Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
$
#
% & % '
*
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"
#
"
$
"
()
&%
(
-2-
%
"
!
"
"
%
$
"
"
!
"
!
"
#
"
"
#
%
!
"
-3-
$
%
"
$
"
!
!
!
"
#
%
%
"
"
!
"
$
$
"
!
-4-
""
%
!
"
#
"
#
"
"
%
!
$
"
!
!
&
"
* %
'
()
$
+
,
"
-
"
.
-5-
(
"
()
(
* %
$
"
((
()
' ()
"
* %
((
$
+
,
"
"
,
%
(
,
$
,
$
(
.
"
.
(
, .
(
()
!
(
#$
#
(
(
(
,
)
%%
, .
(
%
-.
$ *$%* $
, .
/
.
(
(
(
%
$
(
"
((
-
!
(
-6-
23& 45636378 3& 93:5; <8;5=
?A?=3B
<=?B&2?
;?65;
$
$%
%
$
=5A3&65=5; E@
<8;5=
7;5
?8236?
$
5>6378
$
5>6378&
6?B38A
>7A83C?8>5
=3D5
$
!
#$
#
= G
! 79
?=8?6?B?
&27=6 1 43;5D3>
<;A5 , =
3&5?&5&
8 . ?8;
$
8;3?8
% $ ,97= &27=6 25=538?965= =595==5; 67 ?& 1
, . 79
7:3>5 97= 625 79958>5& 4<83&2?E:5
?:&7 97= 625 79958>5& 4<83&2?E:5 <8;5=
?8;
2?=?63@?
67 &56 ?&3;5 625 7=;5=
?=3&38A 7<6 79
5F77=
% 79
(
43;5D3>
5>6378&
3&5?&5&
>6
58?:
1. ?8;
, .
, .
$ $ ,97=
>61. 458;38A 78 625 93:5 79
3F3:
9C?:4<=
25 >?&5 79 625 4=7&5><6378 3& 62?6 ? >7D4:?386
G?& :7;A5; E@ 785
23F?&2?8B?=
993>5= ?::5A38A 62?6 38 &4365 79
&&3&6?86
7=63><:6<=5
7F5=8D586 7=;5= 876 67
>78;<>6 ?8@ ?6=? 7= (5&63F?:& 625 456363785=& 25=538 ?8;
7625=& G3627<6 7E6?3838A 45=D3&&378 9=7D 625
7F5=8D586
2?F5
6?B38A
>78;<>65;
4=5>?<6378?=@
?6=?
D5?&<=5&
?8;
G3627<6
97::7G38A
?8@
A<3;5:385&
-7-
3&&<5; E@ 625
4?8;5D3>
7F5=8D586 G362 =5A?=; 67
85A:3A586:@
?8;
386586378?::@
>78;<>65; 625 ?6=? E@ ;3&7E5@38A 625
25=597=5
?
?8; 625=5?965=
$
$
>?&5
>?D5
625@
2?F5
7F5=8D586 7=;5=
E5 =5A3&65=5;
7F3;* !
=3D5
7:3>5 38F5&63A?65; 625
D?665= ?8; 93:5; 625 >2?=A5 &2556 97= 625 ?97=5D5863785;
79958>5& ?A?38&6 625&5 456363785=& ?8; 7625=& E@ ?==?@38A
625&5 456363785=& ?& ?>><&5;
! 67
#
%
625 :5?=85;
7&
$
%
#
% 67
>>7=;38A:@
?A3&6=?65 677B >7A83C?8>5 79 625 79958>5&
AA=35F5; E@ 625 &?D5
625 456363785=& 2?F5 93:5; 623&
45636378
5?=;
=3
?F38;=?
>7<8&5: 97= 625 456363785=& ?8;
:5?=85;
3A2
6?65
7<=6
7F5=8D586
?E?:5&2G?=
=3
74?:
:5?=85;
=3&28?
