Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
Reserved On
: 25/08/2026
Pronounced On : 03/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.13575 of 2023
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
Sd/Sd/-
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
SLIMTILE PRIVATE LIMITED
Versus
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR B S SOPARKAR(6851) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
KARAN G SANGHANI(7945) for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA)
1.
At the outset, learned advocate Mr.Soparker
appearing
for
submitted
that
the
petitioner-Company
the
petitioner-Company
has
is
not
pressing the prayer seeking quashing and setting
aside of the show cause notices dated 17.06.2023
and
20.06.2023,
issued
Assistant
Commissioner
Circle-2,
but
reference
dated
No.1
and
is
by
of
Income
confining
24.06.2023
respondent
respondent
the
Central
challenge
to
by
respondent
No.2-District
Valuation
made
Tax,
No.1-
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
Officer for determination of the value of the
fixed assets of the petitioner-Company.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE :
2.
The petitioner-Company is a Limited Company,
for the Assessment Year (A.Y.) 2021-22,
filed
its return of income on 14.03.2022, declaring a
total income of Rs.8,17,74,420/-. The return was
selected for scrutiny, pursuant to which a notice
under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
(hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) came to be
issued to the petitioner-Company on 29.06.2022.
Thereafter, from time to time, various notices
under Section 142(1) of the Act were issued to
the petitioner-Company, to which the petitionerCompany duly responded by filing the requisite
replies
and
furnishing
the
information
and
documents sought by respondent No.1.
3.
Subsequently, on 17.06.2023 and 20.06.2023,
respondent No.1 issued the show cause notices to
the
petitioner-Company.
submitted
its
The
detailed
petitioner-Company
reply
thereto
on
22.06.2023, wherein, apart from dealing with the
allegations and issues raised in the show cause
notices
on
merits,
the
petitioner-Company
specifically questioned the very maintainability
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
and validity of the notices and the proceedings
initiated pursuant thereto, inter alia, on the
ground
that
the
proceedings
were
barred
by
limitation.
4.
In
response
to
the
aforesaid
objection
regarding limitation, respondent No.1, by an email
dated
21.06.2023
petitioner-Company,
addressed
which
to
the
communication,
significantly, is not reflected on the Income Tax
Business
Application
(ITBA)
portal,
sought
to
contend that the time available for completion of
the assessment stood extended by virtue of the
Explanation
to
Section
of
the
Act.
Thereafter, on 24.06.2023, respondent No.1 made a
reference to respondent No.2-District Valuation
Officer under Section 142A of the Act, seeking
determination of the value of the fixed assets
allegedly acquired by the petitioner-Company, on
the
premise
that
the
said
assets
had
been
acquired in the names of individual owners and
were allegedly not being used for the purposes of
the business of the petitioner-Company.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER-COMPANY :
5. Learned advocate Mr.Soparker appearing for
the
petitioner-Company
reference
dated
has
24.06.2023
submitted
that
made
respondent
by
the
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
No.1 to respondent No.2 for determination of the
value of the fixed assets constitutes is nothing
but a colourable exercise of power, having been
resorted
to
with
the
object
and
effect
of
artificially extending the period available for
completion of the assessment.
6.
It is submitted that, significantly, in the
very reference made under Section 142A of the
Act,
respondent
No.1
sought
the
opinion
of
respondent No.2 for determining the Fair Market
Value of the tangible assets as on 24.06.2023,
while
acknowledging
proceedings
that
would
the
become
assessment
time-barred
on
25.06.2023. It was, therefore, contended that the
reference
could
not
legitimate
step
in the
have
been
made
assessment
as
a
proceedings,
but was consciously resorted to at the fag end of
the prescribed period, with the sole object of
invoking
the
statutory
reference
and
thereby
period
available
consequence
seeking
for
to
of
such
extend
the
of
the
completion
assessment. On such premise, the reference itself
was
assailed
impermissible
as
being
exercise
a
colourable
and
of
power
and,
consequently, as being without jurisdiction and
liable to be quashed and set aside.
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
7.
Learned
submitted
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
advocate
that
Mr.Soparker
the
very
has
basis
on
further
which
the
reference came to be made to the respondent No.2
is wholly misconceived and legally unsustainable.
