Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
#
#
$
!!
%!
'
Digitally signed
by SUMITRA
SHERIGAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"
"
#
$
%
&
' !(!
)
"
&
-2-
*'
)
)
)
)
(" (, "("(
))
)
+ "(!"
)
)
)
)
$
#
-
!
9/382/0
./ 0/1/20324 52
/2568
=./2>/1684.
5:59
;0</
8/1/88/0 3? @ 8539
6 + "(!" 7/168/ 4./
)
;00/75.39
6;84AB .3? >.399/2</0 3
C;0<D/24 320 0/>8// 034/0 (" (, "("( E3??/0 4./8/52
7F G.5>. 4./ ?;54 168 E38454562 G3? 0/>8//0 52 E384 320 54
G3? ./90 4.34 E93524511? G/8/ /24549/0 46 !" "+4. 320 , "+4.
?.38/ 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/?
"
./ E3845/? ?.399 ./2>/1684. 7/ 8/1/88/0 3? E/8
4./58 832H 7/168/ 4./ 8539
6;84 168 >62:/25/2>/
-3-
,
./ E93524511? 159/0 3 ?;54 52
7/168/
4./
6;84
6 + "(!"
E38454562
?/E3834/
E6??/??562 61 4./58 ?.38/ 52 4./ ?;54 ?>./0;9/ E86E/845/?
%
./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 38/
D/3?;852<
3>8/? ,( <;243? 320
D/3?;852<
3>8/?
<;243? 61
3<;8
2/
13D59F
/ .30 4G6 G5:/? 23D/0
6 ! % ! !#
5993</
;00/75.39
3459 G3? E86E6?54;? 61 4./
//93DD3 5? E93524511
6 " 5? ./8 03;<.4/8
6 !!! "( !#!
;8:/F
39;H
//93DD3
305G393EE3
;8:/F
32<3DD3 320
6 ! 320 4./ E93524511
264./8 03;<.4/8 61 E93524511
6 ! 5?
305G393DD3 G.6 05/0 376;4 !" F/38? E8568 46 4./ 034/
61 15952< 61 ?;54
./ 0/1/20324 5? ?62 61
4.86;<. .5? 158?4 G51/
G51/
32<3DD3
305G393EE3 3459
14/8 0/34. 61 .5? 158?4
305G393EE3 3459 D3885/0 4./ E93524511
4./ ?350 G/096>H 4./ E93524511
7/3852<
;8:/F
3459 3? 3 4/2324
6 ! 320 186D
6 " G3? 7682
./ E86E/84F
6 !!! G3? >;945:34/0 7F
305G393EE3
/ 05/0 52 4./ F/38 !*+(
14/8 .5?
0/34. 4./ 0/1/20324 G3? >;945:3452< 4./ 9320 3? 4/2324
./ 6>>;E32>F 85<.4 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F G3?
-4-
<8324/0 7F 4./ 320
857;239
;00/75.39 52 13:6;8 61 4./
0/1/20324 320 .5? C;2568 ;2>9/
3./73<6;03 320 D;434562
G3? /11/>4/0 3>>68052<9F 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F
./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
;8:/F
6 ! % ! 5? 13D59F E86E/84F
305G393EE3 320 314/8 .5? 0/34. 4./ 0/1/20324 320
3./73<6;03
4./
C;2568
;2>9/
?;>>//0/0 46 4./ ?350 E86E/84F
0/1/20324 320
E86E/845/?
4./
0/1/20324
2 4./ F/38 !**' 4./
3./73<6;03 05:50/0 4./ 376:/ ?350
? E/8 4./ ?350 E38454562 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/?
G/8/ 399644/0 46 4./ ?.38/ 61 0/1/20324
./ E93524511?
>935D/0 4.34 4./F G/8/ 264 3G38/ 61 4./ E38454562 320
./2>/ 4./8/ G3? 26 I;/?4562 61 4./F <5:52< ;E 4./58 85<.4?
52 4./ ?350 E86E/845/?
./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
;8:/F
6 ! % ! !# 5? ?54;34/0 30C3>/24 46 4./ :5993</ 320 4./
0/1/20324 .3? 7//2 ?/9952< E964? 52 4./ ?350 9320 G54.6;4
4./ H26G9/0</ 61 E93524511?
