Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
rHE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION NO: 32236 OF 2024
Between:
Smt. G. Sai Laxmi, Wo Late M. Shiva Kumar, Aged 25 years, Occ ; House wife,
R/o H.No.B-51 18 Raigadda, Wanaparthy, Wanaparthy District.
.....PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by Principal Secretary, Panchayat Raj and
Rural Development Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Deputy Secretary to Government State of Telangana, Panchayat Raj and
Rural Development (MZET) Department.
q The Commissioner, Panchayatraj, State of Telangana, At Hyderabad
4. The District Collector (PT wing), Wanaparthy District.
5. The Chief Executive Officer, ZillaPraia Parishad (ZPP) Wanaparthy,
Wanaparthy District.
6. The Head Master, Zilla Parishad High School (ZPHS) Chintakunta, Panagal
(
I\I) Wanaparthy District.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ order or direction more particularly, one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of the respondent nos.5 in issuing Memo
No. A1/44212023- 24 dt. 13-11-2024 wherein NOC is directed to be furnished from
the other family members is'illegal and arbitrary and consequently set aside the
said memo and further direct the respondent nos.2 to 6 to consider the claim of
the petitioner for compassionate appointment in any suitable post.
t.A.
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filerd in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondenl nos. 2 to 6 to consider the claim of the petitioner for appointment in
any suitable post on compassionate ground in view of death of her husband
pursuant to th,a application dt. '1 1- 7- 2023 without reference to the Memo No.
A1144212023-24 dt. 13- 11- 2024 issued by respondent no. 5, pending disposal of
the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI NAYAKAWADI RAMESH
Counsel for th,e Respondent Nos.1 to 4 : GP FOR PANCHAYAT RAJ AND
RURAL DEVET.OPMENT
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.S & 6 : SRI P.KISHORE RAO
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT
N No.3223 6 of 2o24
THE IOTH DAY OF FEBRUARY 20/26
Between:
Smt. G. Sai Laxmi.
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by principal Secretary,
Panchayat Raj and Rural Development and (5) others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard sri Nayakawadi Ramesh, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Smt. M.Shalini, learned Government pleader for
services-ll appearing for the respond.ent Nos. L to 4 and
sri K.Pradeep Reddy, learned standing counsel appearing for
the respondent Nos.S and 6. perused the material available
on record.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that this writ
Petition is filed seeking to declare the action of the
respondent No.5 in issuing Memo No.Atl442/2023-24 dated
t:
SK, J
w.P.No.32236 ol2C?.4
13.11.21)24, wherein the petitioner was directed to furnish a
No-objection certificate (Noc) from other family members, as
illegal and arbitrary.
3.
Leerrned counsel for the petitioner further submits that
the peti':ioner is the wife of the late M. shiva Kumar, who
worked as an office Subordinate at zilla parishad High
school, chintakunta and while in service, he died on
19 -o5.2ct23 -
The petitioner is the legal heir and eligible
survivor entitled to compassionate appointment as per
G.o.Ms.irlo.687, General Administration (Services_A)
Department, dated 03.10.1972 and. she has no other source
of incorne and must support her minor daughter.
Accordingly, she applied for compassionate appointment to
the resp,ndents. In response to the same, the respondent
No.5 issued Memo No.A r /442 /2023-24 dated 13.1 t.2024,
directing her to furnish Noc from other family members. The
petitioner cannot obtain Noc from her mother-in-law due to
family d isputes between them, as the husband of the
petitioner committed suicide.
4I
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that
-*--7
./
J
SK, J
W.P.No.322l6 of 2024
the petitioner's mother-in-raw is not a dependent family
member, &S she receives a Government pension
uid.e ppo
/Fp consequent to the death of her
husband i-e-, the petitioner's father-in-raw
and the
No:zPP /wNp/89 6
petitioner's brother-in-law is also employed.
petitioner had previously filed w.P.No.3050g
Moreover, the
of 2023, which
was withdrawn with liberty to take future action
after the
respondents assured that they would consider
appointment- However, instead of appointing her,
her
they issued
the impugned memo herein, insisting on NOC.
In view of the
same, learned counsel for the petitioner prayed
this court to
allow the writ petition by setting aside the impugned
No.A L / 442 / 2023-24 dated 13. 1 t .2024
Memo
issued by the
respondent No.4 and consequently to direct
the respondent
authorities to consider the case of the petitioner
for
compassionate appointment in any suitable post.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner reried on
dated 08.06.2021 passed by the High court
of Jharkhand in
Mamoni Gorai us. The state of Jharkhand, and
I
i\
Order dated 08.06.2021 in W.t,.(S).No.2683
passed by the High Court
of 2020
of Jharkhand (Unreported)
the order
othersr.