According
Company
names
to
had
of
respondent
acquired
No.1,
the
individual
the
fixed
owners,
petitioner-
assets
while
in
the
claiming
depreciation in respect thereof in its books of
account. It was submitted that, even assuming the
aforesaid
premise
of
respondent
No.1
to
be
correct, the same could at the highest furnish a
ground for examining the claim for depreciation
of
the
petitioner-Company
impermissible,
accordance
with
justification
valuation
for
of
disallowing
law.
There
whatsoever
the
and,
fixed
such
was,
for
assets
if
found
claim
in
however,
no
obtaining
a
from
respondent
No.2, since the valuation of such assets had no
bearing upon the alleged defect in the claim for
depreciation of the petitioner-Company.
8.
It
was,
therefore,
submitted
by
learned
advocate Mr. Mr.Soparkar that the reference to
respondent No.2 for determination of the value of
the fixed assets was wholly extraneous to the
issue sought to be examined by respondent No.1
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
and
could
serve
no
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
legitimate
purpose
in
the
assessment proceedings. The timing and manner in
which
the
reference
was
made,
particularly
on
24.06.2023, immediately before the assessment was
to
become
time-barred
on
25.06.2023,
clearly
demonstrated that the reference was not made for
any genuine or bona fide valuation requirement,
but was merely employed as a device to invoke the
statutory extension of time and thereby keep the
assessment
proceedings
alive.
The
reference,
therefore, being a colourable and impermissible
exercise of power, was submitted to be without
jurisdiction, illegal and liable to be quashed
and set aside.
9.
In support of his submissions he has placed
reliance on the judgment of this Court in case of
Anand Banwarilal Adhukia Vs. Deputy Commissioner
of Income-Tax, Circle-14, (2016) 75 Taxmann.com
301 (Gujarat) and in case of Me & Mummy Hospital
Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax, (2014)
45 Taxmann.com 248 (Gujarat).
SUBMISSIONS ADVANCED BY THE REVENUE
10. Opposing the aforesaid submissions, learned
Senior Standing Counsel Mr.Karan G. Sanghani at
the
outset
has
submitted
that
as
far
as
the
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
impugned
reference
referring
the
order
dated
valuation
24.06.2023
relating
to
the
depreciation on assets is concerned, he would be
unable to justify the same since it is always
open
for
the
Revenue/
Assessing
Officer
to
disallow the claim of depreciation, and there is
no
requirement
of
However,
with
Valuation
Officer
cash
the
to
referring
regard
to
the
relating
group
it
valuation.
reference
to
company
for
the
of
to
the
unaccounted
M/s.Ratnakala
Exports Pvt. Ltd., relating to share purchase and
other immovable properties and increase in fixed
asset
is
concerned
the
Assessing
Officer
is
justified in referring the same to the Valuation
Officer.
11. In
so
far
as
the
period
28.12.2022
to
17.06.2023,
Assessing
Officer,
learned
consumed
consumed
Senior
from
by
the
Standing
Counsel Mr.Sanghani has attempted to justify the
same. It is contended that the Assessing Officer
during
this
period
has
scrutinized
the
seized
material and correlated with the audited reports
of the petitioner-Company and return disclosures
which
consumed
time,
and
thereafter,
the
Assessing Officer issued show cause notices dated
17.06.2023 and 20.06.2023.
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
12. It
is
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
submitted
by
the
learned
Senior
Standing Counsel that in the matter arising out
of search and incriminating material indicating
cash transactions, two factors are required to be
accepted to make the assessment legally robust
namely, (1) generation/ availability of cash and
(2)
utilization of such cash. In the instant
case,
the
seized
transactions
material
thereby
indicated
raising
an
cash
assessment
relevant requirement to examine the issue as to
whether
to
what
deployed/invested
extent
in
such
tangible
cash
stood
assets.
It
is
submitted that the financial statements for the
year
ended
on
31.03.2021
disclose
to
tangible
assets
incriminating
material
received
investigation
wing
28.12.2022
additions
unaccounted
cash
on
transactions
significant
and
within
further
from
the
revealed
the
group
concerns.
