Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH : AMARAVATI
****
W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008, 17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009 and
23906 of 2010
W.P.No.12361 of 2008 & Batch
Between:
1. M/s. The K.C.P. Limited,, Macherla, Guntur District. Rep. by its General
Manager (CM), Shri K. Ramakrishna, S/o. Sarweshwara Rao.
2. S. Ramesh Kumar,, S/o. Late S. Venakatarao, R/o. K.C.P. Quarters,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad.
...Petitioners
AND
1. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited,
Renigunta Road, Tirupathi, Rep. by its Managing Director.
2. Chief General Manager Expr, Corporate Office. /APSPDCL, D.No. 19-1365/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road, Tirupathi - 517 503.
3. Senior Account Officer, Circle Office, APSPDCL, 4/7, Brodipet, Guntur.
...Respondents
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED: 17.04.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G. RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the judgment?
Yes / No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
marked to Law Reporters / Journals?
Yes / No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to
see the fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes / No
______________________________________
GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD, J
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
+ W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008, 17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009
and 23906 of 2010
% 17.04.2026
W.P.No.12361 of 2008 & Batch
Between:
1. M/s. The K.C.P. Limited,, Macherla, Guntur District. Rep. by its General
Manager (CM), Shri K. Ramakrishna, S/o. Sarweshwara Rao.
2. S. Ramesh Kumar,, S/o. Late S. Venakatarao, R/o. K.C.P. Quarters,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad.
...Petitioners
AND
1. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited,
Renigunta Road, Tirupathi, Rep. by its Managing Director.
2. Chief General Manager Expr, Corporate Office. /APSPDCL, D.No. 19-1365/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road, Tirupathi - 517 503.
3. Senior Account Officer, Circle Office, APSPDCL, 4/7, Brodipet, Guntur.
...Respondents
! Counsel for
Petitioner/s
: Sri K. Gopal Choudary
^ Counsel for
Respondent/s
: Sri Sk. Md. Umar Abdullah, learned Counsel, Sri
Venkata Rama Rao Kota, learned Standing
Counsel for APSPDCL and Sri V.V. Satish,
learned
Standing
Counsel
appearing
for
APEPDCL.
< Gist:
> Head Note:
4. ? Cases referred:
i.
MANU/AP/0442/2008
Judgment reserved on
Judgment pronounced on
Judgment uploaded on
03.03.2026
17.04.2026
23.04.2026
APHC010385752008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY,THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008, 17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009 and
23906 of 2010
W.P.No.12361 of 2008 & Batch
Between:
1. M/s. The K.C.P. Limited,, Macherla, Guntur District. Rep. by its General
Manager (CM), Shri K. Ramakrishna, S/o. Sarweshwara Rao.
2. S. Ramesh Kumar,, S/o. Late S. Venakatarao, R/o. K.C.P. Quarters,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad.
...Petitioners
AND
1. Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited,
Renigunta Road, Tirupathi, Rep. by its Managing Director.
2. Chief General Manager Expr, Corporate Office. /APSPDCL, D.No. 19-1365/A, Srinivasapuram, Tiruchanoor Road, Tirupathi - 517 503.
3. Senior Account Officer, Circle Office, APSPDCL, 4/7, Brodipet, Guntur.
...Respondents
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008, 17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009 and
23906 of 2010
The Court made the following COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri K. Gopal Choudary, learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners
appearing online in (W.P.Nos.17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009)
assisted by Sri Sk. Md. Umar Abdullah, learned Counsel, Sri Venkata Rama
Rao Kota, learned Standing Counsel for APSPDCL and Sri V.V. Satish,
learned Standing Counsel appearing for APEPDCL.
2.
This batch of Writ Petitions bearing W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008,
17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009 and 23906 of 2010 are being
disposed of by this Common Order, inasmuch as these Writ Petitions involve
similar issues.
3.
For the convenience, the facts mentioned in W.P.No.17653 of
2009 are referred to in this Common Order.
4.
The prayer sought in W.P.No.17653 of 2009 is as under:
(a) declaring that the Respondents are not entitled to
keep the generated in, or remained unutilized/
unallocated energy as at the end of, December of 2006
2007 and 2008 and/or thereafter in abeyance or treat
the same as lapsed; and
(b) declaring that the Andhra Pradesh Electricity
Regulatory Commission (Interim Balancing & Settlement
Code) Regulation, 2006 (2 of 2006) is not applicable to
the Petitioner; and
(c) directing the Respondents to implement and
continue to allow the facility of banking of electricity and
the wheeling of electricity generated and banked
electricity in accordance with the Power Wheeling &
Purchase Agreement dated 3.9.1998 as amended on
19.1.2005; and
(d) directing the Respondents to wheel in subsequent
months and notwithstanding any limitation in the
agreement of the period for wheeling of banked energy,
and to thereby enable the Petitioner to sell so much of
the banked energy which was kept in abeyance and/or
treated as lapsed as remains in balance and unsold in
the meanwhile by the Petitioner;
(e) and or pass such further or other orders as this
Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper so that justice
may be done.”
