Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 869 OF 2010 (DEC/INJ)
C/W
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1180 OF 2009 (DEC/INJ)
IN RFA No. 869/2010
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT RUKMINI
SINCE DECEASED
REP. BY HER LRs
1(A) ANJANAPPA
S/O LATE MUNISHAMAPPA
AGED 78 YEARS
1(B) SMT. UMA
W/O VENKATESH
AGED 48 YEARS
Digitally signed
by CHAITHRA A
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
BOTH ARE R/AT NO.1091
23RD MAIN ROAD, 23RD CROSS
HSR LAYOUT, SECTOR-2
BENGALURU-560 102.
1(C) PRASANTH .A
S/O ANJANAPPA
AGED 46 YEARS
R/AT NO. 99, 28TH MAIN ROAD
18TH CROSS, HSR LAYOUT
SECTOR-2, BENGALURU-560 102.
1(D) RAVINDRA .A
S/O ANJANAPPA
AGED 44 YEARS
-2NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
R/AT NO.19, 26TH MAIN
NEAR HSR LAYOUT POLICE STATION
HSR LAYOUT, SECTOR-1
BENGALURU-560 102.
[CAUSE TITLE AMENDED V/O/D 07.09.2023]
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. B. RAMESH, ADVOCATE FOR LRs OF APPELLANT)
AND:
1.
SRI. J. THRILOKA MURTHY
S/O LATE JAYRAM
AGED 56 YEARS
R/AT PANNATHUR VILLAGE
PANNATHUR POST, BANGALORE-560087.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. VIVEK S. REDDY, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. V. VISHWANATH, ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/ORDER 41 RULE 1 R/W SEC 96 OF
CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND DECREE DATED
24.08.2009 PASSED IN O.S.NO.666/1992 ON THE FILE OF
XXXVII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL & SESSIONS JUDGE,
BANGALORE, PARTLY DECREEING THE SUIT FILED FOR
DECLARATION AND INJUNCTION.
IN RFA NO. 1180/2009
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT. D. PREMA KUMARI
W/O LATE P.M.VENKATESH
AGE 59 YEARS
R/A PANATHUR VILLAGE & POST
VARTHUR HOBLI, BANGALORE EAST TALUK
BANGALORE DIST.-560068
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. B. RAMESH, ADVOCATE)
-3NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
AND:
1. SRI. J. THRILOKA MURTHY
S/O P.M. DELLANNA
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
R/A PANNATHUR VILLAGE & POST
BANGALORE - 560 087.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. VIVEK S. REDDY, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. V. VISHWANATH, ADVOCATE FOR R1)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/S 96 R/W ORDER 41 RULE 1 R/W
ORDER XXI RULE 103 OF THE CPC, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT
AND DECREE DATED 24.08.2009 PASSED IN O.S.NO.666/1992
ON THE FILE OF THE XXXVII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE(CCH-38), BANGALORE, PARTLY DECREEING
THE SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND INJUNCTION.
THESE
APPEALS,
COMING
ON
FOR
DICTATING
JUDGMENT, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN
AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The appeal in RFA No.869/2010 is filed by defendant
No.3 and the appeal in RFA No.1180/2009 is filed by
defendant No.2. Both these appeals are filed by the
alleged sisters of plaintiff questioning the legality and
correctness
of
the
judgment
and
decree
passed
in
O.S.No.666/1992, whereby the suit instituted by the
plaintiff
seeking
declaration
of
title,
possession
and
-4NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
consequential relief of permanent injunction, has been
partly decreed. The trial Court has answered the issue
relating to the plaintiff’s alleged adoption in the affirmative
and has granted declaratory relief to that extent, which
finding is assailed in this appeal.
2.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid
confusion, the parties shall be referred to in accordance
with their ranking before the trial Court.
3.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the suit,
as borne out from the pleadings, are as follows:
The plaintiff instituted the suit seeking a declaration
that he is the absolute owner in possession of the suit
schedule properties as he is the legally adopted son of late
P.M. Devanna and the first defendant. Consequential relief
of permanent injunction was also sought to restrain the
defendants from interfering with his alleged possession
and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
4.
The foundation of the plaintiff’s claim is a
declaration allegedly executed by P.M. Devanna, wherein
the plaintiff is described as his adopted son. The entire
case of the plaintiff rests substantially upon the said
declaration.
5.
