Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
,/
[ 3485 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 5197 OF 2010
Between:
1. Smt. Chokkarapu Sorojini Devi,(died) per Lrs 2 to 8,
2. Chokkarapu Ravichandra S/o Late Prabhulingam
3. Boggarapu Rangamma Wo Ganeshwar
4. Chokkarapu Sangameshwar S/o Late Prabhulingam
5. Bikkumalla KalavathiWo Ramesh
6. Mansani Dhanalaxmi @ Swarupa Wo Uma Shanker
7. Chokkarapu tMurali Krishna S/o Late Prabhulingam
8. Chokkarapu Srinivas S/o Late Prabhulingam
(petitoners 2 to 8 are b.rought on recordas LRs of deceased 1tt petitioner as
per court order dated 27.02.2017 in WPMP. No. 42549 of 2016)
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. .The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, Secunderabad Division, Rep
by its Dy. Commissioner, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
2. T-he City Planner, Circle No. 18, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad'
3. The Zonal Commissioner, North Zone, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad'
4. Sri R. Adavaiah, (died) per Lrs 5 to B,
5. .Smt R. Balamani Wo Late R. Advaiah, Occ: Housewife, Rlo 12-7-17011,
Mettuguda, Secunderabad
6. Smt R-. Pushpa Wo Late R/ Adavaiah, occ: Housewife , Rlo 12-7-17011,
Mettuguda, Secunderabad
7. R. l\Iahender Yadav S/o Late R. Adavaiah, Occ: Private Employee, Rlo 12-717011, Mettuguda, Secunderabad
8. R. Rajender S/o Late R. Adavaiah, Occ: Private Employee, R/o 12-7-17011,
mettuguda, Secunderabad
(Respondent Nos. 5 to 8 are brought on record as LRs. Of deceased
Respondent No. 4 as per Court order dated 05.08.2015 in WPMP. No. 15030
of 201 5)
...RESPONDENTS
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue any appropriate writ, order or direction preferably a writ in the
nature of Writ of Mandamus, declaring the inaction of the respondents in acting
upon the petitioners representations in releasing the compensation amount to the
petitioner and restraining the 4th respondent from making any further
constructionl; on the property as illegal, contrary to law and in violation of Art.
300A of the r:onstitution of lndia and in violation of Section 636, 452 and Chapter
Xll of GHMC and consequently direct the respondents 1 to 3 to remove the
illegal constr ctions made upon the petitioners property.
1ott 201
oF 201
Petitior under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidarrit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
direct the respondents 1 to 3 to restrain the Respondent No.4 from making any
illegal and uttauthorized constructions on the petitioner's Property got reflected
as Door No. 12-8-423110, Mettuguda Secunderabad, else the petitioner would
suffer greater irreparable loss and injury.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SMT. K PALLAVI
counsel for the Respondent No. 1 to 3: sRl G. MADHUSUDHAN REDDY
(sc FoR GHMC)
Counsel for the Respondent No. 5to8 :
The Court merde the following: ORDER
n
IN THE HIGI{ COUI(T' I;OI( ]'HE STAI'E OIT TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI IUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRt' I I'[TI'I'ION NO.6197 OF 2O1O
DA IE: 23.0't .2026
Between
Smt. Chokkarapu Saroiini Devi (cliecl)
w/o.late Prabhuling,arn, per I [is, i.e., '
petitiorrer Nos.2 to B.
.... Petitioners
and
The Grea ter I { i, cl e ra [',a rl \4 u rr ic i p-rat I C-<l rpora tion,
Secunderabaci I)ivisiorr anci sevt:n others.
.... Respondents
ORDER:
T'he prescnt rvrit petit'ion has been filed to issue appropriate
writ, order, or c{iret.tion preferably a rvrit in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus dcclaring the inaction of the respondents in acting upon
the petitioner's reprt:sr.ntations and releasing the compensation
amount to thc petitioncr arnd also restraining the 4tt respondent
from making any further constructions on the property, as illegal,
contrary to law and irr violation of Article 300-A of the Constitution
of India and in rriolation of Sections 636 and 452 and Chapter-Xll of
GHMC Act ancl conscquently direct the respondent' Nos.1 to 3 to
,/
/
remove the illegal constructions made upon the petitioner's
property ar-rd pass orc{crs as it decm it ;rrop-rg'rrnd necessary.
2.
