Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 07th April, 2026
Pronounced on: 12th May, 2026
RFA 636/2023, CM APPL. 40775/2023
1. SMT. CHAMAN LATA BHARDWAJ,
W/o Late Sh. R. K. Bhardwaj.
+
2. SH. ABHISHEK BHARDWAJ
S/o Late Sh. R. K. Bhardwaj.
3. SH. SHIVAM BHARDWAJ,
S/o Late Sh. R. K Bhardwaj.
All R/o:Flat No. 101, Shri Shyam Society,
Rajendra Park Ext. D-Block,
Nangloi, New Delhi-110041
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Jai Wadhwa and Mr. Ronak
Karanpuria, Advs.
Versus
SMT. NIRMAL DEVI
W/o Late Sh. Krishan Chander Vats,
R/o H. No. 39, Village &
Post Office Mundka, Delhi-110041
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Aditya Sharma and Ms. Aditi,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been
filed against the Judgment dated 05.04.2023 and Order dated 17.01.2023
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
whereby the Suit filed by the Plaintiff for recovery of Rs. 8,50,000/- along
with interest @ 12% p.a. till its realization, was decreed.
2.
The Respondent/Plaintiff had filed a Suit for Recovery of
Rs.8,50,000/- along with interest @24% p.a. from 01.02.2016 till its
realization.
3.
The brief facts as per Plaint are that the Plaintiff and her husband
Late Sh. Krishna Chandra Vats, and Late Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj,
husband of the Defendant no.1 i.e., were Government teachers in the same
school, and were very close friends for almost 15-16 years. Defendant no.1
is a LIC agent and the Plaintiff and her husband, used to take LIC Policy
from Defendant no.1.
4.
Defendant no.1 and her husband, had taken a loan from the Plaintiff
and her husband on several occasions, and repaid the same within due time,
thereby gaining the trust of the Plaintiff and her husband. On 26.10.2014,
the husband of the Plaintiff expired, and the Plaintiff received an
approximate amount of Rs.18,74,789/- from the office of her husband, as
serving amount/compensation amount, in March, 2015.
5.
In the month of October 2015, Defendant No.1 and her husband
contacted the Plaintiff for a friendly loan of Rs.10,00,000/- because they
were in dire need of money.
6.
Initially, the Plaintiff was reluctant, however, upon much insistence
of Defendant No.1 and her husband, she agreed to give Rs.8,50,000/- as a
loan. Consequently, an Agreement Deed dated 06.11.2015 was executed
between Defendant No.1, her husband and the Plaintiff whereby the terms
and conditions were agreed by both the parties, stating the amount of
Rs.8,50,000/- to be given as a friendly loan by the Plaintiff to Defendant
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
No.1 and her husband, for a period of 3 months w.e.f. 01.11.2015 to
31.01.2016.
Defendant No.1 and her husband, also gave a post-dated
cheque bearing no. 953241 on 06.11.2015, to the Plaintiff, as a security,
from the account of the husband of Defendant No.1.
7.
Upon the expiry of three months, when the Plaintiff demanded the
loan amount back, the husband of Defendant No.1 told Plaintiff to present
the cheques, given as a security, in the bank after 15.02.2016. Subsequently,
on 17.02.2016, when the said cheque was presented in the bank, the same
was dishonored and returned with the remarks as “Insufficient Funds” vide
return memo dated 19.02.2016.
8.
Then, again the Plaintiff contacted Defendant No.1 and her husband
regarding the dishonour of the said cheque, upon which the Defendant No.1
and her husband said that if the said cheque be presented again after two
days, it will be honoured. However, when the said cheque was presented
again on 20.02.2016, it was dishonoured with the remarks “Insufficient
Funds” vide return memo dated 23.02.2016.
9.
The Plaintiff, thereafter, again contacted Defendant No.1 and her
husband and similar assurances were given, and asked the Plaintiff to
present the cheque in March 2016. Then again, the Plaintiff presented the
cheque on 05.03.2016 and the same was returned as “Insufficient Funds”
vide return memo dated 08.03.2016.
10.
Consequently, a Legal Notice dated 22.03.2016 was sent by the
Plaintiff, to Defendant No.1 and her husband, calling upon them to repay the
loan amount, to which, the husband of Defendant No.1 issued two new
cheques bearing no.921979 for Rs.3,00,000/- dated 23.05.2016 and another
cheque bearing no. 921980 for Rs.5,50,000/-dated 10.10.2017, stating that
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
they are not in sound position and financially incapable to pay the loan
amount.
11.
