Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (PIL) No. 5169 of 2023
Shyamanand Pandey, aged about 30 years, s/o Uday Nath Pandey, r/o
village- Rakshi, PO & P.S- Ramkanda, District- Garhwa- 822114
(Jharkhand), Aadhar No: 7851 4592 1377, Mobile No. +91
8051032919, currently residing at Shri Sankat Mochan Hanuman
Mandir, Main Road, P.O- G.P.O and P.S- Daily Market, District Ranchi-834001 (Jharkhand)
…
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. The Secretary-cum-Food Safety Commissioner, Department of
Health & Family Welfare, Government of Jharkhand, Nepal House,
P.O & PS Doranda, District- Ranchi-83-4002 (Jharkhand)
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi having his office at the
Collectorate Building. Kutchery Road, PO- GPO, PS- Kotwali,
District- Ranchi-834001 (Jharkhand)
4. The Administrator, Ranchi Municipal Corporation, Kutchery Road,
PO-GPO & PS- Kotwali, District- Ranchi-834001 (Jharkhand).
5. The Secretary, Urban Development & Housing Department,
Government of Jharkhand, Project Building, Dhurwa, Ranchi.
6. M/s Arsh & Elham Livestock Exporters (AELE), through
Partner/Director Shri Shahbaz Ahamed, S/O Shakeel Ahmed, R/o.
Madhumati Apartment, Joda Talab Road, P.O & P.S- Bariatu,
Ranchi, Current Office- Argora, Housing Complex, Room No. F-10,
Argora Chowk, Ranchi, Permanent Office- Madhumati Apartment,
Joda Talab Road, Bariatu Basti, Ranchi, Jharkhand.
7. M/s Micro Transmission System (M.T.S.), through Authorised
Representative Shri Shahbaz Ahmad, S/o. Shakeel Ahmed, R/o.
Inside Madhumati Apartment, Joda Talab Road, P.O & P.S- Bariatu,
Ranchi, Jharkhand, Regd. Office- D-29, Site B, UBSIDC, Surajpur
Industrial Area, Surajpur, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh- 201210.
...
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD
--------For the Petitioner:
Mr Shubham Kataruka, Advocate
For the State:
Mr Yogesh Modi, A.C. to A.A.G.-IA
For the RMC:
Dr (Mrs) Vandana Singh, Advocate
For the Intervener:
Mr Bharti V. Kaushal, Advocate
For Resp. Nos.6&7:
Mr Pragati Prasad, Advocate
Mr Prabhakaran Munda, Advocate
None
---------
21/Dated: 01.10.2026
Per M. S. Sonak, C.J.
1.
Heard Mr Shubham Kataruka, learned counsel for the petitioner;
Mr Yogesh Modi, learned A.C. to A.A.G.-1A for respondent nos.
1, 2, 3 and 5; Dr. Vandana Singh, learned counsel for the 4th
respondent and Ms Bharti V. Kaushal for the applicant of I.A. No.
13925 of 2026.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the 6th and 7th
respondents have been duly served; however, no one appears on
their behalf today.
3.
This petitioner, by way of purported public interest, seeks the
following reliefs: (a) For directing the Respondents to prohibit the illegal
culling of animals (including poultry birds) and
displaying of carcasses to the general public on the
roads of Ranchi.
(b) For directing the Respondent to implement the
provisions of Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and
Registration of Food Businesses), Regulations 2011,
particularly Regulation 2.1.2 (5) read with Part IV
whereby and whereunder slaughtering of animal / birds
inside the shop premises is strictly prohibited and
specific sanitary & hygienic requirements for the retail
meat shops including provision for location of the meat
shops have been stipulated.
(c) For directing the Respondent to implement the
provisions of Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
(Slaughter House) Rules, 2001, particularly Rule 6
whereby and whereunder slaughter of animals in the
sight of other animals has been prohibited.
4.
