Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3304 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction) .
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU
RAJESHWAR FIAO
WRIT PETITI Ohl NO: 380 04 0F 2014
Between:
Singireddy Venkat Reddv,,
_Chilka Reddy, Aged about 44 years,
Occ - Agricutture, R/o. ff-fifo.f.SJo.
-gZ, eog;iu, Vffr[",'r<"".rra Mandat, Ranga
Reddy district.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State- of Telangana, Revenue Department,, Rep. by its principal
Secretary, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The Joint Collector-|, Ranga Reddy District, Ranga Reddy., _
The Sp_ecial_Grade Deputy coilector & Revenue Divisionar, officer,
Ranga
Reddy East Division, Ranga Reddy district.
4 The Thasildar, Keesara Mandal, Ranga Reddy District., _
Alwal Laxmaiah, S/o. Venkaiah,.fOed about 65 years, Ryo.
Bogaram Village,
Keesara Mandal, Ranga Reddy disirict.
ti. Alwal Kashaiah,, S/o. Venkaian,.nOgO about
54 years, Rl/o. Bogaram Village,
Keesara Mandal, Ranga Reddy disirict.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Articre 226 of the constitution of rndia praying
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High
that in the
court may be preased
to lssue a direction, order or writ more particurarry one in the nature of Writ
Mandamus decraring the action of the Respondent No.2 in passing
of
the order in case
No.D51762512008, vide order dated 11.11.2014, allowing
the revision petition
filed by
the Respondent Nos.5and6 and setting aside the order passed by the 3rd
Respondent in File No.A2l1608/1999, dated 1g.4.2006, as well
as the order passed
by the Respondent No.4 in fite No.B/2303/1996, dated 26 10.1996, as arbitrary,
illegal, contrary to settled principles of law and arso contrary to A.p. Rights in
Land
and Pattedar Pass Books Act, 1g71 and the Rules made there under, as applicable
to the state of relangana , and as also being in violation of Article 14 and 300-4
of
the constitution of lndia, and consequenfly set aside the order dated .l .1 ..1 i.2014
in
Case No.D5/762512O08 passed bythe Respondent No.2.
t.A. NO: 1 0F 2014(WP JI/IP. NO 1 47544 OF 201 4
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pteased
order passed by the Respondent No.2, vide Case No
the
suspend the
D51762512008, dated
11.11 .2014, pending disposal of the above writ petition.
t.A. NO: 1 0F 201s{ WPMP. NO: 1376 OF 201 5 )
Petition uncer Section 1s'1 cpc praying that in the circLrmstances stated
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased
to extend the
interim orders dated 10.12.2014 passed in wp.No.3gO04 of 2014 untir
Orders.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI GADDAM SRINIVAS
Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.1 to 4: Gp FOR REVENUE (TG)
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.S and 6:-The Court made the following: ORDER
in the
further
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
ITYDERABAD
I,
THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE NAMA.VARAPU RT"'ESHWAR RAO
Date : a1 ' o 6- a,o)+'
WRIT PETITION No.38OO4 of 2OL4
Between:
Singireddy Venkat Reddy.
.. Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana and others.
Respondents
ORDER:
This writ petition is frled aggrieved by the order dated
11.11.2014 passed by the 2nd respondent in
Case
No.E5/7625/2oo8
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner's father purchased land admeasuring
Ac.1.3O guntas in Sy.No.113, situated at Bogaram Village,
Keesara Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, through
Ar1
unregistered Sale Deed executed by Alwal Venkaiah, and
since then, they have been in possession and enjoyment of
the said property. The petitioner's father filed an application
under the Record of Rights Act (ROR Act) seeking
regularization of the unregistered Sale Deed. The unofficial
respondents filed their objections. After following the
procedure contemplated under the ROR Act, Respondent No.4
regularized the unregistered Sale Deed. Aggrieved thereby, the
unofficial respondents preferred an appeal before Respondent
No.3, which was dismissed on 18.04.2006, granting liberty to
the appellants therein to resolve their dispute before the
competent Civil Court.
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner further
submits that, after a lapse of 2/z years, the unofficial
respondents filed a revision petition before Respondent No.2
without filing any application seeking condonation of delay,
contending that the subject land was alceslra-l property.