13. It
is
contended
that
the
determination
of
true and fair market value of assets vis-a-vis
the
declared
hence
such
investment
exercise
was
squarely
necessitated
and
falls
the
within
scope of Section 142A of the Act which empowers
the Assessing Officer to obtain expert valuation
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
to
ascertain
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
correctness
of
investment
or
value of assets in question.
14. It
were
is
submitted
subsisting
reference
has
that
thus
the
proceedings
as
on
24.06.2023
and
the
been
made
before
expiry
of
limitation in accordance with Explanation-1(v) to
Section
153(1)
of
the
Act
which
contemplates
exclusion of time for obtaining valuation report
and hence the timing of the reference was within
jurisdiction and in consonance with the statutory
framework thus it is urged that the writ petition
may not be entertained.
ANALYSIS AND OPINION
15. We have heard the learned advocates appearing
for the respective parties at length and perused
the documentary evidence on record. The facts,
which are established from the pleadings and the
documentary evidence on record are as under.
(a)
A search and seizure under Section 132
was undertaken on 24.09.2021 at M/s.Ratnakala
Exports
Pvt.
Ltd.,
after
the
survey
on
22.09.2021. Thereafter, a show cause notice for
transfer of the case under Section 127 of the
Act was issued on 16.11.2021 to the petitionerCompany,
which
objected
the
transfer
of
the
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
case and ultimately, the case was transferred
to the jurisdiction of the petitioner-Company
from
Rajkot
to
Surat
Ultimately,
the
petitioner-Company
return
of
income
with
for
A.Y.
immediate
effect.
filed
2021-22
its
declaring
total income of Rs.8,17,74,420/- on 14.03.2022.
(b)
The case of the petitioner-Company was
selected
for
scrutiny
and
a
notice
under
Section 143(2) of the Act was issued to the
petitioner on 29.06.2022.
(c)
The
petitioner-Company
filed
its
response to the notices issued thereafter, on
12.08.2022, 21.11.2022 and 02.12.2022.
(d)
On 28.12.2022, the material derived from
search and survey of M/s.Ratnakala Exports Pvt.
Ltd., by Deputy Director of Income Tax (DDIT)
(Investigation), Surat was forwarded and handed
over
to
(DCIT),
Deputy
Surat.
Commissioner
Thereafter,
on
of
Income
Tax
17.06.2023
and
20.06.2023 show cause notice was issued by the
respondent – Assistant Commissioner of Incometax,
Central,
material
Circle-2
gathered
unaccounted
payment
on
the
during
the
of
Rs.19,75,00,000/-.
basis
of
the
search
for
Rs.1,01,00,113/-
and
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
(e)
The
show
cause
notice
vide
communication
22.06.2023
pointing
out
that
assessment
has
and
also
contesting
on
become
petitioner-Company
time
barred
objected
to
the
dated
merits.
(f)
The petitioner-Company also objected to
the show cause notice, which is sent via email,
is not reflected on the portal.
(g)
On 21.062023, the petitioner-Company was
informed that the requisite show cause notice
has already been served to the the petitionerCompany through email on 20.06.2023 relevant to
A.Y.
2018-19
assessment
and
will
A.Y.
be
2021-22
completed
based
and
the
on
the
details available on record and merit of the
case in case the petitioner fails to respond.
It was
time
also intimated
was
Section
that
the
extension
of
the
provision
of
in
compliance
of
of
Act
Explanation
and
the
the
period
read
of
with
its
exclusion
of
handling over seized incrementing materials.
(h)
Thereafter, by the impugned order dated
24.06.2023, the Assessing Officer referred the
matter to Departmental Valuation Officer.
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
16. We may, at this stage, clarify that while
passing the impugned order dated 24.06.2023, the
Assessing Officer has specifically recorded that
the assessment proceedings are pending in this
case and it is getting time barred on 25.06.2023.
Thus,
one
day
prior
to
the
expiry
of
the
limitation of the assessment proceedings for A.Y.
2021-22,
the
Assessing
Officer
refers
the
valuation for determining the valuation of fair
market value of tangible assets to the District
Valuation Officer. Further the Assessing Officer
has requested the District Valuation Officer to
send
the
report
earliest
and
preferably
by
30.06.2023.