In the plaint, the plaintiff has averred that the
suit schedule properties are ancestral and joint family
properties of deceased P.M. Devanna. He has candidly
admitted that his natural parents are Jayaram and
Thangamma @ Jayamma. It is further pleaded that his
natural mother Thangamma is the sister of Venkatamma,
the wife of P.M. Devanna. According to the plaintiff, after
the demise of his natural father Jayaram, his mother,
Thangamma gave him in adoption to P.M. Devanna and his
wife when he was about five years old. On that premise,
the plaintiff asserts that he became the adopted son of
P.M. Devanna and consequently acquired the status of a
coparcener in the joint family properties.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
6.
Proceeding on the said assertion of adoption,
the plaintiff claims entitlement to a share in the suit
schedule properties and contends that the defendants,
having no semblance of right, title or interest, are
attempting to interfere with his possession and enjoyment.
It
is in this
background that
the
present
suit
for
declaration and injunction came to be filed.
7.
On service of suit summons, the defendants
entered appearance. Defendant No.1, who is the widow of
late P.M. Devanna and admittedly the maternal aunt of the
plaintiff, filed a detailed written statement stoutly denying
the plaint averments in toto. The status of the plaintiff as
an adopted son was specifically and categorically denied.
It was contended that late P.M. Devanna had executed a
registered Will dated 02.11.1991 making a testamentary
disposition of his properties. According to defendant No.1,
the plaintiff, though brought up as a foster son, was only a
beneficiary under the said Will and cannot claim the status
-7NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
of an adopted son or any coparcenary right. On these
grounds, dismissal of the suit was sought.
8.
Both parties, in support of their respective
claims, have placed reliance on voluminous oral and
documentary evidence. The trial Court, on appreciation of
the entire material on record, rejected the plaintiff’s claim
insofar as declaration of absolute ownership over the suit
schedule properties is concerned. However, it recorded a
finding that the plaintiff has proved his status as an
adopted son and consequently held that he is entitled to a
legitimate share in the suit schedule properties. On that
premise, the trial Court partly decreed the suit by granting
declaratory relief to the extent of such share.
9.
Assailing the said findings, learned counsel
appearing for defendant No.3, reiterating the grounds
urged in the appeal and placing reliance on extensive
rebuttal evidence, has taken this Court through the
judgment and decree rendered in O.S.No.10542/1996,
-8NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
which
came
to
be
affirmed
by
this
Court
in
RFA.No.182/2004. He would contend that the status of the
plaintiff stood conclusively adjudicated in the earlier round
of litigation. The said suit was instituted by one of the
beneficiaries under a registered Will executed by P.M.
Devanna. The Will was held to be duly proved and in the
said Will, the plaintiff is described only as a foster son. The
decree in O.S.No.10542/1996 having been affirmed in
RFA.No.182/2004, and the appeal filed by the present
plaintiff having been dismissed, the findings regarding the
genuineness and validity of the Will have attained finality.
It is therefore contended that the present suit seeking
declaration of status as adopted son and consequential
ownership is a mischievous attempt to circumvent the
binding findings recorded in the earlier proceedings.
10.
Learned
counsel
further
drew
attention
to
Ex.D109 to demonstrate that even in the year 1992, the
plaintiff claimed to be the natural son of Jayaram and
Thangamma.
In
O.S.No.5963/1992,
filed
for
specific
-9NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
performance of an agreement of sale executed by the
plaintiff’s mother Thangamma, the plaintiff had asserted
his status as the son of Jayaram and Thangamma and
contested the proceedings accordingly. Reliance is also
placed on the affidavits filed in support of applications in
the said suit, marked at Ex.D113, wherein the plaintiff has
unequivocally described himself as the son of Jayaram.
11.
Further
reliance
is
placed
on
Ex.D116,
a
registered sale deed executed by the plaintiff along with
his children, wherein he has described himself as the son
of Thangamma @ Jayamma. It is contended that this
document clearly establishes that the plaintiff inherited the
properties of his natural mother and exercised rights of
alienation over the same, which is wholly inconsistent with
the claim of prior adoption. Reference is also made to
Ex.D120 to show that as early as in 1973, while applying
for membership in a society, the plaintiff described himself
as the son of Jayaram. Exs.D127 and D128, being
objections filed by the plaintiff in connected proceedings,
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
and Ex.D129 relating to mutation entries, also reflect the
plaintiff as the son of Jayaram. According to the learned
counsel, these consistent admissions at undisputed points
of time demolish the theory of adoption.
12.