2 4./ F/38 "(!(
4./
0/1/20324 674352/0 ?5<234;8/? 61 E93524511? 3<8//52< 46
>62?48;>4 3 .6;?/ 168 4./ E93524511? 52 4./ ?350 E86E/84F
;4 4./ 0/1/20324 .3? 264 <8324/0 32F ?.38/ 46 4./
-5-
E93524511? 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 268 <64 >62?48;>4/0 4./
.6;?/
./8/168/ 4./ E93524511? 159/0 4./ ?;54 >935D52< 4.34
4./F 38/ /24549/0 168 ! ,80 ?.38/ 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 320
4./F E83F/0 168 0/>8//52< 4./ ?;54
./ 0/1/20324 3EE/38/0 52 4./ ?;54 7/168/ 4./
6;84 4.86;<. .5? >6;2?/9 320 159/0 G8544/2 ?434/D/24
0/2F52< 4./ >624/24562? 61 4./ E93524511?
30D544/0 4.34
6G/:/8 54 5?
32<3DD3 G3? 4./ 9/<399F G/00/0 G51/ 61
305:393EE3 320 4.86;<. 4./58 G/096>H 4./ 0/1/20324 G3?
;4 54 5? 0/25/0 4.34 4./
E93524511
6 ! 320 4.34 4./ E93524511
305G393EE3 D3885/0
6 " 5? 9/<545D34/
03;<.4/8 61
305G393EE3
4 5? >624/20/0 4.34 0;852< 4./
951/ 45D/ 61
32<3DD3
305G393EE3 >3D/ 52 599/<39
8/934562?.5E G54. 4./ E93524511
6 ! 320 6;4 61 ?;>. 599/<39
8/934562?.5E 4./ E93524511
6 " G3? 7682
D38853</ 7/4G//2 E93524511
6 ! 320
E93524511
./8/ G3? 26
305G393EE3
6 ! 5? 264 9/<399F G/00/0 G51/ 61
./
305G393EE3
320 ./2>/ 4./ E93524511? .3:/ 264 ?;>>//0/0 46 4./ ?;54
E86E/845/?
./ E93524511
6 " 7/52< 599/<545D34/ 03;<.4/8
-6-
305G393EE3
5? 264 /24549/0 46 32F ?.38/ 52 4./
32>/?4839 E86E/845/?
4 5? 30D544/0 4.34
>;945:3452< 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
6G/:/8 314/8 4./ 0/D5?/ 61
305G393EE3 G3?
6 !!! 3? 4/2324
305G393EE3 4./ 23D/ 61
4./ 0/1/20324 3962< G54. .5? ;2>9/
3./73<6;03 5? 85<.49F
D;434/0 52 8/:/2;/ 8/>680? 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F
32>/?4839 E86E/84F 61 4./ 0/1/20324 3962/
5? 4./ 629F 9/<39 ./58 61
305G393EE3
4 5?
./ 0/1/20324
./8/ G3? E38454562
7/4G//2 4./ 0/1/20324 320 .5? ;2>9/ 52 4./ F/38 !**' 320
52 4./ ?350 E38454562 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 1/99 46 4./ ?.38/ 61
4./ 0/1/20324
./ E93524511? G/8/ 3G38/ 61 4./ ?350
E38454562 7;4 4./F 050 264 >.66?/ 46 159/ ?;54 G54.52 !"
F/38? 186D 4./ 034/ 61 E38454562 52 4./ F/38 !**' 320 3?
?;>. 4./ ?;54 5? 7388/0 7F 95D5434562
4 5? 0/25/0 4.34 4./
0/1/20324 674352/0 ?5<234;8/? 61 4./ E93524511? 62 4./
E8/4/J4 4.34 ./ G6;90 </4 4./ .6;?/ >62?48;>4/0 52 4./
E86E/84F 7/3852<
3>4562 168 4./ ?;54
6! %
./8/ G3? 26 >3;?/ 61
./ ?;54 61 4./ E93524511? 5? 139?/ 320
-7-
4./8/168/ 4./ 0/1/20324 E83F/0 168 05?D5??39 61 4./ ?;54
G54. >6?4
'
E3845/? 4./
2 4./ 73?5? 61 4./ E9/3052<? 61 764. 4./
6;84 183D/0 4./ 16996G52< 5??;/? 320 32
3005456239 5??;/
K
!