17. The adjustment of limitation period, under
which the revenue has taken shelter is found in
the provision of Section 153 (Explanation-1)(v)
of the Act. Section 153 (Explanation 1)(v) of the
Act reads as under :“No order of assessment shall be made under Section
143 or Section 144 at any time after the expiry of
21 months from the end of the assessment year in
which the income was first assessable.
Explanation 1:
For the purposes of this Section, in computing the
period of limitation,
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
(v)
the period commencing from the date on which
the Assessing Officer makes a reference to the
Valuation Officer under Sub-Section (1) of Section
142A and ending with the date on which the report of
the Valuation Officer is received by the Assessing
Officer.”
18. It is the case of the petitioner-Company that
the Assessing Officer in order to buy further
time and extend the time beyond 31.12.2022 to
25.06.2023
Section
by
resorting
to
the
(Explanation-1)(v)
of
provision
of
the
Act
has
advanced
by
passed the impugned order of reference.
19. We
agree
with
the
submissions
learned advocate Mr.Soparkar on the scrutiny of
the established facts.
20. The Assessing Officer has passed the impugned
order requesting the District Valuation Officer
to determine the fair market value on following
two grounds;
(1)
that
various
the
seized
search
action
incrementing
resulted
material
in
which
exhibited that the the petitioner-Company has
paid huge unaccounted cash in crores to the
group company of M/s.Ratnakala Exports Pvt.
Ltd.,
movable
regarding
share
properties
purchase
during
the
and
other
year
under
consideration and the the petitioner-Company
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
has shown the increase in fixed asset which
includes
land
and
machinery,
vehicles,
to Rs.64,00,02,502/-
building,
computer
plant
etc.
and
totaling
and;
(2) that during the assessment proceedings it
has
been
noticed
Company
has
fixed
assets
owners.
that
the
the
purchased
the
above
mentioned
name
of
individual
in
the
However,
the
petitioner-
depreciations
are
claimed on the same in the books of accounts
of the the petitioner and thus, it is alleged
that the petitioner-Company has claimed bogus
depreciation
on
assets
which
are
not
purchased in its name and neither being used
for its business purpose.
21. As far as the second
reason mentioned in the
impugned order of reference is concerned, it has
been fairly accepted by learned Senior Standing
Counsel
appearing
for
the
revenue
that
the
reference could not have been made on such issue
as it is always open for the Assessing Officer to
disallow the depreciation, if it is found to be
bogus.
22. In
our
considered
opinion,
the
Assessing
Officer has acted illegally in order to further
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
strengthen
his
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
first
ground
for
reference
relating to the valuation of assets and attempted
to
create
another
depreciation
on
limitation,
which
ground
such
of
assets
was
claim
for
getting
of
bogus
extending
time
barred
the
on
25.06.2023. It cannot be countenanced that the
Assessing Officer was ignorant of the provision
of the Chapter IV of the Act, which regulates
depreciation, investments etc, while making the
reference on depreciation of assets by alleging
bogus claim, which he could have disallowed.
23. We
may
now
deal
with
the
first
reason
assigned in the reference order. The same also
appears to be intentional, and is raised in order
to extend the limitation period of completing the
assessment.
24. We may mention that, as per the case of the
Revenue
the
material
derived
from
search
and
survey action from M/s.Ratnakala group was handed
over to the DCIT, Surat on 28.12.2022. For the
period of six months the Assessing Officer sat
tight
on
17.06.2023
such
material
and 20.06.2023,
and
thereafter
on
show cause notices
were issued by the respondent of Rs.1,01,00,113/and Rs.90,75,00,000/- for unaccounted payment. A
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
perusal of the both the show cause notices reveal
that the petitioner-Company has been called upon
to
explain
as
to
why
the
amount
mentioned,
hereinabove above, should not be treated as its
unaccounted
silent
payment,
so far
concerned.
however,
as the
The
the
valuation
petitioner-Company
notices
are
of assets
are
in its
reply
dated 20.06.2023 had tendered explanation to the
unaccounted payment given by it. As previously
mentioned, the petitioner-Company was issued the
show cause notices on 05.08.2022, 16.11.2022 and
21.11.2022 under Section 142(1) of the Act. None
of
these
notices
refer
proceedings.