?;?F
:5?;5= 97= =5&478;586
27<A2 8763>5 3& &5=F5; 67 =5&478;586
25 =5D?385; ?E&586
5?=85; >7<8&5: 97= 625 456363785=& ?=A<5; 62?6
=3?:
7<=6 2?& 876 ?44=5>3?65; 625 ;7><D586& ?8;
-8-
7625= D?65=3?:& 78 =5>7=;
:3F5:3277;
25 456363785=& 67 5B5 7<6 6253=
625@ ;7 4566@ >77:35 G7=B& ?8; 625=5 3& 87
D586378 38 625 >7D4:?386 ?& 67 G2?6 3& 625 4?=63><:?= =7:5
7= ?>6 79 625&5 456363785=& 38 625 &?3;
?6=?
7:3>5
G3627<6 >78;<>638A 625 4=745= 38F5&63A?6378 2?F5 &3D4:@
3D4:3>?65; ?:: 625 F3::?A5=& ?& ?>><&5;
25 456363785=&
853625= 2?F5 ?8@ >7DD36655 87= 625=5 3& ?8@
5D4:5
>7DD36655 67 45=97=D
* 7:3>5
?6=?
25 =5&478;586
2?F5 876 4=7;<>5; ?8@ >7A586 D?65=3?: 67 &27G 62?6 625
456363785=& 2?F5 F37:?65; 625 >78;36378& 7= 7=;5=& 3&&<5; E@
7F5=8D586 G362 =5A?=; 67
7F3;* ! 4?8;5D3> ?8;
625=5 3& 876238A 78 =5>7=; 67 &27G 62?6 625@ 2?F5 &4=5?;
?8@ 3895>6378 7= >7DD3665; 625 79958>5& ?& ?::5A5;
25=597=5
93:38A 79 >=3D38?: >?&5 ?A?38&6 456363785=& 3&
876238A E<6 ?E<&5 79 4=7>5&& 79
D?65=3?: ?A?38&6 625D
7<=6
25=5 3& 87
58>5 4=?@5; 67 ?::7G 625
45636378
:5?=85;
?::5A5; 79958>5 <8;5=
5>6378
?=A<5; 62?6 625
79 625
43;5D3>
3&5?&5
-9-
>6
?=5 >7A83C?E:5 79958>5
25 &6?65D586 79 625&5
456363785=& ?:78A G362 7625=& >:5?=:@ &27G& 62?6 625@ 2?F5
F37:?65; 625
7F5=8D586 7=;5= ?8; >78;<>65; 625
5 9<=625= &<ED36& 62?6
?6=?
2?F38A =5A?=; 67 4?8;5D3>
&36<?6378 625 ?>><&5; 45=&78& &27<:; 876 2?F5 A?625=5;
67A5625=
97=
7F5=8D586
45=97=D38A
?6=?
F37:?6378
<3;5:385& 3&&<5; 38 =5&45>6 79
625 &?D5 3& 876 45=D3&&3E:5
&4=5?; ;3&5?&5
#$ ?8;
#
= G
?8; >2?=A5 &2556
5>6378
, . ?8; , ., . 79 43;5D3>
! 79
3&5?&5&
25 7=;5= &2556 79 625
625 :5?=85;
7F3;* ! ?8;
58>5 4=?@5; 67 ;3&D3&& 625 45636378
>2?=A5 &2556 3& 93:5; 97= 625 79958>5& <8;5=
#
?& 625 &?D5 3& :3B5:@ 67
2?F5 45=<&5; 625 (
!
(
4<83&2?E:5 <8;5=
=3?:
5>6378&
?8;
%%
5>6378&
>6 $ $
7<=6 38;3>?65& 62?6
677B >7A83C?8>5 78:@ 97= 625 79958>5&
5>6378&
5>6378&
!
#$ ?8;
#
, .
, . ?8;
, . 79
! 79
?8;
3&5?&5&
>6 ?8; 3&&<5; &<DD78&
= G
5>6378
43;5D3>
25=5 ?=5 ?& D?8@ ?&
- 10 -
45=&78& &27G8 ?& ?>><&5;
=5?;& ?& <8;5=0
5>6378&
!
#$ ?8;
#
- 11 -
!