This Court has, from time to time, passed several orders in this
petition regarding action taken, if any, against the operation of
illegal slaughterhouses and meat shops within the municipal limits
of the Ranchi Municipal Corporation.
5.
Finally, it was noticed that the State did not have the requisite
statutory structure to regulate the activity of those engaged in the
manufacture, processing, storing, and selling of meat and meat
products. Though powers were vested in the State authorities under
the provisions of Food Safety Legislation and the Jharkhand
Municipal Act, 2011, it was felt that some statutory framework
dealing with this particular issue was wanting.
6.
Accordingly, the State assured that it would frame regulations to
address this issue of Food Business Operators engaged in the
manufacture, processing, storing, and selling of meat and meat
products. No specific timelines were indicated, and therefore, this
Court was constrained to make orders from time to time.
7.
One such order was made on 28.11.2025 by the Coordinate Bench
and the same is transcribed below for the convenience of
reference: “It appears that the respondents are simply dilly-dallying the
implementation of the orders passed by this Court from time to time
more particularly, the order dated 19.07.2023 passed by one of us
(Sri Rajesh Shankar, Judge) in W.P.(C) No. 5175 of 2018
[Jharkhand Quraish Panchayat and Shopkeeper Welfare Society,
Ranchi & Anr. Vs. The State of Jharkhand & Ors.], wherein the
following directions were passed:
“64. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the present writ
petition is disposed of in following manners:
(i) The impugned public notice as contained in Letter
No. 638/Swa. dated 01.10.2018 issued under the
signature of the Municipal Commissioner, Ranchi
Municipal Corporation, Ranchi is hereby quashed.
(ii) The RMC is directed to frame a regulation
covering the subjects as mentioned in Sections 315 &
327 of the Act, 2011 including making provision to
grant licence to private slaughter houses and to get
approval on the same by the State Government as
mandated under Section 594 of the Act, 2011.
(iii) The RMC while framing the Regulation shall
consider the provisions of the Act, 2006 and the
Regulations, 2011.
(iv) Till the Regulation is finally notified, the
members of the petitioner No.1 as well as the other
mutton sellers carrying on their business after
obtaining licence/registration, as the case may be,
under the Act, 2006 and the Regulations, 2011, shall
not be compelled to get the animals slaughtered at the
Municipal Slaughter House situated at Kanke,
Ranchi.”
2. As already observed, no effective steps are being taken by the
respondents to curb the menace of illegal slaughter houses/operators
operating within the State of Jharkhand. Even the latest
supplementary counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent –
Ranchi Municipal Corporation dated 10.10.2025 does not at all
touch upon any of the events which may have taken place after the
year 2023 i.e., after passing of the judgment as referred to above.
3. Likewise, even the supplementary counter affidavit dated
16.10.2025 filed on behalf of the Under Secretary, Department of
Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare, Government of
Jharkhand also does not delve into any of the developments that may
have taken place after the year 2023, save and except referring to a
letter dated 13.10.2025, which is nothing but a reiteration of the
directions passed in W.P.(C) No. 5175 of 2018.
4. In the given facts and circumstances, we deem it appropriate to
grant a week’s time to the respondents to put their house in order
and file a comprehensive affidavit with regard to the implementation
of not only the said judgment passed by this Court, but also with
regard to the implementation of the provisions of the municipal laws
as well as the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 and the
regulations
framed
thereunder,
failing
which
the
erring
respondent(s) shall not only appear before this Court, but this Court
may also be constrained to make adverse comment upon working of
the respondents who, as observed above, have been simply dillydallying and shirking away from the duties and responsibilities.
5. List this case on 12.12.2025.”
8.
Further, since the Coordinate Bench was not satisfied with the
status of compliance, the Urban Development and Housing
Department, Government of Jharkhand was impleaded as the 5th
respondent in these proceedings. A further order was made on
19.12.2025, which is also transcribed below for the convenience of
reference:1. At the oral request of learned counsel for the petitioner, we deem
it appropriate to implead the Urban Development and Housing
Department, Government of Jharkhand as a party respondent in
this case, which shall now be figured as the respondent no. 5.