Without properly verifying the material availabte on record,
Respondent No.2 set aside the orders passed bv Respondent
Nos.3 and 4.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitroner further
submits that the unofficial respondents did not file any
document to establish that the subject properlv rvas a:rcestral
property and, therefore, failed to substantiate their claim in
that regard.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner further
submits that, in the impugned order, Respondent No.2
observed that Respondent No.4 had passed the order dated
26.1O.1996 without issuing notice to the revision petitioners
and without examining the witnesses. However, Respondent
No.4 had, in fact, issued notices to the aJlected parties,
namely, Respondent Nos.S and 6, who filed their objections.
Apart from that, Respondent No.4 had also examined the
witnesses before passing the order. Therefore, Respondent
No.2 ought to have dismissed the revision petition on the
ground of limitation itself. Hence, it is prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to set aside the impug:ned order
and allow the writ petition.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos.S and 6
has frled a counter-affidavit stating that the father of
Respondent Nos.S and 6 was the absolute owner ald
possessor of land admeasuring Ac. 1.11 guntas in Sy.No.113
of Bogaram Village. After his death, Respondent Nos.S and 6,
being his legal heirs, have been in possession and enjoyment
of the said land and have been cultivating the same without
any interference.
7.
karned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos.5 and 6
further submits that the petitioner herein, who had no
connection whatsoever with the said land, filed O.S, No.72 of
1983 before the Court of the District Munsiff, Medchal, Ranga
Reddy District, seeking declaration of title and perpetual
injunction in respect of Ac. 1.30 guntas in Sy.No.1 13 and the
said suit was dismissed by order dated 13.02.1992. The said
judgment was not challenged on appeal and, therefore,
attained finality. Consequently, the petitioner has no right,
title, or interest in the suit land, having failed to establish titie
thereto
8.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.S and 6
further submits that the petitioner, suppressing material
facts, submitted an application before the Mandal Revenue
Officer (MRO) seeking mutation under the provisions of the
A.P. Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971
However, without issuing any notice to the respondents, the
MRO passed proceedings dated 12.02.1999 gllowing the
petitioner's claim for mutation. The said order was never
communicated to the unoffrcial respondents and was passed
behind their back.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.5 and 6
further submits that challenging the order dated 12.02.1999,
the unofficial respondents filed an appea-l before the RDO and
the RDO dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved thereby, the
unofficial respondents preferred a revision before the 2"d
respondent, who upon due appreciation of the facts, evidence,
and material available on record, set aside the orders passed
by the RDO as well as the MRO on the ground that they were
devoid of merit and contrar5r to the provisions of Section 5-A
of the A.P. Rights in Land ald Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971
arrd Rule 22 of the Rules, 1989 framed thereunder and
consequently, allowed the revision
10.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.S and 6
further submits that the 2"d respondent passed a wellreasoned order after duly considering the material on record
and the applicable legal provisions. Therefore, the said order
1S
legal, valid, and justifred ald does not warrant any
interference by this Court. Therefore, the r,r,rit petition 1S
devoid of merit and liable to be dismissed
11.
Heard both sides and perused the record
12. In the present case, the 4th respondent passed the
order dated 26.1O.1996 by observing as follou's :"IVotices in Form No.ll and 12 haue been issued to the
concerned as required under the Act. In response to the notices
rssued Sri Alu.tala Laxrnaiah and Alu.tala Kosaiah haue filed on
objection petition stating that afier the death of lheir father the
unregi.stered document stated to be executed bg his father Lote.
Sn. A. Venkaiah is created bg Sn. S. Chilkareddy u,tith forged
signature, and theg neuer sold tlrc land to the patitioner, but his
fatlrcr giuen to the petitioner's father on leose for graztng
purpose and requested not to regulaise the aboue document.
On the request of the Respondents a chance of heaing
tuas giuen to both the parties. Case heard on 7-9-9t; and 26 1O-
96. Heard the arguments of both the parties and perused the
reuenue records. As per reuenue records, petitioner's name u)as
recorded as occupant ouer the Sg.No.113 ert. Ac 1-!lA @s. since
the date of purchase. The Respondents foiled to proue the
auerments made in their objedion petition ond they could not
conuince the court houl the petitioner came into posihon of [and.