It was further submitted that in the month of May 2016, the
Plaintiff again contacted Defendant No.1 and her husband for presenting the
cheque dated 23.05.2016, upon which Defendant no.1 and her husband
requested Plaintiff that the said cheque be presented in the month of
November, 2017, along with the other cheque dated 10.10.2017, as they
would receive some amount in the month of November, 2017. Due to
cordial relations, the Plaintiff gave the Defendants more time and presented
the cheque bearing no. 921980 dated 10.10.2017, on 08.11.2017 which was
again dishonoured vide returning memo dated 09.11.2017 with the remarks
as “Insufficient Fund”.
12.
Then again, the Plaintiff contacted the Defendants and demanded
the loan amount, however, the Defendant no.1 refused to pay because her
husband had expired.
13.
Further, the Plaintiff visited the house of the Defendants just for the
condolence after death of husband of Defendant no.1 and father of defendant
no.2 and 3, as well as for requesting for the loan amount of Rs.8,50,000/-,
but the Defendants misbehaved with the Plaintiff, and was told that she was
not permitted to even enter into their house, and the Defendants also stated
that there is no relation between them and the amount received by them from
the Plaintiff, shall be forgotten as they would not pay any amount to anyone.
14.
Further, again on 18.12.2017, another Legal Notice was sent by the
Plaintiff to the Defendants, demanding the loan amount of Rs.8,50,000/-, to
which the Defendants sent a reply dated 30.12.2017 wherein they denied
taking any such loan and issuing any cheques to the Plaintiff.
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
15.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff filed a Suit for Recovery of Rs.8,50,000/-
along with interest @24% p.a. from 01.02.2016 till its realization.
16.
The Defendants in their Written Statement took a defence that
Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj never took any loan from the Plaintiff and the
signatures on the aforesaid cheques are forged and fabricated, and are not in
the handwriting of the husband of Defendant No.1 i.e. Rajender Kumar
Bhardwaj; and it was also submitted that none of the Defendants has
inherited any assets from the deceased husband of Defendant No.1.
Furthermore, the Agreement dated 06.11.2015 was also never signed by the
Defendant No.1 and her husband.
17.
The Issues on the pleadings were framed by the learned Additional
District Judge on 09.12.2019 as under:
“Issue No.1: Whether plaintiff has no cause of
action to file the present suit against the present
defendants as they have not inherited the assets of
Sh. R.K. Bhardwaj? OPD.
Issue No.2: Whether the signatures of Sh. R.K.
Bhardwaj on the cheque in question are forged
and fabricated? OPD.
Issue No.3: Whether plaintiff is entitled for
recovery of sum of Rs.8,50,000/- as prayed for?
OPP.
Issue No.4: Whether plaintiff is entitled for
pendente lite and future interest @ 24% per
annum as prayed for? OPP.
Issue No. 5: Relief.”
18.
The Plaintiff to prove her case, examined herself as PW-1 and
tendered her evidence by way of affidavit as Ex.PW-1/A wherein she relied
upon relevant documents from Ex.PW-1/1 to Ex.PW-1/14 and reiterated the
averments made in the Plaint.
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
19.
PW-2, Sh. Puneet Chaudhary, from State Bank of India, brought
the duly certified record of bank account bearing no. 10472717323,
maintained by the Plaintiff, from 01.01.2015 to 31.05.2015, and proved the
same.
20.
PW-3, Sh. Satendra Kumar Bhatnagar, the branch manager of the
Union Bank of India, brought the record of bank account bearing no.
272710100000469 maintained by the Plaintiff, from September 2015 to June
2015, and proved the same.
21.
PW-4, Sh. Sunil Kumar Vats, son of the Plaintiff tendered his
evidence by way of affidavit as Ex.PW-4/A, wherein he also relied upon
relevant documents from Ex.PW1-1 to PW-1/14 and reiterated the
averments made in the Plaint, and further stated that the Agreement Deed
dated 06.11.2015 Ex.PW-1/3 executed between the parties, bears his
signature also.
22.
PW-5, Sh. Hari Prakash, who was a witness to the execution of
Agreement Deed dated 06.11.2015, identified the signatures of Sh. Rajender
Kumar Bhardwaj, Smt. Chaman Lata and Smt. Nirmal Devi. He stated that
Agreement dated 06.11.2015 was executed in his presence and also bears his
signature, and proved the Agreement Deed dated 06.11.2015 Ex.PW-1/3.
23.
However, before the Plaintiff could lead her evidence, the COVID-
19 pandemic disrupted court operations, resulting in nearly a year without
effective hearings. On 12.04.2021, the Defendants failed to appear. The
subsequent Court Notices returned unserved, reporting that the defendants
had not lived at the provided address for years. Thereafter, the Defendant
No. 1 eventually appeared and gave her updated address on record.