2. Impleaded as such.
3. On 28.11.2025, this Court had passed the following order:
“It appears that the respondents are simply dilly-dallying
the implementation of the orders passed by this Court from
time to time more particularly, the order dated 19.07.2023
passed by one of us (Sri Rajesh Shankar, Judge) in W.P.(C)
No. 5175 of 2018 [Jharkhand Quraish Panchayat and
Shopkeeper Welfare Society, Ranchi & Anr. Vs. The State of
Jharkhand & Ors.], wherein the following directions were
passed:
“64. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the present
writ petition is disposed of in following manners:
(i) The impugned public notice as
contained in Letter No. 638/Swa. dated
01.10.2018 issued under the signature
of
the
Municipal
Commissioner,
Ranchi
Municipal
Corporation,
Ranchi is hereby quashed.
(ii) The RMC is directed to frame a
regulation covering the subjects as
mentioned in Sections 315 & 327 of
the
Act,
including
making
provision to grant licence to private
slaughter houses and to get approval
on the same by the State Government
as mandated under Section 594 of the
Act, 2011.
(iii) The RMC while framing the
Regulation
shall
consider
the
provisions of the Act, 2006 and the
Regulations, 2011.
(iv) Till the Regulation is finally
notified, the members of the petitioner
No.1 as well as the other mutton
sellers carrying on their business after
obtaining licence/registration, as the
case may be, under the Act, 2006 and
the Regulations, 2011, shall not be
compelled
to
get
the
animals
slaughtered at the Municipal Slaughter
House situated at Kanke, Ranchi.”
2.
As already observed, no effective steps are being
taken by the respondents to curb the menace of illegal
slaughter houses/operators operating within the State of
Jharkhand. Even the latest supplementary counter affidavit
filed on behalf of the respondent – Ranchi Municipal
Corporation dated 10.10.2025 does not at all touch upon any
of the events which may have taken place after the year 2023
i.e., after passing of the judgment as referred to above.
3.
Likewise, even the supplementary counter affidavit
dated 16.10.2025 filed on behalf of the Under Secretary,
Department of Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare,
Government of Jharkhand also does not delve into any of the
developments that may have taken place after the year 2023,
save and except referring to a letter dated 13.10.2025, which
is nothing but a reiteration of the directions passed in
W.P.(C) No. 5175 of 2018.
4.
In the given facts and circumstances, we deem it
appropriate to grant a week’s time to the respondents to put
their house in order and file a comprehensive affidavit with
regard to the implementation of not only the said judgment
passed by this Court, but also with regard to the
implementation of the provisions of the municipal laws as
well as the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 and the
regulations framed thereunder, failing which the erring
respondent(s) shall not only appear before this Court, but
this Court may also be constrained to make adverse comment
upon working of the respondents who, as observed above,
have been simply dilly-dallying and shirking away from the
duties and responsibilities.
5.
List this case on 12.12.2025.”
4. However, the said order has not been complied with constraining
this Court to pass an order on 12.12.2025 calling upon presence
of the Secretary, Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare
and
the
Secretary,
Urban
Development
and
Housing
Department, Government of Jharkhand, Ranchi as well as the
Administrator, Ranchi Municipal Corporation, Ranchi.
5. In compliance of the above direction, all the aforesaid officers
are physically present before this Court.
6. This Court has interacted with them for a sufficient long time
and apprised them about the provisions of the Food Safety and
Standards (Licencing and Registration of Food Businesses),
Regulations, 2011 [hereinafter referred to as ‘the Regulations,
2011’], the Judgement passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Laxmi Narain Modi Vs. Union of India & Ors., the
judgement passed by the Uttarakhand High Court in Writ
Petition (PIL) No. 152 of 2018 [Parvez Alam Vs. State of
Uttarakhand and Others] decided on 20.09.2018 and above all,
the judgment rendered by this Court by one of us (Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Rajesh Shankar) in the case of Jharkhand Quraish
Panchayat and Shopkeeper Welfare Society, Ranchi and
Another Vs. the State of Jharkhand & Others in W.P. (C) No.
