Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO. 36905 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT. MADHUSHREE
W/O. MR. JAGANNATH KOTIAN,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
2.
MR. JAGANNATH KOTIAN,
S/O. SHRIKANTH KOTIAN,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
BOTH ARE R/AT ‘DAILY NEEDS SUPER BAZAR’,
DOOR NO. 4-77/2A, 'SHANKER SADANA',
IDYA, SURATHKAL, MANGALURU TALUK
DAKSHINA KANNADA – 575 014.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. SACHIN B. S., ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
CHANDANA
BM
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
AND:
MR. I. VITTAL
S/O. LATE SHANKAR POOJARY,
AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS,
R/AT 'SHANKARA SADANA', IDDYA,
SURATHKAL, MANGALURU,
DAKSHINA KANNADA – 575 014.
…RESPONDENT
THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF CONSTITUTION
OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED
11.11.2025 ON IA NO. 4 IN OS. NO. 72 OF 2022 ON THE FILE OF THE
I ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT MANGALORE, DAKSHINA
KANNADA, V ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT
MANGALORE, DAKSHINA KANNADA., AS PER ANNEXURE-A AND
CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW THE IA NO. 4 AS PRAYED FOR IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
This
petition
by
the
defendant
Nos.1
and
in
O.S.No.72/2022 on the file of the I Additional Civil Judge & JMFC,
Mangalore, Dakshina Kannada, V Additional Civil Judge & JMFC,
Mangalore, Dakshina Kannada, (hereafter referred to as ‘the Trial
Court’ for short) is directed against the impugned order on
I.A.No.IV dated 11.05.2025, whereby the said application filed by
the petitionerS/defendants under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to
introduce a counter claim at the stage of further evidence of plaintiff
was rejected by the trial Court.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
counsel for the respondent and perused the material on record.
3.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that the
respondent-plaintiff
instituted
a
aforesaid
suit
against
the
petitioners - defendants for mandatory injunction and other reliefs
in relation to the suit schedule immovable properties. The said suit
having been contested by the petitioners-defendants, the trial Court
-3NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
framed issues and the plaintiff examined himself as PW1, at which
stage, the petitioners filed the instant application seeking
amendment by incorporating a counter claim. The said application
having been opposed by the respondent, the trial Court proceeded
to pass the impugned order rejecting the application, aggrieved by
which, the petitioner is before this Court by way of the present
petition.
4.
A perusal of the impugned order will indicate that the
trial Court came to the conclusion that once evidence has
commenced by the respondent - plaintiff examining himself as
PW1, a counter claim cannot be introduced, by holding as under:
ORDERS ON INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION No.IV
The defendants have filed this application under
order VI rule 17 R/w. Section 151 of Code of Civil
Procedure and prays to permit the defendants to amend
their written statement as per proposed amendment in the
interest of justice.
2.
The application is supported with an affidavit
sworn by the first defendant and stated that the facts
sought to be incorporated in their written statement were
forgotten to be stated therein. However, the defendants
have recalled the omission recently and thought it fit and
-4NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
expedient to bring those facts on record in their written
statement. It is further submitted that the amendment
sought for will never change the nature, scope and defence
pleaded in the written statement. In order to avoid
multiplicity of proceedings between them and plaintiff, they
are advised to file application for amendment of their
written statement. If the application is allowed as prayed for
no prejudice whatsoever will be caused to the plaintiff as
only chief-examination of plaintiff has begun and the above
suit is posted for his further chief-examination. If not, the
defendants will suffer great prejudice, irreparable injury and
hardship. Hence, prays to allow this application.
3.