It is further contended that defendant No.1 has
specifically denied the alleged adoption in paragraph 2 of
the written statement. Attention is invited to Ex.P47, the
registered Will dated 02.11.1991, which was confronted to
the plaintiff in cross-examination and marked on his
admission. It is argued that the mutation entries effected
pursuant
to
the
Will
also
demonstrate
that
the
testamentary disposition was acted upon and that the
plaintiff’s name has been reflected only in respect of the
properties bequeathed to him under the Will, thereby
reinforcing the position that his rights, if any, flow solely
from the Will and not by virtue of adoption.
13.
Per contra, learned Senior Counsel Sri. Vivek S.
Reddy, appearing for the plaintiff, has sought to sustain
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
the judgment of the trial Court. He has placed reliance on
Exs.P29, P30, P32 and P33 to contend that the plaintiff
was integrated into the family of P.M. Devanna by way of
adoption.
The
medical
bills
and
related
documents,
according to him, establish that the plaintiff discharged
filial obligations by taking care of defendant No.1 during
her illness. He has also relied upon photographs marked at
Exs.P40, P50 and P51 and receipts, including Ex.P26, to
contend that the plaintiff cultivated the suit lands and
cleared loans, thereby demonstrating his status and
conduct as an adopted son.
14.
In support of his submissions, learned Senior
Counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions:
(i)
Munivenkatappa
Vs.
Dodamuniyappa
and
Others – 2007 SCC OnLine Kar 530;
(ii)
M.N.
Aryamurthy
and
Another
Vs.
M.D.
Subbaraya Setty (Dead) through LRs and Others –
(1972) 4 SCC 1;
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
(iii) Kamla Rani Vs. Ram Lalit Rai Alias Lalak Rai
(Dead) through Legal Representatives and Others –
(2018) 9 SCC 663;
(iv) Debi Prasad (Dead) by LRs Vs. Smt. Tribeni
Devi and Others – (1970) 1 SCC 677.
15.
This Court, being the final Court on facts, has
meticulously re-appreciated the pleadings and the entire
oral
and
documentary
independent
analysis
evidence
of
the
on
material
record.
On
an
available,
the
following points arise for consideration:
"(i)
Whether the finding of the trial Court that
the plaintiff has proved that he is the adopted son
of late P.M. Devanna and defendant No.1 is
palpably erroneous and suffers from perversity?
(ii)
Whether the
finding of
the
trial
Court
recognizing the plaintiff’s share is in direct conflict
with
the
judgment
and
decree
in
O.S.No.10542/1996, wherein the registered Will
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
executed by P.M. Devanna was held to be duly
proved, and the said decree having attained
finality?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is estopped from
asserting independent right and title on the basis
of alleged adoption in view of findings recorded in
O.S No.10542/1996?
(iv)
What order?"
Finding on Point Nos.(i) to (iii)
16.
The entire edifice of the plaintiff’s claim rests
upon a so-called declaration said to have been made by
late P.M. Devanna, wherein the plaintiff is described as an
adopted son. However, on meticulous scrutiny of the
pleadings, particularly the averments in the plaint, this
Court finds that the essential ingredients constituting a
valid adoption are conspicuously absent. There is no
specific pleading regarding the date of adoption, the
performance of the mandatory ceremony of giving and
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
taking (datta homam or the essential act of transfer), or
the capacity of the natural mother to give the plaintiff in
adoption, especially when he is stated to be her sole son.
The plaint is singularly silent on these foundational facts.
17.
It is trite that adoption, which has the effect of
divesting the natural line of succession and creating a new
line of inheritance, must be strictly proved. In the case on
hand, the plaintiff has not produced any registered or
unregistered deed evidencing adoption. No independent
witness to the alleged ceremony has been examined. The
claim is thus sought to be sustained solely on the basis of
a unilateral declaration and subsequent conduct, which, in
the absence of foundational pleadings and proof, cannot
constitute proof of a valid adoption in the eye of law.
18.
Learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiff, placing
reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
L. Debi Prasad (Dead) by LRs v. Smt. Tribeni Devi
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
and Others1, has contended that long recognition and
treatment of a person as an adopted son may, in
appropriate cases, raise a presumption in favour of
adoption. He would submit that though direct evidence of
the
ceremony
of
giving
and
taking
may
not
be
forthcoming, the consistent treatment of the plaintiff as a
member of the adoptive family and his participation in
family affairs would suffice to establish adoption.
19.