5175 of 2018 decided on 19.07.2023 wherein the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court along with the rules
formulated in Laxmi Narain Modi case (supra) and the rules of
other cases have been considered and thereafter the following
directions have been issued:
”64. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the present writ
petition is disposed of in following manners:
(i) The impugned public notice as contained in Letter No.
638/Swa. dated 01.10.2018 issued under the signature of the
Municipal
Neutral
Citation
2023:JHHC:24929
Commissioner, Ranchi Municipal Corporation, Ranchi is
hereby quashed.
(ii) The RMC is directed to frame a regulation covering the
subjects as mentioned in Sections 315 & 327 of the Act, 2011
including making provision to grant licence to private
slaughter houses and to get approval on the same by the
State Government as mandated under Section 594 of the Act,
2011.
(iii) The RMC while framing the Regulation shall consider
the provisions of the Act, 2006 and the Regulations, 2011.
(iv) Till the Regulation is finally notified, the members of the
petitioner No.1 as well as the other mutton sellers carrying
on their business after obtaining licence/registration, as the
case may be, under the Act, 2006 and the Regulations, 2011,
shall not be compelled to get the animals slaughtered at the
Municipal Slaughter House situated at Kanke, Ranchi.”
7. All the aforesaid three officers have assured this Court that the
regulations as well as the directions passed by this Court along
with the provisions made in various statutes would be
implemented in its letters and spirit and the regulations as
directed by this Court would be formulated within a period of
two months from today.
8. The said statements are taken on record.
9. However, we are of the considered view that the regulations
cannot be framed for only one local body and therefore model
regulations need to be framed governing all urban local bodies
including the Ranchi Municipal Corporation.
10. List this case on 27.02.2026.
11. In the meantime, the respondents are directed to ensure that the
provisions of the regulations as well as the directions as issued
by this Court more particularly as contained in paragraph no. 63
wherein the mutton sellers have been permitted to carry out their
businesses only in terms of the registration provided under the
Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 read with the Regulations,
2011, are complied with. It shall further be ensured that no
unauthorized person is permitted to sell mutton. It shall also be
ensured that even the mutton that is sold, shall be permitted to be
sold only after it complies with the provisions of the Prevention
of Cruelty to Animals (Slaughter House) Rules, 2001, the
Regulations, 2011 more particularly Schedule-4 of Part IV, are
complied with in its letters and spirit. Any violation of these
instructions may entail serious consequences by this Court.
12. In the meantime, the respondents are directed to file an affidavit
in compliance of today’s order as well as the order dated
28.11.2025.
I.A. No. 4006 of 2024:
13 Since the applicants are necessary parties in this case, the
present application seeking their impleadment is allowed.
14. The applicants shall now be figured as the respondent nos. 6 &
7.”
9.
On 29.04.2026, this Court made a further order in this matter
which is again transcribed below for the convenience of reference:-
“1. In paragraph 9 of our order dated 19.12.2025, we had observed
the following: “9. However, we are of the considered view that the
regulations cannot be framed for only one local body and
therefore model regulations need to be framed governing all
urban local bodies including the Ranchi Municipal
Corporation.”
2. After that, this Court was informed that State-wide Model
Regulations are being framed and the same would be submitted
before this Court.
3. Now, in the supplementary counter affidavit filed on behalf of the
2nd respondent, this is what is stated in paragraph No. 7, which
reads as follows: “7. That it is humbly stated and submitted that in accordance
with the directions of this Hon'ble Court, the respondent
no.2, the Department of Health, Medical Education and
Family Welfare, Government of Jharkhand, has officially
communicated the directives to the Urban Development and
Housing Department, Ranchi Municipal Corporation and
enforcement officials (Food Safety Officers) vide Ref. No.189
(16) dated 24.12.2025 and Ref. No.194 (16) dated
29.12.2025. These letters were issued to ensure that the
mandates of the order dated 19.12.2025 specifically
regarding the strict enforcement of Schedule 4 of Part IV of
the FSS Regulations, 2011 and the time bound formulation of
State-wide Model Regulations.”
