Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 15.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 09.01.2026
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
SIDDHARTH MAAN
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Kshitiz Gaur and Mr.
Shahid, Advocates.
versus
SEEMA
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Manish Sangwan, Mr.
Vedant Srivastava and Ms.
Tanya Gupta, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
1.
The present Appeal, under Section 19 of the Family Courts
Act, 19841, read with Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 19552,
assails the correctness of the Judgement dated 09.09.20243 passed by
the learned Family Court, South-West, Dwarka, New Delhi4, in
petition bearing HMA No. 761/20235.
FC Act
HMA
Impugned Judgement
Family Court
Divorce petition
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
2.
By way of the Judgement impugned herein, the learned Family
Court has allowed the Petition filed by the Respondent-Wife and,
having found cruelty proved under Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA,
granted a decree of divorce in her favour, thereby dissolving the
marriage between the parties.
BRIEF FACTS:
3.
The facts germane to the institution of the present Appeal are as
follows:
a.
The marriage between the Appellant-Husband and
Respondent-Wife was solemnized on 03.12.2014 at Village
Chhawla, New Delhi, in accordance with Hindu rites and
ceremonies. No child was born out of the said wedlock.
b.
It was the case of the Respondent-Wife that shortly after
the marriage, the Appellant-Husband and her mother-in-law
consistently demanded dowry, and upon failing to deliver on
their demands, they subjected the Respondent-Wife to cruelty.
The Respondent-Wife alleges that as per the demand of the
parents of the Appellant-Husband, her family already paid an
amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- in cash to them, for purchasing a Swift
Car.
c.
The Respondent-Wife further alleged that since the third
day of marriage, the Appellant-Husband and his mother started
demanding a Fortuner Car and Rs. 25,00,000/- as dowry. On
failing to deliver the same, Respondent-Wife alleges that
multiple instances of cruelty and demands for dowry followed.
d.
It was further alleged by the Respondent-Wife that on
06.12.2014, the Appellant-Husband twisted the arm of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
Respondent-Wife on the pretext that she did not know how to
clean utensils. Further, upon complaining of the same to her
mother-in-law, the Respondent-Wife was further subjected to
physical violence by the mother-in-law and other members of the
family stating that since the Respondent-Wife has failed to get a
Fortuner Car and cash, she is not entitled to stay in the house and
further threatened her that owing to her failure to bring the
alleged dowery, they would all wring her neck.
e.
Respondent-Wife further alleged that on 24.12.2014, the
Appellant and his family members locked her in a room for the
entire night without food or water as punishment for not bringing
the demanded dowry of a Fortuner car and Rs. 25,00,000/-.
f.
According to the Respondent-Wife, the Appellant-
Husband was a habitual drinker and would often abuse and beat
the Respondent-Wife under the influence of alcohol. He also
refused cohabitation with her from 24.01.2015 onwards until she
fulfilled their demand for dowry.
g.
Further, on 24.04.2015, the Respondent-Wife alleged that
she was woken up by the Appellant-Husband and his family
members at about 12:00 AM. She was again asked for dowry,
and when the Respondent-Wife expressed her inability to deliver
the same, she alleges that she was beaten up by the AppellantHusband and her in-laws. She suffered serious injuries and was
bleeding from her mouth and nose. The family of the AppellantHusband did not take her to the doctor, and she had to treat
herself.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
h.
Various other events transpired wherein it is stated by the
Respondent-Wife that the Appellant-Husband and his family
physically and verbally abused not only her but her family and
relatives as well.
i.
The Respondent-Wife further stated that on 28.06.2015,
at about 2:45 AM, the Appellant-Husband came back home in a
highly intoxicated state and started beating her for not being able
to get the Fortuner Car and the cash, despite 6 months having
passed. The Respondent-Wife, thereafter, called the police and
the Appellant-Husband was taken to the Police Station6,
Mehrauli, Delhi. The Appellant-Husband started apologising, and
in hopes that the Appellant-Husband would reform himself, the
Respondent-Wife withdrew the complaint.
j.
Thereafter, it was alleged by the Respondent-Wife that
on the very next day, i.e. on 29.06.2015, the Appellant-Husband
and his mother tried to strangle her with a rope. Eventually, FIR
No. 1746/2015 was registered against the Appellant-Husband
and his mother at P.S. Mehrauli, Delhi, under Section 307/34 of
the Indian Penal Code, 18607. The Appellant-Husband was
arrested and was subsequently released on regular bail in or
around August 2015. It is stated by the Respondent-Wife that the
parties have been residing separately since then.
k.