In the light of the aforesaid submission and the
principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court
deems it necessary to examine the contemporaneous
documentary evidence to ascertain whether the plaintiff
was, in fact, treated and acknowledged as an adopted son
by the family and by himself in public records. For this
purpose, it is apposite to advert to the cause title of
O.S.No.10542/1996, which reads thus:
“Plaintiff:- P.M. Nagaraju S/o Late Jayaram, aged 45 years,
Panathur Village, Panathur Post, Bangalore-87.
1970(1) SCC 677
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
V/s.
Defendant:- 1. Sri. Trilokmurthy, S/o Late Jayaram, aged 42
years, Panathur Village, Panathur Post, Bangalore-87.
The Commissioner of Police, Infantry Road, Bangalore.
Circle Inspector of Police, Vimanapura Police Station,
Bangalore.”
A plain reading of the above cause title unmistakably
reveals that the present plaintiff is described as “S/o Late
Jayaram.” Significantly, the plaintiff himself challenged the
judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.10542/1996 by
filing RFA.No.182/2004. Even in the said appeal, the
plaintiff described himself as the son of Jayaram. This
Court therefore deems it appropriate to extract the cause
title of RFA.No.182/2004, which similarly reflects the
plaintiff as the son of Jayaram. These recitals are not stray
references but are solemn descriptions adopted by the
plaintiff in judicial proceedings.
The cause title of
RFA.No.182/2004 is extracted as under:
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
"R.F.A. No. 182 OF 2004
BETWEEN
TRILOKAMURTHY
52 YEARS
S/O LATE JAYARAM
R/O PANATHUR VILLAGE AND POST
BANGALORE-87
………….APPELLANT
(BY SRI.N.K.SHIVARAJU FOR V VISHWANATH.ADV.)
AND
P.M.NAGARJU (sic. P M NAGARAJU)
53 YEARS
S/O LATE MARIYANNA
R/O PANATHUR VILLAGE AND POST
BANGALORE-87
THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
INFANTRY ROAD
BANGALORE-1
THE CIRCLE INSPECTOR OF POLICE
VIMANAPURA POLICE STATION,
VIMANAPUR,
BANGALORE
…………RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI: S.N.HATTI FOR R.1)"
20.
The next crucial document is Ex.D103, which
evidences mutation of the plaintiff’s name as the son of
Jayaram, following the demise of his natural mother
Thangamma @ Jayamma. This mutation entry, made at an
undisputed point of time, reflects the plaintiff’s status as
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
the natural son of Jayaram and not as the adopted son of
Devanna.
21.
Equally significant is O.S.No.5963/1992, a suit
for specific performance. In the said proceedings, the
plaintiff filed two applications supported by affidavits,
which are marked as Ex.D113. In those affidavits, sworn
on oath, the plaintiff unequivocally asserted his parentage
in the following terms:
“I, J.Thrilok Murthy, S/o Late Sri. Jayaram, Aged about
49 years resident of Pannathur Village, Bangalore East
now at Bangalore City, do hereby solemnly affirm and
state on oath as follows:”
This categorical assertion on oath, made in judicial
proceedings, is wholly inconsistent with the present claim
of adoption.
22.
The next vital document is the registered sale
deed marked as Ex.D116. Under this document, the
plaintiff alienated property which stood in the name of his
natural mother Thangamma. The alienation was made in
the capacity of a son who had inherited the property upon
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
the demise of his natural mother. Such an assertion of
inheritance through the natural line is directly destructive
of the plea that he had been divested from his natural
family by virtue of adoption.
23.
Ex.D120 is another significant document. As
early as in the year 1973, while applying for membership
in a society and in the voters’ list, the plaintiff is described
as the son of Jayaram. These entries predate the alleged
declaration relied upon in the present suit and reflect the
plaintiff’s acknowledged status in public records.
24.
The nail in the coffin of the plaintiff’s claim is
found in Exs.D127 and D128, being objections filed before
this Court in RFA.No.1180/2009 and RFA.No.869/2010. In
both
proceedings,
the
plaintiff
has
sworn
affidavits
affirming his parentage as follows:
In RFA No. 1180/2009
“I, J.Thriolka Murthy (sic J.Thriloka Murthy), S/o Late Sri.
Jayaram, Aged about 56 years resident of Panathur
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
Village, Panathur post, Bangalore-560087, do hereby
solemnly affirm and state on oath as follows:”
In RFA No.869/2010
“I, J.Thriolka Murthy (sic J.Thriloka Murthy), S/o Late Sri.
Jayaram, Aged about 56 years resident of Panathur
Village, Panathur post, Bangalore-560087, do hereby
solemnly affirm and state on oath as follows:”
These repeated assertions on oath in judicial proceedings
unequivocally acknowledge his status as the son of
Jayaram.