SK, J
W.P.No.32236 of 2024
6. on the other hand, learned standing counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos.S and 6, basing on the counter filed
by the respondcnt No.5, submits that the petitioner
submitted representations on l L .or .2023 and oT .o9.2024,
stating thrat she had completed her education in Hyderabad
and is residing there. The petitioner requested appointment
on compassionate grounds in Hyderabad or Ranga Reddy
District, despite her husband having worked in wanaparthy
District. 'l'he petitioner is currently placed at Serial No.19 in
the waitinSl list and must wait for her turn for compassionate
appointment. However, acting on her representation, the
respondeni: No. 5 uide letter dated 12.o9 .2024, has
recommenrled to the higher authorities to relax the local
cadre rule s to consider her appointment in Hyderabad or
Ranga Reddy District, where she feels more secure. Further,
the Government has issued instructions allowing concessions
for widows of deceased employees to be appointed where they
feel secure and the respondent No.5 has communicated the
said recomrrlendation to the respondent No.3. In view of the
same,-fsarned Standing counsel requested this court to pass
,r'
appropriate orders.
SK, J
W.P.No.32236 of 2O24
.
Learned Government Pleader for Services-ll appearing
for the respondent Nos.1 to 4 fairly acceded with the
submissions made by learned Standing Counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos.5 and 6 and requested to pass
appropriate orders.
8. After hearing both sides and perusing the entire
material available on record, this Court is of the considered
view that there is no dispute with regard to the death of the
husband of the petitioner on 19 .O5.2O23, while he was
working as Office Subordinate at Zrlla Parishad High School,
Chintakunta. Admittedly, the husband of the petitioner died
by suicide and there are family disputes between the
petitioner and her in-laws. The Tahsildar issued family
member certificate for the deceased employee, including three
(3) family members ub., the petitioner, her minor daughter
and the mother-in-law of the petitioner. The respondents are
demanding the petitioner to produce NOC from the other
family members. However, the only remaining family member
of the deceased employee for giving NOC, as per the
Tahsildar's family member certificate, is the mother-in-law of
the petitioner i.e., Smt. Laxmi
SK,.I
W.P.No.32236 of 2024
9.
Once there are existing family disputes, the question of
obtaining NOC from the mother-in-law of the petitioner is
very diffic:uIt. Moreover, the petitioner filed a self-declaration
aflidavit before this Court uide Memo dated 23.12.2025 in
W.P.USR.No.150138 of 2025, stating that she will take care
of her mother-in-law for her lifetime.
10. The order in Mantoni Gorai (supra), relied upon by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, squarely applies to the
facts of t,re instance case. The relevant portion of the said
order, reads as under:
"Ele that as it maA, hauing gone through the riual
submis.sions of the parties and on pentsal of the records it
appear:; tlnt onlg legal impediment coming to the wag for
compassionate appointment was NOC from her mother-in-law. As
the petitioner has furnished an affidaui\ mentioning therein that
she uill take care of her mother-inlaw throughout her life and
also the respondent No.S has not appeared before this Court
despite prouiding ample opporturuity, the same may be considered
bg the respondents. Similar issue fell for consideration before this
Court ir,, case of Gita Vs. Bharat Coking Coal United and Others,
reportecl in (2015) 2 JLJR 623, tuherein it has been held thus:
5. Hauing considered the riual submissions of the parties and
i
i
i
I
l
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
I
fachml backdrop of the case, as noticed hereinaboue, it
appears that the rejection of the petitioner's claim for
compassionate appointment simplg on the ground of
obje,:tion by the mother-in-Iaw on unsubstantiated
alleoations that the petitioner was inuolued in the murder of
lrcr ,\usband and she had maried another person after his
death, is not proper in the eye of law. Mere suspicion cannot
take tlrc place of proof. Respondents do not appear to haue
SK, J
W.P.No.32236 o12024
conducted anA inquiry further to find out as to whether the
petitioner had reallA entered into second mariage after the
death of her husband. Th.e Controlling Authority under the
Pagment of Gratuity Act hauing found the claim of the
petitioner admissible being the nominee, has also released
the same in 2O09 itself. As a matter of fact, allegation that
the petitioner was inuolued in the murder of her husband,
deceased emplogee, is wholly untenable on facts also as in
the FIR registered against the unknown for the said incident,
upon submrssron of the final form bg the police, learned Trial
Court has also accepted the same and the case has been
closed. It is not in doubt that the deceased has lefi behind
the petitioner widow along with two minor sons utho were
dependent upon him. Death has occurred in August 2006
and since then, dependents are scurrging for relief, but the
respondents do not appear to haue giuen a sgmpathetic
consideration. The requirement of furnishing no objection
certificate cannot be alloued to become a tool in the hands of
the person utho has certain grudge, mag be against the
claimant in such circumstances
As a cumulatiue effect of the aforesaid rules, guidelines and
judicial pronouncement, impugned order dated 17.08.2020 is
herebg quashed and set aside and. as such, the petitioner is
directed to file a fresh representation before the respondents,
within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order. Afier receipt of the same, the respondents shall
reconsider the case of the petitioner and pass a fresh order
regarding compassionate appointment and issue appointment
letter to her, within a further period of eight weeks as the
petitioner fulfills all the requisite qualification and there is no ang
other legal impediment coming in the waA of compassionate
ground, with a condition that the petitioner shall take care of her
mother-in-law throughout her life."