It is further stated by the Respondent-Wife that various
efforts were made by her and her family to amicably settle the
matter, however, the same failed, and ultimately the RespondentWife lodged a complaint before the A.C.P., Women Cell,
PS
IPC
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
Dwarka on 14.07.2015 and thereafter before the Crime Against
Women Cell, Dwarka, Delhi8, which thereafter got converted
into FIR No. 207/2016 under Sections 498A, 406, 323, 34 of the
IPC at P.S. Mehrauli, Delhi.
l.
The Appellant-Husband, on the other hand, alleged that
there was peaceful cohabitation between the parties until
29.06.2015, and the Appellant-Husband and his mother used to
treat the Respondent-Wife with utmost love and respect. That on
29.06.2015, due to temperamental differences with the Appellant
and his mother, the Respondent lodged an FIR at P.S. Mehrauli.
m.
The Appellant-Husband further stated that he had
suffered severe prejudice due to the criminal cases filed by the
Respondent-Wife, including loss of employment as he was
incarcerated for more than a month, and that his inability to
secure future employment was aggravated due to adverse entries
in his character certificate and that the Appellant and his mother
are being falsely implicated in criminal cases after procuring a
false Medico-Legal Certificate (MLC). He contended that these
proceedings were initiated only because the Appellant-Husband
and his family refused to submit to the Respondent-Wife‘s
demands.
n.
The Appellant-Husband further contended that no dowry
was demanded, whether before or after the marriage and those
the allegations were false, exaggerated, and deliberately made to
initiate criminal proceedings and that the Respondent-Wife left
the matrimonial home of her own volition, neither he nor his
CAW Cell
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
family members ever demanded a Fortuner car or ₹25,00,000/- in
cash from the Respondent-Wife or her family.
o.
The Respondent-Wife finally preferred a petition for
dissolution of marriage under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the
HMA on grounds of mental and physical cruelty and desertion on
03.03.2023.
p.
Notice in the aforenoted Divorce Petition was issued on
15.03.2023, and the learned Family Court framed issues vide
Order dated 04.09.2023. The Respondent-Wife tendered her
evidence by way of affidavit on 30.11.2023, and the evidence
affidavit of the Appellant-Husband was filed on 19.04.2024.
q.
The Respondent-Wife was cross-examined by the learned
counsel representing the Appellant before the learned Family
Court on 01.03.2024, while the Appellant-Husband was crossexamined on 19.04.2024.
r.
Thereafter, the Divorce Petition was effectively listed for
final arguments on 02.08.2024, 28.08.2024 and 03.09.2024 and
the learned Family Court passed the Judgement impugned herein
on 09.09.2024, thereby allowing the Divorce Petition on the
ground of physical and mental cruelty and granting a decree of
divorce in favour of the Respondent-Wife, thereby dissolving the
marriage between the parties.
4.
Aggrieved by the Judgement impugned passed by the learned
Family Court, the Appellant-Husband has preferred the present
Appeal before us.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
CONTENTIONS OF THE APPELLANT:
5.
The learned counsel for Appellant would primarily challenge
the Impugned Judgement on the ground that the learned Family Court
has erred in allowing the Divorce Petition of the Respondent-Wife
without there being any evidence led by her to prove that she was
subjected to cruelty.
6.
He would further state that the learned Family Court has,
merely relying upon the bald statements made by the RespondentWife and on assumptions and presumptions, erroneously passed the
impugned Judgement. He would state that although the RespondentWife claims to have been harassed on account of dowry, as also being
assaulted, the same is not corroborated or proved by evidence.
7.
It would also be urged by the learned counsel for the Appellant-
Husband that the Appellant herein was not granted an equal and
significant opportunity to place final arguments either orally or
through written submissions before the learned Family Court.
8.
Lastly, learned counsel for the Appellant would argue that the
learned Family Court has erred in holding that the Appellant-Husband
had inflicted cruelty upon the Respondent-Wife. He would argue that
while the term ―cruelty‖ as used in Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA
cannot be defined in given parameters, there cannot be a
comprehensive definition of ―cruelty‖ within which all kinds of cases
of cruelty can be covered, and each case has to be considered
depending upon its own factual circumstances.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENT:
9.
