1988) 2
SCC 233 that a senior has to be eligible for consideration for promotion and
seniority will be relevant only amongst persons eligible. It is wrong to hold that
the faculty of Nursing College were feeder cadre for the College and the post
Associate Professor of College is inferior to that of Principal of School.
Page 32
[34]
Accordingly, writ appeals being WA No. 37 of 2017, WA No. 38 of
2017 and WA No. 3 of 2019 are allowed and judgments and orders dated
12.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 572 of 2015 and judgment and order dated
05.12.2018 in WP(C) No. 872 of 2017 are set aside. No cost.
JUDGE
JUDGE
FR/NFR
joshua
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2023.12.13
10:19:28 +05'30'
Page 33
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review