In the objection the plaintiff has contended
that the defendants seeking an order of the Court to amend
the written statement as enumerated in the application at
this belated stage is unsustainable both at law and on
points of facts. The application is filed with a sole intention
to drag on the proceedings and harass the plaintiff who is a
senior citizen. The application is filed by the defendants to
take away the accrued right of the plaintiff to get this suit
decreed in their favour. It is further submitted that the
amendment now sought to be incorporated if allowed, the
nature of defense already taken by the defendants in their
written statement will be changed substantially and
allowing such an application also will amount to allowing
substitution of a totally different defense. If the amendment
as sought for by the defendants is allowed, it will take away
the accrued right of the plaintiff to have his suit decreed in
his favour. The proposed amendment if allowed, the same
-5NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
will amount to allowing the defendants to take contradictory
plea which is destructive of the original plea taken by the
defendants in the original written statement and as such
the present plea urged by way of amendment should not be
permitted as the same will cause serious prejudice to the
plaintiff. The only intention of the defendants is to see that
the plaintiff is harassed by delaying the proceedings in this
suit as far as possible. The plea sought to be urged by way
of amendment is also intended to take away the jurisdiction
of this Court, which again if permitted, will cause serious
hardship for the plaintiff. If the amendment as sought for is
disallowed, no hardship will be caused to the defendants.
Mainly on these reasons the plaintiff has sought to dismiss
the application with cost.
4.
Heard.
5.
Upon hearing argument and perusal of
material placed on records, the following points would arise
for consideration.
POINTS
1.
Whether the Interlocutory application No.IV
filed by the defendants under order VI rule 17 R/w. Section
151 of CPC is deserves to be allowed ?
2.
What order?
6.
Upon hearing and on perusal of the materials
on record, this court has proceeds to answer the aforesaid
points as hereunder;
-6NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
POINT No.1: In the Negative.
POINT No.2: As per final order for the following:
REASONS
7.
POINT No.1: The plaintiff has filed this suit for
the relief of mandatory injunction directing the defendants
to put the plaintiff in vacant physical possession of the
plaint 'A' schedule premises within the time fixed by the
Court. The plaintiff also sought for directing the defendants
to pay past damages at the rate of Rs.30.000/- per month
for continued unauthorized occupation of plaint 'A' schedule
premises from 01.11.2021 to 16.01.2022, mesne profits at
the rate of Rs.30,000/- per month from this date till date of
delivery of plaint 'A' schedule premises from this day till
payment, cost of notice and such other reliefs. Now, the
present case is set down for further chief-examination of
Pw.1. At this stage, the defendants have filed this
application and sought permission to amend their written
statement as per proposed amendment.
8.
The Proposed amendment read as under;
To add paragraph no.18(a) and 18(b) in the written
statement as follows:
"18(a).
For the reasons stated in
paragraph no.13 of the written statement, the
plaintiff is liable to pay damages a sum of
Rs.5,00,000/- to the defendants with interest at
the rate of 12% p.a.. from the date of issuance of
reply notice i.e.. 21-10-2021 till full payment by
the plaintiff. As on 20-10-2022, the said sum with
interest comes to the tune of Rs.5,60,000/-.
-7NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
Similarly, in case the plaintiff is held to be the
licensor and his suit is decreed as prayed for, he
is also liable to reimburse the financial loss
suffered by the defendants as narrated in
paragraph no.14 of the written statement a sum of
Rs.40,00,000/-.
The
defendants
seek
counterclaim regarding payment of damages of
Rs.5,00,000/- with interest at the rate of 12% p.a..
from 21-10-2021 which comes to the tune of
Rs.5.60.000/- as on 20-10-2022 by the plaintiff to
them and also reimbursement of a sum of
Rs.40,00,000/- to them by the plaintiff. The court
fee on the sum of Rs. 40,00,000/- will be paid by
the defendants in case the suit is decreed holding
that the plaintiff is the licensor and defendants are
licensees in respect of the plaint schedule
commercial premises.
18(b). The defendants value the counterclaim for
damages to the tune of Rs.5,60,000/- and paid
court fee of Rs.36,975/-. The defendants value
the counterclaim of reimbursement to the tune of
Rs.40,00,000/- and court fee of Rs.1,77,125/-,
which will be paid by them if the suit is decreed as
prayed for.
18(c). Therefore, the defendants pray that the
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to pass judgment
and decree for the following reliefs:
i) Directing the plaintiff to pay a sum of
Rs.5,60,000/- with future interest at the
rate of 12% p.a. from 21-10-2022 till
full payment as damages to the
defendants towards mental agony
suffered by them.
ii) Directing the plaintiff to reimburse a
sum of Rs.40,00,000/- to the
defendants towards loss of income in
case the suit is decreed as prayed for
in his favour.
9.