#
$#
%
&
'
"
-8-
L
(
)
+
2 ?;EE684 61 4./ >3?/ 61 E93524511? 4./F G/8/
/J3D52/0 3?
! 320
06>;D/24? 34
J? ! 46
! G3? 05?>380/0
G3? /J3D52/0 3?
" 8/?E/>45:/9F 320 E860;>/0
!%
6G/:/8 4./ /:50/2>/ 61
2 4./ 64./8 .320 4./ 0/1/20324
!
7;4 ./ 050 264 E860;>/ 32F
06>;D/2438F /:50/2>/ 62 .5? 7/.391
14/8 ./3852< 4./ 38<;D/24? 61 764. 4./ E3845/?
320 62 >62?50/852< 4./ 6839 320 06>;D/2438F /:50/2>/ 62
8/>680 4./
6;84 32?G/8/0 5??;/?
6 ! " 320 % 52
4./ 31158D345:/ 320 4./ 3005456239 5??;/ 52 4./ 2/<345:/
320 0/>8//0 4./ ?;54 61 E93524511? <832452< ?.38/? 46 4./D
*
/52< 3<<85/:/0 7F 4./ 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24
320 0/>8// 4./ 0/1/20324 .3? >6D/ ;E G54. 4./ E8/?/24
3EE/39 62 ?/:/839 <86;20? ;8</0 52 4./ 3EE/39 320 E83F/0
-9-
168 ?/4452< 3?50/ 4./ 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24 320 0/>8// 320
4./8/7F 46 05?D5?? 4./ ?;54
!(
/380 38<;D/24? 61 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9 168
764. 4./ E3845/?
/8;?/0 4./ 6839 320 06>;D/2438F
/:50/2>/ 62 8/>680
./ 629F E6524 168 >62?50/834562 52
4.5? 3EE/39 5? KG./4./8 4./8/ G3? ?;115>5/24 /:50/2>/
7/168/ 4./ 8539
!!
6;84 46 0/>8// 4./ ?;54 168 E38454562ML
? E/8 4./ >3?/ 61 E93524511?
305G393EE3
5? 4./ E86E6?54;? 61 4./ 13D59F 320 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
F
6 ! % ! 5? E86E/84F 61 4./ 13D59F 61
./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
;8:/F
305G393EE3
6 !!! G3? >;945:34/0 7F
305G393EE3 3? 4/2324 320 314/8 .5? 0/34. 52 4./ F/38
!*+( 4./ 0/1/20324 G3? >;945:3452< 4./ 9320 3? 4/2324
./ 6>>;E32>F 85<.4 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F G3?
>621/88/0
4./
0/1/20324
3./73<6;03 7F 4./
857;239
D;434562 G3? /11/>4/0 3>>68052<9F
.5?
C;2568
;2>9/
;00/75.39 320
./8/ 5? 37?69;4/9F 26
05?E;4/ 8/<38052< 4./ 13>4 4.34 4./ E86E/84F 685<52399F
7/962</0 46
305G393EE3
4 5? 39?6 264 05?E;4/0 7F 4./
- 10 -
0/1/20324 4.34 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852<
F
6 !!! G3?
<8324/0 52 13:6;8 61 4./ 0/1/20324 320 .5? C;2568 ;2>9/
3./7<6;03
7F
4./
857;239
4.34
/3895/8
305G393EE3 G3? 4/2324 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F
./ 629F >624/24562 61 4./ 0/1/20324 5? 4.34 4./ E93524511
6 ! 5? 264 4./ G51/ 61
305G393EE3 320 ./2>/
4./
E93524511? 38/ 264 /24549/0 46 ?.38/ 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/84F
6G/:/8 4./ 13>4 4.34 4./ E93524511
305G393EE3 4.86;<. E93524511
!"
./ E93524511
6 " G3? 134./8/0 7F
6 ! 5? 264 52 05?E;4/
6 ! G3? /J3D52/0 3?
?;7?/I;/249F ./8 /:50/2>/ G3? 05?>380/0
6 " G3? /J3D52/0 3?
?434/0 52 4./ E93524
J483>4? %
3JD5735
./ E93524511
J483>4? !
./ E93524511
6 " D38H/0 "
J483>4 0/34. >/84515>34/ 61
32<3DD3 4./ D64./8
?>.669 >/84515>34/ 61 4./ E93524511
0/34.
;4
" 320 ?./ 8/54/834/0 4./ 13>4? 3?