In uieu of the aboue, I come to conclusion that the
document executed bg late A.Venkaiah is genuine. As such I
order for regulorization of unregistered doanment executed bg
late Si.A. Venkaiah in fauour of S. Chilka Reddg, Under Section
5-A of the Act.'
13.
I
Thereafter, the 4tt' respondent passed an order dated
l2.O2.lggg mutating the name of the petitioner and his
father in the revenue records in respect of the land in
question. Aggrieved by the same, the unofficial respondents
filed an appeal before the 3'd respondent, and the same was
dismissed on 18.04.2006 by observing as follows :Afier heaing the arguments of the appellant and
perusal of counter affidouit filed by th-e respondents the court
doth tle order os under.
"
The main issue inuolued in the co,se is ualiditg of sale
transaction uhich took place behteen father of appellants ond
respond.ents on 11-5-74. Another issue in possession of the suit
land. The appellants and the respondents stating that the land
is in their possession. According to the reuerlue records the land
is in the possession of respondents and the ciuil suit filed bg
them agoinst the oppellants uos dismissed in default Either
this court or tlte lotuer court is not the proper fonlm to test the
uatiditg of the sa:le transoction u.thich took place on 11-5-74'
According to sub section (2) of Section 8 of A.P ROR in Land ond
Pattadar Pass Books Act 197 1 , if ang person is aggrieued as to
ang nght of uhich he is in posses sion bg an entry made in ang
record of ight he moA institute a suit against anA person
denying or interested to deng his title to such ight for
declaration of Hs right under Chapter (6) of the specific relief Act
1963.
I
In uiew of the legal position noted aboue the appeol i-s
dismissed uith an aduise to the appeLlants to settld their case in
ciuil court.'
14.
Aggrieved by the szrme, respondent Nos.S and 6
filed a revision before the 2"d respondent, and the same was
allowed on 11.1 l.2ol4 by obserrring as follows :
The RDO ought to haue seen that the aboue prouision
of Sec.8 (2) applies to the respondents before tL.e Appellate
Authoitg. In the impugned order the RDO him.self leld that
according to reuenue records the land is in posse.ssion of the
respondents and the ciuil suit filed bg them zgainst the
appellants utas dismbsed in defoult- So in accordantce u.tith the
aboue prouisions, the oppellate authoitg should houe aduised
the respondents therein to approach ciuil court ano settle their
case os the names of the respondents are recordec' in reuenue
records in possession column of the pahani and the appellonts
are denging it. Alreadg the respondents Lnd filec!. a sui/ OS
No.72/ 88 before the Dbt. Mun sif, Medchal o.gainst the
appel[ants and the same Loas dismissed. Taking ail the aboue
things into consideration it uLas for the appellate out.\oitA to set
aside the orders of he MRO, Keesara possed in file
No.B/2303/1996, dated: 12.02.1999 in uthich tlTe alleged
unregistered transaction sole bosing on a receipt dated:
11.05.1974 utas regularized for an ertent of Ac.l.3ogts in
Sg.No.Ji3 u.there os the said receipt sags the extent as
Ac.2.OO gts.
In the light of aboue obsentations I do not hesitate to
set aside the impugned order passed bg the RDO, R.R.East
Duision in ftle No.A2/ 1608/ 1999, dated: 18.04.200(i os tuell a-s
the orders of the MRO Keesara passed in file No'B/2303/96'
dated-: 12.02.1999 being deuoid of meits contrasg to the
proui.sions made U/ 5.5-A of the A'P. Rights in I'and ond
Pattedar Pass Books Act, 1971 and Rule-22 of the Rules, 1989
framed theretuith- In the result the reuision is alloued'
Section 5-A of the ROR Act reads as follows :1) NottDith.standing ongthing contained in this Act, the Transfer
of Propertg Act. 1882, the Registration Act, 1908 or any other
latu for the time being in force, [uhereo,s person is an ocd)pant]
bg uirtue of on alienation or trantsfer made or effected otheruise
than bg regi.stered document, the alienee or the transferee mag'
uitltin such peiod as mag be prescibed, applA to the Mondal
Reuenue OJficer for a certificate declaing that such alienation or
transfer is ualid.