On
careful
perusal
of
the
proposed
amendment it prima facie appears that the defendants are
intending to amend their written statement by including the
-8NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
counter claim. Therefore, this Court has carefully perused
the relevant provision relating to the counter claim. Order
VIII rule 6(a) of CPC deals with the counter claim it reads
as under:6A. Counter-claim by defendant.
(1) A defendant in a suit may, in addition
to his right of pleading a set-off under rule 6, set
up, by way of counter-claim against the claim of
the plaintiff, any right or claim in respect of a
cause of action accruing to the defendant against
the plaintiff either before or after the filing of the
suit but before the defendant has delivered his
defence or before the time limited for delivering
his defence has expired. whether such counterclaim is in the nature of a claim for damages or
not: Provided that such counter-claim shall not
exceed the pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of
the Court.
(2) Such counter-claim shall have the
same effect as a cross-suit so as to enable the
Court to pronounce a final judgment in the same
suit, both on the original claim and on the counterclaim.
(3) The plaintiff shall be at liberty to file a
written statement in answer to the counter-claim
of the defendant within such period as may be
fixed by the Court.
(4) The counter-claim shall be treated as a
plaint and governed by the rules applicable to
plaints.
10.
From the reading of the above provision it
clears that counter claim can be filed even after filing of
written statement, but before framing of issues and
recording of evidence. Further it clears that the counter
claim cannot be permitted to file after commencement of
-9NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
recording of evidence. In the present suit issues are framed
on 27.07.2022. The plaintiff himself examined as Pw.l on
30.09.2022 and now case is set down for further chiefexamination of Pw.1. At this stage the defendants have
filed this application and intended to introduce the counter
claim at the first time when the matter is set down for
further chief-examination of Pw.1. As per the above
provision it cannot be permitted to file amendment
application after issues are framed The Hon'ble Apex Court
in the case of Rohit Singh & Ors., V/s State of Bihar
reported in AIR 2007 SUPREME COURT at page No. 10
has held at para No.15 as under.
"A counter-claim, no doubt, could be filed even
after the written statement is filed, but that does
not mean that a counter-claim can be raised after
issues are framed and the evidence is closed.
Therefore, the entertaining of the so called
counter-claim of defendants 3 to 17 by the trial
court, after the framing of issues for trial, was
clearly illegal and without jurisdiction."
11.
In view of the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble
Apex Court in the above reported judgment, the counter
claim cannot be permitted to file after issues have been
framed. Therefore, this court is of the opinion that the
application filed by the defendants is liable to be dismissed
as not maintainable. Accordingly, this court has answered
point No.1 in the Negative.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
12.
POINT No.2: In view of the answer to point
No.1, this Court proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The interlocutory application No.IV filed
by the defendants under order VI Rule 17 R/w.
Section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure is
hereby dismissed.
No order as to cost.”
5.
The impugned order passed by the trial Court is in
consonance and conformity with the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Ashok Kumar Kalra Vs. Wing Cdr Surendra
Agnihotri - (2020) 2 SCC 394, wherein it is held that even under
exceptional
circumstances,
the
outer
limit
for
putting
forth/introducing a counter claim is before commencement of
evidence. In the instant case, undisputedly, the respondent-plaintiff
examined himself as PW1 and at the stage of further evidence of
plaintiff (PW1), the present application having been filed, the trial
Court was fully justified in rejecting the application by passing the
impugned order.
6.
Under these circumstances, I am of the considered
opinion that the impugned order passed by the trial Court cannot
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:574
WP No. 36905 of 2025
HC-KAR
be said to suffer from any illegality or infirmity nor can the same be
said to have resulted in miscarriage of justice warranting
interference of this Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article
227 of Constitution of India as held in Radhey Shyam and Ors Vs.
Chhabi Nath and Ors – (2015) 5 SCC 423, K.P. Natarajan and
Ors. Vs. Muthalammal and Ors – AIR 2021 SC 3443 and Mohd.
Ali Vs. V. Jaya – (2022) 10 SCC 477.
7.
In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
i)
The petition is hereby disposed of without interfering
with the impugned order.
ii)
All rival contentions on all aspects of the matter are
kept open and no opinion is expressed on the same.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
MDS
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 47
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review