By these
Company
called
was
to
search
notices,
upon
to
or
survey
the petitionersupply
numerous
details of bank accounts, claim of deductions,
cash
deposits,
profit
and
loss,
repayment
of
unsecured loans, details of loans and advances
and
investment.
In
the
final
notice
dated
21.11.2022, the petitioner-Company was asked to
furnish the details of assets during the year in
consideration, expenses of repair and maintenance
of plant and machinery of Rs.4,07,66,736/- along
with
copy
evidence.
dated
of
ledger
account,
and
The petitioner-Company,
02.12.2022,
had
explained
supporting
in its
in
reply
detail
by
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
supplying the necessary material explaining the
payments made on the assets such as computer,
machinery,
factory
shed,
vehicle,
furniture,
office equipment etc. The petitioner-Company had
given the details of the payments made through
Bank. After such explanation was tendered by the
petitioner-Company
relating
to
the
assets
on
02.12.2022, the things did not proceed further
till the issue with regard to the valuation of
the assets was cropped-up on 24.06.2023 in the
impugned
order
of
Assessing
Officer
reference,
referred
by
the
which
the
valuation
of
assets to the Departmental Valuation Officer. The
show
cause
20.06.2023
notices
are
also
dated
silent
17.06.2023
on
the
aspect
and
of
assets. Hence, it is to be presumed that after
the petitioner-Company tendered its detail reply
dated 02.12.2022 to the show cause notice issued
on
21.11.2022
under
the
provisions
of
Section
142(1) of the Act, the Assessing Officer did not
choose
to
reopen
or
question
the
payment
on
assets by the petitioner-Company.
25. Thus, on a close scrutiny of the facts and
the documentary evidence on record, we find that
the
Assessing
assessment
Officer
in
order
to
save
proceedings
by
giving
a
colorable
the
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
exercise
extended
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
the
limitation
of
the
assessment proceedings which was going to be over
on 25.06.2023 by passing the impugned order of
reference.
The
Assessing
Officer,
from
the
beginning, was very much alive to the limitation
period
for
the
assessment
proceedings,
which
would get expired on 25.06.2023, as he himself
has referred to in the impugned order. All the
material from the search and survey and from the
petitioner
was
already
available
with
the
Assessing Officer, however, he showed remissness
in completing the assessment before 25.06.2023.
Thus, by creating an artificial cause of action
of referring determination of valuation of assets
and the claim of depreciation on such assets has
attempted
to
extend
the
time
by
resorting
to
Explanation-1(v) to Section 153 of the Act.
26. In addition to the aforesaid aspects, we also
find that no satisfactory explanation has been
tendered by the Revenue to explain the delay from
28.12.2022 i.e. the date when the material was
handed over from the search proceedings to the
DCIT, Surat till the issuance of the notice on
17.06.2023. A lame explanation has been tendered
to the extent that the Assessing Officer consumed
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
the time in examining such material. In case, the
Assessing
material
Officer
within
had
time
scrutinized
limit
then
all
while
the
issuing
notices on 17.06.2023 and 20.06.2023, he could
have re-examined the explanation tendered by the
petitioner-Company to the payments made on the
assets vide his reply dated 02.12.2022 and also
the claim of depreciation, and there would have
been
no
further
while
passing
referring
the
need
to
impugned
resurrect
order
determination
the
dated
of
issue,
24.06.2023
valuation
on
assets which he missed in the subsequent notices
issued on 17.06.2023 and
27. Thus,
the
20.06.2023.
overall
analysis
and
the
appreciation of facts manifest that the Assessing
Officer has very ingeniously raised two issues
for making reference to the District Valuation
Officer
in
order
completing
to
cover-up
his
the
assessment
the
writ
petition
impugned
order
dated
24.06.2023,
Assessing
Officer
inaction
proceedings
in
before
25.06.2023.
28. Hence,
referred
the
succeeds.
whereby
matter
to
The
the
the
Departmental Valuation Officer a mere day prior
C/SCA/13575/2023(GJHC240480492023)
to
the
assessment
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 03/09/2026
proceedings
becoming
time-
barred, is hereby quashed.
Sd/.
(A. S. SUPEHIA, J)
Sd/.
(VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J)
Bhavesh-[PPS]/K.K.SAIYED/1
***
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review