Per Contra, learned counsel for the Respondent, while
supporting the Impugned Judgement, would state that the present
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
Appeal is merely an attempt to invite a re-appreciation of the evidence
which was meticulously considered by the learned Family Court in the
impugned Judgment, and that no perversity, misreading of evidence or
failure to consider material on record has been demonstrated in the
appeal so as to warrant interference with the well-reasoned decree of
divorce granted in favour of the Respondent-Wife.
10.
Learned counsel for the Respondent would further state that the
argument of the Appellant that the statements made by the
Respondent before the learned Family Court were ‗bald‘ and
‗baseless‘ stands vitiated on the ground that the same were never
challenged in the cross-examination of the Respondent and that the
learned Family Court has rightly observed in the Judgement impugned
that no suggestions were put to the Respondent in denial of her
detailed version of dowry demands, physical assaults, degradation and
attempts on her life.
11.
It would further be submitted that the law is settled that where a
party fails to challenge a material part of the opponent‘s testimony in
cross-examination, such unchallenged testimony is deemed to have
been accepted, and the learned Family Court has correctly relied upon
this principle in the impugned Judgment that the Respondent-Wife‘s
evidence stood admitted by the Appellant herein.
12.
Thereafter, on the ground of not being accorded equal and fair
opportunity to argue, learned counsel for the Respondent would
contend that the same are baseless and misconceived. It would be
contended that the learned counsel for the Appellant, along with the
Appellant, was present on all three dates on which the final arguments
were heard before the learned Family Court. It would therefore be
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
contended that the plea of violation of natural justice is an
afterthought raised only at the appellate stage and deserves outright
rejection.
13.
It would lastly be argued by the learned counsel for the
Respondent that the Appellant, although having made allegations that
the Respondent has falsely implicated him and his family in various
litigations and cases, has failed to prove the same and has not placed
on record even a shred of evidence.
ANALYSIS:
14.
We have carefully considered the submissions advanced on
behalf of both parties, examined the evidence adduced before the
learned Family Court, and meticulously scrutinized the entire record
of the case.
15.
In the Impugned Judgment, the learned Family Court framed
two principal issues for determination, namely:
a.
Whether the Appellant-Husband, after solemnization of
the marriage, has treated the Respondent-Wife with cruelty; and
b.
Whether the Respondent-Wife is entitled for decree of
divorce as claimed?
16.
Upon a detailed consideration of the pleadings and evidence
placed on record, the learned Family Court answered the issue
pertaining to cruelty under Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA in the
affirmative and came to the conclusion that the Appellant-Husband
had subjected the Respondent–Wife to cruelty. Consequently, the
learned Family Court proceeded to grant a decree of divorce on the
ground of cruelty.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
17.
The primary challenge raised by the learned counsel for the
Appellant, while impugning the Judgement of the learned Family
Court, was that the learned Family Court had erred in merely relying
upon the statements of the Respondent-Wife and failed to consider
that no proof of such cruelties had been placed on record.
18.
We find ourselves in disagreement with the Appellant and find
no infirmity in the findings of the learned Family Court, as a perusal
of the record, more specifically the cross-examination of the
Respondent-Wife, which was done by the learned counsel for the
Appellant, wherein not even a single suggestion was put to the
Respondent-Wife in denial of her deposition on material facts and
therefore, the learned Family Court has rightly held that the deposition
of the Respondent-Wife remained unchallenged and uncontroverted.
19.
What is surprising to this Court is that, on a pointed query to the
learned counsel for the Appellant-Husband as to why no suggestions
were put to Respondent-Wife, the learned counsel for the Appellant
stated that it was a deliberate and tactical decision. Clearly, this
constitutes an admission on the part of the Appellant that they have
deliberately eschewed their right to put across their case.
20.
It is trite law that where a party fails to challenge a material part
of the opponent‘s testimony in cross-examination, such unchallenged
testimony is deemed to have been accepted. We are guided by the
judgement of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court in Muddasani Venkata
Narsaiah v. Muddasani Sarojana9, wherein it was held as follows:
“16. In Maroti
Bansi
Teli v. Radhabai [Maroti
Bansi
Teli v. Radhabai, 1943 SCC OnLine MP 128 : AIR 1945 Nag 60] ,
it has been laid down that the matters sworn to by one party in the
pleadings not challenged either in pleadings or cross-examination
(2016) 12 SCC 288
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
by other party must be accepted as fully established. The High
Court of Calcutta in A.E.G. Carapiet v. A.Y. Derderian [A.E.G.