5.
At the very outset, it is indicated that the issues involved in the
present Writ Petition are squarely covered by the Judgment of the learned
Single Judge of this Court in Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation and Ors. v. Central Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Ltd., and Ors (in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 dated 14.05.2008) :
MANU/AP/0442/2008. Therefore, the issues involved in this batch of Writ
Petitions are no more Res integra.
6.
The facts stated in W.P.No.17653 of 2009 are to the effect that
the Government of Andhra Pradesh has issued G.O.Ms.No.93, ENERGY
(RES) DEPARTMENT, dated 18.11.1997 (Ex.P.1) with a view to encourage
generation of electricity from renewable sources of energy provided with such
incentives that are uniform to all projects based on renewable sources of
energy; that the Writ Petitioner (in W.P.No.17653 of 2009) entered into a
Power Wheeling and Purchase Agreement dated 03.09.1998 (subsequently
amended on 19.01.2005) with the erstwhile Andhra Pradesh State Electricity
Board (APSEB) (Ex.P.2); that the A.P Electricity Reforms Act came into force
on 01.02.1999; therefore, by virtue of the Reforms Act coming into force, all
the rights and obligations of APSEB stood vested by operation of law in the
A.P Transmission Corporation (APTRANSCO); that the Electricity Act, 2003
was enacted by the Parliament, which came into force on 10.06.2003.
7. It is further submitted by the learned Counsel for Writ Petitioner that
the State Government had notified the Third Transfer Scheme, whereby, all
the obligations of APTRANSCO to purchase unallocated energy from the nonconventional energy stations stood allocated and transferred by operation of
law to the various DISCOMs.
Consequently, the functions of banking of
energy and purchase of surplus energy in respect of the Writ Petitioner’s mini
hydro power plant that was vested with the APTRANSCO has now stood
transferred and vested with the Southern Power Distribution Company Limited
(Respondent No.1); that on 01.07.2005, the APERC (Terms and Conditions of
Open Access) Regulation, 2005 for phased introduction of open access in
terms of Section 42 (2) of the Electricity Act, 2003 came into effect on
01.07.2005; and that APERC (Interim Balancing and Settlement Code)
Regulation, 2007 (2 of 2006) applicable for Open Access transactions comes
into force with effect from 01.12.2006.
8. It is further submitted that Respondent No.1 addressed a Letter
expressing his desire to purchase the surplus energy at Rs.2.41 per unit
subject to acceptance by the Writ Petitioner of the said rate. The said Letter
dated 23.11.2006 had also indicated that, if the rate is unacceptable to the
Writ Petitioner, the Writ Petitioner was advised to bank the surplus energy and
the surplus energy already delivered to the network of Respondent No.1 from
October 2006 may be banked; that there was correspondence between the
Writ Petitioner and the Respondent No.1. Writ Petitioner has addressed a
Letter to the Energy Billing Centre as regards the surplus energy offer and that
some part of the aggregated energy was not shown to the Writ Petitioner’s
banked energy account.
9. It is further submitted that vide Letter dated 07.02.2007, the
Respondent No.1 has reiterated that it would purchase only at the rate of
Rs.2.17 per unit, thereby, deviating from its earlier offer to purchase the
energy at Rs.2.41 per unit, since the issue of rate per unit was reviewed on
16.01.2007.
On 13.06.2007, the Writ Petitioner herein addressed a Letter to
the Respondent No.1 that Regulation 2 of 2006 was not applicable to the Writ
Petitioner. While the Respondent No.1 continuously reiterated the application
of Regulation 2 of 2006 vide Letter dated 10.10.2007 and had kept the
unutilized energy during the December, 2006 in abeyance for want of
clarification from APERC, vide Proceeding dated 12.03.2008, the Respondent
No.1 has informed that the energy remaining unutilized upto the end of
December, 2007 had lapsed, and therefore, the request for billing of the
banked energy during the months of January, 2008 was impermissible in
terms of Regulation 2 of 2006.
10. Having been aggrieved of these conditions, the Writ Petitioner
approached this Hon’ble Court by filing W.P.No.17653 of 2009 seeking
declaration that the Respondents are not entitled to keep the generated in or
remained unutilized/unallocated energy as at the end of December of 2006,
2007 and 2008 and or thereafter in abeyance or treat the same as lapsed with
a further declaration that Regulation 2 of 2006 does not apply to the Writ
Petitioner with a further direction to implement and continue to allow facility of
banking of electricity and the wheeling of electricity generated and banked
electricity in accordance with the Power Wheeling and Purchase Agreement
dated 03.09.1998 as amended on 19.01.2005.