2) On receipt of such application, the MRO sLall, afier making
such enquiry as maA be prescribed, require the alienee or the
transferee to deposit in the office of the MRO an amount equal to
tlLe registration fees and the stamp duty that tuould haue been
pagoble had the alienation. or transfer be effected bg a
registered- dncument in accordance with the proubion's of the
Registration Act, 1908, as fixed bg the registeing officer on a
reference mad.e to him bg the MRO on the basis of the ualue of
the propertA arriued at in such monner os mag be prescibed'
16. In the instant case, the petitioner filed an application
under Section 5-A of the ROR Act before the 4ft respondent'
stating that he had purchased the land in question and
requesting regularization of the sale transaction dated
11.05.1974, which took place between respondent No.2 and
the father of the appellants. Pursuant thereto, the 4th
respondent conducted an enquiry into the matter and issued
certificates in Forms 13-B and 13-C in favour of the petitioner
vide proceedings dated L2.O2.1999. Aggrieved by the same,
the unofficial respondents preferred an appeal before the
appellate authority, which dismissed the appeal with an
observation that the parties should work out their remedies
before the competent Civil Court.
.
After dismissal of the appeal, the respondent Nos.S and
6 neither approached the Civil Court nor closecl the litigation
Instead, after waiting for about two and a half years, they filed
a revision petition before the 2"d respondent. In the revision
proceedings, based solely on the averments made by the
revision petitioners, the 2.d respondent allowed the revision
setting aside the orders that had been passed in favour of the
petitioner.
18.
Once concurrent findings were recorded by both the
respondent authorities, the revisional authority ought to have
advised the parties to approach the competent Civil Court.
it simply
Instead, u,ithout doing so,
passed bY resPondent Nos'3
lg .
set aside the orders
and 4'
unofficial
The main contention of the
was
and 6 is that the subject land
unofficial respondents did
respondents 5
ancestral property' The
not file any document to establish
property and'
ancestral
that the subject property was
their claim in that regard'
therefore, failed to substantiate
oPPortunitles to
aJforded
resPondent
Otn
20. ,n"
that
to substantiate their claim
twice
resPondents
unofficiai
However, on both
the
the ProPerty is ancestral ProPerty'
produce any evidence in
to
failed
they
occasions,
the revenue
their contention' Furtheflnore'
has
that the petitioner's name
support of
records disclose
been recorded as the occupant
ofanextentofAc'1'3Ogts'inSy'No'l13'sincethedateof
purchase. According to
the resPondents, the
records are
transaction ald the revenue
is so'
created documents' If that
fabricated and
the unofficial respondents
the competent
ought to have approached
against
sought appropriate relief
entlre
Civil Court and
the petitioner herein'
In the present case, on 10.12.2014, this
rssulng notice before admission granted
status-quo obtaining
as on that day with regard to possession
dispute be maintained by both the
the same was not extended from
22.
2".1 respondent. The parties
o
t the land in
parties till .si_x weeks and
time to time.
In view of the foregoing discussion,
disposed of by setting aside the
Court while
this r.r.rit petition is
impugned order passed by the
are at liberty to seek appropriate
relief with regard to the entries
in the revenue rr:cords before
the competent Civil Court. It is
made clear that, in the event
the parties approach the trial
Court, the tnal court shall
entertain the matter without
ralstng any objection regarding
delay. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if
any, shall stand closed.
//TRUE COPY//
SD/. A.H.S.GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
\
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, The State of Telangana,
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Joint Collector-I, Ranga Reddy
,uTION OFFICER
Revenue Department,,
District, Ranga Reddy., -
3. The Special Grade Deputy Collector &
Re,,,enue Divjsional, Officer, Ranga
Reddy East Division, Ranga Reddy
distrjct.
4. The Thasildar, Keesara tt/andal, Ranga Reddy
District.
5. One CC to Sri Gaddam Srinivas, Advocate
tOpUCl
6. Two CCs to the Gp for Revenue, Hign Court
fo. tn" St"te of Telangana, at
Hyderabad[OUT]
7. One CC to P Sridhar Reddy, Advocate(OPUC)
8. One CC to K Krishna Reddy, Advocate(OPUC)
9. Two CD Copies
TJ
TKS
I
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 2310612026
1Y\
\- S 1,6
fF o
t,-.
JtlL 2020
\,,->
ORDER
WP.No.38004 of 2014
\,2
'.r../.,
\'. * -' .:\:
\.-]-.
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
0l
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review