Carapiet v. A.Y. Derderian, 1960 SCC OnLine Cal 44 : AIR 1961
Cal 359] has laid down that the party is obliged to put his case in
cross-examination of witnesses of opposite party. The rule of
putting one's version in cross-examination is one of essential
justice and not merely technical one. A Division Bench of the
Nagpur
High
Court
in Kuwarlal
Amritlal v. Rekhlal
Koduram [Kuwarlal Amritlal v. Rekhlal Koduram, 1949 SCC
OnLine MP 35 : AIR 1950 Nag 83] has laid down that when
attestation is not specifically challenged and witness is not crossexamined regarding details of attestation, it is sufficient for him to
say that the document was attested. If the other side wants to
challenge that statement, it is their duty, quite apart from raising it
in the pleadings, to cross-examine the witness along those lines. A
Division Bench of the Patna High Court in Karnidan
Sarda v. Sailaja Kanta Mitra [Karnidan Sarda v. Sailaja Kanta
Mitra, 1940 SCC OnLine Pat 288 : AIR 1940 Pat 683] has laid
down that it cannot be too strongly emphasised that the system of
administration of justice allows of cross-examination of opposite
party's witnesses for the purpose of testing their evidence, and it
must be assumed that when the witnesses were not tested in that
way, their evidence is to be ordinarily accepted. In the aforesaid
circumstances, the High Court has gravely erred in law in reversing
the findings of the first appellate court as to the factum of
execution of the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff.‖
21.
We are also guided by the judgement of the Apex Court in
Mahavir Singh v. State of Haryana10, wherein it was held that once a
party fails to put a suggestion to the person who would be capable of
furnishing an explanation, the legality or correctness of that fact
thereafter cannot be then challenged. The relevant paragraph of
Mahavir Singh (supra) is herein below:
“16. It is a settled legal proposition that in case the question is not
put to the witness in cross-examination who could furnish
explanation on a particular issue, the correctness or legality of the
said fact/issue could not be raised. (Vide Atluri
Brahmanandam v. Anne Sai Bapuji [(2010) 14 SCC 466 : (2012) 1
SCC (Civ) 644 : AIR 2011 SC 545]
and Laxmibai v. Bhagwantbuva [(2013) 4 SCC 97 : (2013) 2 SCC
(Civ) 480 : AIR 2013 SC 1204] .)‖
(2014) 6 SCC 716
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
22.
In view of the settled law, the unequivocal acceptance on behalf
of the learned counsel for the Appellant and facts and circumstances
of the present case, we find ourselves in complete agreement with the
finding of the learned Family Court that no suggestion was put to the
Respondent-Wife and the tactical error or the informed decision of not
doing so, having culminated into the impugned Judgement, cannot be
now challenged by the Appellant.
23.
Further, the learned counsel for the Appellant has questioned
the correctness of the Impugned Judgment on the ground of violation
of Principles of Natural Justice, however, we find ourselves in
complete agreement with the learned counsel for the Respondent that
the Order sheets of the learned Family Court would clearly indicate
that not only the learned counsel but the Appellant himself was
present before the learned Family Court on all the three dates on
which the matter was kept for final hearing. Therefore, we find no
merit in the ground raised by the Appellant that the learned Family
Court has passed the Judgement impugned in violation of Principles
of Natural Justice.
24.
Coming on to the aspect of ―cruelty‖, this Court is mindful of
the numerous precedents wherein the Hon‘ble Supreme Court has
succinctly crystallised the law as respects cruelty in matrimonial
relationships.
25.