However, on 10.05.2022, when the matter was set for the Plaintiff's
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
evidence, the Defendants again failed to appear despite repeated calls and
were consequently proceeded ex-parte.
24.
The learned Trial Court after appreciating the evidence,
observed that the Defendants have failed to explain how the cheques in
question, admittedly belonging to Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj, came into
possession of the Plaintiff, and all three legal heirs of Sh. Rajender Kumar
Bhardwaj are liable to clear his liabilities as they are entitled to succeed his
estate as well.
25.
Accordingly, the learned Additional District Judge decreed the Suit
of the Plaintiff and directed the Defendants are liable to pay Rs.8,50,000/along with interest @ 12% p.a. from the date of filing of the Suit till its
realization.
26.
Aggrieved by the Judgment dated 05.04.2023 and Order dated
17.01.2023, the Appellant/Defendant has preferred the present Appeal.
27.
The grounds of challenge are that Ld. Trial Court failed to
appreciate that the signatures on the aforesaid cheques are forged and are not
in the handwriting of deceased Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj. Therefore,
when Defendant took a specific defence of non-signing of documents, then
Plaintiff ought to have proved the signatures of Defendant no.1 and her
husband, by the Forensic Experts.
28.
The Defendants have not inherited any assets of Sh. Rajender
Kumar Bhardwaj. Thus, in the light of this specific defence, burden of proof
should have been put upon the Plaintiff to prove that Defendants has
inherited any assets.
29.
The learned Trial court failed to appreciate that due to the demise of
counsel for Defendants, they were not represented, and the Defendants were
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
also financially weak and therefore, could not engage any another counsel
and had to get the services of Legal Services Authority.
30.
The learned Trial Court erringly held that the Application under
Order IX Rule 7 CPC was filed with delay, and further did not prescribe any
limitation period. Therefore, in such situations Article 137 of Limitation Act
is applicable, which prescribes a period of 3 years of limitation period.
31.
Reliance is placed upon Visalakshi Vs. Umpathy 2015 (5) CTC 67,
wherein it was held that since Order IX Rule 7 lacks a prescribed limitation
period, Article 137 of Limitation Act applies by default, imposing a threeyear limit for filing.
32.
The learned Trial Court erred in rejecting the Application based on
the Defendant's failure to cross-examine the Plaintiff. The delay was
justified by the COVID-19 pandemic and the fact that the Plaintiff requested
most of the adjournments. Aside from one instance where the defense
counsel was ill, the defendant was not responsible for the lack of progress in
the proceedings.
Submissions heard and record perused.
33.
Admittedly, the parties were long-standing colleagues and family
friends. The Plaintiff advanced a friendly loan of Rs.8,50,000/- under a
written Agreement dated 06.11.2015, and multiple cheques were issued by
late Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj to cover their loan liability but were
repeatedly dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. The Suit was ultimately
proceeded ex parte when, despite repeated reminders and opportunities, the
Defendants chose not to participate in the proceedings.
34.
The grounds of challenge are twofold; firstly, the signatures on the
cheques and the Agreement are forged and, therefore, in the face of such a
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
specific plea, the Plaintiff was obliged to get the documents examined by a
handwriting or forensic expert. Secondly, the Defendants have not inherited
any estate of the deceased, and thus no decree could have been passed
against them in their capacity as legal heirs.
35.
The Appellants further challenges the dismissal of the Application
under Order IX Rule 7 CPC, specifically addressing the prejudice caused
due to the demise of their counsel and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Plea of forgery and burden of proof:
36.
Pertinently, the Defendants in their Written Statement raised a bald
plea that the signatures on the cheques and on the Agreement Deed dated
06.11.2015 were forged and fabricated. However, they stopped appearing at
the stage of evidence; they neither subjected the Plaintiff and her witnesses
to cross-examination nor led any evidence in support of their defence.
37.
The learned Trial Court has rightly observed that PW-1 the
Plaintiff, PW-4 Sh. Sunil Kumar Vats and PW-5 Sh. Hari Prakash, deposed
to the execution of the Agreement and the issuance of cheques. PW-5
specifically identified the signatures of late Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj
as well as of Defendant No.1 on the Agreement. Their testimony remained
unrebutted.
38.