"#$%
"#&%
)
*
+
!
#'%
(
&,&,
"
-
#
!
$
$
#$%
!
.
/
#&% .
!
#'%
#$%
%
25=597=5
#&%
78 45=<&38A 625&5 4=7F3&378&
36 3&
5F3;586 62?6 G275F5= D?:3A8?86:@ ;75& ?8@ ?>6 G23>2 3&
?8; G23>2 25 B87G& 7= 2?& =5?&78& 67 E5:35F5 67 E5 :3B5:@
67 &4=5?; 625 3895>6378 79 ?8@ ;3&5?&5 ;?8A5=7<& 67 :395
&2?:: E5 4<83&25;
!
(
8 45=<&38A 625 &6?65D586 79 G3685&&5& ?8; 625
36 3& 5F3;586 62?6 36 3& 78:@ ? &65=57 6@45 &6?65D586
3& &6?65; 62?6 625
7F5=8D586 2?& 3&&<5; ? >3=><:?= 38 F35G
- 12 -
7F3;* ! 4?8;5D3> 62=7<A2 625
54<6@
7DD3&&3785=
?:?E<=?A3 ;3=5>638A 625 4<E:3> 876 67 A?625= 38 785 4:?>5
?8; 4=723E365; 67 >78;<>6 ?8@ ?6=?
?>><&5; 45=&78& 45=97=D5;
6 3& &6?65; 62?6 625
?6=? 79
?=A?DD?
5F3
65D4:5 ?8; 625@ G5=5 876 G5?=38A D?&B& ?8; D7=5 62?8
$ 67
$ 4574:5 A?625=5; 38 785 4:?>5 ?8; 625=5E@
4=723E365;
7F5=8D586
A<3;5:385&
=5&45>6
?8;
=<:5&
7F3;* !
3&&<5;
E@
4?8;5D3>
&6?65D586& 79 G3685&&5& =5>7=;5; 38 623& =5A?=; ?=5
&65=576@45 ?8; 625=5 3& 87 5F3;58>5 4:?>5; 78 =5>7=; 67
&27G ?8@ 4?=63><:?= ?>6 79 625 ?>><&5;
25=5 3& 87
D?65=3?: 3& 4=7;<>5; 67 &27G ?& 67 G2?6 6@45 79 79958>5&
625&5 456363785=& 2?F5 >7DD3665; ?8; G25625= 625@ 2?F5
6=35; 67 &4=5?; ?8@ 3895>6378 7= 625=5 3& ?8@6238A 78 =5>7=;
67 &27G 62?6 27G D?8@ 45=&78& G5=5 3895>65; E@
7F3;* !
E@ 45=97=D38A ?6=?
$
25 >2?=A5 &2556 ?:&7 ;75& 876 38;3>?65 ?& 67
5H3&658>5
&?3;
?=A?DD?
5F3
65D4:5
>7DD36655 ?8; 36& >78&636<586 D5DE5=& -258 625=5 3& ?
- 13 -
65D4:5 625=5 D<&6 E5 ? >7DD36655 ?8; &7D5 D5DE5=&
?=5 67 E5 625=5 67 :77B ?965= 625 ;?@ 67 ;?@ ?>63F3635& 79
&?3; 65D4:5
25@ 2?F5 67 ;5>3;5 67 45=97=D ?6=?
&27G& 62?6 625 I?6=? G?& >78;<>65; 78
$ 0$$ 4 D
%$
25 (
$
?6
<6 625=5 3& 876238A 78 =5>7=; 67 &27G 62?6 625
I?6=? G?& 45=97=D5; 38 F37:?6378 79 625 =<:5&
6 3& 45=638586 67 8765 62?6 36 3& &6?65; E@ 625
G3685&&5& 38 6253= &6?65D586 62?6 93F5 45=&78& 8?D5:@
3;;?=?D?
<8;?@@?
?&238?62
?:?44?