1. The' above findings of the High Court of Jharkhand are
similar to the facts of the instant case. The respondent No.5
issued the impugned Memo demanding the petitioner to
submit NOC from other family members, which is not in the
:SK, J
W.P.No.32236
ol 2024
hands of the petitioner. Moreover, the counter filed by the
respondont No. 5 nowhere mention with regard to the
impugned memo dated 13.11 .2024 for demanding the Noc
and on the other hand, it states that the respondent No.5 has
sent a l,:tter to the higher authorities uide Lr.No.Al/4421
2023-24 dated 12.09.2024 for considering the case of the
petitione:: for appointment under compassionate grounds in
Hyderabzrd or Ranga Reddy District. [n view of the same, the
respondents shall take into account of the self-declaration
affidavit submitted by the petitioner before this court ancl
process the application made by the petitioner for
compassionate appointment without insisting on the Noc
from the other family members. They should also take into
account c,f her request for appointment in either Hyderabad
or Ranga Reddy District, as per the policy of the state
Government.
L2. In vi ew of the above findings, this writ petition is
disposed c,f by setting the impugned Memo No.A I /442
/2023-
24 dated .t3.1r.2o24 issued by the respondent No.S and the
respondent authorities are directed to consider the case of
the petitiorrer for compassionate'appointment in any suitable
I
SK, J
W.P.No.32235 of 2024
post as per G.o.Ms.No.687, General Administration (services-
A) Department, dated 03. 1 O.L977 , taking into account the
self declaration affidavit submitted by the petitioner before
this Court utde Memo dated 23.12.2025 in
w. P. USR. No. 1 50 138 of 2025 and without insisting for
submission of a No-objection certificate from the family
members.
13. Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this writ
petition, shall stand closed. There shatl be no order as to
costs.
SD/. P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT
//TRUE COPY//
K' SARATH
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE
One fair copy
' to the LordshiP's Kind Perusal)
His
ifot
To
Rural DeveloPment Secretariat,
ofTelangana, PanchaYat Raj and
2.
at Hyderabad
4. The District Collector
5. The Chief Executive
\
\
Praia Parishad (ZPP) WanaParthY'
WanaoarthY District.
School (ZPHS) Chintakunta, Panagal
6. iir; H;;d Master, Zilla Parishad High
(M) WanaParthY Distiict.
7. 11 L.R. CoPies.
Ministry of Law, Justice and ComPanY
8 The Under SecretarY, Union of lndia'
Affairs, New Delhi.
r!- . :L--g. The secretary, reiangan, Advocates Association- Library, High court
Buildings, Hyderabad
, Arrh Dr rDAr r
RAJ AND Ru-BA! DEVELoPMENT' High
10. Two ccs to GP F6H PANcHAYAT.
f"ig," st"t" oi r"i"ng"na at-Hyderabad.
nnMESH' aoypggl:loPuc]
1 1 . one cc to sRt r.iivArnwxot
Advocate (oPUC)
RRo,
i:KisH-oRE
cc 6 SRi
ii.
13.Two CD CoPies
'- ffirt
il;
SA
toul_
HIGH COURT
DATED:11 010212026
L o TTE
o
tr
$"$
9IH +
ORDER
WP.No.32236 ot 2024
DISPOSING OF THE W
THOU]'COSTS.
'd b
I
i
I
i
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review