The Writ Petitioner also
sought a direction to the Respondents to wheel in subsequent months,
notwithstanding any limitation in the agreement for the period for wheeling of
banked energy; and, to thereby enable the Writ Petitioner to sell so much of
the banked energy which was kept in abeyance and or treated as lapsed as
remains in balance and unsold in the meanwhile by the Writ Petitioner.
11. While these issues were pending, learned Single Judge of this
Hon’ble Court had dealt with the similar issues in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 and
rendered a Judgment on 14.05.2008. Learned Single Judge had held that on
careful consideration of the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003 and the
settled legal position, the Court is of the considered view that the Agreements
held by the Writ Petitioners, not being inconsistent with the provisions of the
Electricity Act, 2003 are saved by the provisions of Sub-section (2) and (5) of
Section 185 of the Electricity Act, 2003. The learned Single Judge had also
held that Regulation 2 of 2006 would not have any bearing on the rights of the
Writ Petitioners therein under the existing Agreements. It is also held that
even if the Respondents are implementing the Regulation 2 of 2006 in toto, for
the reasons mentioned in the said Judgment, Regulation 2 of 2006 cannot be
enforced against the Writ Petitioners therein. The learned Single Judge had
further held in Para No.32 of the said Judgment as under:
“The learned counsel for the petitioners contended that even
if Clause 12.1 of Regulation 2 of 2006 along with Appendix-3
is made applicable to the petitioners’ cases, they are entitled
to draw the unutilized energy banked by them during the six
months period from July to December of the year preceding
the year in which the energy was banked.
From the definition of “Banking”, which was reproduced
supra, it is quite clear that its very purpose is to keep the
excess energy generated by the generating companies in
reserve, to be utilized at a later point of time, subject,
however, to the conditions contained in the agreement.
Under the amended clauses contained in the Agreements,
the generating companies, which banked the energy, are
entitled to utilize the same from August to March of
succeeding year in respect of third party sales and from
August to July, which is ca led Energy Year, of the
succeeding year. Thus, a clear intention is manifested from
these clauses that the generating companies are entitled to
keep the energy generated by them in reserve for being
utilized in future period, which shall not be beyond the
periods stipulated in the above mentioned clause.”
12. The above extract would squarely indicate that under the amended
Clause contained in the Agreement, the generating companies, which banked
the energy, are entitled to utilize the same from August to March of
succeeding year in respect of third party sales and from August to July, which
is called Energy Year, of the succeeding year. The above extract would also
indicate that the generating companies are entitled to keep the energy
generated by them in reserve for being utilized in future period, which shall not
be beyond the periods stipulated in the Clause of the Agreement.
13. It is also further submitted that following the Order passed by the
learned Single Judge in the case of Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation and Ors. v. Central Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Ltd., and Ors in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 dated 14.05.2008, several
other Writ Petitions came to be also disposed of in terms of the said Order.
The Central Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh had preferred
Writ Appeal bearing W.P.No.1293 of 2008. The Division Bench of this Hon’ble
Court vide Order dated 17.07.2025 was pleased to dismiss the Writ Appeal
since the Applicant therein has filed only against one Judgment while the
batch of cases have been decided by the learned Single Judge. Therefore,
the W.A.No.1293 of 2008 has been dismissed as being not maintainable.
14. Sri Gopal Chowdary, learned Counsel appearing for the Writ
Petitioners would submit that the Order of the learned Single Judge dated
14.05.2008 in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 had attained finality due to the dismissal
of W.A.No.1293 of 2008 by the Division Bench of this Hon’ble Court on
17.07.2025, and therefore, the Order of the learned Single Judge has attained
finality and the same would apply to the facts of the cases in the present batch
of Writ Petitions.
15. Sri V.V. Satish, learned Standing Counsel appearing for APEPDCL
would also confirm this position that the present cases are squarely covered
by the Judgment of learned Single Judge in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 dated
14.05.2008.
16. Having recorded the same, this Court deems it appropriate to allow
these Writ Petitions in terms of the Order passed by the learned Single Judge
in W.P.No.15313 of 2007 dated 14.05.2008. Accordingly, this batch of Writ
Petitions is allowed. No Order as to Costs.
17. Interlocutory Applications, if any, stand closed in terms of this order.
______________________________________
GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD, J
Dt:17.04.2026
JKS
L.R Copy to be marked.
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD
W.P.Nos.12361 of 2008, 17653, 18553, 18554, 18555 & 18556 of 2009 and
23906 of 2010
Dt: 17.04.2026
JKS
L.R Copy to be marked
B/O : JKS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review