4. From the above statements, it appears that the State is not quite
serious in formulating the State-wide Model Regulations. The
departments referred to paragraph 7 above are the departments of
the State Government itself. Therefore, it is a little unfortunate that
the Under Secretary, Health Department, Government of Jharkhand,
blames other departments, such as the Department of Health, the
Urban Development Department, and the Ranchi Municipal
Corporation, for not cooperating or even responding to the letter.
This cannot be an excuse for not formulating the State-wide Model
Regulations within a reasonable period.
5. The Model Regulations have to be formulated by the State
Government, based upon which, the local bodies and Municipal
Corporations/Councils will have to frame their regulations. The
learned counsel for the State is unclear as to which department will
formulate these Model Regulations. This is again quite unfortunate.
6. Therefore, we direct the Secretary, Urban Development
Department and the Secretary, Health Department, to formulate the
Model Regulations within two months from today. The Secretary is
requested to convene a meeting of all the concerned departments
and the Municipal Commissioners so that these regulations can be
formulated at the earliest. Such a meeting is necessary because the
affidavit filed by the Under Secretary simply refers to reminders sent
by him to various departments and reports that such departments,
despite reminders, are offering no response.
7. Insofar as the issue of food safety is concerned, we refer to
paragraphs 8 and 9 of the Under Secretary’s affidavit dated
26.02.2026, which reads as follows:“8. That it is humbly stated and submitted that subsequent to
the primary communication of the directions of this Hon'ble
Court,
the
Deponent's
Department
(Health,
Medical
Education and Family Welfare) has issued periodic
reminders vide Ref. No.03 (16) dated 07.01.2026, Ref. No.10
(16) dated 05.02.2026, Ref. No.12 (16) dated 09.02.2026,
Ref. No.19(16) dated 19.02.2026 and Ref. No. 30(16) dated
24.02.2026 to the Urban Development and Housing
Department, the Ranchi Municipal Corporation, and all
concerned Food Safety Officers. The focus of these reminders
is the immediate implementation of hygiene standards and
the time bound framing of State-wide Model Regulations.
9. That it is humbly stated and submitted that acting upon the
aforementioned communications and reminders issued by the
Deponent's Department, the concerned departments and authorities
have initiated and undertaken requisite actions in compliance with
the directions of this Hon'ble Court. The details and status of such
actions have been summarizzed into a chart prepared by the
Deponent's Department, which is based on the action - taken reports
and feedback received from the respective departments/authorities.
8. In paragraph 9 of the affidavit, there is a reference to a
summarized chart. However, we agree with the learned counsel for
the petitioner that there is no chart as such annexed to the affidavit.
If indeed any steps have been taken or any action has been taken as
stated in the affidavit, the details of such action should be placed on
record in the form of a chart or otherwise.
9. The Secretary, Urban Development Department and the
Secretary, Health Department must file affidavits in this matter by
15th July, 2026. We clarify that this direction is to the Secretaries
and therefore, the requirement of filing such an affidavit should not
be delegated to the Under Secretaries.
10. List this matter on 22nd July, 2026.”
10. Finally, on 22.07.2026, after hearing the learned counsel for the
parties and perusing the supplementary counter affidavit dated
14.07.2026 filed by the Principal Secretary, Urban Development
and Housing Department, Government of Jharkhand, we made the
following order: “1. We have perused the averments in the supplementary counter
affidavit sworn on 14.07.2026 by the Principal Secretary, Urban
Development and Housing Department, Government of Jharkhand
though, some steps seem to have been taken, the affidavit is mostly
non-commital. In paragraph 11 it is stated that the necessary file for
framing Jharkhand Municipal Regulations for issuance of N.O.C. for
food business operators engaged in manufacture, processing, storing
and selling of meat and meat products, 2026 shall be put up before
the Cabinet for its approval. This paragraph also states that this will
be done on obtaining the approval/consent from the Finance
Department. Today, the learned counsel for the State is unable to
say whether any consent from the Finance Department is obtained
and whether the Rules are placed before the Cabinet. Though, this
affidavit was sworn on 14.07.2026.