'f re brief facts of the case al'e that, thc l.t wr:it
petitioner is the
absolutr: o\\/ner and possessor o[ land to an t'xtc:nt of 1500 square
yards irr Sy.No.493 situated at Mettuguda Vltrir^r Road, Secunderabad
and out of the said land, au exterrt clf 1014 sr[uc'u'c yards was solcl to
one V.Y.Bhaskar Rao under the registered salc deecl and to an extent
of 486 square yards is held by the writ petitior-rer. The Greater
I ll,derabad Municipal Corporatiorr (GI{N{C) l'ras undertook road
widening frorn Sangeeth Jttnction Lo Mettugucla, Secunclerabad and
land to arr extent of 230 square yards allegec{ to have been acquired
by the respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein for roa<l widening and have not
praid the conlpensation till date
3. It is also averred that the resp'rondent No.4 being
Ex-Corporator has encroached a part of the saict land and raised
cortstrur:tions and corlsequent upon thc deatl"r of resporrdent No.4,
his Legal Representatives - Itespondent Nos.5 to 8 were brought on
record. Further, it is contended that the writ petitioner has instituted
the suitr; against thc' responderrt No.-t Lrcforut thct cclmpetent Court of
t
&.
\ \
:n
law and the same were pending adjudication before the Hon,ble
High Court and the instant w,rit petition is filecl for consideration of
her representation seekirrg payrnent of compensation for the land to
an extent of 230 square vards, r,vhich alleged to have been acquired
bv the respondent Nos.-l to 3 hercin for roac-l widening.
4.
Further, respondent Nos.l to 3 herein filed a detailed counter-
affidavit contending that the house of the writ petitioner bearing
No.12-8-423/'10 vr,'as not includeti in the tist of proprerties, which was
acquired for road widening from Sangeeth to Mettuguda junction,
secunderabad and the house bearing Nos.12-8-422/4/1and 12-g-
423/70 was owned hy Mr. Ac'lvaiah ancl rhe H.No.1z-g-424/ L was
owned by Mr. Y.V.tshaskar Rao, which were inctuded along with
other affected propcrties and thereafter, a letter was addressed by
the Assistant city l)lanner, GHN,IC (old Circiel-7) to the special
Deputy Collector to initiate land acquisition proceedings and in the
list of properties, the H.No.12-B-4zz/4/1 is not included and
accordingly, draft notice uncler Section 4(1) notification was issued
by the then District Collector on 27.77.2007 for including list of 22
effected properties for the *rad widening and the list of properties
i.e., hcuse bearing No.12-8-4zg/10 rvas shown to be ownecl and
possesr;ecl by Advaiah to arr extent of 96.52 square rnete.rs <tr 715.47
srlLl.tre t'artls crnr{ [rcrusc L'rcar.irrg \o.12-S-+2+,/-l rr..rs shorr.rr to Lrc
orvrred ancl possessed by Y.v.Bhaskar to an exterrt of 777.37 square
nrcters or 922.79 square yards. It was stated that the enquiry under
Sec-tiorr 5(A) of the Act was corrdu<:ted ernc[ consequerrt upon l,r,hich
the anrount of Rs.28,07,760/- uide cl-reque No.L-031331 cjated
13.02.2008 n'as paid to the 4th respondent torr,'ards cornpensatiop,
wlrcre- t,he I'{ouse Nos.l2-8-422/4/'l ancl r2-s-423/10 are rnentiolec{
arrd th,31s is also correction i.e., rounding off IJ.No.l2-g-423/7,
which iu fact is notified in the rrotification. lt was contended that the
wiit petitioner was ttot clear in r:espect of the house nurnbers and
extent of larrd acquired by the GHMC and as there are disputerl
questions of facts and title, the writ petitioner, instead of working
out her remedies before the competent Clivil Court, l-ras filecl the
instant rvrit petition and is not nraintainable.
5.
[nsofar as the construction made tr]z the 4rr, respondent, it was
stated that there was no construction actirrity being, undertaken by
o
the 4th respondent, and therefore, the question of issuing notices
under the Act does not arise
During the pender-rcy of the rt,rit petition, writ petitioner
expired and her LRs were brought on record i.e., petitioner Nos.2
to 8.
7.
Heard Smt. K.Pallavi learned counsel for the petitioners anci
Mr. G.Madhusudhan Redcly, learned covernment pleacler for
GHMC for respondent Nos.1 to 3 and norle appeared for respondent
Nos.5 to 8 and having givcn earrrest consideration to the
submissions on both sides, perused the material on record.