305G393EE3 0/34. >/84515>34/ 61
61 0/1/20324
!
>/84515>34/
3>H26G9/0</D/24 8/<38052<
.66D5
6"
305G393EE3
EE95>34562
38305
320 >6EF 61 2645>/ 52 )68D "! 8/<38052< >.32</ 61 $.343
- 11 -
3?
E/8
J? !
!%
./8/
G3?
37?69;4/9F
>6248305>4562 /J483>4/0 7F 4./ 0/1/20324 52 4./ >86??&
/J3D5234562 61
!,
" 46 D3H/ ./8 /:50/2>/ 264 7/95/:379/
68/6:/8 3? ?;7D544/0 7F 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9
168 4./ E93524511?
0/1/20324
54 5? :/8F E/8452/24 46 264/ 4.34 4./
G.6 G3? /J3D52/0 3?
!
/J3D5234562 .30 0/E6?/0 4.34 .5? 134./8
52 .5? >86??&
305G393EE3 05/0
52 4./ F/38 !*+( 320 .5? D64./8 05/0 52 4./ F/38 !*'%
5? 48;/ 4.34
52 4./ >.5/1&/J3D5234562 61
0/25/0 4.34 314/8 4./ 0/34. 61
!
32<3DD3
305G393EE3
0/34. 61
6!
/
6 ! G3? 4./ G51/ 61
;4 3? E6524/0 6;4 7F 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9
168 4./ E93524511? 4./ 06>;D/24 34
4./ E93524511
./ .30
305G393EE3
>62483>4/0 3 ?/>620 D38853</ G54. 4./ E93524511
39?6 0/25/0 4.34 4./ E93524511
J !( G6;90 ?.6G 4.34
6 " G3? 7682 62 !' !( !*'
314/8 4./
32<3DD3 4./ 158?4 G51/ 61
305G393EE3 320
376;4 " F/38? E8568 46 4./ 0/34. 61
305G393EE3 62
!' ( !*+( 3? E/8 4./ 0/34. >/84515>34/ 34
J
4 5? 264
34 399 4./ >3?/ 61 0/1/20324 4.34 4./ E93524511
6 ! .30 32F
- 12 -
8/934562?.5E G54.
305G393EE3 /3895/8 46 4./ 0/34. 61
32<3DD3 4./ 158?4 G51/ 61
!%
305G393EE3
? ?;7D544/0 7F 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9 168 4./
E93524511? 4./ /:50/2>/ 61 0/1/20324 3?
! G6;90 ?.6G
4.34 ./ .30 30D544/0 4./ >3?/ 61 E93524511?
./ 8/9/:324
E684562 52 4./ /:50/2>/ 52 >86??&/J3D5234562 61
! 8/30?
4.;?
“
!"#
$%
&'
*'+ ,
-. "
$%
! 1/2 /
()
$%
3"
-#
) 7
*'+ ,
$%
&'
&/0" ) !/#
: ;
'+ <
'
@2 / <
'
1 / !
A
&/0" )
-#
$%
=
=
%
9 <>:
<
!
<>:
1 6/)
3"
@2
/
!#)
DE4@ F
&
4 !GH!
I!J
K$L' $L
/
/ !#)M
&'
4 56
'+
?
%
/
'
A
%
=
6!B C/
/
" 6 /
6!B C/
- 13 -
NO
3"
/
!# O
!#
<>:
3"
! 1 /2
/
I#
&'
) 3"
!
'&
3"
-#
%
B' +6'S #
#
' V L 3"
"T 7U
&Q/ ) O
' $L/0"
' $L/0" ) ! DE
( W O O
&
) X /
!
'&
!
);84./8
4.34
6 !!!
!
!#
1 Q
) O O
B' +6'S #
7U
&Q/0"
/
'&
?
/
3"
E/8452/24
264/
4.34
&Q/0" )M
0/1/20324 3?
0/E6?/0
!
/
!
$%
B' +6'S #
6 )
&Q/
/ R
3"
&
'&
&Q/0" )
' VL
!
'&
'&
!
60/0# /
"C 3"
%
/ PB
% ' /'
-#
<>:
$%
!
&Q/0" ) 3"
F
!
5?
4./
! 52 .5? >86??&/J3D5234562 .30 >9/389F
.5?