25.
It is also of considerable significance that
defendant No.1, the widow of late P.M. Devanna and the
very person who is alleged to have taken the plaintiff in
adoption, has categorically and unequivocally disputed the
plaintiff’s status as an adopted son. In paragraph 2 of the
written statement, she has specifically denied the alleged
adoption and asserted that the plaintiff was only brought
up
as
a
foster
child.
This
denial
assumes
greater
evidentiary value, for if there had indeed been a lawful
adoption, the adoptive mother would have been the most
competent witness to affirm the same. Her categorical
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
repudiation of the alleged adoption strikes at the very root
of the plaintiff’s case.
26.
Equally telling is the consistent conduct of the
plaintiff himself. At no point in the earlier round of
litigation did he assert that he was the adopted son of
Devanna. In O.S.No.10542/1996, which culminated in a
decree holding that the registered Will dated 02.11.1991
executed by P.M. Devanna was duly proved, the present
plaintiff was arrayed as a party. In the said Will, he is
expressly referred to only as a “fostered son” and not as
an adopted son. The Civil Court, after full-fledged trial,
upheld the Will and decreed the suit. The said judgment
and decree were challenged by the present plaintiff in
RFA.No.182/2004 before this Court, and the appeal came
to be dismissed, thereby affirming the finding that the
testamentary
established.
disposition
under
the
Will
stood
duly
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
27.
Once the testamentary arrangement made by
P.M. Devanna has been judicially upheld and has attained
finality, the legal position that the plaintiff is merely a
beneficiary under the Will, described therein as a fostered
son, stands conclusively determined. It is impermissible
for the plaintiff, after having suffered the decree in the
earlier proceedings, to now institute a fresh suit seeking
declaration of his status as an adopted son and thereby
indirectly claim coparcenary rights in derogation of the
Will. Such an attempt is nothing but a collateral challenge
to a finding that has already attained finality between the
parties.
28.
The material on record, as discussed supra,
unmistakably establishes two pivotal aspects. Firstly,
neither Devanna nor defendant No.1 ever adopted the
plaintiff in accordance with law. There is a total absence of
pleadings and proof regarding the indispensable ceremony
of giving and taking. The plaint does not disclose the date,
month or year of the alleged adoption. There is no
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
averment as to the capacity of the natural mother,
Thangamma, to give her son in adoption. No deed of
adoption, whether registered or otherwise, has been
produced.
No
independent
witness
to
the
alleged
ceremony has been examined.
29.
Secondly,
the
plaintiff’s
own
conduct
over
decades is wholly inconsistent with the plea of adoption.
From as early as 1970 onwards, he has consistently
described himself as the son of Jayaram and Thangamma.
In judicial proceedings, revenue records, affidavits and
public documents, he has sworn on oath describing himself
as “S/o Late Sri. Jayaram.” He inherited the properties of
his natural mother Thangamma, had his name mutated as
her son, and executed a registered sale deed (Ex.D116)
alienating the said property as her legal heir along with his
children. These acts are irreconcilable with the legal
consequences of adoption, which severs the child from the
natural family and divests him of rights in the natural line
of succession.
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
30.
The cumulative effect of these documents and
admissions leaves no manner of doubt that the plaintiff
was, at best, brought up by Devanna as a foster son after
the untimely demise of his natural father when he was
about five years old. Long association or affectionate
upbringing cannot substitute the strict legal requirements
of a valid adoption. More importantly, the plaintiff himself,
even before this Court in earlier proceedings, has sworn
affidavits asserting that he is the son of Jayaram. Such
solemn admissions on oath demolish the subsequent plea
of adoption.
31.
In this backdrop, the finding of the trial Court
that the plaintiff has proved his status as an adopted son
is not merely erroneous but perverse, being contrary to
the pleadings, documentary evidence, prior adjudications
and binding findings regarding the Will. The impugned
finding
therefore
jurisdiction.
warrants
interference
in
appellate
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
32.
These
consistent
recitals
across
multiple
proceedings, revenue records, affidavits and conveyances,
spanning several years, unmistakably demonstrate that
the plaintiff himself projected and acknowledged his status
as the son of Jayaram. Such consistent admissions, made
in solemn judicial and statutory records, completely
undermine the belated plea of adoption set up in the
present
suit.
Accordingly,
Point
Nos.(i)
to
(iii)
are
answered in the ‘Affirmative’.
CONCLUSION:
33.