8.
The instant writ petition is pending consideration before this
Court since 2070 and after so man)/ acljourrrmcnts being grantetl,
the counter-affidavit has been filed and on 04.08.2014, this Court
observed that after much persuasion, the counter-affidavit is filed by
the Deputy Commissioner, Circle-l8 stating that the land along with
house No.12-B-423/70 was possessed and owned by Advaiah to an
extent of 96.52 square meters or 115.4T square yards and that an
amount of I{s.28,01,760/- was paid to him (4th respondent) towards
compensation, which shows the house bearing Nos.12-g-422/4/7
-T
and 12-8-423170. ln view of the above corrtentions irr the counter,
the orig;inaI rc'cord was called for bv this Court and also the award
passed by thc Land Acquisition Officer. Hor.t,ever, it vrras staterl that
thg praytuettt is rnaclc pursuarrt to tl'rc arnarrcl pclsSetl bv the [.arrd
':r
>
J.i'
Acquisitiorr Officer, who recommended payrnent of cornpensation
amount on the basis oi sotne credible evidence of ownership of the
latrti atrl as thc saici I{.No.l2-S-423/10 allcgccllv orvncti Lrv the n'rit
petitioner ancl it l-ras been contended that the amount of
compensation, which is liable to be paid to the writ petitioner, vvas
paid to thc 4th respondent herein unde.r mistaken of facts without
proper verification. [n that view of the matter, this Court, on the said
date oi the prosting of the case, has directec{ the Commissioner,
Gt IIvIC to cotrduct an enquiry in respect of the lancl acquisition
involving the disputed properties and submit a report to this Court
9.
Ar; seen fronr the record, vide procec,dirrgs of the Depruty
Commissioner, dated 78.07.201,2, the assessment granted in favour
of the 4th respondent herein by allotting prernises bearing No.12-8423/10, Mettuguda, Secundcrbad, was cancelled based ol1 the
ownership documents submitted by Smt. Ch.Sarojini Devi, writ
n
petitioner herein, and that the Commissioner has conducted an
enquiry by giving proper opportunity to all the parties at page No.3
of the said report, it was categorically statecl that the writ petitioner
- Chokkarapu sarojini Devi is the owner of 1500 square yards in
sy.No.793 situated at Mettuguda, and out of which, she sold away
l014 square' yarc'ls to Y.V.Bhaskar, leaving an extent of 4g6 square
1'ards of land and at sl.No.l4, at page No,4 of the re,port, the name of
4tl' respondent w,as shown to be owner and possessor of land to an
extent of 96.52 square metc.rs or 1t5.47 square varcls and at page
No.6 of the said report, it is stated as follows:
" I. this view of the matter, it is evident that the Corporation has
.
acquirecl 115.39 square varcrs of rancl in premiscs No.l2-u-423l10
under private .egotiatio^ and paid compensation to sri.
R.Acl'aiah rvithout verifying the clocuments anc{ the wrong
payme.t of compensation amounting to Rs.2g,01,260/_ was
marle tcl AcJ'aiah witho,t verifying his documents, which are
liablc tt-t bt-: rcc<'rvttrecl fronr him ancl shall Lrc ptrid to actual owner
i.e. the writ petitio.er - smt. Chokkarapu sarojini Devi.,,
10. It is also stated that disciplinary action will be initiated against
the erring ]'ow^ Plan..ing officer for payment of compensation
to
the 4th respondent, who has not produced any valid document
in
q-.
trI
support of his claim in respect of house prernises bearing No.12-B-
4n/14.
11. [iaving pcrused the saicl enquiry report, as the basic grievance
of thc ra,rit pc'titioner is, fclr non-consideratiorr of the representations
made b',2 her l'or pavrtterrt of conlperlsaticln and as the Comrnissioner
by corrducting an enquiry bir themselves came to conclusion that the
cornpensatictt't attroutrt irr respect of the lancl of the petitiorler bearilrg
.1
Il.No.12-8-423/10 to cur extent ol' 15.39 square vards was wrongly
paid to the 4tl' respondent ancl has stated that the amount n,ill be
paid to the writ pctitioner, who is actual owner of the lancl
admeastrring 1 15.39 square yards or 96.52 square meters.