;2>9/
3./73<6;03
>.32</0 46 4./ 23D/ 61
<64
$.343
! 320 52 4./
23D/? 61 4./ E93524511? 320
3./73<6;03
./ 06>;D/24
J483>4 61
6 !!! 320 52
J , 5? 4./
;434562
F
- 14 -
8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 06>;D/24 4./ 0/1/20324 E9/30/0
5<26832>/
8/?E/>4 61
6G/:/8
;8:/F
./ 30D544/0 4.34 52 4./
6 ! % 4./8/ 5? D/24562 61 4./ 23D/?
61 E93524511? 320 23D/ 61 .5? ;2>9/
G54. .5? 23D/
3./73<6;03 3962<
/ .3? 1;84./8 0/E6?/0 4.34 ./ 050 264
43H/ 32F ?4/E? 46 </4 4./ 23D/ 61 4./ E93524511? 8/D6:/0
186D 4./
!'
68/6:/8
! 0/E6?/0 4.34 4./ E93524511
;?/0 46 :5?54 .5? .6;?/ 320 4./ E93524511
52 .5? .6;?/ 168 376;4 % 46
03F?
6 ! ;?/0 46 ?43F
;4 4./ 0/1/20324 3?
! .3? ?434/0 4.34 ./ 050 264 /2I;58/ 4./ E93524511
3? 46 G./4./8 ?./ .30 D3885/0 .5? 134./8
6!
6!
305G393EE3 68
/2>/ 4./ /:50/2>/ 1684.>6D52< 186D 4./ 0/1/20324
>6;E9/0 G54. 4./ 06>;D/24? E860;>/0 7F 4./ E93524511?
G6;90 ?.6G 4.34 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 38/ 4./ E86E/845/? 61
305G393EE3 320 4./ E93524511?
6 ! 320 " 7/52< G51/ 320
03;<.4/8 320 4./8/168/ 4./F 38/ /24549/0 46 ?.38/ 52 4./
?;54 E86E/845/? 3962< G54. 4./ 0/1/20324
./8/168/ 4./
6;84 .3? 264 >6DD544/0 32F /8868 52 0/>8//52< 4./
- 15 -
?;54 159/0 7F 4./ E93524511? ;20/8 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24 320
0/>8//
!+
>38/1;9 >62?50/834562 61 4./ 8/3?6252< 61 4./
6;84 G6;90 ?.6G 4.34 54 .3? >62?50/8/0 6839 320
06>;D/2438F /:50/2>/ 62 8/>680 52 E86E/8 E/8?E/>45:/
320 85<.49F 0/>8//0 4./ ?;54 61 4./ E93524511? <832452< ?.38/
46 4./D 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/?
/2>/
4./ E6524 168
>62?50/834562 183D/0 7F ;? 5? 32?G/8/0 3>>68052<9F
!
1 4./8/ 5? 32F 5??;/ 8/<38052< 4./ I;324;D 61
?.38/
4./ E93524511? 38/ 34 957/84F 46 E;4 1684. 4./58
>624/24562 168 0/4/8D5234562 61 ?.38/? /:/2 34 4./ ?43</
61 )5239
/>8//
86>//052<?
2 4./ 8/?;94 G/ 38/ 61 4./
>62?50/8/0 :5/G 4.34 4./ 0/1/20324 .3? 1359/0 46 D3H/ 6;4
32F <86;20 46 524/81/8/ G54. 4./ 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24 320
0/>8// 61 4./ 8539
6;84 320 4./8/168/ 4./ 3EE/39 5? 95379/
46 7/ 05?D5??/0
!*
>>68052<9F G/ E86>//0 46 E3?? 4./ 16996G52<
- 16 -
.5?
3EE/39
159/0
7F
4./
3EE/99324 0/1/20324 5? 05?D5??/0
62?/I;/249F
4./
0/>8//
034/0
(" (, "("(
9/382/0
/2568
5:59 ;0</ 320
;00/75.39 52
C;0<D/24
4./
)
6 + "(!" ?4320?
>62158D/0
2 4./ >58>;D?432>/? 764. 4./ E3845/?
?.399 7/38 4./58 6G2 >6?4?
./
6;84
/>680? ?.399 7/ 8/4;82/0 1684.G54.
3962< G54. >6EF 61 4.5? C;0<D/24
()
%
&
()
%
5?4
!
+
$
&
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review