In Ravi Kumar v. Julmidevi11, the Apex Court emphasized that
cruelty cannot be precisely defined and must be judged according to
the facts and circumstances of each case. It encompasses the absence
of mutual respect and understanding, may manifest as violence,
(2010) 4 SCC 476.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
neglect, attitudes, gestures, words, or even silence, and the categories
of cruelty are never closed. The nature of cruelty may be subtle or
severe, and judicial assessment must consider the cumulative effect of
conduct on the marital relationship. The relevant paragraphs of the
said judgment are reproduced herein below:
―19. It may be true that there is no definition of cruelty under the
said Act. Actually such a definition is not possible. In matrimonial
relationship, cruelty would obviously mean absence of mutual
respect and understanding between the spouses which embitters the
relationship and often leads to various outbursts of behaviour
which can be termed as cruelty. Sometimes cruelty in a
matrimonial relationship may take the form of violence, sometimes
it may take a different form. At times, it may be just an attitude or
an approach. Silence in some situations may amount to cruelty.
20. Therefore, cruelty in matrimonial behaviour defies any
definition and its categories can never be closed. Whether the
husband is cruel to his wife or the wife is cruel to her husband has
to be ascertained and judged by taking into account the entire facts
and circumstances of the given case and not by any predetermined
rigid formula. Cruelty in matrimonial cases can be of infinite
variety—it may be subtle or even brutal and may be by gestures
and words. That possibly explains why Lord Denning
in Sheldon v. Sheldon [Sheldon v. Sheldon, 1966 P 62: (1966) 2
WLR 993 (CA)] held that categories of cruelty in matrimonial
cases are never closed.‖
(emphasis supplied)
26.
Further, in Roopa Soni v. Kamalnarayan Soni12, the Hon‘ble
Supreme Court held that ―cruelty‖ under Section 13(1)(ia) of the
HMA, has no fixed meaning, granting wide discretion to courts to
apply the concept liberally and contextually. What constitutes cruelty
in one case may not in another, and it must be assessed with reference
to the individual circumstances of the parties and the totality of their
matrimonial life. The relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced
herein below:
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1127.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
― 5. The word ―cruelty‖ u/s 13(1)(ia) of the 1955 Act has got no
fixed meaning, and therefore, gives a very wide discretion to the
Court to apply it liberally and contextually. What is cruelty in one
case may not be the same for another. As stated, it has to be
applied from person to person while taking note of the attending
circumstances.‖
(emphasis supplied)
27.
Having regard to the judgements referred to above, and having
carefully scrutinized the impugned Judgement, we find no infirmity in
the legal principles applied by the learned Family Court and the
findings arrived at thereupon.
28.
We also note that, having taken the ground that the Respondent
has not placed on record any evidence to prove cruelty, the Appellant
himself has also not placed on record single evidence to support his
contention of false implications in various criminal proceedings. It is,
however, to be noted that the Respondent‘s allegations of physical and
mental assault are supported by the contemporaneous step of
approaching the police on 29.06.2015, leading to registration of FIR
bearing No. 1746/2015 u/s 307, 34 IPC, followed by a separate FIR
No. 207/2016 u/s 498A, 406, 323, 34 IPC. This clearly indicates that it
is the Appellant who has made ―bald assertions‖ as against the
Respondent and himself has failed to support his argument with any
piece of evidence.
29.
We also take note of the Order dated 09.10.2024 of this Court
in this very Appeal, wherein the learned counsel for the Appellant has
submitted before the Court that even though the Appellant has no
objection to the divorce being granted to the respondent/wife, he is
aggrieved by the findings recorded in the Impugned Judgement
wherein, the learned Family Court has come to a conclusion that the
Appellant-Husband and his mother had treated the Respondent-Wife
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
with cruelty.
30.
This Court records its displeasure in the manner in which the
Appellant has preferred the present Appeal, only to ―clear his image‖,
while himself having relinquished his opportunity to effectively crossexamine the Respondent and now challenging the correctness and
legality of the Judgement passed by the learned Family Court.
CONCLUSION:
31.
In light of the foregoing and having taken into consideration
the settled principles of law and the facts and circumstances of the
present matter, we find the Judgement passed by the learned Family
Court is correct. The learned Family Court‘s findings flow from a
careful appraisal of the evidence on record and are consonant with
settled judicial precedents.
32.
For these reasons afore-stated, the decree of divorce granted by
the learned Family Court vide the Impugned Judgment and Decree
dated 09.09.2024 in HMA No. 761/2023 is affirmed. The Appeal is
devoid of merit and is accordingly dismissed.
33.
The present appeal, along with all pending application(s), if
any, stands disposed of in the above terms.
34.
No order as to costs.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 09, 2026/va
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:25:01
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 328/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review