2. After that, in paragraph 12, there is a statement that the
answering department is taking every steps diligently for final
notification of the regulations and that the answering respondent
needs eight weeks’ more time to fully comply with the Court’s order.
3. Given the above vague and non-commital statements, we post this
matter on 20th August, 2026 under the same caption.
4. The Principal Secretary must, on or before the said date, file a
further affidavit indicating the progress if any in the matter.
5. It is this time, we do not expect the usual excuses of bureaucratic
delays and again, the Principal Secretary must himself file the
affidavit without delegating the same to any other officer.”
11. Now, a supplementary counter affidavit has been filed by the
Principal Secretary, Urban Development and Housing Department,
Government of Jharkhand, with which he has enclosed the
“Jharkhand Municipal Regulations for issue of No Objection
Certificate
for
Food
Business
Operators
engaged
in
manufacture, processing, storing and selling of Meat and Meat
Products, 2026” (2026 Regulations). This notification has been
issued under Sections 310, 315, 327 and 594 of the Jharkhand
Municipal Act, 2011.
12. The 2026 Regulations, inter alia, specify that the provisions of
Part-IV of the Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and
Registration of Food Businesses), 2011, and Rules 5 and 6 of the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Slaughter House) Rules, 2001,
shall apply in their true letter and spirit. Further, the prohibitions
on slaughter of bovine animals contained in the Jharkhand Bovine
Animal
Prohibition
of
Slaughter
Act,
and
regulations/circulars issued by the Department of Agriculture,
Animal Husbandry and Co-operative, Government of Jharkhand,
will also apply. The 2026 Regulations also refer to fixing places
for slaughter of animals for sale and the need to obtain a No
Objection Certificate, followed by the procedure therefor. The
2026 Regulations specify that should there be any conflict between
the provisions of these Regulations and the Food Safety and
Standards (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses)
Regulations, 2011, the latter Regulations of 2011 shall have an
overriding effect.
13. Mr Yogesh Modi, learned A.C. to A.A.G.-IA, submitted that, since
the statutory framework is in place, it will be complied with when
dealing with the issue of Food Business Operators engaged in the
manufacture, processing, storing, and selling of meat and meat
products. In other words, the 2026 Regulations, along with other
regulations and statutory provisions referred to therein, will apply
and will be adhered to.
14. With the issue of 2026 Regulations and the assurance about
compliance, the reliefs sought in this petition stand suitably
addressed. In a petition of this nature, it is not possible to address
individual violations. This is more so because the alleged violators
have not been impleaded as parties in this matter.
15. Similarly, the grievance raised by the Intervener by filing I.A. No.
13925 of 2026 also cannot be addressed in this petition, especially
since the alleged violators have not been impleaded. In any event,
it is open to the petitioner as well as the proposed intervener to file
complaints before the appropriate authorities in case of noncompliance with the statutory provisions, and if such complaints
are filed, the concerned authorities are expected to address such
complaints in accordance with law and after giving a reasonable
opportunity to the alleged violators.
16. This petition has achieved its purpose now that a statutory
framework is in place, with the assurance that it will be adhered to
in both letter and spirit. Accordingly, we see no necessity to keep
this petition pending any further.
17. By accepting the statement made on behalf of the State
Government, we dispose of this petition without any order for
costs.
18. The pending IAs are also disposed of.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Manoj Prasad, J.)
October 01, 2026
N.A.F.R.
M.Kr./Sharda/Cp.2
Uploaded on 06.10.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review