On a comprehensive re-appreciation of the
entire oral and documentary evidence, this Court is of the
considered view that the finding of the trial Court holding
that the plaintiff has proved his status as the adopted son
of late P.M. Devanna and defendant No.1 is wholly
unsustainable. The plaintiff has neither pleaded nor proved
the essential ingredients constituting a valid adoption.
There is no specific pleading regarding the date of
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
adoption, the ceremony of giving and taking, or the legal
capacity of the natural mother to give the child in
adoption. No deed of adoption is forthcoming and no
independent witness to the alleged ceremony has been
examined. On the contrary, the documentary evidence
placed on record unmistakably demonstrates that the
plaintiff consistently projected himself as the son of
Jayaram in judicial proceedings, revenue records and
registered transactions. These admissions, made on oath
and acted upon over several decades, are destructive of
the plea of adoption. The trial Court, by ignoring these
material admissions and foundational defects in pleadings,
has recorded a finding which is perverse and contrary to
the settled principles governing proof of adoption.
34.
Further, the declaration granted by the trial
Court recognizing the plaintiff’s legitimate share in the suit
schedule properties is directly founded upon the erroneous
conclusion that he is an adopted son. Once the status of
adoption is not established, the consequential declaration
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
of share cannot survive. More importantly, the judgment
and decree rendered in O.S.No.10542/1996, wherein the
registered Will dated 02.11.1991 executed by late P.M.
Devanna was held to be duly proved, has attained finality
upon dismissal of RFA.No.182/2004 preferred by the
present plaintiff. In the said Will, the plaintiff is described
only as a fostered son and is made a beneficiary to the
extent specified therein. The testamentary arrangement
having been judicially upheld, the nature and extent of the
plaintiff’s rights stand conclusively determined.
35.
The present suit seeking declaration of status
as an adopted son and consequential coparcenary rights
is,
in
substance,
an
indirect
attempt
to
nullify
or
circumvent the binding findings recorded in the earlier
round of litigation. The plaintiff, having participated in the
earlier
proceedings
and
having
suffered
an
adverse
decree, is bound by the said adjudication. He cannot now
assert a superior and inconsistent status so as to defeat
the testamentary disposition upheld by a competent Court.
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
The principles of finality of litigation and estoppel squarely
operate against him.
36.
The earlier judgment conclusively established
the validity of the registered Will executed by late P.M.
Devanna. The plaintiff, having participated in the said
proceedings and having suffered dismissal of his appeal in
RFA No. 182/2004, is bound by the findings recorded
therein.
37.
The Will specifically describes the plaintiff as a
fostered son and confers benefits upon him in that
capacity. The testamentary arrangement having been
upheld, the nature and extent of the plaintiff’s rights stand
crystallized under the Will.
38.
Principles
analogous
to
res
judicata
and
estoppel squarely apply. The plaintiff cannot approbate
and reprobate, he cannot accept benefits under the Will as
a fostered son and simultaneously claim a superior status
as an adopted son to defeat the testamentary scheme.
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
39.
The trial Court’s recognition of a share in favour
of the plaintiff directly conflicts with the decree in
O.S.No.10542/1996 and amounts to sitting in appeal over
a judgment which has already attained finality.
40.
The
plaintiff
is
therefore
estopped
from
asserting an independent right or coparcenary title on the
basis of alleged adoption.
41.
In
that
view
of
the
matter,
the
findings
recorded by the trial Court recognizing the plaintiff as an
adopted son and declaring his entitlement to a share in the
suit schedule properties are legally untenable, contrary to
the evidence on record, and in direct conflict with a
binding prior judgment. The impugned judgment and
decree, to that extent, are therefore liable to be set aside.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
Finding on Point No.(iv):
42.
Accordingly, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
(i)
The appeals filed by defendant Nos.2
and 3 are allowed.
(ii)
The
24.08.2009
judgment
and
decree
dated
passed in O.S.No.666/1992 by the
learned Trial Judge, insofar as it declares that the
plaintiff is the adopted son of late P.M. Devanna
and defendant No.1 and further declares that the
plaintiff has a legitimate share in the suit schedule
properties, are hereby set aside.
(iii) The suit filed by the plaintiff seeking
declaration of right, title and share in the suit
schedule properties by virtue of being an adopted
son stands dismissed in its entirety.
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC:11068
RFA No. 869 of 2010
C/W RFA No. 1180 of 2009
HC-KAR
(iv) In the facts and circumstances of the
case, the parties shall bear their own costs.
(v)
Draw decree accordingly.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
ALB
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 4
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review