?8;
?D?>2?8;=? ?=5 625 45=&78& G27 ;5>3;5; 67 45=97=D 625
?6=? ?8; ?6 6253= 38&63A?6378
?>><&5; ?&&5DE:5; 85?=
45=97=D5;
625 456363785=& ?8; 7625=
?=A?DD?
5F3 65D4:5 ?8;
?6=? ?8; >7DD3665; 625 &?3; 79958>5&
&6?65D586& A3F58 E@ ?:: 625 G3685&&5& ?=5 &65=576@45
(=7D 6253= &6?65D586& 876238A 3& 97=62>7D38A ?& 67 G2?6 3&
625 4?=63><:?= ?>6 7= =7:5 7= 625 4?=6 6?B58 E@ 625
456363785=& G23:5 45=97=D38A 625
?6=? 7= G25625= 625@
2?F5 &4=5?; 625 3895>6378 7= ?8@E7;@ 3895>65; E5>?<&5 79
>78;<>638A ?6=?
25 7D83E<& ?8; F?A<5 &6?65D586& ?=5
- 14 -
A3F58 E@ 625 G3685&&5& ?8; &?D5 ;7 876 ?66=?>6 ?8@
38A=5;3586& 79 625
5>6378&
!
#$ ?8;
#
25=5
3& 876238A 78 =5>7=; 67 &27G 62?6 625&5 456363785=&
386586378?::@ 7= <8:?G9<::@ 45=97=D5;
?6=?
67 &4=5?;
7F3;* ! 3895>6378 E@ ?&&5DE:38A 2<A5 4574:5&
58>5
8785 79 625 38A=5;3586& 79 625 ?97=5&?3; 79958>5& ?66=?>6&
?A?38&6 625&5 456363785=&
8 625 ?E&58>5 79 ?8@ D?65=3?: 67 &27G ?8@
4?=63><:?= ?>6 =7:5 79 625&5 456363785=& 38 45=97=D38A ?6=?
?8; &3D4:@ D?B38A 625 ?::5A?6378& ?A?38&6 625D 3& 876
>7==5>6
25=597=5
38 625 ?E&58>5 79 ?8@ D?65=3?: 78
=5>7=; 625 4=7>55;38A& 38363?65; ?A?38&6 625 456363785=& 3&
876238A E<6 ?E<&5 79 4=7>5&& 79
7<=6
25=597=5 38 625
?E&58>5 79 ?8@ 4?=63><:?= 7F5=6 ?>6& 7= ?::5A?6378& 67 &27G
62?6 625&5 456363785=& 38;<:A5
>7DD36638A
?::5A5;
79958>5& E@ ?&&5DE:38A 2<A5 45=&78& ?8; 45=97=D5; ?6=?
?8; 625=5E@ &4=5?; 625 ;3&5?&5 625 4=7>55;38A& ?A?38&6
625D 3& :3?E:5 67 E5 J<?&25;
- 15 -
8;5= 625&5 >3=><D&6?8>5&
625 4=7>55;38A&
?A?38&6 625&5 456363785=& 3& ?E<&5 79 4=7>5&& 79
7<=6
>>7=;38A:@
4=7>55; 67 4?&& 625 97::7G38A0
,?.
25 45636378 3&
%
,E.
25 4=7>55;38A& ?A?38&6 625 456363785=& 38
$
%
$
$
?=3&38A
7<6
=5A3&65=5; E@
5F77=
7:3>5 97=
625 79958>5& 4<83&2?E:5 <8;5=
#$
#
= G
! 79 8;3?8
=3D5
5>6378&
58?:
7;5
1. ?8;
?:&7
<8;5=
97=
79958>5&
4<83&2?E:5
5>6378&
, .
, . ?8;
, . 79
43;5D3>
3&5?&5&
1 43;5D3>
3&5?&5&
3F3: <;A5 , =
>6
$ $
?=8?6?B?
,97=
8 . ?8;
(
9C?:4<= 3&
+)
%
:
70 %
&27=6
>61. 458;38A 78 625 93:5
25=5E@ J<?&25;
% $
,97= &27=6 25=538?965= =595==5; 67 ?& 1
3&6
!
$
$
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review