72. The learned counsel for petitioners would submit that everr as
on todar,, though thcrc lvds cl rerport fileci by the Commissioner,
GHMC by conducting enquiry as early on 25.10.2074, in pursuance
of the directions of this Court, and the authorities having corne to a
conclusic,n that the writ petition is entitled to the compensation of
Rs.28,01,',760/- for the land acquired to an extent of land
adrneasu.:ing i15.39 square yard ()r 96.52 square meters, the
respondents are dutr'-bouncl to paV tfte corlprensation to the r.vrit
'*r -{
i\
petitioner forthwith and though the matter has been adjourned from
time to tirle, the respondents till date are not paid the saicl
cornpensalion, r.r'hich is cr .focia itlegal and arbitrary on the part of
the respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein and also amounts to depriving the
legitimate right of the n,rit petitiorrer from enjoying the fruits of her
ovvn land. In the cnquirv report submittc,d by the Commissioner,
they rvoukl pay the amount to the writ petitiorrer and it was
categoricallv stated that they would take appropriate actiorl upon
the erring officials for paymerrt of the cornpensation to a wrong
person. Be that as it may, the respondents ought to have at Ieast paid
the compensation to tlrc vvrit petitioner during the pendency of the
wri-t petition to shon, their bttrut fides. ['[owever, they are seeking time
from this Court everl to honour their own undertaking in the
enquiry report
13. Evidently, as it is clear from the report of the Commissioner,
GHMC, tl'rat the land to an extent of 1L5.39 square yards or 96.52
square meters belongs to the writ pet'itioner, which was acquired for
the purpose of roacl widening by the respondent Nos.1 to 3 and the
resporrdent Nos.1 to 3 are duty-bound to pay the comperlsation
t
fr
amount of Rs.29,07,760/_ to the
the date of filing .f report, but
no fault ol the writ
writ petitioners herein even as on
i.steacl kept dociging the payment
for
Fretitiorrers
14. l-herefore, in that vie*, of the matter,
this C<lurt, resporrc..rrt Nos.l tc-l
compensation of Rs.2U,01,760/_
3 are lerlall,r,Lrounci to pa,\,the
forthr,r,ith for the Iancl ilcquired
the firsl. writ petitioner to an e.xtent
square ,retcrs v,ithi^ a periocl
receipt .f c.pv of this orcler,
-[' lrrrt'. nr.rrths frorn the datc, of
6c'1 L-re' ar^^ur, frorn the
writ petiLion trr till thc paynrcrrt is
to pay the
date of the
rcalizccl.
15' In bhe above stated circurnstances, the
are directed to pay trre arnount
from
<lf 115.39 square yards or96.52
Lrcsitles [he.r, are also liable
interest accruerj thereupo n @
resp.ndent Nos.1 to 3
of Rs.28,01,760/ _t.wards the rand
an extent of r15-39 seuc-rre yards
or ()6.52squarcr rneters acquired
the road rvidening to the writ petitioners
the date oI receipt of trre cop,v
in corrsidered opinion of
to
for
withir-r two months from
of the orcier @ 6To per arlnum simpre
interest on the saicl a,rou^t frorn
before this Court on 25.10 .2074
trre clate <>f fili.g, of enquiry report
to tirr rearizatio.. However, insofar
as the balilnce of lancr trrat *,as
alreged to be acquired by the
€
'd
a
respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein, as there is no substantial proof
submitted by thc u,rit pctitioners that the balar-rce of land has been
acquired by the respondent Nos.'l to 3 l'rerein, the petitioners are at
liberty to approach the competent Court of law for redressal of their
qrievance atncl alsc,r in rcspect o[ otlrcr relief sor-rght against the
unofficial resporrdcnts arrd ventilate their grievance.
' 76. Accorclinglv,.the writ Petition is partly allowed and c{isposec{
;;
of. 'l'hcre shall lrc rxr orr{cr dS to costs.
r..
Pencliqg misccllaneous applications if apy shall stand closed
SD/.A.H.S.GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPY//
G
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Dy. Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation,
Secunderabad Division, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
2. The City Planner, Circle No. 18, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
3. The Zonal Commissioner, North Zone, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
4. One CC to M/s. K. Pallavi, Advocate IOPUC]
5. One CC to Sri G. Madhusudhan Reddy (SC FOR GHMC) (OPUC)
6. Two CD Copies.
BSK
BS
\
I
/
HIGH CoURT
DATED :2310112026
t
ORDER
WP.No.6i197 of 2010
rtE SIA
O
o
g 6 ttB 2o2t
*
PARTLY ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
q
+
ta
(')
:x
*
\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review