A mere plea of forgery taken by the Appellants, without any
particulars, proof, or even an attempt at cross-examination, cannot displace
documentary evidence proved through primary witnesses and supported by
bank records and cheque return memos. Once execution of Loan Agreement
and issuance of cheques, to establish the friendly loans advanced, are
proved, the burden shifted squarely on the Defendant to rebut the
presumption that such cheques were not issued or were not towards a legally
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
enforceable liability. If the defendant fails, the Plaintiff is entitled to a
decree, on the standard of preponderance of probabilities.
39.
The contention that the Plaintiff was bound, as a matter of law, to
have the signatures proved only by a forensic expert, is misconceived.
Expert evidence is merely one mode of proof; it is neither mandatory nor
conclusive.
40.
When the Plaintiff has produced the original Agreement dated
06.11.2015 Ex. PW-1/3, the cheques bearing nos. 953241, 931979 and
921980 issued by the husband of Defendant No.1 on various occasions and
bank records of the Plaintiff Ex.PW-1/2, and has examined not only herself,
but also the attesting witness i.e. Sh. Hari Prakash who has identified the
signatures, and when such evidence has gone unchallenged, the Trial Court
cannot be faulted for accepting the execution of the documents.
41.
The onus to substantiate the plea of forgery rested heavily on the
defendants; they chose to abandon their defence at the stage of evidence and
cannot now, seek to take advantage of their own default, in Appeal. The
Appellants have failed to prove that there was no loan given or that the Loan
Agreement was not signed or that various cheques were not issued by Late
Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj, in discharge of his liability, under the Loan
Agreement.
Liability of legal heirs and inheritance of estate:
42.
The second contention of the Appellants is that none of the
Defendants inherited any estate of late Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj, and
therefore, they could not have been saddled with his alleged liability.
43.
It is settled that legal heirs are liable for the debts of the deceased
only to the extent of the estate inherited by them. However, once the
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
relationship and status as Class-I legal heirs are admitted or established, the
burden necessarily shifts on such heirs to disclose the nature of the estate, if
any, and to show that either no estate has devolved upon them or that the
estate is insufficient to meet the liability.
44.
This plea was merely asserted in the Written Statement, however, no
particulars were given as to what properties, movable or immovable,
constituted his estate, and how or in what manner the same did not devolve
upon the Defendants. No material has been brought on record to show that
there was no estate, or that it stood divested before his death.
45.
Thus, the learned Trial Court rightly observed that even though no
evidence was led by the Defendants to show that the Defendants have not
inherited the assets of Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj, they have not denied
the being the legal heirs of Late Sh. Rajender Kumar Bhardwaj. Moreover,
this is a plea to be taken in Execution, and not in the Suit, wherein only the
legal liabilities of the parties are adjudicated.
Dismissal of the Application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC and Limitation:
46.
The Appellants have also asserted that the dismissal of their
Application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC vide order dated 17.01.2023, was
wrong, since no specific period of limitation is prescribed for such an
Application. Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, provides a three-year
period, which ought to have been applied. In support, reliance has been
placed on Visalakshi(supra) wherein it was held that Article 137 of
Limitation Act was held applicable to Applications under Order IX Rule 7
CPC. However, various decisions of High Courts have observed that no
period of limitation governs such Applications and that the overarching test
is whether “Sufficient Cause” for the earlier non-appearance is made out.
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
47.
It is, therefore, evident that the Applicant must still establish
“Sufficient Cause” for the non-appearance during the trial. The Supreme
Court, in Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar 1964 SCR (5) 946 and G.P.
Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada (2000) 3 SCC 54, has emphasized that “sufficient
cause” postulates a bona fide, diligent explanation and does not extend to
cover negligence or prolonged inaction on the part of the litigant.
48.
Likewise, in Parimal v. Veena @ Bharti (2011) 3 SCC 545, it has
been held that a party cannot be permitted to remain inactive after service
and then seek to shift blame entirely to his counsel or general circumstances,
nor can such vague pleas be treated as a passport to unsettle ex parte orders.
49.
In the present case, after having participated in the proceedings and
filing the Written Statement, the Defendants repeatedly remained absent,
despite service of Court notices. The plea taken in the Application was
confined to general averments about the demise of counsel, financial
constraints and disruption due to the COVID-19 pandemic, without any
particulars or supporting material. The learned Trial Court’s refusal in
recalling the ex parte order, is therefore, justified.
Conclusion:
50.
Thus, Appellant has not been able to point out any infirmity in
the Impugned Judgment dated 05.04.2023 and Order dated 17.01.2023.
51.
Therefore, there is no merit in the Appeal, which is hereby
dismissed. Pending Applications, if any, stands disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MAY 12, 2026
R
KUMAR BHATT
17:55:12
RFA 636/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review